Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Scope of Marketing
The Scope of Marketing
The Scope of Marketing
The Scope of
Marketing
A Brief Introduction to 1
CHAPTER
Marketing
© Jonathan Groucutt
Figure 1.1
Stunning architecture such as the Eiffel Tower in Paris
acts as a branding not only of Paris but of France.The
same could be said of the Statue of Liberty in New
York, the Opera House in Sydney and the Houses of
Parliament in London.What other national symbols do
you think represent countries? What are the national
symbols of your country?
An economics approach
With an economics approach the emphasis is on
products (usually referred to as goods) and services,
sources of supply, the most commonly used chan-
nels of distribution and the functions performed
during the marketing process (Cooke et al. 1992).
Three definitions can be provided on the basis of
the economics approach:
especially true of the points in those stages at Marketing consists of four general activities: 1.
which change of ownership takes place. Identifying and selecting the type of customer
(McNair et al. 1975) that the business will cultivate, learning his
needs and desires; 2. Designing products or
Marketing is the performance of business activ- services that the firm can sell at a profit in
ities that direct the flow of goods and services conformity with customers desires; 3. Persuad-
from producer to consumer or user. ing customers to buy at the firm’s offerings; 4.
(AMA 1960) Storing, moving, and displaying goods after
they leave the production site.
As Cooke et al. (1992) state, there are several key (Oxenfeldt 1966)
words that summarise these definitions:
Note the use of the word ‘his’. Perhaps the focus
N goods/services remained male dominated?
N transfer of ownership
That process through which a business enterprise,
N storage institution, or organization 1. selects target
customers or constituents, 2. assesses the needs or
N flow of goods/services wants of such target customers, and 3. manages its
N distribution/transport resources to satisfy those customer needs or wants.
(Star et al. 1977)
N functions.
As Cooke et al. (1992) state, there are several key
We shall return to these points later. words that summarise these definitions:
N consumer
A consumer’s (or buyer’s) approach
N meet – fulfil – satisfy
This perspective arises out of consumers’ dissat-
isfaction with products, services and the organi- N product (goods and services)
sations that provide them. Linked to this is the N wants
subsequent need for governments to protect indi-
N determine – assess needs
vidual consumer rights through legislation. The
dissatisfaction emanated from the following N needs
views: N target customers.
N The marketing system was unresponsive to We shall return to these points later.
consumer wants.
N Marketing practitioners were unscrupulous.
The societal approach
N Marketers made claims that were not borne out
This can be considered as a needs-fulfilling
by the actual performance of the product.
exchange or relationship activity that is present, to
N Consumers sought increased product quality. a greater or lesser degree, within all cultures. Cooke
et al. (1992) suggest that it is the ‘process of
N Increasing concern over hazardous and unsafe
exchange in society and this process must occur in
products entering the marketplace, especially
society so that the consumption of values can
electrical goods and children’s toys.
occur’. They continue:
N Concern over misleading advertising,
deceptive packaging and labelling. The societal view of marketing as exchange rela-
tionships begin with the basic idea that most
Three definitions provide an insight into the human behaviour is the planned, purposeful
consumer perspective: quest and search for want satisfaction. Individu-
THE ORIGIN OF MARKETING 7
als act to satisfy their wants and desires. Goods, not-for-profit and public sector organisations) to
services, or ideas are the source of this satisfaction. marketing. The emphasis is on how the individual
organisation processes marketing and develops the
Cunningham and Cunningham (1981) suggest strategic dimensions of marketing activities.
that societal marketing performs three essential Hughes (1978) suggests that marketing managers
functions: focus on market analysis and the selection of target
market segments, strategy development and the
1 As an information network – knowing and creation of a profit plan. Of course, a profit plan
understanding the consumer’s changing needs does not exist within a not-for-profit organisation,
and wants. such as a charity. Nevertheless these organisations
need to generate revenues to both develop the
2 Equalising the distribution function – effi- organisation and to deliver products/services to its
ciently and effectively managing the supply clients: for example, the distribution of food and
and demand of products and services. medical supplies in famine-stricken areas.
