Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Amherst Charter Chatter 2005
Amherst Charter Chatter 2005
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Bev,
Stan entered just as I opened your email. Yeah, if it is going to snow we
should hold off until next weekend. I figure anyone who gave us $ will allow a
sign (but we can call first to confirm). I will hit up some of my neighbors as
well (Dick and Edna Johnson front yard touches Rt. 1 1 6).
Yes, Churchill did a good job and he's scheduled to debate my School
Committee opponent Elisa Brewer some time in early March. Not having the
School Committee vote against the Charter--like they did two years ago--is
pretty major.
The Gazette did an editorial two years ago supporting the Charter didn't
they? I will of course remind them of that and even if they didn't it's time
they did.
Yes, I agree there's a lot more "chatter"" this time around. But back then I
was on crutches and painkillers, so some of it is a blur. Jim and I work well
together. He can be Mayor and I will be a Councilor.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Bev,
It's actually good the Charterista's are putting them up early. But the
storm tomorrow night could do some damage. But at least people will see
them and realize how effective lawn signs are--and it will be easier for us to
find 1 00 locations (especially since ours look BETIER). I think we should do
it next Sunday after dark.
I have not forgotten Cynthia at the Spfld Republican paper for Stan's
column. I am shooting for a Wednesday deadline. We should just simply
submit it to her then. I'm certain she will publish it, but if not we could
always submit it to Nick at the Bulletin.
I am sending the Charterista's $25 and signing Donna's name to the okay-topublish-in -an-ad box. I figure we may as well show co-operation.
Larry (getting more reasonable in his old age)
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
LK
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
cc:
Hey Jim,
Yeah, and I wonder when Town Meetings' allowed women the right to vote.
Interesting that the town is promoting this "public lecture" by Frank Bryan
(on town web cite) and giving free use of the Middle School when he will most
certainly give a one-sided pep talk on the merits of Town Meeting. Sure the
Town Meeting Coordinating Committee is a legitimate committee among the
multitudes in Amherst, but they surely were not elected by the voters like
our Charter Commission.
But he is going to have to explain why in Vermont, a bastion of Town
Meeting, they could only generate interest of 20% of the voters to attend.
Interestingly enough, that pathetic turnout mirrors exactly the voter
turnout for the past 1 2 years in Amherst for local elections. And I believe
he also says the larger the population of a town the less effective is town
meeting form of government. (I have his book on order at Lord Jeff
Bookshop, so that will be my homework assignment this weekend, not to
mention reading the FY06 School Budget. Yikes!)
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
LK
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Paul,
We are officially out of ours ( 1 00 now deployed plus or minus a few stolen) .
Next time you are driving by the Club could you drop off a half-dozen or so
of yours and Stan and I will start distributing them?
Thanks,
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Friends,
In case you missed it, I am copying below my letter from this week's
Amherst Bulletin, in support of Alisa Brewer's candidacy for re-election to
the School Committee.
I have known and worked with Alisa for several years, in a variety of
contexts. Her commitment to seeing things done properly and fairly; her
ability to think through complex issues and help others understand them; her
effectiveness in getting people of different points of view to work together
productively are truly remarkable. I think she would be outstanding in any
public office in our town. We are fortunate to have her be willing to continue
to serve on the School Committee, an exceedingly demanding job, which she
has been performing with her customary dedication of all her energy and
intelligence. Please join me in supporting her in her campaign for re-election.
Here's my letter:
Dear Editor:
Recent press reports on the three candidates for the one vacancy on the
School Committee seem to highlight each candidate's position on the
proposed charter as a relevant campaign issue. I don't think it should be.
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Re: charter
Friday, March 11, 2005 3:30:21 PM
Amherst AC
teresi@crocker.com
Hey Dick,
I actually saved the question for Ms. Brewer and then sprung it on her on
Wednesday night on Isaac Ben Ezra's live ACTV show, questioning her Monday
night admission that the School Committee "always asks for more than we
think we can afford." Which, of course, makes me wonder if the 7.9% School
Budget is an 'opening bid' so to speak? She actually handled it fairly well.
I also had a print out of Gatti's webcite where he says the Mayor would have
line item veto power over the School Budget which is blatantly false, but I
never got the chance to call him on it as Ben Ezra never got us around to
talking about the Charter.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
School Committee/Charter
Friday, March 1 1, 2005 6:13:59 PM
Amherst AC
SnBDurn
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
No, but about 6 years ago I was in a fairly bad bike/car accident (I was on
the bike). I think our Fire Department (although the accident was in Hadley
the Amherst FD responded) put the word out fairly quickly. Then, when I got
home from the hospital, about 4 hours after the incident. a phone message
was on my machine from Eva wishing me well.
