Hkz"Vkpkj ds fo#) la?

k"kZ
Jherh lq’kek Lojkt dk y¨dlHkk eas
ts-ih-lh- eqÌs ij ,sfrgkfld Hkk"k.k
¼23 Qjojh] 2011½

01
02
 Jherh lq’kek Lojkt dk y¨dlHkk esa ts-ih-lh- xBu ij ,sfrgkfld Hkk"k.k ¼23 Qjojh] 2011½

Hkz"Vkpkj ij tsihlh dk xBu & ,d vfuok;Zrk

ljdkj dk foyEc vrkÆdd
vè;{k egksn;k] usrk lnu us tsihlh ds xBu dk tks izLrko lnu esa izLrqr fd;k gS] eSa mldk
leFkZu djus ds fy, [kM+h gqbZ gwaA
egksn;k] vkt igyh ckj ;g lnu tsihlh dk xBu ugha dj jgk gSA vkt ls igys pkj ckj ;gh
lnu tslhih dk xBu dj pqdk gS] tsihlh ds xBu dk izLrko ikfjr dj pqdk gSA lPpkbZ rks ;g gS fd
tc Hkh Hkz’Vkpkj dk dksbZ cM+k dkaM ns”k esa mtkxj gqvk] ml le; ds izfri{k ny us tsihlh dh ekax dh
vkSj ml le; ds “kkldksa us tsihlh dks Lohdkj fd;kA ysfdu eq>s gSjkuh rc gqbZ] tc bl ckj ge
tsihlh dh ekax dj jgs Fks rks usrk lnu us gekjh ekax dks byksthdy (illogical) dgdj] gesa
ekvksoknh laxBu esa “kkfey gksus
dh ulhgr nhA ftl le; eSaus
iz.ko nk dk c;ku Vhoh ij lquk]
rks eq>s ;dhu ugha gqvkA ysfdu
vxys fnu tc eSaus v[kckj esa i<+k
rks ,dne ls esjs eu esa ;g Hkko
vk;k fd usrk lnu ,d vPNs
vkneh gSa] eSa vxj dgwa fd cgqr
vPNs gSa rks Hkh xyr ugha gksxkA bl
ljdkj ds ofj’B ea=h gSa vkSj cgqr
vuqHkoh lkaln gSaA ysfdu fnDdr
;g gS fd tc mUgsa xqLlk vkrk gS
rks os mfpr vkSj vuqfpr dk è;ku
Hkwy tkrs gSaA tks ckr mUgksaus dgh]
mlij v[kckj esa Nih [kcj dh
Áfr eSa ysdj vk;h gwaA vkius D;k dgk Fkk] ;g 23 tuojh dk VkbEl vkWQ bafM;k gS vkSj flyhxqM+h dh
MsVykbu gS&If the Opposition insists on stalling Parliament over their demand for
a Joint Parliamentary Probe into the Second Generation Telephone Technology
at rates below market prices, they should join the Maoists. Pranab Mukherjee
said here on Saturday.
“The Union Finance Minister called the Opposition's parliamentary
probe demand, `illogical' and said that the Joint Parliament Committee has no
power to punish. The Winter Session is lost and if they have no faith in
parliamentary democracy, they should join the Maoists.”

03
 tssihlh dh ekax vlaoS/kkfud ugha
vè;{k egksn;k] eSa iz.ko nk ls iwNuk pkgrh gwa fd ekvksoknh u yksdra= esa fo”okl djrs gSa] u
lafoèkku esaA os dsoy canwd dh Hkk’kk tkurs gSa vkSj canwd ls gh O;oLFkk ifjorZu djuk pkgrs gSaA D;k
gekjh tsihlh dh ekax fgald ekax gS \ D;k ge dksbZ vlaoSèkkfud ekax dj jgs Fks\ ;fn vkidks laln u
pyus nsus dk gekjk O;ogkj ekvksoknh;ksa tSlk yxrk gS rks iz.ko nk] vkius vHkh tks Hkk’k.k fn;k] eSa
vkids le; dh] tc vki izfri{k esa Fks] eSa ml le; dk ,d mnkgj.k vkids lkeus is”k djuk okgrh
gwaA ml le; ge “kklu esa Fks vkSj dkaxzsl izfri{k esa Fkh vkSj vkt dh dkaxzsl dh vè;{kk] ;wih, dh
pS;jilZu bl lhV ij cSBrh Fkha] D;ksafd og usrk izfri{k yksdlHkk FkhaA ml le; vki yksxksa us Hkh
tsihlh dh ,d ekax dks ysdj ds gkml dks fdrus fnu can fd;k FkkA D;k og vkidk ekvksoknh O;ogkj
FkkA eSa iwjs lS”ku dh ckr dj jgh gwaA 12 fnu can jgk ;k 15 fnu can jgk] ;fn blesa ekvksoknh O;ogkj
cu tkrk gS rks eSa dg ugha ldrh gwaA vki iwjs lS”ku dh ckr dj jgs gSaA eSa vkidks crkuk pkgrh gwa fd
fdrus fnu can jgk vkSj fdlh ,sls oSls nLrkost ls ughaA vius ;gka ,d ijaijk gS fd tc l= lekIr
gksrk gS rks lSØsVjh tujy ,d Mhvks ysVj fy[krs gSa] ftlesa iwjs l= esa D;k ?kVk] ;g fy[krs gSaA ;g ml
le; ds lSØsVjh tujy th-lh- eYgks=k dk
^^ekvksoknh u yksdra= esa fo”okl Ik= gS] ftlesa ls dqN va”k i<+dj eSa lquk jgh
djrs gSa] u lafoèkku esaA os dsoy canwd dh gwaA
“During the Session, the
Hkk’kk tkurs gSa vkSj canwd ls gh O;oLFkk House had sitting for 31 days. A
ifjorZu djuk pkgrs gSaA D;k gekjh tsihlh substantial part of the Session was
dh ekax fgald ekax gS \ D;k ge dksbZ disrupted because of acrimonious
scenes within the House. The
vlaoSèkkfud ekax dj jgs Fks\**
Business Schedule was often
thrown into disarray leading to
adjournment of the House for a number of days at a stretch resulting in the loss of
nearly 77 hours of business.”
This Session has created history of sorts when for the first time in our
Parliamentary history, the Railway Budget was passed by the House without any
discussion. During the Session, due to adjournments and interruptions, the
Question Hour remained interrupted on several occasions. Out of 600 Starred
Questions that were listed, only 66 were answered orally.
N% lkS lokyksa esa ls dsoy 66 lokyksa esa iz”u&dky pykA 77 ?kaVs fdrus fnu gksrs gSa] eryc 12
fnu vkius gkml can fd;k vkSj 15 fnu geus can fd;k rks rhu fnu esa ge ekvksoknh gks x,A iz.ko nk]
eq>s flQZ ,d ckr dguh gS fd ftuds vius ?kj “kh”ks ds gksa] mUgsa nwljksa ds ?kjksa ij iRFkj ugha Qsaduk
pkfg,A

