Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ibanez Case JAN 2011
Ibanez Case JAN 2011
!
"#
#
$
%&
"' "()** +
,$*(%*-.%/)*
0"+$c1c$ c$2$"" $ c 34c%5 $
+$c6
7
34c(584
$+4(**). &% $+4$
+9
" (**). &%34c:58
c
"#.%*;<=
/ (*%*.#/ (*%%
,
4
$
4
>2$ c"
2
!
"
%;
:* (**-
,
#
"#
7
!
"""
8
0"+9c
$
?
"""7# 8
$
@
$%
&
,9$2?
#
"
+
?A ##
V
! "
#
$
%&#
'(()&*+
, !, "
#
'((-&.%/
#
#
'((-&
.%/!
"
0
1#
2
3
0,
2
0
0
4
3
0
0
3
0
5
53
2
4
3V -
ï
.
3- '((6
0
78
78
3
.
03 ,
0
$
00319
19
3
7
0.
'((: ,
1#
1'( ;
)
8
<
4
00
050
<
0
=!/"
20
0
!78
19"
3>
3
+!'"
0
+
!?"
5
0 ,
0
0
5
0
0
0
7
0
&&78
19&&
3
0
05
3
20
7
0
3
20
=!/"
4
<
<
3
1' ;/!4
53
3
"+!'"
3
0
0
>
3
V )
3
1#
0
.$') '((@ 20
2
5
5
1' ;/
0 !
78",
!
19"
0
3
3
0
V 62
A
0
4
0
30
3
0
0
0
V
:
05
5
20
0
/6 '((@
0
0
0
3
2
0
0
>
0
0
2
5
0
5
3
0
3>
0
7
0
0
2
30
0
0
$3
0
80
7819
0
3V @
2
A0
5
20
.
/ '((@
30
0
50
0
,
A
5
,0
3
5
0
0
V /(
.B0/ '((-
78
C/(? -((
3
'(
#3
30
9$
7!9$
"0
353
9$
>
0
0
0
3
0
V //
0
0
0
0.
.$
#
!.
."
0
6
'(()
3'? '(() .
.
>
0
780
.
.
78
0
10
10
D7
#
V /'
0
>0
3/ ''(
0
#
$
%&#
'(()&*,
0
78
5
0
&
35
&&
8
780
3
=
9$
7!
"
EEBFF
.
.$
#
!"
EEBFF
10
EEBFF
10
D7!"
EEBFF
#
!
"
EEBFF
#
$
%&#
'(()&*
0
780
B0/ '(()
0
,
5
0
000!%%$"
B0')
'(() '6?& 0
&
5
%%$
0
55 008
5
0
0
<<
%%$ <V
$
10
V10
D7
B
V
#
0
B
V
$
1
0
0
0
53<%%$
<V
$
1
>
0
<D5
5
2
30
3
780
0
0
./6 '((6 0
780
1#
500
#59
!500
"
5
300
0
5-(#>;;-(/ -// -??!'(()G
77'((:"V /?7
0
<!"<
0
5378
320
') '((6
0
0
500
7
'((6
431' ;/
<
<
0
3- '((6
78
3
3
8
C@ ?-( 5
3
0
0
5
3
!0
0
"
35
$3'? '((:
.
0' '((: 0
3
0
50
0
D0$
5 7 <&&
<
.
.
78
0
>
0
0
8
V /
0
0// '((:
.$3/@ '((- $003
1950
3
)
.
.
3C/(? '((+
0
03.$3') '((- .
.>
0
0
, .
.
19
0
0
3': '((-
50
0
#
! #".
/ '((-
0
0
3 #
0
,
#'((-&.%/
#
&
#
'((-&.%/
50
!%"
190
3
=
.
.$
#
!
"
0
#
!
"
,
#'((-&.%/ #
&
#
'((-&.%/
,
5
2
3
50
0
0
190
3.
.
0
>
3
0
0
>
%0
0
5
0 <3
3
5
53
%V #
#B
$
1<
0
0
0
0
2
19
0
0
0
#
, 5
2
3
%
0
#!
" .
.
!5" , !
