Professional Documents
Culture Documents
الأحكام الصادرة من المحكمة الدستورية العليا بعدم الدستورية وبرفض الدعوى منذ عام يونيه 2011 حتى ديسمبر2015 صادرة عن المكتب الفنى بمحكمة النقض
الأحكام الصادرة من المحكمة الدستورية العليا بعدم الدستورية وبرفض الدعوى منذ عام يونيه 2011 حتى ديسمبر2015 صادرة عن المكتب الفنى بمحكمة النقض
( )
2000 2000
2011
2011
2012 .
2012
/
....................................
......................
49
...
73
101
32
1133/7/13
1133/8/31
" "
32
( )44
127
1980 152
2009 "
1968/12/1
" .
2
113
28
" "
1133/33/31
:
:
( )17
11
1991 9
2005
-9-
1133/33/17
47
129
31
1131/3/31
" "
1131/3/19
( )51
.
)
.
4
199
27
" "
1131/1/4
() 36
35
1131/1 /34
10
1976 " :
"
2006/2001
* .
* 31 9139/1/99 ( :
) .
-31-
220
19
1131/4/3
1131/4/31
( )11
" "
15
146 1996
.
6
161
31
1131/4/3
1131/4/31
" "
15
( )1/82
23
1992 "
) .
.
7
183
31
" "
1131/4/3
:
(
( )337
58 1937
( )534
17 )1999
.
-33-
1131/4/31
15
114
22
1131/1/6
"
1131/1/11
( )11 136
" "
20
()
1981
.
9
261
24
1131/1/6
1131/1/11
" "
20
()
() ( )24
30
)1977
.
10
273
25
" "
1131/1/6
:
(
(/567) ( )1/580
17
1999 (
)
( )580 )
.
-39-
1131/1/11
20
()
11
255
24
1131/1/6
1131/1/11
" "
20
()
90
1944
.
12
95
23
1131/6/1
1131/6/31
" "
23
()
482
1987/12/5
.
13
193
29
" "
1131/6/34
:
()189
17
1999 ()1
( )190
-31-
1131/6/18
26
14
20
34
" "
1131/6/34
38
1972
120
. 2011
:
108 2011
.
:
()
108
2011
.
:
123
2011
120 2011
.
-31-
1131/6/34
24
( )
15
57
34
1131/6/34
1131/6/34
" "
17 2012
24
()
73 1956
16
82
26
" "
1131/8/1
1131/8/31
( )2
19 150 2001
91 2002 2003
-31 -
32
()
17
56
31
1131/8/1
1131/8/31
( 6 )11
" "
32
()
120 2008
()6
.
18
79
22
" "
1131/31/34
:
"
() ( )3
2 1997
11
1991
1992/3/5
-31-
1131/31/14
42
19
151
27
1131/31/34
1131/31/14
" "
42
( 5 2 )79
45
1982
.
20
133
26
" "
1131/33/4
( )99
109 1971
25 2012
-31 -
1131/33/34
45
( )
21
183
1131/33/4
29
1131/33/34
45
" "
( )
( )2/87 69
()4
1994
)
.
22
52
27
" "
1131/1/1
( )167
-31 -
1131/1/34
11
( )
23
155
1131/1/1
22
1131/1/34
11
( )
" "
() 95
1945
250
1952
( )56 109
)1980
.
24
167
20
" "
1131/4/7
1131/4/37
( ) ( )1 2
1997
11 1991
1991/5/4
-39 -
15
()
25
200
27
26
30
" "
1131/4/37
( )44
11
1991 91
1996 ( )43
( )6
.
" "
119
1131/4/7
1131/4/7
:
( )19
79 1975
47 1984
107 . 1987
-91 -
15
()
1131/4/37
: ()4
31
()
27
162
31
1131/4/7
1131/4/37
( ) 17
" "
15
()
( )35
11 1991 9
. 2005
28
161
20
" "
1131/1/31
( )13
192 1958
( ) ( )72
( )73
100 1964
73 1953
-93 -
1131/1/16
21
29
145
27
1131/1/31
:
(
( )20
25 1929
100 1985 4
)2005
.
1131/1/31
:
:
103
157 1981
187 1993
.
