Οι Τρεις Εποχές Του Πανεπιστημίου Σταύρος Δ Μαυρουδέας

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 104

pos .

M a u p o u d e a s

^ | .

. :

. H - :

III. :

V.

1. :
2. ^

3. -
4.

VI. TO ()

VII.
1. :
2. ,

3. -

-:
:

VIII.

. :


. -
-

. -
- .

.
1

.
- ,
-
, ,
. , -
-

.


.

.

-
- . ,
,
.

.
5


.
, (
2)
.

(, .)

. , , ,

.


, ,
.


. ,

(, ,
).


,
.
.

.

.

. ,
.
6

,
. , ,

.

.

.

'
. ,

, .

.

.

.

,

.
- - -
.

, . (
),
.
-
.

- 3.

.
. ,
- -

Smith Ricardo-

. ' - ( )
.
,
. ,

(
),
.

-
. , '
. '
(Schultz (1964),
Blaug (1976), Bowen (1977) .)
. ,

: (educational production
functions)
(marginal

productivity

functions)

(marginal utility functions).


(externalities),
(spill-over effects) ,
.

.
8


. -

()

.
.

.

'70.

)
-

).

- -
.

'



.
,
, -

- -
.

. - :

.

.
, ,
- -


- -


. , (
)
.
,

-
.
.
-
.
-


4 . ,

( ).

( ).

( ),
10

(Parsons (1959), .

(
)
- .

- 5.

.
, , .
Bowles - Gintis (1976)
Bourdieu .


,
.
(
) ,
.
, - ,
.

.
. ,
, :
,
.
5

Maroy - Doray (2000)

,
( ), -

.
.
-
(, , .)
.
11

,
:
.
(
-): ,
-

,
.
- -
6.

Bourdieu -

Giddens

(societalisation). , (habitus) Bourdieu's (duality of structure) Giddens

.
(Social capital)
-

(Bourdieu (1977a) -

(Cultural capital) -
( ),
(Bourdieu
(1977a).
.

. ,
-


. ,
12


- (
).
,


. -
- (
),

.
-
-
,
.

,
.

.

.
,
-- (concrete-in-thought)
.


, - , .


.
, , . ,

(
) ,
, .

Lash (1990), Bourdieu


.
13

. :

-
-
,
.
.
, , .

.

.
.
. -

- -
.

. -
-
.

, 11 12 .

7.

-
(1999, .35). , (2000)

.
14


. ,

.
.

, .

.




.
-

8.

.
.

( )

(
) (
,
).
. ( )

.
- - ,
' .


. ,
, - 15

- '
-

.
oi

.

( )
.
.
9
,
.

.


.

- -
( ) .

, -
. -



. ,
,
' .

.
9

' universitas

.
.
16

,
,
.

, 17 18 ,

.

, 18 19 ,

. '
,
. ,
,
, , . ,
( .) -
-
,
.

,
- .

. ,
,
.
, , '
.


. - ,
,

17

10.

, ,
.
,
, .

10


,
(2000, . vii). ,


,


.
,
-

- . -
19
20 ,
. -
- , ,
.
, (
,


.

. , -
-
.
18

11
.


. ,
- .
20 ,
1870,
, .

( - )

.
-
-
. ,

.

.

.


.
20
. 1973
.
. '

11


.
19


12.

-
.
,
,
.

.
,

. ,
, ,
.
(
) - -
.
- -

. , ,

12

19
.

.

"" - - -
,

- (1993)).
(, , ),
,
. (
)

.
20


- .
(managers)
.

IV.


. (
):
()
,
()

()
(
), .



13. .
,

13

(..
)
.

.
21

,
;


.


, .
, - -
:

.

14.

. ,
(, .)

, .

. ,
-
- 15.

, ,
. '

(,
)

14

, - ,


( (2000),
.99).
15

Weber ((1989), .106)

.
22

(
, .).

.
( )
( )

.
. , ,

. ,
-
- .


,
. ,
. ,


.
,
.
,

. -
.
,
.
, -
,

( .) -
( )
,

23


.
.
-
- .

.

(labour

process).

(, , .)
,

( )

. ,
( , , -)
. , ,
. - '

),

. -
-

16.

16

-

. ,
. ,
,
.
24


,
. ,
,

. '
,
-
.

.

.


, .
(
)

( )

.
,
- ,
.