A softy (somewhere under that scary exterior).
LK
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Bev,
Keep it under your hat that I may withdraw as I can only be effective over
the next few weeks if people take my run seriously. And it's not that I don't
take it seriously--! just know that under the current conditions I can't win,
and could remotely cause Elisa to lose; and while she is a free-spender he is
far, far worse.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Lawn Signs
Saturday, March 1 2, ZOOS 6:1 7:1 0 AM
Amherst AC
mary .carey@worldnet.att.net
Hey Mary,
I forgot to mention ... you need to get out more! The pro-charter signs
outnumber the anti's by ten to one.
Stan and I have completed our deployment of 1 00 (only 2 taken or destroyed
by weather) of the pretty red/white/blue ones; and Charter Now has 250
new Yellow ones plus around 1 00 they salvaged and retrofitted from two
years ago.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Charter
Monday, March 1 4, 2005 6:03:1 0 AM
Amherst AC
Stan.Rosenberg@state.ma.us
Hey Stan,
In defense of mailing the Final Report of the Charter Committee Bryan
Harvey told the Select board back in late January that doing something
different now from what was done two years ago raises a red flag.
Two years ago your name appeared among the many hundreds in the
signature ad for the Charter. If it doesn't appear this time around, many
people will take note.
Things are looking a lot better now than they did two years ago at this time.
We are going to win.
Larry
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Re: Charter
Monday, March 14, 2005 7:32:50 AM
Amherst AC
Stan.Rosenberg@state.ma.us
Hey Stan,
This coming Monday.
Larry
To:
SnBDurn
--- -- --!!
==--:::::
FULL-TIME MAYOR
Professional\ Accountable Council
Maintains School Committee
Maintains Citizen Input
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Mary,
So Barbara Francis has a sign on her lawn promoting the Charter (page 3)
but closes the 'Voters reflect ... ' article (page 9) with an anti-charter quote:
" ... We need more representation--not less."
Maybe somebody snuck a pro-charter sign on her lawn under cover of
darkness.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
LK
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
>>
Hey Bev,
Yeah, but now I'm a tad more displeased I was uninvited to it. Jim P. didn't
know and expected me there.
Speaking of bad behavior could you send the following to all the
Charterista's:
Anne Awad called Kevin Joy yesterday and left a message strongly
suggesting he remove pro-charter signs ( 1 red/white/blue and 1 Yellow)
from the Boys/Girls Club property on Main Street because as a nonprofit
they should not be involved in politics. But the Town Clerk was quick to
confirm that under the 1 'st Amendment a private, nonprofit entity can
display anything it wants (as long as it doesn't receive town tax money-which the Club does not) . Moral of the story: THEY are getting desperate.
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Bev,
Well, I knew Stan R would sign but Olver is a pleasant surprise. Remember he
wouldn't even sign the petition 5 years ago.
LK
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Charter Chatter
Friday, March 18, 2005 9:51 :04 AM
Amherst AC
csimison@repub.com
Hey Cynthia,
Welcome back. The following is, for the moment, Off The Record:
Subj:
Two more signatures ...
Date: Friday, March 18, 2005 7:1 0:1 8 AM
From: harvey@provost.umass.edu
group@thechangeweneed.org
To:
From: harvey@provost.umass.edu (Bryan Harvey)
To:
group@thechangeweneed.org
I am very pleased to announce that two more signatures have just come our
way:
Stanley C. Rosenberg
John W. Olver
I haven't got the written confirmation from John yet, so don't go talking
about this. And they don't want any special prominence. But ...
HOORAY!
BCH
So I'm not surprised about Stan Rosenberg as I started pestering him last week, mainly by
reminding him that he did sign two years ago and if his name was absent this time around it would
raise a red flag. And although I seldom agree with his politics I have always found him to be a
stand up guy.
John Olver, however, (pleasantly) surprises me. Four years ago he refused to sign Stan D.'s
petition to bring about the Charter.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Bev,
Okay, I stayed out of the (expensive) Full page ad in the current Bulletin but I
did think the headline was pretty longwinded and dumb ("what will it take to
keep Amherst the place we want it to be .. ", or whatever they hell the
headline was: by the way headlines are supposed to be short and succinct)
So let me have some input on this one:
If I were in charge, my headline would be: "Change For The Better!" (the old
accent the positive) and then they could prattle on about '"'Courage to
change". My God, Dan Rather just (forced) retired from CBS and almost
everybody mentioned his use of the word "courage" at the end of the
broadcast (that only lasted a few days) a few years back. YIKES!
