Proceedings of the Sixteenth International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence, 1999.

 
 
 !
"$#&%' (*),+.-0/2143657 89(:'
;0<>=?<A@CB:D&EGFIHKJ&B:LLNMOLP@CB:D&MRQSB:TUMOQUV
W*XRY[Z B:Q\];^`_aL b_KF c>M`MOde;gfihkj FCl6mnMRQJ&B4d Z B:QU\F&oqp Y hkjOrOfsFutHs;
v>v>v?ExSw J&QU_4B:E~_4B4Q_OQSxS!J QUw _4B4ET_4T B4w xyQSMRxSd{J B4zOT|}T ExyxSMRJ&d B:~Q_
w w
 y
 U
%6y)k(:5N1O)
u44  O ?
G  
*G94&G:R94*nG&!:9S*4u94
4

>S n& 

:G CGU  
4RGS4S*OGS9OS`NSS4**?>9*ya4:y4>4U S444R44*4G:9y94Gg*4S4!Gyi49u9G44
! S>CS!U94 4:4994:9G"$#
'
y  u9g9G
%# (
!  uCS>**Ry94&
O*GO9*G494R9q4:a4:u:4GuS$*K*49SyR9SGG$R9u4*R
{1 k
) # ] + *-,/. 0 % # 
y!u4!4&s9*S:4S9y4&SsO*G

)#
4>SS949Os
! :ay9 23#N 4 65
) #87
R


:
!
9
514C(4#
.
$#n
// %D% ## : &E 1 
9:ay9:4S?6yC4S*gSOG!Gg4*Uu9444g!SSG9y99449.&?9*OG*9G94
 #;  n
.
<#>=:?A@B-C
R4&49&Ua9y49&4>>U694?y994US : !>USG464>G&!9*44:a*4:4g
 # n**
<@ #2 C # % #
C9*44a6y y9*94U9a4:Sg4gCS9:!4SN4[CsSy2S*>yaG**Gk
u :#; 9 Fu< # `R44y99g9S44USGRy> 9y>4Gg9R
US94440R9G G9>94OGu94:*4O9nGG9?qu::9$949G*.9PCOS*
99O*GR9S4S*494>yS!Sy4499S49]>{S94:$S g 999!y4*4GUSS44O 6444u9:RR`a*OG49G
H O&G"
IKL#M J 2 # % # OO N
SS:yG9O4G*4 y! RS49>gGO*G9S!4]4SyGu944RU9G!y44 Sy
GOaSy9S:9US`G4y9494:$u4&4s4ySG4OG4y>>y449g?S*Gq9!9a
G:9>u4O*G94GG94 RS*GU
9R49*GO>4uG409R49*9R*`9!9?*Gu9.994Sg!4U99?UO*sG494
S yqG99?4!UGg?S?US 9u yS49`> *694GU R494 6 449S9 49:4!9yqGg94UqS94Gg*9SgGSyG99q: 4.99.4q4aSU
uG4464PCy*C:s49G4Q 4 99#R 44: 9y:>GS!as:C:G4*S9>4S gs9y
$ 5#u#&y)
uS:4 ORSS:ayq9uSG:y99y9y:?gaS*9*!444g.4UyG9U*N!::9!44: *R99R*444>Sy$4UsSS$C9y444UsS9:?9 CRSy*9>4&SU4SGU9S49
94gg944!RS9RUgPOay99:4:**S4y?G9nG 4! R2S4*G!g!94yy uUn G99*40G?4>RSk!4?4>9S44
u4 ?' US $GU S4 G SS :4G9y49>SRy: ]9:T 4 9 U94W4VkyyX" : #
9 iR>yy
u

% #  Y





>

>

gUS**Ry949US49*
Gyy G *nG4[nky[ 4USP G >!? G Z 9

9y!  RG u9a>!9$:*GC6!4G9:9*494RGR4uUC?4 >99:4!
L
1 nK
$#n
) #N{+*-, . %W#:E


R
[
G
\
^
.
`
]

