0'(1)'1"11.111. A')..,').lJ. t11V toroptc rn ypacpo\lv ot vt1CT\te~, lCat VtlC11te~ etvoa ot E7tt~cOVtE~. Hotoq EiXE 1tEPtO'0'6tEPE~ 7tteav6tTltE~ vo em~1'\O'Et: ot taA,at1tOlp11~VOt 1'\ ot <xve1t<xcpot;3
Ilutft Tl IlKlltllO'tllma 1tO'\) ~A.£U£l O'tTlV ltV£'\)llllttK1i Kilt O'tTlV icOlVO>V1.K1i ~cm; ~ [ ... ] £iVllllJ.tll K P i 0' n t Tl ~ Il V 0. 1t t u ~ Tl ~. AtO'etxv61J.1lO't£ 1tm<; Ko.tt ePX£tllt, 1(\ avn VIl 1tpOO'1tIl60UIJ.E VIl to 1tvi~o'\)lJ.£ £1t£l()1't IlVlltpe1t£l 1tIlAle~ 0''\)v1't6£l£~ Kill tllpo.~£l tTl IJ.IlKIlPl6tTlto. 1J.1l~, 61l 1tpoO'1t1l61't0'0'\)1J.£ VIl to KlltIlAo.~O'\)IJ.£. (1929,0'.25)
A via, anOY01'l'tEu01l, voo'ta.A. yia 'to>V 1t£pao!l£vO>V, IlOtpOAa'tp£i.a, Tl't'tona8£l.a. H notnon, Tl mo EtA.t1CptV1'\<; a1t£t1Covt01l 'tTl<; atoe"n- 1CO'tTl't~ Ila<;, IltAn Ilovaxa yta 'to Xnpo. (0.23)
o eEO't01C~, 'ta a1.o811lla'ta Tlnona9Et~ Kat 9avll'tou 'ta O"UvSual;Et ue rnv noi.TlO1l rou Ka~aq>1l, zou «cpvsttm IlE 'tOY mo anoA.u'to 'tpono vo ~iJO£l.» (0. 67). at VE01. EXOW ami} 'tTl o'tlYlliJ avaylCTl ano
10K. naPDcrxoe; aaxOI.:fl9T)lCE EVtanlCa.llE tov dpayoUI1T1. BA. ~t~AtOypaq>{a tou one; e. 239-40 tOU t6110U I. dpayoUI1Ttc;, Keiueva A.OrO-reXVlI(a, EmlJ.€AEta K.
45
HACI>ETHPIA
napacrxou, 1963.
2 r. E>EOtOKa<; Kat r. l:E!pEPll<;, AMT/A,OrpaqJia, 1975.0 l:EIj)EPll<;, J.l.aAtcrt<X, KOtta~Et vc <X1tOtPE'I'Et tOY E>EOtOKa: «Kat KUp{co<; vOJ.l.i~ro 1tCO<; tivat Kp{J.I.<X vn 1t<X<; V<X J.l.1tM;Et<; a' <xut6 to a9Aw Ko1tclBt» (a. 70). 0 E>EOtOKcl<; OtlXJ.l.<XPtUPEt<Xt, EmJ.!.Evovta<; J.I.E <x9roo EV90u(JtacrJ.l.6 6tt ° MEAcl<; EiVat «0 mo E;U1tVO<; w9pro1to<; emv Eua&x J.l.Eta tOY BEVt~EAo » (a. 71).
3 Ot 'EmopOOEt<;' 1tOU OEXtllKE 0 ~p<xyouJ.l.ll<; (Nietzsche K<Xt Barres) EmOTlJ.l.W- 91)Kav <X1t6 rnv 1tPcbt1) crttyJ.l.1't n6A.<X<; <X1t6 tOY {ow tOY E>EotoKa (1929, a. 72), Kat J.l.EAEt1't91)K<XV avaAUttKa oro OorlJ.l.t6 tOU "H AOYOtEXVtK1't OTlJ.l.<xm<x t1)<; J.l.op!pft<; Kat tou EPYOU tOU I. ~p<xyouJ.l.ll", Nea Batia, KE>', 1941, a. 243-51 (to tEuX0<; 342 Eivat 6Ao <X!ptEPOlj.LEo orov ~p<xyouJ.l.ll). l:t1) a. 248 ot<x~a~ouJ.I.E:
Autot [ ... ) ot 'J.l.Et<X1tOAEJ.l.tKO{' tOY E~AE1tav Ot<xqx>PEttKa, <XY<X1tOuaav KUp{co<; rnv <x9Epa1tEUt1) <XV1lcrux{<x t1)<; 'lfUx1't<; tOU, tt<; avtt<pclcrEt<; tOU 1tVE\>J.I.<xt6<; tou<;, tnv EarotEptK1't rou tptKUJ.I.{<X. '01tco<; 0 M1tapPE<;, K<XJ.I.J.I.ta tptnvtapta Xp6vt<x 1tptV, tiXE YOlltE\jfEt en y<xUtK1't VEOAa{<X yt<xti rnv E~yaAE <X1t6 env <XtJ.l.6a!p<Xtp<x eou v<xtoupaAtaJ.l.0u 1tOU E{XE K<XtavtitaEt K<Xt<x9At- 1tttK1't, J.I.E tOY {ow 1tEp{1tOU tp61to to Uqx><; ton ~ayouJ.l.ll, to roeo 1tpoaO)mK6, allp6, EUYEVtK6 Kat Ka1tOtE ~<xeu, 1'ttavE J.l.t<X (X1t<xpx1't OOOt1)p{a<; yt<X tOU<; VEOU<; 1tOU tiX<XVE xoptOOEt rnv 'lfUXtK1't J.l.Etpt6t1)t<X K<Xt t1) crevomt<X trov opt~6vtrov t1)<; PEaAtcrttK1't<; J.l.a<; 1tE~OYP(X!p{a<;·
o E>rotoKcl<; EmJ.!.EvEt, <JUJ.l.1tEpacrJ.l.<XttKa, ern <pU<rTJ t1)<; 1tE~oYP<X!p{a<; tOU, «1tOU <JUVEt01)t01tO{llaE t1) OTlJ.l.acri<x, tOY 1tAoutO, to ~a90<; tOU EOrotEptKOU <xv9pcb- 1tOU» (a. 251).
