Tenepansiomy mpoxypopy PoccuiicKok @eneparen Yaiixe IOpmo Sixonnesnyy 125993, 'CTI-3, Poccws, Mocxsa yr. B. JIetpoxa, 15a Or rpaxaanunia CLA Jhxemncona Pasa Dakiepetoyna, saperucTpaposarnoro mo anpecy: 107078 r. Mocksa, Opnuxos nepeymox, 1. 8, KB. 83 Konus: Mpencenatemo Cosera mpi Tlpesaxente PoccuiicKoii DenepanyHn Ho coneHicTBHIO pasBHTHIO MHCTHTYTOB TpAXMAHCKOTO OGmecTHA H MIpABaM sesropexa Tlampit1050% 9.A. 103132, Mocksa, Crapas m., 1.4 14 exa6px 2009 rona 3ASBJIEHHE 3, Toxemucon Pan aliepctoyx, rpaxnanu CLA, o6pamaioce x Bam 8 cBa3H mposomHMo# Tenepamsuolt mpoxyparypoH mo nopyycumo [lpesmnenta P® mposepKoit obcrostemscra ruGems 16 Hos6ps 2009 roma n CH3O «Manpocexas Tamms» (BY H3-77/1) rpaxctanmia P® Maramtcxoro Cepres Jleonmmonmaa. Marnurcxni CJL. n teense 11 Mecauen collepxasica nog crpaxelt Wo xojlatalicrsy cnenosatea CK npa MBJI P Cumsuenxo 0.0., paccuievopaBinero yronoBHoe seo Ne\53123, OGcrostemersa rem Marnurcxoro C.JI. urskinaioT O6ocHOBaHHOe GecnoKolicTHo. Marnurexait CJI. 6xu1 sHUIeH B TIOpEMe HEOOXOMHMOl MeqMUMHICKOH nOMOMU. YenOBHA ero COMepRAHHS B HBONXTOPE MOCHELOBATENBHO YXYMMIANHCS NOCHE Toro, KAK OH OTKaIbIBANICs JUKECBHNETENBCTBOBATE B OTHOUIEHHH CeOA H JIpYTHX JIM, HECMOTPA Ha JABIEHHE CO CTOPOHDI ‘cnenersus. Ero CMepTe MPOHSOMLIA IPH HEBKIACHEHHBIX H MOLOIpHTeNbHEIX OOCTOSTENBCTEAX. Ha ero rene up noxoponax Guu oGapyxenst Ces HACK, B cessu © ora mpowy mpa ocymecraieHHH nposepkH oBcrostesmcra rHGenn C.J. Marnircxoro o6paTit BHMMAHHe Ha cnenyionlde OGcTOsTeNbCTBA. 1. B cnomx noxasannsx or 5 mions 2008 roza 7 oxri6px 2008 rona 10 yrononiomy neny 0374015 u or 13 oxtsGpa 2009 no yronosnomy ery Ne153123 rona CJT. Marserrexait 3a0BHI O6 H3BECTHBIK €My O6cTOsTeMCTBAX KPaKH KOMMAHHi, pate NpHHaNEKABIHX DOHTY Spmarraxk («Maxaon», «Ilaphennom, «Pa191J0)), H WX anbHeliinero HCMOTEIOBAHHS © HEH10 xamenu 5,4 sasuimapna pyOneH us Giomxera PO nyrem oprauusaulMH HEsaKOHHOTO BoaRpaTa nanorop, B 3THX NOKASAHHAX OH ykazan Ha HMEBIIIYIOCS, Mo ero MHCHHIO, MpHacTHOCTE K JaHHBIM mpecrynienusm pana corpynmuxos TYBJL mo r. Mockse, 5 TOM sHoMe, ‘onepynonromoyennoro Kysneuona A.K. 4 cnenosatens Kapnopa JLA., a Take ApyrHX Hil — ampoxaton Tanx0sa A.A., Maiioposoii 10.M., Maxsuenoii E.K, rpaxnan Mapxeona B.A, Kypouxaua B.H., XneGunxona B.D. 2. 24 wosGpx 2008 roma, To ecrs HenocpenerseHHO ocme nay cpneTeRDCKEN moxazanwii mpotus Ky3neyosa A.K. » Kapnosa I1.A., Marawtcxait C.JI. Gnu sanepxan B pamxax pacenenonans yronossoro nesta Ne 153123 corpysuuxama Kysuenoga A.K., KoTOpBti 11B TeNEHHE BCETO BPEMCHH paccieAOBAHHA AAHHOTO YFONOBHOTO esa HeHSMCHHO BXONHX B coctas cslesIeTBeHHOH TPyTNEL, 3. Cueneraennas spynna nox pyKoBoxcTBOM ciezoBaress CumbueHko O.., B cocTas Koropoii sxomm Kystteuos A.K., ocymectmiata OMKOBPeMeHHO paccalenoBaHAa BYX sex: Ne 152979 no daxry xumenna 5,4 musmapaa Gtommerasix cpencts H Ne 153123 06 yxnonenua oT yilars! HaoroB, B paMKax xoToporo Marnurcxuii C.Jl. Guan samepxan corpyaHuKamH Kysnenona A.K. 4, Takum o6paxom, Marnurexnit C.JI. dbaxrivecks Haxomiaca B TeveHwe 1] Mecauen B ‘TOpsMe Ha NOTOxeHHM sanoxHHKa Kysnenopa A.K., IPOTHE KOTOPOTO OH JlaBANI CBANETEECKHE TOKa3aHHA, © eM OH HEONHOKPATHO aN B CROHK KAIOOAX H BLICTYTIEHHAX B cyte. IIpA TOM BO BpeMs conepxKaHHa MarnutcKoro C.JI. non crpaxkell WieHamn cmeacTBeHHOl rpynitst Ha HETO OKA3bIBANOCK NCHXHYCCKOE Ht HABMIECKOE BOINeHCTBHE C HeTIO NONyAeHHA OT Hero HeOGXO/HMBIX CHIE/ICTBHIO 3ABEsIOMO TOKHEIX NOKASAHHH. 5. OGpunenne, npexpannenoe C.J]. MarnurcKoMy cile{CTBREM, O_UIO He3aKOHHBIM 1 HeOGOCHOBAILHGIM, TACKE KAK HEIAKOHHLIM H HEOOOCHOBAHHBIM GBLIO 3aKMONeHHe ero TOL cwpaxy. Marnurrckaii He Mor GsiTb cyGveKTOM HIKPHMHEHPYeMOrO eMy MpecTyILteHHA 0 cnenyomnng npasaias: a) Marnurexnit CJL. ne Gsun Hi cOGcTReHHMKOM, Hu pyKonOsprTeneM, HH GyxrairTepom. 000 «Carypu Humectmente> x OOO «Jlamuat crens» » 2001 romy # He nomnmcnBan HanOroBy!© HeKnapallsio NO HAIOTY Ha MpAOKLIb 2a 2001 ros, B KOTOPyI, To MHEHMO CIXCTBHS, HM GBUIH BHECCHEL HeLOCTOBEpHBIe cReqeHAs. 6) Marmrexnii CJI. we Mor saiuMaries HaiiMOM HHBaMHIOB B OOO «CatypH Hinnectwenre» » OOO «/lansuas crenb» 8 1999 ~ 2001 ronax, NOCKOMBKY HHKOTMa He nocemas. Kamaerknio 10 2002 rona, Kora OH YSACTBOBAT B paccMOTpeHHM esa B cyse Br. Inncra B KaNecTBe 1OpHNYeCKOTO MPEACTABHTENE YKASAHHEIX KOMMANHIA, 8) Marmmrexui C.J. He Mor BMILIHBAT, KoMMEHCANHIO HNBAIHIAM B opHce xommannt «aiiepcroyn JlaHker> HaNHIHBIMM JeNbTaMH, NOCKONBKY HHBAMHZS nomy4aH ofanuanuyio sapaGorHyio mary MyTeM Mepesona cpesicra Ha GaHKOBCKHe cyeTa, 470 OMTBEPANBIOTCS COXPAHARLIHMHCS ILIATEXMBIME JOKYMeHTaMH. 1) 000 «flansnas crems» 1 OOO «CarypH Miuecruentey He comepmtam HanOrOBBX Mpanonapymienuii. TM KOMMAHHH HEOAHOKpaTHO MposepsMch HAOTOBBIMA OpraxamH, YFOHOBHOE eNO TO TAEHEIM OGBHHeHHAM Gs210 Mpexpameno » 2005 romy culenoBaTeIeM Hycxuopsia B CBASH c OTcyTCTRHEM COcTana IIPECTYIICHHA, H GsUI0 cHOBA ROIOGHORLTEHO 27 eapars 2008 roma mocte puaHra mn Onmcty cnenonarenx Kapnona ILA. @ corpysHHKos Kysienopa A.K. p omer 1a xano6y Dora «IpMHT@x 0 Kpake ero KoMMaHHit, 6. Maraurcxaii C.J]. Gut 3akmoueH To Crpaky Ha OcHOBAHHH albcH>HIMpOBaHHEK JOKYMEHTOB COTPYMHHKAMH TIpanOOXPAHHTENbHBIX OPraHOB jOKyMeHTOB. OGcrosrenbcrsa hascupuKannn THX JOKYMeHTOR O¥eBHIND H He BAISBIBAIOT HNKAKOTO COMHEHHA: = on He opopmns Busy B BermKoGpHTaNMi0, 470 noxTnepKnaeTed OcpANHATEHEIM ‘orpetom ocomscrsa 2roit crparter;- on He Gponmposan Guier » Kuen, ceenenHs 0 Gponuposannn hamcuuneposasti, ‘Veasupaemnii cnencranem OHNeT JOmKeHt GsUT OBITS BuIKyTIEH 20 22 Hos6ps 2008 rona, B TO pes Kax Cepreit Maruitcxuii Omter He MpHoGperan a HaxXOnAICA NoMa 24 HoxGpR 2008 roma; = Of He Mor, HAXONSCS Br. MOCKBe, OKASHIBATS RIMAHHE Ha CBRNETEEH, MPOHBAIOUAX B QuuCTe, MOCKONBKY LOTMACHO TIpeNCTARNEHHKIM CHeACTBHEM OKyMeHTaM Gut B Omutcte ‘ToNBKO OnHE pas, B 2002 rony, 3a mecTs Net No apecta; ero sarpaxnanti Nacnopr Guin HSbAT TIpH OGLiCKe NO ero apecTa, B CBSGH ¢ Hem OGKIE COMMIKH Ha nOIMOXHOCTS YeXaTb H3 PD He HMEIOT HOM OOOH HIAKAKHX OCHOBARHIH, 7. B pawgax yromopHoro jena Ne153123 cnenosarenem — CusabsieHKo damcnduumposamcs jlokasarencrsa. C nembio cOKpsITHA crenos dambcubHKanHH OF BORIC HAPYMEHHEM 3aKOHA BRTELL YrOOBHOE TET B oTHOMeHHA MarnuTcKoro C.JI. B orgenbHoe mpoussoncrso. TIpH 3ToM ik «BEETeHAIOTO sea» nporH MarmurcKoro CI. cnenoparens Cumbsenxo O.d, MxTOTARNMBal Tak HASBIBACMHIE “AREPEHHBe KONHH JOKYMEHTOB (JOKaxATENSCTE M0 Zesty), OPHTHHATE KOTOPKIX B yrONOBHOM zene 153123 OTCYTCTBOBATH, H AYTEHTHUHOCTS KOTOPLIX BHISHIBANA ABHBIC CoMHeHAA. Bosiee Toro, caMO 110 ceGe BauTeIeHHe yroNOBHOTO nena B OTHOMeHHH MarHHTcKoro C.JI. w Hanpanienue ero B Cys ¢ KONHAMH HE3HAYHTEMbHOH YacTH cOOpaHHBIX MO ey DOKasaTerbcTs xBNUIOCk rpyGelimmHM HapyMIeHHeM