"
3
0
H>#00
%5
<3
5
53
B
$
1
$
1 <<3
5<
0
0
0
<0
<
0
0
3
%5
2
0
7
,
0
%
3
00
30
050
190
,
19
3A8
3
190
30
30
0
19
.'6 '((6 , 0
500
1#
19
0
0
,
<
!"<
0
53
19
320
,
3? '((6
19
500
0
7
'((6
,
3
3
<
<
0
3- '((6 ,
19
3C/'( ?@6(? 5
3
0
0
5,
>
35
$36 '((:
03 .
.
190
>
0
0
,
+
0
$3/' '((:
>
0
0
5
/: '((6
1'( ;)
0
A
>
0
0
5
! "
(/$')6 ')@!/@:6"0
3
4<
03
0
5
V
<#
! $5"
@
$#
6'6 6?(!'((("4
4
0
5
3
0
$
40
2
8
0
3
1/:? ;'/+1' ;/,
>
0
20
3
0
3
500
0
3
3
>
3
3
0
%! ?)6$?:-
?@(&?@/ ?@? 0 '?:()!/@6-"
,0
0
78190
3
1/:? ;'/
31' ;;//&/6#1/:? ;
'/
0
0
3
0
03
3
53
3
0 <5
0
000
0
0
4
3<H5
0
30
0
0
0
2
V /-%! $
?@?
98
30
0
00
25
0
<
V0
3
07
5>
35< %
/:6$'(6 '//!/@(-"
% /()$-(@ -/?!/:6/"!
0
<0
>
0
0<"& %
%!
%!%'@$:( :!/@?)"V /)
.
0
0
3
<
3<>3<
0
>
0
<1
/:? ;'/1' ;/ <V
0
5
0
8
3
33
83
5
0
00
<0
>
3
3
3
3<2
3<
3
5! % /:@$--@ -)/!/@(-"
%
$ %$ %'!()'6-$
? ?6&?:!'((6"!
0
3
3
3
0
<
53
A
3
3
5
0
<5"
340
0
3
3
40
1' ;/
5
<
0
5
<5
5
0
3
0
<0
5
0
0
0
5>
< %
$
'/'! %
$ !<
3
40
5<"
& %
%!
%!%
$ 3
0
8
0
3
0
3
3
0
03
5
5V /6 %
$ !0
5
0
0
0
"
%*
/?$#
:( :?&:
!/@:'"!50
"
2
3
3
5
3
0
40
3
D
0
0
+
30
3
5
0
1/:? ;'/ 1' ;/
3
>
78190
3
3
0
0
4
?)) 9')-
')@! B$'((6"!<4
0
3
3
$
<"V /:+
! $%+-))'
::- ::)! B
#
/@@("!0"!
0
0
0
000
"
0
8
0
3
0
50
0
0
78190
,
0
0
3
0
0
40
50
1
0
0
53
4
3
1/:? ;?+
ï
",!
)%'''6$/6- /66!/@/6"7
<
3
<$
0
3
%
& $ï
$%
-:$/ )
!'(/(" 03
05
0
0&
0
34
0+
3
0
-+
!%
! ?)($6-/ 6-?!/@6'" 4
% %
+$
,
!/':$?/- ?/)!/::("
!
<
>
0
0
0
<0
3"+
%! $'@
$#
:: @(!/@@(", 0
5
0
&
303
5
0
0
0
5
0
0A000
780
0
0
%%$
0
3
0
2%%$ 5
0
0
>
3
5
0
0
H5
>
0
0
0
>
0
780
0
0
3
0
3 5
>
0
4
35
3
0
&&
#
&&5
0
0
0
09$
.
.+
0
2
.
.5
0
3
V /@
0
0
2 .
.
0
0
5
3
0
190
, 0
19
0
%%
A
%%$
0
!<3
<<35<"
0
,
0
3
4
3
19
0
0
%
$5 , 5
2
0
#!
"
190
3
%
78
19.
.
0
20
1953.
.
3
,
0
0
2
3
0
0
8
1/:? ;'/ 1
' ;/
0
0
2
30
3
$
'))!<,D0H4
V5#
4
5
3
550
3
20
0
3
0
0
3
0
5
3
0<"
%
%
!%#?:'
7?//: //::!'((:"!5
003
20
5
3
<5
V
35
3
2
3<"
,
0
0
0
0
4
3
,0
8
>
0
0
0
3
3
0
0
03
0
D5
0
0
03
3
0
/- 9: '(! B$'((@"
30350
0
0
0
0
0
ï
?') 9
6(: 6'(! B.'((-"!<7
0
4
0
0
0
3
4
0
0
0
5
0
0
<"3
30
0
0
3
3
5
3
!