13 L1ivOVt~ to crtiYJUX tTI~ Katacrt<XOTl~ 0 e£otoK~ KOtta~£t 1tpOVOllttKa 1tOto K£qx'tA.oo.O a1t6 mv ~pao~ KAllPoV0J.Lta stvrn £Kj.L£taA.A.eUmJ.LO Kat BllJ.LtoupytKa a1tOBottK6, Kat j.L£ta OOKtJ.La~£t vc KaV£t 1tpo~M"'£t~ yta to ~Uov Kat yt' autou~ crtou~ o1toiou~ <XY1'1K£t tO~MV, ~A.a&t tOU~ VEOU~, Ot OKE"'£t~ roo yta to 1teO<; 9a stvrn ta vtata crta £Px6j.L£Va XP6vta auyK£vtprovovtat oe Wo CJllj.L£ia tOU oorlJ.Ltou tOU.l:to 1tpcbto EX£t yta KUPto ot6xo rnv 1t£~oypa<p{a (0. 54-6), £vro oro &ut£po EX£t tTlv 1toillCJll (0. 69-70). QOtooo, o» yta rnv 1t£~oypa<pia Btatu1tWv£t to aitTIJ.La 1t£Ptoo6t£Pll~ «oootee;» Kat otoXacrttK6tT1t~, Kat yta rnv 1tOillCJll tTlv £ux1'I vc 1t6.et ?tEpa a1t6 to «Aupt0J.L6», 0 1tpayJ.LattK6~ crt6xo~ ~piax:£tat ?tEpa a1t6 tTlv 1t£~o'Ypa<pia Kat a1t6 tTlv 1toillon, Kat a<pOpa om Aoyot£xvtKil BpaotTIpt6tTtta oro aUvoA.6 tTI~: etvoa £mtaKttKil avaYKll Ot VEOt va eyKataA.ei",ouv rnv «£uKOAll £pyaaia roo 1taAtou KaAoU xmpou», Kat vu £mX£tp1'l00uv Katt to «Wax:OM», J.Lta Kat «EXOUV Buvaj.L£t~ vn ~oBE",OUV» (0. 55). Kata &Ut£pO A.6y0 ot VEOt, 1tOU tOU~ <pavta~£tat «p<OJ.LaMa 1tatBta, YUJ.Lvaoj.LEva», 1tPE1t£t vo
KE t11V A9i)va, 11£ Illa <pa.cnatlldt lpO'lYtO'\}Platlldt EKOt'IMoort, 'to 1933, 0 E>EO'tOKa.C; O"E Eva avu7t6ypaq>o O"X6Al6 rou oro 7tEPWOlK6 I&a (/':, 1933, 0". 202-3) ElproVEt>t11KE tnv «OIlOPq>la. t11C; 'taxut11'tac;» Kat 'ta mrtoxtvrrtu, E~1]y6>V'tac; 6'tl fiXE ~E7tEpaatE{ ma «1] A!l'tpfia rou Il1]X~lO"Il0U» 7to'\} 11:\ a\)'t1'l 'tEAlKa. ceroteAoUO"E Illa a7t67tElpa va7tVtyd 1] «a't0lllldt EAE'\}9Ep{a».
2. BA. 'tcOpa r. E>EO'tOKa.c; Kat r. l£q>Ep1]C;, A.u17A.Orpatpfa, 1975,0". 17-18. :E'tov tOw 't6IlO, 0". 136-38, O11Il0cnEt>E'tCXl Kat 'to 7tOt1]lla 'to'\} l£q>Ep1] "AEr0q>6poC; 1:\)yypou B''', 11£ 1]lI£poll1]Vta «25.11.1935», 67to\) ~A.E7to'\}lI£ 6n 1] AEr0q>6poC; XP1]crill£'IfE Kal yta rnv a.q>l~1] rou rEropyiO'\} B'.
14 «0\ OTII.l£PtvE~ 1tV£Ulla:nKE~ av('tyKE~ tTl~ EAAa&x~ &v EmtpE7tOUV ma 'tTlv EUKOA.Tl Epyacria tOU 7taA.l.OU KaA.OU KatPOU», a7tocpa.{vEtat 0 eEOtoK~ (1929, o, 55). Min OEA.l&x 7tpOYtUtEpa 0 lal.O~ EiXE ~A.c.OOEt on 0 1l0VtEPVtOIl6~ a7t6 uovo; tOU &v i)tav apKEt6~ yta v« XEtpOKpOtOUI.l£ £Va EPYO. ME to va ~MbVEt Ilta to £Va Kat Ilta to auo, 0 6£0- tOK~ KataatKaSEt rnv EUKOA.{a OE 6AE~ tt~ KatEu9UvoEt~, avaq>Ep6- 1lEV0~ Kat oto 7tapEA.96v Kat cto IlEAAOV. MV etvm ~auou 0 7tpciYto~ 7tOU EmOTIllaivEt tOY Kivwvo 'tTl~ EUKOA.ia~. H 7tPOXEtp6'tTlta ata 7tOA.tttKa 600 Kat ota KaAAttEXVtKa, Tl Em7t0A.at6'tTlta, TlIl7taya7tOvtta, Tl a7ta'tTl, Tl A.oYOKA.Om't etvm EA.attcbllata 7tOU ot mo EuauvEi~tOt 'EA.A.TlVE~ atavooUI.l£VOt ta KatW1Kaoav 7taVtOtE. H 7tPOTlYOUI.l£VTl 7tOtTltt-