3 Centralising the exchange function – efficient The managerial approach can be described as
provision of distribution and payment follows:
processing systems.
Marketing is the combination of activities
Two definitions provide an insight into the societal designed to produce profit through ascertaining,
perspective: creating, stimulating, and satisfying the needs
and/or wants of a selected segment of the market.
Marketing may be thought of as that phase of (Eldridge 1970)
business activities which human activities are
satisfied by the exchange of goods and services, As Cooke et al. (1992) state, there are several key
on the one hand, for some valuable consideration words that summarise this approach:
– using money or its equivalent – on the other.
(Pyle 1931) N anticipate (demand)
N business – corporation – organisation
Marketing is the delivery of a standard of living
N goods – services
to society.
(Mazur 1947) N objectives of organisations
N product development – design
As Cooke et al. (1992) state, there are several key
N stimulate (demand)
words that summarise these definitions:
N assess – determine
N consumption – relationship N create (demand)
N matching N meet – fulfil
N society N profit
N exchange N strategy
N social process N target (customers).
N standard of living.
A social and managerial process by which indi- The process of planning and executing the
viduals and groups get what they need and conception, pricing, promotion and distribu-
want through creating and exchanging products tion of ideas, goods and services to
of value with others. create exchanges that satisfy individual and
(Kotler 1991) organisational goals.
(AMA 1960)
By 2000 he had slightly modified this to:
As Cooke et al. (1992) state, definitions of market-
A societal process by which individuals and ing change as a result of environmental changes,
groups obtain what they need and want through or because our knowledge of the subject
creating, offering, and freely exchanging prod- improves, or indeed through a combination of
ucts and services of value with others. these two reasons. Marketing as a subject or
(Kotler 2000) discipline is therefore evolving. It is important to
comprehend marketing as a dynamic and not a
While the differences between the two definitions static subject. As we shall see as we journey
might appear slight, they are significant. Consider through this textbook, the elements that
the following: comprise the marketing discipline are often in a
state of flux due to the fluidity of both the micro
N The second definition has introduced the term and macro environments. (See Chapter 2.) It is
‘societal’ and removed the managerial element. how the people involved in marketing handle
However, it could be debated that marketing such environments and experiences that often
needs management of the process in order for determines whether a product or service is viable
it to be both effective and efficient. or not, and over what time frame.
This is made clear by a new definition issued by
N Also in the second definition the word ‘freely’
the AMA in 2004 (Keefe 2004):
is introduced. Marketing involves an exchange
of one form or another. This can be an
Marketing is an organizational function and set
exchange of a product for money. Equally it
of processes for creating, communicating and
could be an exchange of an emotional feeling
delivering value to customers and for managing
(for instance, a thank you) for a donation to a
customer relationships in a way that benefits
charity, or a huge hug when we give a gift to a
both the organization and the stakeholder.
loved one.
N In the second definition Kotler has also intro- While there is still an emphasis on process – that
duced the word ‘service’. While an early focus is fundamental to marketing – we now see the
on marketing was driven by ‘products’, the last use of the words ‘value’, ‘managing customer
30 years especially have witnessed a dramatic relationships’ and ‘stakeholders’ being brought
rise in service-oriented business, covering to centre stage. These are issues that are reflected
everything from travel companies to super- throughout this text.
markets. Thus ‘service’ is a key ingredient in Equally, as Mercer (1997) contends:
marketing operations, even within a mainly
product-based business. This is an element that Marketing is the one (our italics) fundamental
recurs throughout this text. activity undertaken by all organizations. For
most of them it is also the most important
Now compare Kotler’s views with those of the contributor to their success or failure.
