Portfolio Reflection Paper Directions Rubric Spring 2010b

School of Continuing Studies
Capstone Project
Master of Medical Informatics Program
Portfolio and Reflection Paper Directions and Rubric
Portfolio Directions: Choose artifacts (i.e. - your capstone project, other projects you have submitted throughout the MMI program or projects completed
through your employment that demonstrate knowledge and skill gained from the MMI program) and write reflection papers articulating why the artifact provide
evidence that you achieved the desired course outcomes described below in the scoring rubric.
Reflection Paper Directions: Critically reflect on your experience in the MMI program. Create a framework for your portfolio (for example, Clinical
Applications, Technology, Healthcare Administration or a framework based on each course taken in the program). Write a reflection paper(s) that addresses the
desired course outcomes identified below in the scoring rubric. Describe how the artifact(s) chosen demonstrate your competence, areas of strength and identify
areas for improvement for future development.
Due: The electronic portfolio and all refection papers are due on (May 27, 2010).
The project/reflection papers

Fails to Meet Minimally Meets
demonstrated an application of Meets Expectations Exceeds Expectations
Expectations Expectations
knowledge about:
MMI 401 American Healthcare System
Specifically:
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of our healthcare system to
Major aspects of our healthcare system of knowledge demonstrated Demonstrated knowledge solve a problem - demonstrating critical thinking
acquisition knowledge skills
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of major healthcare issues to
Major healthcare issues within our
of knowledge demonstrated Demonstrated knowledge solve a problem - demonstrating critical thinking
healthcare system
acquisition knowledge skills
The perspectives of the entities within the Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge entity perspectives and their
Demonstrated an
American healthcare system, and how of knowledge demonstrated an roles in our healthcare system to solve a
understanding
they view their roles within the system acquisition understanding problem - demonstrating critical thinking skills
MMI 402 Introduction to Clinical
Thinking:
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of the current clinical care
The current clinical care environment in Demonstrated an
of knowledge demonstrated an environment to solve a problem - demonstrating
which problem solving occurs understanding
acquisition understanding critical thinking skills
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of the complexities of
The complexity of applying an EMR Demonstrated an
of knowledge demonstrated an applying an EMR in clinical care to solve a
context to clinical care understanding
acquisition understanding problem - demonstrating critical thinking skills
MMI 403 Introduction to Medical
Informatics:
Capstone Project

knowledge about:
Lacked evidence Minimally
The academic discipline of medical Demonstrated an Synthesized literature & project contributed to
of knowledge demonstrated an
informatics understanding advancing the discipline
acquisition understanding
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of medical informatics and
The role of medical informatics in clinical Demonstrated an
of knowledge demonstrated an clinical healthcare applications in context of their
health care applications understanding
acquisition understanding respective roles
MMI 403 Introduction to Medical

Informatics & MMI 405 Healthcare
Information Technology Integration,
Interoperability and Standards:
Recognize how medical data including Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of how medical data is used
Demonstrated an
clinical, administrative, and financial data, of knowledge demonstrated in healthcare operations to solve a problem -
understanding
is used in healthcare applications acquisition understanding demonstrating critical thinking skills
Applied knowledge of the nature of medical
The nature of medical knowledge and knowledge and decision-making and the role of
decision-making and the role of decision Demonstrated decision support systems, knowledge-based
of knowledge demonstrated
support systems, knowledge-based comprehension systems and artificial intelligence methods to
systems and artificial intelligence methods solve a problem - demonstrating critical thinking
skills
Identify how current and emerging
information delivery methods including Applied knowledge of how emerging information
mobile networks, Web-based databases Demonstrated an delivery methods can enhance patient outcomes
and decision support systems, and understanding to solve a problem - demonstrating critical
enterprise information systems can be thinking skills
used to enhance patient outcomes
Evaluated and applied knowledge of current
Lacked evidence
Current informatics software and systems Demonstrated an Demonstrated evidence of informatics software and systems used for
of knowledge
used for clinical and professional support understanding of evaluating clinical and professional support to solve a
acquisition
problem - demonstrating critical thinking skills
Integration between research, clinical Lacked evidence Minimally Synthesized, evaluated information and applied
Demonstrated an
data, and theory in improving patient of knowledge demonstrated knowledge integrating research, clinical data and
understanding
outcomes acquisition understanding theory to improve patient outcomes.
Capstone Project

knowledge about:
MMI 406 Decision Support Systems

and Health Care
Understand the basic features, benefits,

and limitations of machine learning and Demonstrated an Applied Decision Support Methods -
intelligent decision support methods in the understanding demonstrating critical thinking skills.
healthcare environment.
Understand the benefits and limitations of Demonstrated an Applied Decision Support Methods -
medical decision making techniques. understanding demonstrating critical thinking skills.
Understand the role of performance Lacked evidence Minimally

