Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lecture 13 Contemprary Modernism
Lecture 13 Contemprary Modernism
Deconstructivist philosophy
Some Deconstructivist architects were influenced by the French philosopher Jacques Derrida.
Eisenman was a friend of Derrida, but even so his approach to architectural design was developed
long before he became a Deconstructivist. For him Deconstructivism should be considered an
extension of his interest in radical formalism. Some practitioners of deconstructivism were also
influenced by the formal experimentation and geometric imbalances of Russian constructivism.
There are additional references in deconstructivism to 20th-century movements: the modernism/
Lizzitzky assembled collections of geometries at various angles floating free in space. They evoke
basic structural units such as bars of steel or sawn lumber loosely attached, piled, or scattered. They
were also often drafted and share aspects with technical drawing and engineering drawing. Similar
in composition is the deconstructivist series Micromegas by Daniel Libeskind.
Computer-aided design
Computer aided design is now an essential tool in most aspects of contemporary architecture, but
the particular nature of deconstructivism makes the use of computers especially pertinent. Threedimensional modelling and animation (virtual and physical) assists in the conception of very
complicated spaces, while the ability to link computer models to manufacturing jigs (CAM Computer-aided manufacturing) allows the mass production of subtly different modular elements to
be achieved at affordable costs. In retrospect many early deconstructivist works appear to have been
conceived with the aid of a computer, but were not; Zaha Hadid's sketches for instance. Also, Gehry
is noted for producing many physical models as well as computer models as part of his design
process. Though the computer has made the designing of complex shapes much easier, not
everything that looks odd is "deconstructivist."
Critical responses
Since the publication of Kenneth Frampton's Modern Architecture: A Critical History (first edition
1980) there has been a keen consciousness of the role of criticism within architectural theory.
Whilst referencing Derrida as a philosophical influence, deconstructivism can also be seen as
having as much a basis in critical theory as the other major offshoot of postmodernism, critical
regionalism. The two aspects of critical theory, urgency and analysis, are found in deconstructivism.
There is a tendency to re-examine and critique other works or precedents in deconstructivism, and
also a tendency to set aesthetic issues in the foreground. An example of this is the Wexner Center.
Critical Theory, however, had at its core a critique of capitalism and its excess, and from that
respect many of the works of the Deconstructivists would fail in that regard if only they are made
for an elite and are, as objects, highly expensive, despite whatever critique they may claim to impart
on the conventions of design.
The difference between criticality in deconstructivism and criticality in critical regionalism, is that
critical regionalism reduces the overall level of complexity involved and maintains a clearer
analysis while attempting to reconcile modernist architecture with local differences. In effect, this
leads to a modernist "vernacular." Critical regionalism displays a lack of self-criticism and a
utopianism of place. Deconstructivism, meanwhile, maintains a level of self-criticism, as well as
external criticism and tends towards maintaining a level of complexity. Some architects identified
with the movement, notably Frank Gehry, have actively rejected the classification of their work as
deconstructivist.[11]
Critics of deconstructivism see it as a purely formal exercise with little social significance. Kenneth
Frampton finds it "elitist and detached".[12] Nikos Salingaros calls deconstructivism a "viral
expression" that invades design thinking in order to build destroyed forms; while curiously similar
to both Derrida's and Philip Johnson's descriptions, this is meant as a harsh condemnation of the
entire movement.[13] Other criticisms are similar to those of deconstructivist philosophythat since
the act of deconstructivism is not an empirical process, it can result in whatever an architect wishes,
and it thus suffers from a lack of consistency. Today there is a sense that the philosophical
underpinnings of the beginning of the movement have been lost, and all that is left is the aesthetic
of deconstructivism.[14] Other criticisms reject the premise that architecture is a language capable
of being the subject of linguistic philosophy, or, if it was a language in the past, critics claim it is no
longer.[5] Others question the wisdom and impact on future generations of an architecture that
rejects the past and presents no clear values as replacements and which often pursues strategies that
are intentionally aggressive to human senses.[5]
Peter Zumthor (born 26 April 1943) is a Swiss architect and winner of the 2009 Pritzker Prize.
