CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriffs Office oca: 2010042662 THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL “POR USE AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. ‘Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mug Status: EXCEPT’ CLEAR; DEATH OF — Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: SAUNDERS, J. C. (06562) Date (Time: 10/11/2010 07:42:05, Monday Supervisor: OOD, G. A. (06187) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/13/2010 16:06:37, Wednesday Contact: Reference: Assist Report On October 11, 2010, I responded to 1948 Duckweed Place to backup D/S S. Hills #25117 on a person calling for help call for service. I was the second deputy on scene. As I pulled up D/S Hills met me on the road next to a white male with injuries, The white male was being treated by public safety who had just arrived on scene. There were still possibly vietims in the residence which had not been cleared so D/S Hills and I approached the residence. As we approached I could see a lot of blood on the pathway leading to the steps. There was more blood on the steps, and on the front screen door. I yelled, "Sheriff's Office," and a female voice yelled, "help," from inside the residence. DiS Hills and I entered the residence. As I entered the residence | immediately noticed two people on the floor to my left. A white male who appeared to be dead, and a white female who had serious injuries but was able to communicate, D/S Hills and I continued to check the residence. The door to the right of the front door led to a bedroom. D/S Hills opened the door, and I looked inside, I was able to see a bed and a large dog on each side of the bed. I did not see any signs of anyone in the room, and because the injured white male on the side of the road told us the dogs would bite us we did not enter the room at the time, We continued our check of the residence by sweeping through the kitchen area and closet. The woman yelled for us to check on the baby. She said the baby was in the bedroom with the flower on the door. As we approached the door I noticed a small live bullet in front of the door on the floor. We entered the room and found a white female child in her crib awake, but untouched. We then checked the bedroom to the left of the child's room. No one was inside, As we came back into the front room where the two people were we noticed an additional white male between two couches who also appeared to be dead. After checking the residence we asked public safety to come inside. Public safety came inside and provided first aid to the white female. 1 walked out the front door and met with D/S D. Paniccia #6137, the officer in charge for the shift, who advised information had been obtained a possible suspect lived in a trailer at the back of the property. D/S Padgett #6996, D/S Paniccia, and I walked back to the trailer, a brown/tan single wide trailer in poor condition past the pole barn on the property. We checked the front and rear doors, but both doors were locked, We returned to the driveway. D/S Paniccia assigned me the task of conducting a neighborhood canvass. Teonducted a neighborhood canvass of the homes on Duckweed Place and Wood Duck Road. After completing the neighborhood canvass I turned my notes over to Sgt. W MeKinney #720. I then assisted with sealing off the crime scene with crime scene tape before being relieved. supe Page |CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office coca: 2010042662 ‘THE INFORMATION BPI OW IS CONFIDENTIAL, “FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY, Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Ming Status: EXCEPT Cl EAR; DEATH OF — Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: PADGETT, C. D. (06996) Date / Time: 10/11/2010 07:46:34, Monday Supervisor: CHALKER, 8. W. (06144) Supervisor Review Date Time: 10/11/2010 08:49:47, Monday Contact: Reference: Assisi Report On 10/11/2010, at 0403 hours, I responded to 5487 Wood Duck Ra. in reference to assisting D/S Hills concerning a call of homicide. Upon arrival I was met by Lt. Burke, D/S Paniccia, and D/S Saunders. Lt. Burke advised that several subjects had been shot within the residence and that the exterior perimeter needed to be checked for the possible suspect(s) and then secured in an attempt to preserve all pertinent evidence. At this time myself, D/S Paniccia, and D/S Saunders completed a perimeter check of the property which revealed no sign of the suspect(s) in the area. What appeared to be those of recent tire tracks were observed from the back of the residence which lead to a mobile home at 5510 Squaw Lane. The tire tracks were then observed exiting the property onto Squaw Lane toward Wood Duck Rd. After observations of the tracks were made we approached the residence at 5510 Squaw Lane in an attempt to contact the resident and confirm the suspect(s) was not inside The door of 5510 Squaw Lane was knocked on several times but an answer was not received. ‘The front and rear door were both found to be secured and entry was unable to be made, Another residence near the back of the property was also observed and later investigation revealed it to be that of 5516 Squaw Lane. After concluding our check of the property I relocated back to 5487 Wood Duck Rd. and began securing the perimeter of the crime scene, After the perimeter was secured I remained at the driveway leading into the residence and began a record of the personnel entering and exiting the area, Relief arrived on scene later in the morning and the record log. was assumed by D/S Calaway, with the Reserve's Unit "Quick Response Team". Assistance was then given to D/S Saunders and Sgt. Chalker to confirm perimeter security until being relieved of my duties by Lt. Burke. Personnel recorded by my record log, prior to transfer to D/S Calaway, are as follows: Clay County Fire and Rescue: Lt. Coleman (Engine 13), Lt. Jennings (Rescue 15), Lt. Loock (Rescue 23), and Battalion Chief Blocker. Clay County Sheriff's Office: Capt. Senters and Capt. Gann Lt, Bucci, Lt. Bennet and Lt. Burke Sgt. McKinney and Sgt. Chalker Robbery/Homicide Detectives Singletary, Cotchaleovitch, and Barnes Deputies Padgett, Paniccia, Marvel, Hills, Saunders, and Dangerfield Crime Scene Technicians Monson and Hearth, ‘This case is active/pending at the time of this report. p38 Page |CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Ofte ca: 2010042662 THe INFORMATION BELOW is CONFIDENTIAL FOR OSE'BY AUTHOWZED PERSONNELONLY | 1) 9) (Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE ‘Case Mng Status: EXCEPT'-CLEAR; DEATH OF Occured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: PADGETT, C. D. (06996) Date / Time: 10/11/2010 07:46:34, Monday Supervisor: CHALKER, S. W. (06144) ‘Supervisor Review Date / Times 70/11/2010 08:49:47, Monday Contact: Reference: Assisi Report Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriffs Office oca: 2010042662 #HiE INEORMATION BELOW 1S CONFIDENTIAL < FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mug Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: HILLS, 8. L, (25117) Date Time: 10/11/2010 09:25:39, Monday Supervisor: CHALKER, S. 1. (06144) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/11/2010 10:19:09, Monday Contact: Reference: Assist Report ‘On 10-11-2010 I was dispatched to the area of Duckweed Place and Wood Duck Road in reference to a person calling for help. While en-route dispatched advised that several people had been shot, I arrived at 1948 Duckweed Place and heard a male voice yelling "Help" I then observed a white male, covered in blood, exiting from the bushes next to the rail box. The male was bleeding from his left arm and had a large cut to the back of his head. The mate said his son, Scott, had hit him with a machete and had shot his wife and other son in the house. As I was talking to the male 1 observed a small dark colored SUV leaving Squaw Lane at a high rate of speed. The male said that was his son, Scott, and he was armed with a shotgun, rifle, and a hand gun. The vehicle turned right onto Wood Duck Road from Squaw Lane. The vehicle then turned right onto Muscovy Road from Wood Duck Road. I advised dispatched of the information. I then took up a position behind a large tree where I had a view of the front of the house and the male subject at the road, Rescue arrived and administered first aid to the male at the road. Deputy J. Saunders arrived and we approached the house from the right side. As we approached the house T noticed a large amount of blood on the steps, and on the front screen door. Deputy Saunders yelled "Sheriff's Office" and a female voice yelled” "Help" from in the residence. We entered the residence into the living room. As we entered the residence I noticed two people on the floor to my left ‘The living room floor was covered in blood. The white male appeared to be dead, and a white female was covered in blood, but was talking. Deputy Saunders and I continued to check the residence, The door to the right of the front door led to a bedroom. I then opened the door, and I looked inside. I was able to see a bed and a large dog on each side of the bed. I did not see any signs of anyone in the room, and because the male at the road told us the dogs would bite us ‘we did not enter the room at the time. We continued our check of the residence by sweeping through the kitchen area and closet, As we were clearing the living room, I noticed several spent shell casings under the kitchen table and on the couch. ‘The woman yelled for us to check on the baby. She said the baby was in the bedroom with the flower on the door. As ‘we were making our way to the bedroom we passed the bathroom which was covered in blood. As we approached the door with the flower on it I noticed a small live bullet in front of the door on the floor. We entered the room and found 1 white female child in her crib awake, but uninjured. We then checked the bedroom to the left of the child's room. No one was inside. As we came back into the front living room where the two people were we noticed an additional white male between two couches who also appeared to be dead. After checking the residence we asked Rescue to come inside. Rescue came inside and provided first aid to the white female, As they were tending to her injuries I continued to watch the unsearched bedroom that contained the dogs. The female said she was sleeping and was awoken to shooting in the living room, When she entered the living room her "son" was going otazy. She said he shot her in the back and in opp Page 1CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office coca: 2010042662 ae | THHp INFORMATION BELO Wis CONFIDENTIAL “FOR USEBY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY [| Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mg Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oveured: 10/11/2010 Otfese: MURDER Tnvestigator: HILLS, S.L. 25117) Date/Time: 10/11/2010 09:25:39, Monday Supervisor: CHALKER S. W. (06144) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/11/2010 10:19:08, Monday Contact: Reference: Assis Report the arm. The female said her other son and his friend were the other people that were on the floor shot. Rescue removed the female from the residence out the back door. I continued to provide security on the unsearched bedroom and also provided security to the small child that was in the bedroom. remained in the house until I was relieved by Deputy M. Dangerfield. Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriffs Office oca: 2010042662 ‘THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL FOR USE AY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. 10/11/2010 EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: (Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE. Case Ming Statu Offense: MURDER Investigator: DANGERFIELD, M. G, (00361) Date /Time: 10/11/2010 15:17:23, Monday Supervisor: CHALKER, S. W. (061-44) Supervisor Review Date Time: 10/11/2010 15:41:24, Monday Contact Reference: Assist Report On 10/11/10 at 0549 hours, I responded to 1920 Duckweed Place in reference to a shooting incident. Upon my arrival I met with Sgt. Chalker to obtain my assignment. I was instructed to relieve the Deputy inside the scene and was escorted inside the scene by Lt. Burke, At the front porch, I entered the residence and walked through the living room, around the right side of the island in the kitchen, through the kitchen and into the hallway. I relieved Deputy Hills where he was standing in the hallway. This location was tactically sound in that I could observe one unsecure room off the living room and still observe the bedroom where a sleeping child was located ‘While inside the residence 1 moved several times between the hallway and the kitchen. On the kitchen table I observed several pieces of mail and one document that appeared to be a legal document. I unfolded the document which was an incomplete temporary custody order. I learned that the name of the child sleeping in the bedroom was Marissa and that her father was Ray Kilgore. Ray Kilgore was intending to seek custody of the child while living with a relative ‘After several hours, I was advised that the Department of Children and Family Services had arrived and intended to take custody of the child, Marissa. I was asked to gather some clothing for the child and attempt to locate a car seat. I searched a cabinet in the child's room but did not find any clothing or a diaper bag, I located a brown and pink diaper bag between a chair and the closet in the child's bedroom. I removed approximately 5 shirts and pants from the top drawer of a dresser inside the closet. 1 also removed approximately 5 pairs of white socks. I located a bag of diapers on the floor beside the child's crib. 1 placed the bag of diapers, the clothing and a stuffed animal from the child's erib inside the diaper bag. I used one of the diapers and two wipes to change the diaper of the child while she lay inside the crib, located a car seat in the kitchen. The car seat was sitting on top of a chair in back comer of the room, next to the back window. I took the car seat and the diaper bag out of the residence and handed them to a waiting evidence technician, Louanne Hearth, ID #7404. She in turn gave these items to Lt. E, Calloway, ID # 9508. Before reentering the residence, I used a green chair that was on the porch to prop open the front screen door. I reentered the residence, walking the same way through the living room and kitchen into the child's bedroom. I picked up the child from her crib and placed a blanket from her bed over her head and my shoulder. I exited the residence carrying the child following the same path that I used to enter the residence. I exited the property and carried the child to a protective investigator with the Department of Children and Family Services who was waiting just outside the ‘outer perimeter. ‘The car seat and diaper bag were retrieved from Lt. Calloway’s vehicle by Detective T. Barnes and tured over to the Department of Children and Family Services Protective Investigator I reentered the inner perimeter of the property but did not go back inside the residence. I maintained a post outside the residence on both the front porch and in the yard until I was relieved by Quick Response Team Reserve Unit. spp Page 1CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriffs Office cm: 2010042662 (EAS TRIBINFORATION BELOWIS CONFIDENTIAL FOR USE BY AUT OWUZED PERSONNEL ONLY : Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE ‘Case Mg Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF —— Occured: 10/11/2010 Offenses MURDER Investigator: DANGERFIELD, M. G, (00361) Date (Time: 10/11/2010 15:17:23, Monday Supervisor: CHALKER, S. W. (06144) ‘Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/11/2010 15:41:24, Monday Contact: Reference: Assist Report Once relieved from the inner perimeter, I took up post on the extreme outer perimeter on Wood Duck Rd. near the intersection of the south entrance of Mallard Rd. While at this location I restricted access to Wood Duck Ré to only those residents who lived on Duckweed Place. ‘The following people were given access to Wood Duck Rd. 1. Loren Nelson W/M 05/10/68 - 1914 Duck Weed Place at 1000 hours. 2. Kenneth Gainey W/M 08/29/64 and Shawn Gainey W/M 01/25/91 - 1924 Duck Weed Place at 1115 hours. 3. Charlene Sigmon W/F 12/30/69 - 1924 Duck Weed Place at 1230 hours. At 1232 hours, I was relieved to resume normal patrol Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57, Clay County Sherif’s Office oca: 2010042662 ‘THE INFORMATION BELOW 18 CONFIDENTIAL - FOR USD BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: HEARTH, L. M. (06878) Date (Time: 10/15/2010 13:08:42, Friday Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 10/20/2010 09:59:58, Wednesday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection On 10/11/10 at approximately 04:26 hours, I was dispatched to S487 Wood Duck Road, Middleburg to assist Robbery Homicide in a homicide investigation. Upon arrival I met with Sgt. W. McKenney and D/$ R. Monson (00511) who told me that four individuals had been shot inside of the residence, D/S Monson determined that I would be primary on this call and CST E, Thompson (06554) would be assisting me. ‘The residence is a single story residence located off a dirt road. A large portion of the property is enclosed by a fence and woods. The rear of the property contained a large metal open front shed. A path in the rear of the property led from the main residence to the back of the property where a brown single wide trailer was set up. Upon arrival I was informed that two victims had been transported to the hospital and two white males were dead inside of the residence. A scene walk through of the residence was on hold pending a search warrant. CST Thompson began to take overall photographs of the exterior of the residence, I observed a trail of blood leading from the front sereen door and down the front porch steps to the yard. The trail appeared to extend down the driveway and out to the mailbox. 