Professional Documents
Culture Documents
إدارة رأس المال الفكري وقياسه وتنميته
إدارة رأس المال الفكري وقياسه وتنميته
.
!
!
"!_(' !
&"%
'"* !+
!
"! (' !
&"%
)2011 "
"/ (22
&% #
!" !
(
*
.
@ @
0
' 1/
"567 2/ 3 *"= / <
;
8'
:
"
&!
? =%7 !/
*
! !76
+ 6C
@"
&<@!
* '
P
MN 8' O &7
& 'L
KE < IE 8E' E3
&E
E
E' 8E FE*G2D
; !3/+ (/
' O I' 2
?
*/ <
&&Q
&.!6
<
"R
? S< O
/"E PL <
E
&E&Q ED
ES
&E
1E
< EE G UEEC
EE 5EE
PEEC+
EE&Q
&EE
& !EEW !EE/ EE'L
KEE EE EES6/
; Z C@CW]/
\!
& G;W
&@^ @E
8\OE U*GE
P
L
E 5
PEC+ !E&
C@ECWW 1E'"6& !E/
&
E'E\ 8E' 1&_E/ E
S
!
6&^ 8
' 8=&
&
^6 !
) ..( 2010
<
2Ec bKE
"%E E/ 8E' E3
& 8EEW 8+
ES W
E 8E/
'@"
&&Q <
& &+
& !'S
'"E E;
E !E 8E' d
E 1EC&!E& !E
&"
2^ !/G = ?G/ 1C 1("/=&
< 8' !\D !e
&"
"S/ !/G
<
?
&C P
&&Q
&E &+ . bKE
OE& !Ee6
EG
& < !E
ES
W! & & 2 +/&3
&*< !Q' '" < 2Ec E
g<E
E /E
^EEE6
.!/EEEGKEEE/ P=]EEE
&"EEE
EEE 8EEE' EEE
]< OEEEEEE
EEE
EEEQ
W !+
O
P+/ !e6 *" * Q/ F
G ; '% =&3
8EE^&/^ <E\ EE'"S' EE/%EE <
EEEEZ 'EE"
&@EE/ EE
&EE
EE^6"EEG) .
;& 8+1427 (
E E7 =&EE &""ER
&EE
E^6 <
E
&EE&Q ' KE !EE/
@E '8EE
S
& '
R )8
0 /' (Ralph Stayer p! (""@C < !E& Zq
E
"
&%
! G < UC
@ 23& r '^"C
3
" !Z& E
&"("E
!E3
*
! '(-
&"%
&% #
!" !
(
2E3& UC E\"E
E ' Et < 2E*' 2E; ES
&%E
!E G
&"("E
!E3
&
^6
K \ 23&/ uG '^"C
3
" !Z"("'
d
"
23&/
&
^6 <
&
G
&5+
E^&/ 2E vE
<
& !&Q&^ ' 8W < " /L 5E' w <"E = !@E<
?E
W < " &+' /
&*! 2
& I&+
C@CW 8E^&/ O
KE
G
"ES xE
&
^6G) :
;& 8+1427 (
@/
5/5
S
<@!
&.!&Q 5( 23&/ ' 8
&
G
&.!&Q
< 23&/
& <!
%* 8^&/"5' / 2^ 6c <@!
&]@! !"&+' 2&/
' 8
"^&/ 8/K 7 ' = "< d. = / "< 0 .1 p%/ 8&
!&/ = /"@' < 5 ' 8 .bd
2& /C <^ (/ " /<^ .!&/7<"EER
EE
OEE\ EEQ ' U*GEE
EE
& !EE'S
&EE&Q ;
EEEE<L
EE 5EE
=&3 <
&
^6 Q
1"' 1C %7 ' 2E3&/ E^E0
*ER E^6
!ELZE7
& E< !E 2E
&E &+ !C@ECW
& E/ !E'S
"IE7
*
' Q bKE
&]@E " 8E'
CE IER
&E
E^6 E'EM 8E
6C (C
&!G' G/ = 2^ D
&! < !E&
"
@E/ %E
E%E7
& <!.
^ *@]' rS
! &! ; < !SS
&
^6
E
E E
' !& g EGE+ '"E < E
E
E P/
E 5E
&EE
& < !EE
EED EEG EE
& !EE
!EE/^6" pEEc
EES
*!EE
< !EES/ !EE3/
"\"
<_ 2
|w
&"d < < '+
&
^6 17&.1
@szja@
= p
&]@E !E' !6%E -']@E
E
-!E\D !6%E
EE3 8E
_
F; 8' v G'
&"
& !/
!/G
^ F; 8' p'
&5
<@!
&@'!
&&
< !3
&
^6 ' !^E' E/* 8^&/ M 8
FE*G
* E<
E
@]' 8' 3
! 26? 7&! "
& <! ^ ( 2KE
4
7
&
^6 1&G 1 b
&"
&
&] rS* < M6
&]!@E
GD
<@! .' 8 8^&/ * '^!
< F*G
@
gw
:
#0 3
&%4
45 #4
!"4
!
(
8^&/ 6/ ' 8K
@ @= <!
*"
:
' -1
&"%S
& <!
& <!
' -2
&"%S
&
^6 ' 1%w%D'^"1C
' -3
8^&/' <
&
^6
' -4
&
8^&/' <
7
&
^6
-57 8^&/ p
&
^6 <
']@
-6 8^&/ p
&
^6 < ']@
-7 !& 8^&/ p
&
^6 <
']@
' -8
&"
&S
S
&
^6 1&
< 1
@szja@c
& 23&!
F*G
*
<
: L
EE '"EE6
& < !EE@EE+ !EE6
EE !6@EE< EEC
@EE !EE/
EE;EE*@ !/"Z !+
&
& + !&Q 3.
x
& <!
'*"% <
&&Q
!%
&ES< I@E
!+
^ \ U*G <w G <
7
' ._/
'"6
&
^6 17 !6 1&@E]'
E< 1E
E
EG b
&" d
&&"
K 8E' I</E6 bKE
&]@E E&7rES*/
&% #
!" !
(
* / P
L
& !6
8^&/' <
7
w=&3 <
E
&
^6 <
']@
.
* /
&G !&
!L
&
^6 <
']@
. "&C /S 'S
S
&
^6 1&@]'
< 1
.@ @ma@szja@b
"
!:
&*" L :
& <!
& <! '"6':"' ;+C 2 '* SG
="6' :
& <!
w%D :CM
& <!
:3
M"C
& <!
" :
& <!
:@'D
& <!
":'+C 2
& <!
*' : +C rG
& <!.
"D :'M rG
& <!.
&*"
: C3
&
^6 1'"6' : 1%w%D'^"1C
="6' :
&
^6.
w%D :
&
^6.
C"^' :3
M
&
^6.
&*"
7 :F
3
&
^6 1& 15+ ' 8
& <! < ']@
= :
8 !7
&
^6
& <!.
*' : CM= 7
&
^6 <
']@
.
: 3
M
&
^6 <
']@
.
G' :
&
^6 <
']@
!& :@'D
&
^6 <
']@
.
&*"
"&C :I 'S
S
&
^6 1&@]'
< 1
.
@ @a@a
@ @Za@ag@
@ @jm@paz
@yb@a@nc@
="6' :
& <!
E
8EE' dEE
&EE&Q
^EEG EE< EE& UEEC
&
EE EER@EE
& <!EE
"
'5 '
+ &S=
& <!
*=
Q&
^ EG
KE *1E
EQ
t ; F
w=%7
& < !E\ uGE
"E "E6/
Ew=%E7
^ 8E' E3E&L
DL
!%
'! .]/
E' O 1Ec;E
E
& !*@E
E(
E UE/
'&Q' 8 &L !^/'L
*5w
(5wE )'"
"^
E
E (|/
"E+
!E'"S ;"E
*/
"( O 1
&&Q ; Fc
! ; bK
*/
< 23&/
EE7 bKEE
&EE&Q 8@EE*
EE
& < !EE' 8EE
EE+ EEL& !EE
^EE EE
& <!EE
< %7/
&&Q
&!
^G
"' ) .
"(2010
&
S
u/ & S
6
" rwS*
uR P
L
&G '^ESG !EC
'&! &L !CL
" 8@; ) .!7(2004
C
8E^&/
"EES xEE EE ' EE ' EE 2%E*/ !EE@EECW 'EED 8EE ; 1EE
"'!EE
1%*
< & / ' G
d
*
& 8E& E E ' E & !EE& / !ES7
<
*
%
!
& !E+
!'E
]E
E
2E*
E !E&w7 !EwC |wEC
ErE7
; F
!6% & /!
! * 2
"EQED 8E' 'E| '""EM
<
* rwS
/+ !).<.( 2010
7
E&*') :
*" !< &
" 6' U
!
6&
+= %; 8^&/
(2&
:13&/ !&Q&
'"(" C
& <!
/ L b+=
The American Society for (ASTD)/"EE
P/EE
!EE^/'L! EE &+
E
! E&Q&
" E("' E %ES/ !E< &
Training And Development
!E& E3 EC E Know Why ' <!
& Know How p & <! r
.!&Q&
! <
/
&"("
&8'
E/ ( Endres 1997, Batem & Zeithman, 1990 @&E/ E EC)
EE
FE*G
! EE;' 8E' !ES
2EE/"*
E ES
EE
E
" E("&
EE %ES/ !E< &
2E 6
& "'
& <! 8 !
G&
! 7
5 (Saffady, 2000 )<
.
SG 2&
2 6
^" / &< 2 6
7 !'"6' <
& <! ' "'
E+CW
E
E'" &
! E&(
E ES
E! E< &
/ (Rucker )
.!/^6
"
& S
G
= = "< S
bK '*0
EE
E<L EE*/ E'
EE! E< &
EE/ ( Ernest and Young |E/ U@EC)
.
& +CW 1< '
:13&/ "S
" Q' 8' !< &
" 6' / I
b+=
EC" S
& <! @ / (Francis Bacon ,Clark, 1996 ^"g@C)<
.!_'?
&^ 2*
6&
23&
8
.6' !S/
& "'8'
%* = 5(!
S
& S
E
1E< / K
&* G !< &
/ (Wick 2000 O/)
!EE&
t EES
IEE&+&
! EE&
EE 5EE! EE&(! EE 6EE\" EE&< 8EE^&/
.
?!
*"
EE EE %EEG
8EE' "EEC 2EE3& !EE< &
EE/ (Dermott, 1998 "EE'/)
bKEC E' E' !^E' E< E^6
KE! +C 1 6*C ' ^6
< G
& "'
.^6
r/Z 8
.!E
&&2E&
8E' E& ' E' EG "E^/ E EG
L EQ6
P %E/ EC=
8/EDt
E
ESC E E5' 8E^&/
Explicit Knowledge
!" ;
"EE; !EE&Q&
&! E
! EE< &
!E\ 1EE
E'
E
E !EE'
E0W rwEEM"
! E"
. 'D?! % +C (Knowing About) 8 ' "R"'
8E' E' E\ EC
E !< &
Q
8^&/ d 6/
bK D 8'
3 C 6
!R 8/K
G
"
& S < I&+
+
G
xEE EES
EES
EE
EE< EE
5EE( "EE^ EEC EE'" &
8EE' !EE
<! EE&7
?EE EE/" EE& EEG EE &
bKEE IEE&+ !EE&
xEE EE 8EE' EE&L
.C\ 23'L=?
!< &
w%D :CM
EQ' wE 8E !E< &
E 5E&
E
w%E
/* U
;+
:
*" R 8^&/ C@CW^ 6
(2& )'*& :!
w%
@ !< &
/ >&
= <
.2\ '"2^ !&/S
& <! /( !< ' !<R
&! & 9
&% #
!" !