AMA. In many ways they are similar, only differing
in some of the nomenclature and specifics, such as Mercer (1997) also suggests that marketing is:
pricing. However, it could be argued that the
AMA’s definition is more financially focused in Both a relationship with the customer, based
terms of transactions. upon a series of transactions which, over time,
In the 1960s the AMA defined marketing as: should result in mutual benefit, and a parallel
THE ORIGIN OF MARKETING 9
dialogue between you and the customer(s), time frame. For example, a commuter buying a
which communicates the information necessary newspaper from a street corner vendor on his or
to define the relationship. her way to work is engaged in a quick transaction.
Others do not. For example, an individual may
There are several key elements to Mercer’s descrip- want to purchase a product or donate to a charity.
tion which define the interaction between customer He or she is short of funds and unable to do so right
(buyer) and supplier (seller) as ‘complex’. This away, but intends to do so later, perhaps in a week
complexity has often been overlooked. or a month. One important issue here is the need
for the organisation to maintain a dialogue with the
prospective customer (see below).
Relationships Mercer’s statement comes into its own when the
These must be seen as two-directional, not just purely buyer and seller develop a relationship. Continual
seller to buyer, but also buyer to seller. The seller transactions – for example, regular visits to a partic-
must understand the needs and wants of the buyer ular restaurant – can deepen the relationship
between the staff/owner and the customer. The
in order to deliver a suitable product and/or service.
mutual benefit derived can be a mixture of:
product’. This ‘problem’ could be price, quality, Let’s consider a Disney movie for a moment. In
accessibility or a combination of factors. 1940 the Disney Organization made a movie that
We have looked at a few definitions of market- has stood the test of time, and remains one of the
ing, but there are significantly more. McDonald best-animated movies ever created – Fantasia. The
(2002), for example, cites some 30 definitions. Virtu- movie is a series of vignettes involving animated
ally everyone who has written on the subject of characters with their actions set to classical music.
marketing has probably put forward his or her own In one sequence Mickey Mouse™ is a Sorcerer’s
definition in one way or another. So as for many Apprentice who decides to find another solution to
other disciplines, there is no absolute definition. filling the well other than his carrying buckets of
The definitions given vary to a greater or lesser water. Through magic he replicates a broom many
extent, depending on circumstances, attitudes and times over and provides the replicants with arms
the time at which they were conceived. At the end and hands to carry the buckets. Having given the
of this chapter we briefly consider the future of this command to the brooms to fill the well he promptly
discipline called ‘marketing’. While it will continue falls asleep only to be woken by the flow of running
to affect our lives into the distant future, what we water. The well has been filled to overflowing and
call it and how we define it may be different from poor Mickey, now awake, doesn’t know how to
the terms we use now. stop the brooms filling the overflowing well. Panic
sets in, but worse is to come as the Sorcerer returns
home to see mayhem. With one wave of the hand
■ The marketer: alchemist, calm is restored except for a bedraggled apprentice.
magician, sorcerer and In the section heading ‘medicine man’ was
included. There is some link to alchemists here in
medicine man1 that many were also considered healers, most
As we have seen from the brief examples earlier in notable being Paracelsus.2 Although medicine men
this chapter, marketing is universal. However, is it an can be associated with native North Americans, the
art or a science? Perhaps marketing is more like native tribes of South America, Australia’s aborig-
sorcery. Think of a sorcerer collecting ingredients ines and African tribes, there is also an association
from different sources and mixing them into a potion, with the charlatans who preached to communities
accompanied with the magical effect of a flash of light in Victorian England and the emerging townships
and the illusion to follow. To some extent this fits with of 18th and 19th-century North America. These
Culliton’s vision of a marketer as a ‘mixer of ingredi- ‘medicine men’ pronounced that they ‘held in their
ents’ (a view we consider fully in a later chapter). Of hands a bottle that contained the elixir of life’. At
course sorcerers are more mythical than real, but if we best it was a rough alcohol, at worst it was a poison-
stay with this myth it may help to dispel some of the ous concoction that could lead to an untimely and
myths surrounding ‘marketing’. painful death. Indeed many were simply known as
Though mythical, sorcerers were far from ‘snake-oil merchants’ doing little to promote the
perfect. Not all their potions and spells succeeded. individual seller or merchant in the then ‘Wild
When they tried to cure diseases, the patient often West’.