-
- (
) 17.

.

( , .).


(
).
17

( ) :
.
25

,
-
- .

18.
( ),
.

(
)

.
- ' (
)
(

. ,
-
, , -
, ( (capital in

,
( Braverman (1974),
, ).
,
:
.
-
- (
) .


. ,
.
18

(1993, .38-42)


.
26

general)),
, , . ,
(
) -
.
,
-
- - " ".
( ' )
. ""
.

,
()
( ) .


, -
. -

( .) -

19.

-
,
,
, : .

19


.
27

) .
.

, -
.
- (
/-) 20 .
.

, - (
, ' , -
21),
. ,
(

): - .
,
,
- .

20

- ( -, )

-
- - .
21

- ,

. ,
- (
)
- .
28

22,
( )
.
.

(
)
, .
. -
. -
-
-
( )
.

22

Mandel (1979, .56)

(
).
. ,
, .
.

,
(
), (
, -
)
.
-
. -
Mandel -
. , ,
, .
29

-.
- .

,
.


, (
). ,

"

", ( )
.
. -
- (
),
.
,
,

-
.
-
.

:
.
,
,
- -
' . , ,
. -
-
. ,

30

V.


.
.

.

,
.


.
.
70
.

1973,

(,
, ,
.).
, -
- .
-
( (1994))
. , ,
- , ,
.
,
,

. ,

- -

31

-

.

.
;
, ,
; ;
,

;

70,
. :

(
). -
/- - ,

. ,


. ,

.
,

.
-
. -
- :
,
"
. ,

32

20
( Lenin).


,

20 .

(Lenin (1977), Hilferding


(1981), Luxemburg (1971), Bukharin (1976) ..),
.
.
(),
(
)
, , .

:

. Marx .
, (Marx (1982), ., .47)
-:
(), , , .
, ,

. ,

, - -

.
Hilferding
(1981), -
( ,
)
.
-

33

. ,
- -

Hilferding.

Lenin (1977),
- -
. Lenin -
Hobson (1902), Hilferding Bukharin. ,
Lenin.
* ,

23.

,
,

24.



.
- .

. -
, -

23

Hilferding

(1981)

""
" ", " " "
". Kautsky
.
24

, , Lenin

. ,

- -
.
34

. - . ,
-25, .
-
- -
() ; -

. ,
.
(Althuser-Balibar
(1977), Poulantzas (1975, 1978)),
"
26.
,
( ). -
, .
, ,
()
. ,
.

.

.

. ,
-.

25

, (

) (.

).
26

(1988, .100-108)

.
35


,

27. ,
. , ,
. ,
Fine-Harris (1979),
.
-.

, ,
.
-

.
.
, -


- 28.
,

27

Zeleny (1980, .3) Marx, Ricardo,

. , Ilyenkov (1982)
Marx
- .

.
28

Marx 1844

.

.
36

- -
. , ,
- .
-
.

.

- . ,
70, ( (Aglietta (1979)),
.) -
-
.

( Brenner-Glick (1991), Mavroudeas (1998, 1999))
( - - )

. ,

Fine-Harris (1979),


.
, , ,

. ,

.
-

.
-.

.

.
-

37

- ,
(
(1994)). ,
, ,
,
.

-.
. ,
, ( ,
.)
-. (
) .
, , -
, -
.


.

.

, -
.
(

).


. ,

. , ,
- . -
, ,
-
.

. ,

38

-
- -
.

. ,
, -.

, ,
. (Fine-Harris (1979),
.)
.
( Mavroudeas (1998, 1999)) ( Brenner-Glick
(1991)) . ,
.
,
.
, ,
-
- ..:
1) /
2)
. ( ,
.)
. (
, .)
.
3) (
, () - .)
4) :

.
.
5)
6) : -

39

-
. ,
.

.

:
() ( 19 )
() -: 1)
( 1929
2 . ) , 2) - (
2 . 1973).
() 1973
, .
. ,
- ,
, .


1) /:
, ,
. ,
,
, - .
2) :
.
. : .
,

.

.
. : ,
(. -

) ( ).

40

. :
.
3) : . ,
.
4) :
,

.
5) :

,
.
,
.


( ),
(, ) .
.
6) : . ,

-
1) /:

,
.

(
, .).
2) :

. , -
-
.