(
@ PG
2 & IG C !Gd@CW <
<* 0L E
"EQ ' <!E G' M 8
*^ <
"*C<_.2
Q & E
& < !E
&"
E 6@E&
uE !ES/ EG E/
"\"E
EESC 'E.' b//
&"
!
8S & ESC
!E7 EC
E 2E
E =&E
E
!E S' !E'?!E
^ =
" C
?.
!7
/+
8 G
* rwS.R/>&
= A
8/
& <! @ (Mc Dermott, 1998) :Cx
< 2 C@C
| 8
^6
"
<
* !Q
!
&
&+
"
&+ !6' !S/
"
& < ;
/S
>&
= B
8/
& <! @
w%
!(pwC 2GC):
]G &
2&E EC=SE =E =GE ==E
* 2E
PE
@6
*^ ' M 8
.]G<
K ZW = "( ' '. !S
!G@EE &
EEEE6
EESGZ pEE EEC
!EE&+
.EE GEE
EE<
EEKEE EEZW = "(EE' ' !S
&"'!.
'8
S
! G w%D
2S
G
& %' C = & 2= (5 eR Iw7
" I7
'! .& D p C 0L D L'.
"\ 2
^6 8
& G u6 u&@ u6' !3& C
8'5 ' ; <
& R
" &
]G */ <
&@.2GS
:3
M"C
& <!
6% '
U"C
& <! 8' :
-1 3E
* ()
+
+
T. Backman
"' 8) :8&_/
"(2010
& <!
Explicit Knowledge !*/%& 23
& <!
" !*R
2S
!S
E
10
EE^6
EE< "EE("&
EE'" &
EE< 2EE3& Tacit Knowledge !&_EE
! EE< &
& <!
.
C@C=
& <
' !
@" G= D
P/+
F*G
D 8' < /
^ G&
& <! 23& !
"+&
& <!
. !&Q&
!
& 6&
Z
D 8' ! 7&
2&E !E/6
+
< L\! <
x'
& <!
^"O C (
Konno
"E L E G
:8/E 8&_E EC E/ .!D
&
g;L S
G&
EE G
" EE< EEDt EE G
EE' !&EE
EEd !%EE
EE&
" EEC 2&EE/
E S
EE G
E E? E
! ES
&
& S
! 3'L S &
2&/ .
< &
!EE< &
8EE' EE G
KEE EE rEEC P %E / 8EE^
.EE @EEC EE' EEG
d EE0L
EE<
(Nonaka I. and Konno, N. ,2000). .
C
! S/
2^/ !&_
8EE^&/ EE
EE0L OEE
EE !EE< &
bKEE
EE
( Snowden2000 "EE )PKEE/
E^
rE/< _Ex GE/ ;E0
E< !E
E
E* =! "
! Z@G 6/
EE EEE / FEEE;
EEE' . (Snowden, D., 2000) 5/?
EEE EEE^
EE&/ 8EEE/ PEEE= 2
E< 8E&^ E
EG
E&
E< 2E3& !E< &
bK
( < Hubert 1996)"
(Hubert, S.O., 1996) .< 0=
G P %/
2S
EEG
EE EE& EE
! EE< &
OEE
EE_&! EE
! EE< &
xEE "EES
8EE^&/ KEE^
E' E
(know how p! )' <! %
;^ L" ==
! S
! %
EC (
D P %/ G
" S < !' ' ^" G
d CL SM" P %/
E6
!&_E
E &
E= !G' QC < = "O
K
.CG
" S Q6;
.' !'^
6=
G 2@/ !*R_
_" *"
' <! D
& <!
GEEE) (Snowden 2000 "EEE) (Nonaka and Konno2000 "EEEC"
E EG / PS@E 8E^&/ E
! E< &
OE ECx ( Seubert et al. 2001 DN
11
E
ESC EM OE
Ed " EG& EQC E< /5 / 2
<
+@
. (Know about 8 !< ') 2w" 8/Dt
:
@
& <! S/ "!
* -*
H *I ! 3E -3
u&@E@! E< 5E'
6&
& <! Innovational !W
& <!
.!G
" 7 ?
"EE("&
EE&
EE7
EE uEER" EE
! EE< &
EE Depth!EES& &
! EE< &
."R"&
!*&
! eG
"( <
8^&/
& <!
EE< EER 8EE^&/! EES/G'= G
EE GEE" EER"&
EE*' EE< "EE("&
rwEES*
.!
&u&@ !
.!/
& <!
_2%* %S/ To know, who 8' !< '
8E !/Q
d! /Q
&
& <! W %S/ To know how p' <!
.!&&
.!
3&
! eG
" % %S/ To know where 8/' <!
P&
U7"
8'5
< %S/ To know when
' !< '
:
@
& <! S/ ( Goldstein G. J M # /*H )3E .(knowledge-zero)!/6%
Declarative knowledge !CW
& <!
. (know-how)p ' <! Procedure knowledge!w(W
& <!
.(know why) ' <!
&Reason knowledge !GG@
& <!
. (know-when)
' !< ' Condition knowledge!Z
& <!
. (know with ) I' !< ' Relation knowledge 7
' <!
:
@
& <! S/ ( Milner B. Z
)3E 12
!@]&
!"&&
d \"q
!&7 rD
!&_E
! E< &
8E 2E6
D 8' !< &
"
Z I' S/ . &+
&@"
(2& )'*& : Q
& <!
.!&_
_&!
8' 2/"*
8&_
Socialization!0= rEE/Z 8EE !EE/Q
EE
_&! EE
8EE' "EE*
Externalization EE
" EE*C bEE+=
*"
E^ ED 8' !&R !< '
Q
& <! 2/"* " Internalization = .!&_
& <! 23' !G"@' Q
& <! uG%
; !&&
E< E& Ec !E< '
E
Ec !E< ' 8E' 2E/"*
E Combination|'E
I&+
.
&
^
13
8EE' 1E
8E' E< !E6' 2DE' ED 8E' OE
E 1E
E u%E&
= E'" &
E< ."@"E*&
Ed "E("&
" 1EC
1
QC 8' & Q
' S "Q'
:
"
*" 6&
K U
6/
v 8^&/ O
Z
!EEE&Q&
W
EEE! EEE< &
( Laurie J. Bassi,1997 "EEE
) EE/
!E&Q
2E
rED 8E' OE
1&_E/ E& !E&Q
& <! /+ 2( 8'
&@&
E'" &
E("
"^ !&
x
<!
RW _8' 2
bK 1(* ' <"
(Laurie J. Bassi, 1997) .!&Q&
/"@' 2
& <! < I/ "2&
<
EEEEE
" !EEEEE& EEEEECx (Thomas Kinney,1999 EEEEE EEEEE'") EEEEE< /
!EE&
bKEE
EE
PKEE/ EE&Q
L 8@EE* 2EE( 8EE' !EE< &
EE 8/5EE
( Thomas Kinney, winter 98/99):8&_
2_EE<L EEC EE"7! EE
EE 8EE' OE
1&_EE/ EE& 6%EE EESM"! EE< &
EE/* .S
&&
&
^GE0 0G&
G
D 8' !&Q&
/"@' 2 &!
&! <
& <! <
2@ .!6
+'G
2&
< C =
^/G
UCC=! D
%=
E
! E&
EC
E (Bukowitz & Williams, 1999 E
5"E )"E< /
(Bukowitz, W., .b/EE KEE
EE^6
EE&
! EE< &
8EE' 6EE=! EE&Q&
uEE
(Sternberg, "EE^C"+/(
| /"EEG GCEE) EE< / Williams, R. 1999
("E
"^ EQC EC
E Spear-Swerling, 1996; Sternberg, Grigorenko, 2000).
E7 E E < E +/
2&
/"S
& 6&
! +W
& <! /
(Sternberg, R. J., Spear-Swerling, L. 1996 &. Sternberg, R. .PE&
UE7"
E<
Kaklauskas, A., 8^EC^ E")E< / J., Grigorenko, E. L. 2000)
2E&
E7 E< ECG
IE&( E 8E< EC
E( Kanapeckiene, L. 2005
!EEEEEEE< &
! EEEEEEE;&
EEEEEEE'" &
EEEEEEE 8EEEEEEE^&&
8EEEEEEE' 2EEEEEEE +
EEEEEEE
W EEEEEEEZ
(Kaklauskas, A., Kanapeckiene, L., 2005) .6&
14
& G 2
&=+
" !6c
.!&Q& "^/ K
pE/ E3 ;"ERE7C 2&E0
' 8
6/ DL
"6' 2* U
& <!
E & / 1CL O
ES
E^6
&*"W !/
& <!
<
& S
& <! ^" /
&! <E
/5" / =G 8
&
^6 ^"
"(
& "' E *rES
'5 <@!
&(2010 8/ ) .!&Q
EE
EE 8EE' dEE
EE6/
@EE
EE < EE !EE
& < !EE= 8EE^&/ 1EEC
' !MM
< 6% 2D! < I' 2' / :
& <!
C ' <^ !&7
' !<_EE
EED 8EE' OEE
EE 5EE
&"("EE
EEd !EE/^6
&&" !EE
EE* EE
!EE&S
.!EE&Q&
!7"@EEEE/ :(A
448
& <EEZ FEE; 8EE' !EE ; P
EE EE"
EE
/5'.' E< :B4
8
E 5E
&@E !E< &
!EL
E&7 E< M]E E
=%7 !/@ < / <!
& !&Q/ 7
<@! < 2c%7
& <!.
15
&% #
!" !
(
" :'+C 2
& <!
<@!
&.!&Q<
"R
*/ O) "(
8E' !E"&+' (Rastogi, 2000
"' 2E
E
8^&/ ]
+C rG
& <!
*"
( Rastogi, 2000) :
x
=^
&@&
<q
&]@!. gx I< !&QC
'&
/"
8! C
&! <ED 8E' 1E !E/(&!.
I+
& 2
"%
S/6 .!&w 5/5
S
"&/ 8/K &C
'@"
6
r/6
&]@!. '@ <L
* /
& <! '_&" C'G +CW SG &
. 5=&
< r
& <! ./5 8' 3
5
*=
&&5 <
&
&S !C
&( ! %S
.
& 56* !D IR
& 5+ 'QC 8
*"< 5
&^<. &^ 8<L ' 8
8 F*G^<L 8
="
S
". 6c "< u'
< & 56* !D
*"< 5
&^<
&. /"EE
EE6
&EE "@EE'
EE
EES EEM
*"EE EE EE +/
"@EE'
EE OEE
&]@! ^.2
R
5 (" <"7 I L 8^&/ uR
E< E0
&1E&< !E&Q.!
"@ 1G
7" ' : +C rG
& <!
*7" ' 8 F/ 2D' rG
& <! G/ ' G
d
E
KE!E"&+' 8
' 8
@= 8^&/ (&
<
: L
2 8' I+
&]@!
rGK
&2D u&@ 2
&]@!
& <! '" &
P+; 8 G 2EEEE EE
EE
EEG
!@EE]&
8'EE
EEG rEEG
&EE
!EE
& <!:
E
& <"E knowledge discovery !E !*/E\ UEC E< !&ER
"S <%
. G
S capture
& <!
&&! " SM( 'S '"<
.I&+
16
&EE! < EE
& <
EE & sharing !EEEESC
& < EE0 8EE' !EE
EEDN
EE
; ;
&" 86c
&]@! <
&]@! = S6
& "'E
= &
0;.
& 2
&+ & S ^" 8/^
& <! .<
K ZW ) /"Eg
(Coakes
EE EE EE EE/ EE7("EE; UEE/ *EE7" ' EE/ 2DEE' rEEG
& <!
