Conduct Board ‘Commanealth of Pennsylvania Robert A. Graci, Chief Counsel 17347911 Press Release Fane TT To: Pres FROM: Robert A.Graci Chet Counsel SUBJECT: Investigation Regarding Former Magisterial District Judge Jeffrey 8. Joy Harrishurg. ‘The Judicial Conduct Board today filed formal charyes by Boar! Complaint in the ‘Court of Judicial Discipline against former Magisterial District Judge Jefirey 8, Joy. The Board ‘Complaint alleges violations ofthe Code of Judicial Conduct and the Pennsylvania Constitution, Under the Pennsylvania Constitution, Mr. Joy, as the subject of the charges, is presumed innocent in all proceedings before the Court of Judicial Discipline. The Board has the burden of ‘proving the charges fled in the Court of Judicial Discipline by clear and convincing evidence. In accordance with the rules which govern proceedings before the Court of Judicial Discipline, ‘Mr. Joy has the right to respond to the charges, to obiain and inspect the evidence which forms the basis of the allegations, and toa public trial before the Court of Judicial Discipline. ‘Upon completion of the tia, if dhe Court determines thatthe charges have been proven by clear and convincing evidenes it will schedule a Sanctions Hearing to determine what sanction should bbe imposed. Possible sanctions include reprimand, suspension, or removal from office. Borel Complaint fe anached. Counsel oar Francis J. Puskas 1, Deputy Chief Counsel Respondent: Christopher A. Ferro, Esquire Contact: Robert A. Grach, Chief Counsel For more information aboutthe Judicial Conduet Board, please vist our website a www Jcbpa.oryCOMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIAS 3 COURT OF JUDICIAL DISCIPLINE INRE: Jeffrey S. Joy Former Magisterial District Judge District Court 19-3-04 Nineteenth Judicial District York County ELD LIAO gi IMPORTANT NOTICE TO: JEFFREY S, JOY: You are hereby notified that the Pennsylvania Judicial Conduct Board has determined there is probable cause to file formal charges against you for conduct proscribed by Article V, §17(b) and §18(d)(1) of the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges. The Board's counsel will present the case in support of the charges before the Pennsylvania Court of Judicial Discipline. You have an absolute right to be represented by a lawyer in all proceedings before the Court of Judicial Discipline. Your attorney should file an entry of appearance with the Court of Judicial Discipline within fifteen (15) days of service of this Board Complaint in accordance with C.J.D.R.P, No, 110. You are hereby notified, pursuant to C.J.D.R.P. No. 302(B), that should you elect to file an omnibus motion, that motion should be filedno later than thirty (30) days after the service of this Complaint in accordance with C.J.D.R.P. No, 411. You are further hereby notified that within thirty (30) days after the service of this Complaint, if no omnibus motion Is filed, or within twenty (20) days after the dismissal of all or part of the omnibus motion, you may file an Answer admitting or denying the allegations contained in this Complaint in accordance with C.3.D.R.P. No. 413, Fallure to file an Answer shall be deemed a denial of all factual allegations in the Complaint.COMPLAINT AND NOW, this 17 day of June 2016, comes the Judicial Conduct Board of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania (hereinafter “Board") and files this Board Complaint against Jeffrey S. Joy, former Magisterial District Judge, York County, Pennsylvai alleging that Mr. Joy violated the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges and §18(d)(1) of the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as more specifically delineated herein. 1. Article V, §18 of the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania grants the Board authority to determine whether there is probable cause to file formal charges, and, when It concludes that probable cause exists, to file formal charges against a justice, judge, or justice of the peace for proscribed conduct and to present the case in support of such charges before the Court of Judicial Discipline. From January 2012 until August 7, 2015, Mr. Joy served continuously as a duly elected Magisterial District Judge for Magis: ial District 19-3-04 in York County, Nineteenth Judicial District, Pennsylvania, encompassing the Townships of ‘Shrewsbury and Springfield, Boroughs of Glen Rock, Jacobus, Loganville, New Freedom, Railroad and Shrewsbury.3. By Administrative Order dated August 7, 2015, York County President Judge Stephen P. Linebaugh removed Mr. Joy from handling all Magisterial istrict Judge duties until further order of the Court, 4. On August 13, 2015, the Board filed a Petition For Interim Suspension With or Without Pay against Mr. Joy. By Order dated August 17, 2015, this Court suspended Mr. Joy without pay. 5. As a duly elected Magisterial District Judge, Mr. Joy was at all times relevant hereto subject to all the duties and responsibilities, imposed on him by the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania and the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges adopted by the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. PARTI, 6. On August 7, 2015, the Pennsylvania State Police, with the approval of the Pennsylvania Office of attorney General, charged Mr. Joy with the following criminal offenses: (1) Official Oppression, 18 Pa.C.S.A, §5301(1), 2 misdemeanor of the second degree; (2) Indecent Assault, 18 Pa.C.S.A, §3126(a)(1), 2 misdemeanor of the second degree; <4(3) Harassment, 18 Pa.C.S.A, §2709(a)(4), a misdemeanor of the third degree; and (4) Harassment, 18 Pa. A. §2709(a)(1), a summary offense, A true and correct copy of the Criminal Complaint is attached hereto, incorporated by reference, and marked as Board's Exhibit oar On August 12, 2015, the Pennsylvania State Police, with the approval of the Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General, fled the following additional criminal charges against Magisterial District, Judge Joy: (1) Bribery in Official and Political Matters, 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4701(a)(2), a felony of the third degree; (2) Bribery In Official and Political Matters, 18 Pa.C.S.A. §4701(a)(3), a felony of the third degree; (3) Official Oppression, 18 Pa.C.S.A. §5301(1), a misdemeanor of the second degree; (4) Harassment, 18 Pa.C.S.A, §2709{a)(4), a misdemeanor of the third degree; and (5) Harassment, 18 Pa.C.S.A. §2709(a)(7), a misdemeanor of the third degree.10. A true and correct copy of the Criminal Complaint is attached hereto, incorporated by reference, and marked as Board's Exhibit ‘ar Following a combined preliminary hearing on both cases held on September 18, 2015, Senior Magisterial District Judge John Zepp held all charges for court. A true and correct copy of the magisterial district judge docket entries regarding Commonweaith v. Jeffrey S, Joy, M3-19301-CR-000342-2015, and Commonwealth v. Jeffrey S, Joy, MJ-19301-CR-000348-2015, is attached hereto, incorporated by reference, and marked as Board's Exhibit "C." ‘The matters proceeded to the York County Court of Common Pleas. True and correct copies of the docket entries regarding Commonwealth v. Jeffrey S. Joy, CP-67-CR-0006006-2015, and Commonwealth v. Jeffrey S. Joy, CP-67-CR-0006007-2015, are attached hereto, incorporated by reference, and marked as Board's Exhibit "D." On April 27, 2016, pursuant to a plea agreement, Mr. Joy pled no contest at Commonwealth v. Jeffrey S. Joy, CP-67-CR-0006006-2015, to Count 3, Official Oppression, a misdemeanor of the second degree, Mr. Joy also pled no contest at Commonwealth v. Jeffrey S. Joy, CP- 67-CR-0006007-2015, to Count 1, Official Oppression, a misdemeanorA. of the second degree, The Honorable Lawrence F. Clark, Jr, Senior Judge, sentenced Mr. Joy in the aggregate to two years’ probation, 200 hours of community service, to pay the costs of prosecution and a fine of $2,000.00, Senior Judge Clark also directed that within 24 hours Mr. Joy was to tender to the Governor of the Commonwealth, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and the Pennsylvania Secretary of State, an unequivocal, non-revocable, resignation from judicial office which acknowledges that Mr. Joy will not seek or accept judicial or law enforcement office in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania for the duration of his natural life. A true and correct copy of the Plea and Sentence transcript Is attached hereto, incorporated by reference, and marked as Board's Exhibit "E.” During the plea and sentencing proceeding on April 27, 2016, the Commonwealth put on the record a factual basis for each plea at each docket as follows: a. Commonwealth v. Jeffrey S. Joy, CP-67-CR-0006006-2015 Okay. On Docket 6006 of 2015, the offense occurred at 28 Berkshire drive in Shrewsbury Borough, York County, Pennsylvania, and on or about December 1%, 2014, at that date the Defendant did take advantage of his official capacity a5 a Magisterial District Judge of York County, Pennsylvania, by infringing on the rights of the victim in this case identified as an adult female, A.P.M, are her initials, by demanding that she model items of lingerie clothing at her residence in ‘exchange for vacating her outstanding fines and costs.12. ‘See Board's Exhibit "E," N.T. at 3, Plea and Sentence Hearing, April 27, 2016. b, Commonwealth v. Jeffrey S. Joy, CP-67-CR-0006007-2015 ‘Then on 6007 of 2015, at 28 Water Street, Apartment 34 in Glen Rock Borough, York County, Pennsylvania, on or about March 4", 2015, the Defendant was present at that location and did again take advantage of his official capacity as a Magisterial District Judge of York County, Pennsylvania, by subjecting the victim in this case she is identified with the initials M.C. to mistreatment from the ~ In the form of unwanted sexual contact. ‘See Board's Exhibit “E,” Id. In making his plea of no contest, Mr. Joy acknowledged understanding the factual bases for his pleas at docket numbers CP-67-CR-0006006- 2015 and CP-67-CR-0006007-2015 and acknowledged that although he was notadmitting to those facts, he understood that his plea of no contest would be treated as equivalent to a guilty plea for purposes of sentencing THE COURT: Okay. Do you further understand that although you are not admitting to these facts, that a plea of no contest is treated for the purposes of sentencing and the outcome of these cases as a plea of guilty, do you understand that? ‘THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. THE COURT: Okay. Do you understand the nature of the allegation against you at Docket 6006, which is Count No. 3, as described by the Commonwealth's attorney, that being a count of misdemeanor graded official oppression, do you understand that charge against you? ‘THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. -8-1B. 14. ‘THE COURT: And to that charge how do you plead? ‘THE DEFENDANT: No contest. THE COURT: And, similarly, as to Count No. 1 at Docket 6007, do you understand the basis of that plea or that allegaticn against you? ‘THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. ‘THE COURT: And to that charge how do you plead? ‘THE DEFENDANT: No contest. See Board's Exhibit “E,” Id. at 4-5. By letter dated April 26, 2016, Mr. Joy gave notice to Governor Tom Wolf and Chief Justice Thomas Saylor that he was resigning as magisterial district judge effective immediately and would not seek any judicial or law enforcement office in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. This letter was also provided to the Pennsylvania Secretary of State, Pedro A, Cortés. A true and correct copy of Mr. Joy's letter to Governor Tom Wolf and Chief Justice Thomas Saylor is, attached hereto, incorporated by reference, and marked as Board's Exhibit 'F.” Mr. Joy's criminal convictions have become final and he has filed no appeal.16. 