Ki) YEVta, IlE tTlv 7tp6q>aOTl tTl~ EtA.tKplvEta~ Kat tTl~ aKatavlKTltTl~ avaylCTl~ EKq>paOTl~, EiXE 7tapaaup9Ei a7t6 rnv 'EuKoA.la' tOU ato9i)llato~, a7t6 rnv Em&PlltKi) Euato9ricria Kat EiXE 7tpoq>amotEl to a'YXo~ 'tTl~ son;~ yta rnv atTlIlEAEta tOU uq>Ou~. H tEXVTl i)tav tcbpa yta tOU~ ] VEOU~ Katt mo {3a9U, Ilta 7tP~Tl u7tEu9uVTl, a7tOtEAEOlla Ilta~ Emllovi)~ 1t1.0 KomaOttKi)~. Tov Kal3aq>Tl, 7tOU 7tEptq>POVOUOE to 'aio9rilla' Kat rnv 7tpoXEtp6tTlta, &v tOY Eixav aK61lTl aVaKaA.u'!'Et ot VEOt OE .auti) rou tTl ataotaOTl. Tnv ayv6'tTlta rou A.6you 'tTl auvaEav ue 'tTl q>paan-
1Ci) a7tA.6'tTlta· uovo 7tOU, a7toOO1Ctllasovta~ rnv 'EUKOA.ia', tpaj3ouoav ima 7tpO~ rnv EPIlTlttKi) EKOOXi) 'tTl~ aI.l£06'tTlta~ rou A.6you, aKOA.oU- 9cbvta~ rnv KatEU9vv'ti)pta MaA.aPIlE-BaAEpu. ME tOY iaw tp67t0 7tOU OtTlv 7tOA.tttKi) oi ootot 'tTl~ YEVta~ tOU Tptavta, yta va avttata90uv OtTl q>ti)Vta teov KEpaOOK67trov Kat troy Ka7t1'IA.rov, KA.EiVOVtat a7t6 a.~W7tpE7tEta OE Ilta. ataOTl a.VtawtEAEta~ xrn a.7tOxi)~, ot A.OYOtExvE~ tcbpa., 7tPOKEtIlEVOU vo ataM~ouv Eva YEO ap61l0 yta. rnv noinon, a.7tOq>EUYOUV to 'A.UptOIl6', rnv a.to9rillatoA.oyia., to 7tp6XEtpO ypa'l'lIlO Kat STltouv Ka.taq>Uyto OtOV EAEq>avttvO 7tUPYo.
49
HACIIETHPIA
'Orcv E~qxxviOt'llKE 'll I1:p0qn'J, 0 naA.a~~ E&ooE tOtaitEp'll 7tpOOOxi1 oro YEyov6c" 6tt 0 7tOt'llti1c" 'tTlc" E<pap~O~E (J' a'Uti1v (J'U(Jt'll~a'ttKa 'tTlV apxi1 'tTlc" Ou(JKOAiac". A'U96p~'llta 0 naAa~ac", 7tEpvcbvtac" a7t6 rov 7tOt'llti1 (JtOV avayvoot'll, (J'l)crxEti~Et to Ota~'ll~a am6 rou l£<ptP'll ~ rnv 7tpOCJ7ta9Eta 7tO'U MattEi avti(JtotXa to 7toi'll~a a7t6 rov avayvroern. «AAAa xpEta~Etat vo ~o'll9i1CJ'll 07tCOOOiJ7tOtE Kat 0 7tOt'llti1c" to (J'l)vEpya~6~o avayvoo'tTl 1'1 aKpoatiJ tou», EtOo7tOlOUCJE 0 naA.a~ac". «'O~coc" ta 7tpay~ata E~EAi(J(Jovtat, ~yaivo'Uv a7t6 ta 6pta to'Uc". Ot <XptcrtOKpa'ttKoi (J'ttX07tAEXtEc" 'tTlc" <pUAi1c" rou l£<ptP'll Kat 'tTl ~oi19Et~ autiJ &v 9EO>POUV a7tapai'tTlt'll. Btvm ccv vo. ~'llv ~'lltouv 'Ifli<PO'Uc,,». (Nea ECJ1:{a, 1931, Kat Nea ECJ1:{a, M"f.T', 1972, (J. 1563).
Tou; t£A.eutaiouc; KatpOUC; to. KO~~OUV\anKa ~~ata &v ouvcvtOUV ma Kal-ua oo~ap1'l t a e 0 A. 0 Y \ K 1'1 avtiat(X(1T\ orov t67to ~ac;, £l;a\tiac; tT\C; O\Ktp1'lC; T\tto7ta8etac; 7tOU KatEx£\ t{J)V 'l'ropoKcbcrtawa. (1931, r. E>£OtOKac; Kat r. l£q>tpT\C;, A.u.T7A.orpaqJla, 1975, c. 63)