(1("
( 0G&
)
*" G
26
8' = ("
"^
%= ; PEEd 8EE; EE< EE<L" EES EED "EE("' "EE^ !EE< &
rEE' 8EE' %EE
.
"S < !'&! R
& <! ^"
.
*"D 8' c
& <!
_&! &
@
!< &
rG "D :'M
E< !E< &
rG
"D L5 Dataware Technologies !@]' *
(Data ware Technologies,inc.1998 ) :2& ']@
'
Identifying the *4Q 4
4-" 4 4H *4 OP4 /0/- : * <MN
EECG
EE"7
EE< !EEC5&
!_EE"&
EECG
EE'" &
EE 2EE/"* L Problems
E^'
E< UE7
E< 1' 8^&/ !&7 0
_ UCCW
G
.G \ e0 G/ 7
&^2; <
E3
& <! L O
Preparing for Change
R /)S :"A
8* MN
2EGS
E 8'E
E
! E<S3
E?
_ E/ 8&_E < ("
"^
rG +' 8'
./" /
& <!
8'EE
8EE' rEE/< EE OEE
8&_EE/ Building the Team T440
44+ :"448
8* 44MN
:23' !e 8 !(
O
6^
8' !
!(
w7 / !@]&
&]@!2D
& <! O&/ K
8'
' 2'
p
& <!bK*
/ K
8'
8(*&
2G7 8' !
"@ ' 8^&/
; 6% 8^&/ p
Implement the Building "44!
S "44A* V44 < W44 :"
44* 44MN
8E' !E< &
EQC KE6 O
K %S/ Blooks for Knowledge Management
18
D ' ' 2D
&; 2 55(
1< !;' 2 '* ' 8E
*]E/ 2E
E
5E+
K /
; 1/
"\"
* 2
K b
& <! .
*4MN :"+
4 X4+
!
4
+ "4 Linking Knowledge to People ; FE E
& <!
" ' QC 5&/
& <! d 8 ' 8
P
& <!
Q
& <!
@+ / 'D 8
&" . M
E*/ ) "E/ (Prior,1999"ED !E"&+' _E/ 8E^&/ E G
&E&Q E
2D' rG
& <! &*' 8) :2& ;& &(2
& <!
&^
&]@! <& ; E< E("/ FEE7 !@E]' 2E ' 8E
& <!E
@EE =
EE
@EE
EE "%EE !**EE\ EEd"EE / EE7
OEE
EE _EE
&"^&/
!&Q ' 8
"\"
"< / &7 !6 &
.
* EE/
& < !EE
&" !EEEE< ; 2EE& FEE
&EE&Q /"EE
EE
&EE "E 7
*(!
&@.!GS
"<
& <! C
D 8' O ""7 / E
ECG
& "'E
& < !E&^8E
' 8' !&Q&
8
"\"
0L
&& 8< r
*(!.
5
& <"E; !E
& 8/6@E
&E
* 8
E
&*&ED 8E' 8E *E(; E/ Gd" 7'@"/ R.
5
& <! ;" < IE
8'EER
6c"E ; 2E3& FE
& <vE
E< !E
&&Q K<C @
D 8' I ' 6"
&L
&@'.
8EE' EE
EEG &
EE PEE7
&]@EE
& & !EE EEw
&^EE 8@EE*
EEEw
*
'D 8
' 8D
&. R
5"R
!/ &
"^/
& 2 IE&( 8^&E/
E; uR
8'E' !"C /* 8
& <!
8@*
& ?G/L.
' 88/Dt &
&S !C
&( ! ' I
&]@
&c. 0
& < !E
(!E
L OE
& I@E = !E&Q "E 2E
& < !E
E(* E.D
W
" /
&@&
!&QCq
&
&+
@".r/ " / !<SM C
I&( 8< '@"/
&.!&Q /" -"C ' QC 8
& "' ' ! GZ I
G'| ='
&@*.!M
19
:
Definition Of Intellectual Capital
^6
"
& 6' :=
EES
EE'
EE E &Q&
@ EE/ EE&' 'EE
EE*
%EE
EE< !EE< &
2EE3&
bKE E . E( 2^E E*" '
& <! C !*(
& Q&
@
M 8' !@<
(2003u
\ &;( 6&
) .!@<&
& Q&
!E
& <
<S
uG\ M
&"(" <
3
C"^' UC
E"'! S
3
C"^' / ^6
& uG\ S< t ' &
&"("
.'"("
&]@
EE; bEEG EE^6
EE&
" EE6&
!EE
= EE/* "EE; EEQ
EE( EE EE7
EE Knowledge Economy !E< &
%E7" EEc IE' Ec EE
! E3/*
E6&
1E
EQ/ & !&Q&
8'
v "<
/ !< &
8' 7 1C
v G
b/ F;
bE/ 8E;
E< !E&Q&
E< 8'
I&/
& S
8' |/5' 1C
DN
E& .!E&Q&
!<_E&
! E&S
IE< /"E E;
E< E<L vE EC 1C
F
M r/<
EG
E&
:2&E E 8E' !@E]&
1^& &< 23&/ 1C_
/ 1
Q/
.W ' 6@&
' &(=
& ^
&
20
/ ) (1990
&
^6 E' E< 2E3&/
8'E' E<
UC bK
& O
& '&5 = < ^&/ 8' ("/
&]@ DL .KE/) P
(Dave, 1998 EE6/
EE
&EE
EE^6
EE /
^EE6 ' <_EE
EE=
5EE LEE
(Rudez, Helena . 2003) .Intellectual Capital = Competence X Commitment
< !EEE&Q' 1EEE
& !EEE
EEE =%EEE7)
EEE ( OECD, 1999" 1EEEC
!EEE&S
=%7 8' 8e6
!/"\L d
&&"!
& :E' !E&Q 'E ) E&Q^ (
E 'E
/ & (Guthrie, 2001) .
v G
&
^6 " '"6 'q
r\E
d
&"Q < S G@/
&
^ .
) 8EEG/
5EE (2001 !EE& C
&EE
EE^6 "EE
&EES
EE
"
EE !EES
' 8E
"E+ & OE
ES
^<L
/+
& !GE
KE6
!ES
"@E& IE& E E
rEES*
E
^' 2EE
EEC"^' 8EE dE '"EE\"
!E6
EELE
&"EE1EE< / EE&
)
& (6\
(2003 u 5( :1C ' 8
&
EG
&]"E^/ !@E '!E"&+' 8E
' 8
"E^&/ 8/KE E7 ' < !E !E&Q Ed = /5E <"@E' E
' 8 bd& / = 1C "< 0 E+; ) .1E p%E/ 8&
!&/
E&+;E
(2010 1C
) 1< /
& !"&+' 1Cx (Wallman
&"("
!/^6
& <!
] < M
/ !E&7
&"("E EDL
&!E&Q EC
&"("E
&ES
"' E/S E< 6%E!EC
& !EE&Q
&"EE7: !&_EE EE @EECW ' 1EEGD 1EE 1EE
") 1EE< / EE&.!EE6c
!ECx (Stewart,1997EE^<L
K !EE
& < !EE
& "'EE
EE
E
EES rEED
EE
EE3
=
*/ w%D^<L
& "'
' !< ' G("& / <L "E3&/ ' E
<^ / = <
E ^"E bKEE^<L
& "'E '&5E =
E< E^&/ 8E' E("/
&E&Q
&<@! EDL ^"E E !+ ^"E
E & !E&7 E ' 1E/
8E= E
&
&+
& rZ
2^E
&%E
*
!E
&" 8/"E^
!E 7
E3 . bKE
ES
2^ !6
K+
?
<! ?
< /K
&@(Bontis Nick, 2004) . 2GS
* 2
!6
K ;" p/
&
^6 8^&/ : L
5G
&
^6
& <!
.!/G 1G06
&
^6 "
& <!
!/G
/"* 8^&/
&7!"^/ ':8/% 8
21
&% #
!" !
(
&
G Human Capital
& <!
& !%%
= &^
&!&Q
^ 6
G ^" '*
< !c"6.1
"EE\L
Intellectual Assets !EE/^6 EE
& < !EE
&^ "E
EE^&
EE
&!EE&Q
^" '@ 0 8 !S
'.2
1G06
&E
E^6 8E^&/\ED 8E' 16E "E&C EMME L _E/
&EE
EEG
&EE
EE D
EE( .<KEE
E S
&"EE EE/
&EE
G
&
P/
G
& I
"ES
'E/ E& !E
&
D
& "'
&_E
&E
2E
!E&QE 2&E
=EED !EE&QCL
^"
"( !EE !EE&QC
FEE*G
/"EE EE/
&EE
EE(
EE
7
*
Q
& I' !&Q
&.
EE 1GEE0EE6
EE 'EE
&EE<L !EE&Q 'EE '&5EE ]EE/
EE<EE&7 IEE
@"!7 ; F
&
G
&&5
' < 8 ' !E&Q
5E&
E 8E
d <
&&Q DL
&c ^"E' 2 %E7EQC !@E]&
/ L
&]@E
<L 8^&/ " </ 6
&M ' .
EEE EEEC ' 8EEE
EEEQ
!EEE&(G
EEEw=%EEE7
&EEE
EEEG
& EEE<
& EE
"EE = EE "6 EEw%EE7EE ' EE = !/ '&5EE & EE EE = EEC 'EE
<^.
R
5 =+@C 8
& <!
E^&/ EE<L
"E6' 8&ER 2DE E
&
^6 !6@< 8
& I&+
&]@! .&7
@& /
&
^6 ' :
&
G Human Capital
&E
^ Structural Capital E
&E =^E 'E
E/+
/"E
d
. O 2 bK
@& "E6' S/
&E
&E Tangible Assets
"\L
S !/^6"\L
& !/ uER" 8E^&/
E6 8E
&E
&E
&
^6 'D 8
+
:
/H )
Y ( 1 #+ "A
G
&
&
&
^6
&5 !L
'" I7
"(
' '&"
8&R
!eG
!D!
& 23
&"(
!&S
!
t
&
& CG
'MC= !%7
<L
&
G
'5/ =^
" !6
3
=
&
5= bGC
"I
22
< &
2&
_
2&
1
&@'"
2 ;
&7"/
EEES
EEE< EEE/5 IEEE' EEE& 1EEE
gEEE
!W
2 ;
&p7"/
?
I7
"
!7
7( C & 1
8'5
(2005 p"/
@G) :%&
."c&
&]@ 8' d 8 5& !/" ' '
! w
"rS* !@]&
^6
& w%D :CM
!E"&+' 1EC
E - !E
bKE QC !( 8' - ^6
& p/ "R
<
E IE' +@E IE&+&
! 6@E< 8E' r <L&^ /
! W<^
& L
/"EE E< @E EM 8E' EDL! EEM&&
@ E]&
E< wEQ
<"E = !@E]&
8EE^&/ cEE&
@ EE]&
8EE' EEd 8EE EE5& !EE/" '! EE
' EEw "EE
rEES* !@EE]&
(2010 6
G 8&/) :
^
*" 6
& w%D (&
: 8&_
!
&]@! eG
G Organizational "; ZF
EN -1
.!/W /"@&
I&(
< ^6
"(
& .<L D 8' &@&
/+
!
@
C
&.!&
d 7
Q
;" .!/W! /5
&8 G
E
EQ
2ED! /EG
E\
&&! G Professional "\ ZF
EN -2
:8&_
P %E
8E' "E^/ FE* !E&
&EG
E
! E&
E&
8E' /
' .
G
.!