LK
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Bev,
"Together, we can have a new beginning". Wordy, wordy, wordy! For crying
out loud how about "Together. .. a new beginning"
LK (the red headed bastard stepchild)
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
< < I agree with that. I'm going to tell him that I really don't like the word "risk". > >
And tell him in a very forthright manner! (he is out of his head if he uses
that headline)
Lk
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
In a message dated 3/20/05 4:51 :54 PM, SnBDurn writes: (Note to Mary:
My computer clock is off by 4 hours so this is taking place around 8:05 pm)
<<This is what I just sent. Let's see ifl get any reaction to this.
Thanks, Larry.
Bev >>
>>
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Bev,
Well it looks like the radio ad suggestion was a hit (as long as they hurry up).
Now try this:
http://www.abicomp.com/order _giant_balloons.php
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Today
Tuesday, March 22, ZOOS 5:54:29 PM
Amherst AC
SnBDurn
Hey Bev,
Sorry if I sounded a tad frazzled when you called but Kirik was gone and Kira
was acting up and I just got an email that somebody hacked my Ebay account
(and my user name password for Paypal is identical. .. so with that they could
drain what little there is in AAC business checking account). So I was trying
frantically to change my Ebay /Pay pal password and teach karate and answer
the phone and .....
The Forum was not well attended (I think the anti's purposely boycotted) but
the two who did show seemed genuine and provided very interesting info.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Re: Today: PS
Wednesday, March 23, 2005 6:1 2:41 AM
Amherst AC
SnBDurn
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Cynthia,
Tonight is the last of the public forums on the Charter and how it will impact the schools in
Amherst (Amherst Regional High School @ 7:00). In my closing statement, after defending the
Charter for an hour and a half, I will withdraw my candidacy for School Committee and endorse
(ugh) Elisa Brewer, the incumbent.
While she' s a tad nai"ve, there's hope for her. The other guy (Gatti) is hopeless. And I would hate
to see her lose by a handful of votes.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Jim,
As I said to Stan Rosenberg last week, when you fail to do something now
that you did do two years ago it raises a red flag. Notice in today's Bulletin
Stan's name appears in the ad supporting the Charter, just as it did two
years ago.
Amherst now has 2,000 new voters who were not here to read the proCharter Gazette editorial two years ago, so they will not notice. But the
other 14,000 voters will probably take note.
On another note:
Tonight is the last of the public forums on the Charter and how it will impact
the schools in Amherst (Amherst Regional High School @ 7:00). In my
closing statement, after defending the Charter for an hour and a half, I will
withdraw my candidacy for School Committee and endorse (ugh) Elisa
Brewer, the incumbent.
While she's a tad nalve, there's hope for her. The other guy (Gatti) is
hopeless. And I would hate to see her lose by a handful of votes.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Mary,
Thanks. Yeah, if I were trying to lose votes I probably could not have done a
better job.
It was a good forum, but with one very large omission: The Charter Question.
It reminded me of that joke about the 500 pound Gorilla sitting in your living
room that everybody is trying to ignore.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
cc:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Only about a dozen folks showed: about half of them parents, no teachers and a few plants most
notably Alan Powell, Terry Forrest and of course Ms. Greeney. The moderator (Lisa Kent) was
also biased giving the other side (Frank Gatti, Mary Streeter) preferential treatment with time and
order of response. She even pointed out the $122,000 cost of Mayor/Council was "two-and-a-half
teachers"
Ms. Streeter seemed grumpy. She used the tired/insulting "women in government" argument.
When I had the opportunity I pointed out that the actual demographic of Amherst is 52% female
48% male so the 53% male 47% female TM make up isn't perfect either; and I threw in the
number of prominent women who chair important committees.
Powell, also looking perturbed, tried to suggest the Charter Committee--because only 14 ran for 9
positions (meaning Mr. Pitts had a 65% chance of election)--was somehow not as representative as
TM with 240 representatives. I of course pointed out the 268 folks running for 240 TM seats
(89.5% chance of election) with 238 on the ballot (89%) with just their signature is nothing to brag
about.
Lots of distortions, that Jim rightfully called "lies". The Mayor having line-item veto (we both
corrected but I'm not sure they believed us), the Mayor could--God forbid--sit in on an executive
session and would not be a member of the Regional School Committee (this one I'm not clear on
so we let it slide but I think that's incorrect. Isn't every member of the Amherst School Committee
automatically a member of the Region -even if nonvoting?)
Ms Streeter started the forum with the disclaimer that the League or Bulletin messed up her
attendance record and that it was not 25/43. She, in fact, has a perfect record (So I would be
careful using any of those attendance figures sited in the League insert).
