Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Composition - How To Make Pictures
Composition - How To Make Pictures
Albert Dorne
Fred Ludekens
Norman Rockwell
AI Parker
Ben Stahl
Stevan Dohanos
Jon Whitcomb
Robert Fawcett
Peter Heick
George Giusti
Austin Briggs
Harold Von Schm idt
Composition
Composition means the selection and arrangement of appropriate elements within the picture space so that they express the
artist's idea clearly and effectively. It makes a great deal of
difference how we put together the things we draw within our
picture space. Often, a picture will succeed or fail, depending
on how well it is composed.
Composition, in a basic sense, means combining [arms and
space to produce a harmonious whole. When we make a picture.
we arrange the picture elements much the way a composer of
music arranges musical notes and themes to form a harmonious
resull. The composer of music creates an arrangement in sound
- we, as artists, create a visual arrangement. In composing a
picture we are chiefly interested in where we place our objects
in the picture space, how important we make them in size and
value, and how they relate to each other and to the outside
borders of the picture.
Good pictures, we see, do not simply happen. They are not
the result of thoughtlessly throwing together miscellaneous
objects or filling up a background with details. No maLler how
well we draw or paint, unless 'we plan our picture carefully, it
is likely to leave the viewer with an unsatisfied feeling. A wellcomposed picture, on the other hand, will give the viewer a
satisfied sense of order or beauty, a lthough he may not realize
by what methods this satisfaction was produced.
Every picture starts with an idea - a story we have to tell, an
effect or mood we are striving to communicate. In composing,
we select those things [or our picture which clarify our idea, and
we discard those which may distract or confuse.
No maller what the subject of your picture may be. begin by
asking yourself: "' '''hat is the basic idea I want to get across?
What things must I put in the picture so that the viewer will
understand it at once? \,yhal is important - and what isn't?"
In composing, you emphasize those elements of your picture
that will dramatite it the most. Usually this requires a change
in the si/es of things. You make important objects larger or
clearer or stronger than they may appear in reality, and less
important objects you make smaller or less distincl.
ObjeCls can be featured or played down by adjusting their
position as well as their size. For instance. you might place a
powerful, important figure in the middle of your picture space
and draw him large. so he would dominate the picture. By contrast, a shy, retiring character might be shown much smaller and
to the side, dominated by the space and the objects around him.
The artist can actually control which part of his picture the
viewer will linger over and find most meaningful. By the way he
arranges the objects, he can establish a definite focal point or
center of interest, and lead the eye to it indirectly or directly.
He can also use light and dark tones to help emphasize this
center of interest.
Often the artist can use the natural shape of his subject to
good effect in establishing his composition and the proportions
of his picture. For example. if the subject is a wide expanse of
meadow or sea, it might well suggest a picture of a long, hori
zontal shape. For a picture of a long, narrow subject like a tall
man or a church tower, a vertical picture of similar proportions
might drama tile the height of the subject most strikingly. Di(
ferent forms are often best expressed by different picture shapes.
All of these are principles you can apply in developing your
own compositions. Once you have learned how to use these
principles, you will soon find yourself giving sharper, clearer
expression to your ideas - saying what you want to say directly
and interestingly in pictures.
3
\
l esson
The elements
Above, you see three picture elements - a man with a gun, his
victim, and a tree. Our problem is to arrange them in the
picture space at the right to form a good composition.
Problem
Problem
~
We con emphasize the figure by making
it toke up a large port of the pictu re
space. The door, lamp, and toble serve
as incidental objects in the bockground.
l esson
Picture area
Pidure orea is the Rot surfoce within 'h, four borders of your
picture - the surface on which you drew end point . When you
work in terms of pidure areo , your chief concerns ore how big
you moke your objeds ond where you ploce them . In this illuItration 'he figure of the loldier claims our oU,nlion
once
because Austin 8riggs mode it the largest form in the picture
ond ploced it neor Ihe cenler. The leu importont forms - the
Imoke ond 'he soldiers in the dislonce - ore all mode smaller
ond ploced in secondory position,.