Demonstrated an Applied Decision Support Methods -
measurement in guiding DSS of knowledge demonstrated
understanding demonstrating critical thinking skills.
deployment. acquisition understanding
Describe current uses of medical Lacked evidence Minimally

decision making and decision support of knowledge demonstrated
systems in health care. acquisition understanding
Understand the use various decision
making and analytic models to solve Lacked evidence Minimally
both structured and unstructured of knowledge demonstrated
problems. acquisition understanding
MMI 404 Health Care Operations &

MMI 408 Medical Technology
Acquisition and Assessment:
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of core operations of
Acquire a working knowledge of the core
of knowledge demonstrated Demonstrated knowledge hospitals to solve a problem - demonstrating
operations of hospital organizations
acquisition knowledge critical thinking skills
Applied knowledge of the role information
Develop an understanding of the role of Lacked evidence Minimally
Demonstrated an technology plays within hospital operations to
information technology within hospital of knowledge demonstrated
understanding solve a problem - demonstrating critical thinking
operations acquisition understanding
skills
Capstone Project

knowledge about:
Did not solve the Addressed the
The project applied
Equip students with the critical thinking problem and problem but lacked Synthesized, analyzed, evaluated information
knowledge to solve a
skills required to analyze and improve lacked evidence of evidence of and applied knowledge to improve hospital
problem - demonstrating
hospital operations critical thinking innovation/ critical operations in an innovative manner.
critical thinking skills
skills thinking skills
Evaluated and applied knowledge of the role of
Lacked evidence
Evaluate the role of the management Demonstrated an Demonstrated evidence of the management team and Board of Directors to
of knowledge
team and the Board of Directors understanding evaluating solve a problem - demonstrating critical thinking
acquisition
skills
MMI 407 Legal, Ethical and Social
Issues in Medical Informatics:
Protected Health Information (PHI) and Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of PHI and HIPAA Privacy
Demonstrated an
understand the range of permissible uses of knowledge demonstrated Rule in solving a problem - demonstrating critical
understanding
and disclosures allowed by HIPAA acquisition understanding thinking skills
Demonstrated an
Demonstrated Demonstrated an ability to
ability to construct
Analyze, criticize and construct rigorous minimal analyze, criticize and
policy-oriented Synthesized, analyzed, critiqued information to
policy-oriented arguments for the understanding to construct policy-oriented
arguments for develop policy for handling healthcare data
appropriate handling of healthcare data handle healthcare arguments for handling
handling healthcare
data healthcare data
data
Articulated basic
Basic government regulations and legal Applied knowledge of government regulations
Lacked evidence government regulations
principles applicable to healthcare data Demonstrated an and legal principles of healthcare data
of knowledge and legal principles of
management (i.e. how to keep your CIO understanding management in solving a problem -
acquisition healthcare management
out of jail) demonstrating critical thinking skills
data
Applied knowledge of Joint Commission
The Joint Commission's accreditation Lacked evidence
Demonstrated an accreditation interest in medical informatics to
interest in medical informatics and data of knowledge Summarized
understanding solve a problem - demonstrating critical thinking
handling acquisition
skills
The key components of an effective Lacked evidence Applied knowledge of the key components of an
Demonstrated an
compliance program, including a of knowledge Identify effective compliance program to solve a problem
understanding
demonstration of regulatory informatics acquisition - demonstrating critical thinking skills
Regarding future legal and ethical Lacked evidence Demonstrate critical Utilized intellect and professional contacts to
Demonstrated an
regulation of medical informatics in the of knowledge thinking and leadership direct, develop and/or help advance medical
understanding
U.S. social landscape acquisition skills informatics regulation legally and ethically
Capstone Project

knowledge about:
Develop a basic facility with legal Understand basic legal
Lacked evidence Applied extensive knowledge of legal
terminology to be in position to know Demonstrated an terminology/laws knowing
of knowledge terminology/laws and appropriately consult legal
when, and how, to consult effectively with understanding when and how to consult
acquisition counsel
corporate legal counsel legal counsel
MMI 409 - Biostatistics and Mdical
Informatics
Biomedical applications of topics
disccussed i.e. descriptive statistics, Demonstrated an Applied knowledge of Biostatistics -
hypothesis testing, t-tests, chi-squared understanding demonstrating critical thinking skills.
test, analysis of variance, etc.
MMI 481 - Leaders

