Research on the Role of Classroom Discourse As It Affects
Reading Comprehension
‘Martin Nystrand
Unie of Wir ado
ree cre rah lnate fring porous experimental ati of srl ps
ing radon hoe rent and coals, lation and rary esechers nt
yma il el ae kof centre en ase cri ise
‘sre conet. Thi reewof roach on lnm dure maf eng compen
on ity exainig 15 oof rear on sm due, ed then finding ed
sighs shaped by ines ni! sts ofthe process an rein compre
ein rete i he dae icant satura and lg sch por cine
‘hat caso dour acl roup work and lec dias work san
pie enone (eas set) fr aoa dele. Newsies caine sated
‘lz al in elton dina ccm ull ati eed the
sano,
‘Toa grat extent the fnguage used by teachers nd stents in eassrooms
etrines what sone a ho arming takes place
Welkom & Silman (2000, p 337)
Introduction
nts ealto reform American evestion, the Department of dation’ asttate
fun Sines (ES) promotingarigorousrcach agenda erasing
‘perimental studies and randomized tales modded afer FDA cia
trae new drugs Caren JE reqs for proposals REP) resize ecaccers
‘orga thir ties ost propose instructional textment one varie
tate agains standard pedagogies. Thisappoachtoedcationesetchechoes
‘he National Research Counc (NRO) chim hat the word ofeduation unlike
dee, heath ae, Fins production doe ot es on asttongresearh
ase In othe fiidare personal experience andidenogy oferty elon
‘oma poiy chokes ann no othe ids thersearchbuesoinadegoateand
ews" (NRC 199,01). Ching tbe NAC report Grover Whur Duetor
Nena ‘tnarnm nacre ana tease Comprenean 7
DF TES, concedes that research on reang and learning to read i adequate for
siding early elementaryschool instruction but hat sch research base falls off
forreadng“at ater pointsinschooingand totally missing forall other areas of
instruction including science, math and writing (2002, .2)-Whitehsestgbes on
toargue,
“The extent of ou ignorance mask by folk wisdom” of education bated onthe
experince of han beige ove the milena in pussng information a al fom
eegenerion tothe next This ewinlom emplrenmenstitccnsjues dot
bedne story
Poe rae slat heme and ha
Ewen Sn 11878.
Hs. (185). Nis with Lames
Iicond workin oman ond cso
New ov Cambridge Univesity Pres
sf Rom A. (1995) ama
{dinittin: Quen abd questioning
{ibe boseas new itv Reach
nmgwopd Sd non, 28.1
Hoss. (996 icone aing and
tenching Ia, pple) even of
‘ew ncn (VL 21 pp. 995
‘Watingn, DO=ABRA,
Hoes (867 Also ie
nal hr ir
(ighsch Eng ae Unpobi
Ahetral iacraton, Washing Une
ory eA Wf (960 The
peritec ofthe statin. Ameri
‘Bhat Rac or & 1-157
bos, Anon R. Ws LB
Lie) penser of tenon dig
‘sain oes, Jor of Edson
‘Byeolagy 98 6173,406 tesearh ne easing tao
aso 6197) eo oeton aa
Ieactoel are Lapua an Sse
men Wy Va, (978)- Toad
‘oie of exe copreensin and pra
‘Son Pye ein 65,3639
Roost, D(982)-The spread of mis
‘aor Teor spt dal
Sm Ameri raf Sao 87,
cn Lag (997) Fur oth
[pale nking a Animvesigtion of
(ee ects. ura ofr Resch 28,
Less D210, Thing hot»
rn: erden- band aso of he
|S are cre oi ad
mpi jor edit Wishing
tem DG Natal ntti Chad Heh
‘nd Hurnan Devopment NICHD»
Ls.) asiinget coe
‘son The dabraton ofp Eno
gen Larges Smita Bae
(El eer ets exh Bien te
(pp. 169-15) Newham
adie Asoc.
Ls), Dioson a explore
Urata ad the bins possi
(CNewall & R Dur Eae), pring oe
Theylo dscason ra wring th
wching adi eee (pp. 25
|W) None UChr Gordon
{Lae (1999) Bon eae
hea inden nd erste
Inaction Now or ahs Calg
Pr
sa) 200), Bengt ods Techn
nile nd highschool entered and
ite rien ction Rech
Sow 357 80,
as.) Siig asa sal fr
erry eprom The pede!
