Professional Documents
Culture Documents
BestBuddies Employing People With Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities I4cp 2014
BestBuddies Employing People With Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities I4cp 2014
A ready pool of
ideal workers
pg. 10
In partnership with:
2014 by the Institute for Corporate Productivity (i4cp). All rights reserved.
No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed, or transmitted in any
form or by any means, including photocopying, recording, or other electronic
or mechanical methods, without the prior written permission of the publisher,
except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical reviews and certain
other noncommercial uses permitted by copyright law. For permission requests,
write to i4cp.com/contact.
i4cp RESEARCH
Chief Research and Marketing Officer: Kevin Martin
Senior Vice President of Research: Jay Jamrog
Senior Researcher: Joe Jamrog
Data Analyst and Survey Manager: Andrew Dixon
i4cp EDITORIAL
Managing Editor & Director of Research Services: Lorrie Lykins
Creative Director & Senior Editor: Eric Davis
FOREWORD
FOREWORD
Charles Calhoun
As a Global Ambassador for Best Buddies International, I speak to
audiences all over the world and tell my story. I used to tell people
about my experience getting bullied as a kid and how Best Buddies
has helped me to heal from those wounds and is creating a world
where other people with disabilities will not have to face that. Now I
still talk about bullying, but I also get to share the impact that having
a job has had in my life.
I was placed with Silicon Valley Bank through the Best Buddies
Jobs program over a year ago. Having a job means you get the
Having a job
means you get the
opportunity to go
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
I challenge corporations
with intellectual or
developmental disabilities.
Key findings
Survey analysis of organizations that employ people
with intellectual and developmental disabilities found:
1) Companies hire people with IDD for business reasons and are rewarded with business benefits.
Multiple dividends are cited, including the addition of highly motivated employees, demonstrating an
inclusive and diverse culture thats attractive to critical talent pools, and improving customer satisfaction.
2) The profile of a worker with IDD reads like that of an ideal employee.
Descriptors of individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities include: dependable, engaged,
motivated, great attendance, attention to work quality, and high productivity.
3) Positive reactions from employers abound.
Nearly three-quarters of those surveyed say hiring workers with IDD has been a positive experience, and
of those, nearly one-third say the experience has exceeded their expectations.
4) Challenges are fewer than expected and resources are greater than anticipated.
Employers report minimal difficulty with preconceived challenges, while support resources for a
successful placementlike job profile matching and guided onboardingare readily available.
Analysis of the data also revealed that success related to hiring workers with IDD is reflective of the level
of commitment an organization has to diversity and inclusion (D&I). Integrating D&I as part of the overall
organizational strategyas opposed to addressing it as part of a compliance initiative, a general corporate social
responsibility strategy, or simply not addressing it at allis a critical first stepone that also has a positive
connection to market performance.
Institute for Corporate Productivity | 3
INTRODUCTION
competitive jobs.
Federal involvement
disabilities.
51%
Overall
HPOs
LPOs
65%
33%
Level 3 - Talent
likely be wrong.
Overall
10%
HPOs
10%
LPOs
8%
Overall
HPOs
LPOs
2x
High-performance
organizations
are
more
likely
to address D&I at
the highest level.
13%
11%
6%
Level 1 - Compliance
Overall
HPOs
12%
5x
5%
25%
LPOs
Low-performance
organizations
are
more
likely
to address D&I at
the lowest level ...
14%
if they address
it at all.
9%
28%
Source: Institute for Corporate Productivity (i4cp)
respective workforces.
FINDING 1
High-performance
organizations are
37
more likely
to hire people with IDD
because they are
good talent matches
for open positions.
Positive
relationship
to addressing
D&I at a
business
strategy level
70%
64%
62%
57%
50%
47%
43%
41%
30%
14%
14%
(58%).
Michelles Story
Michelle, who has intellectual and developmental disabilities, also uses an electric wheelchair. Her
interests include working with children and visiting one particular shopping mall. While Michelle
couldnt work in daycare to read to children or pick them up, she was able to visit her favorite mall every
week. She knew where the pet store was, JCPenneys, Spencers, everything.