04
izfri{k dh ekax dks eku ysuk ljdkj dh detksjh ugha
vè;{k egksn;k] tgka rd gekjh ;s ckr dg jgs gSa] vHkh ;s Jh v#.k tsVyh th dh ckr dg jgs
FksA eSa iz.ko nk dks ;kn fnykuk pkgrh gwa fd gekjs le; dk ,d fjdkMZ ,slk gS] ftldk dksbZ nwljk
mnkgj.k ugha feyrk gSA eSa ftl le; LokLF; ea=h Fkh] ml le; eSaus isIlh dksyk esa dhVuk”kd feyus
ds Åij gkml esa ,d LVsVesaV fn;k FkkA LVsVesaV ds ckn yksx mÙksftr gks x, vkSj ekax djus yxs fd
tsihlh cukvksA ftl Lyksxu “kkmfVax dh vki ckr dj jgs gSa] os ukjs ;gka ls yx jgs FksA ml le;
dkaxzsl izfri{k esa Fkh vkSj Lihdj Jh euksgj tks”kh th FksA ml le; eSa [kM+h gqbZ vkSj eSaus dgk fd vè;{k
th] vxj esjs izfri{k ds yksxksa dk larks’k tsihlh cukus ls gksrk gS rks eSa vHkh vkSj blh oDr tsihlh
Lohdkj djrh gwa] vki tsihlh ns nhft,A bruk gh ugha dgk] eSaus dgk fd budk larks’k djus ds fy,
vki ml tsihlh esa dsoy foi{k ds lkalnksa dks jf[k,] ljdkjh i{k dk ,d Hkh lkaln er jf[k,A ;g
fjdkMZ Hkh gekjk gSA eSaus ;g D;ksa dgk Fkk] iz.ko nk] eSaus ;g blfy, dgk Fkk] D;ksafd izfri{k dh ekax dks
eku ysuk ljdkj dh detksjh ugha] cfYd ljdkj dh ifjiDork dks n”kkZrk gSA vxj rqjar ekax eku yh
tk, rks ml ifjiDork ds lkFk xfjek Hkh tqM+ tkrh gSA It does not only demonstrate
maturity, it demonstrates magnanimity too. eSa ml le; dh dkjZokbZ ykbZ gwaA lcls igys eSa
;g dguk pkgwaxh fd eSaus Lo;a vkWQj fd;k
fd vki loky iwfN,] eSa cksy jgh gwa] Jherh
^^izfri{k dh ekax dks eku ysuk
lq’kek Lojkt vè;{k th ls eSaus dgk] D;ksafd ljdkj dh detksjh ugha] cfYd ljdkj dh
vkidks ekywe gS fd ftl le; dksbZ ea=h ifjiDork dks n”kkZrk gSA vxj rqjar ekax
LVsesaV nsrk gS rks yksdlHkk esa iz”u iwNus dh
btktr ugha gSA ml le; ihBklhu Lihdj eku yh tk, rks ml ifjiDork ds lkFk
us ;g dgk Fkk fd eSa dksbZ loky ugha iwNus xfjek Hkh tqM+ tkrh gSA**
nwaxk rks eSaus muls dgk fd vki bUgsa loky
iwNus nhft,A fQj mUgksaus dgk fd eSa
nks&rhu loky iwNus nwaxk rks eSaus dgk fd vki nks&rhu loky er iwNus nhft,] ftrus esEclZ loky
iwNuk pkgrs gSa] eSa mu lcds lokyksa dk tokc nwaxh] vki lcdks loky iwNus nhft,A mlds ckn mUgksaus
tsihlh dh ekax dhA ml le; eSaus D;k dgk] lcls igys eSa dguk pkgwaxh fd eSaus Lo;a vkWQj fd;k fd
vki loky iwfN,] ijEijk ls gVdj loky iwNs x;sA mlds ckn eSaus ;g vkWQj fd;k fd ,d&nks ;k rhu
ugha] ftrus lkaln loky iwNuk pkgsa] iwN ldrs gSaA mlds ckn mUgksaus dgk fd bl ekeys dh tkap ds
fy, tsihlh cukbZ tk, rks eSaus dgk fd ukjk yxkus dh t:jr ugha gS] vki rqjar tsihlh cukuk pkgrs gSa
rks cuk,aA eSa vkWQj dj jgh gwa fd vki tsihlh cuk,a vkSj ljdkj dk dksbZ O;fDr mlesa u j[ksa] foi{k ds
lnL; mlesa jgsaA Jh j?kqoa”k izlkn th dks mldk vè;{k cuk;k] ;g eSaus vkWQj fd;kA tsihlh esa dksbZ
ljdkjh i{k dk lnL; ugha gksxk] dsoy foi{k ds lnL;ksa dh tsihlh cuk,aA u;h ijEijk LFkkfir djsa]
dsoy foi{k dh desVh cuk,a] mlesa ljdkjh i{k dk dksbZ lnL; ugha gksxkA rc Lihdj egksn; us dgk
fd ljdkjh i{k ds lnL; ds fcuk desVh ugha cusxh rks eSaus dgk fd vki ,d vkSj ijEijk Mkfy,A
vè;{k ges”kk ljdkjh i{k dk gksrk gS] vki vè;{k foi{k dk cuk nhft,A ml le; Jh “kjn iokj th
dh vè;{krk esa tsihlh xfBr gqbZ FkhA vkt vkidks Jh v#.k tsVyh th dh ckr ;kn vk xbZ] ysfdu blh