0'
l
Depth
Depth il the iIIudo" of dillonce or a third dimension. By drawing
things in depth, you make them seem to exist in space, and 10
appear dose 10 the viewe r or for away. In this picture the
slrong feeling of depth is crealed by the brood plane of the
beach. On ii, the large figure of the soldier conlrosts sharp ly
with the smoUer figures in the distance, making them seem for
off. Also helping ore the breakwater woll, which growl smaller
01 it recedes IQword the main figure. ond the rockl. which are
shown in detoil up fronl but become indi5tind farther bock.
Line
line hos two meaning'! (1) The outline which endole! 0 shape.
(2) The line of direction our eye follows in looking 01 a pidure.
This second meaning i, Ihe one we refer to here. In (omposing
with line, you arrange your objects so their shopel or moin lines
lead the eye unconsciously to the center of interest. Here this is
the wounded soldier . The horizon line, smoke, and running "gures
011 corry our eye directly to his heod . At the left, the oreokwoter
shoals in toward him; ot the right, our eye follows the line of
his leg in from the border. The muule of his rifle points TO 0
secondary center of interesT - the running "gurel - ond thele
lead us bock to the wounded soldier.
Value
. ~
Picture area
r
The art ist"s first consideration in composing a picLUre IS the pi cture area.
This is simpl y the Hal surface o n which you draw or paint within the borders
of your picture.
If yo u have ever taken a snapshot you have a lready worked with picture
area. T o take yo ur phoLOgraph . you looked in the viewer o f the camera a nd
moved back LO be certai n your whole subject was in the picture - or e lse you
moved closer so the subject would appear larger and clearer. These simple
steps in controlling th e space in a photograph are basica ll y the same ones
you use to co ntrol picture area in drawin g o r pa inting.
To use your pi cture area most effeClively. yo u must weigh carefu ll y where
you place thin gs within it a nd wha t size yo u make them. Your choice of size
and placemenl should neve r be acc idenlal or arbilrary. After you have
placed an objecl in yo ur composili on, pause and sLUd y the size and loca lion
you have give n iL Ask you rsel f: " Does lhis creale the effect r had in mind?"
If nOl, try making lhings larger or smaller. Move lhem lO differenl places
within t he four borders until YOll are salisfied with the result.
- .-
In the picture at the left the sense of distance ond the dominonce
of space is easily felt. By drawing the figures larger (right ) we
make them dominote the picture oreo.
l esson
10
Overlapping
Most of the pictures we make have more than one object in
them . a nd each often differs from the others in size a nd shape.
Overlapp ing provides a good way to organize these varied objects into interesting. unified arrangements.
When we overl ap things in a picture. we are app lying a prin-
Cropping
Even the border may be used to overlap objects. This is commonly ca lled "cropping. " The border may be used to Crop a
large pan of the Object - as long as the part which shows is
lypical enough to identify the object.
11
l esson
12
Points to remember
On this page we show you some more common-sense rules for arranging objects
inside the picture area. Study these rules carefully and fix them in your mind they will help you to avoid unnecessary errors. Although our examples are very
simple, the points th at they make apply to much more complicated pictures also.
A______ _
Don' t s plit th e picture in half:
Everything is crowded into the right
half of the picture, with the left side
completely empty.
lesson
13
Reduced to ih simple overoll shope, this magazine cover illustration shows Rockwell's concern for the some principles of composition we demonstrated in simpler pictures such as the one at
the for right. Rockwell combined his severo I picture elements to
create one varied, interesting whole.
THE
EV~
Foun~ t
BEGINNING
14
Depth
Depth, in a picllIre, is the illusion of distance or a third dimension. If our pictures are LO create a convincing sense of reality. we mllst suggest a feeling of
depth in them.
One way of geuing a feeling of depth in pictures, we have seen, is to over~ things. Another way is to draw objects smaller as they gel further from the eye.