Easter Seals assistant VP of workforce development, Carol Salter, went to the mall to look for ideas for
a possible job for Michelle. A global coffee retailer had a kiosk there. Salter approached and asked if
they would consider bringing on a staff member if it would make the store more money. Employees
of the other stores in the mall often couldn't get free to visit the coffee retailer, so why not add a
delivery service? The store employees were willing to consider the idea. Salter registered with the state
vocational rehabilitation services and had a tray built for Michelles electric wheelchair, complete with
a bolted lock box and cup holders. The pair took several weeks and went to employees in every store,
introducing Michelle, saying she was going to work at the coffee retailer and deliver orders. Employees
would need to deposit exact change. Salter sewed a coffee store apron to the back of Michelles
wheelchair, and she was ready to go.
Michelle became an employee of the coffee retailer, receiving benefits for part-time work, and expanding
her social network. People in the mall knew Michelle by her first name. And the coffee retailer made
more money. Patrons started adding more than exact change, so Michelle earned tips as well.
After two months, Salter noticed that between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m. there were few incoming coffee
orders because most mall employees were taking lunch. So she thought, why not use Michelles slow
time to deliver lunches from the food court? Michelle also began working for the malls food court
association. Each food court vendor chipped in to pay Michelle to deliver lunches to workers for those
two hours each day. A light was installed above each store to alert Michelle when an order was placed
for delivery.
This success spurred Salter to go to other malls to broach the concept. Now we have to find people
with motorized wheelchairs to fill the spots.
Organizations with
strategic D&I seek a
community at large.
the community.
Positive
relationship
to addressing
D&I at a
business
strategy level
47%
44%
Addition of highly
motivated employees
Inclusive culture
attractive to our
talent pools
Improved customer
satisfaction
Improved communication
FINDING 2
or more
Dependability
88%
Engagement
87%
Integration with
co-workers
86%
Motivation
84%
Attendance
Positive
relationship
to market
performance
79%
74%
59%
Work quality
Productivity
Adaptability
Barbaras Story
Barbara Torres was one of the first hires made of individuals
with intellectual and developmental disabilities through
the Best Buddies International Jobs program at Holland
& Knight. That was 19 years ago, and shes still there today.
Partner Robert Friedman says theres a three-person staff in
the hospitality area; Barbara plays a key role there, preparing
lunches for meetings, stocking the service kitchen on each
floor, and stocking the main kitchen. Theres a significant
amount of work and a consistent flow of duties with little
down-time. Barbara knows what shes doing, and shes doing a
great job, said Friedman.
In the beginning, the idea was not so completely accepted by everyone; there were still some
misconceptions about individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Friedman recalls that
a supervisor didnt want Barbara serving lunch to a meeting of senior management in the conference
room and sometimes heard about others taking advantage of Barbaras friendly, good-natured manner,
necessitating a reminder that mocking a person's disability is offensive.
Barbara has a talent for remembering names. In Holland & Knights Miami office, there are about
100 attorneys and 100 staff members, and shes knows them all, said Friedman. Barbara works about
18 hours per week, Tuesday through Friday. When a new task is assigned, a Best Buddies job coach is
available to help, but Friedman says Barbara doesnt need major coaching. Heres how Friedman sums
up how Barbara favorably compares: Shes outlasted a number of supervisors and co-workers in the
hospitality positions.
(See the Holland & Knight case study on Pg. 22)
problems.
FINDING 3
Among high-performance
organizations
fully
Nearly
of
respondents
overall
23%
8%
50%
/3
1%
Don't know
58%
33%
27%
Materials management
19%
Customer-facing (retail)
18%
17%
11%
Transportation
11%
Other
Source: Institute for Corporate Productivity (i4cp)
developmental disabilities.
i4cp website)
Collins Story
Job customization
(combining elements of various jobs to create one)
Some 15 years ago in Seattle, a man with intellectual and developmental
disabilities worked in a sheltered workshop making 54 cents/hour. Well
call him John.