05
 gkml esa cuh gqbZ bl desVh dh ;kn vkidks ugha vkbZ] ftl le; eSaus rqjar nks ?kaVs ds vanj&vanj tsihlh
dk ,syku fd;k FkkA 21 vxLr dks tsihlh Lohdkj dh Fkh vkSj 22 vxLr dks eSa eks”ku ysdj vk xbZ FkhA
blfy, eSa dguk pkgrh gwa fd izfri{k dh ekax ,sls gh ugha Fkh] izfri{k dh ekax blfy, Fkh] D;ksafd
Hkz’Vkpkj ds ,d ds ckn ,d dkaM mtkxj gks jgs FksA

lh-,-th- dh varfje fjiksVZ us fd;k ?kksVkyksa dk [kqyklk

vè;{kk th] eSaus vkils dgk fd ,d&,d dkaM ij tsihlh cuh gS] ysfdu bl ckj rks 3&3 dkaM
,d lkFk mHkjdj vk x;s Fks vkSj ;s dkaM tks vk;s Fks] iz.ko nk] blesa vkjksi foi{k us ugha yxk;s FksA ,d esa
Hkh foi{kh ny us vkjksi ugha yxk;k FkkA tks laLFkk ljdkj ds ys[ks&tks[ks dh] [kkrs dh tkap djrh gS]
lcls cM+h laLFkk daIVªksyj ,.M vkWfMVj tujy] ;g vkjksi mUgksaus yxk;k FkkA lkjs ds lkjs 2th LiSDVªe
esa 1-76 yk[k djksM+ dk vkadM+k gekjk x<+k gqvk ugha gSA mUgksaus tks pkj QkewZys fudkys] muesa ls ,d
QkewZys ds rgr mUgksaus ;g vkadM+k fudkykA mlds rgr ;g vkadM+k j[kkA
lh-MCY;w-th- dk ?kksVkyk lh-,-th- dh
^^;g tks tsihlh cu jgh gS] ;g baVfje fjiksVZ ls ckgj vk;kA fdlh foi{kh
tsihlh cgqr vlkèkkj.k ifjfLFkfr;ksa esa cu lnL; us vkjksi ugha yxk;kA ;gka rd fd
vkn”kZ lkslk;Vh dk ?kksVkyk egkjk’Vª ds
jgh gSA ;g tsihlh lkèkkj.k ifjfLFkfr esa ,dkma VsaV tujy us fudkykA eSa izèkkuea=h th
ugha cu jgh gSA ;g tsihlh dsoy ,d ls dguk pkgwaxh] vkt os bljks nsokl Mhy dh
?kksVkys dh tkap ds fy, ugha cu jgh gSA ckr dj jgs FksA og ?kksVkyk Hkh lh,th us
fudkyk] geus ugha fudkyk] ysfdu eSa gSjku gwa
vkt ns”k esa ,d ladV Nk;k gqvk gS] ns”k fd lh,th dh fjiksVZ ds Åij tc vkt ds
laØkafr dky ls xqtj jgk gSA** flfVax fefuLVj nwjlapkj ea=h ;g dgrs gSa
fd mlesa rks thjks ykWl gqvk gS] ftldks
lh,th 1-76 yk[k djksM+ dgrk gS] thjks ykWl gqvk gS] ea=h th] rks vkids iwoZ ea=h tsy ds ihNs D;ksa can gS
\ vxj thjks ykWl gqvk gS rks lhchvkbZ ckj&ckj mudk fjekaM D;ksa ekax jgh Fkh \ ea=h th esjs vius “kgj
ls vkrs gSa] esjs lkFk muds vPNs Lusgh lEcUèk Hkh gS] oSls esjs f[kykQ pquko Hkh yM+s gSa] ysfdu ;g yksdra=
esa pyrk jgrk gSA eSa mudh “kqHkfpfUrdk ds ukrs] mudh fgrS’kh gksus ds ukrs vkidks lykg nsuk pkgrh gwa
fd ,sls izlaxksa ij ea=h vxj pqi jgsa rks T;knk vPNk gksrk gS vkSj mfpr le; ij cksysa rks Bhd jgrk gSA
bl rjg dh ckrsa dgdj vki vius xys esa csotg dk Qank Myokrs gSa] tc nks rjQ tkap gks jgh gS vkSj
vc tsihlh cSB jgh gS] tsihlh nh tk jgh gS rks vki mlls igys gh dgrs gSa fd thjks ykWl gqvk gSA
vkidks tks dguk gS] vki tsihlh ds lkeus tkdj dg nhft,] nLrkost ys tkb;s] ysfdu vkius ;g
dgdj lh,th dh laLFkk ds lkeus iz”ufpUg [kM+k djus dk dke fd;kA
blfy, vè;{kk th] eSa dguk pkgrh gwa fd ;g tks tsihlh cu jgh gS] ;g tsihlh cgqr vlkèkkj.k
ifjfLFkfr;ksa esa cu jgh gSA ;g tsihlh lkèkkj.k ifjfLFkfr esa ugha cu jgh gSA ;g tsihlh dsoy ,d
?kksVkys dh tkap ds fy, ugha cu jgh gSA vkt ns”k esa ,d ladV Nk;k gqvk gS] ns”k laØkafr dky ls xqtj
jgk gSA

