Download as pdf
Download as pdf
You are on page 1of 38
ea The Reappeerarce ct Pace 190m, encouterabiliy i describod in tems ofa faceo-fce mesg in the terse of» selghbarood for exami, the Yount” of region ™ The Bava is more than merely ik makes good on a promissory wae fat boved in Heidegger's ery masterwork, and thn neglected out of 3 pe fccpation wih ie nd tempor For Heleegger now procs hat “be peli of which be bd event spoken in is ects on Logic 925 {oa6: another way of conefving Beng apart from be ba of tie." nh comia ting (od efusng Wo itera place nthe aermath of Beng and Tone, Heidegger a it susceds nealing hime from ie Imsrownes of thse cooceps of Being which merely hase tobe avible [dvwich ae forte tos pr rer ough He has venerated i= {Ei Yom the narrowness of bi own concepts of ine and temporality tha sod ode is vison of an aentve out Benga iso via ple (God thus as via the Opes region, things and nearnes). The ceo and Aligessive characte of Heldegge’ ph over marth for does shoal ‘ot blind ws to he fat at he ends by giving the mot sgetv ad ss tained wean’ of place in hs etary eis remartblecooogh hat Heidegger managed 1 o justice wo plce in tte ac of his owa tempore, What Bere di fo uation Hide Uf does for place-—despte the primacy he acoso tenporaiy, Ad ts Ae mare remaable n Hendegger scsomplchee (his even though be ‘acl teases plac elf aa hamat op To recognize he ingeiece [St place in Beg ose ita th ery seing ofthe event of Approiation ‘Sms nx call for tuning plc nto tin top of pops dscoase. Kis {S sehmowtedge instead te spoil vale of prulg, even trough the most ‘Shoow cro, apology of Being" Buco. Tatelg, 12 Giving a Face to Place in the Present Bachelard, Foucault, Deleuze and ‘Guatari, Derrida, Irigaray veything takes fom, even ia in "A son Bachar The Pots of Space Spe is everyre open. We are i his ple —eaLueNaney, The Inperatie Conary In racing ou Heldgg'thnkng stout place and “varios phenomenal sp tile och epi nd ighboriood, we have pused plc ino some tis more rane enters dsr mre. We hve eared mich about the panoply of meanings at place can exit 5 wel the ange of les it (sume in wey eget ones te effets akosopie—led- Ing eto vor place's "tee sop," Ze Spe Rum —it bas allowed us to ‘recap, indeed wo reveogne, the power of place. Eales easomin of ace (ict ate nomen of ks ding ecogaln ne Wes} ead {Oe fe as we sec in Aha fnpmenaryulerstces end Artes ‘meses ok ore a he Opposite exteme hey we efsve nd paegyril, ain Lanblchur's aod Poca ham. Heldegget ‘Sores mil pth For im plac ining and valable indeed fen Iniapral, yt nt rometing 10 be adult as such I doesnot ke on {he conta highlighted sats Blog oe Beingin-th- wor, Tahoe {Langng, he Fourfld or he eve of Appropnion. Ye never becomes ‘meely parse on thse major terme, nor ts iY pest or of ving eis owe etres ad fn ts own neal ig "Te fact remains, bowever, ht fn the couse of Heiepger'sdawa-ot cxengerent wit lace, thephesomenca isl all 0 oe slips rom view ‘No prund ec, lace goes undergo, econ part of Heep’ oe plot plglogue wih te hiker sad oter concep The eu a the 26 ‘he Reapperarce of Pace netstat oF nerment, Pl sae in he coting coro of Hee fs abyenhine ewer Fey hae coir, we ae let ak nat time 1 fee i ke of ev and sexi fl face? 5 ot ie 1 es cae Ov rea to pve x ew at, thal we can at at id oe doom neatly placed eve, nce asi? 1h at (od somes dtinty aha) the fomg shadow ty He impinge here esis vgn ofa enened nd nS esa pa of peng mined nathrs who ik in vty mk of Being He sg ae proved by Sc dey of fachard,Bael