Carol Salter of Easter Seals workforce development knew John had skills
and the potential to be competitively employed. In her first meeting to
find out his interests, she learned John wanted to build truck engines.
While Salter knew he wouldnt pass the ASE certification, she made an
appointment to visit a company that built truck engines, hoping that as
she watched what employees did, it might spark an idea.
She saw $30/hour employees hauling in boxes of equipment and oil,
cleaning spills and breaking down boxes. Salter approached the firm to
explain how it could hire an $11/hour employee to bring in those boxes,
stock shelves, clean up spills, break down boxes and take them to recycle,
thus allowing $30/hour employees to do $30/hour work.
John was hired, and the productivity of the entire staff was increased. Not
only was John excited to work around truck engines, other employees
were excited that his presence allowed them to concentrate on what
they were trained to do. A job coach accompanied John for the first
two weeks and checked in with him periodically the third week. The
introduction served to demonstrate that a person with an intellectual
or developmental disability can be treated much the same as any other
employee.
In another example, Salter visited an aircraft manufacturing plant in
Seattle. She noted an assembly line function, where one person had to
cut cables, bundle wires, cut sleeves of different sizes, lengths and colors,
and deliver them to the next work station. She thought of an individual
diagnosed with obsessive compulsive disorder who loved repetitive work
and being precise.
Salter worked with the manufacturer to take pieces of those various tasks,
to set up jigs and to have this individual cut and deliver the materials. She
has since placed six other people with that employer.
FINDING 4
Preconceived concerns
about hiring workers with
IDD averaged
42
higher
45%
56%
46%
47%
Productivity/performance
34%
47%
37%
41%
Perceived
Actual
23%
38%
28%
Safety
Need for special accommodations
Showing top six concerns. Source: Institute for Corporate Productivity (i4cp)
Holland & Knight can attest to that. The Miamibased law firm brought in its first hire of an
50%
Long-term support
from community
rehabilitation agencies
49%
Job analysis to
determine fit
48%
Transportation
support
43%
36%
33%
Initial training/
onboarding support
Better communication
of support services
currently available
72%
i4cp website)
60%
54%
49%
discernible impact.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
EDUCATE
INTEGRATE
Integrate workers with IDD into your corporate
family. Treat them as you do all employees,
with performance expectations, feedback, and
rewards. Inclusion is a major engagement factor
and a culture trait that's appealing to top talent
and customers alike. People with IDD can be
inclusive culture.
EMULATE
with IDD, but this study has found that the payoff to
Getting started
S T R AT E G Y I N A C T I O N
Mitch Morgan
Leadership Development
Program Manager
Fifth Third Bank
Project SEARCH assists young adults with developmental disabilities in finding meaningful employment. Fifth
Third Bank implemented its first Project SEARCH model in 2006, and considered it a recruitment vehicle from
day one. Mitch Morgan, leadership development program manager, said the over-arching philosophy was to
bring diverse talent into the organization, a goal that has been met.
Project SEARCH interns fit in well at the operations center, which handles everything from loan and credit card
processing to customer service, mail operations, and commercial operations for various divisions. Weve shown
that IDD workers can do complex work, says Morgan. (See Collins Story on Pg. 14)
Morgan points out that in nine years, the bank has not created special jobs for applicants who have received job
training through Project SEARCH. They apply for, interview, and go through the hiring process just like anyone
else. Managers specifically see the benefits of the program in these candidates. They are prepared for the
world of work, for orientation, for performance management, Morgan says. (See a behind the scenes video
produced by the Ohio Rehabilitation Services Commission)
And, Morgan says, Project SEARCH has truly changed the culture of the bank. Weve seen the culture and
engagement levels of employees grow, but we have an ongoing challenge to reach 21,000 employees. His
S T R AT E G Y I N A C T I O N
One need only look at Holland & Knights 20-year history of working with Best
Buddies International to understand its commitment to bringing employment
Partner
opportunities to people with IDD. In fact, one of the first placements for the
Best Buddies jobs program, Barbara, is still working at Holland & Knight after
nearly two decades. (See Barbaras Story on Pg. 11)
Holland & Knights Miami office pioneered the firms involvement in hiring people with IDD. In 1994, two
employees began work at the law firm, supported by the Best Buddies program.