H a\amat{J)OTl aut1'\ a7t0t£A.ci Kat to a7tOq>amanK6 £pt8\o~a 7tOU me£t to 8£OtoKa 7tpOC; tOV l:. M£Aa Ka\ 7tOU tOV m8et vc yiVet 0 oeeoA.oYT\t1'\c; tOU q>\A.eA.eu8£pou \&aA.\O~ou. M6vo 7tOU, 7tapa tT\v apx\KI'l rou 7tp68£0TI vo q>pal;et to ap6~o 7tapaA.A.T\A.a Otouc; KO~~OUV\Ottc; Kat Otouc; q>aaiot£c;, t£A.\Ka 0 E>£OtOKac; rou 7t£pWa\KOU IOta ~7taiv£\ <1tT\ J.lo\paia 7top£ia tOU £UP{J)7ta'iKOU q>\A.eA.eu8£p\o~oU, 7tOU, tov Katp6 £K£tVO, 7t£pva ~\a EvtOVT\ \&OAoytKl'l xpton Ka\ avoiy£\ to ap6~0 ornv £7t\KpatT\OTI tOU q>amo~ou ornv Eupol7tT\'. AA.Aa o» KO\tal;OU~ KaA.Utepa tT\v taKnKl'l 7tOU aKoA.ou8£i 0 E>£OtOKac; evevrtov tOU q>amo~ou, 80. a\a7t\atcbcrou~ 6n yt' aut6v 0 q>amo~6c; &v eiva\ Evac; rlvauvoC; 1tou £K~A.cbv£ta\ ~oa a1t6 rnv £A.A.T\v\KI'l1tpay~anK6tTlta, aA.M ~\a a1t£\A.1'I7tOU l;£K\va ~aKp\a a7t6 tT\v £A.A.T\VtK1'\ £7t\Kpat£\a Ka\ 1tOU teA.\Ka J.l1top£i vo £m~A.T\8ei a1t' tl;{J) Kat ornv EUUOO. Avti8£ta, 0 avti1taA.oc;, 7tOU a1tot£A.ei yt' am6v ~\(X £mK£i~vT\ a7t£\A.1'I 6A.rov t{J)V al;\olv tou q>\A.eA.eu8£p\o~oU !to I1v£u~a, T\ lata), Kat 7tOU £v£ap£U£\ ~oa etov £A.A.T\VtK6 Xropo, £iva\ 0 KO~~ouv\o~6C;. H ~aA.T\ any~1'I yta to
To 'tEAE'lYtaio acpop6. ornv 'tEXVTI. Btvct 8E1lEA.tco~vo ornv apXTt «To EPYO 't1'\~ 'tEXVll~ ~EKtV6.Et a1t6 mv oll6.oa Kat 0' a"ll'tTt ~avay"llpv6.», Kat O't1'\pi~E'tat O'tOV opiouo:
H 'tEXVTI ato9r]'t01totEi n~ av6.YKE~ 'tCOV KOtVCOvtKeOV oll6.<5rov Kat 'ta O"llVato91'jlla'ta nou yEVvtOUV'tat a1t' a"ll'tE~ Kat n~ ucovozoiet IlE 't1'\ 1l0Pcpit 1t0"ll OiVEt o'ta Ol]llto"llpYitlla't6. 't1'\~ 1'1 a1tA.oU01:Epa: l] 'tEXVTI ato9r]'t01totEi'tl] O"llVEiOl]Ol] 'tCOV KOtVCOVtKWV OIl6.<5rov llE'ta OtK6. 't1'\~ EtOtK6. Kat 'tEXVtK6. ~oa. (Neoi npanonooot; B', 1933, o. 7, EI(A£I('re; ucl(&:;, fl.', 1975, o. 78-9).
H 'tEXVl] 'tl]~ E1tavao'ta't1'\~VTI~ KotVcovi~ etvoi «pEaA.tOnKit, vo'to"llpaA.tonKit, 9E'ttKTt, 1tA.ouma OE 1tEptEX61J.EV0». H 'tExVl] 't1'\~ 't~l]~ 1t0"ll 1tcla oro «xaIl6» 't1'\~, 't1'\~ aonKit~ IlE 6.A.A.a A.6yta, a1toq>EuYEt 't1'\v 1tpaYlla'ttK6'tl]'ta, yivE'tat «cpOPllaA.to'ttKTt Kat OtaKoolll]nKit». ME't6. cero 'tt~ OOYllanKE~ a'lYtE~ ~E~atcOaEt~, E~E't6.~Et O"llV01tnK6. 't1'\ VEOEA.A.l]vtKit A.oyo'tExvia, Ka'taOtK6.~Et 'tOY l:tKEA.tav6 IlE rn &A.q>tKit IOEa, 'tOY Ka~roL't~6.lcrI IlE 'to «1lE'taKoIlIl0"llvtOIl6» rou, 'tOY Ka~6.Cj)l] IlE 'tOY «upVTlnK6 cpoPllaA.tOIl6».
Ot 1tapa'tl]PTtOEt~ a"ll'tE~ ron rA.l]VOU, 1tOA.U xalll]A.6'tEpE~ a1t6 n~ tKav6't1'\'tE~ rou Kat "ll1tayopE"ll!lEvE~ ceto 't1'\V av6.ylClJ Ilt~ ~taanKit~ 1tapEIl~aOl]~, Ota'tU1tCOvav IlEPtKOU~ axl]llanKOU~ OOyllanollou~, £veO 1tap6.A.A.l]A.a EKcpp6.~avE IlEptK6. O"llIl1tEp6.olla'ta yta 1tp60co1ta Kat Ka'tao't6.oEt~· av6.llEoa 0't0"ll~ 1tpcO'tO"ll~ Kat o'ta OEU'tEpa avoty6'tav Eva aYEcpUpCO'to K£v6' a"ll't6 'to KEV6 aKpt~~ ea E1tPE1tE vo YEllioEt 0 rA.l]v6~, yta vo OcOaEt 0't1'\ O"llVOA.tKit tou otamo'tCOOlj 't1'\V a1tapai't1'\'t1'\ 1tEtOnK6't1'\'ta Kat 't1'\ llEeOOOA.oytKit eEIlEA.iCOOlj.