1 was informed that the father had ran from the house and out to the street. On the right side of the residence I observed a black handle kitchen knife laying on the ground. In the back yard behind the main residence, I observed a pair of yellow gym shorts and a purple hair scrunchie laying on the ground. With assistance from CST Thompson, we proceeded to take measurements of the exterior property. Measurements will be included with an additional supplement. Following the issuance of the search warrant, a scene walk through was conducted inside of the residence. Entry was ‘made through the front door into the living room area. I observed a large amount of blood on the interior and exterior of the front door. Inside the living room area, I observed a large amount of blood on the tile floor and two white males laying on the floor. Victim #1, James Coody was laying on his left side on an area rug in front ofthe living room couch and a brown recliner, Victim #1 was wearing a red shirt and a pair of red,white and black stripped shorts Victim #2, Raymond Kilgore was laying on his stomach between the couch and a chair and ottoman with both arms tucked underneath him. Victim #2 was wearing a pair of dark colored shorts covered with skulls and a black and white muscle shirt, Victim #2 was secluded by the chair and ottoman at this time. A large amount of blood was observed on the floor in the hallway and in the entire bathroom area, The master ‘bedroom located on the right side of the living room contained two dogs and the door was shut. Two more bedrooms ‘were located fo the left of the living room. One bedroom at the end of the hallway appeared to be the babies room and ‘sped Page |CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office Oca: 2010042662 ‘TIE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL -FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: HEARTH, L. M. (06878) Date/Time: 10/15/2010 13:03:42, Friday Supervisor: MONSON, R. G, (00511) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/20/2010 09:59:58, Wednesday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection the second bedroom located to the left was possibly victim #2°s room. No blood was observed in either of these rooms. Following the scene walk through, D/S Monson proceeded to video tape the entire scene. | proceeded to photograph the interior of the residence. Tentered the residence through the back door due to the amount of blood at the front entrance. 1 photographed the kitchen area where I observed drops of blood on the kitchen floor that appeared to lead from the living room area to the back door. I observed two spent shell casings on the kitchen floor. 1 photographed the shell casings. I continued down the hallway where I photographed the hall, bathroom and two back bedrooms. I proceeded to photograph the living room area. The master bedroom was not photographed at this time due to the two dogs secured inside. Upon completion of taking photographs, I began to mark the crime scene with crime scene numbers and identifying evidence to be collected. The following numbers were used outside: 1) possible blood on ground near mailbox 2) possible blood on side of mailbox 3) possible blood drops on ground 4) possible blood drops along the driveway 5) possible blood drops - front yard near front steps 6) possible blood drops - sidewalk to the right of front steps 7) possible blood drops - 2nd step leading up to porch 8) possible blood drops - 3rd step leading up to porch 9) possible blood drops - 4th step leading up to porch 10) possible blood drops - Sth step leading up to porch 11) possible blood drops - porch area 12) possible blood - porch handrail 13) possible blood - exterior of front screen door 14) kitchen knife - side yard 15) purple scrunchie - back yard 16) yellow gym shorts - back yard 17) possible blood drop - back porch in front of back door ‘The following crime scene numbers were used inside of the residence: 18) possible blood drop - carpet inside back door (kitchen) 19) possible blood drops - kitchen floor Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT finted: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office oca: 2010042662 1/10 AREINFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL FOR USP BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. | TED ‘Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceuredt: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: HEARTH, L. M. (06878) Date (Time: 10/15/2010 13:03:42, Friday ‘Supervisor: MONSON, RG. (00511) Supervisor Review Date Time: 10/20/2010 09:59:58, Wednesday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection 20) possible blood drops - kitchen floor 21) possible blood drops - kitchen floor 22) possible blood drops - kitchen floor 23) spent ammo casing - dining room floor under chair 24) possible blood drops - dining room floor 25) possible blood drops - dining room floor 26) spent ammo casing - floor under dining room table 27) bloody floor in hallway 28) bathroom 29) live ammo round - bathroom floor on bathroom rug, 30) live ammo round - hallway in front of baby's bedroom 31) brown recliner chair - living room 32) spent ammo casing - on floor between recliner chair and leather couch 33) spent ammo casing - on floor in front of leather couch near recliner chair 34) spent ammo casing - on blanket on leather couch, 35) spent ammo casing - on seam of leather couch 36) Victim #2 (Raymond Kilgore) 37) Metro PCS cell phone, blue Bic lighter, key ring "R" with vehicle key and handouff key - on top of ottoman 38) Motorola Razor cell phone - on floor underneath ottoman 39) Vietim #1 (lames Coody) 40) front door / wall area 41) baby chair containing blood - in front of kitchen island 42) possible blood on leather chair 43) possible blood on leather ottoman 44) leather couch with comforter 45) area floor rug - beneath victim #1 in front of couch ‘The living room floor was divided into nine grids using crime scene numbers 46 through 54 55) spent ammo casing - underneath leather couch near vietim #2 56) Samsung (TMobile) cell phone (ao battery) - underneath leather couch 57) shotgun pellets (3) - bathroom floor doorway 58) shotgun pellet (1) - bathroom floor 59) shotgun pellet (1) - bathroom floor 60) projectile - on leather couch between seams Page 3CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sherif's Office coca: 2010042662 (17H INFORMATION BELoW1S CONFIDENTIAL FOR USP BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY C000 (Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mg Status: EXCEPTCLEAR; DEATH OF — Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: HEARTH, LM, (06878) Date/Time: 10/15/2010 13:03:42, Friday Supervisor: MONSON, R.G, (00511) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/20/2010 09:59:58, Wednesday Contact: Reference: Bvidence Collection 1 took additional photographs of the crime scene with the crime scene numbers in place, ‘Once the evidence was marked with crime scene number, CST Thompson and I obtained measurements of the interior and exterior scene for completion of diagram at a later time. Measurements will be included with an additional supplement. I proceeded to start collecting all evidence that was marked including biological samples. I used sterile water and cotton tip swabs to collect the biological samples as follows: - I swab of possible blood from ground near mailbox - marker #1 ~ I swab of possible blood from side of mailbox - marker #2 = L swab of possible blood from ground right side of mailbox - marker #3 = 2 swabs of possible blood from drive way - marker #4 (A/B) = 3 swabs of possible blood from lawn - marker #5 (A/B/C) - I swab of possible blood from sidewalk near front porch - marker #6 ~4 swabs of possible blood on porch steps - marker #*s 7- 10 (I swab from each) ~ I swab of possible blood on porch - marker #11 - I swab of possible blood on porch hand rail (right side) - marker #12 = 2 swabs of possible blood on exterior screen door - marker #13 - I swab of possible blood on back porch - marker #17 - I swab of possible blood on rug inside back door - marker #18 4 swabs of possible blood on kitchen floor - marker #s 19 - 22 (1 swab from each) - 2 swabs of possible blood on kitchen floor - marker #24 (A/B) ~ I swab of possible blood on kitchen floor - marker #25 = 2 swabs of possible blood on hallway floor - marker #27 (A/B) = 5 swabs of possible blood inside the bathroom - marker #28 (A-toilet tank, B-seat cover, C-shower wall, D-sink, E-inside door frame) = 2.swabs of possible blood on the recliner chair - marker #31 (A-seat/B-back) = 3 swabs of possible blood on vietim #1 - marker #39 (A-right foot, B-right elbow, C-bottom left foot) = 4 swabs of possible blood on front door/wall area - marker #40 (A-door fratne, B-wall/light switch, C-door, D-wall left of door) = 2 swabs of possible blood on child seat - marker #41 (A-back label, B-plastic part of chair) - I swab of possible blood on brown leather chair arm - marker #42 = 2 swabs of possible blood on brown leather ottoman - marker #43 (A/B) = 3 swabs of possible blood on brown leather couch - marker #44 (A/BIC) = 4 swabs of possible blood on area rug - marker #45 (A/BIC/D) Page 4CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office Oca: 2010042662 a “THB INPORMATION BELOW iS CONFIDENTIAL. FOR USH BY, AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY |) ‘Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OP Oecured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: HEARTH, L. M, (06878) Date / Times 10/15/2010 13:03:42, Friday ‘Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/20/2010 09:59:58, Wednesday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection - 2 swabs of possible blood on living room floor - marker #46 (A/B) ~4 swabs of possible blood on living room floor ~ marker #47 (A/BICID) - 4 swabs of possible blood on living room floor - marker #48 (A/BIC/D) - 4 swabs of possible blood on living room floor - marker #49 (A/BIC/D) = 4 swabs of possible blood on living room floor - marker #50 (A/BIC/D) ~ 2 swabs of possible blood on living room floor - marker #51 (A/B) - 4 swabs of possible blood on living room floor - marker #52 (A/BIC/D) - 4 swabs of possible blood on living room floor - marker #53 (A/B/C/D) - 2 swabs of possible blood on living room floor - marker #54 (A/B) Alll biological evidence collected were packaged seperately and submitted into evidence at the Orange Park Operations Center. - black handle kitchen knife - marker #14 ~ purple scrunchie - marker #15 - pair of yellow gym shorts "SPC Football” - marker #16 - white hand towel with Christmas wreath/blood - marker #19 ~ spent casing with blood, S&B 7.26x25 - marker #23, ~3 spent casings bxn 53 - marker #5 26, 32, 34 ~2 live ammo rounds bxn 53 - marker #5 29 & 30 ~3 spent casing S&B 7.62x25 - marker #5 33, 35, 55 ~ white tank top with blood - marker #31 - Direct TV remote, blue bic lighter, key ring "R" with Chevy key and handouff key - marker #37 - Metro PCS Cellphone (MEID 268435456408027393) - marker #37 - Motorola Razor Cellphone (IMEI 358302010232005) - marker #38 - Samsung (TMobile - no battery) (SN RPTQ9507806) - marker #56 -3 shotgun pellets - marker #57 1 shotgun pellet - marker #58 - I shotgun pellet - marker #59 - | projectile - marker #60 - pillow and baby blanket - marker #49 grid Victim #1 was rolled on to his back and additional photographs were taken. It appeared that he had a wound in his upper right shoulder area and one in his left side. Both wounds were photographed with and without a scale. ‘The chair and ottoman was moved and additional photographs were taken of victim #2. He appeared to have wounds Page 5CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office oca: 2010042662 THE INFORMATION EL OWS CONFIDANTIAG ‘ : ‘Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE. (Case Mg Status: EYCEPTCLEAR; DEATH OP Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: HEARTH, L. M. (06878) Date / Time: 10/15/2010 13:03:42, Friday Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 10/20/2010 09:59:58, Wednesday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection on the upper right side of his back and on the back of his legs. The wounds were photographed with and without a scale, Victim #2 was rolled onto his back and additional photographs were taken. It appeared that he had additional ‘wounds on his stomach area and the upper left hand side of his chest area, These wounds were photographed with and without a scale, North Florida Body Removal was notified. Animal control was notified and responded to have the dogs removed from the master bedroom. ‘The master bedroom ‘was photographed, however the room was in disarray due to the dogs and animal control having to turn over mattress to contain the dogs. A Nokia cell phone and a Samsung (SN RPESB24666A) cell phone were retrieved from the floor that belonged to the parents. Both phones were collected by D/S Monson. Both phones were turned over to me to be submitted into evidence. Crime Scene numbers were place on the following items located in the bedrooms, Items were photographed and collected to be submitted into evidence: -Toshiba Laptop computer (SN 77436182K) with battery, wall charger and Kensington jump drive located in the master bedroom on a desk - marker #61 - homemade drug pipe paraphernalia found on dresser of second bedroom - marker #62 - black zipper bag with rolling papers, rolling machine, metal case and plastic baggy with green leafy shake found on end table near victim #2 - marker #63 All evidence was packaged and submitted into evidence at the Orange Park Operations Center. Photographs were submitted to the Orange Park Crime Lab to be entered into the photo computer. Page 6CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office oon: 2010042662 { “TT INFORMATION BELOW is CONFIDENTIAL “FOR USE BY AUN)IORIZED PERGONNELONLY| Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Occured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Date /Time: 10/16/2010 22:28:03, Saturday tor: THOMPSON, E: D. (06554) Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) Supervisor Review Date/ Time: 10/18/2010 09:04:10, Monday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection On 10/1 1/2010, at approximately 05:22, I was dispatched to 5487 Wood Duck Rd., Middleburg, FL 32068 in regards to a shooting incident. Upon arrival at 06:10, I made contact with Deputy Monson E0511 and CST Hearth E6878, who advised me that two victims had been transported to the hospital and two white males were dead inside the residence, but that an initial walk through of the residence was on stand-by due to a pending search warrant. I was also informed that CST Hearth would be primary on the call and that I would assist her where needed. took overall photographs of the scene. I observed possible blood located on and below the mailbox at the end of the driveway. I photographed this area with and without scale. I also observed what appeared to be a trail of possible blood leading from the road up the driveway toward the residence. Deputy Monson advised that the father of the subject had ran from the house to the mailbox. As I approached the residence, I observed possible blood leading from the front door, down the porch stairs and across the grass possibly leading to the driveway area where I had previously observed possible blood trail. I photographed these areas. As I continued, along the right side of the property line fence and approached the back of the residence, I observed & large shed with an open area toward the front of it.I also observed two vehicles, a dark blue truck near the side of the residence and a tan and gray colored truck near the back of the residence. I observed a black handled knife near the side of the residence and the dark blue truck, and a purple serunchie with a browa/red substance on it and yellow gym shorts near the back of the tan and gray truck, I took overall photographs of the two vehicles. The two vehicles’ information follows: ‘Vehicle on side of residence: Dark Blue Chevrolet Silverado FL Tag: A682BP Vehicle behind residence: ‘Tan and Gray Chevrolet Silverado PL Tag: M882UL, Behind the residence on the left, T observed a path that appeared to have recent tire tracks in the dew on the grass. This path led to the back of the property where a tan and brown single wide trailer was located. I took photographs of this path. 1 then completed overall photographs of the property line and the exterior of the residence and shed. I then proceeded down the path behind the residence leading to the tan and brown trailer. As I walked down this path, I observed another trailer that was blue in color, located just beyond the tan and brown trailer. I took overall photographs of both trailers, as well as the driveways and paths leading up to these trailers. While taking photographs of the tan and brown trailer, I 7 s08 Page |CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Oca: 2010042662 ‘THB INFORMATION BELOW IS| CONFIDENT Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status: ceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: THOMPSON, E. D. (06554) Date (Time: 10/16/2010 22:28:03, Saturday Supervisor: MONSON, RG. (00511) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/18/2010 09:04:10, Monday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection observed a baby’s car seat on the ground near the front door. (**See CST Antoniello’s report for details reagrding the tan and brown trailer) Aiter overall exterior photographs were completed and the search warrant was issued, an initial walk through of the scene was completed. Entry was made through the front door into the living room area. Upon entry, I observed a large amount of possible blood on the interior wall next to the front door, as well as the interior of the front door. I also observed a large amount of possible blood on the tile floor of the living room and hall area leading to two back bedrooms and @ bathroom. Two white male victims were found lying on the floor of the living room. One victim was ‘wearing a red shirt and a pair of white and black plaid shorts (Victim #1). He was lying on his left side on an area rug, next to a light brown reclining chair and in front of a dark brown couch. ‘The other victim (Victim #2) was located to the right side of a dark brown chair and ottoman and the left side of an end table that was sitting next to the couch in this comer of the living room. Victim #2 was found lying on his stomach with his head closest to the wall and his feet lying near the middle of the front of the couch. Victim#2 was wearing a black shirt and dark colored shorts. He had multiple visible tatoos on his arms and legs. The master bedroom was located to the right of the living room with the door shut due to two dogs being contained within the room. The kitchen was located in the area straight across from the front door on the opposite wall. I observed two shell casings lying underneath the kitchen table, as well as what appeared to be possible blood droplets leading to the back door from the hallway/living room area, Just outside the back door, on the back porch, I observed a small droplet of possible blood. CST Hearth marked this area with evidence marker #17 and photographed it. We then e After completion of the initial walk through, Deputy Monson recorded a videotape of the scene. Evidence flags were placed along the driveway and in the grass areas in front of the residence where possible blood was located, After the video, I took photographs of the areas where evidence flags had been placed, as well as the evidence markers being placed by CST Hearth, I took photographs of various areas of possible blood along the trail and in the grass in front of the residence with and without scale. 