41

.
,

( )
. , -

. -
( )
.
-
.
-
, . -
- .
. :
.

. ,
, (
.).
. :
. ,
, .
. :
,
( .).

(,

)
( ).
.
3) : ,
- . ,

42

, ,
, .
-
,
.
4) :
.
5) :
,
.
. - , , -
,
.
6) : ,

( -
).


1) /: '

-
. ,
.
Braverman -
, , -
(, , Lane (1989)).
( - ) -

43

29.

, .


(.. ,
.). ,
,
,
- 30.
-

. ,


.
- ,
- . -, ,
-

,

- -

( )
. ,
-
-
,
.
,

29


Braverman .
30

, -

.
44

,
.

, -
, , . -
.

,

.
(-
(2000)) , (Schor (1994)).

2) :
. :
.
.
,
(
). ,

, .
,

.
,
,
.
. :

(

.).

(
- ) ( -
).

( )

45

( , .).
Bretton Woods.
. : -

.
-
(

).


.
- , ,
-

(..

).

.

3) :
.
. ,
(
),
- .

,

.

4) :
-
. 1973
.

5) :

,

46

.

- .

6) :
- .
- -
. , (,
, NAFTA .)

VI. TO ()


,

. ,
, .

Ryan

(1998)

-

.
Thatcher
,
.

,
, .

.
-

-
.

.

47

, Luke (1998),
(Sabel Piore

(1984)),

31


,
.
Gibbons -
(culturally concentrated
knowledge) (socially
distributed

knowledge).

(
) . ,
,
,

.
( ) (
,
.),

,
Luke

- - 32. -

31

,
.
32

(Callinicos (1985)), -
. Lyotard
. To - (post-structuralism)
. (textualism) Derrida


. Wortham (1999) (
) Derrida (1992)
- ,
48

, ,
-
.
-
,
- .
,

).
(populist)
.
- -
.
. -
(
) ,

. , ,
,

(
, , .)
.

70 ,
-
. ,
Luke Foucault, Deleuze
Guattari -

.
49

. ,
, .

/- ( -).
- - -
/ / -

() . ,
- ,
-
(, , ).
:
33 ( ,
, ( )

["

"])

( )
.

( -)
. , -

.

33

-
-
.

(, ,
- (2000, .111-119).
,
. ,
Humboldt - .
50

-
. -
, -
- .

" " -

( ) -
,
.

(, .).
( )

. -

Weber

(1989)).

( )
( ) (
) .
,
.
:
18 19 .

. ,
, "" ( numerus
clausus,
). , -
,
(

51

)34.
.
-
()
( ) . ,
, ,

).

(
[
]), -
, ( )
.

, ,
. ,

.

) -
.
(
,

).
.
- ,
- - .
-
-

35. ,

34

Marx Engels -

- " ".
35

,
52

.
, ,

.
- -
:
("

")

, - .

. , ,
,
. Thorstein Veblen 1900

Frank Underhill

^xe lro d (1990, .81)). -

-
.
,
,
.
- :
.

VII.


70,
- .


.
53

()

, .

,
. ,

. (
)
: ,
.
,
, .

(Research

and

Development)

. 19
- ,
- .
( , .)

.

, (
, - ).
(
[ ],

).

.
-
/ -
( ) .
,
,

. (
)

54

.
"",
. , /
"" - .
36 " "

(

).

,
,

-
. (
,
)
.

. ,
( )
( ),

36

. ,

/ ( Machlup (1962))
(utility
functions) .
( , ) -
- ( )
( )
.
55



. ,
-
-
- . ,

.


. ,
- - ,
, . ,

( )
37. -
-
( ).
- ,
-
( )
-

. ,

,

.

37

.).

(..

).
56

(..

-
-
,

.

- -

.
,
,
38.
,


.

,
. ,
.
,
(
, ) ,
-
, ,
, -

.

38


( .).
- -
( .) -
.
57


.
(university of excellence)

. ,
,
(

)39. , -
,
, (managers)
.

.
,
.
.
(
).
.

.
.

. , -

39


-
, ,
,.

( )

.
58

, ,

.
.



.
.

1. :

. Soley (1995)

. ,


.
, ,

(
).
, ,
. -
- ,

59

,
.
:
. Taves (1998, .59)
Andersen Consulting,

.

( Luke (1998, .24-25)).
.
.
,
.
-, ,
.