yronoBHO-MpOUeCcyambHOTO 3aKOHONATEECTBA, 8. Tiponeccyambuste HapyieHus, jOMyMeHHBe cnemCTBREM, He MOsBONATH B TaubHelINeM Ha 3aKOHHBIX OCHOBAHHSX conepKaTs MaruurcKoro C.JI. no cTpaxeli. Buen yFosiopnoe eo potas Maraxrexoro C.JI. 8 oTlembiloe MpoMsBonCTEO | CBORM. nocranomienHem or 16 oxtaGpa 2009 roma, cnenopaTem CumyenKo 0.0. ne Hasna clleqersennyio rpyony Wit paccneqosatua jayHOTO mpectymicHHs, 3aRHB allBoKaTaM Maruurcxoro CJI., #10 B 370M Het HeoOxommMocTi. Tlocne Toro, kAK a1poKaTst MaruHTcKOrO CJL oGxasonat 9TH nelicToua CHe7OBATENA OH 3AMHHM sUCKOM (16 oKrsGpa 2009 roza) MSTOTOBHN NOCTAHOBICHHE 0 HaIHAYCHHM CilesICTBEHHOM FpyMsM M HSTOTOBHA TONKENGBIE JOKYMENTH 0 TOM, TO JaHlHoe MOCTAHOBEHHE GBUIO OGEAHNeHO MarnuTcKoMy 16 oKrsGpa 2009 roza. B xelicraurensuocrH, 16 oxrsGpa 2009 cnencraenHsse Jelicraus c MarHutcKun CJL. ocymectssix1 cxenosarems T'panait, KoTopstit OGEsBH eMy TONEKO ocraHOBNeHHe 0 BLUICNEHHH B OTHOIMEHHH Hero YFoNOBHOTO esa B OT;ENBHOe MpoHsBoNCTBO. B AaHHOM OCTAHOBeHHH HH CHOBA He TOBOPHIOCS 0 TOM, TO MK PaCcHeMOBAMAK Jena B OTHOMEHHH Marnurexoro Gsu1a HasHavena cievicrBeHHaa rpynma. Tipunmsad Bo BHUMAHHe WIOKeHHMe BEIM OGcTosTeNDCTBA, Mpomy Bac B pamKax MpOBORHMOH nO HOpyseHMo FipesmeHTa Pe nposepKH oGcrostetscrs rHGen MarHHTCKorO: 1. WerpeGonars yrononuste ena Nol53123, 311578 # N0152979 y Cuenersenuoro xomuteta npu MBJI P®; 2. Werpe6opars yronopioe neno 374015 y Cnencrsenuoro otmena C3A0 Caenetsennoro ynpanienus no r. Mockse CaestcTeenoro KomaTeTa 1p IIpoxypatype Pa; 3. _TIposepurs o6ocnonastocr mpemssnienioro Maruutexomy CJI. oOpHHeHHs ¢ YHCTOM OBCTOSTENECTE, HITOMEHHDIX B eT NOKAARUSX oT 5 wIOHS 2008 roma, 7 oxTaGpA 2008 Toma # 13 oxts6ps 2009 rona; 4, Tipovepur, axrst hamcuuxanan cneonaterem Curbuenko 0.0. oKasaTex5CTB NO yroOBHEIM esIam No153123 m 311578; 35. Tposepsrrs sakonHocTs BiyyesteHua yronopnoro Jena Ne 311578 8 orHomenu MarHutcKoro 8 OTembHOe HPONSBOCTBO; 6. Tiponepire gars: damcupuxanm corpynmnkacn MBJI P® 10Kynesttos, KoTOpsie OUT MOsIOxeHES B OcHOBY apecta MaraurcKoro; 7. Tpovepars haxrst hamcudbuxauan caenonarerem § Cusmacuxo 0.0, TOCTAHOBNICHAA O HAIHACHHH CNCICTReHHOH rpyNitbl mys PAccnexOBAMMA BHULEMeHHOTO yrosopsoro yema B oTHOMeHHH MarautcKoro C.JL; 8. Fiponepurs saKomHocTs OGOCHOBAHHOCTS MHOTOWHCIIEHHNX mepeBoos Maraurrexoro #3 OnHoro H3OneTopa B pyro H H3 OTOH KAMEPHI B APYTYIO, CoARaHEe EMy GecueoneuHEIX YCHOBHH, TpyGoe HapyieHHe ero MAB, YCTAHOBHTE, KEM HMeHHO OTHABATHCS cotpynmmkan ®CHH coorsererpyionme HHCTPYKIUH; 9, Box6yzurs yronopnoe xen0 Mo axram amcabuKannn cotpynmxann MBI Po joxasaresnscTs 10 YrOROBHOMY AETY H OKYMeHTOB, KOTOPHIE GRIM NOIOKEHBI B OCHOBY mGpausa Maruurtexomy CJL. Meps! MpeceveHHa B BHI 3AKMONEHRA TOM CTpAKY. : Don Lt Tixemucou Pun Datlepcroyt MIpanomess: 1. Texct noxasaxuit Maruurckoro or 13 oKra6px 2009 rona fa 10 mmerax; 2. TIpotoxon jompoca Marsurexoro or 5 sions 2008 rona na 10 smacTex; 3. O6ssicHenna Marsuetcxoro or 7 oxri6pa 2008 rona Ha 7 nmcrax; 4. Kano6a ampoxara Marsrexoro Xapwrouona JIB. or 11 cera6pa 2009 rova Ha ‘7 amcrax;Pacumporka cBHJeTeNbcKHX noKazaHMii Maruutexoro C.JI., aHHBIX BO BpeMa Mpesbapienua OOBHHEHUA 8 OKOHUATERBHOH penaKHHA 16 oxrsGps 2009 rona. (Oparauan poxymenta Haxontcs 8 MaTepHanax yea, KOTMA He 6bUIA MpenocTassteHa cuencTBHeM). 1. Crtavana 6su10 cHenaKo 3anBeHHe 0 TOM, TO caeACTRHe He MpomntopmHpoBATO MATHHTCKOTO C.JI. 06 ocHosanisx npeneasieHHoro OGBHHeHHe, Kak Toro Tpe6yer | xoupenuns. [IpH 9TOM Tog OCHOBaHHIMH MBI TOHHMaeM ROKA3aTENBCTBA, Ha KOTOPBIX ocHoBbipaica cileqoparenb, BLIHOCK mocTaHom/IeHHe © mpupleveHHH » KasiecTRe | o6BHHseMorO. 2. Tlocne sroro MACHHTCKMM C.JI. saapaa, y7o mpempaBsieHHHe emy HOBoro OOBHHeHHA B MOMCHT OKOHYAHHA cxeneTaHa dakrH4eckH sHUaeT ero mpaBa Ha OCYINECTBIICHHE 3all{HTBI. 3. 3arem MATHMTCKUH C.JI. cnenan sasanenve B uen0m 06 yrouloBHOM MpecteoBaHHH crenyromero conepxanns: «OcymlectBaseMmoe B OTHOMLeHHH MeHs yrojOBHoe NpecnezonanHe HanpanneHo He Ha gocTuxenne Neel yeranoBneHHbix cr.6 YIIK P®, a apaserea penpeccuuoii mepoii, Heabio KoTopoi saserca HakazanHe Mesa 3a NOMom, KoTopylo 1 okaabiban cBoeMy KAHeHTY B OTHOMIeHHH paccnelOBaHHA oGcTOSTeALCTR noxMUleHHs MpHuayiexauyax KaneHty OOO «PHsi9H», , «Maxaona», «IlappcHHoHa> Ha nOneTABHEIX THI, KOTOpEIMH BHOCAEACTBHH GbInH ChaGPHKORANE NO/IOKHEIC JOKYMEHTHL C MOMOTILO KOTOPBIX 8 ap6urpaxuix cylax r.Mockeu, Kasana 4 Canxt-Merep6ypra 6611 nozy4en cyseGHie pemenns, NOsBOTHBUNHE 3TOYMBINIeHHHKAM NoTpeGonaTs BOIBpATa M3 GiowxkeTa pave ymIANeHMMEIX yka3aHHbIMH OOulecTBAMH Ha.TOTOB, CYMMbI KOTOpHIX BNOCHEACTEHH GEM PACKMUleHbI 310YMLIULIEHHHKAMH. AA caHTaw, 4To uMeHHO chaGpuKoBanHoe no HHMMHATHBE Ky3zHetloBa yroroBHoe ZeN0 M03B0.1H10 H3bATb yupefHTeIbHbIe H perHCTpaHOHHBle oKyMeHTES HOXHUICHHEIX OGUECTB H JHINHTE MpaBoMepHEIX COGCTReHHHKOB KOHTpO.a 33 oSmectsamu. Hmenno Kysnenon dakTH4eckH onpefleraa xox pacctenopaHHs, of CAMOCTOSTEILHO BHIZbIBAT cRYjleTeIel Ha AONpOCk, HCNOAL3yA NpesocTaBAReMEIe eMy noanucanuse c.tenonarenem Kapnomnim GaankH MopectoK. On xe dbakTHIecKH Olpenerai, KAKHE BONPOCK! HYAHO 34aBaTb CBH/IETEIAM BO BpeMs AOMpocoB, caM NpoBoqHA ponpoc cBHAeTena CaHAakona B MpHcyTcTBHA caeqoBaTeRs, KoTOpbIH TOABKO MevatTaa MpoTOKOA, pacchilaT 3anpock! B GaHKH HW eNOsHTApHH ¢ WeIbI0 OTbICKaTb AKTHBHI, NPHHapexalllMe KOMNAHHSAM, KoTOpbie GEuIH NOXHUIeHEI, HO KOTOpEIe B TO BPeMH He HPOXOMH.H HH 10 OHOMy YFOTOBHOMY jeAY- Stor xe o/y KysHewos ocymiecTBAa.. onepatwBHoe compoBowyeHHe 0 ery 374015, nosGyanennomy CK mpu [poxypatype P® no daxry xmmenHs komnannit. Hm ke ocyulecTBaRtOc onepaTHBHOe COMpoBoxyeHHe No yronoRuoMy Rey NO KOTOpOMy #1 MpuBAedeH B KayecTBe O6BHHSeMorO, H @ CHHTAIO, 4TO YFOAOBHOE MpecleHOBAHHe MeHs! ABAIMETCH MECTHIO CO CTOPOHDI YKA3AHHOTO THIS 3a To, 4TO BO BpeMa BeTped co cstenonatenem CO FOAO CK npu [poxypatype P® Topanesckum #1 coo6uiua emy 06 ykasaHHEix oGcTOsTeTLCTBAX H BLICKA3A.1 MHEHHE 0 Tom, 470 Kysvettona cnepona:to Gui ponpocuTh 06 obcrosreabcTBax noxHUIeHHs «Panna», «Maxaona», «Ilaphenuona», a ne nosponaTh eMy ocyecTezaTE onepaTHpnoe conpoBoxenue j1e1a, paccnenyemoro Topanenckum. © npsmoi sHHoK sauntepeconannocra KysHenona B ocymecBleHuH moero HevaKOHHOTO YTOIOBHOTO npecHenonanusa rosopuT H TO, 4TO MpakrayeckH BCE AOKyMeHTHI, KOTOpEe GhinH chhaGpHKoRAHbI VIA ONpaRAaHNA MOerO 3aKMIOTeHHS H conepkanHa fox crpaxel GoM coctaienbi coTpyAHHKama YUL, spasomumncaflomtmneniom Kysneuosy: Iporaosism, Kpeveropuim, Tonsauckam, PhaOpaKopantt, orepnaHo, no yka3sanHio KysHenopa. Tax, en caeqcrsenHol rpyanst Kpeseron A.A. npeqcrasut B cya Ha Paccmorpenue xogataiicTea caelcTBHa 06 H3GpaHHM B OTHOUeHHA Mera MepbI Inpece4eHHst Ba panopra C ComepXAMLHMHCH B HUX 3apCNOMO ORBLMH CREREHMAMH (0 TOM, 4TO OH, aKOGHI, MEITAICH BPY4HTE MHE MORECTKH, HO, HKOGEI He MOF MeHs najiTH H OCTABASA NOBECTKH B NONTOBOM siMHKe. TakHM oGpasom, Kpeseron A.A. cosa noxHOe foKazaTeALCTBO Toro, 4fO 8, BKOGbI YKNOHAICA OT ABKH K jenenoBatemo. Tor 2xe camusii Kpeueros A.A. u3roTopHat panopt, Koroppiii Gbut mpencTapiteH B ToT |e cy, 0 TOM, 4TO @, #KOGBI, IPH MpoBeneHHAH OGbIcKa Y Meta BKBApTHpe, BERIECKH |Mpensrerponas nponefenmio 3Toro exegcTBeHHOrO jelicTBHs, aKObEI MbITancA |CkDHITE MexoTopsie mPeMeTHI M AOKYMeHTS:, OGHApyaeHHMe HW HsusTHE B pesyabtare o6bicka. JIxHBocT 3Toro panopTa nojTBepxAaeTcA MpOTOKOTOM o6bIcka, B KOTOPOM MAT ero yHacTHAKOB, BKMOHaa camoro Kpeyerona A.A., yKa3ann, 470 HHKAKHX 3aMe¥aHHii Mo Mposejenmio TOF cneqCTBeHHOTo AelicTBHA OH He HMeIoT. Yneu caencrsennoi rpynnst Aporanos A.O. cneunanbno sia 3acelaHHa cyfa, Ha KOTOPOM GLO pacemoTpeno xo/aTaiicrBo 0 Mpo/eHHH cpoKa Moero conepxaHHa HOA cTpaxeii, HsroTOBH.I panopT, AaTHpoBaHHEA 01 AeKaGps 2008 roa. B 2ToM PaNopre OM H310KH/ 3aBeENOMO AOKHEIE CBEIeHHH O TOM, 4TO Of, AKOGBI, pactonaraer onepaTHsHoi HHopmannel 0 TOM, 4TO 9, Haxos~ach B MBC, aKoGni, Wa. yka3avHa Yepes CBoero ANBOKaTa COOGUIHHKaM BbIexaTL B QHCTY, re yepo3aMH WAH MOAKyNOM 3acraBHT paGOTHHKOD-AHBaqHA0B NofaT, 3aaBTeHHst POTHE COTPYAHHKOB MHAMUHH, NOCHE Yero BEIBESTH HHBATHAOB 3a rpaHAly KOEI AAS nevenus. Bee, 410 GbuI0 H2I0KeHO B TOM panopTe, B TOM 4HCe yKasaHHad gaTa eFO HSTOTOBEHHA, - AGCOMOTHAR H OYeBHAHAS JOKE, HCNOTEIyeMaa ¢ HebIO AMCKPeAMTHPOBATL MeHA H cO3laTb He cooTBeTcrByiomMe AelicrBHTeABHOCTA JOKHBIe OCHOBAHHS 1/18 OGOCHOBAHHS Moero apecta. A cantaio, sto Kysnenos 4 jpyrve scrynMemue ¢ HHM B CroBop coTpyAHHKA NpaBoOxpanHTeABHBIX OpraHos MoraH GBITE npHuacrHn K xHmeHMIo OOO «Pasa, “Maxao», «[lapdennom, a nocaeryiomemy xametmio 5,4 mapa.py6nelt ¥3 GioweTa OnHcaHHEIM BhIle obpazoM, u GBLIH Kpaline 3amMnTepeconann B Apeceienuw Moeii jexTeMLHOCTH, CBa3aHHOH c MOMOMIbIO MoeMy KAHeHTy B paccneqoBaHHH OGcTORTeABCTE, CBASAHHEIX ¢ YTOAOBHBIMH MpeCTyNAeHHAMH, ITO HlnocayaHn0 npHuHHol Ala ocyulecTBIeHHA Moefo He3aKOHHOrO yrosoBHOTO Inpecnenonanna, ocymlecTBAseMoro cxtenoBaTetem CH/AbYeHKO. |g cumrato, sro mpH yaacruu caegoparena CanbienKo O.®., air c ero Mour4aABOrO COraacHa ATH MeHH GbiTH cosnaHbt GectenoneTHMe H YHHAAIOUIHe AOCTOHHCTHO, MpHcymee enoRedecKol AWIHOCTH, YoOBHA cOAepKaHHA B cieRCTREHHOM w3oaaTope. 3a Bpema cojepxaHHs nog cTpaxeli MeHs IATb pas NepeBoqHAH B YeTEIPe pasHEIX Mecta cojepxasua nog crpaxeli. $1 ycran CaHTATb KaMepbI, B KOTOpHe MeHSs |mecuerHoe KouH4ecTBO pas nepesoausu. Mue He Mpelocrapiserca MeaMMMucKas |nomoms. HeoaHoKpatHo no HalyMaHHLIM 4 HeoGocHORaHHbIM npH4nnam aanpeulalores CBHAaHHA ¢ MaTepLIO W -AKeHOK, TenehouULIe PasOBOPHI C MOMMH HecopepmrennoveTHHMH jeTaMH. Bo Bpema coepxkanua Ton crpaxeli MHe cosqaBatt CUTYANHH, B Pe3YsALTATe KOTOPHX A JTHUAICR EKEHEAeTLHOTO NPABA NOALIOBATECA AYUIeM, CMOTPeTb TesIeBH30P, HMETE XOAOAHALHMK, H MpOCTO HTB B HOPMAABHEIX YOIOBHAX, HACKONEKO OHH MOryT GEITE HOpMa/ILHLIMH B CsleACTBEHHOM H30AsTOpe. SL ymepen, 47O MHe HAMepeHHO cOsaloTea TaKHe HEBBIHOCHMLIe YCIOBHA C BelOMa caeqcTana. SI yeepen, 4To €NHHCTBCHHOH BOSMOXHOCTHIO NPeKpATHTh Bce ITH WAeBATeENBCTBA Hao MHOii, 9TO cormacHTRCA ¢ HALYMaHHDIMH OOBHHEHHAMH, oronopats ce6a H apyrax Hn Al we joBepmo caeacTBHIO, cUMT@IO BCEX “eHOB caemcTReHHO! rpyrnbt HcnOAHHTeARMH “Bero-TO MpecTynHoro 3aKa3a. AL He mpusnavo 3a coGoii HHKaKOH BHHBI, 1 He COBeptad HAKAKHX mpectynenuil, B TOM 4HeAe Tex, KOTOpLIe MHE MUKPMMUMMPOBAHLI B MOCTAHOBEHHH caenCTRAA 0 MpHBsleveHHM Mens B KayecTBe OOBHHseMoro OT 07 oxTaGpa 2009 ronan. 4, Tlocne storo B npoToKoste 6110 yKa3aHo, ¥T0 K Hemy MATHUTCKMH C.JI. nputaraer NOPOTOBIEHHOE HM 3asBNeHKE 10 CyuleCTBY NPEABABNEHHOTO OGBHHEHHA caeqyIoUtero conepxanus: «lo cyntecrBy npexbanneHHOro MHe OOBHHERHA XO4y IANBUTH cHeAyLoUte 1. 51 He poropapueaaca nn ¢ Pnanoii mpenctasureaecraa KoMnaHHH «pMHTAXK Konutan Meneament JIumurea» Yunamom Denakcom Bpaynepom, Hu c KaKHMH-1H60 HHBIMH JIHIaMH © COBMecTHoM coBepuleHHH aeiicTBHii, HanpapseHHbIx Ha YKAOHeHHe OT ymaTeI HaToron c opraHHsanuii- wanoronaaterbuukos §=OOO «Jlanbuaa Crens» a OOO «Catypn Hunectmento> slyTeM BKMOYeHHA B HanoroBWe AcKRApAUMN 3aBET0MO AOMHBIX cBeqeHHii, rpynnol AMM MO MpelBapHTeABHOMy cropopy B ocoGon Kpynuom pasmepe. Bosee toro, a serpetanca c Yuubamom Denuxcom BpayjepoM ue Gosiee erbipex pa3 38 Bce BPEMsL HAlllero 3HAKOMCTBA, KAKABI Pas MBI NPAKTHHecKH He OGMLANHCE H HUKOTIA He OGcy*AANH © HUM HH OfHOFO Bonpoca fesTexbuocTH Komnannii «lamuaa cremb» a «Catypa Hunectmento», Tem Goaee Mbt He OGcyax1a/1M BOMpOck! HCHHCEHHA H YILIATEL nasoros. . SI we opravHz0pbipast conepulenHe KakHx-1HG0 npectynsenwii, B TOM HHCHE He ParpaGarbinan cxemy mpHoperenua akuni xKpynnelimux poccuiicKax AKUHOHePHEIX oGulecTB, HX MocneayIoMe mpolaxH H HesaKOHHOrO OGorauleHHst HYTeM YKAOHEHHG OT YiLIATEI Ha.loroB. AA we wMex HHKAaKoro OTHOMeHHA K PerHcTpalMH H MOcTaHOBKe na Hagoropbiii yxet OOO «JlannHas Crem» 1 OOO «Catypn Hazectmenter. Camu no ce6e fauubie pelicans we obpasyioT HHKaKOro coctapa mpectynsienna. . A HMKorma He ocyulecrBaA daKrHuecKOro pyKosorcTBA H ynpaBsenua AeRTENLHOCTEIO YKA3AHHBIX OPHAHYECKHX JAI: a. He NpHHHMan HHKAaKHX penleHHii oTHOcHTenbHO TeKyurelt xosaiicTBennoli femTemBAOCTH 2THXx OGulecTR, B TOM HCAE 3aKTOTeHHS HMH JOroBopoB, pacnopaxeHua AMYULeCTBOM, HaiiMa COTpPyAHHKOB, KAKHX-1HG0 HHBIX SOMpocoB, OTHOcHUINXeA = — KOMNeTeHUHH eAMHOAHUHOTO HenosMATeTBHOrO opraHa 3TAX O6MecTB; b. 3 He pykosoqH jelicrsuamn Bpayaepa Y.@., Koropbiii spastca AMpexropoM 9THX OGmiecTBa, ne Jabal eMy WHKAKHX ykasanHii ornocutenbHo jearersnocta OOO «laabuas Crens» 1 OOO «CarypH Vinnecrmenres, B TOM SHcJe OTHOCHTeAbHO MpHBneyeHHa 9THMH O6mectsamH jeHexKHESX cDpercTA, HX HHBECTHpOBAHHA B AKUHH, peaslH3aunu MpHoGperenHnx akunii, Hala coTpYAHHKOB; €. 1 He pyKOBOAHA jelicTBHSMH COTpyAHHKoB 9THX OGmecTR, B TOM HHCAe He H3jaBan WHKAaKHX MPHKa30B, pachopsxentii, He 1aBa1 HM HHKaKHX ykasannii, 51 ne nonysas mpock6st HH ykasanua ot Yubama PeanKca Bpaynepa, paBHo KAK H OT OGLIX HHELX UU, 0 paspaGoTKe Mana cobepuleHus Mpectynienus — ykslosenas oT ynnars nastoros OOO «annaa Crenu» 1 OOO «Catypu Hupectmento> a HHKorga Takoro miana He paspaGaTsipan. O cymecrBoBaHHH ‘Fakoro Ilana MHe HH4ero He H3BECTHO.6. A He MpHHHMan HAKaKoro ysactaa = HasHayenHH Bpaynepa Y.2. na WOMKHOCTE reHeparbHoro aMpexropa OOO «aasnaa Creny» x OOO «Catypn Hupecrmente>, ne joroBapHBaica o ero Ha3HasenHH Ha ty AOTKHOCTE HH C HAM CaMHM, HH ¢ HHbIMH J1HNaMn. SI TaloKe He JaBa.l HHKOMY ykasannii naznagaTs Bpaygepa Y.®. na 9ty nonxHocTs. O Tom, sro Bpayaep Y.