Al the same lime, we must arrange our objeCls in depth so that they express
our picture idea accurately. Purpose and the effect we are working for must be
the guiding considerations here, just as they are when we arrange our objects
within the borders of the picture. or picture area.
In the illustration below we see how Fred Ludekens has arranged two figures
in depth to make a dramatic storytelling picture. He has placed one figure
in the foreground . so close to the viewer that we have a feeling or being directly
involved in the situation. The other figure is further off, but within talking distance, as required by the story. Far in the background, even the high mesa
appears low.
In his preliminary sketches. Ludekens tried out other possible arrangements
in depth. The diagrams below illustrate the kind of thinking he did. Like him,
you should always examine your effect very carefully to decide whether the
figures are at just the right depth - and make changes and adjustments until they
tell your story the way you want it told.
FRED LUDEKENS
lesson
15
-----------
I+---~~_4~
The same principles apply, regardless of subject
moiler. These three objects look Aot and uninteresting because they are in (I straight line.
-.L.
Here thing I are arranged in a monotonous triangle. The objeds crowd the borden. Overlapping
would have created a "ranger illusion of reality.
This is a betler
the objeds
have been overlapped and the placement makes
interesting use of the three-dimensional plane.
There is no overlapping here. The flatness is emphasized by the similar shapes of foreground and
water and the mountains. The for shore seems to
be on top of the bools.
16
In this compolition, notice that Ihe wfo appe ars norrower as it lead. inlo the depth of
the picture. Th. overlapped curtoins and Ihe deco rative r OOl l e r creal. depth on the woll
plane. Th. cropping (II the front bring. 1.11 right into Ihe Ice ne.
l~'{u
Courte.y McC.W.
In Ihi$ iIIU$tralian AI Porker, ..... onling to $ho..... a .....oman lad and alan.,
placed her again$t the upon .. of background sa her lonelineu could b,
fell . The empty choir 01 Ihe fronl tell$ the rell of the slory. The dinner
.ervice is arranged in depth to lead your eye oeroS$ the lobi, to her.
Lesson
17
]n this cover iIlustration for a farm maga7 ine. Heick's center of interest is the
two figures and the tractor and plow. He drew them large and placed them in
the left foreground, so they would dominate the scene. He arranged the plowed
furrows to carry our eye sharply back over the hillside to the farm - and fur
ther emphasized this movement into depth by the direction of the tractor and
the road at the left. as well as we gesture of the farmer.
CourTesy Esquire
Groupings in depth -
18
Line
The term line. as generally understood , is simply the outline o [ a shape. \\' hen we
apply it to composition, however, line mea ns th e direction in which OliT eye moves
as we look at a picture. \\'e creatc this directional kind of line by arranging the
objects in the picture so that their shapes or their main lines lead the eye un co n
sciously to a ce nter of interest.
Controlling the movement of the viewer's eye within the picture borders is a
very irnportant pan of picture making. The artist must a lwa ys be aware of what
the lines in his pi ctures do. In composi ng a picllIre we must plan these Jines to
help guide the viewer's eye. \'\Ie should make Slife thal one line leads LO another,
and ultimatel y LO so me center of interest. If we work unthinkingly, we may create
strong lines that lead to unimportant parts of the illustration or out of it altogether.
It is also important to be aware of the type of movement that directional line
creates. It ca n move our eye a long quite smoothly and rh ythmi ca lly from one thing
to another, grouping and relating objects whi ch belong together. On the other
hand , the movement ma y be abrupt - the artist may purposefully create a clash
of lines. This may be appropriate if he is drawing a scene of viole nce or confl ict.
Line ca n be a strong force or a subtle one - but it should a lways lead the viewer
so that he will see and feel the things we want him to.