. &


.

,
.
..
, Glassboro State College New Jersey Rowan

60

College 100 . Henry Rowan


(Soley (1995))40.
,


-

Ford (The New York Times, 4 , 1996),



Ford (a "Ford curriculum for the next century").
:
,
,
.
.
.




,
()

40

3 .
-

Rowan.


, .
61

' -
-
-

.

1980
1981. Bayh - Dole 1980,
(executive order) 1983,

.
,
.
& ,
.
Recovery Tax Act 1981
. Soley (1995),
.

,

235 . 1980 600 . 1986, 1996


2 . (2000)
1980 1998
8,1%. , Bayh - Dole
250 , 1998
2800 .


. Stanford
, Yamaha,
20
( (2000)).

. NevadaLas Vegas 2
.

ACE

62

Denken

(Soley (1995)).
C , .
. ,

C.
C
.
C .

. Minnesota


(Soley (1995)).
- -

, Soley (1995), to MIT


(Industrial Liaison Program - ILP)
10.000
50.000 .
,
.
ILP,

ILP, 2
, 12

...

,
.
,

, (New Products Program - NPP).


.
500.000 2 . ,

.

63


. ,


. ,
Peter McPherson,
Ford Reagan ray Michigan State University
(Soley (1995)). , ,
Yates (1998):

Pittsburgh
(managers)

. (Board of Trustees)

. ,
, ,
( )
(scholars). Pitt-Johnstown, ,


- (business-like)
.

.

, , ,
.) .

-
,
- () (,

64

.) -
.

(fast

food),

, . ^
Georgetown
Coca Cola, Maryland
Pepsi ("Taking Sides in the Cola Wars" - The Guardian Weekly, 11 ,
1998). Midwestern College
.

, .
. 1996 Wisconsin
Reebok,
(Soley
(1995)). Reebok, ,
, .

Reebok

Reebok.
,
.


, ,
.

.
- ,

-
-
. ,

65

. ,
.
(

).


,
.


.
- -
-


.
.


.
,


.

.
-
- .
-

. .
-
-

.

66


.
.
. Soley (1995)


.
Texas W.Cunningham
Jefferson - Pilot Corp., John Hancock Fund Management Co. La Quinta
Motor Inns (

).

Cunningham


. ,

. Yale
- Yale - New Haven. ,
(2000),

. 1980 1990
85 . Seragen,



Seragen. , California
, , .

,
(board of trustees) . ,
.
-

.

67

( ),
. ,
-
.

.

. ,
,
.
1970,

.
-
- .

.
,
(,
.).
- -
.
,
. .
, ,

: ,


.

68

(
(2000)).

. New England Journal of Medicine


1994


. (Soley (1995)). ,

. Boots 250000
California - San Francisco
(Soley (1995)).
Boots.
Journal of the American Medical Association
- Boots


. ,

.
(2000, .3) 1997 2.167
6
.

2.

-
.

41, .

41

, , ( Kivinen-Rinne (1994),
Bruce Johnstone (1994)).
69

,

.
- ,
-
.

42.

,



.
,
.

, ,
.
42

Ivy League

-.
,
.
.

, ,
.

- ,
.

(
Yale),
.
70

.
.
(
) .

.

.
Aronowitz (1998)
2 . :
,

, ( )

. O Geshekter
(1998, .36), ,
( ),
(
) ,
.

(1999,

.6),

Miller

(1996,

.121-2).

(Advisory Board for the


Research Councils) 1987 : (R2) 15
( ),
(X) 15
,
(T)

. Oxborough
(Oxborough Report on the Earth Sciences).

(University Grants Council) ,

71


. Miller
(Research Assessment
Exercise)
.

,
. ,

. .

43.



.
, /

,
, ,
.
( - ,
) ,
.
( ).

43

M -

(1999) -
.
.
- ,
,
-
.

( )
.
72


.
- -
,
( (1994, 1995, 1995)).
- -

.
-
-

(..
,
).


. ,
(
,
), ( )
.
,

- -

, -


.

. ,


.

.

73

. Soley (1995)
1995
.
-
- Newt Gingrich
.
Gingrich 655 .
(175 . ) .

3. -
-

- .
- -
.
-


. -
,

( , ).
""
( ).
,
- -
- -
.
(, )
,
.



(
).

( ),

74

(, .),
.

.