30
8
1/:? ;
'/ 1' ;/"
2
8
0
0
3
0
3
78190
53
0
2
20
3
A0
5
20
V '(
,
3
0
3
3
0
>
3.
.
3
3<5V0V
0
35
8
0
<
<
50
<
3
3
0
0
0
,5
53
3 0
0
53
5+
0
5
0
%
%
?'6
$'/6 '/@!/@-/"+ % ''-$?/ ?
!/@/)"1/:? ;?
3
0
3
0
0
7$
0
0
3
0
3
0
0
%
/@$/() //!/::@"9
0
0
4
0
0
0303
4
0
!<70
2
0
30
50
0
0
5
$
3
0
0
5334
3<"%
)
3/-' /-!/:-)"7
5
0
0
0
0
000&
/@/'
3
<
0
>
0
<
3
4
3
0
3
1/:? ;'/
3
/@/' -(' ;)
3
0
3
0
2
50
3
0
03
3
-:!?"3
9
H
$
=<
53V
0
$
>
4
$
3
<V '/
>
3
3
0
03
3
3
0
0
0
3
1/:? ;
'/ 1' ;/7
5
0
78190
0
3
3
1/:? ;'/ 1' ;/
0
0
03
0
&0
033<
5
<
.
.A0
190
,
0
0
0
5
3
+
0
5
$
')@
D5
-:!?"
0
0
3 5
0
0
>
0
30
03>
0
550
0
5
0
3
0
1
/:? ;'/+ % $'/$:) :@
!/@''",
0
0
0
0
>
0
0
033
%& %'/)$( &-!/@/"
0
30
5
0
0
530
0
0
0$%
/:6$6? 6)!/@("!0
3<
<
<
5
0
053
0
0<",
50
4
0
3
0
0
30
0
07
2
5
3
5
0
7819
0
0
0
350
3 2
A4
5
53
0
0
0
00ï$$%
! $-6$?): ?:!'(/("!
<0
5
3<"+ï
%)?:)$-( -)-
!/@:'",5
40
A
3
40
0
&
!
2
0
3
78190
0
3
0
340
3
0
+
#.9BI
!
0
2"
73
3
3
0
3
$
0
0
4
0
2
00
5
0
0
4
$
34
3
5
03
$
3
>
2
3
0
0
4
8
0
3
0
&
5
3
40
$
34
503
5
30
0
3!
5"
0
5>
33
80
3>
0
0
A3
0
0
35
5
,
00
&
3
035
0
50
5
3
4
3
3 3
3
3
5
0
5
/
#
$
%&
',
%$19G
?#
A0
#
$
-,
03
3+
$
7+$$B+
#01#
$ 0B% 9
1 #3 9
80
)
3
19
3- '((@ 00
62
5
:7
1
7 11#
& #
'((6&DH'
0
<
53
0
0
0
30
!
0
"<
@.
/ '((@
3
0
0
/(19
0
0
2
0
5
20
3
3
0
3
0
20
0
0
3
//
80
=< .9J1H9H#H7JHB
KKKKKKK
$
B0/ '((->
3
/'
#
3
#00%7
3
3
/?00
$
0
4
0
3
500
/@? -6 0
/@@: /'
/1#
24
0D0$
.
.50
20
4
/-
5
3
0
3
30
3
000
3
0
A
0
%.%?''$) -'&-?!/@6"
3
3035
0
>
&
%
'@6$'
0
3
3
/),8
0
0
3
0
0
<
3<0>
<
0
0
O
%
&&/
/6$?66
4
$$,) ! !%ï ?6?$?/) ?'(!/@66"
3
0
2
/60
51' ;/
0
3
,
0
30
<
0
4 <1' ;
>
3
0
3
/:
8
35
3
;/=
3
5
0
3
33
83
/@78
5
3
0
.
.
0
30
0
0
0.
.
3
5
3
.
.
'(
5
4
20
0
0
20
'/
-:!?"3
9H
<D5
0
5
/@ '((6032
3#
<
?)) 9')-! B$'((
p