_
X
a
O
b
e
M
c
G
d
a
 SG
u U S4 G 9 ROUS9a:y9.uU>u09GG S 9G : 44G I  y U
 U4 
 f6G9gRS>4?9G>!U94$u$9Rq94

1.0

20


15



10

0.5





10

100

1000

9 G:44
q9G
GR44!9D S9Gsy4 G ! 49494q::9!G?S4:?99:6499GGy4G4.> GS0R* G94?4 44 OOgG4G4!O99R9RGSS449Ryy9>944*
RS9 9R9O0 S4:C9G`SS&9:9 49*9u4>O9GuuSs&994yI44R4R`GO>*G4494RIu949R4Uy 9G` G*4S ssu4: 644>4:US9G9:4999449GG>SS9q0S9&G944
SSu:q9:>G9!4:94G!UO49!R49Gn9* 4UGg4Gy>9Sy4U 44U9.*?94y9R94sG4R94 !G9g444O
49944G6 $#Ggu4q4CS!U94u2u94s O R94g99!RN44S4Gy RS96 9%W4#ZS >49:::>9G94G>:4944S]4y
UR!9G44*SS4u4GCSg9:y4C*9C US4#&GyU!R94y499:gy4u4R49u4S:49S6GSG4s99:U4 RSk H 2 u!Gy9 G.9:!9S44g90Su94RRSa*OG49
4:a4SG*4R&U>R!64S44>!S4y94U40R9 > 4# a4>?99:S9
) #
) #9 #
#4
#
9:64U!4USC4U! **Ry949&% # R O?Gs R
* I
L # # 4 N 9
9aGy9*- 23:a# y!9?S9 :9RSS4!>9!F OG23#>SS:!RS40gRyS499yG 4*9k
uG%W#99 4f y4qy9uGRuS ESN2y# 4S 4) # 4S:qygRSu 42 # ?y96SS9y 99S: !) # u4y* 4S?RU9RS> # US**RGy0949G9& 9G*49 9:R9994&9R9S4S4*
9:Suu4!?4!94964R:G94G G$u#>4>`4*6gS4sO9R:Su]4 :949:4?9U49 9 yu49y4 s4*OGGO49aS&USSyU!*49ay4CO*G94>S
9:UqS9G4*G*4!Ss4y9999gSS9R9Rg*: 4%WS#&4S4[U 9u.*44U y4G94g!S 6SOCG4G4C:9O!*G*44!SuGG4949y9&O*4y99gR*9yR9
9:u4 G*4u W4V4k6yX 9:>y 4H * 9SGG$*9OgS9q:y49!4GG S y4?9O4y!:U4U &[4G4S9sG *R4SCu*y94UGyG>S 44 y 94CORG444s[y
99:F %W# USg**Ry949u:9 23#u6940CyaS9G4 *yG4R`4UC SqaR*SOuG4SR9U49uu4!&9:C49 GO6S9S&sS9&9R:S44
SOS*R9S:?US:O 4*G944GP
&99:{SR44S4 CRSC**y*9Ry944?9 uR4&OuG49:4G09GnGG>0RS`:*99GG y>44 u94Ry444
uu4R&UG:9G44UUS4G9SS44ys 9y4 6CyUU4 * 9*yOG9:4994 %W9#GG4:U yG44:UO9*GG949GSGyGG904RS[449>Sy9C:R9!S R SO0SaUy9
4S4O 49!:y 9GU % S# 4O u :G9uq4GG499G:4 6%W9#4n0R4`9y:G9> !u*auG>:G*G9q9u*aOUGS>4U094u4>,SyCG9S4? :Gu4y!SU*
4y4994S9:90GR*iaOaG469u9yu4qSSg9:S:49Sy9G94S u994yuU9G
!S9:9
S9y*R4:!g9::94Gs
yy!*!*uRG
$ 5 `8u)k36')4(458 89I' (4(4#&(
u44g?!9y?9R49g[994$y99:4USu44.GO99[4S4 R9yCU* G`gG4* :9's:64's(45S498 `5 )kR8#&S4P's (4(:#&q( 9:SCP4S 9OG4494
uG:99u9C46S9!G4 ) #sS: %DS #&S S4 C
S#U S :44G RaS*COG4999y&CRSS y949SS4US4y99y9U6G>94. 994: R RC**94O.G9:!94G[94! S
S& y G4RS49y4! #a:NUS49&4S>: 449y SN4CS>**Ry94u9RS:!9:*4>