. -

(, .)
- .
- ,

.
, ,
- ,
.
-

( .).
, 60 70

.

. ,


. ,


44. (

44

,
75

) - .
,
.

-


.
, -
.

(
) (
). ,
,

45,

,
-
' .

- . ,
- .

- ,
, -
.
45


,
,
-
-
, .
.
76

,
( )
(, )

.


.

-.

( )
. ,

, -
,
,
.
, .

.
: ,

( -) -
-
.
(
) -

77

-
( ,
).
, -

(, ,

).
- ,
(
).

. ,


.

.
,
. -

. -
(managers) ,
,

46. ,

46

,
( -) :
,

.

. ,
( )
.
78

(, ,
)


.
Weber (1989, .97-98)
, 20 , -
-
:
,

.
" .
. ,
,
" . ,
,
, .
,
' .
, " .

"
... , '
, ,
(
), ,
.
.

Weber
: ( " ,
) .

79


- -
.
.
, (1)
, (2)
( ) 47.

-
(
).
, , -

. ,
,

.

- -
. ,
(academics labour process,
f i l l e r (1996)) . -
-

,
.
,
.

( , .).

.

47

- Fine-

Harris (1986), .3.


80

( , .)
. , ,
( ),
( .).


.
, .

,
.

( ) .
.
( )

: (managerial control).
,
, (
,
) .

.
.
(tenure)

, (.. ,
, B.Foley Mediations,
1998) .
48.

48


81

,


49.
,
. ,
,
( , .)
.

.

, -
-
.
-

-
.
, ,
( )

.
-

- . ,

(good

causes)

(inefficiency) ( Miller (1996, .124-126)).


49

O Yates (1998)

, ( ,
),
-.
82

.
,
,

50.

-:

(
)

.

- .

.).


.


.
( )
. ,
.
- (
) -

50

, (distant learning)


.
83

.

51.
- -

(
[tenure track]).
( )

, .
, Carr (1999), Georgia State University
95
(non-tenure track).
,

(per course wage).
( .)
.
30% .
,


(Yates (1998)).

, (..
Collinson

(2000)),

.
,

Rajagopal-Farr

(1992,

.317),

51



.
84

: ,
,
.


, 52.

,

.


(gipsy scholars). -
-

,

.

,
(ESRC)

(Collinson (2000), .166).


( Braverman) . ( Collinson
(2000), .163-168)
. , Rajagopal-Farr
(1992, .319) , ,
Braverman .

52

Gappa

(1984,

.75)

25% 35% ,

. , Rajagopal-Farr (1992, .325-326)

(, ) ( .)
- ..
85

53
(
) .
Rosenblum-Rosenblum (1996) (tenured)
(
)
.

Rajagopal-Farr

(1989,

.267)

.
.
.

80 90


.
, Geshekter (1998, .50, .39) 1997 40%

(part-timers),
- . , Pan (1998, .106)
, 1970

53



( ) .
(


( (1998)).
86

22% 1993 40%. Foley (1998)


1998 45%.
, Colinson (2000)

. , Rajagopal-Farr (1992)
.

:

, .
-
,

,
. ,
,

,
60 70, .

- , ,

-
.

,
,
60 70. H
80

.

87


.
,



.
, ,

. ' ,
(.. , )
- - .
- ,
,
.


. () -

-
-

()


,
,
.
-
- .

88


.
-
(
, ).
,
.

.

, .
,


.

,

54.

,
Bourdieu

54

55.

Newman (1997)

( )

.

.
55

Bourdieu , -
-

.
89

-
-
.
( Master)

. ,

. ,
,

,
.



( ),

,
(credential inflation). , ,
,
-
,

Bourdieu


,
(
). ,
- -
, ,
.
-

(
Brown (1995)) -

.
90

.
.

,
: .
,

. ,
. -

- ,

.
( ,
.),


56.

- ,
, -

(apprentices). ,
,
. ,

56

-
.


(


() .
91


( Carr (1999)) ,
,
( , .),

,
.

. , Erard
(1997) Yale
864

(contact

hours)

,
756.5. Texas Austin, 1996-97,
, 55 132
11 29 .

.


- -
.
Yale
1995 57.

