NATIONAL ENGINEERING SERVICES PAKISTAN (PVT) LIMITED aEx NESPAK HOUSE, 1-C, Block-N, Model Town Extension, Lahore -54700 Pakistan FAP POWER & MECHANICAL DIVISION 978 Ref: 3714/165/AHM/B3/0161 Dated: January 15,2016 Mr. Han Lei Technical Coordinator, Harbin Electric International Company Limited, No. 135, Street 9, Block XX, Phase 3, DHA. Lahore, Pakistan. Subject: ENGINEERING, PROCUREMENT AND CONSTRUCTION OF 4180 MW CPP BHIKKI ASIC DESIGN DRAWINGS, References: [1] Mis HEI-HRL Letter no. HEI-HRLFPKBK/INESPAK-0074 dated December 29, 2015 Dear Sir, This has reference to M/s HEI's letter (Ref [1]) pertaining to the subject matter. We have reviewed the basic design drawings and our comments on the same are attached herewith. It has been noted with great concern that the revised drawings have been submitted without changing the subsequent revision no. HE! shall check and correct the revision no. of the drawings, so that an error free review process may be ensured. Mis HEI are required to incorporate the comments and resubmit the revised Drawing and Calculation Sheet for our further consideration/approval. Regards, Very truly yours, for National Engineering Services Pakistan (Pvt) Limited, At) Vera (AKHTAR HUSSAIN MAYO) Project Manager Encl: As stated above Copy to: 1. CEO, QA Thermal Power Limited, 7 C-1, 1# floor, Gulberg-ll, Lahore 2. VPiHead (P&M) Division, NESPAK Lahore 3. General Manager (Technical), QA Thermal Power Limited, 7 C-1, 1* floor, Gulberg-l, Lahore 4. Company Secretary, QA Thermal Power Limited, 7 C-1, 1* ficor, Gulberg-ll, Lahore 5. Master/reading Files Telephone E-mail PO. Box Fax: +92-42-99231936 lim. p> TUV Lahore, Pakistan Website: www.nespak.com,pk austereREF LETTER: M/s HE! BASIC DESIGN DRAWINGS (ENGINEER'S COMMENTS) HRI Letter No, HELHRL/FPKBK/NESPAK-0074 Dated December 29, 2015 sm | contaacrors BBCPLNEM | wa wo.| “orane."= | oRAWNCTme | PRCMINEN Ts se mcuamcs ENGINEERS ConmenrTs Mac oorroraawor men an Recent a eee - aes [ADM BUILDING. sil LeneateT UsLonDe Dae, | istribute and upload copies to OMS for featweron eaten leona [TECHNICAL DESCRIPTION UPLOADED Dus, warring [NTE84Y approved in Category 02. China & (FO6861C-N01-01 HVAC soy ons * |Desien Review Meeting. See Attached Comment lorie are fontanene lose seas Taree | wnresurr PEW URoA2E ous, wilco cance ier neence . om [RAIN WATER — [FOR Exaanine [3724/365/AHM/83/154 Dated 12 Janwary, 2015 fruation& «| rousrcnoeas feotne cone wc roorons sessed commen sat excinaron sneer ; [nets reiewea ong a Tar coon semen lnzowncssiaverorme _ltwuamearcnvmcreret ce * | ascnnor fricoumncinon | Mmtuetwt Jp owrenaconmy og esac pro eos me ~. [Review [Revised document with the changes marked een ere: clearly (clouded) care mass oncrae ncoaor [CASE C24°C GAS FUEL, Mechanica, — JuPOATE attached Comment Shee © | Resercsonas Poe evarcoouenon, | MECHANEA erat omnes set, or coun ear amasscincone easeo seccocruce > sconce : wccinwoat — furoare See ace amet shes ace |2X3, EvAP COOLER OFF, . = se ono ercooune cara nase cnae 10 CASE E47, Gas FUEL (MECHANK Juroare ‘See attached Comment Sheets a eae |2xa, EVAP COOLER OFF, neon: oe ne aso, or cooun cara mass onan 8] rossicmon [SEES CASIUEL | ecusem — forte Set mace comme shes easevouo,orcoowie cara wasscincrwe 1) reemicmes (ESCO | enn lepers See atache Conant sheet ese ton, ercoounslear & ass omoRaNe resssicsorcs [ASEH Ae cas rue Jaase 10K0, or cOOUNG ecianicar — furoare ‘See ettachod Comment sheets lear a mass oacaam Jost aac casruet, sr, evapcoouenor?, Base concase 24 Jou rue scr, evar Icoo.en oF, arse vono| ossssc02.07 wecnawea, — fuvoate Soe attached Comment sheets Jr ocean) oF rosssicxo226 ersraat ame cowtnot |conorrionms sstene Juroxoeo ous, warns FoR |Comments communicated veer ference esavane S7sS65/aHW/39/163 ted ancy 15,2015, ei anen aie lrcxDe ows, wamincroR_|canmens communist vide letter reference vosssicxa227 |eenraa an conte ae oi Espira damper [conorniowinc stem bean [704/1s/an0477263 sted mary 15, 205 eresserarinc srstem| rocssicxoa.ae [Pel DAGHAMFOR uronoeD ows, warING FoR. [comments communicated vide eter referece: Jccureatconrou Jeciane p7sees/anan@s/163 ded anury 15,205( 23-0012? — 1,160 MW CGPP Bhikk, Pakistan Proiminary review procegure [Comment Sheet iD: 