o KapavtooV1]<; EOWE tT]V alC6M>uEhl1tEplypa<p1\ ma 1954:
Oi 1tpomroetaEl<; a'lYt1'!<; tT]<; avayEvv1]OT]<; 1'Itav 1tEpi1tou ot e;1'I<;: Eva cdeEhllla ata9Ep6t1]ta<; lCat av600u tT]<; ~cm'I<;. IJ.E atm6oo~1] 1tPOO1ttllC'fl1tOU t1]V ev{axUE Illa ollaollC'fl matT] 1t0><; 1t6AEIl0<; ma &v 9a ~avay{vEl lCat 1tc.oc; Il1tOpo'liaE ma to 1tVE'Illla va 1tPOxcop1'laEl ~tyvolamo orov a1tEpavto l)p61l0 to>V 1tE1tPO>llfvO>v tou. Mla Ematpo<p1\ 1'1 lCal atpo<p1\, av 9EAEtE, 1tpo<; rn q>U0T], 1tOU OEV EiXE tT] OT]llama tT]<; qroy'fl<;, fi>.UJ. tT]<; avalCaA.u'1"1<; ev6<; 9a'lillato<;. (1958, a. 147)
2 H llap,tUpia tOU 9EOtOlCa. E{Vat 7t0A.U ElC<ppamtlC'fl:
o llap~l0l16<; EIl1tawE a7t6tOlla OtT] ~cm'lIla<; IJ.E tT] promlC'fl tOU qromoyvroIlia, IJ.E Eva llaX1]tllC6 1tVE'Illla OorllatllCo'li EmOtT]lloVlallo'li, fi>.UJ. lCat 9p1]OlCEU'tllC'fl<; a7t0lcaA.U'I"1<;' 61tou V6Ill~E lCavEi<; 6tl auvu7tli.pxouv ot EmppoE<;
58
tOU A£vtv Kat too Tp6tcrKt, tOU TOA0t6t Kat tOU rK6pn, trov llpootKcOV oO()(ppaYIlUtOW tOU 1t£paa)i£vou atcOva Kat trt<; mo 1l0VtEpva<; tEXV1l<;. A1to rnv aA.A.llll£pul, 0 t&:aA.t0Jl6<; tow VEavtKcOv Ila<; Xp6vrov 1'ltav Ilta OtUllaptupia Kat Ilta ulluva evovrtov tOW 1tpcOtOW EKOrtMbaEOW rou OAoKAllProttallou, 1tOU upXt~av va aXllllat{~OVtat ern Pooma Kat va 1tpOKaAoUv, avtavaKA.acrttKa, ta cpamattKU nv1'lllata trt<; Eupc01trt<; (1961, a. 116).
3 0 A. navaEAllVO<; E~1l'YE{ a1'lll£pa (Tote nov 'ovuap£, 1974, a. 182 K.E.) rnv tpaytKl'! Em7ttCOO111tOu EiXE -eo tOtcOvullO ernv KOtvrovtKl'!Kat 1tVEullattKl'! ~oo1'l, avoiyovta<; £Va XUOJla avull£aa Ott<; avti9EtE<; 1tapat~Et<;, OuaxEpa{vovta<; Etm to OtaAoYO 1tOU EiXE apX{aEt yta en YEVtKl'!1tPOK01r1'!.
4 rta to 1tOAtttK6 Kat tOroA.oytK61tAaimo tow 1t£ptOOtKcOv f3A. A. EAE¢Vtrt<;, H E1rayye).{a TT/q aovvaf1/q E1ravamaC1T/q, 1976. rta trt OpOOrt EtOtKU tOW 1t£PtOOtKcOv Kat rn uUyKPOUart tow t&:cbv, f3A. mv avaAUCJ1l tou Tooou Boopvn, "Mta EmU1C61t1lart tow 1tVEUllattKcOv ~tcOv ornv EAAaOa KatU rnv 7tEpioOo 1930-1936", EmgeWpT/C1T/ TtxVT/q, IE', 1962, a. 518-35. rta Kav£va an6 ta 1t£ptOOtKU 1tOU ava<!>EPro OEV KavEt Myo 0 r. Xat~{V1l<;, "nEptOOtKU tOU ll£a01tOMIlou", ArrA.oeM.T/vzK'lf Em(Je(/)pT/C1T/, B' 1946, a. 177-8, 1tOU 1t£ptOp{~Etat oe E1taiVOU<; yta ta Nea rp~aTa, rn Nea Eatia Kat 1tOU 1l6At<; ava<ptPEt 1t£ptOOtKU artllavttKU 61t~ 0 KVK"AoqKat MalrEoovzK"Eq Hp,tpeq.
5 Tnv OAtCJ9rtp6trtta rou Bp61lou autou 1tOU EiXE EmartllavEt t6tE 0 ~. nllv6<;, anavtcOvta<; aE up9po tOU K. Tautaou ("H 9Eart trt<; t&:oKpatia<; OtOV KOtVOOVtK6 aYcOva", I&a, A', a. 361-6), 61tou E&:tXVE rn c:rtJYYEVEta trov 9EaEOOV tOU <PtAEAE'69EpoU t&:aAtOJlOU Il£ rn <ptAoao<p{a roo G. Gentile ("0 <paUtOttK6<; t&:aAlOJl6<; CJtrt" EU<lOa", Neo: Ilparcon6pol, tEUX0<; 7, 1933, a. 213-5). Mta Il£Mtrt yta rn <pamattK1'lKatUAll~ll tOU IptAEAEU9EptallOU emv Eupc01t1l, etvct tou Ernst Nolte, Die Krise des libetslen systems und die faschistischen Bewegungen, M6vaxo, 1968 (Il£talppaallfvo ttaAtKU: La crisi dei regimi libersli e i movimenti fascisti, MtA.<lvo, 1970)
ti1:A.o "Ot aA116tvOt vsot", 67toU !!EO'a O'ta {J).).a U7toO''t1'\Pt~£ on mO'CI} a7t6 au't1'\ 'tTl J.l.avia yta to. vuxta ~ptO'K6tav 0 navaytcbtTl~ KavW6- 1tOUA.o~ Kat to OOKtJ.l.t6 tOU H l(olv{J)via tT/~ enox7f~ J.i~. H aK6A.ou6rt 1tEptKO~ a7t6 to apepo eO. J.I.~ &OO£t J.l.ta £VtOVTJ y£uO'TJ 'tTI~ £7tOXTt~:
A7t6 tOU~ tOtXOU~ 'tTI~ A8l1v~, rou n£tpaux Kat {J)..)..cov J.l.£prov tOU t61tOU J.I.~, 67t~ Kat a7t6 J.l.£ptKcX 1tPO£KA.oytKcX J.l.1taAK6vUl, aKouO't11Kav, KatcX n~ t£A.eutat£~ £~OOJ.l.cX&~ J.l.£YcXA.e~ Kat £mJ.l.OV£~ Kpauye~ yta vfuu~, 1tpO~ veou~, a1t6 "veou;" - 6~ ot tOWt £~£~atCl}vav J.I.£ tp67to 1tapa 1tOI..U vecvnco Kat J.l.£tpanolOTJ, to'~ yta vc <patvovtat mo mO't£utoi. "'EpX£tat 11 vea y£v£cX" yta vc OtOl1;a "to. KopcXna tOU OtXaO'J.l.OU". Ot veoi, oi veoi, 1tOU ~OOPVtKcX avaKcXI..U'l'av ts« <p6tvo1tcopw6 &tl..w6 1t~ eiVat veoi, Kat£~(vouv£ va J.I.~ O'cOOouv, vn O'cOOouv£ 'tTl xcilpa, to eevo~, J.I.£ n~ 1tatOtK~ tOU~ avaKpauy~. Kat eappei Kavei~ 1t~ 0 ayae6~ Kat OtcX<pavo~ qx.r>tav6~ X£tJ.l.CI}VtcXnKo~ ay£p~ 'tTI~ A9ftv~ Kat 'tTI~ EI..I..cX~ J.l.flO'ttyroV£'tat a7t6 KcX1tOWV KaK611Xo Kat av£m8UJ.l.11'to av'ttt..w.o uicvTt~ "T~o~we'tO'~" 1tOU 'tupavvcX a7t6 xp6vta 'tou~ I..aO~ 1tOU Ka'tOlICOUV£ O"tTJv avnKpwTt 6x6rt tou Iovtou Kat rou AOptanKou.