06
Hkz"Vkpkj & laoSèkkfud laLFkkvksa dh vuns[kh dk ifj.kke
dqN fnu igys izèkkuea=h th us ,d cgqr cM+k b”;w mBk;k Fkk] cgqr xEHkhj iz”u mBk;k Fkk vkSj
og iz”u U;k;ikfydk dh lfØ;rk dk FkkA mUgksaus jk’VªeaMy dh tks fofèk dkaÝsal gqbZ Fkha] ykW dkaÝsal gqbZ
Fkh] mlesa cksyrs gq, dqN ckr dgha Fkh% At the inauguration of 17th Commonwealth Law
Conference at Hyderabad, he spoke on 6th February, 2011.
tc vkius dgk %
“While the power of judicial review must be used to enforce
accountability, it must never be used to erode the legitimate role assigned to the
other branches of Government. This is vitally necessary to preserve the integrity
and sanctity of the constitutional scheme premised on the diffusion of sovereign
power.”
;g cgqr irs dh ckr gS] ysfdu eSa
izèkkuea=h th ls iwNuk pkgrh gwa fd ^^eSa izèkkuea=h th ls iwNuk pkgrh gwa
U;k;ikfydk dks vki ;g dg jgs gSa fd
laoSèkkfud laLFkkvksa dks dke djus nks] rqe
fd U;k;ikfydk dks vki ;g dg jgs gSa fd
mruk gh dke djks] ftruk rqEgsa fn;k x;k gS] laoSèkkfud laLFkkvksa dks dke djus nks] rqe
ysfdu D;k ljdkj vius lhus ij gkFk mruk gh dke djks] ftruk rqEgsa fn;k x;k
j[kdj dg ldrh gS fd mlus laoSèkkfud
laLFkkvksa dks dke djus fn;k gS \ eSa iqjkuh gS] ysfdu D;k ljdkj vius lhus ij gkFk
ckr ugha dg jgh] dsoy fiNyh lqizhe dksVZ j[kdj dg ldrh gS fd mlus laoSèkkfud
dh rhu fVIif.k;ksa dh ckr dj jgh gwaA
laLFkkvksa dks dke djus fn;k gS \**
lqizhedksVZ dh os rhu fVfIif.k;kaa fdl Ikj
vkbZ gSaA izèkkuea=h th] igyh fVIi.kh vkbZ]
tc lqizhedksVZ us ih,e dk ,QhMsfoV ekaxk] tks igys dHkh ugha gqvkA nwljk] tc lqizhedksVZ us lhchvkbZ
ls dgk fd Qkby djus ls igys pktZ”khV gesa fn[kkvks] ;g dHkh ugha gqvkA ysfdu ;g D;ksa gqvk] D;ksafd
vkius laln dh vuns[kh dh vkSj vkius tsihlh dk xBu djus ds ctk; lqizhedksVZ dh eksusVfjax esa
lhchvkbZ dh tkap izkjEHk djokbZA twfjlizwMsal dk fl)kar % If alternate remedy is available-
vkt vki iNrk jgs gksaxsA vxj vkius laln dh loksZPprk ekuh gksrh] vxj vkius ml le; tsihlh dk
xBu dj fn;k gksrk rks izèkkuea=h th] eSa ;gka [kM+h gksdj dg jgh gwa u rks lqizhedksVZ vkidk ,QhMsfoV
ekaxrk] u lqizhedksVZ dgrk fd lhchvkbZ gesa pktZ”khV fn[kk,] rks Qkby djsaA vkius gj rjg ds fodYi
gesa fn,A vkius dgk fd lqizhe dksVZ lhchvkbZ dks ekWfuVj dj ys] vki ;g eku yksA vkius gesa dgk fd
ge ih,lh ds lkFk bUosfLVxsfVo ,tsalht yxk nsrs gSa] mldk nk;jk c<+k nsrs gSa] bls eku yks] vki ckdh
lkjh phtsa djus ds fy, rS;kj Fks] exj tsihlh nsus dks rS;kj ugha FksA esjh le> ls ;g ckr ijs FkhA nks
ehfVaXl usrk lnu us cqyk;h vkSj ,d ehfVax vkius cqyk;hA rhuksa ehfVaXl esa izfri{k dh rjQ ls cksyrs

