.
| BARRIE RICHARDSON
Kaster Egg Divination: A Weighty Problem
nis effect follows the same basic plot ofa trick I “Kurotsuke” appealed to me for is directness and also for its
lished years ago, unt fo method, which utilized "a bluff.” [ have borrowed this rus
sa and added some other bits and pieces.
Wh former's ‘When I was a small boy I used to think
ect d hic powers. She
1¢ performer aurel had
ifully produced
m. His presen a
ifying. One in particular, visiting us eachGenii
select a colored Easter egg while her back was turned. She
tunertingly would tell each person the color of the egg they
were hiding from her. Sounds ikea simple demonstration, yet
it was perplexing to me and to everyone who saw her do it.
“A few years ago she explained the secret to me, The
solution has nothing to do with mystetious powers. but is
the result of a careful reading of body language and voice
clues, Let me give you a demonstration of what she did and
to make this more inclusive I will invite everyone in the
audience to participate. Since I am not as experienced at this
as my sister, you may not see perfection.”
Four persons are invited to come forward and to either
stand in a row or sit in chairs provided. Four different col-
cored plastic eggs are shown and placed in an ordinary small
paper bag, The performer's head is clearly curned away as he
extends the bag and invites each petson to dip in and remove
an egg. They are asked to hide the egg between their palms,
“Now ler try a warm up experiment. lam going to ask.
cach one of you the same question ... ‘do you have the red
gg?’ I want each of you to answer with one word—thar
word is ‘no.” This means one of you is fibbing and, of course,
thrce of you willbe telling the truth. I want the a
Tisen to the answers and watch the behavior of the partci-
ppants as I query them.
“Are you ready? Remember, only one word. Please be
sctious for a few minutes.” The performer points to the first
person, “Do you have the red egg?” "No,” she replies. The
same question is asked of the other three helpers and they
respond by saying “No.”
“Turning tothe audience. “Have you made a decision? Let
ime sce if you can tell who is telling che truth. This gives you
pretty good odds since we have three truth tellers.” Looking
at Mary, he asks, “How many people believe Mary is telling
the truth? Raise your hand if you believe she does not have a
red egg?” Most hands go up. “In this case | agree with the
majority. Mary you are a ruth-teller. Now open your hands
and show everyone the white egg you have hidden.”
The audience looks a litle puzded. They are thinking,
“How did he know the color ofthe egg in Marys hand? “Lets
tay the experiment again, but this time I will ask each of you
ro answer yes to my question. Two of you will be lying and one
‘of you will be telling the truth, Remember, just one word
yes.” Addressing the first person, “Do you have the red egg”
“Yes,” she says. The other two respond by aso saying “Ye.”
“Turning to the audience, “Are you ready co find the
truth teller? That is the one who has the red egg,” A short
pause. The performer confidently identifies a person and
asks her to show the audience she has the red egg
Turing co the last wo persons, the performer pauses and
then says dramatically, “You, st, have the white egg and you sir
the green egg. Pease show the audience your egg.” The per
former is correct. Not an astounding feat, but quite puzzling
‘Method:The plastic oggs | use are slightly smaller than real
cegs. They open and can be filled with sweets and snapped
shut. A bag of 24 miné Easter eggs cost around a dollar.
“Two of the eggs, for example, the red and the green
gg arc filled wich heavy steel or lead fishing weights. I
pur three, 3/4 ounce steel bullet weights into each ofthe
two eggs. This isa very snug fit so there is no rattling, Ya
may choose to use other size weights and then place
small amount of tissue paper into the egg to hold the
firmly in place.
‘The other two eggs are filled with loosely-packed ti
paper. This gives them a litle more weight and,
importantly, makes the eggs less translucent. The fou
resting on a table look the same (in terms of lucidity),
‘wo are clearly heavier.
To perform the effect, place only three eggs in the bag
‘The fourth egg, for example the heavy red eg is held b
in your lefc hand. ‘The fingers ofthe left hand (thumb isa
the outside of the bag) conceal the egg, This is like a "Mis
Dream” position with a coin bucket.
“The frst person is invited to select an egg, If che he
green ogg is taken, you will immediately know this by
change in the weight. The green egg will be selected on
third of the time, You then drop the hidden red egg into
bag as you shake it and invite another person to remove
«gg. As this process continues you will know by the d
cof weight, the “owners” of the red egg and the green egg
If the frst person does not take the green egg, dol
drop the red egg. Now the next person has 2 50/50 ch
of taking the green egg. Ifthe green egg is removed, drop
red egg and proceed to have the eggs removed. Once agi
you know the persons who have the heavy eggs.
‘Seventeen percent ofthe time the green egg will not
taken by the first wo persons. In this case, tile che bag
allow the green egg to roll and lodge at one corner. Th
release the red egg in such a way so iti situated on the ot
cersideof the bag. Now you can have an egg selected andy
can tell by the way the bag is weighted which eg
sd. Another approach is to hold the bag on the
the Fingers of your left hand for the last wo se
tions and have your lefe thumb press against the side ofh
and hold the green egg. Then release the red egg. Then of
the bag, holding it by the bottom, and of course you
know which egg, is removed.
In all cases you know which person has the green
which person has the red egg, and you also know that
other two persons have either a blue or a white egg.
The first revelation is a bluff (Mavens idea). Yo
approach one of the persons who has either the white a
blue egg and declare them a truth teller, which you kno
But how do you know the color of the egg this p
is holding? You don’t! But, you pater on with confideng
and when you say “open your hands and show the audi
your white egg.” You do not know the color is white
you catch a glimpse as their hands are opening, Time ya
patter to coincide with the hand opening action.
you have determined who has the white egy
now know which colored egg is held by the three rem
ing participants.
1 originally thought of using ping pong, balls. Ha
pong balls, however, are a curiosity and would se
pingtricky wo a helper. A heavy plastic eg fels firm and solid and
does not seem particularly strange.
Thave recently discovered that rather than using fishing
weights, the exgs can be filled with coins. The light eggs
could have 2 dimes and be filled with tissue paper. The
heavy eggs could be filled with pennies or nickels. The spec-
rarors could keep the eggs and the small gift. They need not
be sealed shut, since they snap together. I do not do this.
keep the eggs and thank my helpers. My old friend Fred
Robinson would have called this a weighty trick.