Part 1 of the complaint filed by World Wrestling Entertainment against the widow of Owen Hart in 1999. The clause releasing WWE from liability in the case of injury or death is on Page 4.
Part 1 of the complaint filed by World Wrestling Entertainment against the widow of Owen Hart in 1999. The clause releasing WWE from liability in the case of injury or death is on Page 4.
Part 1 of the complaint filed by World Wrestling Entertainment against the widow of Owen Hart in 1999. The clause releasing WWE from liability in the case of injury or death is on Page 4.
Part 1 of the complaint filed by World Wrestling Entertainment against the widow of Owen Hart in 1999. The clause releasing WWE from liability in the case of injury or death is on Page 4.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT
WORLD WRESTLING FEDERATION )
ENTERTAINMENT, INC., a Delaware ) os
corporation, ) (5
) Case Number: ie 5 ao
Plaintiff, ) ni G45) ee
> ggQCVi9t:
ws }
)
)
THE ESTATE OF OWEN HART AND )
MARTHA HART, Individually, as Widow of)
‘Owen Hart, as Representative and )
Administratrix of the Estate of Owen Hart. )
and as Guardian and Representative On )
Behalf of Oje Edward Hart and )
Athena Christie Hart, minors, )
)
Defendants. )
COMPLAINT.
World Wrestling Federation Entertainment, Inc. (hereinafter “WWF"), by and
through its undersigned counsel, files this Complaint seeking a declaration of its rights pursuant
to 28 U.S.C. § 2201 et sea, and recovery for breach of contract against THE ESTATE OF
OWEN HART, and MARTHA HART, individually, as widow of Owen Hart, as Representative
and Administratrix of the Estate of Owen Hart, and as Guardian and Representative on behalf of
Oje Edward Hart and Athena Christie Hart, minors, alleging as follows:
Parti
1. Plaintiff WWF is a Delaware corporation having its principal place of
business in Stamford, Connecticut, Plaintiff recently changed its corporate name from Titan
Sports, Ine. to World Wrestling Federation Entertainment, Inc. The WWF is engaged in the
sports entertainment business of promoting live and televised professional wrestling in a variety
PL39890401of ways pursuant to its registered servicemark “World Wrestling Federation.” As an integral part
of its business, the WWF produces television programs which ait on cable and syndicated
networks, live arena events which are promoted in cities throughout the United States, Canada
and elsewhere and special pay-per-view programs.
2. Owen Hart was a professional wrestler who performed for years for the
WWF pursuant to written independent contractor agreements. On May 23, 1999, Owen Hart
died during a WWF show in the Kemper Arena in Kansé
s City, Missouri as a result of a tragic
accident,
3. Defendant Martha Hart is an individual residing at 2028 Sirocco Drive,
S.W., Calgary, Alberta, Canada, T3H 2N9. Mrs. Hart is the widow of Owen Hart, deceased, and
is the court-appointed and duly authorized next friend for her and the deceased’s minor children,
Oje Edward Hart and Athena Christie Hart, Mrs. Hart is also the representative and
administratrix of the Estate of Owen Hart
Ju
mand Venue
4. This Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this action under 28
U.S.C. § 1332 in that there is diversity between the WWF and Defendants and the amount in
controversy exceeds $75,000.
Jurisdiction is alternatively properly vested in this Court under the express
terms of that certain Booking Contract entered into July 1, 1996 between the WWF and Owen.
Hart (the “1996 Hart Contract”), which requires that any and all claims, disputes or other matters
in question arising out of or relating to the 1996 Hart Contract, the enforcement of any provision
therein, or the breach of any provision thereof shall be adjudicated in Connecticut (1996 Hart
Contract at 13.8). The express terms of the 1996 Hart Contract are specifically at issue in this,
action,6. This Court has personal jurisdiction over the parties under the terms of the
1996 Hart Contract and because the deceased, Mr. Hart, was subject to the jurisdiction of the
Connecticut courts,
7. Venue is proper under 28 U.S.C. § 1391. Plaintiff's headquarters and
principal place of business are located in this District. The 1996 Hart Contract between the
WWE and Mr. Hart, which is the subject of this litigation, was made and executed in this
ict and specifically mandates that claims or disputes arising out of or related thereto, or any
action brought thereunder shail be brought in courts in the State of Connecticut. Accordingly, a
substantial part of the events giving rise to this action have occurred in this District.
Facts
The 1996 Hart Contract
8. Mr. Hart was associated with WWF as a performer of wrestling
entertainment services for several years until his tragic, accidental death on May 23, 1999.
