Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mechanical Sealing PDF
Mechanical Sealing PDF
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Best Practices
For
Mechanical Seals and
Sealing Systems for
Centrifugal & Rotary
Pumps
Please send your comments and suggestions to the author.
This document is intended for guidance purpose and may be adopted with minor
modifications by any functional department within RIL group of companies.
Reproduction of this document or parts thereof in not allowed unless written
permission is obtained from the Approving authority.
Page: 1 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
INDEX
TOPIC
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
10.0
11.0
12.0
13.0
14.0
15.0
DESCRIPTION
Scope
Definition
Applicable Standards
Purpose
Seal Categories
Seal Types
Seal Designs
Seal Arrangements and Configurations
Seal Accessories
Seal Piping Plans
Seal Selection Procedure
Seal Maintenance and Best Practices
Seal Documentation
References
Appendix-1 Seal Types Drawings
Appendix-2 Seal Piping Plan Flowchart
PAGE NO.
3
4
4
4
4
5
6
6
7
9
19
20
22
23
24
25
Page: 2 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
1.0 SCOPE
This document covers best practices for mechanical seals and sealing
systems installed in centrifugal and rotary pumps with an aim to achieve a
minimum of 3 years of seal life.
The scope of the document is to provide guidelines and best practices on seal
selection and maintenance.
This document is best used in conjunction with API 682.
Page: 3 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
2.0
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
DEFINITION:
APPLICABLE STANDARDS:
The primary standards applicable to seals and sealing systems for pumps are;
API 610 - Centrifugal Pumps for General Refinery Service, 10th Edition
API 682 - Shaft Sealing Systems for Centrifugal and Rotary Pumps, 2nd
Ed. 2002
ISO 21049:2004 Pumps -- Shaft sealing systems for centrifugal and
rotary pumps
4.0
PURPOSE:
The purpose of this document is to detail best practices with regards to the
design, selection, operation and maintenance of mechanical seals and sealing
systems for centrifugal and rotary pumps.
The document is intended for;
1. Field Maintenance Personnel
2. CES (Functional) Engineers
3. Project Engineers
4. Planning and Materials Engineers
5.0
SEAL CATOGORIES:
Page: 4 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
6.0
SEAL TYPES:
(REFER APPENDIX -1 FOR IMAGES)
The code has classified the seals in three types.
Type A is a pusher seal with rotating flexible element.
Face materials:
Silicon Carbide and Carbon
Metal Components:
SS 316
Springs:
Hastalloy C-276
O-Rings:
Fuoroelastomers
Type B is a bellow seal with rotating flexible element.
Face materials:
Silicon Carbide and Carbon
Diaphragms:
Hastalloy C-276
Metal Components:
SS 316
O-Rings:
Fuoroelastomers / Flexible Graphite *
Note: Fluoroelastomers shall not be used at a temperature beyond 175 deg.C
and Perfluoroelastomers shall not be used in seals operating at pumping
temperatures greater than 240 deg.C
Page: 5 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Metal Components:
Secondary Seals:
7.0
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
SS 316
Flexible Graphite
SEAL DESIGNS:
Mechanical seals designs are typically of the wet contact seal faces
(designated as CW) type. The API code has now included two additional
seal designs and these are as follows;
8.0
The seal arrangement defines the number of seals in the cartridge and the
seal housing pressures. These are categorized as below;
Arrangement 1:
This is the conventional one seal per cartridge assembly.
Arrangement 2:
This is a dual seal cartridge assembly with outboard seal is at a pressure
lower than the seal housing pressure (outboard seal could be a containment
seal)
Arrangement 3:
In this arrangement, dual seals are supplied with an external barrier fluid
which is at a pressure higher than the sealing pressure.
Refer the chart below.
Nomenclature:
FB:
BB:
FF:
FX:
FL:
Face Back
Back Back
Face Face
Fixed bushing
Floating bushing
Page: 6 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
9.0
SEAL ACCESSORIES:
9.1
SEAL COOLERS:
Seal coolers maybe specified to increase the vapor pressure of the fluid or
improve its lubricating properties. The seal cooler sizing shall be adequate for
the required removal of heat. The following shall be ensured;
1. Buffer/Barrier fluid temperature does not reach boiling point. A margin
of 15deg.C is recommended between the maximum anticipated
temperature and the boiling point.