Foe, Delete and Cutt, Desi aoe iad Ney, it Gerany, Bean and Acad snd ate aed in North Arc, Relph, Tan, Eatin Sj Seok Moo Seger cman, Tc a Wale Ea of hese eet fr nceaied in faeioning est fle fo as ne ee cocoverar of he imporiance of plac 8c a gals ofc hing: as 0 tenes sens, Where Vitae at opt soething csening cnet as of place (85 Het tng regi ning) noe othe uae es aes acta anying ike + ei, much es nite h Intempo ruin of ac nse each ies 1 id plas at work Fak for fore Sngoing 08 dyna, igsedint ut someting cs: i oat oy adel, Foucault stra wort (Bey, Syd) Sem en tec, Llebve in ene eins od nl th Pease the rons of ore agian Cache OS5) 8 a tie open sn ety (can, Tan, Sot Rh ESA) earn Sep pls en the cy (Bei, Arey Wale ito a ee oe unl Guat), in ache (Dera, Escoman, Tech), madi ognny, Nam) ea th te tf ame 08 tos 1 i Cr abang oe only it amity resemblance of hanging aca cesT sogest at hr 0 Sng, much ee a pany fren (0 teas leet ras, To tis ete Pe af plac my acon all the ore hide, since et 02 ee Be lol sien signin incidents tobe rented ci aga Hior, “everghing fakes form, even i init” Or Ba yaks ace ina ave Yt intens meson athe subject of place, eof place in Western thought has rey calle form apes sc Book and dono want prolong i way. This st cope, ae coin mere sites of seer only hemos promi scorn wi Sempoary diets, ning ct tos wih am 2 to nse man Not aig fb ehaatine of i we _pressly philosophical ovlentainot neo are meant to serve as signposts for fur~ Civ Facet Pace inte Present a the exploration. Bt ty dosage ot ways in which wo revalrize place in Ur oie to gv potato place Tne gue tobe etd in re sees ‘i Weauon othe cuper—Bacelr Foal, Deleuze and Gastar, De 5S. Sad tigre cpu to acknowledge a appreciate more fly the ‘aces th pcs tae Be found with and In a aun ws ce nen as tig st Sigmund Freud oe of Angst 23, 1938 We do ot tage plc, we change our mate "Gaston Bata, The Pos of Space ato Bacher offers» ist refcing of plae—ia and hough he may ‘Se speifcaly, the pot imagen Bachela'sweisgs om the pocic eeadioe uted om the lt 19300 ut the ery 1960), he so of ‘Splenda rom continuing concer wit undestndng Bow poetic ‘hymen te bumanpyohe. As Bacher ty in La ret es SEES levlome (in) -Ifone ps inapes interes in chic ‘Rien. betre thoughts poses) vane cannot ep bot engnize hat the age of men is esti nage" To put iages i heir ince (eur ate place) id for hem x proper loca i he mind, Bee eat tesel? Arte fd sine tte soa “the place of ‘Raa bt be the ple of imager ato be avery flat pice than ‘Rim Bd ie mt wo be receive and abortive of images i ‘Azar at has if anything to Jo with pecs poston in Nerarchial ‘Muilcao te mst hres wey lnwhich concepts cei the ‘Hhomal salon Arstod'e acount). Metaphors ofthe pigeonole andthe [derive way to the spiders web or the Dechive as we bei o appre ‘vm iat ela pete agey: nese eforescenr. The very mel of Jakes era surface aoter stent stl theme brs be ese etme ine poyhi imlacemet of images nat how they ae “rnd yates if thirfae were tobe sy sande but ow hoy appeay ara sre that ofthe eal elf: "The pote tag” ries Bechler a The Pots of Space "is suden sec oa the rac ofthe eyeie I lnges ae ined efrescet phenomena, ten the place in Tic ey eppear tb apd of eeing or “reveberang”wit tem, erGlopelunt the Receptace the Tacs the sys Tie the Re prac mas be eompurtvely characters in oreo fsoete with te (SRE act a scr sertace The pete src mus send fort the Sng receiver mut ive pice them by folesane with tem, a8 Te Reapposance Pace shining wit tit momentary presence. Te snse of pace