This document discusses how myth was used by Nationalist Spain after the Spanish Civil War to justify their victory and consolidate power. It explores how the fascist Falange movement viewed Spanish history as a deviation from an "authentic" origin and aimed to return Spain to this mythical past. The notion of returning to origins through violence and death in order to be reborn was a key part of Falangist ideology. While the fascist appeal to myth promised unity and a return to a lost wholeness, in practice it resulted in the suppression of separatist movements and a consolidation of Franco's authoritarian rule.
Original Description:
Original Title
Labanyi - Jo - Myth and History in the Contemporary Spanish Novel
This document discusses how myth was used by Nationalist Spain after the Spanish Civil War to justify their victory and consolidate power. It explores how the fascist Falange movement viewed Spanish history as a deviation from an "authentic" origin and aimed to return Spain to this mythical past. The notion of returning to origins through violence and death in order to be reborn was a key part of Falangist ideology. While the fascist appeal to myth promised unity and a return to a lost wholeness, in practice it resulted in the suppression of separatist movements and a consolidation of Franco's authoritarian rule.
This document discusses how myth was used by Nationalist Spain after the Spanish Civil War to justify their victory and consolidate power. It explores how the fascist Falange movement viewed Spanish history as a deviation from an "authentic" origin and aimed to return Spain to this mythical past. The notion of returning to origins through violence and death in order to be reborn was a key part of Falangist ideology. While the fascist appeal to myth promised unity and a return to a lost wholeness, in practice it resulted in the suppression of separatist movements and a consolidation of Franco's authoritarian rule.
Myth and History in
the Contemporary
Spanish Novel
jo LABANYI
Seo Lace, Biskbeck
Cavey of Loran
CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS
Cambridge
Naw York New Rochelle Melbourne Sydney
Roo208 481022
Myth and Nationalist Spain
‘An understanding of the role played by myth in provoking the Civil
‘War and consolidating Nationalist victory is essential to an under-
standing ofits use by writers in the postwar period. As in the case of|
fascism in Italy and Germany, the ideology of the Spanish fascist
movement Falange Espafiola was based on the mythical notion that
the nation’s history was an inauthentic deviation from origins.
Fascism would ‘save’ the nation by returning it to its ‘essential
nature’. This mythical view of history was not a borrowing from
Ialian and German fascism, as Spanish fascist thinkers rightly
stressed, but can be traced back to the analysis of Spain's ‘deca-
dence’ undertaken by the so-called 1898 Generation and by Ortega
y Gasset. In En foro al castciono (1895), Unamuno had divided the
‘sea of history” into the ‘superficial waves of change’ and the ‘eternal
tradition’ ~represented by the folk~ lying in its depths. Unamnuno’s
insistence on the need to plunge into the depths of the ocean (the
‘pucblo) reads like a version of the Jungian quest myth in which the
hhero plunges into the depths of the collective unconscious." In his
Hearium expatel (1897), Ganivet likewise divided Spanish history, not
into an ‘above’ and a ‘below’, but into a ‘before’ and an ‘after’,
creating the same mythical dissociation between an inauthentic
history and authentic origins. Ganivet suggested that the nation’s
course since 1492 (the beginning of imperial expansion) had been a
‘mistake’ or ‘deviation’ from its essential ‘territorial spirit’, to which
it must return, His view that the territorial spirit’ had determined,
not what happened in Spanish history, but what should
happened but didn’, makes it clear that his pretence of positivistic
‘geographical determinism is a mask for mythical thinking. In
Meditaciones del Quijote (1914), Ortega would similarly advocate the
need to buen’ the ‘dross of Spain’s historical past in order to recover
35MYTH AND HISTORY
“the primary substance of the race’, ‘the iridescent gem of the Spain
that might have been’
Such ideas enabled the founder of the Falange, José Antonio
Primo de Rivera, to insist ‘we love Spain because we don’t like her’,
ing a rejected historical reality from an ‘authentic’ ‘origi
nal’ Spain, The Falangist intellectual Pedro Lain Entralgo, twisting
ge eye ales
substance is eternity’, The avant-garde writer Giménez Caballero,
the major literary exponent of fascist thought in Spain, made explicit
the equation of history with the Fall by calling José Antonio the
“Agnus Dei qui tolls peccata Hispaniae’. In his book Bipata y Franco
(1938) he would compare Franco's smile to the Virgin's mantle
holding out the promise of redemption; while in an article of 1937 he
Against a besieged Republican Madrid as a biblical Sodom