2. Barrier/Buffer fluid temperature should not exceed allowable limits of
the materials of construction.
3. The temperature rise of the fluid should be restricted to 20deg.C.
To meet the above conditions, it maybe necessary to ensure that the inlet
temperature to the coolers is atleast 35deg.C below its boiling point.
Additional minimum design criteria is specified as follows;
The process shall be on the tube side and the cooling media shall be on the
shell side. It should be possible to drain both the shell and tube sides.
Prepared by: Paresh Girdhar
Checked by : K Gopalakrishnan
Approved by : A Venkatraman
Page: 7 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Barrier/Buffer Reservoirs:
The minimum design criteria sizes of the reservoirs have been specified in the
code. The minimum volume for these reservoirs is indicated as;
Shaft seal size < 2.500 inches
Volume: 3 gallons
Shaft seal size > 2.500 inches
Volume: 5 gallons
Reservoirs for atmospheric or low pressure buffer liquid and accumulators for
pressurized barrier liquid shall be sized for a manual refill interval time of at
least 25 days based on the seal leakage rate specified by the seal
manufacturer without compromising the specified seal life time.
9.3
Gas supply panels are used on Plan 72 and Plan 74 systems to provide a
filtered regulated inert gas to the mechanical seals. The supply panels must
have, at a minimum, a pressure regulator, coalescing filter, flow meter, low
pressure switch, pressure gauge, check valve, and isolation valve.
Page: 8 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
10.0
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Primary seal plans, such as 11, 13, 21, 23 and 32, shall be executed in piping
with welded or flanged connections.
The use of strainers or cyclone separators to trap sealant particulates is not
recommended. Standard seal flush plans 12, 22, 31 and 41 shall not be used.
A brief discussion on the various seal piping plans is included to aid the
selection process;
Plan 01:
Internal seal chamber flush from pump discharge
Purpose:
Heat removal from seal housing
Venting of seal housing
Reduce risk of freezing / polymerizing fluid in exposed and external
piping of Plan 11.
Application
Clean and medium fluid temperatures
Single seals
Limitation:
Flush cannot be directed over the seal faces.
Plan 02:
Dead ended seal chamber with no flush.
Purpose:
Simple, low cost
Application
Clean and medium fluid temperatures
Single seals
Limitations:
Flush cannot be directed over the seal faces
With higher fluid temperatures cooling water jacket is required for seal
housing.
Construction Features:
Throat bush is removed.
Plan 11:
Default seal piping plan. Seal flush from pump discharge through an orifice.
Purpose:
Heat removal from seal housing
Venting of seal housing in horizontal pumps
Prepared by: Paresh Girdhar
Checked by : K Gopalakrishnan
Approved by : A Venkatraman
Page: 9 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Plan 21:
In this plan, there is a seal flush from pump discharge through an orifice and a
cooler.
Purpose:
Cooling of seal
Reduce fluid temperature to raise fluid vapor pressure margin
Reduce coking
Application
Clean and high temperature service, typically between 80 deg.C to 175
deg.C
Single and dual seals
Limitations:
Failure mode is due to chocking of orifice. Regular field checks to
include monitoring of temperatures upstream and downstream of
orifice.
Construction Features:
Seal coolers and piping need vents at highest elevation for venting
before start
Plan 23:
In this plan, the flush is circulated by an internal pumping device to the cooler
in a closed loop. This lowers the cooling duty of the cooler and may allow
lower flush temperatures.
Purpose:
Cooling of seal
Reduce fluid temperature to raise fluid vapor pressure margin
Reduce coking
Application
Clean and high temperature service, typically between 80deg.C to
175deg.C
Single and dual seals
Limitations:
Seal coolers and piping need vents at highest elevation for venting
before start
Failure mode is due to chocking of orifice. Regular field checks to
include monitoring of temperatures upstream and downstream of
orifice.