-1

-0.5

0.5









21

43

0/

65





7

-98

;:



=<

?>

@



#"

$"

&%('*)

&% B)

,+

-

DC

C4.5
C4.5

C4.5
C4.5

30
30
25
25
20
20
15
15
10
10
5
5
0
00
0

5
5

10
10

15
15

20
20

25
25

30
30

30
30
25
25
20
20
15
15
10
10
5
5
0
00
0

5
5

boosting stumps
boosting stumps

10
10

15
15

20
20

25
25

30
30

boosting C4.5
boosting C4.5



 
"!$# %
&'()


)$*+,&()
,"!$-. /)0123& %547650
85&59: /*
 /) /+;&(<
%+.0+.=(4>60

@?ACB/DEGFH476$
I)
 J4>64C0))
%59:)K60LKK)
6 M)
%)N %
K>0) N0G)6 N)OLPQ4%$ /)

09
)
6Q

9 R&' %4>6.08SKTK65 @UWVX4%(+
) Q0H J04>6Y
I)N
# /K)6 Q) %
)Z %
Z7) .[\
;' %4% /I)>]Z0P' !Q
)65 M
# %& /4>68S^05+)65 _`VX4%(+
) K
# %H)65 M %
7) N0a&'I)

:5R)
N[\9 >b)H59:)7]GH&'I)

:5*"!Q[\

:6()
9)>]%GcN9:9S /K7) %N6C# Z&' % %C# %7 %+.0# /K9)
9 P
C
&' %0M
+5de0Z&(
)
'f[gTK6 .hMiVX+5
:$ %

:

)>0+'0+j J
R0H)65 k
4%$9 %l(
:)O<(mRP'04% Q0H6(<V
')65 % %C=` % ^b

)74% ^nP9$ %Z %)R09OH? CD"]o=(' %4%
qpV
4J9:9<(^()6 /<
%+;) /4765
rI5 %Nbenst0+;uZ0
9 %Q? /D
)$60Lv)6)Z)6 Q %5 %79:
wJ)
j %
J^LK
)6;65
:6;
&WV
&
9
)O<I^0
M)K
)
yGx a?"z,[b_']N| { UD}e
~ G

+ p %+.)&'

UP5

O

[_]

dM
e

O)H
PI5& %i
:;?qRA>}QA>DLK65
:4>6
H'

:)

# K
q0+9<*
q
z4/
%4%)
9:<Y4%9\0

qp %Z)
6  %l0$9 3 /0# %C^S)6 Q0V

)
+ M)
6 Z0

4J&' Z
I)
%5 %)
%+0M C05 Z0
4%(p+ /4% Z
)6 N %+5
:4/)
aH=`476'0
 K /)s9X
0# %+$)6)
9\0
 %Q
:5R)6 .)>0

Y %))
79\0)
.
:()
j(V
' %
K' %K&+..)
6 Z % /709
wJ)
$ %
J=(' %4%
qpV
4J99:<(^)6 Z / %79
:wC0)
 %
N
M0)K)

LK6 %
yGx ?: DP+ %5) /* %$

4J95&'0&
9
)O<,)6 )
7
:`V

>059: TK6
;&'5+5 /),)
60)Y&'I)

:5LK
99
0# /Op)
qM5oQ)(,I<j5+J^
O ^H0de&' %4% %
9\0
 GOX04%)C^()6
K
 /)
 %i+( %K605 %GuM0L %# %C^

