Professional Documents
Culture Documents
First Draft Rhetorical Ana
First Draft Rhetorical Ana
Langlie 1
Cody Langlie
Professor Reed
RHET 1311
11 October 2015
Unequal Wage
Images seem to have the ability to communicate many different complex ideas
that cannot come from just text alone. An images ability to be simple and comedic can
make it easier to sympathize with a sensitive or important topic. The Denver Post
combined this image with text to express the common issue regarding the gender pay
gap.
The overall visual idea that the comic portrays is confidence and contradiction.
President Obama is speaking stating, Its not a myth. Its math! While doing so he
pointing to political sponsored graphic saying women earn 77 cents on the dollar. This
suggests to the viewer that the President is confident in the information he is
communicating. However, the two men on to the side of President Obama said And
we only had to find a female speechwriter 88 cents on the dollar to write the that
whopper! Saying that women should be paid equal to their counterparts is one thing.
Another is not actually practicing what you preach. Even though she is making more
than 77 cents per dollar of a male, it is still not equal. Proof that although the message
should be clear, it is contradicted by the very people who are behind it.
Langlie 2
The Denver Post is the source of this image, the comic was based upon a
speech by President Obama. President Obama gave the speech in 2014 addressing
inequality. The Denver Post believes that he used the figure that women earn 77 cents
for every dollar a man earns for campaign material during midterm elections. The
Denver Post said, Politicians use the figure because it fits the "women as victims in
need of a savior" narrative and it provides them campaign material during the election
season. It continues on to say that women are less likely to try to negotiate their wage,
and that the amount of hours worked plays a large role. While that could all be true, it
does not deter from the fact that women are generally paid less than men on average.
For example, in 2013 young adult males with a bachelors degree earned $51,900,
while their female counterparts earned $44,600. (U.S. Dept. of Education) By showing
the differences in pay it proves that even young educated women earn less than men
with the same education.
Narrowing the gender pay gap should be seen as the primary message of this
comic. Since President Obama has to state that its a fact women are paid less than
men, it can only be presumed that some people do not believe that. Therefore, one
could only be left to presume that President Obama would like to express the inequality
of pay. Also, the image has Equal Pay for Women as the title of the speech. Which is
seen as the primary message, but the two men on the other side interfere with the
message. The interference comes from them paying a female speechwriter less than
would a male counterpart. This leaves an impression that even the ones who may be for
equality are likely to fall susceptible to the common discrimination of women. Overall the
message is strong, but is impacted by the negative outliers.
Langlie 3
Langlie 4
on the side. The silly and basic image makes for comedic message, but its creativeness
puts a tone of simplistic seriousness that allows viewers to relate to the issue.
Langlie 5
Work Cited
"Annual Earnings of Young Adults." The Condition of Education. U.S. Department of
Education, 15 May 2015. Web. 12 Oct. 2015.
Kafer, Krista. "Kafer: Wage Gap Isn't so Simple." The Denver Post. N.p., 19 Apr. 4.
Web. 14 Oct. 2015.