Understand the definition of organizational
culture and how culture impacts an Demonstrated an
of knowledge demonstrated an Applied knowledge of organizational culture
organization's effectiveness and ability to understanding
change
Understand why human change or don't
change and how to apply these dynamis Demonstrated an
of knowledge demonstrated an Applied knowledge of managing change
in planning and marketing of understanding
organizational change
Gain insights into organization alignment Lacked evidence Minimally
Demonstrated an
as a strategy execution method and of knowledge demonstrated an Applied knowledge of organizational allingment
understanding
change management method acquisition understanding
Identify your personal influence and style Lacked evidence Minimally
Demonstrated an
and how best to use and expand on this of knowledge demonstrated an Applied knowledge of organizational influence
understanding
for influence in your organization acquisition understanding
CIS 313 Networking and
Telecommunications:
The OSI Model and the different Demonstrated an Applied knowledge of the OSI Model to solve a
components that comprise the model understanding problem - demonstrating critical thinking skills
Data transmission and different types of Demonstrated an Applied knowledge of data transmission to solve
transmission media understanding a problem - demonstrating critical thinking skills
Capstone Project

knowledge about:
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of various telecommunication
Demonstrated an
Various telecommunication circuit types of knowledge demonstrated circuit types to solve a problem - demonstrating
understanding
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of various LAN hardware
Demonstrated an
Various LAN hardware devices of knowledge demonstrated devices to solve a problem - demonstrating
understanding
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of transmission efficiency
Demonstrated an
Transmission efficiency and multiplexing of knowledge demonstrated and multiplexing to solve a problem -
understanding
acquisition understanding demonstrating critical thinking skills
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of different components that
The different components that comprises Demonstrated an
of knowledge demonstrated comprise a Data Link layer to solve a problem -
the Data Link layer understanding
Demonstrated an Applied knowledge of TCP/IP to solve a problem
TCP/IP addressing and functionality of knowledge demonstrated
understanding - demonstrating critical thinking skills
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of medium access control
Medium Access Control protocols Demonstrated an
of knowledge demonstrated protocols to solve a problem - demonstrating
including CSMA/CD and Token passing understanding
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of LANs, CANs, MANs, and
Demonstrated an
LANs, CANs, MANs, & WANs of knowledge demonstrated WANs to solve a problem - demonstrating critical
understanding
acquisition understanding thinking skills
Demonstrated an Applied knowledge of wireless LANs to solve a
Wireless LANs of knowledge demonstrated
understanding problem - demonstrating critical thinking skills
Applied knowledge of how telecommunications
How telecommunications can influence Demonstrated an can influence and infiltrate our daily lives to
and infiltrate our daily lives and more understanding solve a problem - demonstrating critical thinking
skills
CIS 317 Database Management
Systems:
Applied knowledge of the fundamentals of
The fundamentals of database Demonstrated an database management and data organization to
management and data organization understanding solve a problem - demonstrating critical thinking
skills
Capstone Project

knowledge about:
Demonstrated an
Lacked knowledge
understanding of Designed and implemented a database
needed to design Designed and
Design and implement database designing and application to solve a problem in an innovative
and implement a implemented a database
application implementing manner contributing to the advancement of MMI
database application
database field
application
applications
Lacked knowledge Demonstrated an
Demonstrated evidence of
needed to manage understanding Demonstrated evidence of managing large
Managing the large bodies of data managing large bodies of
large bodies of needed to manage bodies of data without error
data
data large bodies of data
Lacked evidence Minimally Applied knowledge of how data is organized in
How data is organized in abstract data Demonstrated an
of knowledge demonstrated abstract data structures to solve a problem -
structures understanding
Applied knowledge of relational languages and
Relational languages and how they are Demonstrated an how they are used to provide the interface for
used to provide the interface for DBMS understanding DBMS to solve a problem - demonstrating
critical thinking skills
CIS 435 - Introduction to Data
Warehouse and Data Mining
Data mining algorithms, Data mining Demonstrated an Applied knowledge of applying data mining
applications i.e. data warehousing. understanding algorithms
Overall Ratings
Capstone Project

knowledge about:
The project did not The project
solve the problem addressed the
and lacked problem and
evidence of demonstrated
Overall Group Project Rating medical medical informatics
informatics knowledge but The project demonstrated The project demonstrated evidence of
knowledge and lacked evidence of evidence of knowledge information synthesis, evaluation and applied
critical thinking innovation/ critical application required to knowledge to solve a problem in an innovative
skills thinking skills problem solve manner - demonstrating critical thinking skills
The portfolio
lacked evidence of
key aspects of The portfolio The portfolio demonstrated
Overall Portfolio Rating medical demonstrated an evidence of knowledge
informatics and understanding of key application required to The portfolio demonstrated evidence of applied
critical thinking aspects of medical problem solve in the field knowledge and critical thinking skills necessary
skills informatics of medical informatics to excel in the field of medical informatics

Portfolio Reflection Paper Directions Rubric Spring 2010b

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Portfolio Reflection Paper Directions Rubric Spring 2010b

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

School of Continuing Studies

The project/reflection papers

The project/reflection papers

MMI 403 Introduction to Medical

The project/reflection papers

MMI 406 Decision Support Systems

Understand the basic features, benefits,

Understand the role of performance Lacked evidence Minimally

Describe current uses of medical Lacked evidence Minimally

MMI 404 Health Care Operations &

The project/reflection papers

The project/reflection papers

MMI 481 - Leaders

The project/reflection papers

The project/reflection papers

The project/reflection papers

You might also like