Barbara started working here when she was 26-years-old, and shes celebrating her 45th birthday this year,
said Friedman. She works in hospitality and has been a fantastic employee.
In the early days, the Best Buddies Jobs program was operating only in Miami, Boston and Los Angeles. In the
past two years, the employment program expanded beyond those first three cities.
Holland & Knight has experienced multiple benefits from integrating individuals with intellectual and
developmental disabilities into its workforce, says Friedman. Barbara rarely misses a day for illness or
appointments. She wants to come to work." Friedman attests that Holland and Knight's employees with IDD are
"doing a great job and are fulfilling a need in our organization.
S T R AT E G Y I N A C T I O N
Steve Pemberton
workforce, one that began with a straightforward idea. Randy Lewis, a former
Divisional Vice-President
and Chief Diversity Officer
Walgreens
is integral to business.
S T R AT E G Y I N A C T I O N
John Hailer
specialized investment managers based in Europe, the United States and Asia.
CEO
John Hailer, CEO of Natixis Global Asset Management in the Americas and Asia,
Supporting organizations such as Best Buddies can provide opportunities to people who need nothing more
than a little help and an opportunity to succeed, Hailer says. Whats good for the soul is good for your
company as well.
For the past five years, Natixis has sponsored a team and participated in the annual Best Buddies Challenge.
Taking part in Best Buddies employment program beginning in 2011 was a seamless expansion of that
relationship and aligns with the firms corporate culture.
Businesses need good workers, and communities need to enable people to maximize their potential, says
Hailer. People with IDD are a tremendous resource. Weve found people who are phenomenally responsible
and motivated. Our advice would be to partner with an experienced firm that can guide you through the hiring
and integration process.
Employees with IDD work in the firms Boston and San Francisco offices, providing office services that include
maintaining paper trays in printers and ensuring that conference rooms, kitchens, and other common areas are
clean, stocked, and organized. Initially, budgets and skills were something the company was unsure about, but
those concerns were quickly overcome by partnering
and to find suitable employees.
Hailer says, hiring employees with IDD is a morale
as well.
S T R AT E G Y I N A C T I O N
Lisa Damon
Buddies a natural.
Seyfarth Shaws more than 800 attorneys provide a broad range of legal services,
with offices in most major U.S. cities and international offices in London,
Executive Committee
Member
Seyfarth Shaw LLP
operations.
S T R AT E G Y I N A C T I O N
Silicon Valley Banks (SVB) success in integrating individuals with intellectual and
Head of Human
Resources
talent with the right role. Chris Edmonds-Waters, Head of HR at SVB credits Best
Matt Capaci
Staffing Manager
Silicon Valley Bank
for three months, then are hired on as regular employees. Theyre not in harms way, nor do we set up
expectations that might be too big a challenge. Theyre in level-appropriate positions, doing real work and getting
paid competitive wages, Edmond-Waters says.
SVB collaborates with Best Buddies to train supervisors and co-workers on how to prepare for working with
individuals with IDD, who go through the banks new hire orientation program just as any other employee does.
During the first week or so, an employment consultant from Best Buddies accompanies the worker on the job.