©, apasaes s Kakoii-ro nepuon renepanbuLim aupeKtopom OOO «Jaabuas Crent» u OOO «Catypn Vinnectmente> mue 6bi10 H3BecTHO, NOCKOABKY Ocenbio 2002 roga @ Oka3EIBaT MpaBOBy!0 NOMOM> B BENeHHH Mmpoteca OAHHM 43 3THx o6mecTs B Ap6utpaxnom Cyne Kaamercnn. 7, SL ue opranmaonbina.t Beene GyxrarTepeKoro yuera OOO «ansusa Crem» 4 OOO «Carypu Husecrmento» HeycranonneHHbimMn auuamn, A TaKKe He HcnoaABaA 06s34HHOCTH raaBHoro 6yxrantepa OGulecTB. 8. Ane nogsickwnan ua Tepputopan Pecny6ankn Kaamurkna amu, uMeromux HHBAAHAHOCTH, AAT BKMOVeHHA HX B uTaT OOO «annnaa Crem» 1 OOO «Cartypu Husectmento». 9. Mue w3nectno 4ro OOO «laasusa Crenb» 1 OOO «Catypx Hunecrmente» OcymecTBAawH aKTH4ecky!0 AesTeNLHOCTh Ha TeppHTopHH Pecny6aHKH KanMnikust, COOTBeTCTBOBAIH BCeM KDPHTepHSM HHBECTHpORaHHS, Ha 3AKOHHEIX OCHOBAMMSX NPHHSLIN Ha paGoTy JHU, HMeIOUIHX HHBAAHAHOCTS, a NOTOMY 3aKOHHO BocnoaEsoBaqHNcE B 2001 roxy AbroTaMH Mo ynaaTe Hasora Ha npn6nias. 10. we gorowapusanca nu c Bpaynepom Y.®., nH ¢ KakHMH-2H60 HALIMK ANMAMH 0 BKAOYeHHA B HaqoroBy!0 jeKstapanuio H HHEIe GyxraarTepcKHe Zoxymenrst OOO «Jlaavuaa Creme» u OOO «Catypn Hunectmenre» 3aBeqoMo AoRUbIX cBexeHHi. Mue uspectHo sro OOO «laabuan Crenb» 4 000 «Catypu Husecrmente» 8 2001 rogy 3aKonHO Bocno.30BaAHCh sBTOTOH No ynaave Hasora Ha MpHGbIAb, NOCKOABKY B AX Tate paGoTa.t0 Gonee 50 MpoueHTOB JHU, HMCIONIAX HHBATHAHOCTL H YKAsAHHBIe OpHAHYECKMe «HA COOTReTCTBOBAIH BCeM ‘TPeCOBAHHAM, MNPEIBABAeMEIM K KOMIIaHHSM, OcyMIecTBAIONIHM HHBECTHNHH B 92KOHOMHKY Pecny6amkH KanmniKus. Yrwepaaars nogoGHoe mue Jaer npano TOT dat, ro OOO «Jaanusa Crenb» 4 OOO «Carypu HinnectMente> noayaHaH cooTBeTcTayIoulHe cepraHKathl H Guim BHeceHBI B peecT Npe_NpHATHH, ocyMecTBAMOUIHX HHBECTHHHA B Pecny6amxy Kaamerkuto. 11. A ne OGecnesupan ocopMaenne nepaH4HEIx H GyxraatepcKHX JOKYMeHTOB ¢ 3aBe10MO OKHLIMH cBejeHHAMH 0 paGote B OOO «/laBuaa Crem» 1 OOO «Catypu Hunectmenro>. 12. we mpeanarax Banbxaesy nan I[eqeeny, 3a nosnarpaxaenne, naira MHBANHAOB Wd BKIOYeHHA HX B Tar OOO «anbuaa Creme» x OOO «Catypn Hunectmente», a Takoke He Mor cooSulaT» HM 0 KAKHX-T0 cCBOHXHaMepeHuax OTHOCHTeALHO paGOTbI YKASAHHLIX JHU B yKaIaHHEIX KOMMAHHSX H HCHHCsAeHHH HMM Haztorop. C WeneeBbim @ nosHaKomHsies nocare ocenH 2002 Toua Korga # MpHGbIN B JAMCTY AAA yaactus B cyAeGHOM SactaHHH HM panee MBI 3HaKOMBI He Guia. K 9TOMy MoMeHTY Bce paGOTHHKH - HHBATHALI yxe SucaMuch B urtatax OOO «aabuaa Crem» # OOO «Caryps Hanectmentoy & paGoranu. C Barkwessim # Taicke nosaxomuscst B Kouue 2002 rona B anere. 13. A we paspaGarsian TpyAoBKe Aoronops! H urTaTHoe pacnHcaHHe OOO 8 kayecTBe oprannsaunii, ocywecratsmIomHx MMRecTHNHH, Taloke Kak # He Hanpansiaa H MiaTexHEle nopyseunst Ne 63 4 Ne 65. Bonpexw yreepxaenmo cnexcTBHs 0 TOM, TO perHcrpauna B Munucreperne uupectumHoHHoll HOAMTHKH HMenAa cpoelt NexLIO yKnoHeHHe OT YANaTEI HATOFOB, 1 CHHTAIO, YTO ykasAHULIe JelicTBHM Crporo CooTBETCTBYIOT ‘TpeGonanHaM 3aKoWOnaTenveTRa MH HeOGXOAHMBI lax 3aKOHMOrO HCNOAB30BAHHA ALOT WAOTONAATeALUIHKOM, B COOTBETCTBHH ¢ 3aKOHOM, UpeqoctaBasOWlHM HAOrOBEIe ALroTE! 18. Yrnepaxnenne cxeacrBHA © TOM, 4TO ompepra He cosepxana cymlecTBeHUBIX yenopHii AoroBopa No OcymecTBseHHIO HHBecTHUHH, aBAReTCH JLoAHEIM. Bostee Toro, CAMO CieACTBHE B NOCTAHOBACHHH O MPHBAeTeHHH MeHA B KAyeCTBE o6pHHseMoro yrnepmaer, sto OOO «Jaapuaa Crene» 1 OOO «Catypa Hunectmenre> Oni BHecent B peecTP IOpHAHYECKHX AWM, OcyWlecTRIMIOMHX HHBeCTHNMOHHY!O AestTeNbHOCTE. Ito NonTBepxNaAeT TO, ¥T0 OOO «JJanbuas Crent» 1 OOO «Carypa Hnsectmente» ocymecrBum pce HeoGxoquMEIe AeiicrBHA ANA Toro, YTOGEI CHHTATECH NpeANPARTASMH, OCyUIeCTBARIOMMMA HnpecTHHH B 3KoHOMAKY Pecny6auKu KaameiKHa H, cooTBeTcTBeHHO, HOTB30BATECA npeACCTABNAEMBIMH 3AKOHOM HAOFOBLIMH ABrOTaMH. Yreepagenne 0 TOM, 4TO OdepTa H pacnopaKeHMe NpeAycmaTpHBaIA 3ak04eHHe HHBECTHNHOHHOTO oroBopa H AONOAHATeNBHOTO CoraMeHHA He coorpeTcrayeT AeHicTBMTeNHOCTH., T-K. HH o*epra, HH pactiopsxKeHHe Ha 2aTy Paccmarpmpaembix coGsiTaii TaKHX ‘TpeGoBannis Me conepxKanH, caM HHBECTHIMOHULIH 7OTOROp GBA saKMOGeH KOHKIOAeHTHEIMH nelicTRHSMH 000 «antnas Cress» a OOO «Catypa Husectmento», a HMeHHO aktenTOM opepTsI nyrem Hanpannenus naaTewa B CYMMe HB CPOKH, YKAs@HHbIe B opepte. Jrot sonpoc yxe yeTaAbHO paCcMaTpHBanca cneqcTBeHHEIMA opraamn. Tak, 8 HOCTaHOB.AeHHH o NpeKpauleHHH yro1OBHOro Jena OT 5 Mast 2005 r., pbinecenHom crapmam creqoBatenem C4 CY npa MBI Pecny6anKu Kaamerkas Hycxuvospim JL Jl, ykasano «B coorsercrsuu ¢ mHCbMOM Muuncteperpa uusecrunmonvoi noauraka PK No236-PH or 23.03.2000 r. 4 ceprapaxarom = Mynuywnansuoro = pouja = noayepaKA = Matoro HpeAMpHuAMateaLeTBa H PasBATHS KOHKYpennHA r. Ianter Ne614 ov 06.05.1998 ©. COO « kem-H60 or umenn Y.@. Bpaysepa, # HX mpenoctapene 29 Mapa 2009 roa B Hasloronyyo wucHeKMMIO. 21, Jleranbno osmakomHBUIHch ¢ JoKymentamu OOO «anbuas Crems» 1 OOO «Carypu Hunectmenre> 5 2002-2003 ronax 8 pamKax RejenHsa apOurpaxnoro esa 1 npuuien K yGexlenmio, KoTOpoe pazjenaio HB HacTomee BPEMM, 0 TOM, STO YKASAHHBIC KOMMHHH COBEPHINIH BCe HEOGXOAMMEIe AeHCTBAS AIH Toro, 4TOObI COOTRETCTROBATE KPHTepHaM MpeRUpHATHH, ocymecTBAMOMIHX WHBECTHUMH H HCHOMKIOBATE HaJOFOBBe JTLFOTE 8 cOOTBETCTRAH Cc 3akonosaTenpcrnom = PecnyOnuka Kasmeikus. 37H —o6cTomtenberpa NOATRepANCHM BKNOAeHHEM KOMMAHHil B COOTBETCTBYLOUIHH peecTp, a TAKE ABIEQANGIMH HaOTOBLIMH NpoBepkamH 3a 2000-2002 ron. 22,OsnaKkoMMBIIHC B Xone NoATOTOBKE K cHOpy © HaTOFOBOH oceHBIO 2002 ¢ AOKyMeHTaMH Mo Tpyqoycrpoiicray HHBaNAOB, A MpHillen K BEIBORY, 4TO HHBAAHAL GLH MpHHATL wa paGoty B O6mectBa B cooTReTCTBHH c TpeGopaHHsMu AelicrByromero 3aKoHOAATeALCTBA, HA 3aKOHULIX OCHOBAHHS, H coctapaanu we mene 50% cpesHecnHcoaHol “HcaeHHOCTH paGoTHHKoB O6mects. B sto# cea3H upHMenenwe OGmecTBaMH sroTEI NO HanOry Ha MpH6esa, npexycmotpennofi 4. 2 ct. 6 3akona P® «O nanore wa mpH6biiE Rpeqmpastnim, Guino aGcomorHo 3aKoHHEM. Buionei caercrBHa 0 uKrveHom Tpysoyctpoiictse maBatun0B Ha padory B OGmectBa ne cooteeTcTByiOT HH @aKkTH4eCKHM OGCTOsTeILCTBaM, HH nonOKeHMAMsakonoateabcrea. lokymenthi ¢ HHBanHaaMH GELTH — odopmsienI HaquiexallHm o6pas0M, B COOTBeTeTBHH c TpeGonauHaMmH seiicrBylomero 3AKOHOAATEALCTBA: C KAxAKIM HHBAHAOM ObLT MOAMHCAH TpyZOoH AOroBOP, Auperropom O6utecte, Bpayaepom, Gbi1 Haga MpAKa3 O MpHeme Ha paGory, ¢ KoTopuiM KaxKaMii paboTHMK GuLI oanakoMaen. OT HHBavHAOB O1J1H HonyieHbt 3aNBIeHHA o TOM, 4To paGora B OGmecTBaX Aaa BMX HBISeTCH OcHOBHKIM MecTOM paGoTsI. JJanHoe oGcTosTeKcTHO GBUIO OTpaxKeHO B TPYAOBESX AoroROpaX c HHBAMHIAMH. HuBaAHA GLLIM HaHATEI B KayecTBe COTpyAHHKOB avaJHTHYeCKOrO oTAeAAa AAA paGoTHI Ha AOMy, Yo TaKKe coorBeTcTBoRAaNO 3aKoHo/aTembcTBy. PaGoTa Ha jOMy He TpeGonana oT paGorosatens cosaanua paGounx Mect. B npegcraBilennbie HHBATHAaMH TPYAOBHIe KHHAKH OLLI BHEceHbI 3ANHCH O MIpHeMe HX Ha paGory, a Avs JMU, KoTopbsle MpeqCTaBH.IH CHPABKH 0 TOM, To 70 NocrynaeHus B OOO «aneusaa Creny» 1 OOO «Catypa Hnpectmentoy oH He HMeTH TpystoBoro craxka, GuuIH B cooTRETCTBHH ¢ 3aKOHO/aTeILCTBOM 3aBexeHKI HoBbIe TpyzoBbIe KHWKKH. PaGOTHHKH-HHBARHALL MonyYanH MpelycMoTpenHy!o TpyAOBbIM oropopom 3apaSoTHylo HaaTy, KoTOpad NepedHcmasiack na GauKonckue c4eTa, WMH caMuMu yKasanubie, B HasHadenHsXx nuiaTexa B MMATeRHDIX NOpyteHHsaX Guino yka3auo, 170 9To 3apaGoTHas Mata. PaGoTAAKH-HHBAAHAbI BLINOTHATH paGory, KoTopas nomHocTHIO yronneTBopata paGoTosaTesa B MepHon c 1998 no 2004 roga, 7.e. H 20 H Hocae Toro, KaK B 2001 rogy OOO «Janbuas Crenu» 4 OOO «CarypH Hunectmenro» pocnons30paauce npeqocrapseHHoli 3aK0HOM Abrotoii no ynaare wanora Ha npHObur. Hx paGora 3akmouastack B TOM, 4TO OWH OTCHEKHBA.IH H3MeHeHHs B 3AKOHOAaTeNbeTBe PectyGmHKH KasmnikHs 1, B cay'1ae HeoGXORHMOCTH, MHCAaH OTHETEI. 