1 took photographs starting at the ground below the mailbox (evidence marker #1) and the mailbox (evidence marker #2) working my way toward the residence, to include photographs of some possible blood drops on the ground near the entrance of the driveway (evidence marker #3), the trail of possible blood drops along the driveway (evidence marker #4), and the grass in front of the residence (evidence marker #5). As approached the residence, the following evidence markers were used for the areas containing possible blood droplets: 6 - cement sidewalk in front of porch steps 47 - nd step from bottom of porch steps #8 - 3rd step from bottom of porch steps #9 - th step from bottom of porch steps #10- top step of porch steps Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 + 2010042662 Clay County Sheriff's Office "TRE INcDaMaTION peloW IS CONFIDENTIAL FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE ‘Case Ming Statu : EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: THOMPSON, E, D. (06554) Date /Time: 10/16/2010 22:28:03, Saturday Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) ‘Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/18/2010 09:04:10, Monday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection #1 1- front porch floor and green chair #12- porch handrait #13- exterior of the front screen door Photographs were taken of the above listed areas. The handrail, front screen door, and green chair were also photographed with scale. Swabs were collected from the areas of evidence markers #1 - #13. I then assisted CST Hearth in taking measurements of the property and locations of exterior evidence. ("Measurements taken will be attached on additional sheets) I then took photographs of the knife on the ground to the side of the residence (evidence marker #14), as well as the purple scrunchie (evidence marker #15) and the yellow gym shorts (evidence marker #16) located behind the residence behind the tan and gray truck. CST Hearth collected these items for submission into evidence. Before entry into the residence, I tested the area on the back porch (evidence marker #17) for possible blood using phenolpthalein. The tested resulted in a positive for possible blood. This area was then swabbed for DNA. ‘Myself and CST Hearth then made entry into the residence through the back door due to the amount of blood at the front door. CST Hearth photographed the interior of the residence, except for the master bedroom due to the dogs being contained in this room, After photographing the interior, I assisted CST Hearth in placing evidence markers within the residence (**See CST Hearth’s report for the details regarding the evidence markers). I then assisted CST Hearth in taking measurements of the interior of the residence, as well as distances to evidence markers. (**Measurements will be listed on additional sheets) While examining the scene, we observed multiple shell casings in the living room area on the floor and on the couch. A projectile was located, as well as a possible hole from this projectile in the seam of the couch. Unspent rounds were also observed in the hallway and in the bathroom. Upon examination of the two bedrooms located down the hallway, there appeared to be no blood located in these rooms (baby's room and possibly Victim #2°s room). Upon examination of the bathroom, I observed that the interior of the bathroom and its fixtures liad large amounts of possible blood. I observed what appeared to be pellets from a shotgun shell on the floor of the bathroom, these items were marked and photographed. Three cell phones were located within the living room area, one on top of the ottoman, one beneath the ottoman, and the third underneath the couch. These items were collected by CST Hearth, as well as a white tank top with possible blood from the back of the reclining chair, a white hand towel with possible blood near the back door, a TV remote, a Bic lighter, and a set of keys from on top of the ottoman, and a baby blanket and pillow on the living Page 3CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriffs Office coca: 2010042662 ‘THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL, “FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY Case States: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: THOMPSON, E. D. (06554) Date/Time: 10/16/2010 22:28:03, Saturday Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/18/2010 09:04:10, Monday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection room floor near the front door entrance. (**See CST Hearth’s report for details of these items) I then assisted CST Hearth in collecting swabs ofthe areas from the kitchen floor for evidence markers #18-22, #24, and #25. We then swabbed the hallway floor (evidence marker #27), followed by the fixtures and wall of the bathroom (evidence marker #28), We then focused our efforts back to the living room. I assisted CST Hearth in taking swabs of the following areas, as ‘well as photographs of the areas from which the swabs were taken: - Reclining chair (marker #31) = Victim (marker#39) - Front door, door frame, interior wall to left of door (marker##40) = Child seat (marker#41) - Dark brown chair (marker#42) - Dark brown ottoman (marker##43) ~ Dark brown couch (markeri#44) ~ Area rug (matkert45) CST Hearth and I then made a grid of the living room open tile area of the floor where a large amount of possible blood was located. The area was separated into nine grids (evidence markers #46-54). I assisted CST Hearth in taking swabs of these areas, as well as photographs of the specific areas from which the swabs were taken. With the assistance of Deputy Monson, I rolled Victim#1 onto his back. It appeared that Victim#] had an injury to his upper right shoulder and to his left side, CST Hearth took additional photographs with and without scale, ‘The dark brown chair and ottoman were then moved in order to access the area in which Victim#2 was located. CST Hearth took photographs, and then I assisted her in taking measurements of the location of the victim. He appeared to have injuries to the upper right area of his back and the back of his legs. CST Hearth took photographs with and without scale, Deputy Monson then rolled Victim#2 onto his back, Injuries were then observed on the victim's stomach area and upper left torso. He also appeared to have a laceration of some type to his right forearm. CST Hearth photographed these areas with and without scale. After the dogs were removed from the master bedroom by Animal Control, Deputy Monson retrieved two cell phones from the room for submission into evidence. I took overall photographs of the bedroom. Upon entry into the bedroom, I observed possible blood on the floor immediately past the entryway, as well as underneath a side table. These areas of possible blood were in the forms of « dog's foot. These areas of blood were determined to be caused by the dog's, by tracking the blood into the room upon being placed in the room for containment. I also observed that the bedroom was Page 4CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office coca: 2010042662 ‘THEINFORWATION BELOW (5 CONFIDENTIAL ,FORUSEBY AUTHORIZED PERSONNELONLY Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: THOMPSON, E. D. (06554) DateTime: 10/16/2010 22:28:03, Sawrday Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/18/2010 09:04:10, Monday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection in disarray due to Animal Control having to turn over the mattress and frames in order to obtain the dogs. After overall photographs were taken, CST Hearth placed evidence markers on the laptop located on the desk and collected the laptop and its accessories for submission into evidence. Drug paraphernalia was located in the room possibly belonging to Victin#2, as well as on the end table located in the living room. CST Hearth photographed and collected these items for submission into evidence, is Center, Photographs and evidence collected was submitted into Evidence at the Orange Park Operati Page 5CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office oca: 2010042662 THIS INFORMATION BELOW Is CONFIDENTIAL FOR USE AY AUTFIORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY f Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mug Status: EXCEPT CLEAR: DEATH OF ——Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: MONSON, R. G. (00511) Date /Time: 10/18/2010 10:22:05, Monday Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) Supervisor Review Date /Time: 10/18/2010 13:03:45, Monday Contact: Reference: Bvidence Collection On 10-11-2010 at 04:15 hours, I was contacted by communications and told that they had a shooting call and needed a Crime Scene Technician to respond. I was told that there were four victims involved in the shooting and that two were possibly deceased. I was told that the shooting occurred at 5487 Wood Duck ROAD. | instructed the communications center to have CST Hearth, LD. 7404 and CST Thompson, 1.D. 7407, respond to the scene. I responded to 5487 Wood Duck Road and upon arrival I contacted Lt. Bucci and Sgt. McKinney who related what information that they had to me. Lt. Bucci stated, it appeared that a male suspect, Christopher Kilgore had possible shot his mother, father, brother and another unknown white male, I was told at this point we were having to standby for a search warrant, ‘When I had finished talking with Lt. Bucci and Sgt. McKinney, I contacted CST Antoniello, I.D. 7403, and had her responded to assist in the scene processing. Upon the arrival of CST Hearth and CST Thompson I assigned scene responsibilities. | assigned CST Hearth as the primary technician on the scene and CST Thompson as back up to CST Hearth. | assigned CST Antoniello to processes a secondary residence on the property and to assist in the supervision of the scene processing, contacted Lt. Bucci to verify that we could take photographs of the exterior of the residence before a search warrant was obtained and he stated that we could. I directed CST Hearth and CST Thompson to photograph the exterior of the residence and the surrounding property. 1 was contacted by Sgt. McKinney who stated that the search warrant was signed and on scene and we could process the scene, We first conducted a scene walk through. Those present during the scene walk through were Myself, CST Hearth, CST, Thompson, CST Antoniello, and Detective Singletary. Entry was made by way of the front door into the living room, Upon entering the living room I observed a white male victim lying on his left side on a rug in the living room floor in front of a brown chair. | observed a second white male victim lying on his stomach on the floor, between the couch and a second chair. I observed that there was blood on the living room floor, the walls, the hallway and the bathroom, Upon completion of the scene walk through I video recorded the scene starting at the front of the residence ‘on Wood Duck Road. I proceed down the driveway from the road to the residence. I video recorded the residence on the outside and entered the residence by way of the back door. Entry was made through the back door due to the blood evidence present in the front of the residence. I video recorded the interior of the residence and the victims present in the residence. Upon completion of the video recording I instructed CST Hearth and CST Thompson to begin processing the residence. I instructed CST Antoniello to processes a Brown Mobile home that was located at the rear of the property and we were told that this was the suspects residence and a search warrant had also been obtained for tis residence. sump Page |CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sherif’ Office oca: 2010042662 TT a sGi ction Bow 6 CONIDeNTIAL-FOK UsE BY AUGIONZED FERIONNELONLY) Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF —— Oveured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: MONSON, R. G. (00511) 1011812010 10:22:05, Monday Supervisor: MONSON, RG. (00511) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/18/2010 13:03:45, Monday Contact: Reference: Evidence Collection | remained on the scene and supervised the processing of the scene. On 10-12-10 at approximately 1300 hours I responded to 5487 Wood Duck Drive and contacted Sgt. McKinney and Lt. Bucci. Sgt. Mckinney stated, they had obtained a consent to search from the owners of the property and they requested that I return to the residence to search and verify there were no other projectiles in the residence. I entered the residence and searched all the walls and the floor area. No projectiles could be located. I searched all the fu present, top and bottom, No projectiles could be located. Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 2010042662 Clay County Sherif’s Office oc {Tik INFORMATION BELOW8 CONFIDENTIAL FOR USEBY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. (Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF ——Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: SINGLETARY, T. D. (06898) Date / Time: 10/20/2010 07:44:09, Wednesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) ‘Supervisor Review Date / Time: /0/25/2010 10:17:52, Monday Contact: Reference: Follow Up On October 11, 2010, I was notified by Sergeant W. McKinney #6229, Robbery/Homicide Section, that a homicide had Just occurred at 5487 Wood Duck Rd. and that he needed me to respond to assist. He instructed me to obtain the directional information required for the search warrants, While enroute to the scene I pulled up the call notes and discovered that the original caller was Richard Scales and the original address was listed as 1920 Duckweed Pl.. 1 arrived at the scene (5487 Wood Duck Rd.) and met with Sergeant McKinney. Sergeant McKinney and I obtained a preliminary account from Deputy S. L. Hills #25117, who was the first deputy to arrive at the scene, Deputy Hills indicated that when he arrived at the scene he found a white male (Later determined to be a victim, Daulphus L. Kilgore, WM, 12-04-50) standing near the mailbox of the residence, Deputy Hills stated that the male ‘was yelling for help and was injured with blood visible on his body and ground nearby. Deputy Hills stated that Dauiphus Kilgore told him that his son, Scott (Christopher Scott Kilgore) had shot him. Deputy Hills also added that, D. Kilgore told him that a child and his wife were in the house and his wife had also been shot. Deputy Hills stated that Daulphus Kilgore was yelling his wife, a baby and other victims were still inside the residence (5487 Wood Duck Rd,). Deputy Hills stated that while speaking to Daulphus Kilgore he observed a vehicle pull out of Squaw Ln. and turn right (North) onto Wood Duck Rd. Deputy Hills then indicated that he observed the vehicle turn right (East) onto Muscovy Rd... While observing the vehicle Deputy Hills stated that Daulphus Kilgore indicated that the vehicle was his and that the suspect (Christopher Scott Kilgore) was driving it Deputy Hills indicated that when a backup deputy arrived they made a check of the residence. Deputy Hills and another deputy conducted a walk-through of the residence. Deputy Hills indicated that there were two white male victims deceased in the living room area of the residence. He indicated that the white female victim, Judy Griffin Kilgore, WF, 11-03-56, was removed from the residence via the front door. He informed us that Lieutenant Coleman of Clay County Fire Rescue #13 pronounced the two male victims dead at 04:34, While providing the information Deputy Hills also informed us that two dogs were secured in the bedroom at the south end! of the home, in what appeared to be the father's room. Deputy Hills indicated that at least one of the dogs was aggressive. Deputy Hills was advised by Daulphus and Judy Kilgore that one of the victims was their son, (Raymond Lloyd, Kilgore, WM, 03-16-81) and that the suspect was their other son, Christopher Scott Kilgore, WM, 07-06-77. The other victim was a friend of their son Raymond Kilgore and his identity was not currently known. supp Page 1CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office ca: 2010042662 GY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY "THE INFORMATION BELOW 15 CONFIDENTIAL FOR US Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF —— Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: SINGLETARY, T. D. (06898) Date / Time: 10/20/2010 07:44:09, Wednesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 1/25/2010 10:17:52, Monday Contact: Reference: Follow Up Deputy Hills indicated that he and Deputy J. Saunders #6562, searched the outside of the residence were Christopher Scott Kilgore was thought to reside (5510 Squaw Lane). The residence was secure so no entry was made. A child’s car seat was seen in the front yard near the front porch area that appeared out of place. Deputy M. Dangerfield #0363 was assigned to take care of the child that was unharmed but located inside the residence, The child was later released into the custody of Department of Children and Families case worker Kimberly Gowan, I was advised by Sergeant McK inney that Detective T. Cotchaleovitch #6698, was going to be the lead detective in this case and that I should assist him in obtaining the rest of the information for the search warrants. {coordinated with Detective T. Cotchaleovitch on the required information for the search warrant. Detective T. Barnes #6506 and I obtained the address of the suspect's residence at 5510 Squaw Ln. We also obtained the address of an additional residence which belonged to one of the victim's (Raymond Kilgore) 5516 Squaw Ln. This residence is currently rented to Mr. Roger Donald Hadaway, WM, 10-28-44, FI DI, #M300-724-44-3880. Detective Barnes and I provided that information to Detective Cotchaleovitch who then completed the search warrants. Detective T Cotchaleovitch then coordinated with the State Attorney's Office for the required signatures. Arriving deputies were placed in a perimeter around the property. The affected area was cordoned off with crime scene tape. The Clay County Sheriff's Office Crime Scene Units were on the scene processing the area. Crime Scene units processed the front yard and driveway at 5487 Wood Duck Rd, as search warrants were obtained for the residences. I was advised by Sergeant McKinney that I would be accompanying the Crime Scene Technicians as they did a walk-through of the crime scene, T accompanied Deputy R. Monson #0511 of the Crime Scene Unit and Crime Scene Technicians A. Antoniello #6370, L, Hearth #6878 and E. Thompson #6554, into the residence at 5487 Wood Duck Rd. Entry was made through the unlocked front door and each person entering was wearing protective clothing/booties/gloves as required. While conducting the walk-through I observed two white male victims lying in the living room area. I observe the layout of the residence and the positioning of the victims as well as several spent bullet casings. These items, the victims and any of the other articles of evidence were not collected or disturbed during the walk-through process. Upon completion of the crime scene walk-through, I met with Sergeant McKinney and Lieutenant Bucci. I provided them a description of what was observed in the crime scene. The positive identity of the second white male could not Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay Couny Shoris Ofte ca: 2010042662 [THEINEO ATION peLoW is CONFIDENTIAL FOR URE BY AUTORIZED ERSOANEL ONLY Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Cse Ming Sits: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Ocewed: 10/1/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: SINGLETARY, T: D. (06898) Date / Time: 10/20/2010 07:44:09, Wednesday ‘Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/25/2010 10:17:52, Monday Contact: Reference: Follow Up be established at this time due to the crime scene not having been processed and the lack of visual identifying features. | was advised by Sergeant McKinney that he had obtained information that the victim Raymond Kilgore may have possibly been with a white male named James Allen Coody the previous night. He also provided me with another ‘white male nicked named "Chunk" and 2 description of the residence he may live at. went to the described address and determined it to be 5556 County Road 218. I knocked on the door and a white male named Adam Lee McCumbers, WM, 28, 01-05-82, SS# (JJMMEIND 904-925-8625, He indicated that his nick name was "Chunk." I asked Adam McCumbers if he had been with Raymond Kilgore the previous night. Adam MeCumbers indicated that on October 10, 2010, at around 2200 Raymond Kilgore and a young white male came and picked him up at his residence, He stated that he is unsure of exactly what the younger males name was but is aware that he lived in the area of Old Carter Rd. or Bobby Padgett Ré, and County Road 218. He stated that the three of them drove around looking for girls and hanging out until he was brought home at around 0200 on October 11, 2010. ‘Adam MeCumbers stated that he now thinks the white male's name is James Coody but he is not sure. He informed me that Raymond Kilgore was driving his Chevrolet Pick Up truck. I made Sergeant McKinney aware of what Adam McCumbers had informed me of and the possibility that the second victim may be James Coody. I then was advised by Sergeant McKinney that he wanted me to meet with the family members of James Allen Coody. ‘This meeting was in regards to obtaining additional information that could aid in possibly identifying the unknown white male victim, I met with the aunt (Carol S, Brown, WF, 08-05-61) at her residence of 6139 Old Carter Rd, Jacksonville, Fl, 32234 and the father of James Coody (James Allen Coody Sr., WM, 09-23-62, 6084 Bobby Padgett Rd,). I obtained a new photograph and verified that James Coody had been hanging out with Raymond Kilgore over the last few days. I also obtained the name of James Coody's mother (Sherri Rourke, WF, 09-29-63, 11753 Water Bluff Dr. E. Jacksonville, Fl., 32218). I was advised that she was enroute to the address at 6139 Old Carter Rd. | explained to the family that the unknown male victim had not been identified. 1 informed the family that when the unknown victim was identified 1 ‘would respond to the residence and advised them of that information. 1 was informed that James Allen Coody was ‘wearing a red shirt and shorts yesterday, 1 responded to 5487 Wood Duck Rd, I met with Sergeant McKinney and provided him an update of my interaction with the family of James A. Coody. 1 was later advised that the Crime Scene Technicians documenting the scene were able to obtain a driver's license from the rear pocket of the unknown victim. The driver's license was that of James Allen Coody, WM, 08-22-89, FI. DI. #C300-441-89-3020. Page 3CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriffs Office oc: 2010042662 NBORMATION BELOW)8 CONFIDENTIAL “FOR USE DY AU tH ED PERSONNEL ONLY. Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF — Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: SINGLETARY, T. D, (06898) Date / Tim 10/20/2010 07:44:09, Wednesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date Time: 1025/2010 10:17:52, Monday Contats Reference: Foliow Up 1 was advised that based upon the driver's license and the clothing description as well as the physical features to return to the family of James Allen Coody and make the death notification I returned to the address of 6139 Old Carter Rd. and made the death notification to the family members present. This included the father and mother of the victim, I informed them of the process regarding the Medical Examiner and answered any questions that they had regarding the incident that could be answered at the time. ‘After the crime scene was processed by the Crime Scene Units and it was time to move the victims’ bodies Detective ‘T. Cotchaleovitch, Assistant State Attorneys Nelson and Boyle and I, along with Crime Scene Units Monson, Hearth and Thompson entered the residence. ‘The victim Raymond Kilgore was observed to have the following noticeable wounds: three bullet entry wounds to the abdomen, one to the right side upper torso near the right nipple area, several on the left leg. The victim James Allen Coody was observed to have two wounds, one on the upper right collar bone area and one on the lower left rib cage. These could be related due to the positioning with one being an entrance and one an exit. INVESTIGATOR’S NOTE: The exact number of wounds and the type of wounds could not be exactly determined due to the amount of blood and the victim’s clothing not being overly disturbed. The exact location and number of wounds will be determined by the Medical Examiner's Office during the autopsy of each individual. The autopsies were conducted by Dr. Nicolaescu of the Medical Examiner's Office. I completed the Medical Examiner's Report and submitted those reports to the Medical Examiner's Office. (On October 12, 2010, I attended a Homicide Unit briefing at the Clay County Sheriff's Office, Orange Park Sub-Station, located at 212 Blanding Blvd. At that meeting I was provided a copy of the phone records of two phones located in the residence of 5487 Wood Duck Rd., while being processed. Clay County Sheriff's Office employee J.D. Wilson provided me with these records to give to Detective T. Cotchaleovitch. I provided these records to Detective T. Cotchaleovitch on November 19, 2010, for the case file, I submitted a copy into the evidence unit of the records provided me by J.D. Wilson. On October 12, 2010, T attended the autopsies of both James Allen Coody and Raymond Lloyd Kilgore at the Medical Examiner's Office at 2100 Jefferson Ave., Jacksonville, Florida, 32206, The results of the autopsies revealed that the victim James Allen Coody had a single gunshot wound. The victim Raymond Kilgore sustained multiple gunshot wounds Page 4CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office coca: 2010042662 THLE [NPORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL - FOR USP BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY” Case Status: CLEARBD OF PENSE Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF — Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: SINGLETARY, T: D. (06898) Date /Time: 10/20/2010 07:44:09, Wednesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 10/25/2010 10:17:52, Monday Contact Reference: Follow Up INVESTIGATOR’S NOTE: For a complete detailed account of the wounds sustained by each Examiner's report and all photographs obtained. im, it would be necessary to review the Medical After the autopsies were completed, I met with Sergeant W. McKinney and Lt, Bucci to provide them an overview of the results, At that point I was advised to contact Donald L. Messer, WM, 01-23-87, 2070 Mallard Rd., Middleburg, Fl., 32068, 904-282-0456, regarding interviewing him. I met with Donald Messer at his home address. He stated that on October 10, 2010, at around 1230 or 1300, Raymond Kilgore, James Coody and Bonnie Rogers came to his house, He stated that Raymond Kilgore was driving his truck and James Coody was riding with him. He stated that Bonnie Rogers was driving her brown Park Avenue. Donald Messer stated that the three of them were trying to get him to go off with them that night partying. He stated that he told them he could not go because he was helping his father paint. He stated that they left after staying about thirty minutes. Donald Messer stated that he later heard that Raymond and James picked up "Chunk" and they went to Bonnies’ house out in Keystone Heights, Fl. Donald Messer stated that if he had went with them he also would have been at the Kilgore house on the morning of the killings. He stated that he often stays at the Kilgore’s house and sleeps there so often some of his clothes are in Raymond Kilgore's closet. I asked him where Raymond would sleep when he spent the night and he stated that Raymond always slept on the couch when he or anyone other than "one of his girls" stayed the night. While at Donald Messer's house, Bonnie Rogers drove up and I conducted an interview of her at his (Donald Messer’s) house. interviewed Bonnie Ina Rogers, WP, 06-16-88, SSHQEGEEM 5100 Grannys Place, Keystone Heights, Fl. at the home of Donald Messer located at 2070 Mallard Rd., Middleburg, Fl Bonnie Rogers stated that Raymond Kilgore had been staying with her for the last five days. Bonnie Rogers stated that last night she, Raymond Kilgore, James Coody and "Chunk" Adam Lee McCumbers, were at her house in Keystone Heights. She stated that they were drinking and at one point "Chunk" was getting very drunk so Raymond Kilgore said he was going to take him (Chunk) home. She stated that Raymond Kilgore had driven his banged up" Chevrolet truck to her house and James Coody and "Chunk" (Adam MeCumbers) had come with him. She stated that they all left at the same time in Raymond Kilgore’s truck. PagesCASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office oca: 2010042662 ‘THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL - FOR USB BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. (Case Statust CLEARED OF FEI Offense: MURDER Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF} Qveureds 10/11/2010 Investigator: SINGLETARY, T. D. (06898) Date / Time: 10/20/2010 07:44:09, Wednesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) ‘Supervisor Review Date/Time: 10/25/2010 10:17:52, Monday Contact: Reference: Follow Up asked Bonnie how I could verify that Raymond had been at her house last night other that interviewing the individuals listed. She stated that he used his phone to text a female, who she does not know, during the night, She stated that Raymond Kilgore also used her phone to text the female during the night. Bonnie Rogers stated that she and R. Kilgore are just friends and are not in a sexual relationship. She stated that R. Kilgore wanted her to give him money to come back out to her house but she did not have enough to give him. She stated that he was aggravated that she would not give him enough money to drive back to her house. Bonnie Rogers stated that Raymond Kilgore left the house with James Coody and "Chunk" (Adam MeCumbers) at about 2330, She stated that she texted him at about 0030 and he texted back saying he was "OK." She stated that she texted him back saying to him, "Don’t be a dick." She stated that this is the last time she heard from R. Kilgore that night/morning, She added that when she heard that the police were at his house on the morning of October 11, 2010, she texted Raymond Kilgore several times. She indicated that she was texting things like for him not to come home because the cops were looking for him. She stated that he never returned her text so she came out to his house and discovered that he had been killed. Tasked Bonnie Rogers what the sleeping arraignments would be when she stayed the night at the Kilgore’s home, She stated that she often stays at the Kilgore home and when she does Raymond Kilgore sleeps on the couch and she sleeps in his bedroom. During the interview Bonnie Rogers stated that she knew that Raymond's brother (Christopher Scott Kilgore) had stolen some guns from his father. I asked her how she knew that and she indicated that she was at the home visiting Raymond last week when he (Raymond) and his dad (Daulphus) got into an argument over the guns. She stated that Raymond was yelling at his father about why he (Daulphus) let Scott get away with stealing the guns. She stated that the father (Daulphus) was yelling that if he called the cops on him (Scott) the mother (Judy) would be irate. She stated that the father kept yelling that he would get the guns back and that he could not call the police because of the mother (Gudy) 7” BS Bonnie Rogers stated that after she and Raymond left the home he told her; "I am going to beat his (Christopher Scott Kilgore's) ass." also interviewed a friend of Bonnie Rogers, Kathleen Ann Mock, WF, 06-17-88, 4726 Hedge Hog St., Middleburg, Florida, 32068, home phone 904-413-7952. K, Mock indicated that an acquaintance she knows, who was recently arrested for drug possession, Craig Foriner, WM, had also threatened to kill Raymond Kilgore and James Coody. She stated that Craig Fortner thought that Raymond Kilgore and James Coody, along with her and several others (Robbie Page 6CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office Oca: 2010042662 Td RORarON BeLOw I CONFIOENTIAD Von WSENY AUIIONEDMMMOWELONDE SILL Case Status: CLEARED OF PENSE Case. ig Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF —Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: SINGLETARY, T. D. (06898) Date/Time: 10/20/2010 07:44:09, Wednesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: /0/25/2010 10:17:52, Monday Contact: Reference: Follow Up Force, Dustin, and Bubba) were responsible for his (Craig Fortnet) having been arrested for drug possession. On October 13, 2010, I was assigned to assist in perimeter control of an area of interest where Christopher Scott Kilgore had been reported to be contained. On October 14, 2010, at 1500 I was given the keys to the victim's (Judy and Daulphus Kilgore) vehicle (2005, Chevrolet, Trail Blazer, Florida tag #B401EQ, Vin # IGNCS18X35K 101213) which the suspect (Christopher Scott Kilgore) had taken after the incident. The vehicle had been towed to the Clay County Sheriff's Office, Orange Park Sub-Station for processing. The vehicle's keys were retained by Detective T. Cotchaleovitch pending the release of the vehicle back to the owner(s). On October 15, 2010, I attended the funeral of James Allen Coody Jr. at Clay Hill Baptist Church, Middleburg, Fl., 32068. After the funeral I was notified that the suspect (Christopher Scott Kilgore) had been shot and killed by the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office. I was instructed to make the notifications of this information to the next of kin of James Allen Coody Jr. [notified the mother of James Allen Coody Jr., Mrs. Sherti Lynn Rourke, at 1540. I notified the father of James Allen Coody Jr. at 1555. I then notified Detective K. West of this information so that it could be provided to the investigators assigned to the case with the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office. (On October 19, 2010, I was provided with 2 copy (15 