Zumthor was born in Basel, the son of a cabinet-maker. He apprenticed to a carpenter in 1958 and
studied at the Kunstgewerbeschule in his native city starting in 1963.
In 1966, Zumthor studied industrial design and architecture as an exchange student at Pratt Institute
in New York. In 1968, he became conservationist architect for the Department for the Preservation
of Monuments of the canton of Graubnden. This work on historic restoration projects gave him a
further understanding of construction and the qualities of different rustic building materials. As his
practice developed, Zumthor was able to incorporate his knowledge of materials into Modernist
construction and detailing. His buildings explore the tactile and sensory qualities of spaces and
materials while retaining a minimalist feel.
Zumthor founded his own firm in 1979. His practice grew quickly and he accepted more
international projects.
Zumthor has taught at Southern California Institute of Architecture in Los Angeles (1988), the
Technical University of Munich (1989), Tulane University (1992), and the Harvard Graduate
School of Design (1999). Since 1996, he is professor at the Accademia di Architettura di Mendrisio
His best known projects are the Kunsthaus Bregenz (1997), a shimmering glass and concrete cube
that overlooks Lake Constance (Bodensee) in Austria; the cave-like thermal baths in Vals,
Switzerland (1999); the Swiss Pavilion for Expo 2000 in Hannover, an all-timber structure intended
to be recycled after the event; the Kolumba Diocesan Museum (2007), in Cologne; and the Bruder
Klaus Field Chapel, on a farm near Wachendorf.
In 1993 Zumthor won the competition for a museum and documentation center on the horrors of
Nazism to be built on the site of Gestapo headquarters in Berlin. Mr. Zumthors submission called
for an extended three-story building with a framework consisting of concrete rods. The project,
called the Topography of Terror, was partly built and then abandoned when the government decided
not to go ahead for financial reasons. The unfinished building was demolished in 2004.[1] In 1999,
Zumthor was selected as the only foreign architect to participate in Norways National Tourist
Routes Project, with two projects, the Memorial in Memory of the Victims of the Witch Trials in
Varanger, a collaboration with Louise Bourgeois (completed in 2010), and a rest area/museum on
the site of an abandoned zinc mine.[2]
For the Dia Art Foundation in Beacon, New York, Zumthor designed a gallery that was to house the
360 I Ching sculpture by Walter de Maria; though the project was never completed. Zumthor is
the only foreign architect to participate, with two projects, the Memorial in Memory of the Victims
of the Witch Trials in Varanger, a collaboration with Louise Bourgeois (to be completed in June),
and a rest area/museum on the site of an abandoned zinc mine (completion date 2011). In
November 2009, it was revealed that Zumthor is working on a major redesign for the campus of the
Los Angeles County Museum of Art.[3] Recently, he turned down an opportunity to consider a new
library for Magdalen College, Oxford. He was selected to design the Serpentine Gallery's annual
summer pavilion with designer Piet Oudolf in 2011.[4]
Currently, Zumthor works out of his small studio with around 30 employees, in Haldenstein, near
the city of Chur, in Switzerland.[5]
Recognition
In 1994, he was elected to the Akademie der Knste in Berlin. In 1996, he was made an honorary
member of the Bund Deutscher Architekten (BDA). In 1998, Zumthor received the Carlsberg
Architecture Prize for his designs of the Kunsthaus Bregenz in Bregenz, Austria and the Thermal
Baths at Vals, Switzerland (see below). He won the Mies van der Rohe Award for European
Architecture in 1999. Recently, he was awarded Praemium Imperiale in (2008) and the Pritzker
Architecture Prize (2009).
Literature
Zumthor's work is largely unpublished in part because of his philosophical belief that architecture
must be experienced first hand.[7] His published written work is mostly narrative and
phenomenological.