&Q !( I&
.
wMW P/
EG
%E
GE Personal and Behavioral "*4" E4NP ZF
EN -3
: 8&_
K
1w
2Ec
E< 2E&
PE;! E
"+&
! CL& L
7W Z&
2&*
2&
. x
;=
.(G
6C= )8/Dt GD 8' 6= 23
E* E
! E&Q&
!E/^6
" E\L
E
E Intellectual Assets "40
* H*!C"C7 !/&;
'EE
Skandia !EE
r@EE
/EE&
( Edevinsson, 2002 8%EE< ) EE/
E
! E"&&
Ed "E\L
& <! 2/"*
S
<
23&/ ^6
&
!
&
( Edvinsson, L, 2002). :& 8 8^0 K/ 3
r
%'
2&EE/ FEE; !EE&Q&
!/EEG
&" EE GEE/ Human capital
P445
44 6@<< SM&! Q&
7 2&/ &.!&7
/"* 8^&/
& <!
!E/!
&EG
2& !&Q&
!*
! G
G/ Structural capital \
EE<SM! EE&Q&
/EE 2EE3' !EE"&&
EEd !EEG
!EEC
^W GEE*
CEEG&
2EE3'
.5&
1 "P^&
2'
1/ ' 2 2&
' 2&/ &
:2&EEE EEE\ !EEE
EEE
EEE^6
EEE&
( Brooking, 1997 |EEE ) @EEES/
.Brooking, A., 2001)
:2EE3' @"EE
!EEG&
! EE"&&
EEd PEEC"+
IEE&( 2&EE Market Assets *44* 44^ .!&
&G
I/
"K<'
&
&
E7 2E&
2E; E^= E7 !E&
&EG
E Human Assets"0
P45* 4^< .?R U* 2&
2&
< 23' ! ' p7 <
'"L<
L
24
!EE/+
EE7
EEL 2&EE Intellectual Property Assets"440
" 44* 44^ .!< &
"
S; D=
2EE& !EES/Z EE*
EE
EE\
IEE&( 8&_EE Infrastructure Assets "44-" 445* 44^ EE"7
EE&
2EE^
IEEG
" EE7 P
EE EE
EES EEZ !EE&Q&
! EE<SM 2EE3' !EE&Q&
.%= QC
& C
Skandia !EEE0 (Mckenzie & Winkelen 2004 8^EEE/ 5EEE' )KEEE/
(Jane Mckenzie .1EE7 2@EE/
EE;
EE
" EE*
EE EE^6
EE&
EEC"^' @EES !//"@EE
'
" S; D=
!EE
&
EE7
UEECCW EEQC EE'" &
EEQC EE&
!EE&Q&
! EE<SM
.!@<
5&
rS*
DL 5'&
& <!
&I' 7
6
*
8&_/ External Capital H
N
"EEE7 EEE&
EEER @"EEE
! %EEE; _EEE/"
&3@EEE&
"EEE&
2E "E+
/E ' E'= 76 !R6&
" S D
76= I/
"
.! &@
5&
r / '
E
E&
E &
ES
8&_E/ Human Capital
P45
E?
! E(
'"E ES
E^= G&
6c"
/"
&]
!EEEE/6
EEEEG
<EEEES3
EEEE
!EEEECW! EEEE^&
/_EEEE7 !EEEEG/'|
EEEEG
.!&Q&
< < L
&^
2; 7!&+
25
&% #
!" !
(
26
&]@!.
\ Structural Capital 8&_/
& E
E<
ESG
E
&] !@E2&E
EES
!EE&Q"7 EE EEQC
& "'EE EE6CW
EE
FEE*G
/"EEEE+
! ' (5
* P 8'
t
'!
+. !/
4 O4 Customer Capital 'E
E7 Relationship Capital 8&_EE/
&%EE
EE7 GEE
EE
&] !@EE
(EE
!EE
&EE
&"EE8/
?/'" '' :23 R
& 2= 1w=;6 1&^ 1
& 2' 1'
27
!< &
^ 6
!
& 7 :=
'@EE 8EE^&/ EE
! EE
6
L 2EE3&
EE*
%EE
EE< !EE< &
U*GEE\ EES
E< E&Q&
vE !^' 8&^ !&
"
&*! L < %;& 7 I<
&Q&
E(
E
ESC=
! SE= ES
PG@E 5&' !< ' O&
^" v G
CS<
!EC5&
! E< &
E "%E*
E< @E 2wE& =^ Q&
bK @
M 8' D
E 8E' ( E&
EG !'E).!E&Q&
2ED 8/EDt IE'
G SC
^" O "S <
2EED E(W 2EE&
E rEM"
EE 5E E
g/ES&
8C"ES
QEE
vE Ec
EE PEE("/ EE^/'" CEE7 "EE( Sarbanes-Oxley (44 %+
44 ) "CEES E &Q&
E& =E/
E
<! ERW KE .g/ES&
L 8E' OE
d^ 6
& C"^'
L E< 1EG / K
L^
6
! (
& 7"@
! ) SS*
&! S
=
. !&Q&
&(W
EEc EES/Z 8EE 8EE^&/
EE
2wEE"
EE; 1EE7 EE^6
EE&
EE/* 2EE3&/
I7
".&!Q&
!/^6
\" L S 2@
8' 2 :^"
@/ !&Q&
!SS*
&! S
2E3&/ KE
! E< &
% 2^ G/ 1C <
8&^ ^6
& 7 2 '
!EE^'/ w%EED EES
!E7 !^EE w%EED gEE^ !E"&' EEd !EEC" EE'
E<
!@]&
!@]' 8' p ^6
&!
& 7 <!
RW K .7 P %/ ' G
d
.D S
7 8' D
" EE6' EE^6
EE&
" EE6' !EE UEE& EE
EEL p%EE 8EE^&/
( Thomas &2010E<! E) :!E
! EL E+=
E< E& !E7
!E< &
&
28
@EE&
&%EE EE
& EEQ
EE !EE&Q=6EE ' 8EE
& < !EE
8EE' !EE+EEC
"'!.
>&
= (A
8 I' 2' / 8' 2
&
^6
& <!
' &C<P %E/ 8
2%E6
E& r7EE
EE3EE&/ E&C EEL
E+ ' 2EEc E< !EE&Q=%EE7
&
G
& <! &_/ &C
"+
'"E\"
!E
E
&E&Q
& &.!E
!&Q&
8^&/ *@ !& 8
&
E^6 'ED 8E E
& <!E
EE
!&_EE '" EE6c*" EE/
8/EED
!EE;' !*/EE\ !EE< '
EE
8EE^&/
EE
Q
&
^6 'D 8 Q
& <!
_&!
' 8"7 < /5
C
&.!&Q
>& =
44B44
8 EE/
&EE
EE^6 EE* _EE !EEQ' 2EE3&/
& < .!EE< EEKEE
ZW Q/
& <
E !E 2E3& EC; EE
t
& E< !'@E
&
^6 &
@ !6 !& 23& C
&
D 8' !&Q
rEDE/ 'E
&^ 8EE' 1EE
&EE
EE^6 .&"EE^ EE bKEE
!EE/
EEL IEEEEC
GEEq
!:
] vEEE EEE
EEE
&EEE
EEEE^6 /"@EEE' IEEE' 2EEE' / W
EEEEW !+/ rED
5
!E&SE/
EE/ "E\L
&"E
!E/^6
& 2^
!&Q
KE @E/ <
EE/ E7
& 8E' !E&Q
&"EQ EW E< +
;/ 8"6' 5
& <!
" 2w
?!
^^!
E
D 8E' 8E^&/
rD; *" 2/
& <!.
rEED !EECx EE/;EE
%EE6 EE3
EE
& < !EE&& !EE DEE' !EE/
& <! < 2(L
/ 8; < %S
&
E^6 bKE
E !ECL
&E
. G
]/ v
R
83;G =&E E L =%E7 !E< &
!/&E
E
' 8
& <! "
"\"
'@" '&^ 8' 8
&
^6.
/
83;G _/
& <! &"6 - 8' US0
&
^6
KE P+/ 1/"^ /"& b/ ' 1
&*<.1 !Q
7 :CM
&
^6 <
']@
Measuring Intellectual Capital
2EE3&/
&EE
EE^6 & !EEEEG '' "EE&C EE< !EEEEW !EE(CW
&<!@EE
&% #
!" !
(
&&"!E 't
KE ]E/
8@E*
EE6
&]@E E/
!E&S
!7"@E; GE!EE
&EEE
EEE^6 EEEZGEEES
EEESM
^"
("EEE EEE'L
KEEE
EEE M]EEE/EEE/
^EEE6
=%7 < !/
&" I&+ ' !E;C 8
^ E
^ pE"E^ E' EG
d E \E7 E< !" E
&
^6
K 8&_/ 70 23' !"&' d
&%
!/G
&E
^2E
&Q
&
!7 .
&C Z
S "\L
& <!
&
^6 <=E+'
E '2E3
&* !G=%7
&%
!/G
&^!
!/^6 bK
&
5
* 2
*@
=%7 ="@E&
+
&] !@E= bKE
& E/ E
g/ESE ' E< E
S
' !' !6%<
'+
.!\D !6%
/
v G 'xE 8/^< 8 g/E7"E\L
& < .!E<E* 4
+/ Z 'ES
!G' metric !/
& < !E<_
4 *E
E0]' 8E FE*G
ES
& <!
& <! <
; = 7 8^&/ &C
K 1E7 8E^&/E(' "E
!EECL
& < .!EE<
EEKEE EEZW EE/) ( Roos and Roos 1997 ;EE
(" PC
&
^6 & 17
< 23 &!
ES 8E^&/ ED 8E' E *E/
'E0]' !E"&+
^"( 8E' PEC( 2E PEC
&E
E^6( Roos, G. and Roos, J. .
1997).
EE
EESGZ )< EE = (Edvinsson 8%EE
&EE
EE^6 "EEEE/
&E
E^6 8E' KE bKE
& E&7 5E/5
!E\< !E
(Klein, D.A., 1998 ) !7"@E
5EE / KEE
EE EE/ )8EE' 2EE " ( Brennan &Connell 2EEC]/EE ']@EE
(*! ^"
/
S
'
^6 <_ 8' 2
&]@E 2E7L
;+C bK
&]@ 8^&/ / '
^6 ED 8' !
6
E 5E
"+ PC
!( Brennan &Connell, 2000):
-
7
&
^6.
* /
^"
"(
&<@! .&S
* QC /
&^!
!/^6.&S
<
2c 7
P
S
!/S
@ <
7 "\L
&&"!
E
7 !&7 /S
&
^6
K \5E( 2^/ uG EG ' 8E\"E ']@E
E
( U S< !&/%7/ !/
"\"
E
D 8E' 8E^&/ !E3/; g/ES'
E
* /"\L d
&&"
E< !E
E
&]@E .E7 @E+ 8E^&/& !E
&g/ES
30
* !3/
"\ 2
<
OE
&]@E( Chen, J., Zhaohui, Z., and :
E/ E&<
)Hong, Y. X., 2004
!&7
& <!
&&5
&^ bK
&]@E < %E E\ U*GE
& <2^E 1E< !E(5 G ' !&7 8
&| ' !&7 8
&.!&Q
?! '^"EC E3 2&E
&E
EG =^E ER
&E d E
E'" = @ I
P
S
.7 !/S
=
* R
&@7 2GS
&
^6 & 8;
< P
EL
!E/S
&.S< R
5
* rwS
"! 8;
< 5
P
S
!/S
* rwES
& !E/
^&!E<.S
'@E bKE
&]@E
E ^"E E3E6 ED 8E' !@E< E3( Barry, B., :)2000
x 7
* rS<.