15. By virtue of his convictions for two counts of Official Oppression, misdemeanors of the second degree, Mr. Joy is subject to discipline under the Pennsylvania Constitution. cual By virtue of sme or all of the facts collectively set forth at Part I, Mr. Joy is subject to discipline for violating the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges (effective December 1, 2014) and the Pennsylvania Constitution as follows: Count 1: By virtue of his convictions for two counts of Official Oppression, misdemeanors of the second degree, Mr. Joy has violated Canon 2, Rule 2.4(B) of the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges, which provides: "A magisterial district judge shall not permit family, social, political, financial, or other interests or relationships to influence the magisterial district judge's judicial conduct or judgment.” By virtue of his convictions for two counts of Official Oppression, misdemeanors of the second degree, Mr. Joy has violated Canon 3, Rule 3.9A(1) of the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges, w -10-provid “Magisterial district judges and all employees assigned to or appointed by magisterial district judges shall not engage, directly or indirectly, in any activity or act Incompatible with the expeditious, proper and impartial discharge of their duties, Including, but not limited to, (1) In any activity prohibited by law.” By virtue of his convictions for two counts of Official Oppression, misdemeanors of the second degree, and also based on his violations of Canon 1, Rule 1.1, Canon 2, Rule 2.4(B), and Canon 3, Rule 3.9A(1), Mr. Joy has violated Cenon 1, Rule 1.2 of the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges, which provides: “A magisterial district judge shall act at all times in a manner that promotes public confidence in the Independence, integrity, and impartiality of the judiciary, and shall avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety.’ By virtue of his convictions for two counts of Official Oppression, misdemeanors of the second degree, and also based on his violations of Canon 1, Rule 1.2, Canon 2, Rule 2.4(B), and Canon 3, Rule 3.9A(1), Mr. Joy has violated Canon 1, Rule 1.1 of the Rules Governing Standards of MeA Conduct of Magisterial District Judges, which provides: ‘magisterial district judge shall comply with the law, including the Rules Governing Standards of Conduct of Magisterial District Judges.” Count S: By virtue of his convictions for two counts of Official Oppression, misdemeanors of the second degree, Mr. Joy has violated Article V, §18(d)(1) of the Pennsylvania Constitution by engaging in conduct “in violation of a canon or rule prescribed by the Supreme Court.” Count 6: By virtue of his convictions for two counts of Official Oppression, misdemeanors of the second degree, Mr. Joy has violated Article V, §18(d)(1) of the Pennsylvania Constitution by engaging in conduct which “brings the judicial office into disrepute, whether or not the conduct occurred while acting in a judicial capacity or is prohibited by law.” WHEREFORE, Mr. Joy, a former Magisterial District Judge of York County, Pennsylvania, Is subject to disciplinary action pursuant to the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Article V, §18(d)(1). “12.Respectfully submitted, ROBERT A. GRACI Chief Counsel DATE: June 17, 2016 By: Pa. Supreme Court ID No. 76540 Judicial Conduct Board Pennsylvania Judicial Center 601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 3500 P.O. Box 62525 Harrisburg, PA 17106 (717) 234-7911 otaCOMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA ‘COURT OF JUDICIAL DISCIPLINE IN RE Jeffrey S. Joy Former Magisterial District Judge 23D 2016 District Court 19-3-04 : Nineteenth Judicial District York County : VERIFICATION I, Francis J. Puskas 11, Deputy Chief Counsel to the Judicial Conduct Board, verify that the Judicial Conduct Board found probable cause to file the formal charges contained in the BOARD COMPLAINT. T understand that the statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa, Cons, Stat, Ann. §4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Respectfully submitted, ROBERT A. GRACI Chief Counsel DATE: June 17, 2016 BY: Pa. Supreme Court ID No, 76540 Judicial Conduct Board Pennsylvania Judicial Center 601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 3500 P.O. Box 62525 Harrisburg, PA 17106 (717) 234-7911EXHIBIT “A”SRT TOTS PERETTI is ESM Ge or remo Sourvon Yori e ese peer cies Sale Bthee (To a a sa mae (eRe ae a ———_ ae Pitti — feemeea Ee ean cer ose ee casas ammo SS iB fa eae Toorere — Te aes — Tee ie = — ee [fa fae z es es — ee 1 [eer — pe = [coe ete ery Te ae Enea arom” teat Oisine, Hsiens FREES ie—# Se Pisa — Toros exer Fa sae Tes hee — areas sue ee = “DEF ERAN VETRCLE MIPORNATION a ho a i a 7 F ie ear pamntlad tat eM soem) at (esheets) {TEd Ince stra named den wo era weet tte 1D lacus db neue omelets ese 1D Jocanstn dens ose ara and pop dpa ries atsincunta mae vee tava hank dia hiro Ses Don, liisrg i raion f= conmorwesh Peet st a YOR county Bovey OH By HG emai, ‘AOPC atzA ew.488 potice crintAL compLaneT Teantinser aaarace [orate orber eecpranaticier ii irae enitnane [ By eae be ‘The ace comin by th cused ar dascbad blo wheat Act Ase o eae aac vised, Sanahiale.2ieraereda move han ora fee, eaten ehoul ba numbered creraloeay. onan semyertretorotiarsntea iseedsaciatiempresentoneratoanane teeta es oo p= EF Saar B, in eam [ey | + fue 0 Ferman tee Desire _Eirazon Blau Description (rule the nama of vate erdnany foticai Oper Acts oftieaccised aerosafod wih a Olen INTHAT, ona about ead dato, THE DEFENDANT aod ex pasted to at in fic cope lok fesantago of ech csr pupae eapclykrourg tha is cnet was Baal by eecing asa fo net deter, seo, stint, mllieaman,dispaseetioy,eacoecment on reer ingore freon cr proary rhs In oson of Sean 6901 (1) a the PA Crimoa Cod, To Wie THE BEFENGANT di oko adeantega ois aie eapaciy axa Magltrtal Distt Jsige of Yerk County, Penny ania by sdjecng 2 Vici dale ea ed omele HC, DOB: 0428764} to mlsteatment i Ina fr ol swan eon laniac, fear cs = P= Bf Her] Joao [ey J one [ruetopncitmscace [+ _|ue ven eae ‘tse rei Frente Lara tan Saute Deseitn (acid a name o sai or etnanceh Indecent Assault [Acs of ha aecued aseoeated wah Ws Olence [HU THAT, on or about sl date, THE DEFENDANT cd have ledecent contact vith a complanant, rasa dul female victim ole ws MLC, DOB: 04/2074, oe cause tno eorgsiant ta have doco arial wi [THE DEFENDANT, withu| the coniainant's carseni in vlan of Eaton 2125()} ef tia PA Cres Code [To Wi: THE DEFENDANT aubjociad ihe visi fo ncacert contact ky groping tho ets hacia sreca ing up he shi, and king her breast of wilh eecrred whet ht cant AOPC 412 Rev. 12018 Page hot#85 pouice crimat compLanr Teeter | bey Riese OWhivctam Kamion Conplaitncdon Manter a roger Detrsttne | Ne Par a EEneY on ‘oy Tho acts commited by tho accused ae described below wl cach At of Atom ot eat alegedl visto, ermal ee ered one tna one lee gach ene auld berumbored chanel aa a ar ar fo [ 3 [re Jin [ses ren tosrncameece [|e 2 rms | te Cmte Blt Deserpion (rete he vara of sraserert [Acs ole acced assenald wn fe Olen [RUTHAT, on of about eid dale, THE DEFENCANT, wh rtnt to harans, nny oa attr pereon, fmol, ena femal tir Kenic ma MLC, DOB: OVZED4, dl corsmurten oor eel eu eter persen any lev. asivous, theealonng or checene words, langumpe, age or caesar In viton of Seclan f709(0)i ofthe PA Crines Cove. Ta Wit THE DEFENDANT appacred sn victims apaiil andere pretense that he was Inorg to purses her awa apr ancl Inslgae, T= DEFENDANT gaged in a coure ef eeivieus behind comaiatio vine ns epalety omnia on ha loos nd pressured hoe to model agai atoclings for eeiual rte. jer exdnaneay fae — fo =r Bas [ a Tow [ery [ine [enieyrncnices [yo = ce ‘ Chm Chasse Cana i eset (OAS Te na calor) Haravement Aso ta nected aseocatod yah We Olenoe INTHAT, on or about ead ste, THE DEFENDANT, wits ent ta harass, enncy or alarm acts: prson, imal, an aul ema vicim Koiiied 2s H.C, DOS: 0428/04, cl tk, shove, icc ex horse ego uct ee person ta phyla contact, oe all treatm tots in eave, vation tf Gaston 27osah a he PA Crimea Code, To Wt: THE DEFENDANT harassed, annoyed, er aartod tha vc by rong ie ei fpacaiie and breast pling uphir shi and icking her ca wen the isin caer ‘ROPE 412A ov, 4714 Page ot8 pouice orimiNaL coMPLAT ectnomien [Oa Feat | orntivesonn Homtar ‘Coilalatincist Hamar a fasSevot oo se ‘a Deontctne | Foe Sot so 2, Laskthalawarran ef snot era surmene ba Issued and tha the defendant b required anv tha charges Ihave mato, ‘voi that the facts bat fathin Ws cml a vend eat ta tha bes of my hnonladge ot Informatan ard bela. Tis varlicslion sade sutfeeto the ponies of Secon 4004 cl iha Caes ‘Soe 188. G¢004) rating Us unowa ellieaton io aieries, 4. "This complaat conte oftha prosadng pogote)mumbered 4 tough ‘THe aes commited by tne ncaa, na fated and hora, wera wgane the peace ar ely of the {Commonseiinf Pennsyvsla an were corzarytatha Act) of tha Asem orn vlan o he tttes ced (Before a warrant of arcost ean ba Pofore the issuing aul, nl itt lenfi “ feta AND NOW, ontisdsto, _P= T= 2 | cai tat to complet hs boon propery ‘completed nd verted, Aatisavl of proRaivs eaUue Tas ba eempeted befor a Waren con sued, 2 [2e3-04 Q aa =— Sto iat cFeeL Tedg ee musts completed, sworn te ‘AORC 4124-1214 eget otPOLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT. Calta oe reat a rae Te Ss oe = i AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE Your affant fsa Pamsyvania State Trooper curenty essigned to the Criminal Investigation Uni ‘Troop H York Statin, have boon a mombar af the Penneyivania Sala Pobco elnca Decora af 2005 and hava been inths Criminal Investigalon Uni elnea Octo af 2011, tn altima I hve ‘conducted numerous sexual saul investigations thal hava resulted in successful prosaction. Adina, hava investigated malor and compl neldents eluding hae, pli Ivaied ‘shootings, oiler viien times euch as aerpted arieklos and robberies, and franca exknas, 1 have also received exensiva training fn interviewing techniques, On Q3/045 I vias nssined fo investigate an incident Involving an adult fmmale vet konto a {his documenta “M.C* (COB: G4/26/04 vito teporlod the Yo aoxualy noacied by ths delendent, ‘York County Magistetial Dist udga Voficy Scott JOY. Al ths Uma of this incident, MO. relded at 20\Water GL, Apt #4 Glen Rock Born, York County whch f lcalon where (ne Incident ke aged {ohiava osatined, ‘Accoring to Fully mallabia records, the defendant hos served as Meglstrlal Dist Judge rest over Dist Court {0.3.04 beghnng n January cf 2012 efor olny ected fe potion ‘on Hovember 6%, 2011, The defendant has cerved in this ofe‘al capaci rough the presen dala. ‘Ackéloraly, ti detendans public oaely experiance Includes serving tan yeas ex he former chalmnan ofthe Souther