Thinking Architecture
In Thinking Architecture Peter Zumthor expresses his motivation in designing buildings that speak
to our feelings and understanding in so many ways and that possess a powerful and unmistakable
presence and personality. It is illustrated throughout with color photographs by Laura Padgett of
Zumthor's new home and studio in Haldenstein.
To me, buildings can have a beautiful silence that I associate with attributes such as composure,
self-evidence, durability, presence, and integrity, and with warmth and sensuousness as well; a
building that is being itself, being a building, not representing anything, just being. The sense that I
try to instil into materials is beyond all rules of composition, and their tangibility, smell, and
acoustic qualities are merely elements of the language we are obliged to use. Sense emerges when I
succeed in bringing out the specific meanings of certain materials in my buildings, meanings that
can only be perceived in just this way in this one building. When I concentrate on a specific site or
place for which I am going to design a building, when I try to plumb its depths, its form, its history,
and its sensuous qualities, images of other places start to invade this process of precise observation:
images of places I know and that once impressed me, images of ordinary or special places places
that I carry with me as inner visions of specific moods and qualities; images of architectural
situations, which emanate from the world of art, or films, theater or literature.
Atmospheres
Atmospheres is a poetics of architecture and a window into Zumthor's personal sources of
inspiration. In nine short, illustrated chapters framed as a process of self-observation, Zumthor
describes what he has on his mind as he sets about creating the atmosphere of his houses: Images of
spaces and buildings that affect him are every bit as important as particular pieces of music or
books that inspire him.
From the composition and presence of the materials to the handling of proportions and the effect
of light, this poetics of architecture enables the reader to recapitulate what really matters in the
process of house design. In conclusion, Peter Zumthor has described what really constitutes an
architectural atmosphere as "this singular density and mood, this feeling of presence, well-being,
harmony, beauty...under whose spell I experience what I otherwise would not experience in
precisely this way."
Peter Zumthor Therme Vals
Therme Vals is the only book-length study of this singular building, features the architects original
sketches and plans for its design as well as Hlne Binets striking photographs of the structure.
Architectural scholar Sigrid Hauser contributes an essay on such topics as Artemis/Diana,
Baptism, Mikvah, and Springdrawing out the connections between the elemental nature of
the spa and mythology, bathing, and purity.
Annotations by Peter Zumthor on his design concept and the building process elucidate the
structures symbiotic relationship to its natural surroundings, revealing, for example, why he
insisted on using locally quarried stone. Therme Valss scenic design elements, and Zumthors
contributions to this book, reflect the architects commitment to the essential and his disdain for
needless architectural flourishes.[8]
Seeing Zumthor
Seeing Zumthor represents a unique collaboration between Zumthor and Swiss photographer Hans
Danuser, containing Danusers images of buildings created by Zumthor. More than twenty years
ago, in a milestone event of twentieth-century architectural photography, Danuser photographed, at
Zumthors invitation, two buildings: the protective structure built for archaeological excavations in
Chur and St. Benedicts Chapel in Sumvitg. When first shown in exhibition, those photos ignited a
lively debate that has been revived with a recent exhibition of Danusers photographs of Zumthors
most famous work, the spa at Therme Vals. Seeing Zumthor collects these three important series of
Danusers pictures and includes essays by leading art historians exploring the relationship between
the two seemingly different disciplines or architecture and photography.[9]
Frank Owen Gehry (born Frank Owen Goldberg; February 28, 1929)
His buildings, including his private residence, have become tourist attractions. His works are cited
as being among the most important works of contemporary architecture in the 2010 World
Architecture Survey, which led Vanity Fair to label him as "the most important architect of our
age".[2]
Gehry's best-known works include the titanium-covered Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Spain;
MIT Ray and Maria Stata Center in Cambridge, Massachusetts; Walt Disney Concert Hall in
downtown Los Angeles; Experience Music Project in Seattle; Weisman Art Museum in
Minneapolis; Dancing House in Prague; the Vitra Design Museum and MARTa Museum in
Germany; the Art Gallery of Ontario in Toronto; the Cinmathque franaise in Paris; and 8 Spruce
Street in New York City. But it was his private residence in Santa Monica, California, which jumpstarted his career, lifting it from the status of "paper architecture"a phenomenon that many
famous architects have experienced in their formative decades through experimentation almost
exclusively on paper before receiving their first major commission in later years. Gehry is also the
designer of the future Dwight D. Eisenhower Memorial.[3]
Much of Gehry's work falls within the style of Deconstructivism, which is often referred to as poststructuralist in nature for its ability to go beyond current modalities of structural definition. In
architecture, its application tends to depart from modernism in its inherent criticism of culturally
inherited givens such as societal goals and functional necessity. Because of this, unlike early
modernist structures, Deconstructivist structures are not required to reflect specific social or
universal ideas, such as speed or universality of form, and they do not reflect a belief that form
follows function. Gehry's own Santa Monica residence is a commonly cited example of
deconstructivist architecture, as it was so drastically divorced from its original context, and in such
a manner as to subvert its original spatial intention.