pages) of materials from the following web site http/W WW. coolguy.demon.co.uk/handbook/(varying page numbers).htm, I provided these copies to Detective T. Cotchaleovitch for his case file. Case Active Pending, Page 7CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 heriff's Office oa: 2010042662 ALY Clay Count i ee Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COYNE, S. M, (06512) Date / Time: 10/29/2010 14:12:33, Friday Supervisor: COTCHALEOVITCH, J. M. (06353) Supervisor Review Date ‘Time: 1/02/2010 14:54:11, Tuesday : Follow Up Contact: Referen ‘On 10/11/2010 at 0445 hours I was contacted by dispatch and advised to contact Sgt. McKinney. Set. McKinney advised that he needed me to respond to 5487 Wood Duck Rd. Middleburg Fl. in reference to a shooting incident. While enroute, I was diverted to head to Shands Jacksonville to interview the two surviving victims. Upon my arrival at the Hospital I made contact in the Trauma Room and spoke to the staff. I then met with Det. West and began interviewing Daulphus Kilgore who had received a major wound to his left arm. Daulphus Kilgore advised that he had been asleep in his bedroom when he woke to several loud popping noises that he recognized as gunshots. Daulphus Kilgore advised he had been in his room alone and his wife was sleeping in another bedroom with their grandchild (Ray Kilgore’s child) He headed into the hallway and saw his wife confronting his son Christopher "Scott" Kilgore struggling with his wife in the bathroom doorway. He saw Chris shoot his wife with the shotgun as they struggled, his wife collapsed after fleeing toward the living room. He advised that he was surprised that Chris had shot his wife as she was the only person he was close to in the family. Daulphus Kilgore advised that initially Chris Kilgore was reloading the shotgun as he began struggling with him. Daulphus Kilgore advised he continued to struggle with his son and was struck several times with a "machete" type knife. Daulphus Kilgore advised that he was not aware he had been shot until he tried to use his hand and realized that his arm was useless and barely attached to his body. Daulphus advised he might have passed out for a second because he doesn’t know witen he got shot. Daulphus advised that he recognized that he was losing the fight and he decided to run out of the house to try to draw the suspect away from everyone else. Daulphus Kilgore advised that as he left the house he saw his wife covering Ray with her body. Daulphus advised that he began screaming for someone to call the police in the hope of drawing the suspect after him, Daulphus advised he began falling as he tried to run and he was sure that he was going to dic if his son found him and sure that he would bleed to death even if Chris Kilgore did not find him, Daulphus Kilgore stated he saw Chris Kilgore leave the house turn on his wife's trailblazer and then return to the house and he heard more shots, being fired, he then he saw Chris Kilgore walk through the lights of the vehi Daulphus Kilgore advised that he then saw his wife's vehicle drive to the trailer his son lives in and stop there. Daulphus Kilgore advised that he made it to road near his mailbox and he wrote "why Chris?" on the mailbox because he did not want to die without leaving a message for someone to tell who killed thom. Daulphus Kilgore advised that he hid in the ditch when he heard a vehicle coming up because he thought it was Chris driving around looking for him. Daulphus Kilgore advised that when the first deputy arrived he was contacted and he advised that the deputy initially treated him as a suspect. He advised that he believed he was dying at that time and he advised the deputy who had shot hhim and who was in the house. (With his stated belief that he was dying the statement he made to the deputy should be rapes Page 1CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office oca: 201004262 TH oN ATION nELOW W cOMFIDENTAL FON USE AUIIONIZED PERSONNEL ONLY Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mag Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Investigator: COYNE, S. M. (06512) Date/Time: 10/29/2010 14:12:33, Friday Supervisor: COTCHALEOVITCH, J. M, (06353) 1112/2010 14:54:11, Tuesday : Follow Up Contact: viewed as a dying declaration even though he did not die.) Daulphus Kilgore advised that he told the deputy that his wife was wounded in the house and that he believed that his son was dead in house. He advised that he told the deputy that his infant granddaughter was inside the residence still. The deputy stayed there with him and did not approach the house. While they were there he heard a vehicle go by which he thought sounded like the trailblazer. Daulphus Kilgore advised that he was transported away by rescue, Daulphus Kilgore was asked several times if he knew who the second white male that had been sleeping in the living room was and he advised he had no idea as the person must have come in after he went to bed. Daulphus Kilgore was asked for consent to search the residence and property for evidence related to the murder. Mr. Kilgore gave consent for the search, advising that it did not matter what was found in the residence because the shooting would finish his job at the base anyway. Daulphus Kilgore advised that the shotgun he saw Chris using was his that had been stolen earlier in the week and that it had been cut off, He advised he had never seen the machete before. He advised he did not see his other guns that had been taken but he recognized the shooting noise that had awoken him as being from his pistol. Dalphus Kilgore provided identifying information on the three guns that were missing which included where he had bought them. This information was forwarded to the detectives on scene at the Kilgore house, Mr. Kilgore advised he ‘was missing a 12 gauge pump shotgun, a rifle that fired 7.62 bullets and pistol that fires 7.62 bullets. The rifle and pistol were of foreign manufacture. Mr. Kilgore advised thatthe rifle and pistol both used an unusual make of ammunition, and that he had only had 10-12 rounds of 12 gauge ammunition of mixed size and brand. Daulphus Kilgore was taken to surgery where surgeons attempted to reattach his arm and repair the damage. We then made contact with Judy Kilgore who had been shot in the side; she was stable and was not expected to need immediate surgery. Judy Kilgore advised that she woke up to hearing shots being fired in the living room area. She ran out of the bedroom she had been sleeping in leaving Ray's infant daughter behind from the hallway she saw Chris backing info the bathroom with a shotgun in his hands. She advised that she saw that Ray had been shot and she feared that Chris was trying to get to Ray's child. Judy Kilgore stated that she did not believe he would shoot her as she was the only one that he ever cared for in the family. Judy Kilgore advised that as she struggled with her son she heard her husband approaching, Judy Kilgore advised that as her husband joined her she was shot; she ran towards the living room and covered Ray. She advised that while she crawled to the phone she heard another shot but she is not sure who was being shot at, She advised that she did not see Chris shoot anyone else. Page2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office oca: 2010042662 E ‘TUE INFORMATION Below 1s CONFIDENTIAL - POR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY, Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COYNE, S. M, (06512) Date Time: 10/29/2010 14:12:33, Friday Supervisor: COTCHALEOVITCH, J. M. (06353) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 1/02/2010 14:54:11, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up Judy Kilgore advised she spoke to Chris the day before when he needed cigarettes; she advised that Chris had never gotten along with Ray or her husband. She advised that at the time she saw him he was acting normal for Chris. She described her son as a loner, advising that he did not get along with people, and had a hard time working because of his poor people skills. Judy Kilgore described Chris as sullen, quiet, moody and abrupt. Judy Kilgore advised that the last major issue she knew of was an argument about the usage of the computer. She advised that this occurred about a week prior and that her husband's guns were taken, they believed by Chris right after this argument. Judy Kilgore advised that her son Chris had no bank account, no money and no access to any money that she was aware of, she further advised that Chris had no friends and no one he was close to, Judy Kilgore advised that her son ‘was a recluse, and that there was no one in the family he could go to for help. Judy Kilgore advised that she knew of rno where he would go; she had no knowledge of him having any resources beyond her vehicle which was on empty when he took it. She advised that Chris drank and took his prescription Xanex but that she was unaware of any other drug usage. She advised that she knew of no reason that Chris would have to shoot Ray or his friend. Judy Kilgore advised that she only knew the other young man as James. Judy Kilgore could not advise any other identifying information about James, Judy Kilgore provided the following description of the clothing she had seen Chris wearing atthe time of the incident, a black T-shirt, dark long pants. She further advised that he had a short hair cut and was clean shaven. Judy Kilgore advised that she did not recognize the shotgun that Chris was using and she did not see any other ‘weapons. Judy Kilgore advised that her husband had told her that Chris had a knife but she had not seen it. Norma and Lloyd Griffen Sr. arrived at the hospital and were allowed in to the trauma room to visit with their daughter Judy. Several interviews were conducted through the day in an attempt to get more information for the detectives on scene, especially on possible areas to check for the suspect. The Kilgore’s remained consistent in the accounts of what had occurred, Mr. And Mrs. Kilgore were unable to give any information on where the suspect might be hiding or where hhe might be enroute to Security for the victim’s was arranged with the Shands Jacksonville Security Director. The victim's were lodged in the same room and were removed from the patient listings. Page 3CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office Oca: 2010042662 Og LOWE CONTOTAL Ok SUN AMON (Case Statust CLEARED OP PENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COYNE, S. M, (06512) Date / Time: 10/29/2010 14:12:33, Friday Supervisor: COTCHALBOVITCH, J. M. (06353) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 11/02/2010 14:54:11, Tuesday Contacts Reference: Follow Up ‘On 10/12/2010, Detective West and I met with Mr. And Mrs. Kilgore again, provided them with an update and ‘obtained permission for their residence to be reentered to secure day time photographs of the scene. The Kilgores were initially suspicious of why we would need to reenter the residence after having served a search warrant on the day of the incident, Specifically Mr. Kilgore advised he felt that we might somehow be trying to make this his fault, After asking some questions the Kilgores agreed to allow the entry. On 10/13/2010 the Chevy Trailblazer was recovered in Jacksonville and I was assigned to obtain consent from the Kilgores to move the vehicle back to Clay County from the recovery site. I made contact with Dalphus Kilgore and obtained his consent to tow the vehicle back to Clay County and search it for evidence related to the murders of Ray Kilgore and James Coody. | then relocated to the Orange Park Substation and supervised the search of the vehicle by CST Antoniello, See CST Antoneillo's report for the details of the items collected. On 10/15/2010 I was assigned to make contact with the family and advise them of the death of the suspect, Christopher Scott Kilgore, I made contact with Daulphus Kilgore at Shands Hospital and notified him of his son’s death at 1552 hours. Thad no further involvement with this case. Case remains assigned to Det. T.. Cotchaleoviteh, Page 4CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 oca: 2010042662 TH INFORMATION BELOW (8 CONFIDENTIAL;- FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY (Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mug Status: EXCEPT CLEAR: DEATH OF —— Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: WEST, K. &, (06113) Date / Time: 10/31/2010 10:53:27, Sunday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 11/09/2010 15:57:06, Tuesday Contact: Kilgore, Raymond Loyd Reference: Follow Up 5487 Woodduck Rd, Middleburg On 10/11/2010 at 0445 hours I was contacted by dispatch and advised to contact Sgt. McKinney by phone. I contacted Sgt. McKinney who advised me to respond to 5487 Wood Duck Rd Middleburg, Florida in reference to a homi investigation. While enroute, Sgt. McKinney contacted me and requested me to respond to the Shands Hospital located in Jacksonville, Florida. Sgt. McKinney advised me that two victims were transported to the Shands Hospital due to being shot during this incident. Sgt. MeK inney provided the victims name of Daulphus and Judy Kilgore. He advised the vietims were shot by there son Christopher Kilgore. He also advised Christopher Kilgore had shot and killer his brother Raymond Kilgore and an unknown white male who was present during this ineident. Sgt. McKinney requested me to interview Mr. and Mrs. Kilgore upon arrival in an attempt to gain details of this incident. Upon my arrival atthe Hospital I made contact in the Trauma Room with the Medical Staff. They provided me with the location of Mr. Kilgore and advised his injuries were not life threatening, I observed Mr. Kilgore lying on a hospital bed talking with the Medical staff. I walked over to Mr. Kilgore and introduced myself. I then asked Mr. Kilgore if he felt like explaining what had happened this morning at his residence and he said "Yes". During this time I observed Mr. Kilgore had been shot in his left forearm. I could tell by the appearance of his injury that his forearm was broken and had a large amount of trauma. asked Mr. Kilgore what happened at his residence this morning and he provided the following account. Mr. Kilgore said he went to bed on the evening of 10/10/2010 around 2300 hours at which time his oldest son Christopher "Seott” Kilgore was watching television in the family room of the residence. He said he does not get along with "Scott" so he did not speak to him, He said he woke to sounds of fire crackers. He said he soon realized the noise he had heard was his pistol being fired. He said he owns a pistol that has a distinct sound when itis fired. Mr. Kilgore said he exited his bedroom and observed his wife Judy in a physical struggle with his son "Scott", He said he noticed Scott had a shotgun in his hand which they were struggling over. He said as he approached, they entered the bathroom and continued to fight. He said that’s when he observed Scott point the shotgun at Judy and pull the trigger shooting her in the upper torso area. He said his wife exited the bathroom and crawled towards the living room area. He said he then grabbed Scott and began to struggle with him as he attempted to re-load the shotgun, He said he pushed Soott backwards causing him to fall backwards towards the bath tub, He said that’s when he was struck in the head with what he described as a machete, He said as he was being struck he attempted to grab Scott with his left hand but discovered his, arm would not move. He said he realized he had been shot and was bleeding profusely from his arm and retreated from the bathroom. He said he figured Scott would follow him so he ran out of the residence through the front door. He said as he was exiting the residence he observed his wife Judy lying on top of his youngest son Raymond Kilgore. He said he noticed Raymond appeared dead due to being shot numerous times. He said he also noticed another person lying on the floor who had also been shot. He said this person was Raymond's friend but could not remember his name, Daulphus advised that he began screaming for someone to call the police in the hope of drawing the suspect after him, Daulphus advised he began falling as he tried to run and he was sure that he was going to dice if his son found him, He also said he was sure he would bleed to death even if Chris Kilgore did not find him, Daulphus Kilgore stated apps Page 1CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay Couny Sheris offer _ oca: 2010042662 ‘i INFORMATION DELOWS CONFIDENTIAL - OR USE BY AUTHTORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY: Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF —— Oeeured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: WEST, K. E. (06113) Date/Time: 10/31/2010 10:53:27, Sunday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) ime: 11/09/2010 15:57:06, Tuesday Contact: Kilgore, Raymond Loyd Reference: Fallow Up 5487 Woodduck Rd, Middleburg he saw Chris Kilgore leave the house and turn on his wife's Chevy Trailblazer and then return to the house, He said he then heard more shots being fired believing Scott was finishing off his family. He said he then saw Chris Kilgore walk through the lights of the vehicle. Daulphus Kilgore advised that he then saw his wife's Chevy Trailblazer drive to the trailer his son lives in and stop. Daulphus Kilgore advised that he made it to the road near his mailbox and he wrote "why Chris?" on the mailbox because he did not want to die without leaving a message for someone to know who killed them, Daulphus Kilgore advised that he hid in the ditch because he heard a vehicle coming believing it was Scott. Daulphus Kilgore advised that when the first deputy arrived he was contacted and he advised that the Deputy initially treated him as a suspect. He advised that he believed he was dying at that time and he advised the Deputy that Scott had shot him and who was in the house. Daulphus Kilgore advised that he told the deputy that his wife was wounded in