16.11.2015 l 05.12.2015 Reviewer: | Employer / Document Control [ NESPAK? Document Control Lahmeyer / Document Control | Contact: | gmtechnical@qatpi.com [pm. nespak. bhikki@gmail.com piotr. sputo@de.lahmeyer.com | Drawing/Document F06861C-NO1-01 I | contract Drawing/Document Ti Besides the information discussed in the f Subjects and the document itself are al lea: Contract Specification, Techni The Categories of Approval follow: Chapter xxx, page yy Approval or comment will ical Description of HVAC System 1= Approved, no comments / Reviewed f 2 = Approved, with comments/ Reviewed as noted Fee erent Not approved, rejected / Retumed for correction a=. iccordance with the 4= For information only ‘ot relieve the Con- [tractor from tulfiing his Contractual obligations, Cat: |2 Com | Review [Do | Predeces | EmployeriEngineer’s Comments Contractor's Action Conclusion mID: | er c | sor (Tobe submitted together with Re therevisedicompleted docu- v 1 [NE o{NIL Mention other codes 7 standards as per Clause 613 Closed, of Employer requirement in basic conce, HEI will update the document 2. [NE 0 | NIL The indoor design con distrib Clos distribution is maxi Sper Clause HEI will update the document, 6.7.10.4 of Employer requirement. Please correct 3. [NE o [NL 50% RH in gas and steam trubine is quite high and TAs Per Clause 6.7.10.4, 80% | Closed check Wath eae cen ess than 80% RH. Please | RH'n gas and ea trubine peck with electrical / electric equipment maximum | is percnoa humidity accpetance. eugipment in the gas and am turbine halls 4. [NE ONL Add air change crateria in Table 1-1 for ventilation | Ar change rate has been | Closed, areas. added in Table 4.1. HEI will update the document 5. [NE oY NIC Add all areas including electical and coinrol room in| Noted Closed, 1g like pumps room, treatment plant, HE! will update the document. {ube wel, canal water intake etc. in Table 1-1. Please add all areas of Comment Sheet iDxxex for Document IDyyyy Power plant and 500 kV sub-station 0 tot - — Wen. as {hp Zz. (520-23-00127 os|23-00127 ~ 1,180 MW CGPP Bhikki, Pakistan inary review procedure in Table 1-1 6 TNE 0 [Nic The reffence for excess heat emission in sleam and | Noted Closed, 98 turbine halls is required. Use actual data for HEI will submit actual data at equipment detail design and submit for our review: the detailed design stage, 7 (NE JOT Nie n of evaporating cooling units size fs | Calculation wil be provided | Closed, required to review before detail desig during the meeting, HEI submitted the preliminary load calculations which will be eviewed, 8 [NE 0 TRL The ventilation or battery room shall be of minium six | Notea Closed. airchange. HE! will comply with the E requirement. zi 9. NE OTN The cooling load and ventiallion calcualions of all | Noled Closed. areas need to be provided for reivew before detail HEI will provie the design a per Clause 6.7.2 of | Employer calculations. For basic requirements. For basic estimate purpose, please estimate purpose, 180 Wim2 {ake value not less than 250 Wim? cooling toad cooling joad will be considered office rooms. 10. | NE ONL Specifically smoke exhaust areas in separate clause. | Noted Closed. provide seperate somke exhaust 14. [NE 0 [NIL ing shall be served with VRF system. | Noted: Closed at Page 10 in basic concept, There is not seperate Laboratory Building. Laboratory Room is inside the Control building of wat treatment plant. HE Provide Fan Coil Ui 72 [NE [0 | wit Reo ensure that al the requirements as stipulated | Agres in the Contract Documents for design and execution I! of the systems are fully complied. 13. [NE [oO [Nic HEI fo confirm that Employer's Requirements, good 7 compliance | Closed engineering practices and/or implied requirements statement requirements shall Cave been completely incorporated in the system, | bo eevee by Project Checklist / compliance statement to be provided Management Group L along with all the system drawings. Comment Shest IDxx0 for Document IDyyyy Page 20f3 i QP. 20280012723-0127 = 1,180 MW CCPP Bhikki, Pakistan Preliminary review procedure NESPAK Comments answered: Date: ee -—— Lead Engineer Name & Signature Contractor Comment Sheet IDxxxx for Document IDyyyy Page 3ot3 3 @ 20-23-0127 ft