1 K~ lXpy6tEpa, lCat ~aa oro lCl..tJUl eou MEtru;a typlX<fl£ to ap9po "Ta vtata lC' 1'1 1p\l1..1't" (Neoe.U71VlK'a rpap.J,la1:a, 27 Ck~poulXptou 1937) 0 A. T£p~alCTI~. Btvat q>aV£p1't 1'1 7tpoamWEta tOU va U1tOO't1lpt~Et rn &Uv~1'I trov vtatrov, UltO"fP~l1t~ovt~ ~ rnv tota attYI11't lCat opu:r~a «lp\ll..£ttlCa» £l..attcbl1ata. 2 Kata I1lXptupta tou Bl..utTI (1974, a. 272), 0 Kav£ll61toul..o~ I1E tOY K. Taatao lCat tOY I. 0£oSropalC61toul..o, «(l(J1Coooav 1ttXvro crtou~ vtou~ I1tav aOtwptI..ovilCTltTI y01'ltcia». H I('OlVll.IV{a 'CT/q E1Coz7fq J,laq, 01l11Oat£\l~0 to 1932, 7tpotpXEtat a1t6 tt~ 1tapa06aEt~ tOU alCaOTIl1ailCou ttou~ 1930-1, lCat &v 1t£pttXEt tlC01l~ 1tpOtPO~ eto 1tVeUl1a 1tOU evvoet 0 K. KIXp~uVTJ~, crta ttaaEpa ~P1'l ' rou (A' "'Bevo~ lCat EevtlCtaI16~", B' "i\tOl1ov lCat atol1tlCu:r116~", 1"' "Kotv1't yvcbl11'1", I!.' "l:up~ - 11600"). To 1tp6~1..1'II1a 1tOU avttl1£'trom~Et 0 Kav£ll61tOuI..o~ civat oi axt~ tOU at6110u I1E env xowevtc, To avnro1tO 1tOU txro \l1t6'1f11 110u, 1tPOEPX6I1£VO a1t6 tTl ~t~l..to91'tlCTl tOU I. MEtru;a. tXEt rnv rupWP(J)(JTJ: «Eu; tOY ru;t6ttl1ov Kuptov IcoWVTJ MEtru;a I1Et' ~atpttOU aE~aGI10U lCat ~aeut~tTI~ ElCttl11'taE~. AUyoucrto~ 1932».
ttep« anD TOV I(OJ.ll.lOVVl(JJ.lO
21 H ot'l'a 1tpoooounO'J.l.ou Tt'tav ma rooo ev'toVTJ avcXJ.l.£O'a O'tou~ veou~, Kat ot 1tpOO&unK~ t~ yta 'tou~ Ka'tam£O'J.l.Evo~ 1tOU ~cXyya-
A. epUAo, TI. Kapa~{a, K. AEUlC01tap{15rt (U1tEU6UVOC;), r. MT\Atcl.l>rt, ~. MtXaA.61tOAo, K. Oupcl.VT\, K. TIaylCaA.o, T. TIa1tatcrcbvT\, KA.. TIapaoxo.