5
&Q !
|'CG
. G/ &" 2/
F*G
"./ " I
&D 8' !&Q * /
&" !L^ P+ &L.<
" E(" = I7E !ES/Z;E 'E7 E< E rE6
&E
E^6 <
E
S
K !(CW
& 8
& <!.
!7L
&"
S \"
& <!.
31
&% #
!" !
(
V0
Y -2"
Intellectual Property Measurements "0 5E bKE
&g/ES
* !&7 /
&
^6 & C"^' 8' 1&_/ ! 2&E 'E ^ E
' ' " 2/"* M C"\L
& <! d
&&"! < E@E7
& !&Q
& !6
^0
&^!
"^
!/^6 /* 3 2' .
V0
4Y -3 "4Y Market Value Measurements "*4 5E bKE
&
E g/ES
6 8
!&S
< !/
!&S
@" !&Q&
!7
E E& E' G
d gE'EG '
!E
'*: 23' !G
!&S
@".!7
!&S
<.!/
d !&S
&&"!
&*@"!.
V0
Y -4
) /F<^* Return on Assets Measurements & bKE
&g/ES
;@
w"\L ) P@; ( ROA
!?%
! :
"\L
&&"!
!
S' / O w "' I' C
S
K C IS/
& 1&R !&Q E/EG
/ "' 8
S D w
&
^6
&. !&Q
EE 8EE^&/ EE
EE
&EE
! wEE
EE
EEEE' <EE7
EE
&EE
^6 <
&&Q !' !6%
E /" EE'
ES
&E
E^6 <
E
@]' 8' 3
<
8' 3
O
*"
:
-1
#+ "Y*" "4Y Market to Book Value "40
!/"E^ E7
bK
!S/
E @E
E
&E7
E< !'@E
&E
E^6 ; 2E3& FE
!E&S
!&S
^! L
& .!&QE '"E^ E
!E&S
!7"@E 8E'
E
!E&S
<PG@E !E/
&
^6 K ' /
@6
&G
&&
S I</
&@&3 8E' 3
!EE&S
*"EE\q
!EESS
L !EE3 EE0! PG@EE
< "EE
&EE
EE^6
OEE
EE!.
@/ K
&"
!?%
!( G.G. Dess et al. , 2004) :
&
^6 =
!&S
@"
!7!
!&S
<!/
<
! = ' 5 3 CC 1&7
*
! < E
"@E 10 E
< CC !&7
&
^6 = 5 = 5 10
32
8EE^&/EE bKEE
EE< !EES/
EE
& !EE'S 8EE' EE3
EE
' !EE
@EE= OEE
"G\ <
&6^
!'S
^ g L
!&S
*@]&
!SS
E'" '
E .!ES7'
E< EE
E
' EQ &< !EE
"G\E = EE6^
@E '< EM 8EEE6
I(/ 7 L
"'G' d 2 _E' !E+C = E'" '
E
EG .!ES7
)./
"(
7
8^&/(& =R
"( 1 bK
( Cetin )1'7 &< !S/
*"
G 8) :
@ .(2005 p"/
v
&&Q = ' I' 2"L
'! " L
&
!
= "/<
E !7" !&7' /* P %/ M 8&
^6 'D 8 bK
.!S/
EE E EE< EEL
"@EE
&
!EEEEx
*@EE
!EE&S
EE
!7"@EE!
*EE/&
^6
KK PG@ & g " \ L . Z"G
!&7
&
^6
< 23& UC
6 8
!&S
@" !7
<S / v G
< !/ G
&
^6 ' 8
^"
&
! !^E' 23&/5 IE' !E\D !@Ew E/
E6
8
!&S
@" !7
!&S
< 2^ !/.G
8^&/ = 1C 5 /
6 8
!&S
@" !7
<
!/
&
^6 <S ; F
8' /
"' 2
!D
(!
7 <
"
K
6 .
-2
44 >
E44Y @EE bKEE
EED 8EE' !EES/ =&EE
EE&EE %EES
&@*
8/
w=&3 <
&
^6 <"E
ES
) :!EE/
"(
7
* \ /
&
^6. * 2' /
+ "% % 2^
L .7 8^&/ 0]' &%
S "' 2
+
\
& .7 8^&/
&]0
!
S
% 2^
w
/H )
a (2
)
/F
%
&]0
&
G
&
^
'
&
&"&+=
&
^6
!G@C R
'&(W 8
'8
/ '
& G
* !%
@"!7
w=&3
33
E7 !E7
bKE
E< E/
4MY /4F
)" 4;
84 > 4) /4F
#4+
-3
EE EEw
2EEM& : !EER<
EE EE&= EE^6
EE&
EE< &3EE=
EE EEw
@E]&
8E ED= 5E / EZW K <
.;
"S
2D&
&]@ 3=
E/ .^6
&
&]@! <
& 3= ;
"S
2D& 3=
w
<
(
7"
/ ):D 8' ^6
& <
& 3=
w
7
.! "MM 8 2S = !' < D !@]&
&3=
w
7 g6EEE
OEEE
!@EEE]&
1EEE
EEE& KEEE
EEES
EEE"&
&3EEE=
EEE EEEw
EEE7 .!'5
6
2EE3&/ EE6
EEG EES
EEw EE"'@! EE]&
EEw 8EE EED= EE7 .^6
&
!E0 8E 8E' E3 UE'7 FE; Intangible Assets "4 *
4c
<^*a -4
Konrad !E/QC Corresponding Theory !E/QC E 1987 E E< !//"E
EG&
ESGZ E %E<W! E"&&
Ed
"E\ E7
E< IE EC
Theory
!EE/Q
/"EE EE EE7 .!EE
&
w"S
EE !EES*&
EE/S EE< OEE
! EE/Q
EE< "EE
: ! '*8'
&"
.!&S
"
.&L & .!*%&
\* ."&
34
& <!
-1
&" :
L
&]0
7
?
*@ 8 =^
&-2 &L
L
&]0
7
? <
& &L
!/W!+
L
&]0
* / !/
!
!&wS
& <!
-3\*
&!*%
L
&]0
7 C =
\*
&D !*%
'D
!&S
&_<!
7
*@ 8
&
" -4
!&S
L
&]0
7 C
!&S
(& %7/
"/
a
of
Assets
&" !C
^!6
Yogesh Malharta (2002).Measuring Knowledge
Nation: Knowledge System for Development, UN, p32.
Source:
&% #
!" !
(
!CG
" uR
"% '0G3'
."%75" :O
!EE7 EEL
&"EE '& IEER" !EEZ;
!EE
&] !@EE* rEESEE^'/
Q=6 '"' 8
!/EG
&ED 8E' !E/ ' 1E(" g/ES' 8E' 1&_E E
"E+
rS* "*C< ./'(Olve, N., Sjostrand A.,2002) :
5& C< M 8
-
8L
|w
"
@q
G ' +C b.17 !6
* / "C
& g/S
&@'! < "*' 2.
"< \" ! 8&L
.!@]&
!/K6
@ =% <
& 2=+
<!
&@"/
&]@!.
<7 I '^C
&
^6
&]@! 'D 8 "< ? !/K( 8E !EL
^
.
&3
N W
"&
!
6
D 8' !/G
*"<L 5.
36
&]@!
SG =&
&
"D 8' 2/
S ^ 2
!S/
@" !//
&& 0]'
< !3"\L d
&&"!
!S/ !^/'L
&&!E7
E< !3
L
&" 8^&/ (&
*"
) :'! G
& (.
! BQ #>
fQOA O
:
-
6' @S/
&=+ d
&&"! d
&
!
e< !MM.
6/
& d g/S
&
! P+/ *0]&
r
&
!.
/
EE 5EE
&]EE0
EEd P@EE
&
PEE+/ !EE *"EE ' 8EE
&"@EE
?EE
EE
&@" = + 2D
&.!&Q
r6/ "
S = EG / E/( !E7 PE+/ E&C @E/
* 8@E
E
<L
*" ' .
BQ #>_O fQOA:
.O
'] EE0"EE\L EEd
&&"EE6/ !EE ("EE !EEMM\"EE ) !EE"&' EEd
& "EE
EE/+=S( = '*' 8
! +/ '<"6%
6 bK"E\L
ED 8E' OE
0]' &% "E& GE 2E\L' E E+ bE6 =E6C 1E'@ED ZE E< 1
;/ = 8 "L Dt
.O
'] 0"\L d
&&"! /^<
5
&"Q
& < < ^" 8/
&= 8; < !&Q 7/" !7L
&" &! ^" 8/
&.!&Q
-6 "Y Knowledge Value Added ( KVA ) "!
"!
9 bK
E& !S/
(K
!% ; F
_ !&S < & 8' !& 2 CW & 23& C
& !EEEEG < EE%EE7
& <EE&
u&@EE EE< !EE
& 8/&3@EE "EE*/ "EE\L
:!EE
EEG
@EE]&
EE< !EE&&
" EE'L 8EE' EE /
EE*
UEE7"
EE< uGEE\
(Thomas J. Housel, and Valery Kanevsky)
EE3L! EEeG
EEQ
2EEc
EE< EE 8'EE
" EE( @"EE' !EE< '
EE
@! EE]&
! EE(; . S
.8//&
2< +C ;(!
&]@!
' <! 'EE
'"E p _E
W L 1EE/ KE
G@E
MxEE
@E]&
8E' E3 .
'+&
6 p
^
@
!@E]&
E&Q
L E7
E< ^6
& 8&_
&]@ 8' 3 ..!@]&
L !"R"'&"
! 0 3 \" S/
8E' !S&
! 6^
@ C 8 S
P@
&!
&_<!
& <! < S
23&
bKE uER"/
E
2^
. !@]&
! =&
& <! < /+
!
& /S
S<
. !L R! <S/
&(
y
!< &
&!
D&
x : "
<
I>!
. "!
9 "
V ( y = x ) gA
1
.
R LE "+*M
!" /Y+
Y0 W
5" ( " Y 2
.
R LE "+*M
!" /Y (
R " " j! W 3
Source: Thomas Housel and A.H.Bell (2001). Measuring and Managing
Knowledge, McGraw-Hill/Irwin, p94.
!EEEE< &
EEEES EEEE rEEEEZ! EEEE< &
EEEE @EEEE]&
EEEE7 EEEEGD=
8EE EEG EE Knowledge Management Assessment Tool (KMAT)
(Martha de Jager, 1999) :2& !eL 8' !"&+'
/ 2
" U7
&%
&@'
8' ! ^<L
/+
I&( @/ 2
&@' 8 ' < 8
& <!
2
& "' 'C 23
& <^ +/ _& < QC
& <!
2 'QC /"
< !C
& 2
"%; !6
&@'
E 8
& "'E
'
2
&]@! "' 2^ gS\ !&7 2 '
^6
2% 2
&]@! 8' G
&%
*"%
<_ 2
& "' 8
&&!
2
&]@! * ^ r' 2
& <!
< 2^ 8'@&
!D
&% / 2
^0
^ /DL
I+
&!
& <!
2
&]@! P
!eG
& 8' !/( 2@ 2
&! <
& <!
: !SC 9
&* !&Q
*@.5&' 8
: !SC 19-10
&]@! @ < = b+
.u*%
: !SC 30-20
&]@! @ <
&.!'S
: !SC 40-31
&]@! w < '
& <!.
&
^6 7
rZ bKL Info Line G 8' !"&+' 8
&E6
& ):2 &*' :QC& 2 G
5/5((1
EE !+
&]EE
!@EE
EES
"@EE
3EE
!EE !*EERLEE L
"EE/
'.!'"6
& <!
&&!