the house and that he believed that his son was dead also. He advised that he told the Deputy that his infant ‘granddaughter was inside the residence as well. He said the Deputy stayed there with him and did not approach the house, While they were there he heard a vehicle go by which he thought sounded like his wife's Chevy Blazer. He said he told the Deputy present that the vehicle he heard was his wife's vehicle and that it was occupied by his son Scott Kilgore. He said he also told the Deputy that the operator of this vehicle was the person who had shot him, asked Mr. Daulphus Kilgore several times if he knew who the second white male that had been sleeping in the living room was and he advised he had no idea as the person must have come in after he went to bed. He said the person was Ray's friend and he had been at the house several times but he could not remember his name. asked Mr. Daulphus Kilgore if he would give consent to search the residence and property for evidence related to the murder. Mr. Kilgore gave consent for the search, advising that it did not matter what was found in the residence because the shooting would finish his job at the base anyway. Daulphus Kilgore advised that the shotgun he saw Chris using was his that had been stolen earlier in the week and that it had been cut off. He advised he had never seen the machete before. He advised he did not see his other guns that had been taken but he recognized the noise from the first gun as his pistol. Mr. Kilgore advised he knew his son Scott had taken the guns several days earlier but had not confronted him about them. He said he knew he would get them back at a later date. He said "I never thought Scott would do such a thing to his family", Mr. Kilgore repeatedly said "Scott needs to die because he had killed his good son", He said "Scott would kill himself or he will make the Police do it". Mr. Dalphus Kilgore provided identifying information on the three guns that were missing which included where he had bought them, This information was forwarded to the detectives on scene at the Kilgore house, At this time Mr. Daulphus Kilgore was taken to surgery where surgeons attempted to reattach his arm and repair the Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriffs Office THGINFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF ——Oceured: 10/11/2010 (Offense: MURDER Investigator: WEST, K. B, (06113) Date / Time: 10/31/2010 10:53:27, Sunday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 1/09/2010 15:57:06, Tuesday Contact: Kilgore, Raymond Loyd Reference: Fallow Up ‘5487 Woodduck Rd, Middleburg damage. Detective S. Coyne and I then made contact with Judy Kilgore who had been shot in the left side and left arm. She was stable and was not expected to need immediate surgery. Judy Kilgore advised that she woke up to hearing shots being fired in the living room area. She ran out of the bedroom she had been sleeping in leaving Ray's infant daughter in the bedroom. She said from the hallway she saw her son Christopher "Scott" Kilgore backing into the bathroom with a shotgun in his hands. She advised that she saw that Ray had been shot and she feared that Scott was trying to get to Ray's child. Judy Kilgore stated that she did not believe he would shoot her as she was the only one that he ever cared for in the family. Judy Kilgore advised she began yelling at Scott "what are you doing” and then grabbed the gun he was holding and bogan struggled with him, She said her husband approached them and began to help her pushing them inside the bathroom. She said at that point Scott shot her with the shotgun. She said she ran towards the living room and fell on top of Ray to shield him. She advised that while she crawled to the phone she heard another shot but she is not sure who was being shot. She advised that she did not see Scott shoot anyone else. Judy Kilgore advised she spoke to Scott the day before when he needed cigarettes; she advised that Scott had never gotten along with Ray or her husband. She advised that at the time she saw him he was acting normal. She described her son as a loner, advising that he did not get along with people, and had a hard time working because of his poor people skills. Judy Kilgore described Scott as quiet, moody and abrupt. Judy Kilgore advised that the last major issue she knew of was an argument about the usage of the computer. She advised that this occurred about a week prior and that’s when her husband's guns were taken. She said they believed Scott had taken the guns right after this argument. Judy Kilgore advised that her son Scott had no bank account, no money and no access to any money that she was aware of. She further advised that Scott had no friends and no one he was close to. Judy Kilgore advised that her son was @ recluse, and that there was no one in the family he could go to for help. Judy Kilgore advised that she knew of no ‘where he would go; she had no knowledge of him having any resources beyond her vehicle which was on empty when he took it. She advised that Scott drank and took his prescription Xanex but that she was unaware of any other drug usage. She advised that she knew of no reason that Scott would have to shoot Ray or his friend. Judy Kilgore advised that she onily knew the other young man as James. Judy Kilgore could not advise any other identifying information about James. Judy Kilgore provided the following description of the clothing she had seen Scott wearing at the time of the incident, ablack T-shirt, dark long pants. She further advised that he had a short hair cut and was clean shaven. She advised that Page 3CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sherif’ Office coca: 2010042662 “RI NRG TOMBE OWN 1S CONIDIA OKONH DY AUTHORIZED PRSONNEL ONLY e Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF} Oceured: 10/11/2010 Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Offense: MURDER 10/31/2010 10:53:27, Sunday Investigator: WEST, K. B, (06113) Date /Tim Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 71/09/2010 15:57:06, Tuesday ‘Contact: Kilgore, Raymond Loyd Reference: Follow Up 5487 Woodduck Rd, Middleburg she did not recognize the shotgun that Chris was using and she did not see any other weapons. Judy Kilgore advised that her husband had told her that Chris had a knife but she had not seen it, Mr. Lloyd and Norma Griffin Sr. and several family members arrived at the hospital and were allowed in to the trauma room to visit with their daughter Judy and Mr. Kilgore, Several interviews were conducted throughout the day in an attempt to get more information for the detectives on scene. These interviews consisted of possible areas to check for Scott. The Kilgore’s remained consistent in the accounts of what had occurred, Mr. and Mrs. Kilgore were unable to give any information on where the suspect might be hiding or where he might be going. Security for the victim's was arranged with the Shands Jacksonville Security Director. The vietim’s were placed in the same room and were removed from the patient listings. On 10/12/2010, Detective West and I met with Mr. And Mrs. Kilgore again, provided them with an update and obtained permission for their residence to be reentered to secure day time photographs of the scene. The Kilgore's ‘were initially suspicious of why we would need to re-enter the residence after having served a search warrant on the day of the incident. Specifically Mr. Kilgore advised he felt that we might somehow be trying to make this his fault. ‘After asking some questions the Kilgore’s agreed to allow the entry. ‘On 10/12/2010 I responded to the Chevron on Yellow Water Road in Jacksonville, Florida due to it being robbed. The suspect in this robbery was identified as Christopher Scott Kilgore after reviewing the business CCTV. Scott was also identified by the blue Chevy Blazer he was driving during the robbery. The area of Yellow Water road was searched for Scott but he was not located. On 10/13/2010 the Kilgore's Chevy Blazer was recovered in the area of Normandy Blvd in Jacksonville, Florida near the area Scott Kilgore had been hiding. This location was also several miles from where the robbery took place. It was determined by a witness who confronted Scott Kilgore al the vehicle that the vehicle had run out of gas. The vehicle was recovered and towed to the Clay County Sheriff's Office for processing. For several days I was assigned to the area Scott Kilgore was last seen in an attempted to detain him in the area. On 10/15/2010 I responded to an Officer involved shoot in the area of Normandy Blvd and County Road 217. Upon arrival I spoke with Detective Stooky with the Jacksonville, Sheriff's Office Homicide Unit. He escorted Detective E. Twisdale and me into their scene. Detective E. Twisdale positively identified the person involved in the shooting as Christopher Scott Kilgore who was deceased, I then contacted Detective S. Coyne to make notification to Mr. and Mrs, Page 4CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:57 Clay County Sheriff's Office oca: 2010042662 e 77 ea INFORMATION BELOW is CONFIDENTIAL “FOR USI BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONL as | Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE ‘Case Ming Status: EXCEPT-CLEAR; DEATH OF —— Occured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER 1 WEST, K. E, (06113) Date /Time: 10/31/2010 10:53:27, Sunday 1 MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/09/2010 15:57:06, Tuesday t: Kilgore, Raymond Loyd Reference: Follow Up 5487 Woodduck Rd, Middleburg Kilgore that their son Christopher Scott Kilgore hiad been fatally shot by Police. Thad no other contact with this investigation. ‘This case is pending, Page 5CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sherif's Office Oca: 2010042662 Te THe INRA TiON aL OW IS CONFIDENTIAL FoR USE. BY AUTIORIZEDIPERSONNEL ONLY! +} EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mng Stat Offense: MURDER Investigator: ANTONIBLLO, A. L. (06370) Date /Times 11/08/2010 16:10:55, Monday Supervisor: MONSON, R. G. (00511) ‘Supervisor Review Date /Time: 11/10/2010 06:40:51, Wednesday Contact: Reference: Bvidence Collection (On 11/08/2010 at approximately 15:30, I was contacted by Detective T. Cotchaleovitch E6698 who told me that he was in possession of three firearms related to this case. Det. Cotchaleovitch asked me to take photographs of the firearms. 1 took digital photographs of the following three firearms: X53 pistol; SN: K05709, 7.62x54R rifle; SN: 9130123640; model: 3346; and a Charles Daly shotgun; SN: 7502698. The firearms were then submitted to evidence by Det. Cotchaleovitch, All photographs taken were submitted to evidence at the Orange Park Operations Center. sums Page 1CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriff's Office cm: 2010042662 : ‘TIE INFORMATION BELOW isl CONFIDENTIAL | FOR|USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. Case Status: CLEARED OF PENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF ——Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T: R. (06698) Date /Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday ‘Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up 10-11-10 0352 hours: A911 call was received from Richard Scales stating he heard gunshots from the area of 5487 Wood Duck Road. R. Scales stated he also heard a male yelling. R. Scales further stated he could see a blue SUV leaving the Kilgore’s residence. An additional 911 call was then received from Judy Kilgore advising four people were shot inside the residence of 5487 Wood Duck Road. 0353 hours: D/S Hills #25117 and additional Deputies were dispatched to the scene. 0401 hours: D/S Hills arrived in the area of Muscovy Road and Wood Duck Road. D/S Hills made contact with Dauiphus Kilgore who was at the end of the driveway of 5487 Wood Duck Road. D. Kilgore had a gunshot wound to his left am. D. Kilgore provided D/S Hills with the suspect's information (Christopher Scott Kilgore) which D/S Hills relayed to dispatch and the other en route units. Public safety responded to the scene and transported Judy Kilgore and Daulphus Kilgore to Shands in Jacksonville, Raymond Kilgore and James Coody (whose identities were still unknown at that time) were both pronounced dead at the scene. Numerous additional units responded to the area and began searching for the suspect. (0445 hours: I was contacted by dispatch and advised to respond to 5487 Wood Duck Road, which is within Clay County, in reference to a person shot call (0543 hours: I arrived on scene and was advised by Sgt. McKinney #720 that two white male subjects were located inside of 5487 Wood Duck Road who were deceased from gunshot wounds. Two other subjects had been transported to Shands Hospital in Jacksonville with life threatening gunshot wounds. ‘The suspect was identified as Christopher Scott Kilgore, who resides in the trailer located behind the residence at 5487 Wood Duck Road. ‘The suspect was identified by the two surviving victims (Judy and Daulphus Kilgore) who are the suspect’s parents, The suspect fled the scene in a blue Chevy Blazer which belongs to Judy Kilgore and had not been located. The suspect drove to his residence prior to leaving the scene according Daulphus Kilgore. 1 was advised that an 18 month old child named Marissa Kilgore was also inside the residence and that she was unharmed, DCF was contacted prior to my arrival and ‘was responding to assist in placing the child in the custody of another family member. 1 was also advised that two dogs ‘were contained in the master bedroom of the residence, I was advised that I would be the lead detective on this case. I was advised to obtain a search warrant for the residences of $487 Wood Duck Road, and 5510 Squaw Lane. I was advised to obtain an arrest warrant for Christopher rans Page 1CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriff's Office _ oca: 2010042662 TEE INFORMATION BELOW 1S CONFIDENTIAL - FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONN iy Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF — Oveured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C, (06229) ‘Supervisor Review Date / Tim Date /Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up Scott Kilgore. ‘On arriving on scene I observed the residence of 5487 Wood Duck Road was secured with crime scene tape. Wood Duck Road is an unpaved road which runs north and south between Muscovy Road and Mallard Road. On traveling south on Wood Duck Road from Muscovy Road 5487 Wood Duck Road is on the left (east) side of the road, and is the first residence south of Squaw Lane. I observed a metal chain length fence separating the residence from Wood Duck Road. An unpaved driveway led to the residence which has a gate that opens inward. The main residence was located to the north of the driveway. A metal mailbox on a wooden pole which was marked 5487 in black marker was on the north side of the driveway. I observed what appeared to be blood on the metal mailbox, as well as blood drops on the ‘ground around the mailbox. I observed the residence to have white siding with brown trim. A set of steps led to the front doorway, which faces Wood Duck Road. A small American flag hung from the front porch area, I then proceeded to Squaw Lane and traveled east on Squaw Lane from Wood Duck Road. T observed an unmarked driveway which led south from Squaw Lane to the residence of 5510 Squaw Lane. The main residence at this location is a brown single wide trailer with brown trim, The residence is not visible from the roadway. The residence is directly behind 5487 Wood Duck Road, and the driveway for 5487 Wood Duck Road connects to the driveway of 5510 Squaw Lane. Detective West #8409 and Detective Coyne #8404 responded to Shands and conducted interviews of Daulphus and Judy Kilgore. I made contact by phone with Det. West who advised both Daulphus and Judy Kilgore stated their son Christopher Kilgore was the suspect in this case. Judy Kilgore stated she was sleeping in the rear bedroom of the residence with her grand daughter Marrissa. Judy was awoke heating gunshots in the residence. On exiting the room Judy observed Christopher backing into the bathroom holding a shotgun. Judy began struggling with Christopher for the gun at which time Daulphus arrived to help her. Christopher then shot her at which time she ran into the living room before falling on the floor, Judy observed her son Raymond and the second vietim whom she knew only as James lying on the floor. Both Raymond and James appeared to be dead from gunshot wounds, Det, West also advised me of the information which Daulphus Kilgore provided. Daulphus stated he was sleeping in the master bedroom alone. He was awoken by gunshots inside the residence at which time he exited his room into the living room, Daulphus observed Judy confronting Christopher at the entrance to the bathroom. Christopher then shot Judy with the shotgun. Daulphus began fighting with Christopher as Christopher attempted to chamber a round in the shotgun, Christopher then struck Daulphus in the head multiple times with a machete. During the struggle Christopher shot Daulphus in the left arm with the shotgun. Daulphus ran from the residence to the end of the driveway on Wood Duck Road, Daulphus then observed Christopher enter Judy's blue Chevy Blazer and drive along the connected driveway to 5510 Sqauw Lane (Christopher's residence). Due to his belief that he would die from his injuries Daulphus attempted to write "why Chris?" on the mailbox in his blood so as to identify Christopher as the suspect. Page 2CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriff's Office cca: 2010042662 fae THIF INFORVATION BELOW 16 CONFIDENTIAL -FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF — Oveured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITOH, T. R. (06698) Date /Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday sor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday : Follow Up Supe Contact: Referenc Based on the known information, to include the statements