Here is 0 less obvious exomple of the ule of line. Our eye enters Ihe
picture in the lower left corner ond move, olong Ihe rood . This movement is pid:ed up by the Iree trunk, ond (orried out through Ihe
bronch to the church. Agoin the mountoinl interJect the steeple.
lesson
19
1 This lirst altempt at composing two ligures in the picture space is very weak. The lines of the man' s suit are
confused by those of the drape behind him. The lampshade hil! the edge of the other drape and confuses
the lines of the woman' s head . The window in the center
is on empty, wasted space. Our eye is pulled down and
out the bottom border by the converging lines of the
woman's hand, the drape, and the man's side.
1 Almost every main line in this picture works against good 2 See how much easier it is
composition . The lines of the rood, fence , and hill corry
our eye sharply to the left border. Even the tree leans out of
the picture. The man 's arm runs into the top line of the hill.
3 This is still better. The girl has been moved to the left, so
thai she is no longer portly concealed by the tree . Drop
ping the hill line makes both man and girl stand out more
clearly. The tree trunk and branches turn our eye movement back into the picture and help frame the two ligures.
20
'n or out: Remember Ihol lines con lead Ihe eye into or Qui of
o picture . In Ihe left diogrom, the lines of the figures leod the
eye to Ihe left border and out. At righl. they bring our oHention
bock into Ihe picture spoee. Alwoys use your lines 10 creote the
porticulor movement a nd direction you wonl .
,
This scene, which contoins mony figures , is core fully or
gonized so thot the moin movement is one of opposition
between the figure leoning forword 01 the left ond the
mon on the Aoor. The line olong the bock of the mon 01
the left follows 0 definite curve toword Ihe foiling figure .
This figure ond the toble ond choir in turn creole 0 pot.
lern of line Ihol opposes the o ther figure .
lesson
21
Tong e " ts: Don 'l arrange objects so Ihot a line on one will meet a line
on another . They will form a longer line and drow the eye away from
the center of interest. In the left diagram the lines at the lop of the
man' s head, 01 his shoulders and jacket boUom form distracting tongenh
- which are easily corrected (righ') by moving the objects a little.
Picture corne rs: Picture corners, due 10 the meeling of the frame IineJ,
are II rang and oUtod attention. Don't let any of a picture', main lines
run into corners - as the rood, long branch and top of Ihe tree trunk do
in the left diagram - or they will lead the eye oul of the picture. plan your
lines 01 01 the righl to keep the viewer's interest within Ihe picture area .
22
Value
Value - lightness or darkness - is the fourth of the elements of composition. AI
though last in order, it is by no means last in importance. Like area, depth. and
line. value can playa leading part in the making of a picture.
Many piCLures have a mood, and a major factor in creating this mood is the
over-all value we give the picture - the "key," as it is frequently called. For
example, a picture of a gay picnic or a children's party should probably be painted
light in value, or in a fairly "high key." But if we wished to paint a scene with
a feeling of sadness and despair. we could accentuate this mood by mak ing the
picture dark in value or in a "'ow key." In a violent fight scene or a picture of a
storm we might logically select a wide range of contrasting values ranging from
pure white to solid black.
Values hould be consistent within a picture. particularly where we use them
to set the mood. For example. the over-all effect of the picnic scene might be
ruined if part of the picture or some of the figures in it were painted in deep.
somber lOnes. out of key with the rest of the illustration. And, similarly, a picture
with a mood of dark despair could be weakened by thoughtlessly introducing
light or gay tones.
Just as the proper use of line leads our eye lO a focal point in a picture. so our
eye tends to go to those points where there is the greatest contrast of values. This
is because objects become more conspicuous when placed next to a value that
contrasts with their own. On the other hand. when an object is surrounded with
values that are nearly the same as its own, it is not so likely to attract our atte ntion. Thus OLlr eye is drawn lO the black hat on a man standing in front of a pile
of snow - but it is not attracted when he moves over and stands in front of a
pile of coal. We can L1SC this principle to help focus attention where we want
it in a picture .
.,
~
.
.,
'"
t:
"
-...