ta coun ere wth of lc si cota nd perdu Dut asi ighs up with he suden Spark ofa sngleskig age, Eke shooting tar in he dark bys of sieht "Atk nhs nus of Buchel’ works majors: the pata fy x tet the laity ofthe py In proposing that th sou provides lice for images acl i conesiog ot only Arte but Deserts ‘ell Coxe Art, he Holding that here avai ease of place for Tmonscsle tems plae ca be nonptyical nd yet sil cot fly a plc. {the ance werk, ely Planes aad his sucesrs had ded fo posit a ‘sly nonsenl fm of place, ta, “nelle plac.” (The aslogse in apace to nell lace fas we have sen, th infinite iagiory space tt medial thesogian took to be equal! to God) ln te meri, ‘Bacto endorses ster igpifcan except the sense-tound Ariote Tian cher: pyc place But fom he soul a place ore of pass ir sao fy fete fee of Desa, for how he sou as no extension of fy Kin. evideat Bacher, however, ta poetic images Gare op hehe and the place in whic hey do i pyc in mature. This tu toms ta peyeic place Is thee-dimesiong, noch ss thats scaly empty. Here thinking aguas bth Descartes and Pilopons ‘ocean a he etemsion of soul a is own propre abd parame {erramong tem, spec Kind nsidenes sd sown modalities of a evant dept (hereby, for example, u poetic image may och the eps ‘fre sti the sac) "The more we tik i ist dct, he loser we come Fre, who sso props psytledeth and istioy and who, at he very ead fi ite Pocsined the wososiou tobe exteadod” Becher ware of he lralel omuse be is oe wit Freud-—and sith Jung aswell. Areltion of ‘Sng competion wih peychoanalysis palgble rom The Paychownly Sir of Pre (038) ©The Petr of Space (195) the evo books tat frame ‘aches thinking abst pete imager and te psyche: What sn ex9- {ona comme! in Hed, oan egy exceptional Gren in Jung” beoomes oe Bechlard agin of esearch tha deserves its own name: "tpossalyi” Tn tgoealya, desi peyton, depth paycnogy, psychoanalysis, Sd phewomencogy all come gee na coma eters, ae thc fe dened as be sypemaic pychnlogial study of he lcaliies of Ime ves Lew utd tha a tte, opal oss o he Pinca! properties of esa twgs, for stance te hose: “On whatever eschew examine ite hunt kage woud appear fo have become the ‘Gpography of ou nimate being" tee cvllay of apna is hither serious, opoand ue dermines temporocenaae The tote we ead 1 the topo of payee i, Nees ieee thot tis life--coutrary 10 what Kant and Bergson, James Caving a Facet Pace into Prosent Ey and Huse contend—is not merely fenton of ts datos ow. Spee ‘ita han ine the foem of inne sete.” When we look within ousves Fath lai gesture of Slt Augustine, we dont nda beer sequence of ‘omnis mich ess cabeonte fa” Gower instead, “all we know B® sof Baton nthe spc ofthe subi of being—a being bo does ‘ot want met sy and who, eves i the past when eset oot in search tings pst, wants ane pend” sgh" Wht intoxpecion ‘ees resins” memories al he more "sl fr being bt! pe ze" To comet re with he net fet is ot eng coastite Nogspty er ebiogaphy in arative terms ne ns i and mote rly do opty ofthe places one bas ited or expences far + Enewlege of inti, lcm in the spaces of ex inimacy Is ‘hore uge than determina of dos" Not ly moe urgent bat more Pas foie emporal contig fe gives aly "aso extras, fox xtara ee fob commence oer” ha ths way Buchel the bles on tine ater ta Being re eiveral hin space (8 Kant ad iy or Serpe oe ep sl (Bergson msstaned) ane aso ito payee spt "in coumessaveol space conaos compressed time nce, when we immn oreve in psjehiea pth ad tin Ay we find ta “hare sce severing nd tate unconscious fa