"Theyre in level-
appropriate positions,
Respondent profile
actively
recruit people
with disabilities
2x
APPENDIX A
A snapshot of additional
employer benchmarks
For full access to the findings of i4cps Intellectual and Developmental
as many
high-performance
organizations
differentiate for IDD
currently
employ workers
with IDD
Over
keep
oversight within HR
40
employ 1-5
people with IDD
21.8
average hrs./week
per employee
have
employed workers
with IDD for more
than 10 years
APPENDIX B:
Resource list
AbilityOne (abilityone.gov): The AbilityOne Program is the largest source of employment for people who are
blind or have significant disabilities in the United States. More than 500 nonprofit organizations employ these
individuals and provide quality products and services to the Federal Government at a fair market price.
The Arc (thearc.org): The Arc promotes and protects the human rights of people with intellectual and
developmental disabilities and actively supports their full inclusion and participation in the community
throughout their lifetimes. This site maintains links to many additional employment resources.
Association of People Supporting EmploymentFirst (APSE) (apse.org): A national non-profit membership
organization focusing on integrated employment and career advancement opportunities for individuals with
disabilities.
Best Buddies International (bestbuddies.org): A national non-profit dedicated to establishing a global
volunteer movement that creates opportunities for one-to-one friendships, integrated employment and
leadership development for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD).
Disability.gov: The U.S. federal government website for information on disability programs and services
nationwide. This site maintains links to many additional employment resources.
Employment Alliance for People with Disabilities (EAPD) (eapd.weebly.com): EAPD focuses on increasing
employment opportunities for people with disabilities and empowering business performance by leveraging
best practices in diversity and disability inclusion in the workplace, supply chain and marketplace.
Employer Assistance and Resource Network (EARN) (askearn.org): EARN's vision is to increase employment
and workplace inclusion for people with disabilities by engaging and empowering employers to be leaders in
this effort.
Easter Seals (easterseals.com): A national non-profit organization that provides services, education, outreach,
and advocacy so that people living with autism and other disabilities can live, learn, work and play in our
communities. This site maintains links to many additional employment resources.
Job Accomodation Network (JAN) (askjan.org): The leading source of free, expert, and confidential guidance
on workplace accommodations and disability employment issues.
ManpowerGroup/Access2Ability (manpower.us/ability): Access2Ability is ManpowerGroup's national
disability employment program, collaborating with employers, state and federal agencies, professional
associations and community-based organizations to help job seekers with disabilities connect with job
opportunities.
Office of Disability Employment Policy (ODEP) (dol.gov/odep): ODEP is a sub-cabinet level policy agency
in the U.S. Department of Labor with a mission to promote the adoption of policies that will impact the
employment of people with disabilities.
Project SEARCH (projectsearch.us): A business led, one-year high school-to-work transition program. Total
workplace immersion facilitates a seamless combination of classroom instruction, career exploration, and
hands-on training through worksite rotations. Project SEARCH's primary objective is to secure competitive
employment for people with disabilities.
RecruitDisability Job Board (recruitdisability.org): Job seekers with disabilities can search for a job, post
a resume, and get career news on RecruitDisability, a new job board especially for people with disabilities.
Employers and recruiters can also use the site to find qualified individuals with disabilities. You can also get
information about companies that are hiring now.
U.S. Business Leadership Network (USBLN) (usbln.org): A national non-profit that helps business drive
performance by leveraging disability inclusion in the workplace, supply chain, and marketplace.
Washington Initiative for Supported Employment (GoWise) (gowise.org) Based in Seattle, Washington
GoWise has been promoting equitable employment for people with developmental disabilities through
innovation, training and technical assistance for nearly three decades. GoWise is nationally recognized and
provides training related to Employment First initiatives throughout the U.S..
Workforce Recruitment Program (WRP) (wrp.gov): The WRP is a recruitment and referral programmanaged
by U.S. Department of Labor's Office of Disability Employment Policy (ODEP) and the U.S. Department of
Defense's Office of Diversity Management & Equal Opportunity (ODMEO)that connects federal and private
sector employers nationwide with highly motivated college students and recent graduates with disabilities who
are eager to prove their abilities in the workplace through summer or permanent jobs.
Acknowledgements
We express our appreciation to the individuals and organizations who made this research possible.