,

57

: (Will teach
for food: academic labor in crisis) Cary Nelson (1997),
Illinois Urbana-Champaign.
,
- ,
GESO -
Yale situation
.
92

. 1995,
(Teaching Assistants)
(Graduate Employees and Students
Organization - GESO) Yale (grade strike) -
Yale
.
, GESO
, ,
. Yale - -
its $4 billion endowment, and its
non-profit status, 250
.
(American Association
of University Professors) Yale

GESO .
, ,
.
Andrew Ross (1997), Social Text,

(corporatization)
, Yale
.
,

1998


California

.
,

(United Auto Workers).



.

93

()

...

-L

(
)

, -

VIII

94




. ,
(
) . ,
()
. ,
().
,
.


.

.
-
.
,


. , (culture wars)

58

(politically

correctness)58,


(.. , , , ).
,

.

95

,
.
Minnesota,

(Soley (1995)).


.

/

. ,

. ,
- -
.

- ( .).
,
.

, ,
.
,
, .
.
,
-
- -
. -

(, , .) -

. ,
,
.
96

- .
,
.
, ,
59.

,
.
,
-
- .


.

.

. ,
.
,
-

. -
-
. -
-
- -
.

. -
- (

59

B.Foley

(1998) C.Nelson (1997). O Nelson (1997, .6)



(workplace).
97

)
.


.

.

,
,
.
.



.
-

. -


,
:
.

.

, .

.

- .

-
-
.
.

98

.


. ,
,
. ,
.
,

, .

60.


. ,

(
)
. ,

( , .).
,

.
-
- .

60

(sweatshop).

( ,

.).

(Worker Rights Consortium).


(Fair Labor Association).
99


Aglietta M. (1979), "A Theory of Capitalist Regulation", NLB
Althusser L.-Balibar E. (1977), "Reading Capital", New Left Books
Aronowitz S. (1997), "Academic Unionism and the Future of Higher Education"
Nelson ed. (1997), Will Teach for Food: Academic Labor in Crisis ,
University of Minnesota Press
Axelrod P. (1990), Making a Middle Class: Student Life in English-Canada during
the
Thirties, Montreal-Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press
Becker G. (1964), Human Capital , Columbia University Press
Blaug M. (1976), "Economics of education", Penguin
Boulding K. (1969), "Economics as a moral science", American Economic Review,
vol.LIX March
urdieu P. (1977a), Cultural reproduction and social reproduction in Karabel J.

Halsey A.H. eds., Power and Ideology in Education, Oxford University Press
urdieu P. -

Passeron J. (1977), Reproduction in Education, Society and

Culture ,
Sage
Bowen W.G. (1977), "Assessing the economic contribution of education Cosin
B.R. ed. (1977), "Education: Structure and society", Penguin
Bowles S. (1971), "Unequal Education and the Social Division of Labor", Review of
Radical Political Economics, vol.3 no.4
Bowles S. - Gintis H. (1976), Schooling in Capitalist America, Basic Books
Brenner R.-Glick M. (1991), The Regulation Approach: Theory and History , New
Left Review no. 188
Bruce Johnstone D. (1994),
2000 . (.),
, Gutenberg
Bucharin N. (1976), "Imperialism and World Economy", erlin
Callinicos A. (1985), Post-modernism, Post-structuralism, Post-Marxism', Theory,
Culture and Society, vol.2 no.3
Carr F. (1999), Organizing for a Fair Deal: The History and Prospects of the
Academic

100

Labor Movement, Modern Language Association,


27 1999
Collinson J. (2000), "Social Sciences Contract Researchers in Higher Education:
Perceptions of Craft Knowledge", Work, Employment and Society vol.14 no.1
Derrida J. (1992), Mochlos Rand R. (ed.), Logomachia: The Conflict of the
Faculties, University of Nebraska Press
Erard . (1997), Class Solidarity On Campus, the Picket Line Begins to Form - A
book
review of C.Nelson ed. Will Teach for Food, Texas Observer, 18
1997
Fine B.-Harris L. (1986), " , Gutenberg
Foley . (1998), Nelson C. ed. (1997), Will Teach for Food:
Academic Labor in Crisis, University of Minnesota Press Contemporary
Literature vol.39 no.2
Gappa J. (184), "Part-time faculty: University at the crossroads, ASHE-ERIC Higher
Education Research Report no.3
Geshekter C. (1998), The Politics of Higher Education Finance in California, Telos
no.111
Gibbons M. (1994), The New Production of Knowledge: The Dynamics of Science
and Research in Contemporary Societies, Sage
Hilferding R. (1981), "Finance Capital, Routledge
Hobson J. (1902), Imperialism - a study, Allen & Unwin
. - . (2000),
. E ^ ;, 7