The Gehry Residence is Frank Gehry's own house. It was originally an extension, designed by
Gehry built around an existing house. It makes use of unconventional materials, such as chain link
fences and corrugated steel. It is sometimes considered one of the earliest deconstructivist
buildings, although Gehry himself denies that it was deconstructivism.
The Gehry Residence is located in Santa Monica, California. In 1977, Frank and Berta Gehry
bought a pink bungalow that was originally built in 1920.[citation needed] Gehry wanted to explore
with the materials he was already using: metal, plywood, chain link fencing, and wood framing.
[citation needed] In 1978, he chose to wrap the outside of the house with a new exterior while still
leaving the old exterior visible.[1] He hardly touched the rear and south facades and to the other
sides of the house he wedged in titled glass cubes. Then, in the fall of 1991, they chose to remodel
due to the needs of their growing family including two teenage boys.[citation needed] Many of Gehry's
neighbors were not happy at the unusual building being built in their neighbourhood. It's rumoured
that one neighbor used to regularly bring his dog to defecate on Gehry's lawn, in protest
The Guggenheim Museum Bilbao is a museum of modern and contemporary art, designed by
Canadian-American architect Frank Gehry, built by Ferrovial,[3] and located in Bilbao, Basque
Country, Spain.
It is built alongside the Nervion River, which runs through the city of Bilbao to the Atlantic Coast.
The Guggenheim is one of several museums belonging to the Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation.
The museum features permanent and visiting exhibits of works by Spanish and international artists.
One of the most admired works of contemporary architecture, the building has been hailed as a
"signal moment in the architectural culture", because it represents "one of those rare moments when
critics, academics, and the general public were all completely united about something."[4] The
museum was the building most frequently named as one of the most important works completed
since 1980 in the 2010 World Architecture Survey among architecture experts.[4]
In 1991, the Basque government suggested to the Solomon R. Guggenheim Foundation that it
would fund a Guggenheim museum to be built in Bilbao's decrepit port area, once the city's main
source of income.[5][6][7] The Basque government agreed to cover the US$100 million construction
cost, to create a US$50 million acquisitions fund, to pay a one-time US$20 million fee to the
Guggenheim and to subsidize the museum's US$12 million annual budget. In exchange, the
Foundation agreed to manage the institution, rotate parts of its permanent collection through the
Bilbao museum and organize temporary exhibitions.[8]
The museum was eventually built at a cost of US$89 million.[9] About 5,000 residents of Bilbao
attended a preopening extravaganza outside the museum on the night preceding the official opening,
featuring an outdoor light show and concerts. On October 18, 1997, the museum was opened
When the Guggenheim Museum Bilbao opened to the public in 1997, it was immediately hailed as
one of the world's most spectacular buildings in the style of Deconstructivism (although Gehry does
not associate himself with that architectural movement),[13] a masterpiece of the 20th century.[14]
Architect Philip Johnson described it as "the greatest building of our time",[15] while critic Calvin
Tomkins, in The New Yorker, characterized it as "a fantastic dream ship of undulating form in a
cloak of titanium," its brilliantly reflective panels also reminiscent of fish scales.[14] Herbert
Muschamp praised its "mercurial brilliance" in The New York Times Magazine.[16] The Independent
calls the museum "an astonishing architectural feat".[12] The building inspired other structures of
similar design across the globe, such as the Cerritos Millennium Library in Cerritos, California.