J9<, %l( /
 %()
J^H
%# /709Z0)
6
?"(^KAC1^G1CDK&5 %
# %+
%$

4J099<,)6'0)&'(
)
ob) /+( %,0# %Ep)J^N %# /
LK6 %.
bP)
65705+K0G5+JH3 /0# %C^
)PLK0&`V
 /# /+*)
60)cM+nP(
)GLP9+
$ %)
 /4%()
( P)
K+
#
+0LK$)6 R % %>09
wJ0)

 /M95@Wb) %K)
6 Z)>0

Q %OV
Z60+Y J4>6 %+,w% %
^S4/9: C09<;4/()>0+
4%)

:5)65 *


)Z0
)65 &'5+f&0# ,*

)7054% ^H)
6 .9 >b)Q
+ 
G1
650LK;)6 ,)
7
:5
:5f05+) %
);4%
# %Y05
-&(
)OV

Yo)
0N
9\0a "!.+ /4%

(VO)
% ;9 J
9qV

)65?"1/Da.)
6 .k9 %))
%m$+0)>0
%)J
O

%'5
)

)6 %

%$

4J9 p+5
:5J^
=(4>6
 . %)09OP?"1/DE^990LK
:5)
6 .LP8,Mns)9 %)
);?A
DE^
IC# @9) %
0)

:# @09<(
N
:Y) /Zs)
6 ;*b\(Q0
)65 *)
70

 /l`9 %CMTK65 *.0
0 %l059: [_a>U]N


y x a? 
a[_a>U]s/D} ~
G

0
ba0(<LK
)6Z6
6Z
&&
9:
)O<(N) i)6)S)6
a&'5+

Q %()
 %9<
:5+ %' %+ %()dR^)6 .(&' %Q0M+$0
&'()

SO++
)
a^0=(4>60

K %)P09O0# %+Q)6)H&()OV

K
a'0)

4%9\0
9:<Z0 /
# P0) %+54%
Z)6 
Q[\
R
r(I)

qp0&9  %5 J]

:54% K
)H4%54% %()>0) /K)65 M %l0$9 %
LK
)6Z)
6 P
9:9 %
).0

G[\LK6 %)
6 %H'

)
# HS %(0)
# J]%
n()

 G >S %4%)K)
6 K
:5a4J&' K % %$ %5
:

4J099<I^
bP

)74% ^5.)6 
6()
+ Z0P
1LK6
476.
60LKK)6
4%59\0)
# +
)

&)
0R
:5*)
6 ;)
70

, /lV
9 %K;)6 Yk9 %)
) %
m;+)70
%)JZOY)65
:Z4J ^ %# %oWb) /
)
6 K)>0

R %
P
J04>6 %Kw/ %'^(&(
)
R4/()
( %)Q
(V
4%
J0
)
6 
N0P)
6 )
7
:5
:5 %l0$9 %Z >S %4%)
Y
4%
%'+5
:5+
.)65 )
%)N %
C
cK)) /)
[g)*9LsC<(R
4%4% %
Ob59]);5 .)6 $

6()