( )
lyenkov E.V. (1982), "The dialectics of the abstract and the concrete in Marx's
Capital", Progress
. - . (1999), ,
27-9-1999
Kivinen O. - Rinne R. (1994),
. (.),
, Gutenberg
Lane C. (1989), Management and Labour in Europe, Edward Elgar
Lash S. (1990), Sociology of Postmodernism, Routledge
Lenin V.I. (1977), Imperialism, the highest stage of capitalism in Lenin I.V. (1977),

101

Selected Works, Progress


Luke T. (1998), The future of Universities in an Era of Flexible Specialization, Telos
no.111
Luxemburg R. (1971), "The Accumulation of Capital", Routledge
Machlup F. (1962), "The production and distribution of knowledge in the USA",
Princeton University Press
Mandel E. (980), ", ",
. (2000), .., 12-3-2000
. (1994), , 24-12-1994
. (1995), : ,
1-1-1995
. (1995), : ,
8/1/1995
Maroy C. - Doray P. (2000), Education - Work Relations: Theoretical Reference
Points for a Research Domain", Work, Employment and Society vol.14 no.1
. (1994), :
, .5
. (1994), :
, .9
Mavroudeas S. (1998), Contemporary Capitalism: Is there a new stage in
process?" Marx II International Congress,
CNRS - University of Paris X, 30 - 3
. (1998), :
;
,
,
, 27-29 1996,
Mavroudeas S. (1999), Periodising Capitalism: Problems and Method - The case
of the Regulation Approach Research in Political Economy vol.17
. (1993), ,
. (1988), :
,
Miller H. (1996), Academics and their Labour Process, Smith C.-Willmott H.
(1996)

eds., White-collar work, Macmillan

Nelson C. (1997) ed., Will teach for food: Academic Labor in Crisis, University of
Minnesota Press

102

Newman K. (1997), Poor, Hungry and Desperate or Privileged, Histrionic and


Demanding? In Search of the True Meaning of PhD, Nelson C. (1997)
ed., Will teach for food: Academic Labor in Crisis, University of Minnesota
Press
Pan D. (1998), The Crisis of the Humanities and the End of the University, Telos
no.111
Parsons T. (1959), The School Class and a Social System: some of its functions in
American Society, Harvard Educational Review vol.29 no.4
Poulantzas N. (1975), "Classes in Contemporary Capitalism", New Left Books
Poulantzas N. (1978), L Etat, le Pouvoir, le Socialisme, PUF
Rajagopal I. - Farr W. (1989), The political economy of part-time academic work in
Canada, Higher Education vol. 18
Rajagopal I. - Farr W. (1992), Hidden academics : the part-time faculty in Canada,
Higher Education vol.24
. (2000), : ,
Rosenblum G. - Rosenblum B. (1996), The flow of instructors through the
segmented labor markets of academe, Higher Education vol.31
Ross . (1997), The Labor Behind the Cult of Work, Nelson C. (1997) ed., Will
teach for food: Academic Labor in Crisis, University of Minnesota Press
Ryan D. (1998), The Thatcher Government Attack on Higher Education in Historical
Perspective, New Left Review no.227
Sabel C.-Piore M. (1984), "The second industrial divide: possibilities for prosperity",
Basic Books
Schor J. (1992), The overworked American, Basic Books
Schultz T. (1964), "The economic value of education", Columbia University Press
Soley L. (1995), Leasing the Ivory Tower: The Corporate Takeover of Academia,
Boston: South End Press
(P.Bourdieu, C.Charle, B.Lacroix ..) (1999),
,
Taves M. (1998), The New Fragmentation in Higher Education, Telos no.111
. (1999),
, 11-7-1999
Weber M. (1989), " ", .,

Wortham S. (1999), Rethinking the University: Leverage and deconstruction,


Manchester University Press

103

. (1991), "
" (1991), "
"
.- . (1993), "
,
Yates M. (1999), Lambs to the Slaughter, Workplace - The Journal of Academic
Labor,
vol.1 no.2
Zeleny J. (1980), "The Logic of Marx", Blackwell

104

You might also like