23.To, aTo zeatessuocts, OSmects G1u1a Hanpanieda Ha nonysenne npHOLuIH («oGoramenue»), Bnomue coorReTeTByeT HenaM KoMMepYeCKHX OpranHsaunil. 24 leiicreyromee 8 2001 rony saxonogatennctBo P® ne sanpemasto OGmectnam TOMb3OBATLCS YCTAHORACHHLIMA HAOTOBLIMH ABTOTaMH, B TOM “Hee, BeCTH BONO JesTeALHOCTh TAKHM 06pas0M, 4TOGHi COOTRETCTROBATE TeM HaslorOBLIM arora, KoTOpEIMH OGulecTRa 2kes1a1H BOCTIONE30BATECHD.soe nagar 8 16-% 20 Neer Gonpos exosen 8 19.9 30 xm caenosare no OBY creicraennoro oraena no 1OAO CY Cx q cei poryparypk PO n0 r Mockse vopnce 1 easeca Topatencrat CE, & nosesemnt caymetnoro kaGuem Ne 29 & coortescrnen oF a9 w 190 (1 "® acurpocna no yrasotony aesy Ne 374015 8 xaveetec canacress: | Qonenans, woes, oTICCTHO: Maramrexutt Ceptet Teoms0s bees ee omens 3, Mecro poacientta: F.Onecca Vxpazascxod CCP 4 Mecto warremcria i (iH) peructpapen: ¢. Mocisa, yn Tho ‘ pen 8-916-675-84-75 a EY ao § Fpexaancrao: PD 6, OGparopasine’ mactuee 7 Ceselinoe noxomesiue: aur 8. Mecto paGora nm yaecOke: ayanerap 3A) «tPatteperoyn Hatenct» : 9, Qniosente K BORCKOR oGsaNsoCrH: RORRMoOBrRAtHEET 4 10. Hammar cysnuoce He cyzaI 1, Tlacnopr WAH mHCH AOXyMeNT, YROcroREpOUD aMNLOCTE cHuneTens: 45 OS 623943, maaan ols OBA Bacasnnore psa r Mockans 15.05.2003. 52, Hive samme o srmoeTm canzeteax: & HILn TIL co enow ua yucte ne cocrowt Csunerem, L Vouse yuaereyronuse sutnm axpoxer Xapuronos Jporprtt Baxepsenu, y sauzane 2404.03 TY MiO Poccun uo r.Mocine MKA al pases n Haprsepian opmep N04 Yracrepounon mai oOaaieNo H NpaMewemas TexHMNEcKux peacTe it apimsemomcs_ Tlepea namin 2onpoce mie pesuscnesta ripana x OBsRasNOCTH. cRUIeTESS, UpeaycMorpenmnie wacTLio YeTECPTOR cr. 56 YTIK Pd: % 1) omauarsce connerexscTauaars mporns casoro ee6a, cnoero -Bynix Gmarskwx PoaCTHCEIEAKOS, RpyT KoTopLEx onpencgen #4 ev.5 VII ‘Soxasarms # apenyperteR_0 TOM, TO MOM HOKASEIA AoKMSBTEALCTE LO YTOTOBHOMY NOMY, & TOM NBEOE H B MYER normed asTe eyamescny yronontoro nes Tio poaY choc mpoece KpecuOUpOACTSPeRAR, ROM 30, expoctme |. tae a € Mecano» tourer sete Bass ees Cama, eae = fk eo gard ene yolynt no aovonopas, sixcoosenmam ¢ xen. B. owe i ReGen GOLECTS, OTOP Cea NE KOO YAPEEITEINENE, SOOO XPreusopa Xonmurrs Jinwrresn (Glendora Hox pocertfexol KoMmTATIEN OOO «Pumaitz» 1 OOO ill {Kone Holdings Limited), ataamomed! 100% ak OOO eMsaaoay ¢ 1 arxaSps 2005 ros mseten Ton Pens, aupetroposs OOO «flapgenmann 26 moe 2006 to anaaerex Maprins Zbsou Vancom, om ie sataerea aapeRropon OOO «Paitin © 1 eka rox, 000 skaven». OOO «Hlapdexmor», OOO «Purim 1 O00 «Maxson » 2006 raxy smsunrersebe EaxeTL ax OAQ «Paampown, KoTOpME HMM GHA NpMoGpeTesM 3 MpeNEIYT roma. B pesyqerare TpOROXH yRmaMMN asm KOMIIALGM noRyeam snameTeMune ¢ patie, Naor © Koropax Gas tanazren » Geapane — ampere 2006 rona no cranes W 3 G yereroeseumie PoccnfiexaM waloraan sarougmirenersow. Tlociie yroars wasors ocTamunites patie Guna pacnperenena 8 Meay yqscrimko pocenticerx OOO, cexaoaa, Oxon nHUIpCHE KONE Cywms ynraseumace wanorom Chtth sar rresMATLNO, “70, 1O-MUDIMOMY, RANG Horrepee: sauonom. Hackomxo 4 nosnoo, » wae 2006 sauna sapere KOM Galosae rasan kosmenaush re Gasteos. Co con revepambtzoro ampextope OOO aiKwvenn Yepeacona’ Mae iepectwo, ro ® kowme max 2006 roma compyamme YHIT spx TYBI no t, Mockne Kys A.K timate cRavati.cs sampoorms nepANTIAyIO DOKYMERTANNO flo Kowa Kah pes 000. Mockomry Yepeacon H.C. ems n nasare 2006 roaa yexar xa Pocei ana BesnacSpwramint, 8 fO‘PEKTOPIS ApYTEX KOMNANI RAREANCK _ROCTPSENNIH rowraxK YnoIMoMODL MoeTO wwaKOMor Canaxona AA. actpeTitTacs ¢ Kystcuosnine AIK. 747 Keobnemnete COnacmem. Catizaxcs ofsskmACT JOPANITICEAIE YET, M HOME fa covepmeune xaicm-T0 eRerant OT HME HRHOCTpaHETIx yancTHEXO O6MICCTR, Camaros scrpesaca ¢ Kyatetionum AK, B Ravane mm copemmic seta 2006 rose. Casations s suao, yro Kysneaos AK. smrrepeconance aemremaccro yoann oxsannan Cenmanony GaRKOCKHE EEIIMEG M eIME KAKHE-TO AORYMERTE ormyaa ROCTYTANH ReNeACINe CpemeTEAY KAR HAMpARALLIACe, KAX, yi HRGIMC, 3Wcorpymunsoe scans. epes necomno (@ana) Cepsnces Jaren x cooGunize, #0 Sop Soe eta cee Mog ‘Sanepcroy Mawncex (CRARSe) Tncarea,Mororare We YRINAMO, KAGKe mea Aoey wiecrepeK 9TH ROXYMCNTY xpenunice, aoxymewm OOO «Pasay, Koreas crore, Gum noxpoGno nepeme : " sapotino nepewxcteni sco 08 7. HOXOMDUMICE OPETMM Nocaea sieppemon>. OOO «PEER x OOO sMicnn fnunvonu yer, CPHTUNARI cHHEXeTECTS 0 rocymapersemOd pees "ama, rene y feTpaRHOR OpIUGHUREOTO opuraman tpororonde coCpaKaR PEER exmcTaeMEIN Seacrrimon GOMEETS, psmatiNl ema CSPTURMAETS,ETHCPRRAG PENT YORTONRGD SOK we _apyrae aoKYWeira. ‘Flocne oGweRa am OmIOrD us’ YxASAMEAIK. pmo mini OBMIECTY 8 once EONAR He feTaOC. me ze oftecks Take Sunt HNMR XOMEMKOTEpM, OpuUaZexaRnmte @aepcroyn JlummeM (CHAR2«) Jignete 3, 6 TOM “Olen ceppepAt H PAGORNE CROLL, wk OTOpUK B IMEIRPORHON Gone sick Roxy Wer OOO «Kasers, OOO «Flsppensor, COO «Paransy x O00 «Meson g cnc, TERCTE YEFAMOR, ROREPEMHOCIES, mpoToRDTOR Copan YMACTEAKON, M HeXOTOPLEN ewenTos, TT MOeky MiRCiEmO, KOTOPEE ¥ Mex eHOATINOCK NONE HXYHEHE NOREEN Sovosans cprasos KOM nosok PEAR YereRs COO Puxrear, Repent GOO «Hay7oe, smame REpORWO, ro MMeHEO aneKrTpoINe GANAS, KOTOPRNE AmODENe. sALeTAK y KoMMAHon Dafieperoym amen (CHARI) Tknatrer 8 xose CkeRs soxmiotepax, F)470 CHO AORANS suk COCTABERN 2xOM HORDE PeAGKTIM YETARR TAF KAK TERT " UPAKTINCER RAEUTINEH TOMY, NOTOpUl conepRaace 8 yrasastaX alkaary ot KTHLENTENGH C YRETON WK MEUM ocoGeamocTeR m GUA Neck B vexcte woea -rana GOO «Purvi, o KOTOPOR HET pew, aaKe GL anierpedarece wecme ouMABFE, AONMEMWE NPA NepRONERANaRos x HEPEAM ycTiaOs OOO «Kamen, OOO OPHONNATM CEMTETERLCTA O NOCTAROERE 8 Besepow 8 news ofiucka ROM Ha creayouNN Jew 2 Gecezonaa ¢ Hepwacouin H.C. 20 Teeny, og cman wae, “ro Kysmeuow AK, mpacyteruexat npw oBscxe = odmee Qanmana Sprotae Kommrax (Paats) Cepances Thncrren w