Construction Features:
Seal housing requires close clearance throat bush to keep away the
process liquid
Tangential seal gland taps shall enter at bottom and exit at top
Prepared by: Paresh Girdhar
Checked by : K Gopalakrishnan
Approved by : A Venkatraman
Page: 11 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Plan 32:
In this plan, the seal flush is provided from an external source.
Purpose:
Cooling of seal
Reduce fluid temperature to raise fluid vapor pressure margin
Prevent entry of dirty, polymerizing or solid particulate matter in the
seal housing
Application
Service that maybe dirty, polymerizing, oxidizing or has particulate
matter.
High temperature service
Single seals
Limitations:
External barrier liquid has to be available and compatible with the
process liquid
Regular monitoring required to ensure supply of correct quantity of
flush at the specified pressure
Construction Features:
Throat bushing needs to be sized to hold pressure or maintain flow
velocity
Plan 52:
In this plan, the unpressurized barrier liquid is circulated through the reservoir.
Leakage of the inner and outer seals is monitored.
Purpose:
To provide a backup seal for the primary seal
To provide seals with zero emissions, especially in applications of light
hydrocarbons
Applications where no process contamination is allowed
Application
Plan is used for dual seals in face to back arrangement
High temperature, hazardous or toxic service
Limitations:
The required instrumentation raises the cost of the plan
Construction Features:
Piping loop needs to self vent to vapor recovery system near
atmospheric pressure
Buffer liquid to be compatible with process liquid and should preferably
have a good specific heat
Inboard and outboard seal leakages are known by increase in reservoir
pressure and reservoir level respectively
Prepared by: Paresh Girdhar
Page: 12 of 25
Group Manufacturing Services
Engineering
Services
Dept
Date: 9-Mar-07
Checked by : K Gopalakrishnan
DOC. No: GMS/RP/26
Revision no.: 0.0
Approved by : A Venkatraman
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Plan 53 - A:
In this plan, the pressurized barrier liquid is circulated through the reservoir.
Barrier liquid is circulated by pumping ring. Barrier liquid is pressurized in the
reservoir by gas which is in direct contact with a liquid.
Leakage of the inner and outer seals is monitored.
Purpose:
To provide a backup seal for the primary seal
To provide seals with zero emissions, especially in applications of light
hydrocarbons (having high vapor pressure)
No process contamination is allowed
Application
Plan is used for dual seals in face to back arrangement
High temperature, dirty, polymerizing, oxidizing, hazardous or toxic
service
Limitations:
Requires regular monitoring of the reservoir pressure.
Plan 53 A as pressurizing gas is in contact with the barrier liquid; gas
pressure can drop due to absorption
Gas charging arrangement is required
Construction Features:
Piping loop needs to self vent to vapor recovery system near
atmospheric pressure
Buffer liquid to be compatible with process liquid and should preferably
have a good specific heat
Inboard and outboard seal leakages are known by reservoir level
alone.
Plan 53 - B:
In this plan, the pressurized barrier liquid is circulated through the reservoir.
Barrier liquid is circulated by pumping ring. A bladder in the reservoir
separates the gas from the barrier liquid. Leakage of the inner and outer seals
is monitored.
Purpose:
To provide a backup seal for the primary seal
To provide seals with zero emissions, especially in applications of light
hydrocarbons (having high vapor pressure)
No process contamination
Need higher pressure than in Plan 53A
Application
Plan is used for dual seals in face to back arrangement where charge
gas in reservoir can be absorbed by the buffer liquid.
Prepared by: Paresh Girdhar
Checked by : K Gopalakrishnan
Approved by : A Venkatraman
Page: 13 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Page: 14 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Limitations:
Need periodic checking of the drain line for choking
Requirement of close clearance throttle bushing may require
extended gland
Construction Features:
Requires a close clearance throttle bushing to aid directing leakage
to the collection vessel
Plan 71:
This plan provides supply of gas buffer for dual gas seals and containment
seals.
Purpose:
Provide for low pressure containment seal with gas buffer as backup
for primary seal.