Inpleaton ofen in her
ge (NCTE Reseach Roper N38,
Ubinas cre
Volume 10 May 2006
Ios € 2.195). Acura sd
come spent: Ting tan
Ares gh al tes sin
thesyinterpreetion. Rn Rc
aren 86.
Lis. (1987.Brnghome schon
Teal: mode fear reponse
‘echitg [a] Hood 58 Heath & Lapp
(a) hand fr lira actor
Resch on hing he mmuve and
tl rep. 38031) New rk
Nacnin
Lec (198) Comprbensiie inp
tnd tod langage susion. Whats the
‘lates Stes ned Lona
‘eget 1530532.
MucNaata D Koch By Som NB
Pe esc (1958, nde ae
ee inercton ef eter,
Tacground knowidge ad sol
sncestndng neg ome
(api ad ncn 18-3
Massa Stone, Ps SEM
(09) Tenge of epee
Pate of sce doa
Eee bana I NCTE
eka MB ye Wom (988)
Gespling waht ides Qusoning the
uta The owing Tach, #690385,
‘Mn PN. (1974), Thermal ethan
Tey sie Wee Tra)
{atindes ohn Hopi Univers Ps
(Giga ook pblsbed 928
Mora, B..F PsxD O19
[Mrcsfdscouse ype on a Arcot
"uct ora 21203,
aus (1922) Te admins ws of
Ing toa inthe ig schon
hii) The admin of
nip tee entra ero of
[etion Soe othe tu of aan,
‘ae pp 18923) Bloomington
Pac tho! bling Co
Maw, PK, at M208 Apel.
We era ta a A means of
sera ‘aero cnr an tenia Comaahenin “9
ceson appothsSanposum pete
the ennol meen the Aree
cational ear Asai, None,
Canad.
ue We Soe (190), Wd shea
opeotons aati and mening
ew worde Cain arco, 7108
7,
Nai Rena Canc 19%),
Tmprering staan nomi Astra
rrcaton ens utaeon Wakingon,
De: Naina Acie Pres
Nisns (0. Tes of wien
Noman Stan ep teet
‘res ond den, Onde FL Lond:
Ksieic Pram
‘Saas M199, pel-On he gi
Homa wnersondng een dr nd
tes mare asi tie al of
‘Chol ing Pope ponte ate
‘Comerionf he Aenean Edens
‘sec Acton, Chg.
ros M (nr Gn A Kao
eStomenn 7 Or |
(blog: Undertones
Tips dcr oe Ei
aso New Ys eho Cole Pres
Noes Gor A)
Invrctinrl dour teen engaemen,
ttre scenes Research n ch
Teaching of gah 25 2129
pny Ms Gaon Ay C9080,
‘9 (20) he esa of aso
Intros: Thc of wig igh
‘Shoelaces a
‘yl Maso, 8 Landa
‘ting esac el pp. 57.
Doric the Neer Ker
‘end Pushers
iamiso Gans As kM.
(Gon nan) Csog mal cups
‘pone and hing out erate.
‘Engi oral 2,162.
Neen Cue WI
(0985 fa Whee a omposon ses
ome to? An ine ito rin
Sito Won Git,
Sv Lino 008 res ge.
‘sn tin ean te
‘Secure und doar ning
‘astm dca. Dione Pras 35
{pee (egy pele ar CA
epost on
asc Bu A (1988) Rio
alten cmpresmsion eng and
‘Soncoring sien Copia
Teen 8.
Pron. Fon. (170,
“iadingeatngompoenson New ode
‘An,
ne (196 Reach negation:
What doe toes ou cn sgoae
nating condone pss nd
on Langage Learn, 49 5.
rea TDs C YONG (986
ing inp concen Dor
feos sone 7 Reef
‘Appel Lng 2.128,
Pea TeDover Cf Yo R187)
‘heinjutl ncsctionon come
ten ESO! Quay. 21797756
Pras MDs Mann
Seo Re rn 192) Good sategy
ccctn ing ad imei
hoe ep lh hele
Inersin ining ond eb 3%
58) Hid ME
Pes, Src S MDa
Sam BL Tn 1 (158).