provided by Judy and Daulphus Kilgore, I completed the search warrants and the arrest warrant and responded to the Clay County Courthouse. I made contact with Assistant State Attorney's Jamess Boyle and Steve Nelson and reviewed the warrants with them. The warrants were signed by Judge Skinner. The arrest warrant was for two counts of murder and two counts of attempted murder. There was no bond for the arrest warrant, The arrest warrant was taken to the warrants section and entered into NCIC. 1145 hours: I returned to $487 Wood Duck Road with the search warrants at which time the Civilian Evidence ‘Technicians entered into the yard of the residence and began processing the scene. Sgt. McKinney, Det. Barnes #8405 and I proceeded to 5510 Squaw Lane to serve the search warrant and secure the residence for crime scene personnel. After knocking on both the front and rear doors of the residence and announcing "Sheriff's Office search warrant" numerous times forced entry was made through the front door of the residence. The residence was cleared at which time crime scene personnel responded to the residence and began processing the scene for usable evidence. remained on scene while the two residences were processed for usable evidence, 1 was advised of a hand written letter which was located in a garbage bag inside of $510 Squaw Lane. The letter was written on yellow paper with a black marker. The letter reads as follows: "Ray love you baby with all my heart, I miss you so much. Pm sorry this shit. happened. All I want you to do is please always be here for me. tl be home soon Hove you" At approximately 1400 hours I was contacted by Sgt. McKinney and advised that a female subject named Ashley Grancham, W/F 07-08-92, had contacted dispatch advising she was with the suspect earlier in the day. I contacted Ashley by phone at 404-641-3881 and obtained the following information from her. Ashley stated that on the night of 10-10-10 at approximately 2300 hours Raymond Kilgore and another male whom she Page 3CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriffs Office oa: 2010042662 “The RPOIIATON SULOW SCONTBINTIAL OA USE NT ATHORERD MONEE Case Status: CLEARED O1 Offense: MURDER Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF —— Oceured: 10/11/2010 ‘OTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Date/Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday Investignto Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C, (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up knew only as James came over to her residence at 4158 Old Jennings Road. Ashley stated they remained at the residence until approximately 0200 hours. Ashley stated she heard that a Kilgore was the suspect in this case and did not know ifit was Raymond. I advised Ashley that Raymond was not the suspect. Ashley stated that she did not know Christopher Scott Kilgore, and had only met Raymond Kilgore once prior to Jast night. Ashley had no further information. I advised Ashley that a detective would contact hor in person later on, During the course of the investigation both of the deceased victims were identified. One was identified as Raymond Kilgore W/M 03-16-1981. Raymond was identified by his numerous tattoo’s and from information provided by Judy and Daulphus Kilgore. ‘The second deceased victim was identified as James Allen Coody Jr W/M 08-22-1989. James ‘was identified as his Florida Identification card was located in his pocket. The victim's families were notified of the victim's being deceased. ‘At 1935 hours I entered into the residence. I observed victim Coody lying on his stomach and left side in the center of the living room. I observed victim Kilgore lying on his stomach in between a chair and a table in the northwest corner of the living room, Both victims were still in their original positions on my entering the residence. The victims were then moved for a gross bodily examination prior to their being transported to the Medical Examiners Office. At 1954 hours David Johnson of North Florida Removal Service (body transport) arrived and removed the victim's bodies to the Medical Examiners Office. Jeff McKeown of Animal Control then entered the residence and removed the two dogs which had been contained in the master bedroom of the residence. [advised J. McKeown that the animals were to be held for safekeeping until such a time that family members could respond to Animal Control to obtain the animals. 1 remained on scene until the crime scene personnel completed processing the scene for usable evidence, I left a copy ofthe search warrant inside the residence of 5487 Wood Duck Road listing the following items which were collected as evidence ‘Toshiba laptop computer Comforter Blanket Pillow White tank top shirt Direct TV remote Lighter Set of keys Marijuana pipe Bag of drug paraphernalia Towel Page 4CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sherif's Office 0c: 2010042662 “THE INFORMATION BEL OW CONFIDENTIAL FOR USEBY AUMIORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. 25 ‘Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE ‘Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 ‘Offenses MURDER Investigator: COTCHALBOVITCH, T: R. (06698) Date/Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up (©) spent shell casings, (2) live rounds (1) projectile (5) shotgun pellets (8) cell phones (1) cell phone charger Knife Pair of yellow gym shorts Purple scunci Multiple DNA swabs Victims’ purse Victims’ wallet | further left a copy of the search warrant for 5510 Squaw Lane inside that residence listing the following items as having been collected: Fishing knife set ‘Ace hardware bag containing shotgun shells Empty box of 9mm rounds Note on yellow paper Yellow notepad (1) car seat (1) apology note (4) non working cell phones Prior to departing from the scene I was provided with the crime scene log which is transcribed below. It should be noted that one Deputy, Dangerfield remained inside of the residence with Marrissa Kilgore until she could be removed from the residence to a safe area, No other personnel entered inside the residence after the residence was cleared and the injured were treated until I returned with the search warrants, (Log started by D/S Padgett #6996) Units in scene prior to 0615 hours (when log was begun) Lt. Sennango (Reseue 15) Lt. Loock (Rescue 23) B.C. Blocker (Fire Rect) Page 5Clay County Sherif's Office Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Offense: MURDER “TIBINFORMATION BELOW CONFIDENTIAL OR Use BY AUTHOR CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 COTCHALBOVITCH, T. R. Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Contact: 119872010 08:40:27, Tuesday Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Follow Up (06698) Referen DIS Hills #25117 DIS Saunders #6562 Lt, Bucci #836 Lt. Burke #822 D/S Marvel #6143 D/S Padgett #6996 Sgt. McKinney #720 Sgt. Chalker #721 DIS Calaway #25004 D/S Monson #7401 Lt. Bennett #818 DIS Cotchaleovitch #8406 CST Hearth #6878 D/S Dangerfield #0361 DIS Singletary #8407 DIS Gonzales #6897 D/S Bares #8405 D/S Holmes #6267 (Log continued by D/S Calaway #25004) D/S Bennett #9517 D/S Bachtold #9582 CST Thompson #7407 (0730 hours: ASA Steve Nelson 0734 hours: D/S Dangerfield left residence with Marrissa Kilgore (0800 hours: Lt. Senters #906 1110 hours: CST Antoniello #7403, 1117 hours: Ike Brown FRFTF 1117 hours: David Alred USMS 1117 hours: Silvestre Delroserio USMS 1209 hours: D/S Condurelis #25136 1314 hours: Parrish #25005 1353 hours: Wily #9507 1516 hours: Stowell FWC 1516 hours: Wiggins FWC 1649 hours: Ellis #6773 1717 hours: Sgt. Mahla #702 Page 6CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriffs Office del Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF — Oceureds 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Date/Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday spervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) ‘Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up 1720 hours: J.D. Wilson #6747 1733 hours: Sgt. Coldiron #731 1842 hours: Lt. Wagner #815 1850 hours: D/S Williams #9541 1855 hours: D/S Calhoun #6318 1924 hours: Lt. Bames #805 2337 hours: All units depart the inner perimeter It should be noted that the crime scene log documents all personnel who entered the outer perimeter onto Wood Duck Road, and does not distinguish the personnel who entered into the inner perimeter. I was also provided a list of residents who were allowed to travel on Wood Duck Road to their residence’s which is transcribed below: 1255 hours: James Allen Taylor W/M 12-25-1986, Cynthia Thomas W/F 11-17-1959, and Bthal Canterbury W/F 04-20-1936 to $199 Wood Duck Road 1415 hours: Breanna Nicole Moffo W/F 02-14-1996 to 5503 Wood Duck Road 1450 hours: Mr. Moffo to 5503 Wood Duck Road 1515 hours: Angela McKenzie W/F 04-10-1968 to 1908 Duckweed PI 1643 hours: Alesha Nelson W/F 11-19-1989, and Loren Nelson W/F 05-10-1968 to 1914 Duckweed PI 1645 hours: Kenneth Gainey W/M 08-29-1964 to 1908 Duckweed PI 1715 hours: Lauren Fountain W/F 12-29-1988 (no address listed) 1815 hours: Rose Leverette W/F 12-25-1964 to 5506 Wood Duck Road 1820 hours: Angela McKenzie W/F 04-10-1968 to 1908 Duckweed PI 1830 hours: Wendy Nelson W/F 12-11-1970 to 1914 Duckweed PI 1845 hours: Kimberly Hamilton W/F 07-19-1990 to 1925 Duckweed PI Page 7CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sherif’ Office coca: 2010042662 “Hin INFORMATION BELOW 8 CONMIDENTIALL FOR USE BY AUTON PERSONNEL ONLY (Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE ‘Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Date/Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday Investigator Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: J1/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contacts Reference: Follow Up 1855 hours: Shelly Paige W/F 09-02-1984 to 1920 Duckweed PI 2115 hours: Aaron Dryden W/M 08-02-1984 to 5507 Wood Duck Road 2247 hours: Anthony Mofo W/M 11-11-1972 to 5563 Wood Duck Road 10-12-10 I responded to the Clay County Courthouse and returned the search warrants for the residences of $487 Wood Duck Road and 5510 Squaw Lane. Iwas then provided a lead which stated a Justin Thomas had stopped a Deputy the previous night, J. Thomas stated ‘that he spoke to David Demay who stated he saw the blue Chevy Blazer driving into Jennings State Forest at approximately 0400 hours on 10-11-10. I was provided with a contact number for David Demay (904-328-4031). ‘At 1250 hours I made contact with David Demay by phone at the above listed number. David provided me with the following information, David Demay wim 06-27-1982 2077 Wisteria Lane FL DL# D500-176-82-227-0 SSN# David has known Raymond Kilgore since they were children, however he has not spoken to Raymond in approximately 2 years. David also knew Christopher Kilgore, though he did not consider Christopher to be a friend. David desoribed Christopher as being "strange." David stated that the last time he saw Christopher was approximately two years ago at Seth Hilton's residence. At that time Christopher spoke of killing his family and then living with Seth Hilton. Seth Hilton has since moved to the state of California. Christopher and Raymond Kilgore did not have a good relationship per David. David stated he did not see the blue Chevy Blazer entering Jennings State Forest the previous day and did rot know why anyone would provide that information. David stated that Seth Hilton was the only person he knew that Christopher Kilgore was friends with. David described Christopher Kilgore as a loner, and stated that no one that he knew of were friends with Christopher. Page 8CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriff's Office och: 2010042662 Tid INPORNIATION DELOWIS CONFIDENTIAL FOR USE BY aUnyigiuaeD ri f Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Status SONNEL ONLY. a EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF — Occured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. Re (06698) Date/Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date / Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact Reference: Follow Up "A computer search was conducted and found that Seth Hilton had resided at 2077 Wisteria Lene approximately two years ago. Two possible addresses in California were located for Seth Hilton, 1632 Virginia Ave, West Sacremento, CA and 16657 Paradise Mountain Road, Valley Center, CA. The two addresses were provided to the U.S. Marshal Service as possible locations that Christopher Kilgore may seek to travel to, 1400 hours: I responded to 4404 County Road 218, the business of We Store, and made contact with Billy Campbell, anager. The business has video surveillance which points to County Road 218. B. Campbell allowed me to view the surveillance footage for the morning of 10-11-10. I did not see the Blue Chevy Blazer which Christopher Kilgore was believed to be in on the footage. B. Campbell was unable to make a copy of the surveillance video at that time due to technical difficulties with the recorder. I left my contact information with B. Campbell and requested he contact me if he was able to make a copy of the footage. 1445 hours: I made contact by phone with Dustin Thomas, who reported that David Demay had seen the Blazer driving into Jennings State Forest, at 904-383-5945. Dustin refused to meet with me in person, Dustin stated he only heard that David Demay had seen the vehicle going into the woods while at a gathering the night before. Dustin would not say who he heard this information from, nor where the gathering was at. Dustin stated he had not spoken with David Demay and only wanted to pass on the information in the event that there was any validity to the claim. 1530 hours: I made contact with Amanda Marie Meltale (who claims to be Raymond Kilgore’s fiance) at 1102 Blanding Blvd. Amanda provided the below information. Amanda Marie Meltale WIF 12-27-1990 5747 Lamoya Ave, Jacksonville, FL 32210 Phonel! 904-294-6826 FL DL# M240013909670 ‘Ve ‘Amanda claims to be Raymond Kilgore’s fiancé, however she claimed that no one else knew of their relationship. ‘Amanda knew Raymond for approximately one to two years. During that time Raymond would sleep at her apartment from time to time, Christopher and Raymond had a bad relationship per Amanda, Approximately one and a half tonths ago Christopher attempted to stab Raymond with a knife in her presence. That incident occurred at the $487 Wood Duck Road residence. Amanda stated only Christopher, Raymond, James Coody and her were the only ones present during that incident, Amanda could not provide any further details about that incident, such as what caused the incident, Amanda stated she only met Christopher a small number of times and did not consider him to be a friend. Page 9CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriff's Office oon: 2010042662 “THE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL - FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE ‘Case Ming Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF — Oveured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Date / Times 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up ‘Amanda did not know where Christopher might have gone, ‘Amanda did state that Christopher had a Metro PCS phone, unknown description, ‘The phone number for that phone was in Raymond's phone under the name "dickhead." Amanda stated she had witnessed Raymond call Christopher on that number in the past. Amanda did not know the number but insisted it would be in Christopher's cel! phone. Icontacted J.D. Wilson, who had recovered the contact information from Raymond's cell phone, J.D. Wilson advised that there was no contact in the phone listed under "dickhead," nor was there a similar listing that appeared to be a number for Christopher. At approximately 1630 hours Det. Barnes #8405 and I made contact with Richard Alan Paschen at 5032 Cattal Street. R, Paschen was believed to be an associate of Christopher Kilgore. Richard Alan Paschen WM 08-14-1987 5032 Cattail Street, Middleburg, FL 32068 Cell phone# 904-410-6168 FL DLA P250741872940 SNe Richard confirmed that he did know both Raymond and Christopher Kilgore, Richard provided the following information. Richard has gone to a spot in Jennings State Forest with Christopher in the past which Christopher considered his personal area in the forest. The directions to the area were to enter the forest through the end of Nolan Road then take the first right, continue until the road forked and turn left. The road would then come to a U bend at which time Christopher would park and walk approximately 200 yards to the creek, ‘The area has several cliffs and was a place ‘where Christopher had gone to hide in the past. The location described was relayed to Sgt. Gordon #703 who was coordinating the search of Jennings State Forest as an additional area to search, Richard stated he had not spoken with Raymond in quite some time, unknown exactly how long. Richard stated he last saw Christopher approximately 10-14 days prior in the area of Old Carter Road and Louie Carter Road. At that time Richard was riding with a male named Joe Howell. As they were driving on Old Carter Road they observed Christopher riding in a blue Acura car with an unknown male. ‘They pulled up next to the vehicle and Joe Howell Page 10CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriff's Office coca: 2010042662 “Fp INFORWATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL POR USE BY AUTHORIZeD PERSONNEL ONLY. ‘Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE ‘Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Occured 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T: R. (06698) Date /Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday + MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Reference: Follow Up spoke to Christopher through the open car windows. The two spoke about buying and selling illegal drugs. After a short period, less than one minute, Richard and Joe continued to drive away. Richard stated he did not recognize the other male in the Acura ot know where Joe Howell may be at this time. Richard stated Joe Howell used to live off of Blue Jay Drive, but believed he now resided off of Louie Carter Road. I conducted a computer search and located a Joseph Howell W/M 08-17-1988 who had a prior address listed of 2098 Hermitage Pl, which is off of Blue Jay Drive, Det. Barnes and I responded to that address where we made contact with ‘Joe Howell's brother James Howell. James provided me with Josephs phone number of 904-328-4605. James confirmed that Joseph was living off of Louie Carter Road, possibly on Westwood Road, though he did not know the address. J attempted to contact Joseph Howell by phone, however a male answered the phone, denied being Joseph, and hung up. James then offered to call Joseph from his cell phone. James was able to speak with Joseph at which time Joseph agreed to speak with me by phone about this case. Joseph refused to meet with me in person or provide his address. Joseph stated he did ride with Richard Paschen on Old Carter Road approximately one to two weeks prior, though he denied seeing Christopher Kilgore at that time, Joseph stated that he did know Christopher, however he had not seen ‘of spoken to him in a long time. Joseph stated he had no further information. Due to not having a good address for him, I was unable to contact Joseph Howell in person for further interview. 