9: C0 %+)6 )6 /<
.6C# ,& / %.0+

16

35

14
30
12
25
% Error

% Error

10
8

20

6
15
4

AdaBoost
Sleeping-experts
Rocchio
Naive-Bayes
PrTFIDF

2
0
3

AdaBoost
Sleeping-experts
Rocchio
Naive-Bayes
PrTFIDF

10

5
6

10

12

14

16

18

20

G4  y!R99y!S&9y 96y RC*y94G:uG9: * U9yG9U9Gg94*4 RSy2yU:49yR

4G[99C6 `*O>9G R y* 4 44g999!:::u>9u*R9.S99 Su?OG9>?S4* OS:49u9u49 g 44SG44? 9uG4* SyG944$!u&9G9*94
*4>O9uNSuSO Su44U9gG94*9S*CNU!OG4G
*G$994yy9>OG49*49y99> *u9G4Gu4> y 449SG:g4O9GsCI9g4.R*qG yu4S9
$94 94*C4U.9a:S9::44S9GGOy9S94.`G 944$`4
4q*4s>:9s4GC4u44OG9y*4Gu9q494!&4sCqSg4:S*!S4G99:k u*S?*9O S ?44G*44949*u4]9G4G9GO9GS:,6G4494g*44
!44gSGs
:G9!S:9SGS:POG4:4 94y9 R
ug4a!OR9:*GG?9 >9R9S94*G9S0U*S4G9*O,:4944449a*4 a*G9 UUS49 4!RuS4*$G9US ?4OS4444[gU9SP4OG$&449R 9[u
R494U  SGq4 *44qS:qG O94$*RSR4 y> 4O4S449C?O*4G9 44yu?9G9 yyyG!y9!S44yy944
SS:0!9O9USq?:3 S !!R99S4SaU*!O*GGs944 USRCR*G*CU 4:u*4U
O9q44SuG&:*O4??9RRU9Sg *SS9!gCS4!nGGC>4G4:9S*qS9yS
99y>a44UC:a9G!yG`!u!:u4SO 94SuuRSOay9:CS9 + S7' U(4S8Pa 's R)4S?*5G 90 R5S7 q7 98*1`q5s)4S:8#&GS * G 9
44>4*4$4uUSyC944*4G>yRS.C N9y4R4 > 4. RS9S!a:9 :
)4891 5N*1 5N**8 1`5 )k8#&
u9:4>>4S9S9y U9Gu944>*4!gy9699*9S:G4*4G 2 O9S.Gay49?S 4OGaG449*4US&Gu> :R4SG:!auRsy4y !GD4V>u!C9S9.4I*9S9yS:&RR4:4G44.99?UUU4SGO*SRG
UUSSGU9U49O&USN9 G4 RS4y*4GG9> GSO4G4*9RSS9yRuS:40.49G: a4u y4ySg*9:*&!G46a!uO*S4SS9:}S4U>9uS9U:S **RRSyu9U4

U>u:944?9G4>US44S9*9
USa4y449Gu *S G4SyyGGU&&9U44SuR2y9 9:4a9.944S4Sy 4us944g9U994USGa> U9:9R49 4RS9>G4! S :4999S?SyR9>a9:4?696*9499y9RIGuS9:g:USSyG499U4
R49gy 494>94S49y4UUS G9GS&G99y449US9k 4*:g9G>OR4R4949g 9UOSS*g4g4U4SG.4 4?SGy99:!u9OSy4
*444:R?y9>4>R>:4GS9G6O49syg4u :9?Gg4S9yS.4CRyS9?*:.9G9k 4U $.u9:4?yS949R0 RSO4 `y99yg!S4UySUSR*GS994y:.R99G
G9* u *R!S49U 9S44! 0 94G6SS&u4 yRSKS>y4G99y44! SRnGCu*Uy9Ug y 4USg:9UG:94   y49S99.*4uO4?49a:GGa`O4*!GO9S4g!4Sg94
G94CC&GG yOCuS9O49**a!OSG4a94Ru444 :SGS9949G*6G!C:U`9
GS44S4.q4S,O 4 $gUS94:$[9O4GG4994.4? SSO O>OS$:4uG9S?
S $?94Ugg!nGG:S9GyS9>949::y ?U*SGR69*4ayO9A
OSay9  u4[g RS S9g RS4}4

4R4y9gS 49yy4!R:SG*GUU.4SGG494gu?49yU99]USR USS:R:GsC9:*C9G:?44R,:4q44O  :RC4*9u9gU* !4Ny4N99y*UN y4O*S 9ag?yS9:*GG.*

! *4ug4US G 94 Z RsRG s S &946y9  4yu4S!: UuSSg 9 U 94O4!44yqG9>4R4 9NG494S y G9O4GuN4
Number of Classes

Number of Classes

>

7>

!:













!:



4:1/0.23,4/0.22

8:6/0.18,8/0.18

4:9/0.16,4/0.16

4:1/0.23,4/0.22

3:5/0.18,3/0.17

0:6/0.22,0/0.22

7:9/0.20,7/0.19

3:5/0.29,3/0.29

9:9/0.15,4/0.15

 R9 ?9y2S4O?GGS:4 uGS9RUyR9G* GG94!494uUSuyGG4O

OO*USG  94R&4GS*9U G 44  4 &S*
 >`uS: S:,* 49  U OGIS *y> 4G
yy9yU !U4GK$G4y:4UGyS4USy  

S 4U9CP4 ?:!*9 4>:9 S>449*s :i*USRRS:* 44

4uU G4n4Gy 
4 9G yy4u 4**
4 ! G: 94G 4s   V  2 44 a Z uyG 4 
G4*69yRGy4
69:4R!S fui{CS4:G`U (
9SO44 ?SG y9 944G ysnGG4*
g4 Sa4 g S G$&
>% S
9 RS:U/]!G  Uyu Ga
nGSny 4 4# "
 

  :
ZV *RGG' `Uy4OUGy4
 *i 4? 99q9sC 6 RS49.94*U 4G4yG?944 U nGO9:G
9
uCG*sGy4
 Ri9?U9q44sU!S  4OGyySRa !S9S9:S69O:Sq9!9*
9 4G9! Sy94C9y*sUyG:
 i)RnG$nCn q4 S4 yZ  G:* 44S$a:*SUG9yR4 U(
 :! 44 ,
 y y99y4uR4  yG9aS 4y : 4S : !4C 444G:` G  G4G:+kRyyG94
49>OGG:
Uu4y4q9> !64*499u9y s y 499*4O994!ga4Sy>4G RSC4G
 Gy 4 49 &
u 4Sy G *49O!UO*4GOU9S4 RyS4>S44y!U9Gs
G u44uy>q4  C964U9944u:S9G::  !aO:a: 92y*G 9 G4y
y4 9 4 : u4D * 4yUk,y : ' .a4 a O S-9.E Uy G4U  4n `y4
U yS!92969/:y  U4y 4 y94 R   G 99   U 
*GG9n4G> 4 

) VnU0#/ :RSyuaya*G:4Uy 4
U Sg9S9 C69*:Gy9U4 !O yRG9q S :RS4?4G:SS44Cy999*U
  4
Gnn  y4nyG4
4G 4y G4 0
E n  1
4  ` G4 R 4 a  yG+ k444Gy4
- 2C*4*:?94q:sG*C# *y 99 4  yPyUSG 4 U SG4I 4*yS GG
4GnG  y +kGy4*UyG:
U- 2C2C*y 4 444Gs " y!U * yRR*y 99u4 ? RyG494G4y
y>G4 4>4 >4 40 " 4U4 X   4 n y  4:Gn4G: #   4G  G 3 94
GG:
-2Cu*9g:944{4?R*Sy49 94!yRG GI9 4 .R S4! G G 4* R4 9!
* 

y 3 G 9 4U G   4  4+ nU:X  4G 4y G4

*RGa+ KU 4OUy 4


9:9/0.16,4/0.14

3:3/0.19,5/0.17

9:9/0.20,7/0.17

9:9/0.25,7/0.22

4:4/0.22,1/0.19

7:7/0.20,9/0.18

5:5/0.20,3/0.17

4:4/0.18,9/0.15

4:4/0.20,9/0.17

4:1/0.27,4/0.17

5:0/0.26,5/0.17

7:4/0.25,9/0.18

1:9/0.15,7/0.15

2:0/0.29,2/0.19

9:7/0.25,9/0.17

2:3/0.27,2/0.19

8:2/0.30,8/0.21

4:1/0.27,4/0.18

3:5/0.28,3/0.28

9:7/0.19,9/0.19

4:1/0.23,4/0.23

4:1/0.21,4/0.20

4:9/0.16,4/0.16

9:9/0.17,4/0.17

7:7/0.20,9/0.20

8:8/0.18,6/0.18

4:4/0.19,1/0.19

!