Matt Capaci, Manager of Staffing, Silicon Valley Bank
Chris Edmonds-Waters, Head of Human Resources, Silicon Valley Bank
Robert Friedman, Partner, Holland & Knight
Mitch Morgan, Leadership Development Program Manager, Fifth Third Bank
Felicia Nurmsen, National Access2Ability Leader, ManpowerGroup
Steve Pemberton, Divisional Vice-President and Chief Diversity Officer, Walgreens
Carol Salter, Assistant VP, Workforce Development, Easter Seals
John Hailer, CEO, Natixis Global Asset Management in the Americas and Asia
Lisa Damon, Executive Committee Member, Seyfarth Shaw
Additional thanks to Barbara Torres from Holland & Knight and Collin Biddle from Fifth Third Bank for their
personal employment stories.
Images used in this report feature employees placed through the Best Buddies Jobs program.
Cover:
Top left, Rianner Gonzalez, with Vanesssa Pineda, Hollywood Animal Hospital
Top right, Richard Reimer, Seyfarth Shaw LLP
Middle left, Christian Portillo, Latham & Watkins LLP
Middle right, Pelayo Vigil, Ocean Drive Magazine
Bottom left, Oliver Britten, Entertainment Tonight/The Insider
Bottom right, Erin Thompson, Rosetta Stone
Page 3:
Arjun Hemphil with Anthony K. Shriver at the Audi of America headquarters
Page 15 (top to bottom):
David Gauthier, City of Long Beach, Mayor's Office
William O'Brien, Eaton Vance
BJ White, Avid Technologies
Daniel Baumgarten, Holland & Knight
References
Annual Disability Statistics Compendium. Web. Jan. 2014. disabilitycompendium.org/
Heasley, Shaun. Kids Autism Care Runs $11.5 Billion Annually, Study Finds. Disability Scoop. Web. 4 Mar. 2014.
Institute for Corporate Productivity. (2014). Critical Human Capital Issues 2014. i4cp.com
Institute for Corporate Productivity. (2013). Interactive data. Intellectual and Developmental Disability
Employment Survey. i4cp.com
National Center on Inclusive Education (Fall 2011). Working Draft: Research on Inclusive Education.
Web. iod.unh.edu/NCIE
Siperstein, Parker & Drascher. (2014). Journal of Vocational Rehabilitation. National snapshot of individuals with
intellectual disabilities in the labor force.
U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Population Survey. Web. Jan. 2014.
bls.gov/cps/tables.htm#charemp
About i4cp
i4cp is a human capital research firm that discovers the people practices that
drive high performance. Ranked among the fastest-growing companies on the
Inc. 500|5000 list for four consecutive years, i4cp provides its extensive member
network of leading global employers and government institutions with the research,
peer collaboration, tools, and data essential to developing and executing workforce
strategies and practices that deliver higher market performance. To learn about
i4cp and i4cp's People-Profit Chain, an empirical model to increase organizational
performance up to 3x, go to i4cp.com/ppc
Find us on:
For more on advancing the role and impact of global diversity &
inclusion leadership, visit i4cp's Chief Diversity Officer Board page:
i4cp.com/solutions/chief-diversity-officer-board
Our partners
Best Buddies International is a nonprofit 501(c)(3) organization dedicated to
establishing a global volunteer movement that creates opportunities for one-to-one
friendships, integrated employment and leadership development for people with
intellectual and developmental disabilities (IDD).
Distribution partners
Association of People Supporting EmploymentFirst (APSE) (apse.org) assisted with the distribution of the
survey to its members in all 50 states, Puerto Rico, and abroad. Founded in 1988, APSE is the only national
organization with an exclusive focus on integrated employment and career advancement opportunities for
individuals with disabilities.
Washington Initiative for Supported Employment (GoWise) (gowise.org) assisted with the distribution of
the survey to employers and agencies across the US. Based in Seattle, Washington GoWise has been promoting
equitable employment for people with developmental disabilities through innovation, training and technical
assistance for nearly three decades.