sanman Komy-ro xoaner epxacona H.C, xoTopsie ApyeyreTaoname nIpH DCrPERETECA, KOTAA IO peNArAM, TOrAS Bel MHNER Tavoro we npowaosz0 8 more 119 aaryeve 2007 rons exeaouarens Kapuos TLA., xovopoMy nepeaRm exeacrale 10 ae 000 «Kanen® simsaan ma aoupos Canzaxone. TTo xaKolt-r0 mpreie CaRtatoe me ewor xBRTEEA 1 veay p manntewnoe BpeRSt, A OREAEML, KOTAK MKOMDENCE w ofpuce dum esleperoy Tasik | (CRAH3c) Jbeworrea, tryna smnes Kysuenos A.K. ann toro, 06m upyurt, Camzaxony ‘AT OCYMICCTURTS €To ipHAyayTeskMaM npawox ua dorpoc. YI ‘AX, cxa3e1, ‘10 MME OM TORE BPYWET (DOBEETKY, seat MOULIN 8 KOMMATY aK MEpeTOBOPS, Kymeaos aocran m2 nant niewry Guamos nosectox, yae nogmmcammx Kepnoms 1A. cepenteHanms Kaxo-TO newaTHO, no-MoeMy, nevarLio TCY, Venomsys 7a Gram K on AD snanacan novectxy Capizaxony, Mie meme, kamen, PyacesofJL.A., 1 Bpy‘a0t Me 2TH 10 Co caow Canamona Mue uspecTHO, so KOraR OM € allPORATOM MpHOLT so Mockat x cnezonatemo Kapnosy ILA, » xaGuuete naxomumcs Kapnos ILA. 1 Jlonpoc sen KyzHenos A,K., 8 C¢0BaTEMD M6tth IAUHCHBAN BOMPOCE! H OTRETH. Astorar Gadtepcroyn Auaxen (CHANGe) Junarrea, a MpEACTaRTeANat KONI Spamazich & eneaomare;no Kapaony ILA. 6 sorspemenHe HEXOTOANTD AYGAMURET HeMaTeH, MyGmmeare Gree Gus, SoOMOIOUDINCR maTOTORREABIEN NEATER H ures CSpeauan OTTICKON HepuotiawaMinsy neqerell ua pon Gum upeaecTameR peacranirenmon sosmasHil. B KaKOR ONKDCTNO, xouasotm, Glew inroronatims ues O00 «Manaow, 000 eMlapmom u OOO Pasany one eka Be ory TAR XAK TOT XC WEPWOR Gham daxasans NeuaTD GoautDOre ene apyru oBtacerm, 0 xoropsx Game ea Mpa oGexe, MnO KOTOpKM taxa NeOoLOMIMO Earw rooean Kana, KARE HHH Ht Fe GL MATOTOBAEHH 8 KSCTORTCE BpeMA RePOUSHORND, Mlocne ssrovoRnewts pewars OOO «Maxson», OOO «llapdennon» x OOO «Panzete UEXOSILANCS pace koomamin @afepezoym Tamxen, Tenepaxbinze anpertops xaxi0N 5 Koomamel, ayOm0es PRA Ohi HAFUTOBACM, WDA APARATO HAAS MEROMMAORARTA MORM severed pwkasti GW AcsTannems 8 owe KoMmunr Dafieperoye asxKen xypLepeR - ckopee seere DHL ‘ Bonpoc crenosareas: Mowers 2m Bix opeaoctanis mpuxaiis of axpextopos 06 msroTosaestin sydamaror 2 Onner: 4 # RactoutIM(A MOMENT He MOFY, 2.x, He SHMUO THE Olt, HO Eom} HeoGxomonl A cawEKye © aMpeXTOPAMH KOMTIANU B LORYKCRTH Ovayr UpenocreATeNA, Bomomenst oScrorresicre, mpm woropuut sme crazo wisetrdo o rom, ra OOO «flapiexmot 000 aPuxmz # OOO «Maxsomy Sai NONKMIEM Hx IEKONHAIC HALIEASHES MOCY NOKESST saeayroimee. B cae c yeM, 19 @aflepctoyn Aawwer (CRANIc) mere ocymecrmasto Topmmveckoe Syvranrepexoe conposcanemne aememuocTs OOO «Tapper», OOO «Prem n OOF Maxson, mpeacranerent Oafleperovu Hasaxes (CuAS3e) Jaren neproriecit SYA RCI KOPPECHOHLACHTGHO ApURoARYO B aapeC mUMMeyRATaNEEN oGmecTs, B cepeAKt orrstpx 2007 roaa api OvepeAHOR MpORSpXe KOPPeENOMIeKIGM, NOTOPSX RAKpARIENeCh: B ropmaimeckue aapeca Crapommenosexait nep., &, 13 erp. 2, 6tt ara m Mocxae, ya. OGpaaiions, 5 19, crp. 9, no xoropias superacrpupovasta GOO «Tiapersicrs, OOO «Pxaetz 4 OOO «NfaxsoH ruixcuerecr, to wa aapec m CrapouRMeMoackow Repey/ine Shiatt AOCranACHD NECKONDND THEM, oropuix naxomume® cyAcGie OMpEAReNAs © NESHANCHMM ApKrepeKaED cy 0. TOPO Care Tlereptypra Jleanmrpaaceoft oGnacrst cyneGmnux saceamin® to weKaa 3AO eioroc Fave», "REx? on mcm weeny npememseint O00 sania OOS Pesce, 06) «Maxaow 370 auwcustnocs 16 oxtabips 2097 roa. ‘tees, a Tare ws sunpopue Koropyo s » Yor me AeMb DOTY IEE na cattte yaa, Hoe craze BIReCTHO, TO SAO «loro TI Boman HEX HA CYNMM OT HECKOMIOM NIIIMIOHOR Ao BOR Reyx SMAMMEEPION ‘PRNDEAL KONIRHODE, CCHLIAACH Ma sHOGLA SAETICHIENEESE HM AOTOROPH7 g epnay #6 cookiiann 06 THe AoKyMene: i Alpes raX R enenersex Hepeacony H.C. ui KneBieny BY. -paberaer srt ® Tor eprom ® JTemaowerose aan Sraeeion eG 7 ee cna aaeneR face nocanx Spun Koen Ot Oat Raarenr. OOO “Elaphe, OOO -l Soe sr 000 W MNATS NO KEM pens B M@HC No 28, 9 we Koropyo sa wamTnceanan ws El Fr 000 «Maxton K OOO ell ‘a Jere w ances He eOETORT. MHOHC Ne 46, xy2i0 ‘acwe oGpanmimet oa nimeceann 22 smsepe 2008 ron, crxesnnice spounsth (aXNTCHIA 42 AX AMM, MOTMERORED Orxay Tem; NTO MEMRROATO AN ITOFO. OH saperncrpmponaitsr HOMCHCURA YYPRIMTEMBURIE aOR yweiTTIg BceX Tpex KOMTANTE. RoayoMn mamiteRn tty Meapaior Joi3 0 Poeroenol OOmaeTR, evan Gum bepenenats ae pt kena, 40 Komyueuy oes be yatrock 3-38 TOTO, 479, 10 €TO ChoAAN, sHANATE AOTARLOCTENE AKA MHLCNERTOON HesaxORHS peony, "708% y Hero Gsxmm AOMepeMROCTH OF SCex TPEX KoMAAMK, MOTOM. ROTA TeNE onepetmiocTH OF PONY, AMIN KABANITS OTM Box ofuacHeNRA Maan. Komyaoe imuraxcs pewHTs BompoC ¢ HOAYRCUNCK muMMICOK sepes Yipannemae @HC no Pocrowesol Garr cGwanonan TaM nelicrans MMOHC 213, nacxomixo amie sanecrso, Yapansemte aaxe MAGHC 2e13 yearue BHELAT HICK, OANAKO STO YraBANUE TaK ¥.e GuatO BMOMMEHO. B one wapra 2008 ro7s ot Knetinepa BLT. sme crato wamectno, wro om obkapysew na calize SHC PR mnpoomarnno O TOM, WTO We Te oGmecrsa O7 mapra 2008 roma cwowa Guts epeperMeTpHPORAn!, © pesYIMTATE SEFO A peectpE NORMAANCS 3AM O YOM, YEO HNN Gk ‘msuaient Rosie aApextop CTupoas Punova Muxaltronsa, scout! yaseriom nova Kowa “SORT CHCTEMC JT” i ece apm rosmmanins Gaim nepencacrn » Xia. 26 wapra 2008 roga OpFRMNDOEAT noRAYY sANpOCOS wa DONYEKHE MUTINEDK Hes Mexpallonol sameness @eacparHoll naoroRO® crym6u Ne 13 mo MockoscKot ofsacnt, ofMako MMC nosy. we YLANOCE, TOK KA HUCUOMIIN CTRCTILNA, 70 PerNCTpAMNONNCe AeM0 TYAR EME Hh AEEYTAO, 18 mapra 2008 roaa w owe atlepcroyn Jlamren (CHAM3c) Jmorrex Skin noeraRNEWR NOBECTER anase ta anmpoc x cnenonaremo CH ops. TY MBJL P® no OO byzuno H:H, ABpextopon OOC sTlappesaow, OOO «Parmer x OOO «Maxson» Pera x Yiticoits, 8 acwe PAIR Tom ConpyIAaRMiN ¢ YRASERINH KOMMAMEAEH Ht OastepeToyH JlarKen (CHAMSe) Tioeen, CO anpeae 2008 rox smaTorvaHBie NoBcCTKR CTAIH NOCTYUATL Ha ROMAUNRME AIPES YR THRE Upwien uovecros, xsTaposarimnse 02 ampein 2008 roas, nce nogmacam He sMexaony, a rare mx aefllermaremuix yaacrauxon, rons Kone XOMK ie Taeanopa Nenzwsra Jhmaren » apbrrpexnbix eymex 8 MocKie xt ib Marepuatos MEE CTaNO WIBeCTHO, ro eme 02 more 2007 re : Moriomaonsnne, XaX A TpeRHOAATEDyGpeTeIN NOAA. KEK A Pomme “BOWTA CHCrEMe Rea *poftt CUCTEMC JIT" wPinyroa ® Kore Xora ‘casaWAR MPNOGpEremTex oun cHcreMe yr *BOMLIM CHCTEMC IITA" Gxzna e nmene xeneeuehs ofGmocpamsx xonasntt CSL. Law & Comiting (7. Moccia, ya Kena eee ~ henrp, Ceasmell ava, 700. 