Application
Typical application is in face to back seal arrangement where outboard
seal is a containment seal in dead ended seal cavity.
High temperature, hazardous or toxic service
Limitations:
Gas buffer supply pressure to monitored on a regular basis
Construction Features:
With containment seals gas buffer pressure is limited to 0.7 bar (10 psi)
Plan 72:
This plan provides supply of gas buffer for dual gas seals and containment
seals. This is selected when it is beneficial to sweep the containment seal
cavity with an inert gas.
Purpose:
Provide back up for primary seal using a low pressure containment
seal with gas buffer
Application
Typical application is in face to back seal arrangement where outboard
seal is a containment seal.
High temperature, hazardous or toxic service
Limitations:
Gas buffer supply pressure to monitored on a regular basis
Used in conjunction with Plan 75 or Plan 76 where sweep of buffer gas
and seal leakage is led to a closed collection vessel
Page: 16 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Construction Features:
With containment seals gas buffer pressure is limited to 0.7 bar (10 psi)
Plan 74:
This plan provides supply of pressurized barrier gas for dual gas seals.
Purpose:
To provide seals with zero emissions, especially in applications of light
hydrocarbons (having high vapor pressure)
Isolate the process liquid
Application
Where liquid barrier for seals cannot be used
Plan is used for dual seals in back to back or face to face arrangement
High temperature, dirty, polymerizing, oxidizing, hazardous or toxic
service
Moderate temperatures
Limitations:
Clean and reliable supply of barrier gas supply is required.
Construction:
Barrier gas supply is typically 1.75 bar above the seal chamber
pressure
Gas flow meters indicate leakages of the inner and outer seals
Bottled gas supply system maybe required as an emergency backup
system
Plan 75:
This plan provides for collection of drain from containment seal cavity. The
drain may then be led to a liquid collection system and/ or for vapor recovery.
Purpose:
Leakage collection for zero/low process emissions
Safety indicator for primary seal
Application
Used alone or with Plan 72
Fluids that may condense in ambient conditions
Service that maybe hazardous or toxic or with high vapor pressure
Clean, non-polymerizing, non-oxidizing fluids
Limitations:
Regularly monitor liquid level, valve settings and low vent pressure.
Construction Features:
Collection reservoir is located below seal drain and downward sloped
piping
Prepared by: Paresh Girdhar
Checked by : K Gopalakrishnan
Approved by : A Venkatraman
Page: 17 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Plan 76:
This plan provides for vent from seal cavity of containment seal to vapor
recovery.
Purpose:
Leakage collection for zero/low process emissions
Safety indicator for primary seal
Application
Used alone or with Plan 72
Fluids that do not condense in ambient conditions
Service that maybe hazardous or toxic or with high vapor pressure
Clean, non-polymerizing, non-oxidizing fluids
Limitations:
Regularly monitor liquid level, valve settings and low vent pressure.
Construction:
Collection reservoir is located below seal drain and downward sloped
piping
Hook up vent collection reservoir to low pressure vapour recovery
system or flare system
Primary seal leakage is indicated by increase in level / increase in vent
pressure
Page: 18 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
11.0
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Hazardous services
Hazardous services shall be defined on the following basis
o Category 1:
Liquids containing hydrogen sulphide in concentrations
above 600 mg/kg.
Liquids consisting of or containing lethal substances as
indicated in the data/requisition sheet.
Examples of lethal substances include but are not limited to: HF acid,
phenol, concentrated sulphuric or nitric acid.
o Category 2:
Liquids consisting of or containing very toxic substances
These are substances with TLV-TWA rating of 5
ppmv and lesser
The value maybe extended to TLV-TWA rating of
20 ppmv if the location / site of the pump is
frequently visited by personnel
Liquids that are known to be proven carcinogens
and or have been to known to be causing cancer
in animal experiments.
Hydrocarbon liquids at an operating temperature above
their auto-ignition temperature.
o Category 3:
Hydrocarbon liquids with a seal chamber vapour
pressure higher than 5 bar (abs).