Poco Connstion, Ho eso served as ha frmer Mayor of Nev Freedom Borough for on yoars and wae previously a dispatcher with Yok County O11 fot Avo years “The flowing are the fas ofthis case developed primal fom personal inorvows that vera ‘ondled with the vin, tha dofecant, and one wlnesees Kanifed through tls Investigation ‘who Were abla fo ihilate an ongoing course of conduct and mlstresimant rlaliva a ta defendant's {interactions with female cout patefpan, and wi futhor cartoborate the viens allegations -CONTINUED- i (601 4RUSSO, BENG DULY SWORN ACCORDING TO THELAN, a ‘THerAcrs ger Foren THe FoEGNG AFFIDAVIT ARE TRUE AND CORRES] 70, NONLEDGE, FORMATION aN ELE, ron GA TIAT Seem to monndeutactbedbelve mains TE depot bse Lape yearn exes Senier Mag’ Sedge “ROPE ATT Rav O78 Poae toah POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT AFFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE DOT [ORM PUTNEY cea [ee eae Dette: [BE FA i AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION ‘On G9/04/t5 st 1933 hous, your lent conducted an interview vith he vel HL, a the PSP York Staton. B.C. rlste tat she fet not MIDS JOY on 02/18/16 et istet Court 10-3-04 vila sho Wes Under subpoena as a Vetimhuiness for tho Commonwoeth for etiminal eae involving hot boyfiend V. MATTHEWS, who was tho cage defandant. In a epolisted ploa agrecmont, MATTHEWS plead gully lo to summary Hla-Traffe violation for Disorderly Conduct end Harassment, In exchiarga the misdemeanor charga ef Simple Aeauit vas withdraim. Aa ares of ‘bo ples, Diskiet Court 163-04 maintain contol of his caso because MATTHEWS ovied JOY'S ‘our In excess of $1,000 in fines and costs, Although the MATHEWS caso was adjcleated, ha Femained in the custody of York County Prigen Indefnitly dota a prctationvilalon and Was ‘allring la galn approval forthe wererelease program. untpraceedng descifed above, M.. sal she approached JOY and reported an suspicionthat cit abuee vis eccuning in an adjoining apartment MLC. fnfrmed JOY ould heat thezbuse curing threugh tha wale of her apavtmant. JOY provided her wih his business eard and edvised MLC. to catac hr eh heard ening elsa. MC. rlatod that duting tho afterncon howe of 02! (ator the above rlerenced pretiminany hnosring concluded), JOY drove his poreoral vehlle tothe speriments located at 28 Wale: Steet and ‘eneounred MC, oulste, Al frst, MC. eald she diet recogniza JOY unis lente himeelf es “udge Joy" H.C. sald she and JOY conversed bisy and he asked ML. ihe ead coms inside her ‘spatimentt talk, Once H.C. alowed JOY insido, sho cuggosted having her next doot neighbor ‘cone over fo that tha neighbor eld provo adiloral formation regarding the eid elxise male, SOY told MC. thal he dnt went enyans ta know he was ther bocauea ha as etlerpling to confi NG’ eater repot that tha alleged child abuse could ba Herd from Insists walls of her ‘paris. Busing this encounter, MC, relaod bath ehe and JOY dd infact hear yalingthrugh ti Walls by an ett from the davmsiake apartmont in quostion. According ta N.C. JOY stayed athe ‘partment for spproximataly 20-50 minutes, Por fo JOY leaving, MC. eald JOY asked Nerf cha Needed any many for rel or food. He alse aakad abou her wetkout routine end commented lat ‘ha had a rice body. JOY hugged MC. and tld hor to cal him she needed anything or heard ‘enyting farther, MG. relted in hr talement tha sha fll unceenfrtable wth this encounter seein fr “CONTINUED. bsibag 1 nial” ore Ce Ponoko,oy POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT "ABFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE Ea [Op Tne BE aie Botnet tere | ey ia sor AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION 1.6. then reported that on 03/0415 at 1454 hour, sho rocalved « phone eal fem the Diatit Court 40-3.04 office number. MC. anavired this phone call, which was placed by JOY. Tha cal laelod 8 minutes. JOY Inially ackiset! MC. thal sie needed ta provide a formal etatement tothe Southern Regional Pole fpatment regarding the aleged child abuso caso, The conversation then dovetoped info JOY exking abcut M.C.S fnancos ard wellbeing. She hited she wes struggling ae rane fe nar pat ooh JOY thon aed iad any avo ral. 8. sponded atfimativey, and sald JOY asked Iie could etap by ater and buy a palning to help her ‘out financially. MMC. apread a this roquse (01 0/04/15 at approximately 1645-1839 hours, M4, eald JOY arived at her apartment. She ‘towed him inside and bogan showing him ha aor. B.C. Inleald that JOY asked for ‘epostodly che had any colt pote thal csplayed her tlions, Sho tld JOY sha eel no, bu sl ‘hed custom pin-up drawings thal resemble her. MLC. than showed JOY ena of te custom pin- ‘pa that were ox her comptier. Ths pater pnp ql was posed In epaualy suggestive pestion ‘whe wearing a pal aftteckings, which became tha opie ef eenvarsaton. MC. indicated that she had a sina pair of eockings and said thal JOY asked fart put tiem en. ALC, telaed she inal ‘eld no fo tis request, bul began to foa that f she upeet JOY, tic hor boyfrend could face ‘ationa!purishentfor his eiminal eases. MC. then walkod lo her bedroom ta change and coved the bedroom door. MLC. sald hal JOY walkad back to het bedroom inimvlled, onan the door ed ‘ontored her bedroom wile she was paling the stockings up waring enly underwear anda shit. N.C, said sho panicked and reached int her close! a find ecthos fo eave rel he ald JOY. ‘approrched hor and groped hor bask and breacl and than offered het “S150 Ufo take off hor hi e0 that he enuld sea her tatoos wiloutccthing. M.C. sald ehe reused, but advised that JOY pulled up her shirt anyway and Ikea! her breasts. H.C. reported that he deserlad see contact ‘curod vihout her permission or eansent. MC. gaid she ran out of tha rom and opened ta front ‘oor for JOY to eave. immediately folowing tie sexual encounter, ee reported whal ect to her rex doer nefgber anc mad a prompt complaint to PSP the samo evening -CONTINUED- ROPCATTE Rov OTHPOLIGE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT ‘AFFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE ose] ma B rosin i Tie Tr Detordictteres [EE Sc sor AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION (On 03/05/15 at 1057 hour, | intervie! JOY relalve to this invortigallon Ha eo fis met MLC, through Distt Court proceedings and acknowisdged that ho traveled to MG's apartment on (2/1016 and OOM, confirming M.C'e statement witha alatica degre of eonsstencyrogning thelr parsonel and phene interactions, Howovor, when JOY was questioned about the clea event ‘egarding en alleged sexual encounter wilh HC., he Was evasive and decepiva. Ae evidence, JOY Frovided threo front vereions ef tha seine even. In is fst statomant dealing the encotniey, ‘JOY said ho drove to #.C.'8 epariment on 03/04/16 and anid between 1015-1030 hatte. Gold M.G, elowod him inside and began shckng hin some ofthe plelures hat sha had in her apart. GY noted that H.C. yas wring stockings when he et eaW her. JOY eald he wai inereted ih ‘ny of ta pilus inital shor to him becausa thay were strange ard gothic in lye, Ne said MC. ‘fated to do custom wen fr hm, and thoy eventually etait foaking at apes on KC's phone of forte wearing sleckings Wi in a cexualysuggentva poston, JOY tad they sated lang ‘beat those parfcularetockings, but saldit was actualy MI. win offer to pil ona esr pair {OY Indicated that MC. went bak nia har bedroom fa change. Hl ead they confined ta tlk wha ‘MLC. wes in her bedrocm sid he was in another roer, JOY tll slated that MLC. ead him hack ‘thay dating thal she raquested him to cama back ta the bedroom. He sakd he walked back to fa bedroom and saw that MLC. now had mdflewnt pa of stockings on and thet she wes Westing ‘only undenvear and a hit. JOY contended thal MC. took her elit of Voluntary asta stoed Usera {coking at her. He said ho thought to hime, "his ent good" yo en ho alayed fara couple mara ‘nines, Ho conehuded by stating tha, "I wish I woud have Went, Lats putt thal voy, bl ntling Nnoppaned No crime was commited. should aven hava gotten volved and been hese” {Upon questioning JOY furer, he proved a second vorsion of events that ifr to hi ial account, JOY relate tha ho Was elming In Une eamputar room conversing wilh MLC, ve she as changing In har bedroom. This time he seit ha was having trouba haaring her, coe docked fo wale back fo the bodom (he mada no mention thal MLC, asked him fo coms back duing tls versie). ~JOY sald tho doer es apen, and ubserved MLC, pling stockings an wile Weatlig only undewese ‘and a black: ee shift, JOY sald MLC. then pal ona pol ef short shode® and modaled tha a ile bk ‘Ali hal, JOY sald 4.0, too her shi off ithout balng promplod and he observed her tote nada from the Waist up. |then esked JOY ithe had any convarsation wll N.C. a hat point. He sald he asked MC.,“lcay to louct7” JOY sald MLC. respondod by saying “Okay * JOY than acme tna ho reached ovar and touched M.C/s exposed broaet. JOY opel told tne that he read his wa3 Wrong, end thal he neaded to leave. JOY acl f fofWwltyn a mati ef minutes gy lated that ‘MG, thasked him on his way cut, AS & noe, later tn ls ntrview wiven the Isla ear reve, JOY eat M.C's response ta his question of "Okay to touch was gAbysNO -CONTINUED- ‘ we RoR ae ev 070ee POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT AFFIDAVIT CONTAWUATION PAGE [Bast aes [pane — Ore ee i inant Tae a Tae Deoetaatiae: [SE = Fy AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION ‘thon asked JOY i anything elee happened between him and MAC, Ha responded think thel was |X Aller Informing JOY that MLC. vas taken to York Hospial whore kody swab were collected for DNA, 1 askod hii he would be abe to explain iif his salva cr DIVA was fund! on har chest or ‘body In rospanse ta tts question, JOY thea provided a thie vereion ef events and stated,“ may hnavo Kssod her breast” JOY inelsed thal this was tha extent of th piysleal comact ha hv N.C. He boli the encounter ta Le eoneensual, and slated ha as not al he epariment i 8 Judicial capac, but admitted that he shouldnt sve gotten knvalved or been [ta M.C's partner JOY niso refuted 19's elaim that he offered her $180 dota to romava her clothing. > explained {hat ho only hed a fowydatiars on itn, ever thaugh is hill reagonlng for ny he went Lo MCG. ‘apartment was epectically fa prchage autveck thle he fancal eduaton. Furhermere, JOY stated that th abors deseibed encounters with MC. yore the only seca ‘where he made personal vss @ cout palpant al Ilr fame. This enewer was att dalarmined to be aie after your afin interviewed an adul feral Mlontifad ae "RD (DOL: 1222880), 2D ‘advisod that she has been in Judge JOY'S court asa dofendant en eaveral accatlens, and enly know him from in-cour sppoaraices, She recalled 2013 heating where JOY lokd her sho wes “loo prety" tobe in his court for ehig charges end eald JOY referred ta hor ae being prey mara than once {ang the hearing. Afar this heating, LD, esld JOY mada tm o vee personal vs la her ‘sparimont. She acid JCY somiaimes stayed at hor apatmen for 12 hours. RD. sald sho st fad activa cases fh JOY'S court atthe tne ofthese personal Vs vere ela eve fines. During Ha ‘personal visits fo her heme, R.D. said JOY would ask how ehe was doing financially and provided hor ‘and her mothe Informalin regaiding local ervces thal could acest them. thought twas ‘unusual fora 1.010 vila court defendant al til apartment, esetally