: "
" 2004
91
2005
3 2005
.
:
.
" "
30
229
29
" "
-99 -
1131/1/16
1131/1/16
21
( )
21
31
292
29
1131/1/31
1131/1/16
" "
21
( )113
( )134
82 )2002
.
32
29
31
1131/1/31
1131/1/16
" "
21
91 )2005
.
33
37
33
" "
1131/1/31
1131/1/16
( )20 25 1929
100 1985
.
-91-
21
34
17
15
1131/6/1
1131/6/1
" "
22
( ) 1 ( ) 3
162
1958
.
11
4
22
" "
1131/6/1
:
(
( 9 ) 10
114 1946
)
.
-91-
1131/6/31
23
()
16
230
25
1131/6/1
" "
17
41
26
" "
1131/6/1
:
(
( )79 60 59 58 49
1977 ( )33
99 1978
(/ 2/9) 136
1981
1965/3/22
)
.
:
: ( )1
( )42
97
1983
.
-91-
1131/6/31
23
()
1131/6/31
23
()
38
112
34
" "
1131/6/1
( )2 120
1980
120 . 2011
( )8
109 2011
: ( )24
109 2011
()
38 1972
( )230 .
-91-
1131/6/1
22
39
127
30
1134/4/6
1134/4/11
" "
( )341 ) .
.
40
213
32
1134/4/6
1134/4/11
( )1
" "
16
()
( )108
16
()
70
1982
.
41
24
33
" "
1134/4/6
1134/4/11
( )14
10
)2004
-91-
16
()
42
10
16
1134/1/38
:
: ()9
1134/1/14
() ( )21
" "
21
()
70 1964
6 . 1991
43
75
26
1134/6/3
" "
44
35
30
" "
1134/6/3
: ()
( )2
2936 . 1992
:
.
:
( )83
66
1963
.
:
(
( )341 )
.
-91-
1134/6/9
1134/6/9
23
23
45
180
24
1134/7/6
1134/31/31
()
1134/31/11
" "
28
.
25
1134/7/36
( )955 )
46
" "
205
43
13354 1995
()3
" "
394 1954
.
47
150
31
" "
1134/31/31
( )56
-99-
1134/31/11
43
48
131
32
1134/33/8
1134/33/36
" "
46
443 . 2003
.
49
196
35
" "
1134/33/8
1134/33/31
( )26 394
1954
6 2012
()17
-11-
45
()
50
36
19
1134/31/31
51
28
" "
1134/31/11
1134/31/31
:
(
190 189 184
13 1968
18 17 16 1
90 1944
)
.
-13-
-13-
51
()32
132 1964
( 24)
70 1964
6 .1991
" "
120
()
1134/31/11
51
()
52
21
30
" "
1134/31/31
:
( )223
12 . 2003
:
( )223
.
:
( )223
.
: ( )1
216 2003
217 2003
: ( )256
( )223 .
:
.
:
.
-19-
1134/31/11
51
()
53
22
28
" "
1131/3/31
1131/3/11
"
156
2002
1395
2002
( )%1
-11-
4
( )
54
205
28
" "
55
165
30
:
1131/3/31
:
519 2003
73
2003 142
2003 % 60
.
:
.
:
1131/3/31
( )108
17
1982
.
-11-
1131/3/11
1131/3/11
56
34
31
1131/3/31
1131/3/11
" "
( )14
1990 "
" .
.
57
178
32
" "
1131/1/34
13 )1968
-11-
1131/1/11
()
58
200
32
1131/1/34
:
(
1131/1/11
( )434
" "
()
) .
.
59
78
36
" "
1131/1/34
1131/1/11
( )26 394
1954
6 2012
( )17
-11-
8
()
60
88
36
1131/1/34
61
1
37
1131/1/14
" "
62
15
37
" "
1131/1/3
( )26 394
1954
6 2012
( )17
.
:
"
"
383 84
. 2014/12/23
:
202
2014
" ()
"
( ()10
46 )2014
.
-11-
1131/1/11
()
1131/1/33
10
()
1131/1/3
9
( )
63
16
1131/1/3
37
" "
64
18
37
1131/1/3
(
( )10 6 4
46 2014
202
2014
)
.