Hydrocarbon services of butane (C4) or lighter.
Page: 19 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Page: 20 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Preventive Maintenance:
The following activities are suggested during the normal PM schedules
of the pump.
Opening and cleaning of sealant lines, orifices, vents and drains
especially for unclean services
Back flush or cleaning of seal coolers. Ensuring adequate
cooling water supply and return
Calibration of instrumentation for Plan 32, 52, 53, 72, 74, 75, 76
12.3
Corrective Maintenance:
The recommended practice is the use of seal cartridges in all
applications. These cartridges maybe be restored and tested in-house
or by the seal vendor. In any case, the following shall be the guidelines
for repair as a minimum.
1.
Surface Finish:
The seal faces shall be lapped and finished to a maximum
tolerance of 3 light bands or 0.87 microns
The surface finish of the sleeve shall be a minimum of 0.8
microns Ra
Surface finish of the seal housing face shall be 1.6 microns Ra
The seal housing bore shall be machined to a finish of 3.2
microns Ra
2. Geometric Tolerances:
3.
Page: 21 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
13.0
Page: 22 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
14.0
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
REFERENCES:
API 610 - Centrifugal Pumps for General Refinery Service, 10th Edition
API 682 - Shaft Sealing Systems for Centrifugal and Rotary Pumps, 2nd
Ed. 2002
Shell DEP - Shaft Sealing Systems For Centrifugal And Rotary Pumps:
DEP 31.29.00.33-Gen. - July 1998
Overview of API 682 and ISO 21049 Michael B Huebner Proceedings
of 21st International Pump Users Symposium 2004
Overview of API 682 Second Edition - Michael B Huebner Proceedings
of 20th International Pump Users Symposium 2003
Advances in Mechanical Sealing An introduction to API 682 Second
Edition M.B.Huebner, J.M.Thorp, G.S.Buck, C.L.Fernandez Proceedings of 19th International Pump Users Symposium 2002
Containment Seals for API 682 Second Edition P.E.Bowden, C.J.Fone Proceedings of 19th International Pump Users Symposium 2002
Use of Non-Contacting Seals in Volatile Services B.Goodenberger,
D.E.Barron, J.Marquardt - Proceedings of 20th International Pump Users
Symposium 2003
Understand Mechanical Seals A.S.Godse Hydrocarbon processing
April 1995
Mechanical Seal Piping Plans Flowserve Document FTA160 Rev
12/03 Flowserve Solutions Division
Advanced Gas Sealing Systems for Hydrofluoric Acid Alkylation and Other
Extremely Hazardous Duties D. Kozlowski, E.Jahromi. J.R.WasserProceedings of 20th International Pump Users Symposium 2003
Burgmann Mechanical Seals Catalogue
Page: 23 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Appendix 1.0
Page: 24 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0
For
Internal
Circulation
Only
Copyright:
Reliance
Industries
Limited, India
Single Seals
A
Optional Fluid
Quench
Plan 62
External flush
External Pressurized
Barrier Gas
External Pressurized
Barrier liquid
Plan 74
Plan 54
Self Flush
Plan 32
Dead Ended
Inboard Seal
Outboard Seal
Plan 02
Inboard Seal - NC
Sealant is dirty/solids/
polymerizing ?
Yes
No
Plan 54
Normal
External Pressurized
Barrier liquid
External Unpressurized
Buffer liquid
Induced Circulation
Induced Circulation
Plan 74
Product Temperature ?
Outboard Seal
Pressurized
Barrier Gas
Unperssurized
Buffer Gas
Plan 52
Plan 01
High
Plan 11
Sealant Cooler
Plan 21
Induced Circulation
Vertical Pump?
Needs venting ?
Dead Ended
Possibility of
Gas absorption?
No
Plan 23
Plan 71
Yes
Plan 53-A
Plan 75
Need dynamic tracking
of system pressure?
Plan 13
Drain-Completely Dry
Plan 76
No
Plan 14
Plan 53-B
Yes
Plan 53-C
Page: 25 of 25
Date: 9-Mar-07
Revision no.: 0.0