‘borne itarogon aes
gusto cig tors of
‘uo Py 9826-78.
Bara, EMMA. (998 Bk
fit anaes
noun, eg ase 4 0
ne
cr. as (9, he
for Knol on gd and poor ee
Fey ft jr Esa“410° sasearen nth Teaching anak
Renatos Ras MA, Sao Mt
5, Sun Lt, asso C8).
‘Coral cheats sn rang compre
‘on Reading earch Quai. 2358.
Renata, A A000 F.C (2002).
Ife of con nl gt ration
sehen asf argent
‘rekon Urbans Cer rhe ty
oF ang, Univers of.
Row (988. Mod of cussion I. 7
ila), Quetionng and cine
hipaa ip 16191).
‘Noro, NF Aber
Rous 1991. Students era res
‘hein cmperences band
proces a i rae ns raf
eaing Behav, 28 39104
owner (1974. On mesg sac
Afro oe say fuged
‘mma ondon Wey
oct, Mes C195),
ecproal ching Avo af ete
‘periment ss Revie of duction
mach 6409-530
Sas H, Sain £ A een 6
(0970.4 inp spear he
pinaon ature aig convertion
Lang 5,696-795,
S001 Ca Bg yo MEK M,
(195. Aconpsrian oft dion
‘oes once compe sd
interpreta of cmp etre Rein
Poly. 20 177-2
Sus 5. (18D Schotngin Acs
‘Speed sation Now oot
Sunes Ws Gaza (989), The
‘ets of inractio somevaton nd
‘erarlogron the tory sompenen
snd thers understating of Engl
Profient and ime git oink
Raden Emery Schl onal, 9, 277
Ses (1959). Coe goa
ng Bally A Schaye A,
Volume 40 May 2006
‘diner (Es). (W asin, Tes) New
ork: Pisopic Bray (Orginal work
pubis 919)
Scat (1984). On sae etre
‘elation to spe In) Ato
Penge (5), Sines of oa aon
‘Stale comers ana Ca
Pei, Us Cambridge Lest Pre
Scoutes, W. Koss, 8 Wana
(096) Domispstcinowlog nd
rnemony petra Acompion oF
Ng endow pte ire Joel ef
lotonl Pola 1, 3631,
Sone Ke PIR K (199), Tig aot
tools Poremoxth, NE Heinemann
Sus R-205, Janse)
Whee the cone The msn
turn ined, Edna
Beware 982025
‘ou, (199) aii a soit
cate rey development Now
‘resin or dad deopnent 3124
Sow 2002), Ralingfr nde
ing Tart areata detpment
eg nig mgr Se
Sonn A A Ty (198) Labor
at statues job obi Rach
nS Sri and ly 1,679,
Son, A sine L205 Ap, Wat
these tla lod cto
Inpho smpreieien Spire
Pete then meeting he
Ameri Easton! Resa Asotin,
Mosel Cais
Sun Me Nooo Le (997TH
‘stom vo weing communes ban
tnd suburban teh aes arnigo
Ree eg fg
‘Sus 4, RErsem 2,(980) Fomal
mean ofa may a Rep No
$b) nn Centr forthe tayo
aig Utero oi
Savas R191) The uation ra mea
‘ffenyin nara Arla of.
Nosimo ‘aston cers no ania Doasbesion a
uso practice (Contrbatost
“action Na 8).New York eases
Colege ne
Scan, W091), Clasrom alk,
owldge deepest and wig.
sah Tg nh 28, 7-
8.
Tea, W. S288 (980) Emer
Tie iting a rang Nowa
aie
“Tn RGus (988. owing
Ind ie Tein ring nd
‘hosing ese em. Yok
Cambie Use Fr
“ayn V9). The pang he
‘eatin Moe. Heath
“Ts (1585). Wier ear rani
‘fons: Defining he dnensins of eps
Sons Stock (fame Essen
ery ond rs te igo ig
{pp 14-150. Oper Montel NI
Beynon
Peper BLAZ00 190) Te is
‘dopo a ender a WHA
‘haculagremen Lane 97,
Tenn, & 9048 (98) Rese
nie ending iin reaonshir.
ection eanucings abd outomes
tn (2), Hanae of reading ea
{2p 246280. nga
“Tas, jy Henn (88D)
Sere model nae ovarian of
Fn sc child oma inet.