:
1131/1/3
1131/1/3
" "
202
2014
" () "
.
65
24
37
" "
1131/1/7
"
" ( )1
( )8
46 2014
.
-11-
1131/1/7
10
66
120
20
1131/1/34
" "
67
323
23
1131/1/34
" "
68
144
24
" "
1131/1/34
(
()48
35 )1976
.
:
(
( )580
)
.
:
( )32
256 1993
49
2006
.
-19-
1131/1/11
12
( )
1131/1/11
12
( )
1131/1/11
12
( )
69
22
25
" "
70
107
32
" "
71
149
33
" "
72
227
20
" "
:
1131/1/34
(
( )305 )
.
1131/1/34 :
(
( 65 ) ()68
95 )1992
.
:
1131/1/34
(
( )222 221 42
"
.
:
1131/4/33
(
230 1986
)
.
-11-
1131/1/11
12
( )
1131/1/11
12
( )
1131/1/11
12
( )
1131/4/11
16
()
73
56
27
1131/4/33
" "
74
177
27
1131/1/9
" "
75
22
29
" "
1131/1/9
(
( )2 ( )11 ( )14
10
)2004
.
:
(
( )20 25
1929
( )2 ()11
10 )2004
* .
:
(
( )341 )
.
1131/4/11
16
()
1131/1/11
20
()
1131/1/11
20
()
91 9131/1/1
( : ) ... ( :
. ) ...
-13-
76
122
30
1131/1/9
" "
77
96
31
1131/6/31
" "
78
70
35
" "
1131/7/11
(
( )37
71
1946
)
.
:
(
( )499
13 1968
76 )2007
.
:
:
( )123
91 . 2005
: "
"
( )122 .
-19-
1131/1/11
20
()
1131/6/14
25
()
1131/8/1
31
()
79
116
29
1131/7/11
" "
80
87
33
1131/7/11
" "
81
63
26
" "
1131/33/7
(
( )341
( ) )
.
:
(
( )117
49
1972
)
.
:
(
() ( )567
( )580
17 1999
( )
( )580 )
.
-11-
1131/8/1
31
()
1131/8/1
31
()
1131/33/38
46
()
82
50
33
1131/33/7
:
(
1131/33/38
46
( )120
" "
()
1376 1998
)
.
83
19
26
" "
1131/31/1
:
(
( )917 )
-11-
1131/31/36
50
()
84
173
29
1131/31/1
1131/31/36
( )72
" "
50
()
()4
1994
9 2009
( )69
( )69 )
.
85
14
30
" "
1131/31/1
1131/31/36
( )22 1 2000
-11-
50
()
86
97
32
" "
1131/31/1
:
(
( )152
13 1968
23 )1992
-11-
1131/31/36
50
()
()
- -
- -
:
( )367
341 1116 311 . 1117
22
18
:
- :
( )11 11 3919
311 3981
33
23
- :
( )11 11 3919
29
22
( )34 31
41
27
-19-
( )1 ( )33 ( )34
73
41
( )11 11 3919
74
41
31 . 1114
()1
( )33 31 .1114
( )11 3 1111
85
45
:
:
( )31
391 3918
28
21
( ) ( )71 ( )71
311 3964
71 3911
- :
( )16 194 3914
6
1131 ( )37
.
-11-
49
30
59
36
1131 ( )37
.
( )16 194 3914
60
37
1131 ( )37
.
:
31114 3991
46
29
3914 .
:
:
481 . 3987/31/1
12
13
:
:
( )33 316 3983
.
-13-
12
( ) 79 61 19 18 49 3977
( ) 11
36
25
99 3978 ( / 1 / 9)
316 3983
3961 / 1 / 11
( )181
67
39
()
:
( )71 ( )4 3994
9 1119
84
45
( )69
:
( )1/87 69 ()4
21
18
( )69 .
84
45
3994 .
-19-
()
- - -
:
:
( )1
16
15
.
( )4 ( )39
26
20
79 3971 47 3984
317 . 3987
:
- :
( )389 37
3999 ( )3 ( )391 .
13
13
- :
( ) 114 37
11
(/167) ( )3/181 37
10
12
. 3999
3999 ( )
( )181 .
