Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Is It Ethical To Colonize Mars Kqed Education Kqed
Is It Ethical To Colonize Mars Kqed Education Kqed
Is It Ethical To Colonize Mars Kqed Education Kqed
ORG/EDUCATION/COLLECTIONS/DO-NOW/)
IsItEthicaltoColonizeMars?
ByCaliforniaAcademyofSciences(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/author/calacademy/)
DECEMBER9,2014
SHARE
TorespondtotheDoNow,youcancommentbelowortweetyourresponse.Besuretobeginyourtweetwith@KQEDEdspaceandendit
with#DoNowMars
FormoreinfoonhowtouseTwitter,clickhere(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/how-to-use-twitter-in-your-teaching-practice/).
DoNow
IsitethicaltocolonizeMarsorotherplanets?Whyorwhynot?
Introduction
IsgoingtoMarsareality?Inamissionwherethelinesbetweenrealityandfantasyseemtobeblurred,theMarsOne(http://www.marsone.com/)teamisplanningtolaunchanexpeditiontoestablishahumansettlementontheredplanet.In2024,fourindividualswill
leaveEarthonanone-waytriptoMars,withanewcrewoffourdepartingeverytwoyearsafterward.Fromanoriginalpoolof202,586
people(http://www.npr.org/blogs/13.7/2014/04/10/300601241/why-do-202-586-people-want-to-leave-our-planet),thefinalgroupswill
soonbeselectedforeightyearsofintensetraining.Thegoalofthismission(http://www.mars-one.com/mission)istoincreasehuman
knowledgeabouttheoriginsofthesolarsystem,humanlifeandtheuniverse.Thisisthefirsttimehumanswillsettleonanother
planet,sonomatterwhattheoutcomemaybe,thescienceworldwillchangeexponentially.However,therearemanyquestionsthat
ariseconcerningtheethicsofthismission.Shouldwereallybesendingpeopletoanotherplanet?Isitourplacetoleaveourplanetand
imposeourselvesonanentirelynewone?
TheMarsOneMissionisaone-waytriptoMars.Humanshaveneversteppedfootonanotherplanet,andMarsprovidesan
environmentthatallowsustomakeafirstattempt.Withsoilthatpeoplecouldtheoreticallyextractwaterfrom,adaylengthsimilarto
Earthandtemperaturesthatrangefromabout70to-225degreesFahrenheit,Marsisthemostsimilarplanet(http://www.marsone.com/faq/mission-to-mars/why-mars-and-not-another-planet)toEarthinourSolarSystem.Thismissionwill,ofcourse,becostly.
ThecostofbringingthefirstfourselectedpeopletoMarswillbeapproximately$6billionandeachsubsequentmissionisestimatedto
costaround$4billion.However,notjustanyonecanmakeittoMars;thephysical,mentalandemotionalrequirementslessenthepool
ofqualifiedcandidates.AMarsOnecandidatemustbe18yearsofageorolder,betweenfivefeettwoinchesandsixfeettwoinchestall,
freeofillnessesandhavetheemotionalcapabilitytocoexistwithothersinacompletelyalienenvironment.Asthisisthefirsttime
humanswilllandonthisplanet,therearemanyuncertainties.Forexample,explorerswillbeadvisednottohavechildrenbecause
thereisnocurrentknowledgeofhowhumanconceptionandhumanfetusdevelopmentwillfunctiononMars.However,theexplorers
willbesupportedbyagrariantechnologydesignedforMars,aswellasperiodicmissionsfromEarthtoaidtheexplorers.Ifallgoesas
planned,theMarsOneMissionmayresultinhumanshavinganotherplanettoliveonlong-term.
Therearebenefitsanddownsidestothisproject.SendingpeopletoMarswouldprovideanunprecedentedwaytostudytheplanet.
And,Earthisrapidlybecomingoverpopulated;thereisacarryingcapacitythatmaysoonbereached.Thismissioncouldpotentially
openupanentirelynewplanettocivilize.However,thosewhogowillnevercomeback,devotingtheirlifetoariskymissionthatcould
verywellfail,despitetheimmenseamountofmoneybeingdedicatedtotheproject.Therearealsoethicalconcernsformovingontoa
planetthatisnotourstobeginwith.
So,whatdoyouthink?WhatisthefutureofMarsexplorationandwillhumansbeabletoadapttothenewenvironment?Isitethicalto
colonizeMarsasawayofdealingwithEarthsoverpopulation?WhatkindofrelationshipwillwehavewithMars?
Resource
VIDEO:AOneWayTickettoMars:BehindtheMarsOneProject
(http://content.time.com/time/video/player/0,32068,2424118205001_2144787,00.html)(TIME)
BasLansdorp,CEOofMarsOne,introduces,describesandaddressesseveralconcernsofthishighly-anticipatedspaceventure.
TorespondtotheDoNow,youcancommentbelowortweetyourresponse.Besuretobeginyourtweetwith@KQEDedspaceandendit
with#DoNowMars
FormoreinfoonhowtouseTwitter,clickhere(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/how-to-use-twitter-in-your-teaching-practice/).