Btvrn 7t0A.U 0"'I11lavnK6, K<x\ IlE Ka7to\O tp67t0 7tapTtyopo, to YEYov6C; 6n £vac; a7t6 touC;£7t1,q>av£iC; £K7tp60"C07touC; tllC; Y£V\ac;, 0 K. f>. ~l1llapac;, 8a OIlOA.oyTto"£\ to 1965, 0"£ 1l\<X A.<X8paia u7too"'l1Il£icoo"'l1, env £~TtC; a7toOpallat07totllIJfVll aM8na:
H Y£v£a 1l0U UO"tEpllO"£ 7toO"onKa ornv £V£P'Y11nKTt 7tDA.mKTt 7t<Xpoooto tllC;, yta tpEic; O\aOOX\KOUC; aA.A.E7taA.llA.oUC;, A.6yOUC;: tllv O\K-
70
IAEOAOnKEl: KAI An:6HTIKEl: ZY"Mm:En:
tatopia rou I. MEt~a, tOY BEUtEPO 1taYK6crl-nO 1t6AE!10 Kat ta 1t£ptcrtattKa 1tOU aKoAou6T\crav omv Euaoo. na toUto icrc.oc; 0\ VE6tEPOt E1tA11macrav 1tp66u!1a oe Katt 1tOU 6u!1i~u 'crtpatEuoj..l£vnv 1tOAmlC'l't notnow', Kata rnv E1tttUX11~ £K<ppa01l £V~ Aoyiou tOU PCOflavttcr!1ou. (IVf.l1COmal(a, 1965, cr. 63)
Ilportottopia xca xotvotma
23 0 tBEOAoytK6~ opyacr!16~, 11 E1tttaKttKTt avay1C1l Pt~tlC'l't~ avav£ro- 01l~ t<OV Ko\VO)Vl.](cOV Oo!1cOV, !lETt oiXc.oc; E1tavacrt(l<J1l, oo"youv oe !lE- 9600u~ 1tOU uopeonoiowrca £vtova, avaAoya !lE to ~amK6 1tpocravatOAtcr!16, avaAoya o"AaOTt ue to av E!11tV£Ovtat a1t6 tt~ 1tpocrOo~ tOU <PtAEAEu6£pou acrttcr!1ou Tt a1t6 tOY 1tpoypa!1!1attcr!16 t11~ !1ap~tcrttlC'l't~ E1tavacrtattK6t11ta~. M.V U1tapXEt a!1<pt~oAia on ot cruVUOTtcrEt~, 1tOU Eivat Euaicr6TltE~ oe 1tap6!10\£~ E1tttay£~ avavt<OO1l~ Kat Kata~aAAoUV 1tpocr1ta9EtE~ 1tpO~ autTt rnv KatEu6uv01l, BEv Ex0UV, 1tocrOttKa, mv iOta E1tt<pWua ue to crUvOAo t11~ KO\v6t11t~ omv osoto avTtKouv. A1t6 to y£yov6~ Kat uovo en aut~ ot cruvEtOTtcru~ a1tOtEAouv !1ta 1tpo11Yj..l£V11 Katacrt(l<J1l a1t£vavtt crtt~ crUVOAtKt~ cruV9itKE~, !-ua atX!1Tt, BEv cru!11ti1ttOUV 1tocrOttKa ue to crUVOAo t11~ Ko\V6t11t~. Av 1ttcrt£'Vou!lE 6tt xovovucc 11 1tp<Ot01tOpia avtt1tpocrCJ)1t£'l)U tacru~ t11~ KO\vCOV{~ a1t6 t11v onoto 1tPO£PXEtat (Kat yt' aut6 OEV u1tapxu a!1<pt~oA{a), t6tE !11t<r pooue vo avap<Ot119ou!lE 1tota cruyKEKPt~ ta01l t11~ KOtvrovi~ evn- 1tpocr<01t£uu. H Y£v\1l rou Tptavta EK<ppa~u !1ta KOtV6t11ta; Iloie; 'H 1tP£1tEt !1aAAoV vu 1ttcrt£'Vou!lE 6tt j..l£cra crt1l 'y£V\a' Xropouv cruyypa<pcl~ 1tOU EK<ppa~ouv 1toUa1tAt~ Kat Ota<pOpEttK£~ KOtv6t11tE~;
H 9Eropia 1tOU 9E!lEAtcOVEtat crt1l OtaKpt01l tCOV t~E<OV £XEt £tOt!111 t11V a1t6Kpt01l: :\>1tapxOUV 1tp<Oto1t6pOt Kat y£v\Ka, uepixot AoyOt£XVE~ 1tOU avta1tOKp{VOVtat £itE crtt~ avaYKE~ t11~ acrttlC'l't~ t~11~ EitE aAAOt crtt~ avaYKE~ t11~ EpyattKit~ t~11~, tOU 1tpOAEtaptatou. Ot 1tp<Ot01t6- POt Kat oi AOyOt£XVE~ t11~ acrttlC'l't~ t~11~ £ivat 1tapaK!1taKOi, E1t£tOTt 11 ta~11 tOU~ oro cruvoM t% ~ao{~Et 1tpO~ tOY a<pavtcr!16, ~p{crKE'tat crt11v 1tapaK!1Tt t11~ Kat '1tapa!1tMW. 1tptv 1t£9aVEt". Avti9Eta, ot 1tprotonopoi Kat O! AoyOt£XVE~ rou 1tpoAEtaptatOu, t11~ t~11~ 1tOU aupw 9a e1ttKpatitcru ue :.c11V E1tttuxia t11~ £1tavacrta01l~ ~picrKOVtat Ot11v aK!1Tt t<OV Ouv<'q.l£cOv to~.
To a1tAo1tOt11j..l£vo aut6 crxTt!1a, 1tOU ot K0!1!10UVtcrt£~ to U1tocrt11pi~ouv Ooy!1attKa, o"A.<lOTt Xropi~ vu crt11pi~ovtat crnv E!11t£tptlC'l't otam-
Na 1tO"\)A.lE'tat q>'t1lv6., yta va 'ta ~~eouv 6A.a ['ta ~laAtx't6. KO~~6.na Ol 1tPOAt't6.PlOl], va 1tO'tlo'touv ~' a"\)'t6. Yla va ~"\)va~olOEl ~oa rouq 11 Ka'taA."\)'tlK~ op~~.
To 'tl~11'tlK6 'tEUX0<; ytv6'tav E"\)Kalpia Kat Yla Eva ~l~aK'tlK6 KUPlO 6.pepo, av"\)1t6ypaq>o, J.lE 'tl'tA.0 "H 'tEXVl1 Kat Ol ~6.~E<;".l:u~q>O)va ~E 'tOY apepoyp6.q>o, 0 B6.pvaA.l1<; «Bptoxetm Kal J.lE 't11 OKE'IfTl roo Kal J.lE 'to o"\)vaioel1~a rou Kat ~E 'ta Epya rou ~Eoa ornv E1tav6.0'ta0l1». Ot «aO'tlKE<; q>6P~E~ 't11<; 'tEXVl1<;, Ol paq>lv6.'tE<; 'tEXVO'tP07tlE<; 't11<; 1tapaK~~<;» ~EV ~lA.OUV 0't11 "'"\)X~ rou 1tA.~eo"\)<;. A1t6 'tl1V 6.A.A.11 1tAt"\)p6., 11 aO'tlK~ 't~11 'tpoq>ooo'tEi «rn ~EY6.A.l1 ~6.~a rou Epya~6J.lEvo"\) A.aOU» «J.lE XOV'tpOKo~~va ovoootc, 1tapaA."\)'tlK6. 't11<; 'If"UX~<; rou avayvo>cruceto». To KUplO aU't6 6.pepo 'tEAtlolVEl J.lE 'tl1v 1tp60KA.l1CTTI: «TExvi'tE<; rou A.6yo"\) Kat K6.8£ 'tEXVl1<;, ~uyo>cr'tE 'ta 1tA.~81l».
