Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome
Council on
Compensation
Insurance, Inc.
RESEARCH BRIEF
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
JUNE 1996
National Council
on Compensation
Insurance, Inc.
I. INTRODUCTION
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome (CTS)
causes thousands of lost workdays
per year and costs industries millions
of dollars in workers compensation
claims. Indeed, the Bureau of Labor
Statistics (BLS) found that the median
number of days lost from work for
CTS claims was three times the national average of other injury types.1 In the
last few years, there has been a striking
increase in the number of CTS injuries
reported in the workplace. NCCIs
Call for Detailed Claim Information
(DCI) data show that the relative frequency of CTS claims (as a percentage
of lost-time workers compensation
claims) increased by 55% between
1991 and 1994. In addition, out of 10
nature of injury categories researched
by NCCI,2 CTS was the third most
costly in terms of average cost per
workers compensation claim. Yet, little research exists that has analyzed
1 Occupational Injuries and Illnesses: Counts, Rates, and Characteristics, 1992. U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor
Statistics, April 1995.
2 NCCI, Workers Compensation Claim Characteristics Series, July 1996.
RESEARCH BRIEF
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
JUNE 1996
First report information (information from six months after the claim was reported) was used in analyzing frequency and
demographic information. Second report claim information (information from 18 months after a claim was first reported)
was used when analyzing CTS costs and milestone durations.
4 Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, March 9, 1995.
5 Ibid.
2
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
RESEARCH BRIEF
vibration, the manipulation of small
parts and the use of computer keyboards and mice. All of these actions
involve awkward and repetitive movement of the wrists and fingers.
Initial treatment of the disorder
may include the placement of splints
to the wrists and hands for several
weeks in order to restrict movement
and reduce swelling. Anti-inflammatory drugs, including cortisone and
steroids, are also administered. In
advanced cases, surgery is often
required. New treatments and surgical procedures are beginning to see
better results. These include an endoscopic surgical procedure6 and a nontraditional carpal tunnel release
operation, which is a 15-minute procedure requiring only a small incision
and an average two-week recovery
period.7 These forms of treatments are
only in their early stages of use and
their effect on the cost and duration of
CTS cases is, as yet, unknown.
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
JUNE 1996
Figure 1
PERCENTAGE
2.0
1.5
1.78%
1.77%
1992
1993
1.97%
1.27%
1.0
0.5
0.0
1991
1994
ACCIDENT YEAR
Source: NCCI DCI database
6 Endoscopic Release of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome. Roth, James H. , Journal of the American Medical Association,
Sept. 14, 1994.
7 CTS Prevention, Treatment. Pagnanelli, David M., Occupational Hazards, Volume 51, April 1989.
8 News: Workers Injuries and Illnesses by Selected Characteristics, 1993. USDL-95-142. Bureau of Labor Statistics, United States
Department of Labor, April 26, 1995.
3
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
RESEARCH BRIEF
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
JUNE 1996
Table 1
FREQUENCY (%)
1.7
0.4
0.2
1.6
1.3
1.4
1.8
0.4
0.3
0.7
0.2
3.1
1.4
2.3
2.4
2.7
2.1
0.2
1.0
1.2
1.8
AVERAGE
COST ($)
12,731
14,514
10,553
19,250
9,639
18,812
14,421
8,169
21,581
10,375
10,031
15,930
11,889
7,572
11,442
9,597
STATE
AVERAGE
COST ($)
2.0
0.9
2.7
1.9
3.2
2.1
0.8
0.7
1.3
1.6
1.8
2.6
2.8
2.6
0.8
1.6
2.6
2.9
2.6
1.2
2.9
9,699
9,166
15,914
7,904
18,690
19,338
12,994
20,056
12,904
12,312
18,368
19,371
15,392
12,602
5,667
10,899
8,798
8,581
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Utah
Vermont
Virginia
Wisconsin
FREQUENCY (%)
V. COSTS
Carpal Tunnel Syndrome injuries
are among the most expensive types
of workers compensation claims. Out
of 10 injury categories studied by
NCCI, CTS injuries had the third
highest average incurred total cost
per claim of $12,730 (includes lost
wages and medical costs) as shown in
RESEARCH BRIEF
Table 2.10 Incurred costs include both
paid to date and anticipated future
payments to be made on a particular
claim.
However, average CTS claim costs
varied greatly by state as shown in
Table 1. Illinois had the highest average cost per claim ($21,581), while
Utah had the lowest ( $5,667). Idaho,
the state with the highest frequency of
CTS claims, had an average cost of
$8,169 per claim. Eight states lacked a
sufficient number of CTS claims for an
accurate average claim cost to be
determined.
When analyzed by accident year,
the average incurred cost per claim for
CTS cases was higher than the average
for other injuries for all accident
years studied (1991, 1992 and 1993).
However, this cost differential
appears to be decreasing. In 1991, the
average total incurred cost for CTS
claims was 34.2% higher than the
average for other injury types ($13,594
vs. $10,128). In 1992 this difference
dropped to 9.8% and by 1993 CTS
costs only exceeded the average by
4.7% (see Table 3a).