&]E*' !@E ' < !E
^ E< 2E(E
&]E/ !@E
&E
^6 23&/
&5
<@!
.
&]@!
<q =;6 2^ G/ I' rM !+
& E 2E;(E
&% #
!" !
(
("/
&]@! !+% E< E& E<SM P
OE 2wEEW
&) :!E6
/G^
W C
2wGDW !^G0 !/ ...UCCW
(.
!<SM
&]@!
&! <
& "' ^<L ^ <E
&"EG
E I+E
' 8DL.
?5EE
&%EE
!/EEG
&EEEG
EE< !EEG/
&]EE !@EEE EEQC W
& <!EEE
/* :8&_/
^6 !C
" /
&!
& P7
& !S
&@
@" QC L.
*
&]@!
"\ 2
P/
& P
<L ' 1C"(*/@ 2wE
W ) !^G0CW UC
"/6
" rM
"6% ...
(.
&]@! <@]' I' g D <_ 2
*" W
& <!
&;!
./
7 /
&]@!
" /"']/ =&3
" /
<
&@.2GS
^"EEEE 8EEEE !EEEE(WEEEE6' 2EEEE ' 8EEEE bKEEEE
&EEEE6 EEEE;x=EEEED
:!EEEE
)
6 (1) Lm
Y
) (2
&0S )((3
< "R '"&+
S
&+
&]@! /"@E' 8 6% /
& <!E
!M3:!t
&]@!
"^/ !SC (30-25) 8' I&+ ( R^"
W
& <!.
&]@!
"^ !SC (24-20) 8' I&+ < E
!ES'
E rE/*E
E
EQ
E v
/_S
&]@!
8'x
K6
(.u
&]@!
"^/ !SC (19-10) 8' I&+ E " !E
;
E< U@E
ECL pE7= E ?G/ ( I^<L
&;! < '+
& <!.
'& u_EE/ rGEE E
EE 1EEC
8E' dEEEE3
&*EE=
&" !"EER
EE&C U'EE7
EE
' P
S
&
^6 1&S= 5/ = 1C E6 8E
&8%E
;" EZ ES"E\L
& < !E
&E
E^6 . 8E^&/E
&;EQ
"E; !E
&*=
^3
* !6
!33
K
S
&
^6:
OEE
&*EE= EES
!EESS; !EE(; 8EE EEG EES
&EE
EE^6 < EE
8EE' EE/
&]@.
bK
&*= 8E^&/G"ED E & !E'"!E& !E+' /"E 2GE E< !"ERS
!\D S
&
^6.
bKEE
&*EE= "( 1EEEER EE/ xEE '^%EE
EEC
& EE/* !^EE
& /EE
&]0
&@
S
& <!.
40
^ 8' 3
&
8' U'7(7 2 S
&
^6 @
E
^8E' EG
&]EE0
EE EE;7
8EE' EE/
& EES / EE&' 8EE
rEEGEE+' EE< !EE\D EE'
& G) .!R/
@ 2005p"/
:3
M
&
^6 <
']@
@EE]' g<EE
EE
EE E&<
EE'
@EE EEM 8EE EE' 2EE
EE ^"EE EE3
EE &5EE 'EED 8EE "
EE
& < !EE!EE
6 EE <
& %EE
KEE EE/EE EE< bbKEE
K %E&
IG
G/
!/EG; E bKE
&%E .
" IE7
&%E
E* = !/EG
"R
< S< &7 %
& !&Q
^ *E "ER
E< _E/
EQ
" !EZ
!@E
=(&! =%7 !/
&! ''< M 8 bK
&% ^ED 8E' E( 2
; 2
&^
/_S
G
' ' 2x
" /"E
E< !E/
& IE&+*E
N E/
.1'S 2
8E' O
&&^ 8E
E @E/E+/ !E&Q !E&7;^E' 2E !EeE&L
E
? ^
< I/ 2
&&Q.
EE( EE7 *"EE
&EE&Q "EE*C=&EE EE ' 2DEE
& <
EE< !EE
&
^6 < ']@
!+ 'EG 'M]E !Ee !EDD(!E
8^&/(&
<
"') : L
"(2010
c
& <! < E+C
&E&QEQC
&
E< vE6 8E' 1EM* E
^ !E6<
E< IE !&7\"
&. !&Q
" 2w=% 8E
&E &+ !C@ECW ; FE U&E !E&QC==%E
^"
"(E
&"EE <EE7 rEED EE 8EE' ! E
& "'EE !
"EE
*"%EE EE"2^EE EE /
I 'L
K 3 <
7 0 <!.
&]@EE
^EEG
& < !EE
EE< 2EE3& EE
&EE
EE^6 &%EE' 2EE3
&5EE
<@! <
&]@ S 7 C
&%
23' !/SL
&.
5 /W
!&S
*_
& = !< &
!SS
E
" !EQ*
< &7 E&C
!&S
G
&
.
41
&% #
!" !
(
! G
"E("&
!^'/
& < !E'^E 5/5 E
&@E]'
E< &@E
E
EE/( !EE< ' /"E EE'L
KE 8EE' 2EE +/ES ' !EE& E PEE/
EE< I<EbEE+
" /'| W
& <!.
?
^ G
@ < I/ + & ']@
"E
E "CE EZ
'" ']@ & d '& 8' 2 +/E&CL W !E/
!E&w' Ed !E/S
&" O !G
? .
@
&=+
UE*+C E
& < g<E
rE / E&< &E= E+
'
E< !EEW
/+
".
EE/ "( 1E%EE7/
&EE&Q "EE*C%EE7
'EE @EE 1EE7<N
&" KEE' !EE/EED
@ G ' 8
S
& R 'L
K /
E %E7
& <E\ !E "E*' 2^E/
< " /
& &+ 'D 8:
^"
"(
& "' =
^C
%
&".
=&
&
^6 G bZW
K @ ' 1
& &+ /" 2G.
G
& <! I&+(5
& !&Q^<!
Z
& L E<W 2ED']@
; F
& "' &"E( 2E3
&E
!E&Q
&*E
E 6
& p
Z
&! W.!/
EEE EEE"C EEE ' 8EEE
& < !EEE@EEE]' 2EEED
EEE
EEE& :EEE
& <!EEE
_&!
"( <"ES E<
E
EG
E/
EED 8E' @E E
EG
!S@E
!EE< ' 8EE' E G/S (%42) 2^EE
& !EE&Q"EE^ EE' E G
d P %E / EE&' %EE0 IEEZ
:
&G
& <! W
&
^6 <
']@
%; 8^&/
&
^6 <
']@E
E
E<
E
& < !E
"E^ E
E
! ' !&7K (Natalija Sedziuviene, Jolita Vveinhard) :P/ 'L
"\ p
& <!
CG "C& &
^0("& <
']@
. /* - "7
& <! <
O
&]@.
42
* /
&
\Ex !E
& < OE
E< !E
&]@E
& < !E
& !E+
&"!"ER w%"( '* w%D6
"ES
!/EG
' E< !E
"E
&@ !GS
&".
! 7
' <! O !C
&]@ <
MN 'G & ;&=
&@.!GS ' <! &' |wC
&
^6 ' 26
' 8
&
( 1E&/"S
.
' <! &C
&
^6 "C
&&
< 'E&Q ED E+wC !6=< '.
*"5EE( 2EE/ '%EE' 8EE
& "'EE EEd
&"EEQ < OEE
EE
&]@EE
&"("EE <"EES
EE
' 8
' <! c.1/
* /
&%
& "'! *" 2^ /&
&! @
& <!. * /
&!
&"\!
&7 !&
< ! G
' 2^ 8&
. C
& <!
&@'! ' 2G7 8
' 8_ !e
< g/
&
^!. "<
Q
&/( !< '
"
!&w <
!. *"7 /
& <!
&@'! <
&
^! W ^ 2
& <! /+. !S/Z P/+
& <! 2SC !L
& <!
. *& / 2SC
& <!
"S
I' IG
& &.8
*"7 !*\ 8' rS
& <! <
&
^!. \ & 2SC
& <! ' <
! "7
& <!
&@'! <
&
^!.
& <!
&
*
@ O
< w
&]@ " I7LR
&@ !GSMx E
&*&!E
^ 2
"S
'!
&]@! 6 " rS*
6cL.
' <!
"S L
& /
@w <
& I&+Mx
<
E OE
&]@E< ' '"' I
.!/G
7@]' U
<
@"
!S
& !R&! EG W
&
^6 / ' !\D !6%
& <!
!GS d
&"EQ Tribal
2E3&
E
ES
!EE\L
&" !EE<SM EE< !EEM
&] !@EE
"EE^
EE '*"%EE <EE EE '*EE ' 8EE_EEL.
& !
) :2(2010
-
& <!
!GS
\!
! ? 2
&" I7&L
&&! 2D
&]@!.
& <!
!GS
&@'!
&
!S g/
F*G
&
!'D
&. I&+
& <!
!GS _ !e
g/
' 8
&
&.8/S
& <!
!GS
&x !G !CL
& ES Ed
!dE\ 2E3' !E/ /"E
&5!EC
" /
"S.
43
&% #
!" !
(
44
! W
mS
m #0 &*)" < "d
":
-
2 / D
& PG@ !&Q'^ !C; 2 bK
G
<
'*
!
(! 8 bK
@E= ES/ )
vE (2000
&@E
EG 2w
8E^&/
E
' ;
^6
"^ 7 ';!
&:!&Q
/H ) (3/5 UF #0 /N\
Q
";
+ "Q
"Q
E
p
_
* *
( (4! InformateU4
* O "
8 t #
0 "4Y
. "!
9
4 44444) %4444444W4444444 *4444444
84444444=
Capitalize /-<. E
Automate "444444 U444444O444444Q "444444Y
5
- *
>>
E U4-*4
P5.
#44 ZN44 =W44<)
44
44 S
+ 4
44R
Outsource
&%
:
@& .2000
* 2K
+ u_/:
&"
G 8' !
; 1 [1] 7
P %/G
1
^ < 1
"v6' U7
!&S
&_<! . bK
*
! v < Q
^ @7L
&! W !/
&@* !M
= "/< < <! ' 8
& 8%%
S
! .<
bK
*
! "^/
&
^6 ' v6= & 2
&]@!
*@ 8L < I
!&S
&_<!
'D 8
P/
&!
&@& D '^" ' "' <
&"^
2 ! 6' 3
&% #
!" !
(
&"
G "' p%/ [3] 7 <"' !/ 2@/; '* G
< ;
!D( ' 8
&]@! <
""+/ 1@6C U7 !_6' !<_' !&7< ' 23 bK
*
!
P+/=
&]@! 3 =&3 < P/&! K
&"
G
!^& 3
& 2; !S
*G
& "' ==% '* 2
&"
G
< !\D
PC+W ' 2& 8
&]@!.
&"
G [4] 7 !
; 23&/ <" '" 2@/G
" < 1<"
!+C 1
&2 %7
" U7
W b 2&
1e
^ < 8
".! 6' !<_' !&7 rS*/ 1@6C U7
< bK
*
! "^/
&]@! &
2=;6 K
&" 6!6^
/
;W < g6C
" U7&3 7
< 1C .! 6' !<_' !&7
&"
G [2] 7" '" C P %/
*"%
bS< !
; < 1
2/& 1C .!
!<_' !&7 rS*/< bK
*
! "^/
&]@! *< 1 &
2
;@ 1Z "7 ' 8
!/
* 56Z
6
1 CW ' M 8&3b
*
%7L ; F ' 23]= <L " &/
&
G
^6 "+/
@ I
'
Gd/
& "GS/ .