died through severe poisoning – and the fate of the So what has any of this got to do with market-
sorcerer was anyone’s guess. Perhaps the same ing? I can see four separate, but linked, ways in
could be said of alchemists. Alchemy was the which an analogy can be made.
medieval dream of using a ‘philosopher’s stone’ to
change base metals like iron and lead into gold. It 1 Companies spend billions of dollars on
was a combination of chemistry, astrology, philoso- marketing campaigns that either help to sell
phy and mysticism, and took hold not only in their goods or services, or do not. The literature
Europe but in India and China too. No base metal is full of companies that have implemented
was ever transmuted into gold, but plenty of people marketing campaigns which for one reason or
spent their lives searching for the formula. another have failed. Therefore some of or all of
So what has this to do with marketing? In reality the ingredients in this marketing potion were
a great deal. wrong, or incorrectly mixed.
ALCHEMIST, MAGICIAN, SORCERER AND MEDICINE MAN 11
2 Those with some knowledge of marketing do large. As with the snake oil merchants,
not always have enough knowledge to deal the game will unravel, with disastrous
with specific situations and the complica- consequences for all parties.
tions that can ensue. It is sometimes claimed
that if you can market cars you can market Earlier in this chapter a statement was made that
cosmetics – it’s all the same. This is a myth. marketing is neither a science nor an art. In fact
An understanding of marketing principles is it is a hybrid drawing upon a diverse range of
only the start. Then you need to understand disciplines. Purists would disagree with this
the product or service you are marketing, not view and suggest that it is really a science or an
just in broad terms but in depth. In the movie art. However, if you consider the range of disci-
Fantasia, Mickey as the apprentice had a plines that marketing draws upon, it can really
basic understanding of the magician’s craft – only be classed as a hybrid. Those less disposed
but not sufficient to achieve what he set out to such a description may call marketing a ‘thief
to accomplish, hence the debacle at the end. in the night who steals ideas from other disci-
Marketing comprises a series of techniques plines’. Whichever view you are predisposed to
or tactics that can be engaged as a part of an take, remember that it is a ‘potion’ that cannot
overall marketing strategy. This, in turn, cure all ills. Many marketers have believed that
feeds into the corporate strategy. For a they can build a brand in such a way as to gain
marketing strategy to be successful the and sustain competitive advantage, only to see it
marketer must understand what tactics to falter and fail. Equally, organisations have failed
use, when and when not to use them, and in to harness the possibilities that marketing may
what proportion to use them and for how be able to deliver, to in turn falter and fail.
long. It is a skill that is developed over time. Therefore marketing must be viewed objectively,
3 Marketers need to have a grip on reality. and a course in marketing does not make a
Research conducted at Cranfield University in marketer. It is experience, and the knowledge
the United Kingdom by McDonald (2003) gained from that experience, that makes for a
suggests that marketers, consultants and potentially more objective and thus ‘successful’
academics have failed to understand the real marketer.
dynamics of the marketplace. McDonald (2003)
found that a significant number of senior
marketing practitioners revealed a depressing ■ Marketing as an
‘lack of knowledge about the financial impact organisational function
of marketing expenditure’. He also contends
While marketing is central to most organisations,
that many companies fail to integrate market-
it does not stand alone. Figure 1.5 shows a
ing within corporate strategy decision making,
typical arrangement of functional units within an
and to measure marketing performance (for
organisation. Each unit has separate functions,
example, the link between customer retention
procedures and staff, but they are also integrated
and profitability).
within the organisation as a whole.