when she hed active ‘sea, ordeal tha the Information ha provided to her was something thal could have been dons In ‘court. PLD. also descibed a convoreaton thal eccured at het fmme Whats JOY offered la take her ‘end her mother cul fo Red Lobster if ehe slayed out of rouble. She call JOY called her cel phono ‘on more than one eccaiens to chack on herwel-baing an to aca If she needad anda for seu appearances er conmunty sence. MD. cald JOY nover made ety exual advancea towards het, ‘but added that her mother was aiays present ortho eccasions wien JOY came to er epariman, RD. descived JOY as being “overly earl." Sha thought Iwas une a eld Ios ie much fora Judge tobe tit cencerned for her wel-being, “CONTINUED. Lotti, ‘ROPSATG Rev OHO PaesPOLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT AFFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE oe carci a me] fier Hise =—— we Detentanttes | ey ee Fl AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION Investigators from tha Jucelal Conduct Board mat wih ane ferme Kensfed as "6.0." (O0B: 11/5/02), GO. also repeited that sha only knew JOY by eppoating bofore Kim cout, |i har etatoment, 6.0, indeated that eha appeared bafore JOY on tea eeparalo occasions beginning in 2014, anddescribed a series of unusual and Inappropiata behavior end commen ‘mai by JOY tovards eral slemuning from In-court appearances. Aceording ta G.O,, ding a tallic bolation heating JOY said to het in open cout, "This officer did you favor becauoe you rw pal i" .0. said she fll uncomfortable since Its ont tha judg, the eer, and GO. i tho ourtroom. Than, en Jawary 6°, 2018, G0. en sho and JOY Were aiano fogelhar In te couttoom District Gourt 1-3-0 whon JOY made Inappropriate eaxus| carmen ta her alta earclisan of. a hata tended ta ese fe poy sue GO. sal thal ho we clad fthabarch JOY, and ho asked ferif sho wios drugs. G.O. ld he dd tat se drugs end havly Wiske, JOY then asked 6 O. che smokes, 6.0, reeponded affimatvoly, bul eal ho wished sho da JOY thon teplie, "You ca that they eay abaut gis that emake?” G.0. rope) No" JOY aald, “hay ie tings In thelr meats, ds you ke things h yeur mouth?" G.O. ropertel she was taken shack by hal JOY just said to her ond repo Hka candy" JOY than eal "ls that alf"G.O. ales acid JOY omionled about how they would hava fun they altanded a pry together, bul eum thal sho ‘cud not remersber tha exact words bacatto sho vas upset and wanted ta leava. .0. slated the ‘was ao “disgusted and fustered” thal she asked I sia yas excel and let the couteam, Duaing tho sforereniored intorviow with JOY, Ni ad alsa stalod that fe referred the allgod cid suse incident (9 Detecve SHAFER af the Southern Roglonal Police Department and to Cline on (92/20/16. JOY incised that approximately ono weak later (02/26/15). he Was helio thal Yor Coury Children Youth ene Famlies investigated and closed the eld abuso invoctiglion dus lo 2 lack of disclosure by both tha visi and alleged perp {nan eet to coat JOY'S account of his rpert a ay enforcement, your aan conducted Interviews wh Detective Witiam SHAFER and Officer Michael STOREMAN of the Eaulhem Regional Police Deparinent. Both Deleciva SHAFER and Offcer STOREMAN reeal JOY making a {ocilest for investiglionto their agoncy regarng en elaged cid staso ease on or about O26 However the ofcars were never nollid By JOY thal he went fo MG's eparimem and onelcied an ‘vestigation, ond JOY noverrepoted his cbservations tat ha evetheard ying and comms the downstals spartmort on O2/10/1. tinal dr ceed tin i che nn eg wer nosy tne ‘oy Gate sent ete’ ftp asta et tte ‘ee Yat oh ease soe cmdencaaache poe SS eceg che cee hae ne ‘eRe etcoet reece heel pers en, ag see onEXHIBIT “B”faa 12 1005 12:24 mag ha POLICE CRIMINAL. COMPLAINT [ COMMONWEALTITOF PEINSYLVAWA ——] Eahitonveat OF PEMA SouNTV OF. YORK ‘en against 19351 as ‘MOE Rare Hon. sahiozees ig scart “or “— [RED LION, PA 1 fate antes Farris #38, 4TH ST. ce rauans esi RSG ra TERT eramyrercecwtenboen — Pbilaienenartotuentn dee J siarweer Pea den em [aaa ——— sri see ans amg oor ST ame rat Paso sen |asa cats haioo0 goons men fa ar Tare os [race [ora Dan Tra Chien cera Dhuscine aaa? — Efe eee a7 pam aacon fe aay Fama ere aa, -~ firanem [ewan sa ote) Elotmes Fleocaiiaan Hgmtoey Elcsua my rca “Chere IRS (ies ae aren Five) Ewes __CHraeag” ana See I TRTTERT [sa PA [rst OTST Tei a WEoHT a) et jess [one rns aa] TT on FE Cee + [a cop cn aot te [na [grein separ) | Coe CA BR NSE Coe a a f fa rar aa i ar a | I EF I 8 tie Sanaa Naeeed eaaeaa a oe ghte | RMON eg anusso SER smnmesment tune neg ten ‘RE sae: ppt 11 teem tne ae cn ete om 1 Ince te dnt wos rane etn lara bans asses, 1 Inset dotnet hese re nd pp deayrstn ora nincun ome sn te reo etd Dea sa Don winds ta esta ote Commemonine reset a 2)... ARERR eee BORD, fn yo cxety Ehyeny HI LR, OPC 4428 Rew. 1246 Pogo tol 5.og. 12, 2015 125240 : wD BG 885 pouice crmmmar comprar Saas — Sanger s Caspr aie ROS | shai TST 3 iat xerdmttice | BE i ie ‘Tho acts commit by tho accused are descrbed below vith occ Act of Adsembly or lau allege vat, aekioetieee mira Mner eases aoe alenge gh fens shou {mule la ai a ee ee th ‘es ett wots Pe a nna irae C= ar Tae a fe | __4 Jaror Joey | sme |ruera encnencese [1a aa Od Seer eee Fase ‘esa RESP eR FeooT oar Te (eet rar Clini Cewa ree wean Stale Deserption (neha ba came of alco or ordnance) Bribery In offltal ae! potcl altos. Acs cttho accused assacatd wit thie Ofeneee ln that on or about eal date, THE DEFENDANT cffwed, canforrod or agreed fo const upon ancther, or Ialicod,accoptel or agreed te accent trom anoter any bene ae consteralion forthe declson, vets, ae or olber exer of ofa sceonby the recent na juice, ennstrallve at elleve ing edn. To vit: THE DEFENDANT, a Naglstria Dist Judge in ax Coun, Pernalvanin,olered 0 Na cu ies oreo vin AF a, (DOE: 172075) eachange orth Vt del ee ig lthing ater rcldenca per p= Ee Taner i) Ser] favor Joa | sae [te 18 Paci cote ran tae fr Clean 2o Chmatzo ‘Sialute Description (cide the name of ala or ordanca) Brive in oil and pollcal mattore, [Acs of he accused assocsle with his Ofonse sina, on of about said date, THEE DEFENDANT cflered, eonfered er aged to canter upon ence, oF allcted, excepted or agreed toeczop fram anor any benolt ws caisorain for a vllion of «Know leal {fy aa pute servant cr pat cil To wit THE DEFENGANT, e Magee leet Judge tn York Cound, fPernsyvanla,otlered to vata al court es for adult feral vin & P.M. (DOO: 10/20/75) in ekcharga tthe [tin “medaling ems of Inge dling at har reatonca, ‘ROPE A128-~Rov. Aa" Pogo 2 ofS.Ang 12100) 1248 my 4 485 pouice crImNAL coMPLANT or its To gin vwteentene [8 cy wage a ‘Tho acta come by te assed are describe bolow wth onch Ac ct Assembly or solo alegeay ood Rare nee a one tt, ee ed oR sacmnn ‘ernment tnt an nun pe wart agonatvateenteson enh Sitausnannayenaa fends Feet Poe at acannon Pe ra aT [aa Ta loner ata sae En 4g fir] a fos | jew, Pacumeceae [+ Juz 210 Sook fete Bia Puente Corte NST ven erate ot Diets 2 waza Salute Bosarllen (ncude We namo of dati or ordnance) loffetal Oppression Acs ofthe accused assoclaed wit is fone IN-THAT, n or about ead dato, THE DEFENDANT actod or purarod to ac in an ofl capo or took faantage of auch eatal or prpertel capzely knowing hat his cont waa Moga by ublecing sneer eat, eteilon, search, seizure, misrealment, cisnosgescion assessment sn of cfher ingame of personal oc property iis in olen of Geen 6204 (1) of fia PA Crimes Code. To Wit THE DEFENDANT dd fake advantage ofhis ofa capecly aa a MagitaalDistct Judge of York County, Pannyivania by lang fant rights of ne icin (ond us aul formala APM. (DGB: 12076) by demand hat tha vin “nade cms of gets ching et he rsidence in exchange fr vacating ha oulslandng lines and cos! a "asa Fates Toni g. Sir | 4 Jere |r | we [rate rrcimencnde | fas su Omeet__ fein Same Pea nit dow Finer Son woes, Noe feed Caz Corea State Dewarlon(nchide Wo rama of elataa reninan) Horassmant Ads of tho pcsused associa wih is Ofonse: IN-THAT, on er about ald dale, THE DEFENDANT, with tonto hares, armoy o alae anchor pert, fnarely an adult female ict denied as A P.M, cd eatrusicata to e about such ator person any ew, fascvious, threatening or obscane wards, language, drawinge or catoaes, in thal THE DEFENDANT dt [4emana tha the vim mee toms of finger ot or asohious purposes wer ofleing to vacale her lautstanaing fis aw ene, Invlllon of Soon 2700(2)4) ofthe PA Cres Cade, OPC AIDA —Rav. 216 Pogo Sot.fog 12 2015 12240 wy BS 485 Pouce crmvat. compLamT ‘Complainant amber Te Dob | Ts figure Fi leat atrdetttame | Fay tg ‘The acts come by ho acatced ar descibod below wth each Act of Asaombiy or slat alogedy Vato, ‘Rbemoetitg When here aa tan one ateree, eer olenee shea enum SrA ewe ‘eration ccspantenetoniitantmog ornate ecsiotans nrsere t rear ar = a Fla [5 [ara lox [sss Tretaencimcae | _|us 20 Cant tai ets Pa he NSS Sea roa a evs od Elites Daw Clwwrzon State Descrpton frets Ra narra of sit or ednancoy Haragsimant ets che accvoed eases wi ve Oe |N-THAT, on of about ald date, THE DEFENDANT, wih nent fo harass, anny or als anon poreen, adult femal simi dened as APM, dl tert ropoatcy communica tothe vt, lll af Secton 27067) of tie PA Crimes Cove To Wi: Aer THE DEFENDANT eps a ho vt ome unlvied on 12/04/0 and eoiced ha o model nga ting, ha cantncod ths vim by phone multe fenos after 12/01/15 and lf 23 volcerall maasages. Tae Ineiional, repeated aca of conmtnteaion shrrac| jive vic to tha degre tat whe weed her Babystlr thet che was fear THE DEFENDANT wae “etalknghar* aw hen in her how AOPC A12A— Rev. 4244 Pegotl ot S28 POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT ase ee none Seng ner artentntitone | ey ee iss 2. ask that a warrant of ast ora summons be issued and thatthe daferdont be required to answer the charges Ihave made. 3. venly that the facts set torthin his complain are ttue and care tothe est of my knowledge oF Information and belt This veifcalfon Is madi subject tothe penalties of Section 4904 of the Crimes Code (18 Pa.