9. Mr. Hart performed professional wrestling entertainment services on
behalf of the WWF under a variety of stage names and as a variety of wrestling characters. Most
recently, Mr. Hart played the WWF wrestling character known as “the Blue Blazer.”
10, Inor around July 1996, Mr. Hart entered into the 1996 Hart Contract to
‘appear as a professional wrestler exclusively for WWF. The 1996 Hart Contract, along with the
First Amendment thereto dated November 18, 1997, and the Second Amendment thereto dated
January 11, 1999, was the exclusive operative agreement between WWF and Mr. Hart and was in
full force and effect on May 23, 1999, at the time of Mr. Hart’s accidental death.
11, Pursuant to the 1996 Hart Contract, Mr. Hart expressly agreed to certain
specific, legally binding contractual obligations with respect to his rights and obligations relativeto the WWP arising out of, relating to and in connection with, his performance of professional
wrestling entertainment ser
's on behalf of WWF.
12. Specifically, Mr. Hart expressly acknowledged the risks of harm and of
physical injury involved in the performance of professional wrestling entertainment services, and
he voluntarily and expressly assumed such risks under the 1996 Hart Contract, Mr, Hart and
WWF agreed, and the 1996 Contract provides:
[Owen Hart] acknowledges that the participation and activities
required by [Owen Hart] in connection with his/her performance in
a professional wrestling exhibition may be dangerous and may
involve the risk of serious bodily injury. [Owen Hart] knowingly
and freely assumes full responsibility for all such inherent risks as
well as those due to the negligence of [WWF], other wrestlers, or
otherwise.
(1996 Hart Contract at § 9.12 (b)).
13. Having acknowledged the risks attendant to his profession, Mr. Hart
thereafier expressly released WWF from all liability, and covenanted not to sue WWF for any
and all loss or damage, on account of injury to Mr. Hart, including Mr. Hart’s death. In that
regard, Mr. Hart and WWF agreed, and the 1996 Hart Contract provides:
[Owen Hart] hereby releases, waives and discharges [WWF] from
all liability to (Owen Hart] and covenants not to sue [WWE] for
any and all loss or damage on account of injury to the person or
property or resulting in serious or permanent injury to [Owen Hart]
or in {Owen Hart's death], whether caused by the negligence of
[WWF], other wrestlers or otherwise,
(1996 Hart Contract at 4 9.12(c))(emphasis added).
14. Mr. Hart’s agreement to assume the risk of harm, and to release the WWE
for personal injury claims, is further evidenced by provisions of the 1996 Contract which made it
his obligation to carry health, life and death insurance. In Paragraph 9.13 of the 1996 Contract, it
was therefore specifically provided that Mr. Hart had the election toobtain heaith, life and/or disability insurance to provide benefits in
the event of physical injury arising out of his/her professional
activities; and [Mr, Hart] acknowledges that [WWF] shall not have
any responsibility for such insurance or payment in the event of
physical injury arising out of his/her professional activities.
(1996 Hart Contract at Paragraph 9.13).
15. Moreover, with respect to the availability of punitive or exemplary
damages, Owen Hart expressly agreed, and the 1996 Hart Contract provides
In no circumstances, whatsoever, shall either party to this
Agreement be liable to the other party for any punitive or
exemplary damages; and all such damages, whether arising out
of the breach of this Agreement, or otherwise, are expressly
waived.
(1996 Hart Contract at § 12.4),
16. _ With respect to the law governing interpretation of the contract, Mr. Hart
agreed that the 1996 Hart Contract was “made in Connecticut and shall be governed by and
interpreted in accordance with the laws of the State of Connecticut, exclusive of its provisions
relating to conflicts of law.” (1996 Hart Contract at § 13.7).
17. Finally, Mr, Hart expressly agreed and the 1996 Hart Contract expressly
provides that
[iJn the event that there is any claim, dispute, or other matter in
question arising out of or relating to this Agreement, the
enforcement of any provisions therein, or breach of any provision
thereof, it shall be submitted to the Federal, state or local courts, as
appropriate, only in the State of Connecticut. This provision to
submit all claims, disputes or matters in question to the Federal or
state courts in the State of Connecticut shall be specifically
enforceable; and each party, hereby waiving personal service of
process and venue, consents to jurisdiction in Connecticut for
purposes of any other party seeking or securing any legal and/or
equitable relief,
(1996 Hart Contract at § 13.8)(emphasis added).