234-3833) ne crparmme ‘Wann jawsery.runews/shelf phtm! nie: 2p08 fas, fe eer» misrtaue Tak, tro xonmasms “BOR CHCTEMC ITE tang yeN-T0 CNEWAIbAO ALE COBepHeNMR 08 (000 «Pause t OOO «Maxaon». To, ce» Kagan yrivutnaet ua ro, ro. soawoNo, cao mproSperense aonen OOO sPurmar x ODO «Maxaow Grane cosepmeno romxo muta set nor obearonays epenicy une Cem, TAK KX agen “SORTA CHGTEMC IITA” sorna ne tomo yauers wesdxoumocm nitotheteiae 000 «flayroHr:. wo # ManaTe anMOKATa, noMTOTORMTS meKOROe ‘iamBNesN Topoae 8 xaunenxpino cya. Bec 310 wuranau Tax, xax eck Gat“ Apuotpevaxa Kowrann » GOO eflnyToa aoene toro, Kax © xMINenK Kostas eteto as ackemurresianw coOcTmCmKaM, TORK C TeAG OpraMNOBET. weper cya ToMMIEMEE kowBuNN ofperNo wa Kone Xonamur Jaren # Paeaops Nowe soGu Bee WAI'SANETO Ta, RAK ecm KEMLEMIA RE GHANO, HU KaK ecm Gu ymLeph Ae soferbenuuean ne Gust HaneceR. B nOmsy 91OTe TOROPUT H TO, TIO @XSOKET ROMENAGHIN CUCTEMC JHU" Hstroases 10,H. wa npece-rombepeium, xoTopyto om costa: 09 anpens ; Foul Fe CNor NORCHTS AYPsamcTaM, ROMY MpeHAieMATT Kounasinat "SORTA CHCTEMC. 3 muxof cTpane paxcawToa ome KoNnaNHH, BENET MM komen “BOT Cl uxwo~tGo AeaTe-mHocTe HOMEND MpHOGpeTEHME AOReHi » OOO «flapdernotmn, OOO 000 eMaxaon. Taso ofpison, mrwenzoxcumue coSsrran OGNCKTHRRO CRLETESUCTEVIOT© TOM. 970 8. pk BOUMOAMIOM MCROILAGKANEH MATepHAHOR H cheneHRl, iniuerBxX pH OGMCK 5 plccrenonanne yroonMoro exe B OTHOMIeM TenepamNoro Seen aoe H.C, Guno cosepmieno xamnemte spex oGwecre: OOO allepbemnam, OO sPurman co sce x werwaa.at, Tlpowsomie 970 © mpiweneuen ‘Bpeactannenmux p Kasam, Mockse CanxrtlerepSypre apy m6 RPCPEMITpALMO # HANOTORLIe OpTaHs, pM HOARE 2AoXOB ra, Mocks Kesanm, Sarem, Kix a Romani, |eran Ch seca peomorpeuns, TAC KAK MCEORiE. samncuas fnaensient mBcHOpr. {Tuoxe max mite RARETOR MMecTes eay3s coenonareaa Bysan0 spencrasnmounin Kosetammo nem Bezoparese 0 OBY CO ne 1040 CY CK pu Tpoxypatype P@ no tMockwe psnacce | Opaussoxutl C.E., w cootaercraiu co ct. 38 VII PO, # nontemenatH xa6. Ne 29 nomysnn oGuicHenne. - : ie as, OTHeCTBO: Marurtexstt Cepreit leomioniey poxactna: 08.04.1972 rp, powaewHx: t.Onecca Vpanucsol CCP anwe: Buictee Hoe MonOKeNHe: KeHaT fo paSorus HM y4eGss: aysuTop 3AO «Paiiepcroys ManKes jeine K BOHHCKO OSssaMHOCTH: BoeHHOOGaRartHA MMe CYAMMOCTH: He CY , HIM HOME NOKYMeHT, ynocToRepmOUKl mrawocTs: 45 05 633943, ak wore p-Hta r-Moexsss 15.05.2003 r. anal amuse 0 auMMOcTH: 8 FT mTTHD co con wa ysere ue coctoNE103 —* a ee nt SaieTeMcKHe Howasaita, aatune 05.06.2008 no 15 MMCTRa BLUTBH OBEpeHNOCTER aIBOKATY. jony 9M. or umeHH OOO «Flapgeusnow, OOO «Maxaoie # OOO «Puiu, 17.10.2007. AOWOARCHHE K YRasaNM ox: HIM nosrNepxano, onepenttocrefi, . ‘aliperaunony 3.M, 000 000 «Maxaow» 4 O00 «Purse 1) ry wren al 000 17.10.2007, 6110 ‘HHGerO He HIBECTHO Tlapdewston», «Maxaot a” «Punonan Gone ‘MesaKORHO PHPORAHS H B FOCYHApCTReHMT peectp Guinn auecettn, He3aKOHNBIC 2aTHCHO HOBBIX TeHEPAMBHEEX AytpexTopoB sTHx KoMnan PEMA, U3 LOKYMeHTOS, no: sro a gary To aosepentoctH, aaruponaHHom 10,0 > Majiopos 10.M no aoBepeHHoctH, , oF Hert OOO «PwroKup - Manos A.A. no aonepermocTt, Mue Guo w3BectHo, “To TaKHe AOBEPEHHOCTH He MOFAH kaxne-71H60_ OBAIHCL MIA TOPO, 4TOGEI CKPEMANTS HMI Rieger 10 He B urrTepecax OOO «Mlappemuam, SMccTO Toro, NTOGM SAINT sarei) Sonam Maprenonviw 3a me ee TOMPEMOCT flaproBy A.A. anHponata 2 MEEK 20 yeasaritx ar AHO, TO 8 oTHOMeRHH OOO «flapgeHnoi», 10 ove M; H noSpoconectHo saniINAIOUNE. MHYEpeCtl 8 He AKUANH, KOTOpHE, OveBINO, GaLI ya cxeMht, HANPATeHNOM Ha ueKyecTacHHoe cor qH010», OOO «Maxaot u OOO «Pussy wan fouinio | cyneGusx pemenntt, UpOBANMEIX OKaRaTEMBCTD HO, STO aanoKat Xaliperaunon geticrmiremeo scnoms0BaA J pie euy OOO «fTapihexion, OOO «Maxaon 1 aie sazom«KeRHOCTEl y OOO KPemLLetitn THX SATO REHHOCTEH CcHonaMtix a mMpencrasneNMM 8 eye ANHODLIM GLOW MONA Mo Pesyzbraram paccmotpenuix Koropsrx DAC C30 19.02.200 05.02.2008 Gsum ommenensi patie nprmerete HesaKouNDe pet sanomkenHoct OOO «Llaphentow, OOO «Maxaom 1 OOO O Wloroc Tmoc» (Kom noctaHosnenm na 8 mcrax Kpome toro, Gnarosaps jelicrsum apoKara camo YOMC no SlpocnascKolt oGaactu Ne 1/ax19992 or 2mae Xaiiperamossnn 5, CMUTIO, 50 8 aes ot AO*E2AreMoTNa Ht yaoRerwopw samnnenuok ma TAKUX Yonomitnx. upsananie nonmowowen Rene Koraa Ws uctynusutero » cay cye6xor? alow 3.M. wa ocHosanun n0RepeNt 007, craneTs nox ‘BONpo Aehoracrensu: aa : peanael iain OCT yrasanwolt onepeHHocTit $6: Tarcxe Oper sinwaime ua to, sro nag @ YOMC no Apocaanckoa, OGnactn, ono xmeTCR mona 9.M., AATHPORAMHET 24.10.2008 rona, 10 ‘ecTh cpaty me noche sdaxton mpormonpaniasx aefictons, catsanux noasech ween 3AO wlaroe SOOO MTR AHA cooTReTETEYOGNX noAKOMOU oT aeAcTEHTeRbtM apes OOO «Tlapdernow, OOO «Maxaon, a 000 «Pico. anoxat BPeAMpHIG aelicTuHa, HeoGxommMute ann -MIGOMIMEHEE YRasaNO & YrOMAHYTOM miaMe OTReTOM Ma sampoc atBOKaTa Onacti 8 cenrraGpe 2007 roma fe InIOKeHHOC CBAETEASETAYeT 0 TOM, TO ROBEpeKHOCTH, AAILAKMME ARBORS ORY OT HMeHH OOO «flapberaiom, COO «Maxaom v OOO «Pansat 007, Ssi7t BbiwaHe! gefictaurenBHsIMK ampeKropama yeasaHttstx ‘konerranoat, mINpoRaKO 1 ROGPocoBecTHO Henomaosanct ansoxatos XaipeTanWODAIM AA 3AKOHHWIX MHTEPECOR KOMMAHN, AI OTMeHLI HeseKOHHO BMECEHMEN SAGUUNPORANINM —ROKYMeHTAM cyneGuBX —pemennfi 1 HUN COCTORBINCTOCA XEN GHODKETIGR JeHCAHEX CpeICTE B Gaon 5 (nate) sqrinnapsios pyGreH, conepmeHHoro, oxeBnano, pYMEHT AS COBEPIIENHA XHINEHMA eHer 43 FocyAapeTueHHOrO OTHOWEHHH reepanb¥bix AMpextopos OOO «LlaphexnoH», ome sookenan ObI Dare CHenvoMHe OGbACHeHH. ; PO, cr, 21 @enepaxsuoro saxoua or 8 despanx 1998 1 sanmicell 8 Gul Aorosopa, a He fia OCHOBANKM coro saxon or 8 anryera 2001 1. N 129-03 «0,ee AtevtidOu), 05.06.2008 slenapranenry nodunnn iMx TpeKTopa yeasseBarot (1. 8.3, 0. 84 NONASANL Hokoanni Xpuctenna Aprapiay, Komi HS aMevax na TAC) Seems ANTaNicKOM sauiKe npunaraioreR), TO OHH ee mutes era Tet Facancoy, xovopuit, xax use nsacortnn taebeosael p OT HMCHH KOMManWH «Pnensopa Xonauurs hoasre; Yr 4 «Kone Xoaawurs Jaren» (Ke a» (Glendora Holdings one Holdings Limited) ot 000, © mponaxe OOO «dlapdeinow, sitcenm @ O00 me 000 «Maxaor» 1 OOO «Pras ie aNBNEHH Shu cACAAEE AHO; Anexcas apy « Xpictannoa Aprapany OS (komm: sammuctul wa 6 mectax u 6 mictax cooTaetcTReHHO npunaraiores € OM). WHO KaK A Cuitraio, y Pacanona orcyrcrsosantt mo: uenanuit «Paenopa Xoxmumrs Muwsrrea» (Glend -AKOMOMUS J1CFICTBOBATS OT Jlawtem» (Kone Holdings Limited), lora Holdings Limited) w«Koue WTO 3aKMONCHIMIM HM OT HMeHIE m KoumaitMii ZooBopam ¢ OOO «flzyvorm w cay n. 1 ct. 183K PO mpaaalse H BOIHMKAM Me Y ITWX KOMTIa:Hii, a y camoro [acaHOBa, TO CCTs KOMMAEHA opa Xosttiers Jimwerrea» (Glendora Holdings Limited) n «Koxe Xoammars Em Kak OLLI, TAK HAO CHX Mop ocTalotca nelicraHTeTbUBINH CO cK Yerasubm xanuranax OOO «Taphertow, OOO «Maxaou» 1 OOO orpaiirienHol orserctmennoctsion, ust oprad oGutecTsa (renepambantii AmpeKTop, upemmext x Sum coGpanHes yuacruukos oGumecrsay. — TMockomsny n OOO «Mlapdexnow, OOO «Maxsox x OOO Paiste» ppa Xonzmrs Iimsurem (Glendora Holdings Limited) a ex) (Kone Holdings Limited), nootosy tomxo 27m KosmaninH 000 Tene ubix Ampextopos OOO «[lappennom, ay Ws yee suuie couterensen nova Xomunrrs SKsnurem (Glendora Holdings Limited) 4 ran (Kone Holdings Limited) caeayet, 4To omm HHKOTAa wt KypouKuiia renep@ibieiMH ZMpexTOpaMH© cymecrsyotivadt HOWMMITTeMis Opratom OPrAMisALAEN Mt Wsroromicnne Houux newareli BaaMeHt TONUKG HOBRE NESATH ABMUMHCS nelicruTcMUbIMM NeNATEMH YRAMANHEX Stu Metarn Biepawe GuxiK Wcnomaonamet 8 one 2007 roa ARR ma Ma OYXTanTepcKOR, uasoronoh om crarucTHeckoll - oTHeTHOCTH, moi TEHePAABRIMM AMpexTopav OOO «{lappernorm, OOO «Maxaowy it pPiorsHa» Flonom Perrsem 1 Maprimom Yuuncotiom (xommm orteruocT#, AOnamNOR pBtie oprant Wa 23 AACTaX, 28 aucrax 4 20 aucrax cooTueTCTHEHHO MIpMNATAHOTCR), GeToRTeTbcTRO Mo‘KeT GuITE erKo UpoRepeHO HyTeM OOpaUeNKA 8 HAAONOBKIE opraiist CTATHCTINAL i opransi GotLia couMATEHOrO CrpaXORaHita, # KOTOPL ipbexnoH, OOO «Maxaow» # OOO «Pi1H coctoamt wa yere 6 mine 2007 © OGCTORTENCTRA MOATREPAAAIOTCR NNCEMENIOM JAA RTEHKEM, atom Yictconom 06.10.2008 (komma adypraasira wa aNTaTicKOM sBIKE Ha OM npwraraetes).. B otom sastuncaxa Mapran Yuncon nosrmepaaaer, 05 -M AO HACTORMerO BPeMeHH Of RBRACTCA FeHEPATbHKIM THPEKTOPOM Peropox OOO «flaphennowm, noareepamact, “10 15.06.2007 ou cHMM ayGAMKaTOR revacell, WEsTHX 04.06.2007 oe ayOqMKaThl MuMAMbHOl AaTol Kayata MCTOMBIOBAHHR HOB! T 8 Seapnenne Mapraua GbuTH HCTOMI0BaMEt DAK ee Tomi Opruncnug, Dosa = HOHC NaXe 10j OTH AM OWN B HaCToRue, A ee Bpen aanch © MORE 2008 roma ante # MEMO. A npetonara, tM QcTH OT OPCAMIAUI «darn, NPCMEHHN 4H Gyrtarrepexo w HasorOnolh ronnie AYOANKATOR . newares maneg tbe» 1 «Pepi. Yeaanue ma ” ‘ AMPEKTOY opranisail t. EI renee aeT# BaRnetteM MJLVYuncona oe Oona ronal Boro Ka s € Mpwraracres OBbacHeHMO, Aawanuce mm gia Ho srOTOREHHE AyGAHKATOR HocAe Hearn nen ‘aca ¢a 04.06.2007 & TOKO He Noto, Ho — a go TO TABATICK, OTHAKO MMcHMeRKOrO tn peacra ; c © MORTREPANEHNA JTOMY x NPECTABHTE RE AA nONTHEPATIANO TO 8 wWoHE-Mone 2007 roma auperncpaun TLeMee i Yancouom Gs.aH WaAAHEL MpHKase! o Hasane lichombsonasHR ayGruKaTOR nedaTell @Maxaon, «Tap QHIMEX NpHUKAI08 § MPeMOCTABAID pane Renen, 3 OHO He GPHADHAD, KOHL ye Broa c eindaeraui a pacewarpnmas cany MocTaHoBKy Bompoca o neleTEE epernoctell, BEIMANHBIX ampoxary Xafipetannosy 3M. OOO «llapemmor, O xan « OOO «Pras 17.10.2007, ax mporoxanno, wan EPeavrauio 3aKOHHOH ABOKATCKOH AeRTeAbHOCTH aTBOKaTa u OUUY!O Leh Tb ROIMOAHOCTS yikTH OT oTHCTCTBCHHOCTH MIAN, HEMET KE M pwoblareHs! B peryabrare aelicremt axwoxata XaliperaMHoBa Ha ix JOBepeHHOCTEH. uous chob 4 Baty ive leas oserens no OBA,TEHEPAABHAR NPOKYPATYPA ©. Ns POCCHACKOH @EAEPAUMK Mowsna, Pocenss IC, 2003, b,omipeana, 1S Bau ofpaenne © nprsro geaucaoay Base cota Tipoxypop yupanacun (oats) Cee ere eee,Tenepansuomy — apoxypopy —Poccxitexoit ‘benepaunn Deitcrorenswomy Focyzaperpentomy copeTHHky 1ocrMMHHt Toctoanny Yaiixe 10.51. Konus: Havaapnnxy Caejtereennoro komutera nipx MBJl Poceniickoi Deaepannn Tocnoanny Annanty Amexceio Bacnanesity Konus: Crapuiemy cactonarea no 0co6o Raxmbim jeram CaemeteenHoro KoMHTeTa pa MBII Pocewu maiiopy wocruunn Cuassenno Osery Peroposnty Aapoxata MockoseKoii Konaerum anpoKarow 4fpuanen 4 napriepem Xapuronosa J.B. r. Mona, J-H Toayrauncknii mepeystox, 2.1, OLU «oye», ome Ne 9, Tes. 739-2523 OKAOBA B nponsgoaetee cTapurero csienosatens 10 0coGO BaKHKIM jena CaencTBeHHOrO komurera npn MBI P® waslopa soctaunn Cunpienxo Ou. waxoanrca yronosnoe xeno Ne}53123, no Koropomy Marautckomy C.J. npembspneno OGaHHEHHE & conepuleHI NpectynaenA, npestycMoTpeHHor 4. 2 cr. 199 YK Po. C momenta npenvananents oGannenta 25 Hoa6pa 2008 rona Marnurcknit C.J. We MpiaHaeT ceOR BHHOBHDIM B CoBeplleHHH 2TOrO NpectyntenNs, TAK KAK HMKAKHX HaoroBbIX Hapyulennil H MpecTynaeHHit on KE conepuban. Yranoawoe npecnenoBanue, paiaepHyToe MpoTiE Hero, No cBoell cyTH RANAeTES pacnpaBoil JauwTa HeonKoKpaTHo OGpammaiace ¢ KonatallcTeamn M xKaNOGaMH © TOM, ¥TO cnencrave Mo 3TOMy YyronoBHoMy steay BeleTcR ¢ MHOrONNICReNHBIMH HapyuenMaMi 3aKOHA, JamBNAA OTROA CTeAOBATENIM, KOTOPKIE sAOMyeKANH HapyurenHe saKoHa. JlelicTaus AOMKAOCTHDX TMU, ROTYYCKABWNX HApyWeHHs, MHoroKpaTHo O@KatoaaiIHck abilLlecToRllleMy PYKOBOACTBY I B cya. Marnwexnii CJL. « tauurra HeoaHoKparHo yKasbipann, 4T0 oGocHoRaTs BEIABHHYTOC MKPOTHB Hero OGBHHEHHE HEBOIMOKHO, Tak Kak HMKAKUX APOTHBONPABHHIX NOCTYMKOB OH He CoBepilan, a AOKyMeHTEI, coGpanHBTE CHeNeTHHEM, CBRAETERLCTEYICT 0 era HEBHHOBHOCTH, IKCHepTHHle 2aKONEHHA,MWoTORICHMTE -KUUITEPECOBAHINBINH BELOMCTKEHMAMH sKCHEPCAsIH Hs MBJL, Cosepaxar ABIIO HATANYTHIe, Hy OGBEKTHBHELE BEIBOAL! H yroay OGRATCHIO, Ect Ho dtowly yroswsHOMy steAty CVAAEO CocTONTEH Cf-leGUOMY paxGHpareMDcrBy 10. HO HPEMIK . B oway cr, 32 3axona Poceuitckoi Denepaunn «O npoxypatype PoccaticKoti Genepaunin mpeaMetom mpokypopcKoro Hamiopa sBNAOTCA coGmoneNne YeTaHoBnenisix sakoMosaTenbcrsom Poceitickoi Penepaun pan OGwsAHHOCTEN JanepRAHHEIX, JAKMIONEHAMX Noa ctpaxy. Craths 33 yxasanHoro sakotia onpenenser, To OPH OcyulecTBAeHHH HagI0pa 42 KCHoMHeHIEM 3akoHOB MpOKypop Bnpawe NocewaTs 6 MoGoe BpeMa OPraHB! HM YUPEKMEHNR, B TOM HHCTE MecTa MpeABapHTeAbHOrO 3AKMONEHHA, OMPAIMBATL sAKAONEHHBIX MON CTpEKY, TpeGowaTs oT aaMiNicTpaUMl cozmaNHa yeoBnit, obecnewaaioWNX npaBa Sak MOUeHHBIX NOM CTPAKY. C yuetom WanoxeHHorO, Ha ocNoBaHUH cr. eT. 123-124 ner. 126 YIIK PO, npowy: 1. MIposepure onvcanuste 8 Hactosuiel skanoGe oGcToaTemkcTea 1 onpociTt Marwutcxoro Ceprea Jleonuaosnvia 0 HapyuleHHsX, AONYCKAEMbIX B OTHOLIEHITH nero 8 BY H13-77/2 Y@CHH Poccuu no r. Mockse. Onpocuts npyrix saKmONeHHDIX, comepxaniiliixcs ComMectHO ¢ MardutcKum C.JI. 6 Kamepax No 267 ¥ Xe 59, a TaKKe HOCTABNABLIHXCH COBMECTHO Co HUM H3 BY H13-77/2 YOCHH Pocen mo r. Mockse 8 Tsepckolt paiionmmit cya r. Mockes! ana yyactit & cyaeGueix aacenannax 06, 10 4 18 aprycta 2009 2. HIposepats 3akonMocTs HeomKoxparHBsx nepesonos Marnittcxoro CJL 43 ‘onHoro cneacTBeMKoro WIONATOpA B Apyroii 3. ObasaTe anMitunetpamino CH3O comars yenonia, oGecneynsaioune Marnutckomy C.JI. peannsautinio npan, ia ero mpouly HetpeGonats y BY H3- 77/2 YMCHH Poccun no r. Mockse uy YOCHH Poccun no ¢, Mockse Konno TeKcTa ero Ka06b1 OT 31 aBrycTa 2009 r. H cBEeHHA O ee Nogave H HanpasMeHHH anpecary; 4. HetpeGosate 13 DBY H3-77/2 YCHH Poccnn mo r. Mockse caeneHia o Perhictpaunm 8 >kypHane 6 nopaaKe 1.92, 93 TIpaana syrpennero pacslopaaKa MOUX JannenMil H >KaI06, KONMH yKaIAHHIBIX daanneHM H >KaI06, cBELEHHA O AAMWLIN Ha ITH 3ARBICHIA H rKANOGI OTBETAX, CBEHEHIK O HasHaYeHHOMMaruurckomy C.JI. MeaMIRHCKON oGcnedoBaKH Ht MeYeHNH, MenmUMHCKHX ‘OcMorpax, conepxauinecs! # Moc MezINLAHEKXo!l aMGy1aTOpHOH Kapre. 3amrranK Marnurekoro C.J1. jl Aapoxat A.B. Xapurouos W090?Bcero npowitypoBaHo 1 npoHyMeposato 42 nuctos etn daneNQoyx, AP