Terry Forest followed up on Gatti's assertion that a Referendum overturn of the Council was
impossible (getting 18% of voters with those darn students inflating the number) and he used a
figure of 5,000. I pointed out it was 2,565
All in all, I would guess that almost everyone who showed up had already made up his or her
minds--so we didn't add or subtract any support. But, as usual, we showed more passion. I also
took the opportunity in my closing remarks to announce that I was withdrawing from the School
Committee race and endorsing Elisa Brewer.
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
cc:
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Elisa,
Very nice response in what we former journalists call "hot copy." Of course,
I had to deal with Holly on the phone this morning after just downing a large
cup of coffee--so God knows how that will read in tomorrow's paper.
The reaction from Gatti was kind of interesting. I looked over at him (we
were all sitting at a head table like you and Andy at the first forum) and said
in a joking manner "Nothing personal Mr. Gatti." And he actually sounded
depressed when he replied "How can I not take it personally?" Oh
weii. .. Psychologist! (I hope he can heal thyself.)
<< I look forward to his increasing involvement in our schools. >>
And yes, that you can bet on!
Now go kick some butt (and reing in the Regional Assessment!)
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
<< t prevents the Awad crew from being further entrenched in the school
system through Gatti and also helps to swing some of Elisa's voters to the
Charter >>
Hey Paul,
I only considered the former but not the latter. Good point. Now I feel even
better. Thanks!
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
They were clearly caught off guard by your announcement. I wanted to say to them that what
they should care about is who sits on the school committee if you really care about the schools, not
waist their time on the Charter's impact on school policy. But that would have lessened the impact of
your announcement. >>
Hey Jim,
Good call. Absolutely correct. Eva has been saying that for over a month
(maybe now she will go back to liking me).
Thanks for being there. When no reporters showed and hardly any
participants--with the ones that did looking fairly hostile, I honestly thought
about not making the announcement (and simply sending out a press release
today or something else far, far less effective). But I knew I had your
receptive ear there at my side, covering my flank. WE ARE GOING TO WIN
THIS!
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Cynthia,
I know the Republican doesn't have as large a circulation in Amherst as the
Gazette and we do provide you with reams of story material (which would go
down under mayorI council leadership) and you did ignore it two years
ago ... BUT if the editorial folks are having a slow week and they need
something to write about for Monday or Tuesday's edition .....
Larry
1/5/04
Page 1
Hi everyone,
Reminder to Amherst voters: the election is March
29th, Tuesday.
This is a very important election for Amherst and for
our dual language effort. We have strong support for
the dual language Chinese/English program from the
following candidates:
School Committee: Dr. Frank Gatti
Select Board: Ms. Hwei-Ling Greeney
Select Board: Prof. Rob Kusner
Library Trustees: Mr. Chris Hoffmann
Library Trustees: Ms. Pat Holland
Note: if two candidates are listed above it's because
there are two open seats.
Please vote "No" on Question #1 to defeat the proposed
Charter and keep Amherst's Town Meeting. Town Meeting
will vote on our dual language proposal in late April
or early May. It is very important to keep Amherst's
Town Meeting because they can help us get the program
we want.
If you have questions or concerns, let me know.
1/26/04
Page 2
Thank
Kathy You Have a great weekend.
P.S.
If any one wants t h
l"t
I erature or put up Ia o ~lp distribute cand"d
you.
wn s1gns, let me know.I Thank
ate
1/26/04
Page 3
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
LK
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Rich,
Yeah, it came my way via the Charter Now email chain. I notice he spelled
"Republican" wrong. Gee, he and Andy sound a tad at odds. Next School
Committee meeting is going to be interesting (especially since Flittie will be
unhappy that Elisa is reelected).
LK
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Today
Tuesday, March 29, ZOOS 3:46:43 AM
Amherst AC
group@thechangeweneed.org
We stand on a mountain pass in the midst of whirling snow and blinding mist,
though which we get glimpses now and then of paths which may be deceptive. If
we stand still we shall be frozen to death. If we take the wrong road was shall be
dashed to pieces. We do not certainly know whether there is any right one. What
must we do? 'Be strong and of good courage. Act for the best, hope for the best
and take what comes .. .If death ends all, we cannot meet death any better.'
Then again, there's always Robert Frost's "The Road Not Taken."
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Re: Today
Wednesday, March 30, 2005 4:54:25 AM
Amherst AC
mary.carey@worldnet.att.net
LK
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Re: Thanks
Wednesday, March 30, 2005 9:00:1 1 AM
Amherst AC
avbrewer@comcast.net
Hey Alisa,
Your most welcome. Doing politics in Amherst over the past 23 years I have
developed a rather thick skin, but yeah, "dashed" would perhaps define it.