€.8.54904) relating to unswor flsfication te authrites 4, This complaint consits ol the preceding page(s) numbered 4 through § ‘The acts committed by the accused, as listed and horeatter, were against the peace and dgnty of tha Gommenwealth of Pennsyvania and were conrary to tho Act() ef tha Assembly, orin volalon of the atalules cited (Bofore a warrant of arrest can be Issued, an affidavit of probable cause pyust be comploted, sworn to before the Issuing authority, and attached.) gui, 2015 ‘AND NOW, on this date, __B >.) thatthe compisint has been propery Ccampleted and verted. An afidait of probalje cause musi be completed before a warrant can be Issued, 1 Salve Magistetal. Todge seat ‘AOPC 412A Rov. 1244 Pape ot SAue 12 20)5 12-240 Fe Hai RT ue POLICE GRIMINAL COMPLAINT i SE haar ‘eau Tat ae Tae Jwtetetnene: [Frey aes ae AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE ‘Your affant I a Ponnaytvana Stato Troopor curonly esstoned tothe Criminal Investigation Unit, “Troop H York Staion. Ihave been a member ofthe Pennajvana Stata Police elnce Decamber of 2006 and have been inthe Crininal Investigation Unl since October of 2014, tn thal time | havo Conductad nurerous eexual agsaull investigations that have resulted in successful prasecton ‘Addlionally, have investigated major and coraploxInedenta inching homictdes, polos involved shootings, other Violet ctines euch as allempted hamickos and rabberies, and fisanetal rime, (0n 99/04/15, The Pennsylvania Stale Police ilated on investigation into allegations thatthe defendant, MagicoralDietctJudgo Jefray Scot JOY of Distt Court 10-3-04, sarualy assaulted sn adull female court partdpant atthe female victim's homo. As a recut of tho Invastigation, criminal cargos of indecent Assaut, Oficial Oppression, and Harassment were filed agalnst the defondant ‘00 08/07/15, Tho Offee of Mtornoy Goneral and the Persiylvania State Polos disseminated publle Information releases containing the besle facts of tha ease, and ths Information was made evalable {o tho public by local media oles, (On Monday 08/10/15 at approximately 1620 hours, your aftant was walking through the station paring lt affer completing my assigned shit. At is tno, [observed a femala parked in a white four-door stato wagon in fro visors park area. | nalced thatthe femala appeared netlceably ‘anxious and nervous. | approached the female end asked her If she needed assetance. Tho fomalo, {ater dented es “A P.M" (DOB: 10/25/78) by way of her PA dive’ license, asked If | was a pole officer and stale thal she needed to epeak with somaona regarding Magisterial Dist Judges ‘eley JOY. Afler explaining to AP.M that Iwas the investigator assigned to tha JOY case, sho providod a statemant fo ma regaiding encounters ehe had with Judge JOY that were sar to what ‘sho road about nthe nave, -CONTINUED- TPR, JONATHAN GOLARUSSO, BEING DULY SWRI ACCORDING TO THELAW, DFPOSE AND SAY THAT ‘THE FATS SET FORTH N THe FOREGOING AFFIDAVIT ARE TRUG AND CORRECT NOWLENGE, INFORMATION AND RELIER. ‘Cooma Mogi Dr ute Sue magrrtenne Todge | on Pome tanfaa 12, 1005 12:258 k eM Bg POLICE CRIMINAL COMPLAINT AEEIDAVT CONTINUATION PAGE Pee" tans ee Triettiane | Bpey ie AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION ‘APM relaled thal she was charged with misdemeanor Simple Aseauit and aurmmary Haraserent In September of 2014 stemming from a domestic diepuie wilh er boytiond. She later appeared before ‘Magisterial District Judge JOY and pleaded gully fo summary Hataseinent. AP.M, cal sho wae ‘rdored to pay fines and costs as te reault of he gully ploa. She alao Indicated that her bafrend llved at an out-of-stot addees, wich is information that would hava bon known fo JOY. APM Indieated she was employed as an aduit dancer ata business Inz neighboring county at that time. ‘A.P.M. thon sald that in December of 2014, eho traveled back to Dll Court 19-9-04 fo request restucturng of her fine payment plan. She sald sho went before JOY who granted her request and ‘engaged fen conversatin about har children. Part of the conversation included JOY Ingukng as the whether her son would be inforaetad In otning local youth basketball program. JOY alsa Ingucod 2s to her employment ‘Aer the fine payment heating (do‘ormind from AOPC cout rer tobe 12044), APM, ead ‘he rolured home, That ering, APM adisod that JOY showed up by himself ther hor in ‘rewsbury Borough, YoukCounty, She eal thal her son and daughter were prosent tis ie, and that her daughfstangwored the fran! door an allwed JOY ino te foyer area. AP. sald she ‘was shceked thatthe Judge cama to her home an sald sha neva nite the Judge ta hor havo or previo him with er conc information for personal us. Sha belived that JOY used the Information contalna in hr cout pap sworktoobtln ho: adroas an phon number. APM. sid sha and JOY inal began conversing about her son's htrost I folhing youth basketball lao, tic sha ier eoved Was his "guise for caing fo her home, APM. Wan leed that JOY an ‘s0ked if sha sf had her court paperwod avaible. AP.M, sald ee tld JOY her documents vee a tha kizhen, Thay waked ino the Klcen where JOY reviawed her papesvork. APM. ten slated thal JOY then ofered to vaca hr cout ines end expunge her etinal ecard provided she wou “made ems of tng clahing of tha fypo sho ware fr exo dancing far hi, AP. tle washer bol ha his was auld pro quo yp ofr. AP.M, sald she refused, and ended JOY fhathar con woro neaty. Sha said JOY ft chorly aftr. -CONTINUED. se antog PeoMag 12. 2015 122258 Wig bo POLICE GRIMINAL COMPLAINT Fe aes le Deienitine [ney = = AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION APM. provided PSP witha signed won tatomont detaing her knowledge of this incident. A.M futher corroborated her statement when sha showed PSP an email cacord she sent town ‘oqualntance dated 12/01/14. Inthe body ofthe emai AP.M. describes her unusual and Inappropriate encounter wih Judoa JOY trom earlier inthe dey and asked (or advice, ‘APM. cold that after tha wove deseribed encounter vith JOY, sho began receiving numerous Done calls ta her coll phore from blacked numbers, and belleved twas tha JOY calling, A.P.M. ck she was afrald to answer phona calls from unknawn numbers because of the previously desea encounter, and sak! she di not want fo continue any typo of communication With JOY, APM, sald JOY also ft har a least 23 volcernall messages baleen 12/01/14 ~ 12/09/14, n each mossago, ‘sho ald JOY agahninqulod ebout her son folning youth basketbal, APLM. eald that at last one of the phone calls mada by JOY were from his home phone, APM. provided PSP wih her phone records which reveal that aphono call was placod fom a 10 dig number your affiant knows to bo Constant with the home phone numberof vefrey JOY. The ammunition log was dated 1210244 at4ett PU, ‘APM. father ported that she went cul of own on 12/08/14, Sho said she explant her ciiren’s babysior, Kontiled as acu foals BL, (DOB: 1124768) to bouaro of tho Judge or her court case. AP-M.snidaho tod her babysitar sh though! JOY wes saleg her and expand the basie dois of her enenunera wh JOY. APM gid shaded tha bebysier not fo answor tha dcr oF slow JOY to enirif he shoved up lth house. APL. adied thal oy 12/04 et _pproximaaly 1610 hours, JOY showed up at har house while sho wae ot of tov, AP-M. reported {iat she was actully peaking n tho phone wills BIL. wen JOY ave. Sho gael B.LF. ordered 410Y cif he premises and thal sho look a col phana image of his blue Chevrolet SUV parked out iron, This imege was proved to PSP 01 09/12/16, your affiant lorlowod BL.F. a the PSP York Staton, babysiting AP.M's chidten on 12009/44, ’M. pleviously explalnod hor ‘encounter with JOY visting the house, and expressed eoncom that JOY might reun. B.LF, sald APM. told hor nolo answer tis door if JOY came fo the house, and advised her not ta allow JOY inside for any reason. B.LF. sald at at approximately 16{0 hours, her atlonllon was drawn to the teat door of ie teskdence alter she heard the door handle belng osled, Sho eald she absorvad a man at the rear door and then A.P.M'c daughtorchoutod, "That the judgel” BLP. sed JOY sald ‘that white JOY was starlig cutee, he stated several times that ho wanted to speak lo AP. son about askotball. BL F.advaed that she told JOY sha rew who he was and ordered hm off ha promises. BLLF. sal JOY thon vaked quichly back to his SUV which wae parked in frontal the house. BLL, sad Uiat JOY remalned patked out infront ofthe house for several minutes, which ‘cared her. She confirmed taking ool phone plture of JOY'S vabele whlch -CONTINUED- ‘estate Page 3. of 4.vg, 12. 1015 12-2500 mM bb POLICE CRIMINAL’ COMPLAINT ‘AFFIDAVIT CONTINUATION PAGE TRS a eT 587A) conde Dandntnane: | racy or BY AFFIDAVIT of PROBABLE CAUSE CONTINUATION (0n 05/05/15 at 1057 hour, | Interdewed JOY relative to an Investigation into the xual assault of an adult female, M.C, JOY said he tral met MLC. through D/stict Court procoadings and acknowledged that ha traveled 10 M.C.'s partment on 02/40/15 end G3I04/15, confining M.C.s etafement with a relative degrae of consistency regarding thelr persone! and pho Interactions. However, whon JOY ‘was questioned about the alleged sexual encounir vith WLC., ho wna evasive and deceptive, Inthe ‘cours ofthis intarview itvas dotomnlned that JOY mada many false or namnelstent statements, In partlculr, JCY tnaleated hs had never gone to the hora ofa vei or defendant, as he had ons ‘wilh MLC, at any pont prior to our interview. The evidence coleced in the cours of tis investigation into JOY’ contact wih AP. incleatas that JOY Ved during his pace interview an Moss. ‘Criminal charges contalnad within tho sttachelciminal complaint were approved by tho Offiga ot Alforiey General which has assumed jutslcton of ths prosecution unr the Commonwealth Allomneys Aol. Your afiantbolves the ebove information esiablshes probable cause forthe chargosllted in he pracating cminalcorlait, and belleves tha Information contalrod within this, docuinent 1 be rue and correct | respectuly request that an arrest warrant be lesued forthe defendant, Jeffry Soott JCY, (ers di ‘NORC «4G Rov. O78 Pagel oYEXHIBIT “C”Magisterial District Judge 19-3-01 Docket Number: -10301-CR.0000342-2015 Criminal Docket} (Conmarmen of Pomeyionie aye fey Sct Jy Pages SS ee ee ou: essness ieee: oworas samnatomae © YaRPEP cana: Samulinnccen —HTza:01 Somat te eon Yee suaote Glan Re Bog Ct ‘winnie Comptes cuurenis—_pwcteg Freier Heng Seid SietTing Raa sete = Seer cuaszots o.00em egos is Jony Contd cles Fray iting owveatte so908m gitre ene ip Join Saha Wf Feat emiamest towns semen hte eS SEPT NATOMAS ve ‘oy ety Sox anaes i uri meinen try ees nthe remit rds cea erm id nt {EeConemnarmtPesapara rat tonraie Cha Paap carer ton rameter teeta eae ‘Saab enna een Expeyes oa ss cp ube arto Hany seca eas ae. ‘connie neybensms een saab ease CantMagisterial District Judge 19-3-01 Docket Number: MJ-18301-CR-0000342.2015 Criminal Docket ‘Conmaneea of Peansiais Jefroy Sea Joy Amacoee Bait ease tone tones Ure ‘commen Sit etn ‘tome Deze Hisgssors6y MB GrtGponesenAve Sea Be Ghousons Feit coat 2iagarceges 2 Inne au Cae OF eee noazons Fetter cat 108272884 3st Cam, Led, Tren Ee ouoacons Fale Caut language 4 ras z7009581 8 Vereen Steet one Pye Const TaDUnS Hallo Coot Men CiseghorA Fore, a, ame, Dil aD, aq ‘Brac: Jy. date Sa smeeeig: Cereal Pema uma Sas: Acre ‘Gaetan: Ave ‘Sunes Got: 05067 ‘SemceCautlo, 206598 examen: eee a1 Prone a: 71776768 ites. 160 E Manet st ‘Masai PAOeatAtomey Geral ven Pa raLs219 tri Fiseaeary mag P70 ect resent ng any mtb rat mtn ene tice ene Heft calntedt ‘ncomnannanye Pershore hamachi Corr eeraron he corset eee ‘ossety nPop SaPan Expyen in etch Pa posanctvn cn nay cna aT POS, Seino sace|meyonajer eneaoay satan a os SoonMagisterial District Judge 19-3-01 SS RE BE STE COO OH 1S @ ‘Docket Number: MJ-19301-CR- 00003422016 Criminal Docket CConmanicln of PemsjianiaMagisterial District Judge 19-3-01 Docket Number: M-18301-CR-0000846.2016 Criminal Docket} ‘Commanweath ef Pomona yeas Jeti Bot oy Fase tet oe Se a Meee Fate. xan feweatciny, Yau ease: Comune HrzAi808 as He eran Cot: Yo ‘Danone: sents Temi Sree Boosh ‘coms, tose lest feraa0is Case Tantered Cau of Conan Pa foriano’s—Campome rtaats—_pyotgPtrwan Hem ‘ime caer ‘sole ase Entries Sauilie Suing sam ete Nene ins Priesry Arai OHRROIS 005m agate itt Ace in secu cea Prion Haney onavo1s stam Noga Omit en Corin Whee Prise Hoang aaz01s s0000m axel ge eos Wate Femal rast toreno1s so0am ‘cds a Ss ueetten: fevianoss vie ‘aces owed A 1348 ‘dt a gta Ray aigeert Came? Pl Deena essa yh Det? ocean Prov Appoiinon Pa ener? atthe etna Boer Fhgora? Eeee fart reenter ty nine ten at tae Hewson Set etoematht Peri Pe nian Che ef ean Cam sae asp te meee al a an ‘Suman ne sonata, Dose nt mons das techn