:::~~
-..;:,.. - -=='-_ - ~
S _ - ~~--::-_~_- .;::-- ...;:;;-- - - -- - ~
----- --
--
---,..
Here is a pic1ure in which we have applied the composition principles we have learned 50 for . The elemenll are well arranged in
depth in the picture area and the movement of line is equalJy
satisfactory. Now we are ready to odd the conlideration of niliL
lesson
23
24
l esson
25
the same subject would look in the other keys. Next to each piclUre a value bar with a bracket indicates the range of values used.
Notice that the relationship of value5 is consistent in eac h of
these pictures. For examp le, the girl's dress is always the lightest
LOne, her black eye one of the d arkesl. Always choose the key
most appropriate to your subject - and stick to it as yo u pail'll.
...
lesson
26
1
well much too dull. Th. caddy is too
promin ent and dillroding .
6
w.
3
In this nut e ffort, everythi ng wos pushed
to one sid. of the area, leoying (I 101 of
uni"t.,."i"; spoce on the right. The
coddy Hems to be holding up Ihe picture frame with his head .
7
lowering the line of the trap and Oyoiding th. corners, we ore now beginning
to gel some iemblance of unity. The
brief case ond the caddy or. still not in
exactly the right position. The landscape
ad ded at left fiUs a gap.
8
Shif.ing the brief cas. give, us better
balance . But the ,traight part of Ihe
trap on the right givel a feeling that
e ...e rything is a hou. to slide through the
bo ttom. Th. caddy still appears to be in
the wrong place.
9
The completed illustration
The finished illustration as it appeared in the magalines.
lesso n
27
2
This wos the flnt tr y. It seems too spread ou t and
the man seems lost in a tot of office equ ipment.
3
This look-down view also loses the man . The
typewriter, rather tha n the mon, oppeors to
be the center of inte rest.
5
4
The man' s fe et on the desk seem like a good " stopper ."
However, this picture hos the some foults o s No. 3 - there
ore d isturbing ton gents, the mon looks a slee p.
6
A dose-up of the man seems to crowd the picture. How_
eve r, there is on ideo he re. We show the client's prod.
ucts on the desk ond the subject' s foce.
7
The feet ore bock on the desk and the picture
is opened out a little more. The dient' s products
in the for eg round give depth to the composition. The mon's attitude seems good.
8
This is the com position we decide on . It seems to sa y frustra tio n ond dutter. W e now refine our composition , making sure
there ore no tangents ond that ou r spoce is well designed.
9
He re is the finished penci l drawing . We add the heavy
book to streng then the lower right corner. The heod is now
definiTe ly the center of interest.
10
This is the finished picture. The design o f space ond the plocement of the objects turned
ou t welt. The tones ond values ore goad - ond while there ore mony elemen ts in the
picture, our attention is held by the mon' s heod .
On this page we show you another advertising illustration in its step-by-step developmeot as a compositio n.
The subject is an adverti sing writer who is hav ing
trouble geuing an idea for his client's products, whi ch
are piled up on his desk. The atmosphere is one o[
frustration and cluuer - the man is o bviously tired. In
making pictures, the number o[ approaches to working
out th e composi ti on o n a given subject are enormous,
and there are man y ways of doing it that are good.
The important point to remember is the selecti on of
the right composition to solve the advertiser's specific
problem - to get his message over to the public.
28
Valu e: Porker hal used the bOlic device of
dark ogai.ut light and light against dark
to empholiu the two figures. The girl' l
blonde head contrOlh with the blackboard.
the boy's dork hair stands out ogoinst the
light mop. te u important thing 1 such 01
the boY'1 sweOler or the girl's drell (ontrost lell sharply or ore tied in wilh obieeft
of similor value so that they do not claim
our otten lion so for cefully .
Courlely Good Ho usekeeping
-,-,.,.-~
~.z'"
-_.ar.;
t'1.-
;-0 , /
/d-..
A
,.
".'
...Q)
Il.
~
~