See ya at some meeting or other (not Town Meeting however)
Larry
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
<<
I'm sorry I wasn't there last night. I had child care at my advanced age.
We fought the good fight old buddy. I can't promise that I can get the town to erect a statue of you
on the Common with signature papers in hand, but I see you in my mind's eye every time I go
downtown.
Love, Jim
>>
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Rich,
Yeah, after 23 years of political involvement in the Peoples Republic I get
use to heartache (but I am getting a bit old for such a bitter, bitter batch) .
I too was far more concerned for Stan (and Bev) But I saw him today and
he's holding up. Messages such as this have helped:
I'm sorry I wasn't there last night. I had child care at my advanced age.
We fought the good fight old buddy. I can't promise that I can get the town to erect a statue of you
on the Common with signature papers in hand, but I see you in my mind's eye every time I go
downtown .
Love , Jim
>>
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
LK
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Rich,
Yeah, that is still the final trump card or "gun to their head". They can only
spend so much money on their own and if they can't get this budget down
$1 .2 million they need an Override and as such the people can say "NO". (and
even back when the sensible center ruled over the past dozen years the
folks said 'No' to about half of all the Overrides)
I fear you are correct about the Students. One of my long-time, older,
retired club members who comes in here like clockwork at 6:00 am is a
warden at Precinct 8 and just reported to me that in the middle of the day
all of a sudden a heard of Hampshire College students all came in together.
And with the Umass Daily Collegian doing an editorial that morning saying go
out and vote down the Charter because it will be bad for the University I'm
pretty convinced that students easily accounted for 300 votes. The Valley
Advocate also came out against the Charter at the last moment (and we
found copies stuck under car windshield wipers all over town center that
morning)
http:/ /www.dailycollegian.com/vnews/display.v/ ART /2005/03/29/ 4248b5f
aeea04
<< Gazette feel some obligation to quote Dave Keenan in every election? >>
Yes, Dave is nothing if not colorful and the media kinda likes that. But even
he on the current Select board would be far, far better than the two who
just got in.
I honestly believe now with all five Select board members one happy Gang and
1/26/04
Page 1
LK
1/26/04
Page 2
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Bev,
The Town Clerk said they would have individual precinct results available by
middle of next week, so I will be able to figure out how many Hampshire
College students "invaded" Precinct 8. But the problem is, it will be almost
impossible to figure out how many Umass students voted off campus (where
most of them are registered). But since the few who voted on-campus all
voted against the Charter it gives you an idea of how the ones who voted off
campus probably voted.
I will have a Final Stan Statement ready by Monday morning 8:00 am. Not
sure if I'm quite ready to deal with it just now.
Larry
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
defeat
Sunday, April 3, 2005 3:26:22 PM
Amherst AC
Amherst AC
AUTHOR:
Frank Leslie 's Illustrated Newspaper, November 22, 1862, p. 131, attributed this reply to
President Lincoln, when asked how he felt about the result of the New York election [where the
Democratic candidate won the governorship]: "Somewhat like that boy in Kentucky, who
stubbed his toe while running to see his sweetheart. The boy said he was too big to cry, and far
too badly hurt to laugh."
Adlai Stevenson told this story in his nationally-televised concession speech after the 1952
presidential election: "Someone asked me, as I came in, down on the street, how I felt, and I was
reminded of a story that a fellow-townsman of ours used to tell-Abraham Lincoln. They asked
him how he felt once after an unsuccessful election. He said that he was too old to cry, but it
hurt too much to laugh."-The Papers ofAdlai E. Stevenson, ed. Walter Johnson, vol. 4, p. 188
(1974). The speech was delivered at the Leland Hotel, Springfield, Illinois, in the early hours of
November 5, 1952.
SUBJECTS:
Defeat
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
The boxer
Sunday, April 3, 2005 3:45:42 PM
Amherst AC
Amherst AC
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Letter to Bulletin
Monday, April 4, 2005 3:34:35 AM
Amherst AC
SnBDurn
Amherst Bulletin
Letter to the editor
When asked how he felt about an unsuccessful election Lincoln
replied "...he was too big to cry, and far too badly hurt to laugh . "
I have not lost nearly as many Mr. Lincoln, but I can truly
relate.
Five years ago when I started collecting thousands of signatures
my idea for government reform was simple, some would say naive :
let the people decide. And they have. While I'm not thrilled
with the less than majority turnout, or the last second editorial
in the Daily Collegian that could have aroused student voters, I
will avoid the blame game.
Two years ago I thought the pro-Charter folks (myself included)
could have waged a more spirited campaign. Now I have no such
feelings. We worked harder this time around, much harder. And I
can't thank everyone enough.