cela a ne ‘ost Persia St Plen Ener in retry wba rasta cna ia ear POEMagisterial District Judge 19-3-01 Docket Number: MJ-18301-CR-0000968-2015 Criminal Docket| Conant of Panna Jotoy Say a ES EG ESSE ATE OTE sniacsentioe Salcimow Balas Pecrtae tons set cara08 Urscaree sooo ‘ame ‘cit Qescmnan ‘Semen Dama, Tioga esa Fa Bboy Boett pow Hod cant amperage Filmy batt ovr Heater Cant asap gs M2 lopped Are ges fe smorzate fate Cost eae gan ROUTE Heiter Coat 1052700 AT Attn Cann Reger Miner ——ESDUROH4 Hl rca cr) Peta Fra mane Fe Scr eres nb utig mney tb yen ct ah ter Peed Se ‘Comer Perna bu bara Ge Pera ny enor aly orbs deed ae oe ‘ann art lon. Cent ron sat nite we cuca aa Separates ume eneyes [escent Pa Ents ot ese wo pet sty Rc men hae Pa ions esjmeybeniea want tay etennn Fas Senttare: Chetener AF, sums. oy, Jefe Seon ce ae Ave men custo: 85057 Pisoni: 17650-160 biagas—OE tomes YouPa treo 1299 uzois mae Docket Number b-19301-CR.0000848.2015 Criminal Docket} ‘Cemmonwosth ef Persyveria an: ari Set OE, mance: Corman Pers Sana Ace ‘Sumemecmio: 20560 fioatins revere amas PAOIEotAtamey Gera 16TH F exaveery 5a eau Pa t20 reas Poneman Fp ‘rican mean i ae Ensen ono eae ww soot heen May Mond ron aE PCS, cinsinaroeniptcndinsye ona SnEXHIBIT “D”‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-cR.0006006-2016 CRIMINAL DOCKET Court case Paces ‘bese Aeon Ch Lan atin oozancis ante e220015 om voner742 1am ‘Geaoxin Dotan Wm cRareoan918 mu carne Jo Fist allemand Fe ‘csi fata Ye Pop ‘gia iar Cron Jenonan ‘combat HO2e691 Deze Serene tpcced ‘urrani8§——puatig Seinen ute ‘rain rel Catone cewvarnis Anam Jy 8018 sng re lotr cn22z015 ——euing Fama Arar ua27015 aula Pity ef rs ‘Guecaedar Scheie Sa BS ‘dome ‘Soe ania ‘Baie Ine ‘ama eigen cro dpe irs Ronn Move Aion toes 19803m Serio seg Laer comets Cane peta ames thanan —Coutoomstt2 Sonar ape Laver seat Cortese te rere ewiozois 10pm Couns? San toe Laver Sth Ceese sre feta cvarz018 13pm Couette Sev ge awe Seite Cm Say Tas! orm Bona ‘Ser utp Lone F cates Gat srbina nmnen gma hn al nar sya et "eerste ec ysCconmornate of Pennyania ‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-cR-0006006-2015 CRIMINAL DOCKET eos ‘Dee cieen ‘oes Sn, New Frese, PA 17368 Pancrase Mare ete se dete Sat ey ay Seat - ais sta: Hone Ldn bo ah Pomme Anim, Buoomsiut Eats et cao! Uneaned $0000 Ee. Oulu, Ouse srs separ gpa iro faovie _Tenerraz 2 sagt yey tee ‘aoiaare Tere =a Wifi sr el Sac Be ‘Samia vena 44 MY 8g 200 gEA—— Hereenrs: Com Lv Tresng, ——TaznIe Teno FRB a7 versa: Com Repay Taal Tae tterCoun dawerCaun) Slants Waa Peer {owe Cau Depston owraros reat Veni Beret eit Cout dane Ce a 2 biby Bott eile Cut ane Cat 5 810M Orpessonda Sec alr Cat Loner Cot me “irosmer- Comm Le, Peseta tr Cot fone Cast ms (muane Sree Conn. Rept ets eit Cout Lone cout ms omer Tnermaon ed toons Notre "eter Bort Promeste Coat a sageorso2 se gaor 500 sageaosst sa gars4 sagzmmstar ssearoiesa femme mat 5st nen my te rc en es ie ss ah ea ene ad pie lite Coreen Pevrae ekmca cne Perahanaoat me yy areca lt Sth acar roms enPee tnt. neraan eeedrattsedn pe ca ieey wagons ceo ‘trbeponsey Pernt is Fe. rere orga a oma coma ten fon aon ys "Morasm acme tenes cue aamamn sv P4.8 SeenCOURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-57-CR.0006008-2015 CRIMINAL DOCKET Court Caso commenaatn cf Panneyierie nf Paces Bea [gee nce epost selnoieldreiatn eT Dron ‘Sasa Ect sess ‘amas, ‘SeuceDemrton ‘en zson aie Secon ‘Seulacen e ‘Seca ‘Gf Te et ‘SetiameDanion Pam ae TREamEeNesoney Fees lata ‘Siri Cznsions 21 tayo reese Coat FL sepamnggas S1omiGpsvain are Seer Ee Promed teat ne eesmigst ‘iMraerer-Conm Lave Teese 6, rosette Cout wo regzmagsag Uerginge Sse Com Ress nate rete Coat mo segzmasar renal Conran ounranie Flies {itr Benet Note Pome Freepers (Gy owen Fo cuz aie Bet Nate Proed a ame Ca Lemons Fe uate {VO Cerone Sa Be Tie Coenen eae (la, Lawrence Je cuaraote ay Cou rtrd Cat Fe Denar geo 100 us conan sence ny Seam way oa Creoar 218 an Repo roberto by eben Petar Temstd When CariFis ai WF start yo oer he core ‘hn 34 rs rein a ore cok ay al La poate “arson: Con: Ld reser BS timate (ra aware Sr irasemt- Conn: Resa Bt wae Feta rasan azn tn aN mie nee eta Nae ent en {Sptencnermenain Renata Aron er ofertas mney hy eee et ‘ayeencvassysePuvsrom Geol Ws toc’ eto ers tpn cern ay ee "ares Actes naam nore Seca‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0008005-2016 CRIMINAL DOCKET Court Case CconeranisotnetPennyieia onnaate Her tue uae} Gere mamecoutic 208888 ‘mee uni Trasrst8 Ohl toma empeca Atos TIresesis Pane) PADI atAesrey Genoa cua Oh tein Skansen 6 oo ons, Pa 17120 CDE Yon Pa tia 219 : tuseno1s sien To Etre Dadi Fer Soin Of Fre Tete Pret ani 1268 FC suc erase ect ng et nye siren els rh ed {nent Grimms lPevmrena cr Aart easa Ont atc ee sy teers aes a rostrata mtyeeott Cosa thos tetanus tonne mpas seme hey tage on iytenmndsr se Pavan Ene ks User oe Ye sets ene Sn Sy Fd ‘HominAciney nga ty orem n WPL Secon EL‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0006006-2016 CRIMINAL DOCKET ‘Court 2 Comet Connon Fess -Yon Coy Hoar ies comaneatn et Perris vavraa4e int Case Fre Cesepor sey sotey St Yerceuy Coun Atineratin curt Col Comme Peas oh Coy exeatese ProanTtaD orb a Cun Coat amnaetin Fea Cher A. ‘rk Coty Cot amneaten ‘urvzni Pcie oy, Joey S| a Coury Coat amineten etc ‘er -SeeonavPnaty nena China ay Ti Caen cw2anoseDocket Number: CP-67-CR-0006008-2015, CRIMINAL DOCKET Court case Conant of Peanyiania ‘ ososz016 ‘arnevotEanet Annan 1 oszazaie caste Caren ets Yak Cay 4 sonra era cesar A Matin atest Cantina Pb 1 cooune (i, Lene ‘elesrt wal mal be paced on eax onto crn or ane larder Seaton, Oekrdel 6 Klow te (ene cata pon, oe a ‘rz room ye Sat sesce PoymertPuntisy Beeet cae moxie Paco mst nun stn omen Presa vnunet ar ry Pace ed Sy paisa tavsara Seek. epee oon at me hn a Rad ‘horona hina) basiort si tnuyavemteninWPoes ScnsGbLtT OF COMMEN PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number -57-CR 20080062015 CRIMINAL DOCKET ‘Court Case Paserats street te etd UP oy deo sett tommmenl Eames Adin en Money a etna amet ma Ho 000 000 a) Being Cntr Fe Yah 0000 00 fou 00 soon ‘Gomori Cest- hz hate? sons sat oro si sans ore (eat Pasion CEA ssa eo 00 er) ear Cot Con et 2040 1978) m0 eo oo m0 mao (im Vie Carport eS 3500 no ‘00 re) ) ‘ares Vee Compara ie siast 0 000 sm seas aerses) Fieam Editon Tang Fd sso 20 000 somo 800 ae au 00 000 sow tas ‘asad Comper Pe 00 ow 000 foro tno ‘te Coat Coat 2046172) stor 000 foo oma ‘is Wee ere et 11 fm) eon wooo son fo 2500 ‘Ataien Fee Ye) ‘00 0 so fom san Garey Paro) sae0 00 on ow syeasn DA Medeeanar (ak) 1800 0 som som ts00 ose Co S240 000 om fom st2a0 ‘She Madera ra 200 om 000 om sean eral Aneut te are s70 fom uo m0 sa00 vers aa Vette Aout be aed 00 oo 20 sm eato0 crews a Promos Fg Fe) 500 0 00 to sss00 ‘contzve cos ron) 738 om 00 oo ras (CantticEdetin Tring Ae $500 oo 00 om ss00 conarenn Tet: sors om no som snore Comes Cot te 1.9000 000 00 00 siemc0 Eyam lve rma Reinecke nt art Ges rey ty nec es [Sh teravdsy Poms eek Use ecb Yes entrar levee Re "Wares teed oat nyu cme Pts tesa‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORI iK COUNTY Docket Number: CP67-0R-0006005-2015, CRIMINAL DOCKET Court Case Corman rojocts Jey Seo Joy Gemetonke ash ‘soos 000 soos saso7s tant anemeri regsted fect ena tn toy ce een tect a in ofr es Incraion Aimy tonneau bearyen solemn whe S Senate.‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0006007-2018 CRIMINAL DOCKET Court case tei onamcis uate ONCTENNS tom ‘Giana tetas Mtn cRareesRIs ‘Buliadcadumatie seo Fan sate ter Clana Joana, ‘Shan Localtueto io Jcgnent- Falconer nor Srenoucesa om onset Ose esis Cheat ‘Suueue Eom Bus ‘Comanioas C8078 ‘AzTante Sentence oe warts nmin Serer unite paatng Pea Cafes evrozis pein ay Te ‘52015 ing ral Coren uzunts——_vmng Formal rier founzn01s ating Fig hot Sustemis ——sScimula Sade ‘sneriane ‘Saas Gerlioe antes Ie aa ‘rage ovens 8a se spe ears Reon ove oom st Aeignnert fors0015 19003 Seto Laer conte Pret {2080015 14e0n —caunaemest® Sener dg Lana shea Pret 2016 13pm caunemonte Sener pe anes F Seems Cire an fete uza701G +3pm —CauoomS008 Serer utp Lane eho ‘coil say ToT eoDan Slr ug Lene Crate Cees scream rates ig try nt my tad nen ann Nah cs eda {emit Common eRe ann te et etsy carats rare et Sierntsoriuae opto, Cot nats despa eg ace oes cron Intratzessnatensheiosbatyarontonte trees Car e3‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Numbor: CP-67-CR.0006007-2015, ‘CRIMINAL DOCKET ‘court Case CCommonusetn el Pernyveria Paoe2eto sa coviazo1s Urseares 2000000 Se Gonten inte Sas ‘Baudet ‘seme On Te ag non gy (Oper est earn 2 cnowzms resets Baga pate 0 Coober aussi Tene 3 SWS sgn gene nana Comm Ld, Treen, —OUDNDIS —TELEES Hoiatorcowt ower Cour) Oetendnt nares 170m Operon he Sas Et el toe Cut) na ngs 2rnge fe 0 Com 1a at Coa Lower Ca) me wegaiaessan ‘Pzaamert-Conn Lo Tose, Ee, et Cour ewe Cast Ma segarnstad targane {Ar ieraemert ijt Cert Pn Cet, et Cu Lene Caut 5 wgaressas Inmsn ind sooan0s Netra 11 Oppeaon JaeSereh Ee Procedts Coot ME sagssonssy 2 rec ea 00 Cone O! Ce Procter M2 tesaregear 2 armament: Conm Ld Ting Ek Prceodts Cot wa wegzrogsaa cers rains gy ete med ead ne ines a snd eda | roe ite Grommet Praja kann Ota reheat ony beer ood 1 wrt oon on wom Ease emanate ciety Meagan ‘vse mouezoyteanaen Ee Poor Woe enema ar "rem Anat ie sr tyIN PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0006007-2015 CRIMINAL DOCKET ‘Court Case CConersmeathf Pen Taliesin Puseaato | ersamer. jet Overt Py Comat Promesta coat 8 wegen Pret Cores currents FslOmeston 170m Cpe Ae Ssh ato Comanen mo ingeoiast (isk. LawreeFJ cuarnie ay Cat es Cot Ft Deer gerom 100 ois onary serie to see ey Shou wae nec 2 ‘Ponaioare Temiaa nen ossrine Fad Ful et em te oncaerteronce ion pring Pastan feud Sm prs unr 24s tre on fe adore eck or actA ea eer 7 Tite A Cans Ger Taleo aA i tae F ours “ST ieamert Cor Lee Teg TateFroeee ween Ce aaa Ft oxarts a Spc Oar Pal Ca Tite Pred S wsnmaaT rr ova (Parr onan 045-185 501 )-Pin Conant (Cegrehonems-2015-5e4 1. 3%0 01 $5 Pain rnsscntae rut uals ncn costs ee coinsn ernst ‘Svsnnanrb 2 Pepin St fee Mawson enna a natovey re puna ei ay Fr Inset ama bapa sabiystoelonih WPA CaenCOURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0006007-2015, CRIMINAL DOCKET Court Care Corman Fenian Proesars Jetey Sex Soy rey Cant name courns 2830 TIEN Gene m stan Tiras PAC! Are Geert oseesses tain rseeneeny ee ea, Haar, PA 17120 TOEMotat epee oy te Sx cerita Bake op Jey eon OtgealPapers ane ar Loe a (ne Grn Pa Matar Te tr Desi For Stren CHP al tons renal notin ausine eed 14572 ‘Mr tcmaara shal fed pi ah cee faces on Decor th, ye Dane eae Rentnsininnbactty synbboely cn aelaet Na eciead a Eicon eranar selon naan aon ryan a ‘ronerevounsonbeo nse ne maton eran econ sens hb ae Sys aise soar tno mann a etary ae| ‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0008007-2018 CRIMINAL DOCKET ‘court Case ‘Commenwsath ef Porsieria Page sale Fara Cheater A : apanois (wrens tral Contre Cet Gana ' aronats Yer Caan Cert Aaron Protein 12818 0cerLFe a, Sot tamaae Finns 1 caezeve Yocom Cost kaneistten Proof at Sence ANUS era csr uaa, etc 2 ou courte Gormen Peae-Yoh Cary Hearrghatce Proazrg3a Dre Oma ‘Yor Couny Carin ‘une rates Fare, Coaeoer A ‘Yor Couny Cart miei une Ftc sy sey So York Coury Gout Admin 1 ounrani8 let Lesa ec einai fot gir tbe nme ten at sat a Hr sol ren {joan menu reasons ehhh Oat ease ecm ee a es ‘omsinaainey tenia tedy eesti niwPees seta fa‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0006007-2018 CRIMINAL DOCKET Court Case (Conaneeas of Pannsyaia roposie 2 oxzranis Cink, Lee ‘er Berton a currants Yeokcury Geen (inns ary Te Canes ‘ cuaanore ‘Yorcaey Cain Aanbacn Preto ain Ore aaPBLEC 1 cvszni6 ‘ea Beret omitsn pa cnensntenes oven Frat Ce ‘ aero one Asses 1 cexnanie Osman rey a Sotrent 1 saree Fao, craeper a ete lat Cendant Pron ‘ caus a, Lense er rte Man er ote Paben Coins dant tal ot te paced on soe onder confine or sr afendr reamen OWendnt to flow the ences of ceo ye Bento o0a%6 etc ero, crrtaer eoaaore Fat cans ‘Yoram At Paton Iceni act ng sytem ett emt Hey ass etn ee Spansion vanaf aaa we hate eo Inte cra Se menage syn asem notes scene‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY Docket Number: CP-67.CR-0006007-2018 CRIMINAL DOCKET Coun case Canmore cf Peseshaia ners ote i [nr ‘asia ‘sent secant couans = a Pauetone cee tens Feces rg ens mt ey ec en tes Marc ka Sj fe oomanea Peon anu a ane (Syston Pompeo: Suu hs Maceo ete ae nba ent ste Gro ney Ret “rancan mabe esqeaearbiyaveetomin ie Fe.ce Cave——_—_—_—_—_—_——— OC ‘COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY. Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0006007-2015 CRIMINAL DOCKET Court case CCenmonate of Peoria ronan Seat Toit aes ey ete Seat sseoanh Pama Aen eaomwsy ed Theat ast ‘Spare Cet ran) 08 000 000 sor sn a Ho 00 000 soo sam sara Cone Fas os) ‘com 00 foo foo smo cxs na sa00 000 foo na75 Comarweth Co HE (et 10F so18 00 ow sow sats stim (ons eProecton Ca tom avo sow er) out Ce at 20170) 300 oo tow er) ‘Gi Visa Conoeneten et 6 0 00 ono a0 asm =) ‘ere voonee Cargo et s1000 ao 000 rc) acess) res suet nd Tin Fund 800 201 oo a) oe 125 wot so00 m0 mize ‘he Camper Pj 800 so. oo ee) ‘ite Court Cue 2040 170) siies 20 000 si sites an ea a At 119 100) aso po 0 a) ‘asa Fee (08) s80t 00 00 ee) (he Coury Pa Yo) senso so. ‘00 0 sua DAM) 1802 0 0 no tis Psp Yon) see vo 100 a) ‘Sheds 8) zo ec) ‘100 so nw erate norte Det S201 20 200 som aay vers Hat ‘orbits be Die e801 no 000 soo ean veri ‘rere FegFee oa) ssso0 oo so somo ssn Const Cots (a) ss08 sow on fom teas Corte Eaten Tamra A sso so om fom san (rent e815) som no on fom sesoan (SP vant 35 181) sono 00 som ou secaan covereerTosls = S2z0158 00 on fom s2m339 ect asec rt ma eerie ene te a et ne ead rom oarsmen shee hmraeSta feanana casts ase ayy orerones aet sehen anor mtn ton, at che ren ntsc caer ny age hah Siren earoman som en ee vena wiser te Sm aRCOURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY. Docket Number: CP-67-CR-0006007-2015, CRIMINAL DOCKET ‘Commanweath of Pannyvera ies Cade, 120000 no soos fo sigoosn Foe Tonle $1000 soo soot fom sgoaen Cnt tenke 802838 00 000 to sz tng sean ros om be Carmen el Papna ae avr Ott fara Car sore years caret fa eran ornamntese reat Ease See oman seers np moa Ney enc er Stacy Poroara Een nove a eee Yoasons tsp ats Pepsvaas stern ay Nee omeiansiny bes wend by espa n PACS SesEXHIBIT “E”2 THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF YORK COUNTY, PENUSYLVANTA EAT LAA COMMONWEALTH : (GRoA7-eR-onoe006-2015 7 + GP=67-CR-0006007-2015 vs JEFFREY SCOTT JOY : (Plea & Sentence) York, Pa., Wednesday, April 27, 2016 Before the Honorable Lawrence F. Clark, Jr., Judge ‘ABBEARANCES: REBECCA 8. FRANZ, Eaquire Deputy Attorney General For the Comonvealth CURISTOPHER A. FERRO, Eaquire For the Defendant. THE COURT: Good afternoon, everyone. RITORNEY FRANZ: Good afternoon, Your Honor. ROTORNEY FERRO: Good afternoon. THE COURT: Are you ready to proceed this afternoon, Conmonvealth? AYTORNEY FRANZ: Yes, Your Honor. Before the Court is the matters of Comonwealth of Pennsylvania versus Jeffrey Scott Joy at Dockets 6006 and 6007 of 2015. Ke 1s before the Court today to enter ar open no contest plea to one count of each docket. 0n Docket 6006 of 2015, it would be Count 3,official oppression, a misdeneanor of the second degree; and on Docket 6007 of 2015, he will be entering the no contest plea to Count 1, official oppression, a Misdemesnor I. mu COURT: Very well. Is that your understanding of the agreement between the Commonwealth and your client, Mr. Ferro? ATTORNEY FERRO: Yes, Your Honor, that is a correct recitation of the agrecnent. THE COURT: Okay. May we have the Defendant please stand and be sworn. (Whereupon, the Defendant was sworn.) ATTORNEY FERRO: Your Honor, I do have ¢ plea collequy which has been modified te reflect a no contest ples. THE COURT: Very well. Have you shown that te the Commonwealth? AITORNEY FERRO: Wo, Your Honor. ‘THE couRT: Would you do that, please. ATTORNEY FRANZ: And, Your Honor, T would note for the record one of the victims is’ present today and does wish to address the Court at the appropiate time, I vould also note the -- I don't know if you want me to go inte the specifics. THE COURT: Well, ve do need a factual basis, at least what I will call Reader's Digest version, that can support a plea in thie matter. mean it can be ~~ I mean you don't have to read the whole file, but it has to have at least a framework such that there is no question of the basis of the charge, and that the Defendant is entering that plea Knowing exactly what is charged againat hin, ATTORNEY FRANZ: Correct, Your Honor. T can do that at this point if you would wish. THE count: You might as well.ATTORNEY FRANZ; Okay. On Docket 6006 of 2015, the offense occurred at 28 Berkshire Drive in Shrewsbury Borough, York County, Pennsylvania, and on for about Decenber ist, 2014, at'that date the’ Defendant did take advantage of his official capacity as Magisterial District Judge of York County, Pennsylvania, by infringing on the rights of the victin in this case identified as an adult female, A.P.M. are her initials, by demanding that she model items of Lingerie clothing at her residence in exchange for vacating her outstanding fines and costa. THE COURT: Very well. RYTORNEY FRANZ: ‘Then on 6007 of 2015, at 28 Weter Street, Apartment 34 in Glen Rack Borough, York County, Pennsylvania, on or about March ath, 2015, ‘the Defendant vas present’ at that location and did again teke advantage of his official capacity as a Magisterial District Judge of York County, Pennsylvania, by subjecting the victim in this case she ig identified with the initials H.c. to mistreatment from the ~~ in the form of unvanted sexual contact. ‘the Coun: Very well. ATTORNEY FAANZ: And again the victim whose initials are M.C. is present in court and does wish to addresa the Coust at the appropriate tine. the only other thing I would note is hile this is an open plea and the Commonwealth will leave the length and other pieces of the sentence to the discretion of the Court, two conditions must be included in that sentence, and that includes that the Defendant will immediately resign from his judicial office, and thet he will agree to nevor seek Judicial or law enforcement office again in the future. ‘THE COURT: Mr. Ferro, does that First of all, does your client understand, and you can confer with him now to ask this question, that that's the basis for the open plea of no contest to Count Ho. and Count tio, 1 reepectively at 6006 and 6007 on the docket? ATTORNEY FERRO! Your Honor, wo have spoken about this matter significantly and exteneively prior te today's date. As the Court I believe knows, there is a significant dispute regarding the accuracy of those facts, however, there is a full acknowledgmentand understanding that if those particular facts were Presented to a jury and subsequently believed by @ jury, that they would form the basis for a conviction of Count 3 and Count 1 respectively. THE COURT: Okay. Mr. Joy, will you please stand. Mr. Joy, although you are a Magisterial District Judge, I'm constrained to have to just make sure thet this record is complete. Do you understand this plea agreoment that has been outlined te the Court this afternson? ‘THE DEFENDANT: Yes, sir, I do, yes, Your Horor. THE COURT: Have you had a full and complete opportunity to discuss this matter with your counsel, Mr. Ferro? THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. ‘THE COURT: Are you satisfied with any and all responses to any inquiries that you have made to him ox any discussions that you have had with him have provided you with whatever additional information you sought in the course of those discussions? ‘HE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. THE COURT: Are you satiefied with his representation of you throughout this matter? THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. THE COURT: Do you have any criticism at all of kim, hie professional representation of you? ‘THE DRFENDANT: No, Your Honor. THE COURT: Okay, Do you further understand that although you are not admitting to these facte, that a plea of no contest is treated for the purposes of sentencing and the outcome of these cases a2 2 plea of guilty, do you understand that? THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. THE COURT: Okay. Do you understand the nature of the allegation against you at Docket 6006, which is Count No. 3, as described by theCommonwealth's attorney, that being a count of, misdengenor graded official oppression, do you understend that charge against you? THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. THE COURT: And to that charge how do you pled? THE DEFENDANT: Mo contest. THE CouR?: And, similarly, as to Count No. 1 at Docket 6007, de you understand the basis of that plea or that allegation against you? THE DEFENDANT: Yes, Your Honor. ‘THE count: And to that charge how do you pleed? THE DEFENDANT: Wo contest. THE COURT: Very well. You may be seated. Thank you. Commonwealth, you have indicated that in the Case of 6007, the victim of that matter identified here for a KM. wishes to be heard, 4s that correct? APTORNEY FRANZ: Yes, hor initiale are ‘THE COURT: M.C., I'm sorry. Okay. Whoever that is, will they come’ forward. Will you stand -- renain standing and be sworn, please, by the clerk. (Whereupon, the victim, M.c., was sworn.) TRE COURT: Okay. Ts both the Commonwealth and the Defense satisfied that both they, and especlally on the side of the Defendant, understand who the true identity of the young lady is euch that I do not tave to have her to recite her pane on the record in this case? ATTORNEY FERRO: Yes, Your Honor, we exe satiefted.APTORNEY FRANE: Yee, Your Honor. ‘HE COURT: Very well. Good afternoon, ‘THe vEcTIM: Hi. THE COURT: Okay. Under the laws of our Commonvealth, it waen't always this way, but within the last couple decades the law has natured, let's use that word, okay, which establishes that in every instance in Which there is a victin of crime, the victim has a right te be heard. Now, of course, we are not going to ait hore this afternoon and Listen'to you read the Brooklyr telephone book, okay, but you have a right to be hearc about any the matters that are involved in this case and ask the Court to consider your thoughts and feelings about the matter and to consider whatever suggestion or request that you may make aa a reoult of this circumstance. So what would you like to tell me? THE VICTIM: I just wanted to THE COURT: Tf you will pull that mic directly in front of you, that will help. Right there. ‘That's good. THE VICTIW: I just wanted to explain how his actions, his