Case: 07-60756 Document: 00511097646 Page: 1 Date Filed: 04/30/2010

United States Court of Appeals

FIFTH C IR C U IT
O FFIC E O F TH E C LER K
LYLE W . C A YC E TEL. 504-310-7700
C LER K 600 S. M A ESTR I PLA C E
N EW O R LEA N S, LA 70130

April 30, 2010

TO ALL COUNSEL LISTED BELOW

No. 07-60756 - Comer vs. Murphy Oil USA

Dear Counsel:
The parties are hereby notified that since the en banc court

was constituted, new circumstances have arisen that make it

necessary for another judge to recuse, leaving only eight members

of the court able to participate in the case. Consequently, this

en banc court has lost its quorum, precluding the court from

acting on the merits of the case. Accordingly, arguments

scheduled for May 24, 2010, are canceled. Further notification

to the parties will follow.

Sincerely,
LYLE W. CAYCE, Clerk

By:_________________________
Valerie L. Bellanger, Deputy Clerk
504-310-7632

Mr. Carlos A. Zelaya, II

Mr. Rick Richmond
Ms. Kathleen T. Sooy
Mr. Peter D. Keisler
Mr. Timothy S. Bishop
Mr. Edwin W. Small
Ms. Tracie Jo Renfroe
Mr. Raymond B. Ludwiszewski
Mr. Edgar R. Haden
Mr. Douglas A. Henderson