Unfortunately our do-or-die Charter campaign fell short, leaving
intact a system of government now almost entirely comprised of
individuals who only put forth an anti-charter platform. And 48 %
of Amherst voters voiced no confidence in the current system.
So get to work Select board and Town Meeting.
watching.
A lot of us are
Stanley Durnakowski
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Folks,
Two years ago, on crutches from hip-replacement surgery and still getting
used to my daughter (who arrived Christmas Day) I felt detached from the
battle. So it was easy for me to rationalize that not enough energy went
into the campaign--and if only everybody (myself included) had worked a tiny
bit harder ...
But now I have no such regrets. I think EVERYBODY worked their butts off,
stayed on the high ground (although TM lovers probably thought my little
factoid ads were negative attack ads) and still we lost.
I was warned a few months back about the "Sleeping Giant", student vote.
But when the Select board did not place an advisory on the Ballot that would
interest students (Pot Legalization, Anti-War, Free Love, etc) I figured the
students would be a non-issue.
The Collegian and Valley Advocate editorials (we found copies stuck under
car windshield wipers in town center that morning) hurt us. And vanloads of
Hampshire College kids invading Precinct 8 didn't help either.
So now, because we waged an all-or-nothing campaign, Amherst has 240 TM
members and 5 Select board members who are almost entirely 'birds of a
feather'.
I agree with Jim and Bryan, we need to stay organized, be vigilant and let the
damn building burn.
Larry
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
cc:
<< I believe that the twenty or so of us who are Town Meeting members who
supported the charter should hang in there and at least vote our
consciences.
Paul D.>>
Remember 'Thermopylae', 'Wake Island', and 'Pickett's Charge'.
And may God have mercy on us all.
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Re: election
Wednesday, April 6, ZOOS 5:44:23 AM
Amherst AC
teresi@crocker.com
Hey Dick,
The turnout was actually okay for a local election. In the past 1 2 years they
only averaged 20%, while Presidential averaged 70% Uust this past
November it was 65%). The turnout is also a tiny bit skewed from two years
ago as there are now more registered voters in town (because of the
Presidential a lot more students register in Amherst so they can vote here
rather than their hometown). But yeah, I had actually predicted 38.5%. But
I also predicted a win for the Charter by 3 50 votes so what the hell do I
know.
No, that criticism (coming from Dave Keenan) about Charter folks not being
organized is totally dead wrong. I think two years ago the efforts were a
tad lackluster--but not this time.
Yes, Dave Keenan and Kevin Joy talked John Burruto into running for Mayor if
the Charter passed and even wanted to call a press conference on the steps
of Town Hall to announce it a few days BEFORE the vote. A few people
thought (myself included) that it would be perceived as arrogance for the
Charter and could result in a backlash. Plus, John does have a slight
negative because he's an ex-cop, ex-Marine disciplinarian (in a town full of
tree hugging, Kumbia types).
Yeah, I definitely dodged a bullet with School Committee (I notice on the town
web cite they are all on a "retreat" today ... YIKES!). Problem with me is if
elected I would do the job to the best of my abilities and that would have
consumed way, way too many hours.
Hidden agenda? Again I point out that Northampton has had no corruption
scandal in their town hall at least in the last 50 years. And I'm more certain
now than ever that Bryan Harvey would not have run for mayor (and even if
he did he is certainly not the kind of guy who would be in the pockets of
developers and real estate agents ... Umass maybe).
1/26/04
Page 1
I sent this out to the Charter Now group under the subject line: 'Post
Mortem Analysis'
Hey Folks,
Two years ago, on crutches from hip-replacement surgery and still getting used to my daughter
(who arrived Christmas Day) I felt detached from the battle. So it was easy for me to rationalize
that not enough energy went into the campaign--and if only everybody (myself included) had
worked a tiny bit harder. ..
But now I have no such regrets. I think EVERYBODY worked their butts off, stayed on the high
ground (although TM lovers probably thought my little factoid ads were negative attack ads) and
still we lost.
I was warned a few months back about the "Sleeping Giant", student vote. But when the Select
board did not place an advisory on the Ballot that would interest students (Pot Legalization, Anti War, Free Love, etc) I figured the students would be a non-issue.
The Collegian and Valley Advocate editorials (we found copies stuck under car windshield wipers
in town center that morning) hurt us. And vanloads of Hampshire College kids invading Precinct 8
didn 't help either.
So now, because we waged an ali-or-nothing campaign, Amherst has 240 TM members and 5
Select board members who are almost entirely 'birds of a feather'.
I agree with Jim and Bryan, we need to stay organized, be vigilant and let the damn building burn.