4 Marketing is not a cure for all ills. It. For Marketing cannot operate without finance,
instance, it cannot sell a product or service for operations, HRM and other functions within an
which there is no market. It cannot turn around organisation. Table 1.1 illustrates the linkage
the fortunes of a business that has no markets, between Marketing and other functional units
no real product or an unsafe product, any more within the organisation.
than a government that has continually lied to When marketing works effectively in concert
people can use spin to keep its majority in a with other functional units, the organisation
democracy. Thus marketers cannot be medi- has an opportunity to create an efficient corpo-
cine men who turn a failed product or service rate strategy. Unfortunately, though, many
into an overwhelming success, no matter how organisations operate in a manner that pays only
much they believe they can, or how cleverly lip service to functional integration. The organi-
they manipulate their clients and the public at sation might survive in the short term, but its
12 1 • INTRODUCTION TO MARKETING
Board of Directors or
Governing Committee
Marketing HRM
Finance team Operations team
team team
longer-term future could be in jeopardy, as this is in both our working and private lives, has a
an inefficient use of valuable internal resources. direct or indirect link to marketing activity. We
Business history is littered with examples of might take it for granted, but it is with us all our
companies that were once powerful but have waking lives.
since gone bankrupt, or have been acquired and
merged into other businesses. In many cases
their collapse has been caused by a lack of func- ■ Marketing now and
tional integration and a dynamic and sound tomorrow: current and future
corporate strategy.
trends
Initially it may seem out of place to comment on
■ Who is engaged in marketing? future trends towards the end of the first chapter.
It would probably be very difficult to find a However, in attempting to understand what
group or organisation that is not, in some way or marketing is, we need to consider and analyse
another, engaged in marketing. Even tribes where marketing is positioned today, and where it
within remote jungles often engage in trade may be positioned in the future. While there are
through barter. They are ‘selling’ and exchanging numerous industry watchers, in the main the focus
produce to gain a mutual benefit. of investigation has been the work of the Marketing
Table 1.2 outlines the various groups involved in Science Institute (MSI). In its research it has
marketing. The objective here is to consider the vast outlined the key developments and research topics
array of organisations involved in marketing opera- over a ten-year period (see Table 1.3). Many of the
tions, and the groups to which they market. B2C and issues raised in the MSI research are discussed in
B2B are widely acknowledged abbreviations, but the this text. However, it is worth briefly considering
other abbreviations given are less well established. what might be the ‘hot’ marketing topics over the
As you can see from the table, every one of us, next years or so.
MARKETING NOW AND TOMORROW 13
N There will be stronger links between marketing N Computing power will increase, and lead to
and strategy. It will be the real strategic more embedded systems within the home and
thinkers who will be able to leverage products office that act on behalf of customers. For
or services into the marketplace. Indeed the instance, remote systems will order products
marketplace may increasingly be looked upon and services automatically. Thus will market-
ing messages need to be directed to the home
as a battlespace where companies compete for
computer system rather than the home owner?
market share.
Will customers use home computers to remove
N Competitive sustainability will become the marketing clutter from their lives?
increasingly hard to maintain within a global
N The World Wide Web and the Internet will
business environment. More of the developing
grow – but what form will they take, how will
nations will attain developed status, and have we interact with them, and on what scale?
the products and services to compete with Whatever the answers, companies will need to
established companies and brands head to be both proactive and reactive to meet the
head. The major brands of the future might be needs of customers working and living in
not American or European, but Indian, African cyberspace.
and Chinese. China-based companies have
already created several major brands. N Measurement will be critical to truly under-
standing success or failure. Computer systems
N The marketing mix and relationship marketing will drive the mathematics to interpret real-
will combine to form a new approach to how time movements in products and services.
companies and organisations relate to their
customers. N Customers will seek deliveries at times that
suit them. While some companies are already
N Information will be the key to success in the providing such services, not all companies
competitive world of the future. Thus compet- have realised that customers will switch
14 1 • INTRODUCTION TO MARKETING
Government G2G Governments market to other governments, for example, in support of indige-
to nous companies that are pursuing contracts abroad. Equally, one government may
government use public relations tactics (see Chapter 10) to lobby another government to
reduce barriers to market entry (protectionism).