Weencouragestudentstoreplytootherpeoplestweetstofostermoreofaconversation.Also,ifstudentstweettheirpersonal
opinions,askthemtosupporttheirideaswithlinkstointeresting/crediblearticlesonline(addinganiceresearchcomponent)
orretweetotherpeoplesideasthattheyagree/disagree/findamusing.Wealsovaluestudent-producedmedialinkedtotheir
tweets.Youcanvisitourvideotutorials(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/category/tools/video-tutorials/)thatshowcasehowto
useseveralweb-basedproductiontools.Ofcourse,doasyoucanandanycontributionismostwelcomed.
MoreResources
VIDEO:MarsOneIntroductionFilm(http://youtu.be/n4tgkyUBkbY)(MarsOne)
SeehowMarsOneplanstoestablishahumansettlementonMars.
VIDEO:CanWeMakeIttoMars?(http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/space/can-we-make-it-to-mars.html)(NOVA)
Thishour-longprogramexploresthechallengesthatwouldbefacedbyhumansattemptingatriptoMars.
WEBSITE:28MonthsonMars(http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/12/09/science/space/curiosity-rover-28-months-onmars.html)(TheNewYorkTimes)
ViewimagesandmapsoftheMarsexplorationbyNASAsCuriosityrover.
KQEDDoNowScienceisamonthlyactivityincollaborationwithCaliforniaAcademyofSciences.TheScienceDoNowispostedeverysecond
Tuesdayofthemonth.
ThispostwaswrittenbythefollowingyouthfromtheScienceNewsTeamwithintheCaliforniaAcademyofSciencesTechTeensprogram:
AlexanderB.,DarrahB.,JonathanH.,NoraH.,JanelleL.,OliverL.,OttoL.,andSamuelP.TheTechTeensareyouthleaderswhousedigital
mediatodevelopandcommunicatesciencestoriesforthepublic.
EXPLORE:COMMUNITY(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/CATEGORY/COMMUNITY-CREATED-CONTENT/),SCIENCE
(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/CATEGORY/SCIENCE/),COLONY(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/COLONY/),DONOW
(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/DO-NOW/),GRADES6-12(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/GRADES-6-12/),MARS
(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/MARS/),MARSONE(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/MARS-ONE/),PLANET
(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/PLANET/),SPACE(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/SPACE/)
(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/MARS/),MARSONE(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/MARS-ONE/),PLANET
(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/PLANET/),SPACE(HTTP://WW2.KQED.ORG/EDUCATION/TAG/SPACE/)
(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/2014/12/09/isitethicalto
colonizemars/?share=facebook&nb=1)
(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/2014/12/09/isitethicalto
colonizemars/?share=twitter&nb=1)
(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/2014/12/09/isitethicalto
colonizemars/?share=pinterest&nb=1)
(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/2014/12/09/isitethicalto
colonizemars/?share=linkedin&nb=1)
(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/2014/12/09/isitethicalto
colonizemars/?share=googleplus1&nb=1)
(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/2014/12/09/isitethicalto
colonizemars/?share=email&nb=1)
69Comments(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/2014/12/09/is-it-ethical-to-colonize-mars/#disqus_thread)
RELATED
WatchSanFranciscoFall:
ACollectionoftheMost
DestructiveMovieScenes
TheScariestMoments
YouWon'tFindina
HorrorMovie
HowtoGetThatFall
Feeling,WithorWithout
theGoldenFallingLeaves
ShouldWeKillOne
SpeciestoSaveAnother?
JuneSwoon:5toWatch
JarmanRetrospective
(http://ww2.kqed.org/arts/2014/06/03/juneEndsinPoignant'Blue'at
swoon-5-to-watch/)
(http://ww2.kqed.org/education/2014/02/04/invasiveBAM/PFA
species-predator-kill/)
(http://ww2.kqed.org/pop/2014/05/08/watch(http://ww2.kqed.org/pop/2014/10/30/the(http://ww2.kqed.org/pop/2013/10/10/how(http://ww2.kqed.org/arts/2014/08/
scariest-moments-you-wont-find-in-asan-francisco-fall-a-collection-of-the-mostto-get-that-fall-feeling-with-or-withoutretrospective-ends-in-poignant-blu
destructive-movie-scenes/) horror-movie/)
the-golden-falling-leaves/)
bampfa/)
Poweredby
(https://contextly.com)
AUTHOR
CALIFORNIAACADEMYOFSCIENCES
TheCaliforniaAcademyofSciencesisaleadingscientificandculturalinstitutionbasedinSanFrancisco.Itis
hometoanaquarium,planetarium,naturalhistorymuseumandresearchandeducationprograms,whichengage
peopleofallagesandbackgroundsontwoofthemostimportanttopicsofourtime:lifeanditssustainability.
Foundedin1853,theAcademysmissionistoexplore,explainandsustainlife.Visitwww.calacademy.orgfor
moreinformation.
VIEWALLPOSTSBYTHISAUTHOR (http://ww2.kqed.org/education/author/calacademy/)
ABOUTKQEDEDUCATION
ABOUTKQED
FOLLOWKQEDEDUCATION
FundingforKQEDEducationisprovidedbyt
UsUsonvia
KQEDEducationprovideseducatorswithmultimediacontent,studentactivities,andprofessionaldevelopmenttoolstohelpcreatea21stcenturyclassroom
About(http://www.kqed.org/about/)
alignedtostateandnationalcontentstandards.
Jobs(http://www.kqed.org/about/jobs/)
Internships(http://www.kqed.org/about/internships/)
DonatetoKQED(https://www.kqed.org/donate/)
Websitehelp(http://www.kqed.org/about/help/index.jsp)