J.R, Jimenez, A. Machado, M. de Unamuno, P. Salinas, M. Villa, F.G. Lorca, R. Alberti, V. Aleixandre (0 KVICA.o~, B' 1933' at 'tEA.Eu't(XiOt 'tpEte; oro 'tEUxoe; 6-7 rou 1933, a. 237-60). 0 Ka.~a.v't~uKTle; cruIl7tEPtA.aIl~<XVE, oov
83
MEOAODKEl: KAI AIl:ElHTIK&ZYMru:EIl:
av-ra,7t600011 <PlAO~EVia~ 7tpO~ rnv K'U~£PVTlO1l 7to'U £f..l£AA.e vu 'U7tOKU'tIEt O''tO cIlpaVKo4, Kat 'tOV' A6pKa Kat 'tOY AAI.l7t£P'tt, &v ~£pO) f..l£ 7t601l EmYVCOO'll 't'% O1lj.1aO'ia~ 7tO'U fix,av Kat oov a'YO)vlO''t£~. To j.1EO'o'YElaK6 KAij.1a rou AAj.17tEP't\ OEV a<p1lO'E aOla<pOpo 'tOY EAU't11', EVro 11 7toi11011 rou A6pKa TJ'tav 7tpOOPlO'j.1Ev11 vo a7tOK'tTJO'El oAo£va 7tEplO'0'6'tEPO'U~ ea'Uj.1aO''t£C; Kat j.1lj.111't~ O"tTJV EMaOO6• H EVEP'Y6~ 7tapo'UO'ia rou A6pKa O''t11V Euaoa TJpeE Ka9uO''tEp11!J.Eva, oix,~ vc. <j>£PEl 'to 6<peA.o~ 7tO'U ea £<PEPVE't11 O''tt'Yj.1TJ nou ax.11j.1a'tl~6'tav 11 EM11V\1C1'j nponosopto, Av 0 ~. Totpxce; Kat 0 e, ~KO'UPATJ~ 7tapa~p£9'l1Kav O''tOV '6PKO' 'Yux'to A6pKa, oro ~EU'tEPO ~'Uv£op\O ~'U'Y'Ypa<p£O)v yta mv Y7tEpaO'mO''t11 't11~ KO'UA'toupa~ oro TIapim', j.1a~i us 'to'UC; 'EPEj.17tO'UP'YK, Apa'YK6v, M7tPEX,'t, ~7t£vO'EP, NEPOUOO, R. Desnos, oivov'ta~ 'to '7taprov' 'to'U~ f..l£ j.1la 7tP~11 av'tiO''ta01l~, a'U'tTJ 11 E7tElO'OOla1C1'j 7tapo'UO'ia EAATJVO)V AO'YO'tEX,VroV &v fiX,E lCaj.1la O"Uv£7tE\a O"ta EM11v\Ka 'Yp<l!J.j.1a'ta. 0 Aopxo, 'tEAllC6., j.17tTJKE cmv EMaOO f..l£'ta 'tOY 7t6A.ej.1o'.
1 0 U1tap~tO")l6c; rou l:apavtlXp'l1 tXEt Ilia KateU9uvO"'ll spiritualiste, 1tOU a1tOKWt Elpa1tt6jlEvec; jlE to llap~tO"ttK6 u1tap~tcrIl6. BA. CJ\Y"fKEKptjltva Ivp.{JoAf! oe uux qJzA,ou()({Jla TT/q V1rap~77t; 1937, jlE E1taVtKOOO"'ll ma Aoxiuux; 1970 (~A. etOtKa to KElp. "H 'I1oovi)Kat '11 mCJt'll").
2 0 EAUtTlC;, 1974, cr. 274-5: «Ata~~ajlE Il~i rauouC; Kat ItaAoUC; 1tOt'l1ttc;, tOtahEpa tOY Ungaretti, nouto 1tEpi<P'llIlO 1toi'l1lla tOU "Memoria d' Ofelia d' Alba", 9ullallat, to Eixa lla9Et a1t' ~ro eto 1tprot6tu1to». H KPU<P1'l aya1t'l1 rou EAUtTl yta tOY OuyKapttn yiVEtat q>IlVEP1'! Kat ue ta 1tOt1'!llata 1tOU jlEttq>pacre os (JlJvepyama jlE tOY ItaM Kat OTIllomeljlE CJt'Il &Vrep77 rpalfJ11, 1976, (61tou Kat '11 jlEtaq>P!lO"'ll"Mvi)Il'l1 t'IlC; O<pt]Aiac; t'IlC; Auy1'tC;").
3 BA. crxenKa F.M. Pontani, Fortuna greca di Ungaretti, navto~a 1972, cr. 7-15. 4 0 Pontani, 6.1t. cr. 19, tXEt u1t6'1f11 tou rnv a1toAoyia tOU l:apavtap'l1, Ta Nta rpap.p.ata, I" 1937, cr. 423-4. Ta crxenKa us to PavtO, Nea 4>V.ua, A', 1937, teUX'Il 3 Kat 4, cr. 83 (61tOU Kat '11 EKtill'l1O"'1l tOU PavtOu 1tOU avaq>tpro), oro otK61lou "Duo note su Ungaretti in Grecia", Prospetti, Pci>jl'l1, teUXoC; 28,1972, cr. 53-4.
5 Aev Eivat emO"'llC; op91'! '11 a1tallaKnx:it Ipp~ tOU A. Kapavtrov'l1, tPvC1lDrvWJlleq, B' 1960, cr. 213: «AiXooc; v' aKoAou91'!aet Kallta a1t6 nc; Ka9tEpClijltvec; VEroteptO"ttKtc; crxoA.tC;» ...