07
 gq, reke yksxksa us vius&vius rdZ nsdj dgk fd tsihlh D;ksa pkfg,\ buds leFkZd nyksa us dgk fd
tsihlh D;ksa pkfg, buds ?kVd nyksa us dgk fd tsihlh ns nks rks gesa vkifÙk ugha] ysfdu ljdkj us gesa
,d ckj Hkh ugha crk;k fd tsihlh D;ksa ugha nsuh gS\

tsihlh ^bubQsfDVo ckMh* gS] rks mlds xBu ls ljdkj D;¨a lgeh
eq>s ,d ckr ;kn gS tks vkids ?kj ij ?kVh FkhA vkius Hkkst ij cqyk;k Fkk] l= ds varjky esa ,d
igy vkius djuh pkgh FkhA vxj l= ds nkSjku jkLrk ugha fudyk rks pfy, vc fudkyrs gSaA vkius
vius ?kj ij ,d Hkkst fn;kA mlesa vkius usrk lnu dks cqyk;k] lalnh; dk;Z ea=h iou dqekj caly th
vkSj ukjk;.klkeh th dks cqyk;k vkSj bèkj ls eq>s vkSj vkMok.kh th dks cqyk;kA [kkuk [kkus ds ckn tc
ge ckr djus ds fy, cSBs rks eSaus dgk] iz.ko nk vki tsihlh D;ksa ugha nsrs] rks bUgksasus eqag fcpdkdj dgk
fd ,d bubQsfDVo ckWMh gSA eSaus dgk fd bubQsfDVo gS rks vkSj T;knk vklku gS] ns nksA bQsfDVo gks rks
ljdkj Mjs] vxj dksbZ bruh fu’izHkkoh laLFkk gS] bubQsfDVo ckWMh gS] rks ns nksA bUgksaus cgqr xaHkhj gksdj
dgk fd dksbZ Qk;nk ugha gSA vkidks ;kn
^^izèkkuea=h th us ;g ugha dgk fd gksxk] eSaus dgk Fkk fd ,d Qk;nk rks gSA
laln dh loksZPprk LFkkfir djus ds fy, mUgksaus dgk D;k] rks eSaus dgk laln py
ge tsihlh ns jgs gSaA mUgksaus dgk] D;ksafd tk,xhA rks og f[kyf[kykdj gal iM+s vkSj
rc vkius dgk Fkk -that is matchless.
iwjk dk iwjk l= [kRe gks x;k vkSj nwljk That is Sushma and I cannot answer
l= Hkh [kRe u gks tk,] blfy, ge tsihlh that. eq>s yxk fd “kk;n mlh fnu ls vkids
ns jgs gSaA mudks yxk fd bl rjg ls laln fnekx esa ;g ckr vk;h fd laln py tk,xh]
blfy, tsihlh nsuh pkfg,] D;ksafd og ckr
py tk,xhA** izèkkuea=h th ds ml oDrO; esa >ydhA
izèkkuea=h th us tks ckr ml fnu dgh] mlesa
dksbZ vkSj nwljk dkj.k ugha fn;kA ;g ugha dgk fd laln dh loksZPprk LFkkfir djus ds fy, ge tsihlh
ns jgs gSaA mUgksaus dgk] D;ksafd iwjk dk iwjk l= [kRe gks x;k vkSj nwljk l= Hkh [kRe u gks tk,] blfy,
ge tsihlh ns jgs gSaA mudks yxk fd bl rjg ls laln py tk,xhA pfy,] vkius gekjh ckr ekuh] pkgs
fdlh Hkh dkj.k ls ekuhA eSaus ml fnu Hkh izèkkuea=h th dk èkU;okn fd;k Fkk vkSj eSa vkt Hkh èkU;okn
djrh gwaA

#dh gqbZ laln lRrki{k ls T;knk izfri{k dks [kyrh gS

D;ksafd iz.ko nk laln pyus ds fy, cuh gS] #dus ds fy, ugha cuh gS] #dh gqbZ laln lcdks
[kyrh gSA izfri{k dks T;knk [kyrh gS] ysfdu vxj ljdkj vfM+;y joS;k gh viuk ys] rks fQj ge D;k
djsa\ fQj gekjs ikl dksbZ nwljk jkLrk ugha cprk gSA eSa izèkkuea=h th dks dguk pkgrh gwa fd lqizhe dksVZ
dh izfrdwy fVIi.kh blfy, vk;h] vkidk ,fQMsfoV blfy, ekaxk x;k D;ksafd vkius tsihlh dk xBu
ugha fd;kA lhchvkbZ dks pktZ”khV fn[kkus ds fy, lqizhedksVZ us blfy, dgk fd vkius tsihlh dk xBu