Larry
1/26/04
Page 2
Great assessment of what happened, clearly said, plus a good thank you to everyone involved
in the Charter campaign. Did you hear from Town Clerk on the voting by precinct yet? I
hadn't heard about the newspapers under the windshield wipers either on Monday.
Just in case we haven't said it before, your help was invaluable to everyone who put their all
into changing our government, especially Stan and me. Kudo's to you Lany. One thing we
know for sure we aren't going away and this topic will continue to motivate us and return again.
Stan and VOR >>
1/26/04
Page 3
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Paul,
Sorry, didn't mean to sound overly pessimistic in that last email (well,
actually I did, but I just returned from a long bike ride on this warm spring
day and now feel a tad more optimistic)
Twenty or so folks voting their conscious can be a very powerful thing. Give
them hell!
Larry
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
<< I should have looked at the resignation letter closer (heck, it was only one
sentence). I simply noted the March heading and assumed it was the day
after the election (especially since this week's Bulletin posted the results of
the 3/29 election and had Root as one of the top vote getters in his
Precinct but the word "resigned" in parentheses). So, if dated March 20 ,
then that resigns him from Town Meeting as of THEN (technically, because
of redistricting everybody was up on March 29, which constitutes an entirely
NEW TM) but he was reelected (or since technically no longer an incumbent
TM member, I should say 'elected') again on March 29 ... so, technically, he
should have to write another Letter of Resignation dated sometime after
the election.
Should I even bother to point out the irony of getting on the Ballot with one
signature, winning, and then using that same one signature to resign?
Larry >>
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Dear Alan,
If you're dying of an incurable disease you have my deepest sympathy. Believe it
or not I will actually miss you (kind of).
If that is not the case however, your instant resignation from Town Meeting
Precinct 5 makes you the biggest hypocrite in Amherst, a town renowned for--and
defined by--its ubiquitous hypocrites.
Your friend,
Larry- "never stops"- Kelley
Cc: 'All The Usual Suspects' (and then some)
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
LK
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
LK
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Political realities
Monday, April 1 1, 2005 6:14:46 AM
Amherst AC
ar1 932@gmail.com
Hey Alan,
Sorry about your brother. I went through that 5 or 6 years ago with my
mother (although I didn't resign my TM seat, column or business ... but I was
younger then) and it is indeed very hard. Stan also went through it with his
older brother just when he was in the middle of the Charter resubmission
petition drive.
Yes, unfortunately you're correct that the "new political realities" will have
to be addressed by the Select board and Town Meeting and I'm certain we will
find them incapable as ever.
Thank you. Kira is as beautiful on the inside as she is on the outside. We
are now in the middle stages of paperwork for going back to China (in the
late Fall) to get her a sister.
Good luck with photography, poetry, painting and things of the nonpolitical
persuasion. And may God quell your brother's suffering.
Take care,
Larry
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
<< At the precinct 8 meeting at CF last night Mary Streeter told me that
Alan
Root's brother is dying of cancer.
Oh and she is extremely upset that her son is being dragged into some story
Nick Grabbe is doing on these TM quitters.
As a parent you can kind of understand her feelings.
Anyway, I hope this wasn't a "major faux pau" after all.
Taking the high road keeps your boots clean .
These rabid TM folks will eventually turn on themselves and destroy their
own efforts without much help.
That is just my view,
Clare >>
Hey Clare,
Nick called me yesterday because his editor wanted him to follow up the
story of Mr. Root quitting (this makes the second time Alan has done that-the first back during the peak of the Garage War in TM).
Nick mentioned that it looked as though Kusner's kid may also be jettisoning
his obligation to the voters. So I immediately called the Town Clerk to see
who else may have quit, and they said Theodore Streeter had come in the
day before ( 4/1 1 ) to resign.
So I certainly am not guilty of dragging him into anything. He's a Big Boy
(the majority of our casualties in Iraq are his age). And since he willingly
filed (although probably at mom's urging) a public document to run for TM
(with his mom spearheading the PR campaign to retain that antiquated
1/26/04
Page 1
institution) and then was elected he is--at least for the moment--a public
figure.
As for Alan, if I were an attorney cross examining him I would point out that
he freely admits "when it became apparent that all 240 seats would require
that many candidates, but preferably more -- I decided to run." And of
course the most damning evidence of all: "And political realities dictated
that success in the contest to retain Town Meeting depended on there being
enough Town Meeting members."
Quite frankly I think Alan and Theodore Streeter and Woden Kusner are the
ones who made the major faux pa.
Larry (keeping his sneakers clean)
Page 2
but
has resulted in severe loss of memory and he has a very restricted capacity
to communicate.
When I visited his bedside, on Wednesday -- he could recognize his daughter
but not me at all. He is extremely fearful of death and highly agitated. He
probably will be transferred downstairs in the hospital to a hospice where,
hopefully, he will pass away soon. He has received Extreme Unction.