and ‘whore of Babylon’ paying the price for her sins. His best-
known work Gena de Espate (1932) set out to denounce ‘three
centuries of bastardization’, calling for the ‘cleansing’ ofthe nation
from the ‘drugs’ that had ‘poisoned? its soul, and a return to “the
genital root of the n Franco's sister Pilar would give
characteristically blunt expression to the notion that Nationalist
victory had ‘cured’ Spain from the ‘sicknes: of history when she
declared: ‘Ortega y Gasset diagnosed Spain as invertebrate; my
brother tried to fit her with an orthopaedic corset.’ Just as Mussolini
had said that ‘Today, in Italy, we are not living the time of history
but of myth’, so the Falangist Rafael Garcia Serrano would say in
ggg: ‘We shall create a new mythology, which this time will be
fullbloodedly romantic." Fascism is indeed the ultimate expression of
the Romantic appeal to myth in that it takes literally and puts into
practice the urge to ‘undo’ history and return to origins. The
Romantic longing to recover lost purty finds its political equivalent
in the Comisiones de Depuracion (‘Purification Committees’ set up
in all walks of life after Nationalist victory.s
The notion that Spanish history since the Catholic
gs had
bbeen a long process of decadence led to the conclusion that the
ration must undergo a ‘sacrificial death’ to hasten ‘rebirth’. The
36
MYTH AND NATIONALIST SPAIN
Nationalist ‘myth of the Crusade’ has been savagely demolished by
Herbert Southworth.* Franco himself would betray the reality
behind the myth of a return to spiritual values when he declared
‘Our Crusade is the only struggle in which the rich who went to war
ceame out of it rcher."? The cult of sacrificial death and its corollary
of rebirth is a salient feature of Falangist ideology. The Moroccan
divisions. under Franco's command proclaimed themselves the
‘Bridegrooms of Death’; ther rallying ery *Viva la muerte’ expresses,
the notion that death is the pre-requisite to salvation. In Genio de
Espana, Giménez Caballero asserted that the ‘true, eternal life’ of a
nation is embodied in its dead, going on to demand a ‘resurrection’
of the national soul. The book ends with its author in Nietzschean
fashion heralding the fiery sunset over the Monte de El Pardo in
Madrid - his Mount Tabor’ - as an annunciation of the apocalyptic
battle to come.* The terms ‘youth’, ‘dawn’, ‘spring’ recur through-
‘out Genio de Espata, as throughout Falangist ideology in general. The
words of the Falangist anthem ‘Cara al sol proclaim that the blood
of the fallen heroes will ‘blossom’ in a new ‘spring’. José Antonio
‘would encourag: the ideal of heroic death by insisting that the future
Spain would be built on ‘the blood of our dead’, and that ‘death is an
act of service’ His mystical conception of violence as the prelude to
as ‘half-soliders half-monks’. Franco would dedicate his,
script Raze (whose thesis is the need to return to ‘essential’ racial
virtues) “To the youth of Spain, whose blood paved the way for our
rebirth.'* By ‘rebirth’ José Antonio had in mind a return to
i ‘what Franco meant was a return to purity in the
__sense of puritanism, Despite the Nietzschean streak that remained in
‘Nationalist ideology even after the war - when propaganda was put
in the hands of the Falange-it was the Francoist and official
The tension between the Nietzschean and the classical strands of the
‘modernist appeal to myth come to the surface in the growth and
final emasculation of Spanish fascism.
‘The political ambiguity of the fascist appeal to myth was io fact its
‘main attraction, allowing it to claim that it transcended the divisions
ight and Left, restoring the nation to a lost ‘organic
wholeness’. The emphasis on ‘unity'—which in practice meant the
suppresion of regional separaisfmovements~is entirely in kerping
\
37\,MYTH AND HISTORY.
with the appeal to myth as a source of wholeness. The original
Falange— before its domestication by Franco on his assumiption of
overall command of Nationalist forces in 1987 ~ was, like its original
alian and German counterparts, oppored both to communism and
to capitalism. {1 mobilized Right-wing Spposition to the modifica:
tion of traditional clas structures at the same time as appealing to
the popular notion of millenarian revolt. Not for nothing did the
‘Spanish peasantry divide its allegiance between fascism and anarch-
jam: both movements with a strong millenarian appeal. The Falange
promised to transcend class conflict by uniting employers and
workers in state-controlled ‘vertical syndicate’ (the only part of the
_2riginal Falangist platform that was put into effect under Franco).
‘Its dream was the return to a paternalistic feudalism in which the
people seen as the repository of the nation’s spiritual values
{would be ‘saved” from the divisive evils of progress and returned to
‘their ‘oneness’ with nature. The one concrete demand in Jose
Antonio's political programme was for an agrarian reform that
Would produce ‘a genuine return to Nature, notin the sense of the