crimes have affected and impacted ny life, and probably the other victins that were Involved, ile knew that T vag in a vulnerable situation, He knew that I was not from Pennsylvania, and that Twas alone. My boyfriend who T Lived with’ as in Jail, and he was the dudge for his case, and that was the day that, you know, T was in his courtroom. He came, you know, to my apartment and abused his power as an MDs of the Commonwealth and pretty much deceived me into thinking that he waa there to help e victim -- a young minor who was my neighbor, and insteed, you know, he took that tine to pretty much == he Just = he’ abused =~ he abused ny trust, and he was suppose to bo a person that was an honorable Judge and sonebody that had the citizens! best interest in mind, and I think he did everything that the law is againet| Basically, after he attacked me, I had to Live in fear because I was afraid of what he or other people that knew him would do because T caneforvard. He turned my whole life upside down. when ny boyfrierd finally got hone from jail, we had to immediately just leave Fennaylvania just to get away, and we vent back to Maryland, and still to this day all of my stuff is in a storage unit because I had no tine to prepare. I just wanted to gat avay from here, Thad to go seek therapist just because Twas in such a depression with everything. Tt vas a domino effect, and 1 had been on numerous antidepressants because of this, vhich only made things worse. I lost my job that I had in Pennsylvania because my boss she knew -~ I had to tell her what happened, and she ~~ I guess because of the nature of the erine ohe didn't want ne working for her. So it was really hard to get through everything that was happening all at once, and I don't think people that commit these crimes really stop to think about how their acticna affect the victims. They ‘think about what is happening to them, and they don't really stop to think about vhat they have done to other people end how it just docsn't atop at what they did. It just creates a nightmare, and, thankfully, it's been T guess about a year and a half ince this happened, and I'm still dealing with a lot of the things from that. i'm, thankfully, in Maryland, and I'm getting my life back together, and I'm happy cause I'm Fesiliert, but it's been really difficult, and I just. want hin to know that. T can't speak for the other wonan, Dut I'm sure they have similar experienc THE COURT: Very well. THE VICTIM: ‘Thank you. ‘TRE COURT: Docs the Commonwealth wish to proffer any questions to the lady? RETORNEY FRANZ: No, Your Honor. THE COURT: Uefense? RETORNEY FERRO: No, Your Honor. ‘THE COURT: Okay. Well, for what it's worth, today 4s the first day of the rest of your life with regards to this matter, and the strength that youexhibited to come forward and be heard will not only assist you but will assist cthers who might some day find thenzelf in a eimiler situation, okay. So dzav some strength from the fact that you had the strength te come forward and be heard. Thank you for coming in. THE VICTIM: Thank you. THE COURT: And talking to me. Thank you. Commonwealth, do you wish to bring forward anything else? RETORNEY FRANZ: No, Your Honor. ‘THE COURT: Mr. Ferro, on behalf of the defense do you wish to bring forvard anything else? ATTORNEY FERRO: No spocific testimony or witnesses, Your Honor, just a brief statement to the Court. THE COURT: Okay. Well, the first thing T have to do hore before we go any further with this ie, Me. Joy, under the constitution yeu have the right of allocution, which meana that you have the right to be heard by the Court before the Court imposes any sentence on you for these matters. You don’t have to say anything, but you do have the right to be heard. Do you wish to be heard? THE DEFENDANT: No, Your Honor. THE COURT: ‘Thank you. Mr. Ferro. ATTORNEY FERRO: Your Honor, I indicated to the Court I would be brief, and I will keep that promise. I vould tell the Court that for just about half my 1ife now T have been in and out of criminal courtrooms, all types Magisterial District Judges, Court of Common Pleas, Appellate Courts, et cetera, and over the course of that career, Your Honor, aa it relates to Magisterial District Judges, I have never been before a kinder, friendlier, a nicer, a more learned, a more invested, a more interested, a nore caring District Judge than Jeff Joy, and i thought that many, many, many sonthe ago, and I still feel that way today. No contest pleas are di¢ticult, Your Honor, because it leaves certainly an aspect in whichthere is still a significant dispute regarding the accuracy of certain facts, and the decision to nove forward today in this regard is made for a nunber of differert reasons, and most of those are not particularly relevant for this argunent, but I'd ask the Court to consider the lifetine of service that Mr, Joy has given to the Conmonwealth of Penneylvania in so many different respects and the reputation that he enjoyed I believe throughout the Bar and individuals who appeared before hin prior to this incident in fashioning a sentence that allows this matter to be over for all parties and, a the Court indicates, for tonorror to be a new but different day for all parties. i'd ask the Court to consider that in fashioning an appropriate sentence. SHE COURT: ‘Thank you. Commonwealth. ATTORNEY FRANZ: Your Honor, the only comments T vould make are just to again reiterate we aze leaving sentence as a matter for the Court aside from the two conditions that I had mentioned, one being thet he immediately resign from his judicial’ office and, two, that he agree to never seek judicial or law enforcenent office again in the future. SeurEuce THE couRT: Okay, Well, the Commonwealth and the Defendant through his counsel hava ~= the Court 1s avare of this because we have been assigned to this matter for avhile now, it being a matter nost appropriately that would not be handled by one of the existing Judges in this county. Rather it's a classical type of situation where an out-of county Senior fudge is an appropriate judicial official to hear these kinds of cases, and, thus, I'm here. Okay. There's no winners here today. There Le only the potential of some healing and sone other considerations. ‘There's a lot of things I could do with this case, okay, however, I have given it some thought, and T'think under the circumstances we are going to impose a sentence which we believe given the no contest plea ia fair and just under the circumstances, and so we are going to proceed as Follows: Mz. doy, please stand. On Docket No.G006-CR-2015, at Count No. 3, the Court sentences you to pay the costs of prosecution, a fine of $1,000, to undergo @ period of probation which ts two years in duration, this is a second degree misdemeancr, subject to some following condition: You will perform a hundred hours of community service on this count at this docket. You shall within 24 hours tender to the Governor of the Commonwealth, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Secretary of State an unequivocal, non-revocable resignation fron your Judicial office, which shall include a caveat that acknowledges that’ you will not seek or accept a judicial or law enforcement office in this Comonwealth for the duration ef your natural life, At Docket No. 6007, Count No. 1, the sentence is identical to the sentence at 6006. The probationary periods for thie sentencing purpose only shall be concurrent. Additionally, and as T forgot to mention, the community service 1s a separate hundred hours in this one, and the comunity service going forvard shall be performed at a rate of not less than five hours per week. The director of Adult Probation services in York County shall at the director's discretion have the ability, {f it's deened appropriate, to have this be non-reporting but verifiable probation. Tf after the peried of one year you heve paid all your fines and costs, conpleted all of your conditions of conmunity service, and have been otherwise on exenplazy behavior, you may apply through counsel for a consideration of release fron probation at both dockets. T think under the circunatances, considering all of the factors here, you have not had any other kind of criminal history in this Conmonvealth, that this mects both the objective of deterrence not only for you but especially for others and at the same time an opportunity to recompense your fellow citizens in York County for this entire matter. I believe that covers the conditions and the renainder of it. Commonwealth, do you have any cbservation as regards to any of this? AUTORNEY FRANZ: Your Honor, T would just ask that the letter that 4s tendered within 24 hours that a carbon copy of thet be delivered to the 20Office of Attorney General. THE COURT: So ordered, Mr. Ferro. RPTORNEY FERRO: Your Honor, T believe there is a dismissal of remaining counts, but nothing other then that. ‘THE COURT: ALI right. Commonwealth, based upon that, there is 2 motion for dismissal of the other remaining’ caunta at both dackets. Da yous object? ATTORNEY FRANZ: Wo, Your Honor. THE COURT: 90 ordered. Mr. Ferro, will you advise your client of all of his pest-sentencing Fights such that that does not have to be articulated fon the record at this time? ATTORNEY FERRO: I will, Your Honor. ‘THE COURT: Anything further from the Conmonwealth? ATTORNEY FRANZ: No, Your Honor. THE court From the Defene AYTORNEY FERRO: Wo, Your Honor. ‘THE couRT: ‘The court is adjourned. ‘Thank you very much. dar 4/27/16 aEXHIBIT “F”‘Apiil 28, 2016 Governer Tam Wolf Governor's Correspordence Office ‘509 Main Capitol Buiding Harrisburg PA 17120 Chief Justice Thoms Saylor Pennsylvania Judiia! Center 601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 1500 PO BOX 61260, Hanisburg PA 17108 RE: Resignation - Magisterial District Court 19-2-04 Dear Governor Well end Chief Justice Saylor Please accept his latter as my formal resignation from the office of Magisterial District Judge for Magisterial District Court 19-3-04. This resignation is effective immediately. Futhemore, | agree, consistent with the terms of a sentence Order by the Honorable Lawence F. Clark, Jr, Senlor Judge, dated Apri 27, 2016, nat ta seek any future “judicial or ‘aw enforcement” elected affica in the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, ‘has bean my honar to serve the citizens of York County in his elected positon Sincerely, JH Fr Jetirey JoyCOMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA ‘COURT OF JUDICIAL DISCIPLINE IN RE: Jeffrey S. Joy Former Magisterial District Judge: 23D 2016 District Court 19-3-04 Nineteenth Judicial District, ‘York County PROOF OF SERVICE In compliance with Rule 122(0) of the Court of Judicial Discipline Rules of Procedure, on or about June 16, 2016, a copy of this BOARD COMPLAINT was sent by Certified Mell to Mr. Joy’s counsel, Christopher A. Ferro, Esquire, who agreed to accept service on behalf of his client, at the following address: Christopher A. Ferro, Esquire The Law Office of Christopher A. Ferro 160 E, Market Street, York, PA 17401 Certified Mall No. 7161 7145 5373 0150 2679 Return Receipt Requested DATE: June 17, 2016 Pa, Supreme Court ID No. 76540 Judicial Conduct Board Pennsylvania Judicial Center 601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 3500 P.O, Box 62525 Harrisburg, PA 17106 (717) 234-7911