-11-
() ( )167
( )181 37 3999 (
81
43
) ( )181
:
:
() 91
23
19
" "
61
37
181 84 . 1134/31/11
()
- - -
- :
( )11
116
3991 49
1116
.
-11-
68
39
:
( )337
49 3971
80
43
:
:
( )81
43
28
66 3961
:
:
() ( )14
11 . 3977
12
:
111 3986
.
-11-
72
40
( )
:
:
37 1131
71 3916
15
15
()
:
:
( )44
" 3968/31/3
" .
( )
- 1 :
- :
( )9 () ( )13 71
3964 6 3993
() ( )1 1916 . 3991
-11-
42
28
- :
( 14 ) 71 3964
6 . 3993
50
31
- 2 :
:
91 3944
11
13
38 37 36 3 91 3944
51
31
.
.
()
- -
:
:
( )11 311 3964 .
50
31
:
:
( 1 1 )79
41 3981
.
-11-
19
17
:
:
( 61 ) ( )68
91 . 3991
70
40
()
:
:
( 9 )31 334 3946
35
24
()
:
:
( )37
33 3993 9 1111
113 3993
341 . 3991
-11-
() ( )1 1 3997
33
18
16
3993 . 3991/1/1
() ( )3 1 3997
33 3993
24
19
. 3993/1/4
( )44
33 3993 93 3996
25
20
( )41 ( )6 .
( ) 37 ()11
27
21
33 3993
9 . 1111
311
30
22
.
" " 1114
93 1111
1 1111
( )311 93
-19-
78
42
:
93 . 1111
32
23
()
:
:
( )3 ( )1
361 3918
34
24
()
-
:
( )117 18
11
( )143 .
39
27
( )143 .
44
28
( )111 .
69
40
( )143 .
75
41
( )143
79
43
. 3917
( ) .
-11-
:
- :
( )111 31
52
32
1111
.
( )111
( )3
136 1111
137 1111
( )116
( )111 .
.
- :
( )111
31 . 1111
316 1111
3191
1111 ( )%3
-13-
52
32
53
33
( )
:
:
( )13
10
.
.
()
- - -
- - -
:
:
18 3971
311 . 1133
318 1133
.
-19-
14
14
()
318 1133
.
311 1133
311 1133 .
:
:
( )1 311 3981
38
26
311 . 1133
( )8
319 1133
( )14 319
1133
() 18 3971
( ) 111 .
:
( )16
-11-
47
29
- :
111
1134
" () " .
111
1134
" () " .
46 . 1134
- :
62
37
64
38
65
38
( )31
62
37
( )31 6 4
63
38
46 . 1134
46 1134 111
1134 .
:
( 6 )33
311 1118
( )6
.
-11-
17
16
:
:
( )911 .
45
29
( )414
58
36
83
( )937 .
44
:
:
( )3/81
11 3991 "
11
.
391 389 384
51
31
57
35
( )111 113 41 .
71
40
( )499
77
42
( )311 31
86
46
31 . 3968
31 . 1968
-11-
:
:
( )331 ( )314
81 . 1111
31
23
:
:
( )311
3176 3998
82
44
()
:
- :
() 16
11 3976 "
"
. 1116/1113
-11-
10
( )33 346
. 3996
11
:
( )48
11 .3976
66
39
()
- - -
- -
-
:
:
( )3 ( )318
71 3981
40
27
:
:
( )99
319 3973 11
.3981
-11-
20
17
- -
:
:
( )34
3 3991
56
35
"
" .
:
:
( )318
37 3981
55
34
:
:
( )3 ( )41
97 3981
.
-11-
37
25
:
:
139
1111
54
34
71 1111 341
1111 % 61
:
:
441 . 1111
48
30
()
:
:
( )17
73 3946 .
-19-
76
42
()
()
49
49
()
50
57
50
57
51
58
51
()
( )
52
56
58
()
( )
58
53
()
53
54
()
54
60
61
()
60
54
()
55
55
()
55
62
63
64
64
65
()
56
()
56
-11-
62
65
68
66
68
66
68
69
69
()
66
()
()
67
67
-11-
69