4:4/0.18,9/0.16

4:4/0.21,1/0.18

7:7/0.24,9/0.21

9:9/0.25,7/0.22

4:4/0.19,9/0.16

9:9/0.20,7/0.17

 GG4*2Wy  S 4u& SO949u4S!4OG 99RN*OG:9944: S9y49

SO`GROa94yy9q9 : !9:`G4u>:9:49UUS:4US6US94y.44Rg4SyC4:y4!9Us449!CsG96u:99yy44y44944
9
e 
6U 4 
4 u4 4!SOS 4!4!4G
4S:G 9:4>94 &yS4G?S9 :9qy4!R9S:y >G9yR>4S4>4y`S>:a 94*
gOG 4 4y
49C9Sg>&S499O4[S>&9OyGG94*
4
9OG:44>4Gq>9y9
R94:G! 9:GqCOK4 494y$C9K9:!449.G*>O9:G*99C>94u9:S9uy
,4g 94R>`: U 04US9OG94 94y US944RRyS49?y`yyGR*GG**
94949G* 9 OS4G4yu9:9: OI*G9G944R  S*OG449SyS>g*G`G O9:
y9q4G

4G9`SSR:*GUy99:9s*4aO&GGSg449*OaC9USu*4G99yU9 >USuR:SG4{29S4C*Uy 4:4yGugC49S:

9:49?[G!*R49!:?*9S?GRGS$:G 4 4RC9G* G? G9 >G94g4y994S
!!9*4*44S99G:SuN2 4!OOOG:qUSS:SGUSR944999*R9
O9:a!y9G:4?>R9y49!*40,99s[&G0ay99G4:RRS*9?9O?9O9RSk
4!>9*IR9:qG&S4[9S4*4G4G4U9
44GO9? OSay9 9S4!!4*9
 * G 4 G*4S4u9OS94!R!?9:
9S44R:Cy>u4]S? 44*9>4G4y44
RGg9>49RUS94y9G64GS&4UU4y99 4R4C!*G4*u49g94&4y4G*9
44G4*GC49G!9U:S9.gRG499Oy 49O`>U G4SG 4SuSs 9u:
*O9!auG44:9ag444?4 RS4 
"$' U's(:'s 1`'
 S99 R&Uu9SG9.u994.u444S&!:4CyG9*4*4> 9SORSSu99:
G9G`*
9u  u !y9 6 G*RyyU9nGSk*&9yO Sg 94 GnyS 9 44:  ZV
GOyZ Gy ky : ?S,Gy4

4:1/0.28,4/0.20

2:8/0.22,2/0.17

0:2/0.26,0/0.19

5:3/0.25,5/0.20

4:1/0.26,4/0.19

7:2/0.22,3/0.18

4:4/0.19,9/0.16 9:9/0.16,4/0.14

4:1/0.23,4/0.22

4:1/0.21,4/0.20

9:9/0.17,4/0.17

9:9/0.19,7/0.18

9:9/0.19,4/0.19

2:0/0.23,6/0.18

0:6/0.20,5/0.15

8:2/0.20,3/0.20

?

9:9/0.19,4/0.18
+

9:9/0.21,7/0.21

7:7/0.17,9/0.17

B



<

B

;

+

?



5:5/0.19,3/0.17

4:9/0.16,4/0.16

B



U-2CG*ay,Gk:94:449:4 9GygRS4 >IO*G 9R44Re9G  9SG 4S

44
  4X 
:
Z4V  a -  G  U:>y  yu*yy4

*RGGG+ kyG4:UG 4
U- 2C9:*G49g4G4:S:U9GGO IG * R4S>:UGS4 4?4S4$GS*
S) :V4nU S9)Ry?U9:gO aRyy949:Z RG  ` U G4: :G4 yuUy*G:G >G4
U- 2Ca*!]:4*4444S:9 4 >GO499 4IU S yR S:GG*9 R2S4yG
G:  y4G
4 U  :9!S:RUU
G gO9S4 .R!  G S?G?*S:]4S 9: q*449Gq>S:UU94*G?94*
9G> 4 UUT : G
9E n y }:g X : G"4 n4   GnG4