2048 hours: A BOLO was received from the Jacksonville Sheriff's Office in reference to an armed robbery that occurred at 14801 Normandy Blvd. ‘The BOLO stated the suspect in the robbery matched the description of Christopher Kilgore. The BOLO further stated the suspect carried a sawed off shotgun, and left in a blue Chevy Blazer. I responded to the scene of the robbery and made contact with JSO Detective Bearden and Detective Miley. Det. Bearden advised he was the lead detective on the robbery and provided the JSO case number of 2010-817080. entered the business with the JSO detectives and viewed the video surveillance of the robbery. The suspect entered the business at 2020 hours. I recognized the suspect to be Christopher Scott Kilgore. The suspect walked to the counter carrying a sawed off shotgun and proceeded to commit the robbery. ‘The suspect then left the business in the blue Chevy Blazer. Detective Bearden stated that no witnesses were able to obtain the tag number for the Blazer, or the direction in which the vehicle left. Det. Bearden stated the suspect asked for (5) cartons of Newport brand cigarettes, candy, and money. During the robbery a black male approached the suspect at which time the suspect stated "go to the bathroom and I won't kill you" to the male. At the end of the robbery the suspect requested the clerk to "turn con pump 2," however the suspect did not pump any gas prior to leaving the business, 1 contacted Set. McKinney with the above listed information. Numerous units from the OSS squad, Street Crimes Page 11CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sherif’s Office ca: 2010042662 THIE INFORMATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL “FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Date / Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up Unit, and the U.S. Marshal Service responded to the area and began searching for the suspect. JSO also had numerous Units respond to the area to begin searching for the suspect, 1 then met with Det, West #8409 and began checking gas stations in the area as the suspect may attempt another robbery, or need to purchase gas, We responded to the Kangaroo gas station at 10401 Normandy Blvd, On arriving outside the business I was contacted by Ralph Richardson (full information listed below) who stated he knew Christopher Kilgore and had seen him earlier in the day. Ralph Richardson WM 07-21-1990 10333 Lila Mae Lane, Jacksonville, FL 32221 Cell phone 904-505-9183 FL DL# R263-730-90-261-0 SSN# Ralph stated he has met Christopher Kilgore twice, both times through Jimmy Kilgore. On this date Ralph received a phone call from Jimmy Kilgore at approximately noon asking for help in fixing his father's truck. Jimmy asked Ralph {fo meet him at the Kangaroo gas station located atthe intersection of Yellow Water Road, and Normandy Blvd (which is 14801 Normandy Blvd). Ralph drove to that location where he met Jimmy Kilgore at a closed business across from the Kangaroo. The truck, a primer grey 1985 Ford F150, was at the closed business. Jimmy asked Ralph to replace the distributor cap on the truck, which Ralph did. Ralph stated that Christopher Kilgore was in the vehicle which Jimmy ‘was riding in, Ralph stated Christopher would not get out of the vehicle and did not say much. Ralph stated Christopher was wearing a Florida Gators shirt, and unknown further description as he was seated in the vehicle. Ralph spoke briefly to Christopher about the Florida Gators, though that was all. After completing the repair Ralph drove back to his residence. Ralph stated he did not have any knowledge of this case until seeing the newspaper just prior to contacting us, Ralph further stated that Jimmy Kilgore resides off of Yellow Water Road with his father. Ralph stated Jimmy Kilgore and Christopher Kilgore are not related, though they became friends due to the common last name. Ralph agreed to ride ‘with me to point out Jimmy Kilgore’s residence. On riding to Yellow Water Road Ralph observed the Police activity at the Kangaroo gas station where the robbery occurred at which time he began asking what happened there, Ralph claimed to have no knowledge that the robbery had occurted, or that Christopher Kilgore was the suspect in that case. Ralph pointed out a residence at the intersection of Yellow Water Road and Yellow Water Lane as being Jimmy Kilgore’s residence. 1 drove Ralph back to the Page 12CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriff's Office oa: 2010042662 1 TT THEINOIOMATION BELOW 1S CONFIDENTIAL. FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. ‘Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oeeured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Date / Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Twesday 1: [1/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R, (06698) Supervisor: MCKINNY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date / Contact Reference: Follow Up Kangaroo gas station where he contacted me and he left in his vehicle. I retumed to the area of the residence which Ralph stated was Jimmy Kilgore’s. A computer search was conducted which revealed that a James Kilgore did reside at 4906 Yellow Water Road, which was the residence that Ralph pointed out. Members of the OSS unit, U.S. Marshal Service, Det. West and I then attempted to contact Jimmy Kilgore at that residence with negative results, I was then flagged down by an unknown neighbor and advised that Jimmy Kilgore actually resided at 14908 Yellow Water Lane, We then responded to that location and made contact with Jimmy Kilgore whose information is listed below. James Richard Kilgore WM 02-06-1989 14908 Yellow Water Lane, Jacksonville, FL 32234 Cell phone 904-672-5217 FL DL# K426-456-89-046-0 SSN# Jimmy was asleep on our artival, but agreed to come outside to speak with me. Jimmy stated he does not know Christopher Kilgore, and had never met him, Jimmy stated he does know Ralph Richardson, but had not seen him today. Jimmy stated his father’s truck was not broken down during the day. A check of the area did not reveal any evidence that Christopher Kilgore had been present. 10-13-10 0702 hours: I was contacted by dispatch and advised the blue Chevy Blazer which Christopher Kilgore was driving had been located in Jacksonville, responded to 16610 Normandy Blvd and observed the Blazer, Florida license plate B401EQ in the unpaved driveway to the residence, On arrival there were numerous J.S.0. Officers on scene. I made contact with John Waters who provided the below listed information. John Alvin Waters WIM 02-25-1964 16610 Normandy Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32234 Phone # 904-626-1351 Page 13CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriffs Office oc: 2010042662 aa THIBINFORMATION BELOW Is CONFIDENTIAL. FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE (Case Mng Status: EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF ecured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Date /Time: {1/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 1J/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up FL DL# W362-461-64-065-0 SSNi ‘At approximately 0530 J. Waters was awoken by his dogs barking, which is out of the ordinary. J. Waters did not go “outside at that time to check on the dogs, as he believed they may have been barking at animals. Approximately one hour later his wife, Kimberly Waters, left the residence in her vehicle. Kimberly immediately returned and informed John that a vehicle was blocking their driveway. John told Kimberly to call 911 as they were aware that Christopher Kilgore was inthe area the previous night, John took his 9mm pistol and went outside to check the vehicle, The driveway is not lit, and John could not see the vehicle to determine whether or not it was the blue Blazer. On approaching the vehicle John realized that it was in fact the Blazer, at which time he yelled for his wife to call 911 again to inform J.S.0. As John stood near the vehicle a male subject approached from the woods on the west side of the driveway, John could not see the males face or clothing due to the low light conditions. John could not tell ifthe ale was armed or not. John yelled to the male that he had a gun and had contacted the police, The male told John that he was out of gas and just needed help. John told the male to stay where he was until the police arrived, at which time the male turned and walked up the driveway to Normandy Blvd. As the male reached Normandy Blvd John observed the miale was carrying a sawed off shotgun at his right hand side. John continued to watch the male who ‘walked west on Normandy Blvd for approximately 100 yards and then entered the woods on the south side of ‘Normandy. John returned to his residence and waited for J.S.O. to arrive. I then made contact with Kimberly Waters whose information is listed below. Kimberly Suzanne Waters wir 16610 Normandy Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32234 Phone#f 904-626-1351 FL DL# W362-517-65-871-0 Td Kimberly confirmed the account of the morning provided by her husband, Kimberly stated on first seeing the vehicle she could not determine if it was in fact the blue Blazer. Kimberly stated she did not see the male subject whom her husband encountered. I then contacted Det. C. C. Waters #7349 of the J.S.0. Robbery Unit, I requested the vehicle be towed to the Orange Park Substation for processing which Det. Waters agreed to. T contacted Det. Coyne #8404 and requested be respond to Shands Hospital to ask Daulphus and Judy Kilgore for consent to process the vehicle for usable evidence. Both Daulphus and Judy signed a Voluntary Consent to Search form authorizing the Clay County Sheriff's Office personne! Page 14CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sherif's Office : och: 2010042662 ‘TABINFOR MATION BELOW Is CONFIDENTIAL: FOR USPBY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY. Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Case Ming Stat : EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Offense: MURDER Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Date /Timer 1/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C. (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday’ Contact: Reference: Follow Up to process the vehicle. CST Lynch #7403 responded to the scene and photographed the vehicle. ‘At 1007 hours I contacted dispatch and requested the departmental wrecker respond to tow the vehicle to the Orange Park Substation. 1 then made contact with J.S.0. K9 Officer D. B. Hall #5368 who requested a scent article be retrieved from the vehicle fo assist in the K9 track of the suspect. At 1118 hours due to the exigency of an armed homicide! robbery suspect being on foot in a residential area placing numerous persons in danger CST Lynch and J entered the vehicle and retrieved a black Columbia brand jacket which was provided to Officer Hall for use in obtaining a scent track. CST Lynch secured all ofthe doors and windows of the vehicle with evidence tape, At 1133 hours Dewey Purvis of Scott's Affordable Towing towed the vehicle from the scene, 1 followed the tow truck to the Orange Park Substation where it was placed in the secured back parking lot for processing. The vehicle was processed by CST Lynch forall usable evidence, for full details refer to her supplemental report ‘After the vehicle was processed I returned to the area of Normandy Blvd where the suspect was believed to be contained and assisted in the perimeter. On 10-15-10 I was contacted by Lt. Bucci by phone and advised that Christopher Kilgore was shot and killed by members of J.8.0, reference to J.S.0. case #2010-824381. I was advised that J.S.O. recovered a handgun, and shotgun, ‘anda rifle which were in the possession of Christopher Kilgore at the time of the shooting. For further details itis recommended that authorized personnel view the J.S.0. report documenting the incident. On 10-18-10 1 was contacted by the warrants section and advised that the warrant issued in this ease was removed from the system due to the death of the suspect. On 10-22-10 I made contact with Daulphus Kilgore at Shands Hospital in Jacksonville. Daulphus requested that any items which were collected as evidence that belong to either he or his wife Judy be released to Mike Straver once they ‘were available to be released. Daulphus completed a sworn written statement with the request. 10-25-10 I made contact with Mike Straver, W/M 10-08-1960 at the Orange Park Substation, As per the request of Daulphus Kilgore I released the Chevy Blazer, and both Daulphus's and Judy's cell phones to Mike Straver who signed for the Page 15CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sherif's Office coca: 2010042662 "THE INFORMIATION BELOW IS CONFIDENTIAL © FOR USE BY AUTHORIZED PERSONNEL ONLY, Case Status: CLEARED OF FE Offense: MURDER ‘Case Mng Status: EXCEPTCLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, 1 R. (06698) Date Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Twesday Supervisor: MCKINNEY, W. C, (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Contact: Reference: Follow Up items. 11-08-10 I made contact with Detective Stucki of the J.S.0. Cold Case Unit at $01 E Bay Street, J.8.0. headquarters. Det. Stooki released the guns which were in Christopher Kilgore’s possession at the time he was shot to me. I transported the guns to the Orange Park Substation where they were photographed by CST Antoniello prior to being submitted into evidence. Summary On the moming of 10-11-10 Christopher Scott Kilgore entered his parent's residence at $487 Wood Duck Road, Middleburg, FL 32068, which is within Clay County, while armed with at least a handgun, a shotgun, and a machete, Once inside the residence Christopher shot his brother Raymond Kilgore at least 11 times with a pistol killing Raymond. Christopher also shot James Coody one time with a pistol killing James, Christopher then shot his mother Judy Kilgore once with a shotgun. Judy was transported to Shands Hospital where she later recovered from the injury. Christopher then struck his father Daulphus Kilgore twice with a machete. Christopher further shot his father Daulphus once with @ shotgun. Daulphus was transported to Shands Hospital where his left arm was amputated just below the elbow as a result of the gunshot. Daulphus was able to recover from the injuries. Christopher removed several of the spent casings, including both spent shotgun shells, from the residence. ‘After the shootings, Christopher took his mother’s Chevy Blazer bearing Florida license B401EQ which was parked on the south side of the residence. Christopher drove to his residence of 5510 Squaw Lane via a shared driveway between the two residences. Christopher removed a child safety seat from the Blazer which was located near his residence. Christopher placed numerous pieces of his clothing and other supplies in the vehicle and then left fled the area. Despite an intensive search, Christopher remained hidden until the following night, 10-12-10, at which time he committed an armed robbery of the Kangaroo located at 14801 Normandy Blvd in Jacksonville, Christopher carried shotgun in that robbery, believed to be the same shotgun used in the homicide, Christopher fled the area and was not located that night. (On the morning of 10-13-10 the Chevy Blazer was located at 16610 Normandy Blvd. Christopher was seen by a citizen with a sawed off shotgun. The Chevy Blazer was recovered and a perimeter was established around the area ‘where Christopher was last seen, Christopher was not located until 10-15-10 at which time he was shot and killed by 1.8.0. Officers Page 16CASE SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT Printed: 12/20/2010 09:58 Clay County Sheriff's Office Oca: 2010042662 St USERY AHORA MAGEANELONUT a ‘Case Status: CLEARED OFFENSE Offense: MURDER : EXCEPT CLEAR; DEATH OF Oceured: 10/11/2010 Investigator: COTCHALEOVITCH, T. R. (06698) Date/Time: 11/09/2010 08:40:27, Tuesday 1: MCKINNEY, W. C, (06229) Supervisor Review Date/Time: 11/30/2010 14:51:04, Tuesday Reforence: Fallow Up Christopher Kilgore shot four people, two of which died as a result of theit injuries. None of the people shot were armed or threatened Christopher Kilgore’s life in such a matter as to cause the shootings to be justified. Probable cause for the arrest of Christopher Kilgore did exist as an arrest warrant was obtained for two counts of murder, and ‘two counts of attempted murder. Christopher Kilgore died prior to the warrant being served Due to the above listed facts this case is closed, cleared by death of the offender. Page 17