08
ugha fd;k] vkius laln dh vuns[kh dhA nwljh izfrdwy fVIi.kh fdl lanHkZ esa vk;h&lhohlh dh fu;qfDr
ijA ogka vkius usrk izfri{k laLFkk dh vuns[kh dhA usrk izfri{k dksbZ O;fDr ugha gksrk] og lq’kek Lojkt
ugha gS] vkt eSa gwa dy dksbZ vkSj gksxkA gels igys Jherh lksfu;k xkaèkh usrk izfri{k Fkha vkSj muls igys
Jherh bafnjk xkaèkh Hkh usrk izfri{k Fkhaa gekjs vkt ds izèkkuea=h Lo;a jkT; lHkk esa usrk izfri{k Fks] ysfdu
vkius usrk izfri{k dh vuns[kh dhA eSa dksbZ vujhtuscy ckr ugha dg jgh FkhA eSa flQZ ;g dg jgh Fkh
fd vkids }kjk fn;k x;k tks iSuy gS] mlesa ls cdk;k nks vfèkdkfj;ksa esa ls fdlh dks pqu yksA vxj
vkius pqu fy;k gksrk rks] esjh ckr eku yh gksrh] rks lhohlh ds lUnHkZ esa izfrdwy fVIi.kh vkidks ugha
lquuh iM+rh] ysfdu blfy, lquuh iM+h] D;ksafd vkius ,d vkSj laLFkk dh vuns[kh dhA rhljh izfrdwy
fVIi.kh dkys èku ds lUnHkZ esa vk;hA tc mUgksaus dgk fd ;g dsoy VSDl bostu ugha gS] D;ksafd ljdkj
dh rjQ ls ;g c;ku fn;k x;k fd ;g dj pksjh dk ekeyk gSA ml ij lqizhe dksVZ us fVIi.kh nh fd ;g
dj pksjh dk ekeyk ugha gS] jk’Vªh; laifÙk dh ywV gSA ogka vkius viuh ftEesnkjh dh vuns[kh dhA vxj
ljdkj us viuh ftEesnkjh le>h gksrh] pquko ds nkSjku vkius dgk Fkk] tc vkMok.kh th us bls eqn~nk
cuk;k fd vxj ge vk;saxs] rks ge Hkh dkyk èku okil fudkydj yk;saxsA vkius tks lkS fnu dk oknk
fd;k Fkk] vxj mlds fy, dqN iz;kl fd;k
gksrk] ysfdu vc rks ljdkj dks Ms<+ lky gks ^^laln pyus ds fy, cuh gS] #dus
x;s] vxj ml fn”kk esa dksbZ Bksl iz;kl fd;k ds fy, ugha cuh gS] #dh gqbZ laln lcdks
x;k gksrk vkSj ;g u dgk gksrk fd dsoy dj
pksjh dk ekeyk gS] rks ;g fVIi.kh Hkh ugha
[kyrh gSA izfri{k dks T;knk [kyrh gS]
vkrhA blfy, ;g vki ds fy, fpUru dk ysfdu vxj ljdkj vfM+;y joS;k gh
fo"k; gS A It is a matter of viuk ys] rks fQj ge D;k djsa\ fQj gekjs
introspection for you fd lafoèkku dh
ikl dksbZ nwljk jkLrk ugha cprk gSA**
laLFkkvksa dh vuns[kh dkSu dj jgk gS\
eSa vkt vkidks dgrh gwa fd vxj
laoSèkkfud laLFkkvksa dks ljdkj dke djus ns rks U;k;ikfydk dHkh lfØ; ugha gks ldrh] vfr lfØ;
ugha gks ldrh] D;ksafd ljdkj ds gkFkksa ls ihfM+r yksx tc U;k;ikfydk esa tkrs gSa rc U;k;ikfydk
lfØ;rk fn[kkrh gS] mRlkg esa vfr lfØ; gks tkrh gS ftls ge T;wMhf”k;y ,DVhfoTe dgrs gSaA ysfdu
mlds fy, nks’kh ljdkj gS] mlds fy, nks’kh ge yksx gSa tks U;k;ikfydk ds gkFk esa os phtsa nsrs gSa tks gesa
Lo;a dks djuh pkfg, blfy, eSa vkils dg jgh gwaA iz.ko nk vkius tks izkjEHk esa iwjs ns”k ds lanHkZ esa cksyk]
lp og gSA vkt iwjs ns”k esa yksdra= ds pkjksa LraHk yM+[kM+k jgs gSaA

y¨dra= ds fdlh Hkh LraHk esa Hkz"Vkpkj ls vfo'okl dk ladV

vè;{kk th] vki esjh bl ckr ds lkFk lk{kh gksaxhA vkt ns”k esa yksdra= ds pkjks LrEHk
foèkkf;dk] dk;Zikfydk] U;k;ikfydk vkSj izSl yM+[kM+k jgs gSaA pkjksa LrEHk lansg ds ?ksjs esa gSaA vfo”okl
dk ladV xgjk;k gqvk gSA gj O;fDr ,d&nwljs dks “kd dh fuxkg ls ns[k jgk gSA jkfM;k VsIl us bl
ra= dk [kks[kykiu mtkxj djds j[k fn;k gSA m|ksx txr bl rjg ls gekjh iwjh ikWfyfVDl es aizos”k

09
 dj x;k gS fd ea=h dkSu cusA blesa os gLr{ksi djrs gSaA fdl ea=h dks dkSu lk foHkkx fn;k tk,] blesa os
gLr{ksi djrs gSaA fdl dkWye esa D;k fy[kk tk,] blesa os gLr{ksi djrs gSaA dkSu lh [kcj izFke i`’B ij
Nis vkSj dkSu lh [kcj vkf[kjh i`’B ij Nis] blesa os gLr{ksi djrs gSaA iwjh O;oLFkk dks nhed [kk jgh gSA
iz.kc nk] blfy, eSa vkils dguk pkgrh gwa fd vkius tks VElZ cuk;h gSa bu VElZ esa vkius vkf[kj
esa tks fy[kk gS] mls O;kid dhft,A bl VElZ ds rhljs IokbaV esa vkius fy[kk gS&
“To make recommendations to ensure formulation of appropriate
procedure for implementation of laid down policy in the allocation and pricing of
telecom licences.”
vkius bls dsoy ogha rd lhfer j[k fn;kA loky dsoy VsyhdkWe ykblsalst ds izkslhtj dk
ugha gSA iwjh O;oLFkk <g jgh gSA tgka gkFk yxkvks] ogha HkjHkjk jgk gSA blfy, t:jr bl ckr dh gS fd
lkjs yksx cSBdj ,d lkFk fparu] euu djsaA tsihlh esa gekjs tks lkaln lkFkh tk jgs gSa] muls eSa gkFk
tksM+dj dguk pkgrh gwa] eq>s [kq”kh gS fd cgqr gh ofj’B lkFkh blesa j[ks x;s gSaA ;g tsihlh dsoy
nks’kkjksi.k ds fy, ugha cu jgh gSA fdlus vkcaVu dk fu.kZ; fy;k] dSls fy;k] fdruk uqdlku gqvk]
bldk vkdyu rks vki djsaxs gh] ysfdu vki
^^vkt ns”k esa yksdra= ds pkjks LrEHk ;g r; dhft, fd bl ra= dks okfil dSls
foèkkf;dk] dk;Zikfydk] U;k;ikfydk vkSj [kM+k fd;k tk,A bl O;oLFkk esa dkSu lh
[kkfe;ka vk x;h gSa] mu [kkfe;ksa dks dSls lqèkkjk
izSl yM+[kM+k jgs gSaA pkjksa LrEHk lansg ds ?ksjs tk,\ D;k pSDl ,aM cSysalst ugha gS \ vxj
esa gSaA vfo”okl dk ladV xgjk;k gqvk gSA ugha gSa rks dSls yk;s tk;sa\ vxj gSa vkSj mudk
gj O;fDr ,d&nwljs dks “kd dh fuxkg ls bEIyheSaVs”ku ugha gks jgk] rks mudh ikyuk
dSls dh tk;s\ D;ksafd vHkh fiNys fnuksa tc
ns[k jgk gSA** izèkkuea=h th dh iSzl dkaÝsl vk;h] rks mUgksaus
,d u;k iz”u ns”k ds lkeus [kM+k fd;kA
mUgksaus dgk fd mUgsa xBcaèku èkeZ dh etcwjh gSA
vè;{kk th] eSa vkils dguk pkgrh gwa fd bl ns”k esa xBcaèku ;qx iUnzg o’kZ igys “kq: gqvk vkSj
fudV Hkfo’; esa [kRe gksus okyk ugha gSA D;k ge ;g eku ysa fd xBcaèku dh ljdkjsa Hkz’V ljdkjsa gksaxh
vkSj Hkz’Vkpkj dk vkSfpR; fn[kkus ds fy, xBcaèku èkeZ dk lgkjk fy;k tk,xk\