oe ing set of pre drat ox ered amis, inpy abies" The fer we pute inert lacy othe wncoscas, he es impe= Uetecone te dcmoods of ne —wbeber a he eve of cases arin ‘rofunconcous Keaton To aim pyc lcfulnest st refomalle the Arcytn ssc: be psychical be in place. “Ph fs hen, Bacheard pes forthe peo sal sa lac cep cle or imagen dove a pst images. Ae sume ine mages offer a= ‘So et own content wheter hese coatens be coat, ev, it~ ui, o (gin) imagining. Senling on the src of the psyche, ‘Thies pocectng fom the dep, parca imapes ato place such Comnts flting thes nan nega bome fri comin prose ing Bachelor cals bis specllyimapnal sense of place ftcous pecs cont i he infeet pcs” ofthe svar, hi te TREE we lve” tha “elie pace Hosters vest “opp” hte pat of thone wh savor tiie inlacement—sbve al de ‘Sted ear of pouty. love fc nips goes had in hand with opm Js "fponalse ear he stamp of poplin” "Wo ar remied € Heidggn's cl for» poly of Bein” This al waned out of Heidegger concern io nove he peting chart of Thnkingeece chat at, song wi space, ssid to be “ill ved tree" Moreover ja space ras sud In Being and Toe 0 be “slit Upto pce” 0 pote images are for Bachlard spit ino te places they ofr for thir wm cae, Helge wool not aie tha poet abd =o The Reappewancect Pisce lwp come together inthe age term f which he wes deeply shy Fear would concert these sk he conjit vesture of oe ‘gam philoephzing so ay bares toplogy, logos (acount) of te pa ‘GES inn ouch poctzing inking fs ad where Being tds Hs ove (oe ace (Orachef >" What Baca calls "opoamays”Heieeget ere pera “im-pacing”o-plncig hog” In th a phase of is ee rch seks pinoy lnsped poec images as much # SeeSTasegacr in isle wating. ln heen bowers, despite a sted ‘nor tepeiag pct a8 of prvieged pot, he wo tikes past PeSpey. "The topology tat mts mot for Bacelrd i ot ht wich STEP nse “ou [ows] imate eing”* And the aia tremcendence of Hepp ein Beng is considered "Si intconons pore ani single"=exnnt be econced with he prc ‘Bt immancnce of Bache pean, anes preposag he pyc ashe seat ofl significa es sects dese ception of parcult iages, Sch images belie co ‘Sot ut arange hemssves it systema themes, for example aw te fre which taken togeter,cnstinte Bochelas owe ditve ‘aan Aa imagite poy opie tus inborn hema I 9 ‘eaty foal or avr he coment tee of given pi informs om witia, Moreover, here in principle mo init he umber otpcly regal thmes an subse al te bj to tpoanass. Yet cer ‘Menta undue piled ox notably, th fe Rouse, ich er eco ctuplrs of The Pets of Space ae deve Fo he house — 2 Sip wen ts als bomecomuin “Ie opm de ate ve Fe i iseger considered th world be “he ase in which mor ached wl ay he same of the image (nd menor) of he Tous wtich ensues owe poet placer habit by te rade ti ane topo! ake Aeon to the ule scares ofthe Supnedemerberes bse its naga tpoerapy, wil eve wa emcee feo ofthe sope and itso tpoaalyss "fe bur na prdoncl ety. As a home, is Your ist universe” a cou tao mod" hs auch, ik precedes ut sese a» more capecous ad aay weere. Buchel side piosopbes who post te univers ‘Rong before, ad independent of the house qua home. They lai © now viverse before they Kn the Rouse” whereas in fact wit Ruan ‘ngs now fasta never frget—are “he iain vaoes of inside se tape a set apa from be hosehe at a ae with TPS ot yt poeta” Sas ielevant » simple ut has mor, not Hee cea tan amuse, What mans isthe degree of itinacy {ee meni of our expense there; when tee are ssl Fels the very ‘Bilatine Semoon univers aa wotd—ich we cima elp but ma

You might also like