[citation
needed]
The museum is seamlessly integrated into the urban context, unfolding its interconnecting shapes of
stone, glass and titanium on a 32,500-square-meter site along the Nervin River in the old industrial
heart of the city; while modest from street level, it is most impressive when viewed from the river.
[5][16] With a total 256,000 square feet, it had more exhibition space than the three Guggenheim
collections in New York and Venice combined at that time.[7] Eleven thousand square meters of
exhibition space are distributed over nineteen galleries, ten of which follow a classic orthogonal
plan that can be identified from the exterior by their stone finishes. The remaining nine galleries are
irregularly shaped and can be identified from the outside by their swirling organic forms and
titanium cladding. The largest gallery, measures 30 meters wide and 130 meters long.[6][16] In 2005,
it housed Richard Serra's monumental installation "The Matter of Time",[17] which Robert Hughes
dubbed "courageous and sublime".[18]
The building was constructed on time and budget, which is rare for architecture of this type. In an
interview in Harvard Design Magazine, Gehry explained how he did it. First, he ensured that what
he calls the "organization of the artist" prevailed during construction, to prevent political and
business interests from interfering with the design. Second, he made sure he had a detailed and
realistic cost estimate before proceeding. Third, he used computer visualizations and collaborated
closely with the individual building trades to control costs during construction.[19] Computer
simulations of the building's structure made it feasible to build shapes that architects of earlier eras
would have found nearly impossible to construct.[
Renzo Piano, Ufficiale OMRI (Italian:[rntso pjano]; born 14 September 1937 in Genoa) is an Italian
Pritzker Prize-winning architect. Architecture critic Nicolai Ouroussoff said of Piano's works that
the "...serenity of his best buildings can almost make you believe that we live in a civilized
world."[1]
In 2006, Piano was selected by TIME as one of the 100 most influential people in the world.[2] He
was selected as the 10th most influential person in the "Arts and Entertainment" category of the
2006 Time 100.
Piano was born in Genoa, Italy, in 1937 into a family of builders. He was educated and
subsequently taught at the Politecnico di Milano. He graduated from the University in 1964 and
began working with experimental lightweight structures and basic shelters.[3] From 1965 to 1970 he
worked with Louis Kahn and Z.S. Makowsky. He worked together with Richard Rogers from 1971
to 1977; their most famous joint project, together with the Italian architect Gianfranco Franchini (it)
is the Centre Georges Pompidou in Paris (1971). He also had a long collaboration with the engineer
Peter Rice, with whom he shared a practice (L'Atelier Piano and Rice) between 1977 and 1981.
In 1981, Piano founded the Renzo Piano Building Workshop, which today employs 150 people and
maintains offices in Paris, Genoa, and New York City.[4]
In 1994, Renzo Piano won the international competition for the new Auditorium in Rome. The
Auditorium Parco della Musica, a large multi-functional public music complex situated in the north
of city, was inaugurated in 2002.
In 1999, Piano designed a watch entitled "Jelly Piano (GZ159)" for the Swatch Summer Collection.