Hkz”Vkpkj &xBcaèku èkeZ dh etcwjh ugha

vè;{kk th] eSa vkils dguk pkgrh gwa fd Hkz’Vkpkj vius vki esa vèkeZ gSA eSa ;g dg jgh gwa fd
vkxs Hkh ljdkjsa dksbfy,”ku dh gh vk,axhA vHkh nksuksa jk’Vªh; nyksa esa ls fdlh esa Hkh ;g rkdr ugha gS fd
og vdsys ljdkj cuk ysaA D;k xBcaèku èkeZ dk rdZ ysdj Hkz’Vkpkj dk vkSfpR; crk;k tk,xk\ blfy,
eSa vkils dguk pkgrh gaw fd Hkz’Vkpkj ,d vèkeZ gS vkSj ,d vèkeZ dks iuikus ds fy, èkeZ dk lgkjk ugha
fy;k tk ldrkA xBcaèku èkeZ dh etcwjh jktuSfrd eqn~nksa ij crk;h tk ldrh gSA
izèkkuea=h th] geus Hkh dksbfy,”ku ljdkj N% o’kZ pyk;h FkhA gekjk 24 nyksa dk xBcaèku FkkA

10
ge Hkh etcwjh dh ckr djrs Fks] exj jktuSfrd eqn~nksa ij tSls èkkjk 370 ge pkgrs Fks] exj gekjs ?kVd
ny ugha pkgrs Fks] rks ge vius dk;ZdÙkkZvksa dks le>krs Fks fd xBcaèku èkeZ dh etcwjh gS] blfy, ge
ugha dj ldsA ysfdu xBcaèku èkeZ csbZekuh dks <dus ds fy, ugha fd;k tk ldrkA bl le; eSa lcdh
rjQ ls ckr dj jgh gwaA bl le; eSa izfri{k dh ckr ugha dj jgh gwaA
eSa ;g dguk pkgrh gwa fd xBcaèku èkeZ ,d dksbfy,”ku lh,eih cukrk gS] ftls dkWeu fefuee
izksxzke dgk tkrk gSA ml dkWeu fefuee izksxzke esa dksbZ etcwjh gks rks ckr le> esa vkrh gS] ysfdu
dkWeu fefuee izksxzke vxj djI”ku eSfDlee izksxzke cu tk,xk] rks ns”k mls Lohdkj ugha djsxkA