If you are a praying person, please remember him in your prayers.
During the past several months, I have usually reached my bed between 2AM
and 2:30AM, 7 days a week. Despite my brother's illness and related family
problems, I have not relaxed my efforts on the political front at all.
I resigned from Town Meeting because I simply felt that I wanted to see
some
rotation. It's really just that simple. I will continue serving on the
Comprehensive Planning Committee as best I can and for as long as I can.
I honestly believe that there are a lot of new political realities for
Amherst that will have to be addressed within the framework of a Select
Board and Town Meeting. I also believe that it would be nice to have a
"cooling off" period but that simply is not going to happen. And when things
slow down just a little, I want to analyze more intensely some of the
complaints aimed at the present system so that I can perhaps suggest some
incremental adjustments to reduce the polarizations that are still very
real.
I have asked many people to provide me with their individual fantasies of
the Amherst that they would like to see in 5 years, 1 0 years, and beyond.
Surprisingly, those kind of questions don't draw out as many answers as
some
might imagine!
Maybe you can't let go of Amherst politics. But for myself, there are a
number of other Alan Roots that I need to tend. Alan Root, the
photographer.
Alan Root, the poet. Alan Root, the traveler. Alan Root, the painter. Alan
Root, the designer. For any of these capacities to bloom -- something has to
give on the political front. Neither of us are indispensible, you know!
1/26/04
Page 3
1/26/04
Page 4
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Hey Stan,
Yeah, and unfortunately it mars the reputation of all politicians (some
of whom are hardworking, honest, altruistic folks like yourself)
LK
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
cc:
. .
7
<< And your po1nt 1s ......... >>
Hey Gerry (figures you would have to ask)
Thomas Paine observed a long, long time ago: " The Summer soldier and the
sunshine patriot will, in this crisis, shrink from the service of his country."
Today we have the sports metaphor: "When the going gets tough the tough
get going".
In business-the real kind-it's called "barrier to entry". If you're in an
industry/service where a new competitor coming into your territory would
need to spends tons of money to set up shop-say a new Health Club for
instance-then that 's a good thing for the established business because
competition will not suddenly spring up on every street corner (although I
would argue this side of the Bridge is now overly saturated with Health
Clubs).
But if you're in a business-say landscaping, where any yahoo can go to WaiMart and buy a $1 00 lawnmower and $1 0 rake and call themselves a "lawn
specialist"--with no real training, no insurance, pay employees cash under
the table, etc--then that can be a problem. (Although Taylor Davis seems to
do well anyway).
If Town Meeting really were this vibrant thriving entity then there
would/should be actual competition for membership in the club. You know ...
that old business maxim: "When products compete they get better."
So with the 3/29 Annual Election Ballot providing absolutely no barrier to
entry for Town Meeting seats--and even then--the best you could muster
1/26/04
Page 1
was 268 candidates for 240 seats (with two instantly resigning and fellow
Selectman Kusner's kid, if he had any integrity, should also resign because
Pa. Is a pretty far commute).
The simple but startling figure 201 out of 226 elected on 3/29 got on the
official ballot with only one signature underscores the outrageous ease of
becoming a Town Meeting member.
Thus, we now have self-appointed, part-time, amateur hobbyist overseeing a
$60 million enterprise.
Larry
1/26/04
Page 2
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
cc:
1/26/04
Page 1
Subj:
Date:
From:
To:
Bulletin letter
Monday, April 18, 2005 3:51 :02 AM
Amherst AC
SnBDurn
Amherst Bulletin
Letter To The Editor
Select board member Gerry Weiss is correct "Numbers can be used in many ways
to make many meanings." Because of a comparatively low 35% turnout--with
about 18% supporting Town Meeting--he spins the assertion that "8 3 percent of the
voters opted for no change." However it's also correct to say 82 percent of the
voters did not support Town Meeting.
Just as it would be equally correct to say in last year's election, even though he
won handily, 85% of the voters did not vote for Mr. Weiss.
According to the Town Clerk's office: "Out of the 226 elected town meeting
members whose names were printed on the March 29,2005 Annual Town Election
ballot, 201 nomination papers contained one certified signature."
With only 268 citizens bothering to run for 240 Town Meeting seats (and two have
since resigned) roughly 90% were guaranteed victory; and of those actually elected
90% made the ballot with one signature. So what do those numbers mean?
That the main hurdle to joining Amherst "Representative" Town Meeting is but one
signature, your own. Not a very good way to weed out what Mr. Paine described
as "The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot."
Larry Kelley
1/26/04
Page 1