Non- NGO2B This is marketing activity that supports good works. An example is UNICEF, the
governmental United Nations’ fund for the care and welfare of children worldwide. Such
organisations organisations will actively market to both businesses and organisations that they
to business believe will help fund their welfare programmes in various countries around the
world.
Non- NGO2C or Throughout the year but especially at the time of national disasters NGOs mar-
government NGO2P ket the need for support from individuals, usually in the form of donations. An
organisations example is the earthquake that devastated the ancient city of Bam in Iran on
to consumers Christmas Day 2003 killing an estimated 30,000 people. NGOs, such as the
or non- International Red Cross and UNICEF, immediately issued appeals for donations to
government help the thousands who had been made homeless.
organisations
to people
brands based upon delivery slots. This is companies and governments must consider
because people’s time is increasingly limited. the reality of this environmental threat, and
Companies that cannot adapt their distribution how they tackle this issue might determine the
channels to meet customer demands will not outcomes of many of the trends suggested
survive. above.
N Customers will seek the best deal for them, so
brand switching will increase. Companies thus These are thoughts based upon current trends.
need to position themselves in the group of However, as we live in an increasingly turbulent
brands that customers consider. There will no world it is really difficult to predict developments
longer be single brands of choice. over the next few years. Whatever happens it will
be a challenge for marketers, no matter what type
N Consumers will seek higher ethical standards of organisation they work in.
from companies and organisations. The scan-
dals of the late 1990s and early 21st century
have cost stakeholders significantly, for ■ Chapter summary
instance, in stock values, life savings and prod-
uct–service quality. Organisations that fail to This chapter has briefly considered some of the
meet higher standards will see increasing developmental aspects of marketing, the organisa-
shareholder power and boycott action. tion of marketing, who is involved in the marketing
function, and possible future trends. It has stated
N Clearly these are major issues. However,
that marketing is an amalgamation of various disci-
perhaps the greatest concern facing
plines, so it is dependent on research and develop-
humankind is the threat of global warming and
ment in many disparate subject areas in order for it
global dimming (see Chapter 2). Individuals,
to evolve further. Equally, marketers must accept
16 1 • INTRODUCTION TO MARKETING
■ References
American Marketing Association (AMA) (1948)
‘Report of the definitions committee’, Journal of
© Jonathan Groucutt Marketing 13 (October), p. 202.
AMA (1960) Marketing Definitions: A glossary of Kotler, P. (1991) Marketing Management, New Jersey:
marketing terms, Chicago: AMA. Prentice Hall.
Cooke, E. F., Rayburn, J. M. and Abercrombie, C. L. Kotler, P. (2000) Marketing Management, Millennium
(1992) ‘The history of marketing thought as edn, Harlow: Prentice Hall.
reflected in the definitions of marketing’, Journal of Lehmann, D. R. (2002) ‘What’s on marketers’ minds?’,
Marketing – Theory and Practice, Fall, pp. 10–20. Marketing Management 11(6) (November/
Cunningham, W. H. and Cunningham, I. (1981) December), pp. 16–20.
Marketing: A managerial approach, Illinois: Irwin. Mazur, P. (1947) ‘Does distribution cost enough?’,
Eldridge, C. E. (1970) Marketing for Profit,London: Macmillan. Fortune 36 (November), p. 138.
Hughes, D. G. (1978) Marketing Management: A plan- McDonald. M. (2002) Marketing Plans: How to prepare
ning approach, Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley. them; how to use them, Oxford: Butterworth-
Keefe, L. M. (2004) ‘What is the meaning of Heinemann.
“marketing”?’ Marketing News, 15 September, pp. McDonald. M. (2003) ‘Marketing died in the last
17–18. decade’, Interactive Marketing 5(2) (October/
18 1 • INTRODUCTION TO MARKETING