flQZ tsihlh dk xBu dkQh ugha

eSa ,d lathnk ckr dj jgh gwa] iwjs ns”k ds lkeus ckr j[k jgh gwaA vkt ls igys tks tsihlht cuha
gSa] muesa ls fdlh Hkh tsihlh ij ;g ftEesnkjh ugha vkbZA T;knk ls T;knk fdlh ,d foHkkx ds fy, og
cuh FkhA vkius bl tsihlh dh Hkh rhljh VeZ
foHkkx ls lacafèkr cuk nhA esjk vkils ;g
^^Hkkjrh; yksdra= dh [kwclwjrh gS
dguk gS fd vxj dsoy foHkkxh; tkap djds
;g tsihlh mB tk,xh] rks og viuk dke iwjk fd ge tfVy ls tfVy ifjfLFkfr esa Hkh
ugha djsxhA gesa O;oLFkk esa lqèkkj ds fy, feycSBdj jkLrk fudkyrs gSaA vkt
tsihlh pkfg,A eSa ;g dsoy vkt ugha dg
jgh gwaA ,uMhVhoh dk ,d izksxzke gksrk
ifjfLFkfr tfVy gh ugha fodV gS vkSj ml
gS&okd fn VkdA mlesa bafM;u ,Dlizsl ds fodV ifjfLFkfr dh lkjh phtksa dks ge
,fMVj “ks[kj xqIrk ds lkFk ckr djrs gq,] le>sa] ml fodV ifjfLFkfr ls ns”k dks dSls
“khrdkyhu l= ds vxys fnu eSaus dgk Fkk]
tc mUgksaus eq>ls iwNk fd vki tsihlh D;ksa fudkyk tk, bl ij fopkj djsaA**
pkgrh gS\ eSaus dgk Fkk fd ih,lh viuk dke
dj jgh gS] ,dkm.V~l ns[k jgh gS fd fdruk uqdlku gqvk] Vªstjh dks og ns[k jgh gS] lqizhe dksVZ vkSj
lhchvkbZ Hkh bldh tkap dj jgh gS] ysfdu bl O;oLFkk esa tks nhed yx x;h gS] mlds ckjs esa dkSu
fopkj djsxkA rc eaSus dgk Fkk fd vkt vko”;drk gS feydj cSBus dh] bdV~Bs cSBus dh] lkjh phtksa dk
fo”ys’k.k djus dhA vkt tgka vkdj ge [kM+s gks x;s gSa ogka ls iwjh phtksa dks lqèkkjus dh t:jr gSA
blfy, esjk vkils dguk gS fd bl VeZ dks vki ,DliSaM dhft,A bldh rhljh VeZ vkius foHkkx ls
lacafèkr cuk nh gS] blls dke ugha pysxkA ,d cgqr cM+h ftEesnkjh bl tsihlh ij vkbZ gSA vkt ns”k
cgqr vk”kk Hkjh fuxkg ls ns[k jgk gSA tc laln ugha py jgh Fkh] rks dgha u dgha yksxksa esa NViVkgV Fkh
fd D;k gks jgk gS] yksdra= dk eafnj can D;ksa gS\ blfy, eSa vkils dguk pkgrh gwa fd vkids vkSj gekjs
feyus ls] geus ,d jkLrk fudkyk gSA igys Hkh fudkyk FkkA eSaus ml fnu izèkkuea=h th ds oDrO; ij
fjLikaM djrs gq, dgk Fkk fd ;g Hkkjrh; yksdra= dh [kwclwjrh gS fd ge tfVy ls tfVy ifjfLFkfr esa
Hkh feycSBdj jkLrk fudkyrs gSaA vkt ifjfLFkfr tfVy gh ugha fodV gS vkSj ml fodV ifjfLFkfr dh
lkjh phtksa dks ge le>sa] ml fodV ifjfLFkfr ls ns”k dks dSls fudkyk tk, bl ij fopkj djsaA ;g esjs

11
 vkSj vkids mcjus dk loky
ugha gS] ;g izfri{k vkSj lÙkk
i{k ds mcjus dk loky ugha gS]
;g loky gS ns”k dks blls
mckjus dk D;ksafd bl
ifjfLFkfr esa ns”k dk vkRecy
detksj gks jgk gSA yksxksa dks
;g yx jgk gS fd ge D;k djsa]
;g D;k gks x;k\ blfy, eSa
vkils ckj&ckj dgrh Fkh fd
tsihlh dk xBu dhft, rkfd
dqN lhfu;j yksx cSBsaA
vkReeaFku ds fy, cuh gSa
tsihlh] xgu fpUru ds fy,
cuh gS tsihlh] ;g tsihlh
dsoy 2th LisDVªe ds vkoaVu]
izkbflax vkSj ikWfylh dh tkap ds fy, ugha cuh gSA vki blds VElZ vkWQ jsQjsal dks O;kid djds bldks
;g dke nhft,] ojuk ftldks Hkh vki ps;jeSu cuk,axs] eSa dguk pkgwaxh fd tks esEclZ blesa gksa] os vkil
esa r; djsa fd ns”k dks dSls bl ifjfLFkfr ls mckjuk gS] blds fy, Bksl phtsa lq>kbZ tk,a vkSj ns”k esa og
rkdr gSA geesa feydj&cSBdj lqy>kus dh {kerk gS] ge ml {kerk dks fudkysa vkSj tc vki bl n”kZu
ij ckr djrs gSa] rks vkidks xqLlk dHkh ugha vkrkA vki tc bl n”kZu ij ckr djrs gSa] rks cgqr lathnxh
ls ckr djrs gSa] èkhj&xaHkhj ckr djrs gSaA blfy, eSa vkils dguk pkgrh gwa fd bl izLrko ij ge mlh
èkhj&xaHkhjrk ls fopkj djsaA
eSa ugha pkgrh Fkh fd ftl lathnxh ls eSa bl ckr dks ;gka j[k jgh gwa mlesa fdlh rjg dh
Vksdk&Vkdh gksA eq>s nq[k gS fd bruh èkhj&xEHkhj ckr esa Hkh Vksdk&Vkdh gqbZ gSA eSa vkils dguk pkgrh
gwa fd ftl èkhjrk vkSj xEHkhjrk dh bl tsihlh esa vko”;drk gS] oSls èkhj&xEHkhj lnL; bleas igqaps gSaA
blfy, esjk lHkh ls vkxzg gS fd vki dsoy bldh VElZ dks ns[kdj vxj ;s bls ,DliSaM dj nsa rks cgqr
vPNh ckr gS] ugha Hkh djsa rks Hkh bl fodV ifjfLFkfr ls ns”k dks mckjus ds fy, vki mik; lq>k,aA mu
Bksl mik;ksa dks tc ns”k lqusxk] rks ;g fxjrk gqvk fo”okl gS] ;g okil ykSVsxk vkSj ns”k bl ifjfLFkfr
ls okil vk,xk] ;g mEehn trkrs gq, eSa viuh ckr lekIr djrh gwa vkSj bl izLrko dk leFkZu djrh
gawA

12