10
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
JUNE 1996
Table 2
AVERAGE
COST ($)
STANDARD
DEVIATION ($)
19,036
215,799
1,522
249,769
13,526
65,410
Contusion/Concussion
10,060
154,707
Fracture/Crushing/Dislocation
15,639
569,552
9,430
84,974
Laceration/Puncture
10,039
102,710
13,105
143,486
Other Trauma
14,121
247,300
Sprain/Strain
11,537
558,660
Amputation
Burn
Infection/Inflammation
Table 3a
1991
13,594
(56,555)
10,128
(691,249)
1992
14,586
(78,680)
13,289
(404,191)
1993
12,284
(52,274)
11,729
(344,791)
Ibid.
5
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
RESEARCH BRIEF
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
Table 3b
Indemnity Incurred
7,654
(43,163)
6,774
(440,367)
Medical Incurred
5,872
(37,209)
5,267
(84,423)
Figure 2
20,000
15,000
14,586
13,594
13,742
12,284
10,000
9,238
12,215
9,324
8,069
7,816
5,000
1991
1992
ACCIDENT YEAR
11
Sprains/Strains
1993
Fractures
JUNE 1996
Overall, when medical-only cases are considered, medical costs comprise roughly 52% of total costs.
6
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
RESEARCH BRIEF
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
Figure 3
12
13
JUNE 1996
Carpal Tunnel
Syndrome
20.5%
35.4%
Goods/Services
Goods/Services
12.7%
Construction
4.8%
Construction
3.7%
Other
13.1%
Other
26.1%
49.7%
Manufacturing
21.4%
Manufacturing
Office/Clerical
12.7%
Office/Clerical
Figure 4
20,000
16,784
16,027
15,712
15,000
13,861
11,758
13,240 13,021
14,047
11,436
9,767
10,000
5,000
CONSTRUCTION
OTHER
INDUSTRY
Other
The five aggregate U.S. industries are Manufacturing, Construction, Office and Clerical, Distribution and Services, and
Other industries. Other industries includes mining, transportation and other professions.
Number of nonfatal occupational injuries and illnesses involving days away from work by industry and selected
natures of injury or illness, 1993. Bureau of Labor Statistics, United States Department of Labor.
7
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
RESEARCH BRIEF
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
Figure 5bSurgery
31.1%
31.9%
68.1%
68.9%
OTHER
CARPAL TUNNEL
42.0%
14.8%
58.1%
85.2%
OTHER
CARPAL TUNNEL
Male Female
No Yes
8.3%
6.3%
91.7%
CARPAL TUNNEL
No Yes
14
15
93.7%
OTHER
18.8%
13.6%
81.2%
CARPAL TUNNEL
No Yes
86.4%
OTHER
JUNE 1996
Statistical tests (T-test, F-test, Chi-Squared and Duncans Multiple Range test) were performed on claim characteristics in
order to measure for statistically significant differences between carpal tunnel syndrome cases and all other types of
injuries.
According to research published in Workers Compensation Recipients with Carpal Tunnel Syndrome; the Validity of
Self-Reported Health Measures, Katz, Jeffrey N., et al., American Journal of Public Health, Volume 86 (1), January 1996,
females taking oral contraception were found to be particularly susceptible to CTS.
8
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
RESEARCH BRIEF
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
Figure 6
JUNE 1996
35
33.0
31.6
28.1
30
26.4
25
21.8
20
17.4
15.2
15
10
8.6
7.4 7.7
1.0
1.7
0
UNDER 24
2534
3544
4554
5564
OVER 65
AGE
Other
Figure 7
400
$387
390
380
$372
$374
$390
$370
370
$360
360
$355
$359
350
1991
1992
1993
1994
ACCIDENT YEAR
Other
9
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
RESEARCH BRIEF
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
Figure 8
350
325.3
300
243.9
250
142.8
150
100
50
209.1
198.8
200
67.3
58.4
24.4
0
REPORTED TO INSURER
RETURN TO WORK
CLOSE OF CLAIM
MAX MED IMPROVEMENT
Other
Figure 9
150
146
121
120
89
90
60
45
30
0
YES
NO
SURGERY REQUIRED
16
JUNE 1996
Other
Changing Composition of Workplace Injuries. Helvacian, Mike N., and Christopher K. Fred, NCCI Research Brief,
Volume 3, Issue 1, April 1995.
10
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
RESEARCH BRIEF
number of carpal tunnel cases as a
percentage of all lost-time claims
increased by more than 50%.
The high cost of carpal tunnel syndrome cases is an additional area of
concern. Out of 10 nature of injury
categories studied, CTS cases were
found to be the third most costly type
of injury. The average cost of CTS losttime claims is more than 12% higher
than the combined average of other
lost-time injuries. CTS injuries were
also found to be significantly more
expensive than other injuries of the
wrist.
The higher indemnity cost of CTS
claims appears to be a function of the
relatively long durations of these
injuries rather than claimants wages.
Indeed, the average weekly wages of
CTS claimants were significantly
below the combined average for other
injury types, while the time to return
to work was 144% longer.
Many of the characteristics of CTS
claims vary significantly when com-
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
JUNE 1996
11
1996 National Council on Compensation Insurance, Inc.
All rights reserved.
National
Council on
Compensation
Insurance, Inc.
750 Park of Commerce Drive, Boca Raton, FL 33487