Peomgpy 20 128
“Toa (197), Rost rapes ane
‘of aby A romans otinsi=
Sesncate el Amico Solo
‘ove S338
avo aX (200), Doe epi
tina meting promoter compte
Fenn Ady fing inary
‘hod lise ending esearch Qasr,
Innsa
Visto (1979) Moon and te
pop lmgage Mia LR,
“Tins Ne York: Seni
(ginal work ple 193)
aor (1960 heh and ngage
In oi 6a Tra).
‘Cag MQ DIT Pr (Orn wore
pale 1986)
Yyoos LS1978) Mind inci The
Uap per belgie ree
Inv Cale joes 8. Serb
‘Shubsn (Ee Tae) Cami, A
Harvard Users Pes.
Waa 1-090). eave imperane of
ona hewiege ad opera apa
‘Shustion of domain ttinforation.
‘tgniton na nrc 425
Was6, (99) about ex: Where
Tey ernedand a Crim
gy 20 90,
‘ws (1983 Reraating t E
Sens. Apropal fort aici of
hoonml acta deouse forte
alo aching ed ming the
‘Sesoom. ingests and Bato, 38
‘Wis (1999, Digna
Sie pcr an hey fen.
Conti UX: Cambsdge Unesty
ee (198) Minds ation New
“ils Obed ater Pres
‘Were 62002) Steen oe the
‘Ste Canin eth, actin.
Torand Resent Raed Deeb
Dove om the US Departmen of i
tn We te ber gant
‘poh 06625202
Wis Mo Ke Sor A.
(Gorn, Govp danas ara mechan
[romaing ie comprehension ofc
Rina poral US Deparment of
‘fue tate of Eben Sens
‘nso, Mar Som A285
‘Api ating so of sp aliens
‘Bie promote yh loncmpreson
(Fre Snore psete the 8
‘eng othe mean Eto)
eth Aeiton Mona Cal12 ‘soaen nose ote atoms 40 May 2006
Wns L Raw (205 Api). WL. (996) Bes of ay ina
That speci lo 4 copa ice, and nar tayo ek of
Jronverordicusos Sporn prema i Aen Sac!
round sethesmoal mening the Rew a 386-408
mera Earonl Reva Section, Wut hams (198) aly
Monreal Caan ‘rasan thr of prea bie
Waensow ER AeSto05 C.D), Ame Scola Ree 5 210-32,
Custoom gage aed ey ease Yop, Wau, Cras Le
MRan Ds Pason Ra (EI0 Yr (1980) The nacre of
Hendokf eng roeack LIU? ema Kooi nee me
$57 60). Maweh NE, Soni amas ma Gene ee
Wotonm iy Waco T, Won Ede Bower (ie) The pel of ning and
Psa, (3980) abate neg’ moron Vl 35 p.17598). New rk
Seniesa lesingotnveal Alem Pres,
ragga of Eco Pye
eon 53 528
Cal for Submissions: James Berlin Outstanding Dissertation
Award
‘he CCEC amet Ben Merioril Outta dig Dissertation Awd Commits cls
for submissions fo» 20052006 daca diration award in compostion sie,
“Thsawardngien anna wa gradot whos deraton improve the eduction
proces in compoon stds rads othe f= body of kcndedg tiraugh
exch orecolal ingir Applicant mast sbi CCC teflon ens (1)
{ie page, (2) arc, (3) sums f the dsersion nainum log 10 pages
‘muna mas bo acu for), and (4) 90 anlound copy ofthe dserton-
‘obec for th svar, the dseration mst have ben cepted bythe degree
antag aston, at the wri of he dsteration mathe rc he gree
Berna September 1205 and ug 3, 206 Submissions must be ecived by Sp
tember 1, 2008, Sen 6 opie ofthe teri fe copy of he il disertation ts
(CCCC fame Bein Memoria Outstanding Diversion Avard Committ, NCTE,
LW. kenjoo Reed, Ub 1 61802-1086