8EE^&/\ pEE
& < !EEEE' <
EE
&EE
EE^6 <@EE]' EE
E
E !E< &
E
" !E& EC
!E&S
FE; E< ^*E bKE
&]@E &2E3
'%EE ' EE
"
EE
& < !EE' EE PEE+/ EEM 8EE &"EE&C OEE W
& < !EE
&EE
^ '"( D
< /
&% "\L <
& . !&Q]/
'8DE
' 8^&/ 86'& <
"\L
:!E&Q&
!/^6< ]' !E'S'
E E& / E
/ " 8Z
& <! <
&]E/ !&Q
EE/
"
E Ew
&E
.E G'/ EM 8E 5EKE
&
2D
' 8
&
" 8
& <!
=%
&! <
&.!&Q' U_/
46
8E ^&/
EE
!EE&Q&
!/%EE7=" EE\L EE; 1EEC
EE EE^6
EE&
EE
EEQ<
44_u
EE EE/ @EE
KEE
EE< 1EES/Z 8EE EEw "rEES* UEE7"
EE'
EE EE !EEQ<*&
: 2&
KE 8E' u_E/ ."+
'@" I< 2GS@&
<
/"
u&@/ K
G
!&
&"
Sedziuviene, Jolita Vveinhardt )
(Sullivan 6
"EE)"EE&C EE 8EE' EE^6
EE&
W EE/ EE&C EE
Onge |EC g/ES
") E&C ( Brooking |E )"E&C ( Skandia /^E )"E&C
( Petrash EE ) "EE&C ( Wiig |EE/") EE&C (Sveiby
G6EE )"EE&C (St
E 2%E6
8E' E Petrash Skandia E&C E E/ "E !E
bKE 2E(L
:
*"
Skandia *A -1
E&
E+'
E< E
EG
8' ( ;Leif Edvinsson 8%< )/
47
8'xE
!E
!
//"@E
Skandia !E0
E< E^6
& /' x 8 7 ^6
^6
& + !/<
&! S
! = 7"@
&! S
E
D 8E' E E^
G
! /G
L 2& 5 3&" +'
< / "5
(Andrew Kok ):
^
*" 6
& p/
^
& + G
^ =
& 6
&
Intellectual capital = Human capital + Structural capital
'"EE
EE/
EE
! EE"&&
EEd
&"("EE
EE^
EE&
EE
EE/ FEE;
E< G
'
& 1<
&(1 '8^&/ 5&
K
&]@! 6D
uEER"
wEEG' "EE&C /C^EE !EE0 EE^ E 7 EES< b+eEE 8EE^&/ 8EE^
1EE '8EE^&/
:
2^
D 8' u_/ ^6
& 2^
! 6&
\
Market Value !7"@
&! S
&
Financial /"&
&
Capital
Organizational Capital
&
Customer Capital
'
&
&Q
48
'
(3) Ua
^
UP
< ;CK
2^E
!E&S
@ES !7"@E
E
&E
&
/"E
&E
'
&
&
&Q
K @S/ b
E 'E
& !E
' W .
*A -2 Petrash
ES/ )"&C (Petrashs 1996(' !E 8E' E; 8E^&/ 2EE'W 1
&E
"+6
' 8
&&^ 8 'D 8
" /
K
D 'D 8 @ '8
'% D(!.
!& :@'D
&
^6 <
']@
/
&
^6 <
']@
;
"' 2
/"E E< !E6L
&]@ * rS
"+
<@! <
bK
&]@ '
EQ*/ EM 8KE
&"E6 &E EG
EE
& 8EE
& 8EE 8
]@EE EE
@EE =EE+
& bKEE
!GS@EE
&]@EE < EE
' p
&ES
'E <
EKE EZW KEG/
& "E < E bKE
&]@E ("E
49
&% #
!" !
(
G
"E /'| '&5E
& !E
&E
E^6 E= bKE
EG'| ' E
EG = UE
'G
&!
&"! " / 7
O
"'/ 2 8' & &) :
S(2010
=S
'"6 uR'*
&
^6 rS* < b
<@!. p R
PC+
G
&/"S'|
&"(!
&!
&
^6. "@' C 6CW
'| &!
&
^6 < . SC
"*G
&!
&"(! "*C! '| &!
&
^6. " IR'| &!
&
^6 5 = C < ./ p R=+
&@'! < '| &!
&
^6. p R
& 8
"3&/ 8/K '^" C /"
< @w'| &!
&
^6. " pcC^'W
&;! "\ 2_<x '&^!. p R
^/* I' p
"
&! %
& "'!. !G p R;( "
& 2'G D
&!.
HS
(! ")*A "YA "
pM0 <
)
: (u
=SC ' 2SC 8
& <!
*
& <!. =EESC ' 8EE
EE^6
EES <EE /"EE EE'| & !EE
&EE
EE^6
EE
EE^6
& EEW
&' < .
= '"' 8EE pEE7
EE EE< (Reactive) 2EE 6'|
EE
&" pEE7= EE "(Proactive) !7GEE& !EE
&EE
EE^6 =EE+' 2EE* rEE/Z 8EE
& 2EE
!eEE0
^EE0
EE ]EEG
=
.
UEE\" EE7
8EE' EE/
EE
EE ; EEEE
t
8EE^&/
EEEE'
(&!EE
' u%
&E
E^6
E 2E/"*
E< 2E3&
E& IE7
&E&Q
E&Q'
E ' &!E
Learning Organization ;K/ F) E< (Peter Senge |E " 1E
E G
g'E
" EE6^/ = 1EEC EE0 EE/;"EES/ EEM EE * 1EE(* EE' EE/
& !EE&Q 1EE G/
"7EEG
^8EE
*
&&Q 6
& !&Q
< u+
&@ 2GS
^ pE8E' 6@E pE
!7Z
(& I< ' < !E
& !E&QE ' !E"&+' 8E' EG < @E') .E
G
*&(2010
& !&Q
& &!
O
& !&Q
E7 !E& "E*C &@E' 2^E
@E
^pE
'EE?' IE
%EE
! /@E
&; !EE? !EES
IEE' /E
& .2GS@EE
" IE7
&EE&Q <
EE
&"'EE&
@E E
E( !E EED
^ 8E
&E&Q
& &E&
E !EE
EE
< &@' 2^ bK6Z E*' !+ '&@E ]' !E7 8E' E7C E E7
QC
SG
*6
^' 1" P/ 1C "^/ '@"
& <!
@E' 1 !+/
"@&
27L
?
&"(" <
.!EeG& E
& !E&QEQC E '"E6 E& MxE E*/
50
2004 @EG^
' E).rEG
!E7 P
2w uG%
6c"=^
& <! "
.(
! E< &
@ E 1ECx E
E / ( E& ) !E< &
rED &G 8^&/
) ECx !E< &
rD & & @ !
G
D 8' !G
6
&
!E& &
! E&Q&
!EL@& E
( Pearn et al1995 EDN E ) E/
ES/ .E !&S
"'! Q&
P7
< IS <
GS@' ! ;"/ <
' 23&
Senge, :2&E !E& &
! E&Q&
!E EC"^' gE&D (Peter Senge1990 |E E )
(P.M., 1990)
2E& = !E&Q&
!EC"^&
! E6
! E&QCL 1E %ES/ System Thinking ;4
4
.
&&6&
8 d 2^ 2'^ ^
_ 8 2%6' 2^
&@EE' 2^EE !EE&Q&
_ EE EE7 EE %EES/ Personal Mastery "E44NP" 44)
5
rE&
E< FE*G
EM "ER"' 2^E IE7
"EQ
/E
&"<S
5
./ /"
8E'
E
E6
E E/
! K
" %
%S/ Mental Model "W
.! ' !S/ %/ M
EE7 EE! EE/" EE( EE %EES/ Building Shard Vision "
P44" 440
44+
PEE& gEE
5EE&
EE
EE& "EE*C <EE .!EE&Q&
_ EE EE
!EE' !
EE
.O
// CL 8^
6c& Q
E&Q&
E< "E+
" E^&
2E3&/ rE/6
E FE; Team Learning T0
.!3/*
51
&% #
!" !
(
Concepts & 2^<L
&6
" 2w
S
& &!
' M 8=^ W
./+
44YS Competence 2&EE
&EE = EE
EES
!EE& EE v&EE EE
&( /
" & .
*^Connections U 2&E/
E7
E6
&G
!E
E !E&wS
*"E
EG
& "' ? /K"
.
EE
8EE' dEEEEC '"EE6
& !EE&Q
& & !EE
2DEE' rEEG
!EE
& < !EE EEQ
&
^6 <
']@
v=SC
"( 1E
EKE
&"E6
8^&/(&
*"
G @') :
*&(2010
KEE
&"EE6 'EE+ Vision !EE/ 8EE' EE3" !EESS; 1EEC FEE; !EE 7@EE/ 1EEC
?&" /6' I' 2D D ' 23
P/
&!
&^.8
&&Q <ED 8E' S E<L
^_E
gE
8E ]E/ EE<L
&" Mx
!+C !&Q' 2D ' 2E3W
.!EeG E'L
KE I_E/ E7
'"EE6
& !EE&Q
& & OEE0 2EE*' !EE EE3/
8EE' EE/
@EE= ;"EE 'EE EE !EE7
<L
&.!&Q
_& 8
&&Q
8' /
<S3
S
& u
%
& 8;
< !/G "6' rG
& !&Q
& &! */
!' !<SM( ' 8=6 ;" &
.
8/G
!+C
"S v 2D
&&Q !'"Q' 1+ 7
2D
& !&Q
& &!E
"*C + E7E<L
"E &/ 8/KE ES 8E' EG
"ES 2ED
&
E !E&Q
;@ '"&+ D.
& !&Q
&"
&;!
/(! Mx
!eG
(! .KE !<ERW
EEG' ECS
! ' : 23
^6
& '"Q
"6
%
&"
S
!/
&E!
E
<L< r/6 " @/
< Mx
Q "<
!G' 2& !e&
&
^
!&Q
"7 8' I '@* GS
? (K < !S< 8' ( 2EC
& <!E
/5 ' ' D .
<"EER EE ' !EE& 8EE^&/ rGEE EE
&EE
EE^6 <@EE]' EE
EE
EE
EE
*"
:
&@&
& <!
^'!
&
!C5 <L
&
&
2P/
"( 1
* 56
&^.8
& <!
^'! *" /
\" <^ ! ' !/'&"!
&]@!.52
" rM<!
&
!/^6
<
& :23' !&Q
&%
?
"/x ; 1 2%*/ &< 7"S<L '' PG@ !< ' 8 < bK
& .
*" 2/
&
^6
D 8' Marketable values !7" !&7 =D=^
=&
&"
!
!/G
!&S
&_<!
6
& *" 2/"\L
!/^6
'^! <^"S; 6* !/
&]@!.
53
&% #
!" !
(
&^"C
!:
&
G ). Human capital (HC
&
^
)Structural capital (SCCustomer Capital
' U '
O)Relational capital (RelC '
Renewal capital (RenC) /+<
/" 2GZ &ES
2E E+C ']@E
E
E<
E '
E
'
8@
& <!
_ !/
&
'! L &
&@"
& /
& "'
& '.....2
U4 ; FE 8E' 1EC
&E6 I_E
%E' !E '+ *%E UE \*E
& !*%EE
EE( 8
&EEEEG'
EE< 8
& !EE
& !EE6
EES
EE 8/=6EE '8EE
EEG
&"("EE . EE & EE bKEE
&EEG'
EE !EE
EE g/
PEE+/
'EE+ _EE/
26
7 8 ^'/
&*R
& ' 2
&.I&+
O 7 8&_/
! '+
(!