`Gy4

4 .G9O KS9 O 9 .*S49*9Gy4e S4 6? G94
  G  9s i US 44
nG 9 ) V#/ 4RG yS' y4OUG 4
G gayRUSSPnGU9S>4:S:y iR49 ] S4CGgSSS*U iSU[SR4S4
SSG:R4:S Ry9 y4 9G9
9 :y9 y y!44Sy sRySGa 4y49
UyG:
G GgS4R:S>!S9S:9G4S>: y]`U99 4 4$6CS*GSU*S{ nG 9>*4:9
S :G>IR 4*n  S: 9GGg 4S44G $ ZV  : R G 4U  y 4 G44  .a*URSG?nyU GR
S gR 9 R*SUn y.O!4n U 9G4I S*:nG n9 G4  9g ::C S  S44 V  
9NGR
G R 9RG.9 Su?RSSyG4Sg:S4.aR*y 99:4OG   949UyUG!
4
n ` " yU 4 n*R4S y  GSn y44G 4 y RG Gy 4 U :uy E n  '
`69 GS49ysR USy$2S9g9SU9`y44!! .G!y:R9SSGRS>gGuS4*9SU
6USRG9{!aSG > 4*94!S49GR4U9 4O 4449US09 OfGU
9yRS 9 4G9a`Gy4
G 9y! 9 .O Sg 9 qS44 4  U9 4g4 44R*a RS9  URGyG:
uu U 4 46!U9 Ry99y9* a>
G .R U  G::! s> 4u SyG:+4 OnC4O * G 9y4R Gu4 4  y RG: 9T 4
G
E n   : G4 :RSy Gy 4GG:RG 4
G .R
4y9

 6g4y49*SSsg S* g 3 S4 4 U
y 9Gy4 
 y :4
G ay R 9 G u4 : RS4 G4* u 44u49nG9Z :GG 94>GyK44UGG:U SRS4
4 > y4R99 u9s UR94S:40G4 9y9 4:!Dy4 94 :G 4*4: 
O4*G 9 3
4 U :RGSy 4 6 Xk:y 4" yR  GnG:U4  4n 4GnG:  G G
D



;

<

B



+

<

0+

B











G 4G O9 u 4 OSi4G9y 2*aG94:944:?suqs99y32 994U

 * :4-R4S4 y  G#)O94y6Kn 9*G :4y9Z ys4*G`Gy44S!694G*O4
GG:
G GO9 u OS49?4 2CGS 4GUK!4SG
O*yG49UE 4? SG 9y994y u49 >4 4 G*O 444X  S49 * 4-  4y
G 94gG  yu *yy4  :   :
ZV &OSG
y k:GOUyG4 4OUS1  G 4:  4
S GO  9 Ou* G 9O4SS4R9S.S$4 9*2C9G S G >4y*>U$US*GGyN9UG
ys  y :4  4   *!S4OUU
G R GO`C9 *yu99 4>RSS::G *2G4>S 4:4yUO9S49 * R  944O
 )   / 3 9y2 uX:14a :G
4 y G4
  Gyn G G 94UR > GU 
9 y4 0  `4

OUyG4
6*4GGy ! S*RC49:yq4O# *2CGy994*RS44y4OG 4S4G4*!U *
6 G42   9 
GnG 9 )eV n
 4OSG Sa+  yG4OUyG:
G 4  y: GC*S Su*X U:  9$4.yG9y?4G&U9 4GUU' S`RGS*4*GZ f6SGG>0 O
GSO
G64 4!    f:C ZSV : 4 4K :G 4s Uy G:y  ] )RnGnn


6+

<



*

B

(

<

$<

<

B

B