The watch design is clear and the exposed inner workings were influenced by his Centre Georges
Pompidou design.[5]
On 18 March 2008, he became an honorary citizen of Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina.[6]
Piano's recent expansion of the Art Institute of Chicago includes a 264,000-square-foot (24,500m2)
wing with 60,000 square feet (5,600m2) of gallery space[7] called the Modern Wing, which opened
on 16 May 2009.[1][8] It includes a "flying carpet", a sunscreen that hovers above the roof and a
620-foot (190m) steel bridge connecting Millennium Park to a sculpture terrace that leads into a
restaurant on the wings third floor.[9]
His current projects include the The Shard, Europe's tallest skyscraper which was opened on July 6,
2012, and the Centro de Arte Botn. The Botin Foundation,[10] the largest private foundation in
Spain, will invest over US $150 million for the construction and programming of a new Botn
Center that will become an international reference in culture and education for the development of
creativity through art.[
Biography
Taniguchi is the son of architect Yoshir Taniguchi (1904-1979). He studied engineering at Keio
University, graduating in 1960, and studied architecture at Harvard University's Graduate School of
Design, graduating in 1964. He worked briefly for architect Walter Gropius, who became an
important influence.
From 1964 to 1972, Taniguchi worked for the studio of architect Kenzo Tange, who was perhaps
the most important Japanese modernist architect, at Tokyo University. While in the Tange office,
Taniguchi also worked on projects in Skopje, Yugoslavia and San Francisco, California (Yerba
Buena), living on Telegraph Avenue in Berkeley while involved in the latter project. Important later
collaborators include Isamu Noguchi, American landscape architect Peter Walker, and artist
Genichiro Inokuma. Taniguchi is best known for designing a number of Japanese museums,
including the Nagano Prefectural Museum, the Marugame Genichiro Inokuma Museum of
Contemporary Art, the Toyota Municipal Museum of Art, and the Gallery of the Hry-ji Treasures
at the Tokyo National Museum.
Taniguchi won a competition in 1997 to redesign the Museum of Modern Art, beating out ten other
internationally renowned architects, including Rem Koolhaas, Bernard Tschumi, and Jacques
Herzog and Pierre de Meuron. The MoMA commission was Taniguchi's first work outside Japan.
Taniguchi has since won a commission to design the Asia House for the Texas branch of the Asia
Society. This $40 million project will be located in Houston's museum district and will be
Taniguchi's first free-standing new building in the United States.
Steven Holl (born December 9, 1947) is an American architect and watercolorist, perhaps best
known for the 1998 Kiasma Contemporary Art Museum in Helsinki, Finland, the 2003 Simmons
Hall at MIT in Cambridge, Massachusetts, the celebrated 2007 Bloch Building addition to the
Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art in Kansas City, Missouri,[1] and the praised 2009 Linked Hybrid
mixed-use complex in Beijing, China.[1]
Early works
Kiasma, Helsinki, 1993-1998
Holl won first prize in the Amerika-Gedenkbibliothek International Library Design Competition in
1988, an expansion and renovation of the American Memorial Library in Berlin. In February, 1989
Holl's work was exhibited in a solo show at the Museum of Modern Art (MoMA) in New York City.
MoMA later purchased twenty-five works by Holl for the museum's permanent collection. In the
1992 competition for a new contemporary arts museum in Helsinki, Finland, Holl's entry, entitled
"Chiasma," won first prize out of more than five hundred international entries. The museum opened
to the public in 1998, having permanently adopted the name "Kiasma," the Finnish translation of
"chiasma."
Career
Holl graduated from the University of Washington and pursued architecture studies in Rome in
1970. In 1976, he attended graduate school at the Architectural Association School of Architecture
in London and established his offices New York City. Holl has taught at Columbia University since
1981.
Holl's architecture has undergone a shift in emphasis, from his earlier concern with typology to his
current concern with a phenomenological approach; that is, with a concern for man's existentialist,
bodily engagement with his surroundings. The shift came about partly due to his interest in the
writings of philosopher Maurice Merleau-Ponty and architect-theorist Juhani Pallasmaa.
Architecture in
English II
Lecture 13: Recent Movements
Fall 2012
Peter Zumthor
Frank Gehry
Renzo Piano
Yoshio Taniguchi
Steven Holl