!S3
&G
! 8
! '+
E '+']@
& I&+DL ' /
@" Norms of Behavior
54
EESG
!EE&
" EE&
EE /"EE
FEE*G
EE+' EE< EE
EE
& 3EE=
&! QC&
< 3= D= G
!G(L
<^
& L&"! +'" 1C^
6
!
& bK p/ Z<
< = "!@]&
I' +@ I&+&
! 6@< 8' r <L&^ /
! W
EE
rEES* !@EE]&
/"EE EE< @EE EEM 8EE' EEDL! EEM&&
@ EE]&
EE< wEEQ
&
.0]&
QC
; L 2/"* u&@ !/ 5/5 .!@]&
!&S
&! "
p\"
S
.^6
@!
& w
3
C"^&
?! .!/
&d! /
&0]&
8' D ^".' rS*
!7 ^"@EE]' EE< EE^6
EE&
EE?' EES
EE< EEC=! EESC EE/* 8EE^&/ EE&
!+EW! E
E< E "%E&
@! Ew
E+
2E'@ "ES ED 8E'
OE
G@EC! ("E '( Skandia !E0
E< E^6
E&
&" SGZ ! '+
:
*"
^
& + G
^ =
& 6
& Intellectual Capital = Human Capital + Structural Capital
&Q
& + 2&
&
^ =
& Structural Capital = Customer Capital + Organizational Capital
!&
' + W& =
& Q
& Organizational Capital = Innovation Capital + Process Capital
!"&&
d
&"("+!/^6
3
= W ' Innovation Capital = Intellectual Property + Intangible Assets
(See:Dorota Weziak, & :
E
" E*
E uER"
8E' E OE
E 8E^&/
Andrew Kok )
55
&% #
!" !
(
P5 Human capital UP0
R
":
&?
!:
^"
"( . *
"+.
G'|
!
.!%
444 \ ) 4 4
&EEE
: EEE&Q 'EEE EEEW
&^ !EEE
( !EEE/^62&EEE/
&?
!:
!"C
"*G .
Internationalization 2/
\ !& :
& 2&/
&?
!:
!+
& !/
&!. =
5
!
&]@! .
Financial capital
" IR
&
&]@! TY-0W * /! p4&0 L4H L94N
4R \
4Y "4 #4
_O4
44a * x44I
\44 S W44 44/Y0 4!
44R U44
44
44 . "44
&
+
/0/- #0
a
"
A* V0
Y
!
:
56
P5
< 7K
&*" D
&?
"E^'
E !Ee
Eg/
<
']@
&]0
G < r
& <!
O
*"
:
)( See: Ibid
&%
.!/G !e
.g/
" U7
^
Full-time
" U7
Part-time
w5+ !G@C
' 8' 8 !e
+' 8' 2^ g/
FE*G
& E'E+
E g/
E
E
^
.() !e
d !G@C
& 8W 8/
^
.()!e
< r
^
.()!e
< r
^
+&
!G@
!e
F*G'+
.g/ '
/5 )
@ !G
&D 8'
!/"e
8.(27L '"
&
!
'
@".
K6 /W.
&
/
.
3*G (&
!
S
"_d < !e .() 8 '"&+ _
!eL !&/
.!3*G
8/K & .() ! 35 ; 25 8
8/K & .() ! 59 ; 35 8 '" 8
!e
& F*G
8
. '] 0
S. '] 0
< !. '] 0
&^.8 '] 0
!.
P/. <RW
&" 86c
"S 8/K .P/ '"&+ S6C
.pc"' 2^
P/ -
@ !G
&6C
!/"e
8' P/
&5.!C
\ Structural capital !"&+' 5
&]0
'
&2
&
&Q
O
*"
(See: Ibid) :
57
&% #
!" !
(
Customer capital U /
E 1E< 5
& < !E
& E& !ES
!E '+
&
*^"'!
!*%' !G;%
! '+E*L 8E^&/E
&]0
!:
& \*
&. !*% G
&|
!.
&|
!
'. 8
&|
\
!6.
^
.
&" <
.
^.pc"' 2
^ 8' "_ 2
!e
!3*G
.!@/
^D 8' "_ 2
. !e R
&.2 '% p/
@".r/ \"
! '+& .1 '
"\ G 2
.!^G
< 83;G+' 2 .%
&]@
"*G
!'"S. !G@C
& u
"
.! '+
;( ) <^*
c* "( /
E 1E< 5"E\L Ed
&&"!E
'D
&^G
& "'.
^ !6Q
!
&(W
&^G
& "'. 6CW
^.pc"' 2 (&
'+
^.P (&
8/
^ P
&"(". (&
'+
/ . (&
8/
/.
"\ G 2
< "_ 2^
!G@
!^G
!e
!3*G
.!@/ '"&+
&G
!
;_". '"&+
&G
&*!
;_".
@&
&(W& <
&G
!.
@&
&(W& <
&G
&*!. (&
"%6 /
&@& <
^.P (&
&=S
"*G
&" '"@' 8 . A and B (&
&=S
"*G
&" '"@' 8 . C
&(W
&(@.
&(W
".b (&
_ !e
+
< g/
&+
&!. (&
_ !e
+
< g/
&
.
.Internationalization 2/ GS ' 8
*G.
S /5 * &< !3
*G.
;( )"
PE FE; ("0
&^ !E
!E/^6 '"
E< E IE/
& <!E
^ *
;& .!/ 8^&/
&]0
!( See: Ibid) : :
&^!
. Intellectual Property !/^6 =D
&@ !+
.! '+
8' 2D =D .
"S; 8' 2D
IG
.
44 ;) (44
44 ("44 8&_EE/ 'EE
& !EE EER\*EE
&!*%EE
Q/ p
< r
& <! <
& !&Q 8^&/
&]0
!:
&
^ : '
&!. '] 0 R
'.2 ==%
&0G
& / 2
@!.
59
&% #
!" !
(
-0
& I&+
&* .
^
rG /K
&" <
E7
&E
E^6 <@E]'
E
E
E
P+/ "<
S <
O
&]@ w%D7
! &^ ' 8 '2DE
EE <
EEW EEQ
EE @EE/
&EE
EE^6 .EE/ EE' EEG
d
EE=]EE
EES
&" u%\; P
&E
E^6" Intellectual Capitalists& E/ EKE
&u%E
_/
!EeW !E/
&E
& & 8E
ES EQC rED
E 8/E Ee @E
( !EEEEG EEQ
EE
&EE
EE^6 . /440/- #440 ZF
E44N 4! /)
44 4
) *-
(( Charles R. B. Stowe. ) :
7
!
"\. 2 '
^6
S
_&' < 8
< !6' 2D
& r
^6
. /S
G
< !6 2
&=+.
2
S
< ^6"'L d
& ) !w
D ^6
%(.
" IR
"_6
< !Gd
@].
S
"; 8 F*G.
S
& 2 _" < < r/ _/ wS < v;L ^5' 2'.8 <
!eG
!C"CS+ ;& !/
&
^6. /0/- #0<
>
&( S
!(
( ) *-
):
@&
(
=& "S
G' < 2D
&]@! &
rS*/
S
(' /S '8
&"
G
&& I' P 5;(
&&Q
& < !6
&< < I&+
'! 7'!.
W !+
?!
"</"@' I' r
& <!
&!
"
=+' < !S
P/
x 2&!
&"
!/G' "\ U
1
& "S / L.
^ *S F/ '% ' <! (/ 'D 8
"\ 2%' I' +/WCW
& <
& K 'D 8 \ ;(
& '^ L
'G
*@ 8
"./
7
<@! '*
! @ '5 &^ ' 8
&<@! ' I
&]@
&*! !G(L
(".
=
5 & rS
"+
'! <
< 2\. ' ! ' 6
& ' (' 8
&
2 7 . ' !&w60
=
5 "\L L
&! Professionalism
@&"\"
u
'@"/ L
&
&.
5L
^6
K 2D
&]@!.
&
2
& <!
^'!
(& I
' 8*" /
\" <^!/' ! '&"!
&]@!.
G' rG S
&^ I&(
8
'.!@]&
8
5
*"< 5
& " !/' u
;%. =&
"+ PC
& " !/
< !/^6
& 2&!
S
!/^6
7 W!
6.
!& -
& 2
.
S/6
61
!0 !
; !! %
& L
' bM^ 6
& &
G !'( 1
:
'!CL 5+
@! G
L
http://www.hrdiscussion.com/downloadfile/2195/1/1256763968
./]&
:/
(1 &!
& &! )Q&
& Q
( 2007 ) _D "& " /( 2
E< !'
<@!
&@/5&
^ <
6
& (2010 ) 6
G 8&/( 3
"eEE
EE7L EEG
EE&
/"EE &]EE' :"EE* 8EE' !EE< &
" EER
.// 20-18 U/"^
/"
7 !'W
E\ &
E&Q&
8E' IE<
E< E! EW! E< &
E; E
" 3' M 8 (4
http://www.aecfkh.org/articles-action-show-id-30.htm :
'
!E7& +E ! :W < 5&
S
! <
3/; + (2006) 8@*&
G &*' r<" (5
.
^ 6
S
&"S
.// 20-18
E
! < C! '- &Q
L < M
& <! (2009)
G 0 (10
."C"/ 1
29 +&
!
!
+&
!CL! %
.!/W&!
!
&! Q&
:S
!< &
(2005)
@G^
8/
( \ 11
P
E! E7 EZ : E^6
E&
(2003 ) E E&; u
\( 6&
( ;;" 12
!/W&!
!
&! Q&
: S
1 !Q<*&
E rEG
IE' E^6
E&
/"E E< E 6
P/E
(2010)E E&*
EG !
(13
G
& /" &]' : *"8' !
%' !/ < (&"S
5'
.// 20-18 U/"^
/"
7 !'W" e
7L
F/*
' +
P^&
S
;
0*M
!" ( 2004) @G^
_ D ' (14
<Y
^
U_/
< * (2009)
?&
6
G &*
G (15
:
'(&
S
, accessed on 11/10/2009
http://elmaghrby.com/researches/3.doc
8EE' EE&L EE0 EE< EE^6
EE&
EES! EE (2005)pEE"/ 8@EE; @EE
EEG (16
!EEE '( !EEE/W" EEE
%EEE7=! EEE "0
E444>" 444" 444!
E444
444:"EEE*
.2/ 29-27&!C"/5
:
'
& <!
& "'1(
5/5
G (17
http://www.inteltao.gov.jo/forum/viewtopic.php?f=12&t=1949#p6137
62
E
! E'
! Ee6
8' !
*"+ -^6
& (1427 )+ ;& 8 8&;
G (18
. http://www.yamany.info/images/Art4.doc :
'5&&
! e6
E/*_!E< &
E^6
E&
_ 5E&
8 F*G
2G
< (2010) <8@; ! (21
!'EW" eE
E7L EG
E&
/"E &]E' :"E* 8E' !7
! GZ
. // 20-18 U/"^
/"
7
&?2c < S
" 6&
2S' G
&" F/*
" 6&
" &@
(
22
"'.!S;&
http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:zG8DuVOPhn0J:media.kenanaonline.co
".m
44
44 (4! (0
44( <44
< 0*4M (4! "4480/-
4 >&
:( CEE3
E
2/ 15 14 "%&
(' ! !"
!
! (+
E (! ()*
(
31) Andrew Kok ,Intellectual Capital Management as Part of Knowledge
Management Initiatives at Institutions of Higher Learning University of
Johannesburg,
South
Africa,
Available
at:
http://www.jpsdir.com/forum/uploads/13352/Kok.pdf
63
64
65
&% #
!" !
(
66