Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Validation Du Code NSI3FS Sur Des Écoulements Turbulents Autour D'un Tablier de Pont Élémentaire
Validation Du Code NSI3FS Sur Des Écoulements Turbulents Autour D'un Tablier de Pont Élémentaire
N° 0283
Juillet 2003
THÈME 4
apport
technique
ISSN 0249-0803
!" #$%&'#)('
'* '+
#
%,- '.
#)/
$
%0213
4,5%0768
+
('('* '+
%9
:!;<;>=@?BADCFE'GHJIK=L?9MONQP$CFHRSCUTVIKWQCFHJ?9XZY
[5\^]_.`acb dfeg_h^ikjmlnegoqp`lroqstluek_.egvnjmluekowp
x `vzy{vzlu]_.`vZ|oq_.s^ig`}f`v
~Qzom`lZ
-V
rjws^sLoql5ln`|\tp^ekFh^`p@wwcb wh^egigik`lVmqqb q+sjwq`v
/{J9)B`/|o x `Vdf
q¡dsS`u_.`l x¢¤£ lnh x ek`ci ¢ `¥S`l x h2¦q`pl.vuh^ x `vcstuow§igv
x `/sLoqplnv+`lci ¢ jws^sjmue¨lnegoqp x¢ ekp^vljw©tekigegl £ vj £ uo £ ikjwvzluekFh^`vª«`njms^sSowzl¬jmegl+vzh^e¨ln` ®
h^p^`.v £ ueg` x `.lunjJ¦mjwhf} x `.¦mjwige x jmlnegoqpUvuht x `v4 £ oq_ £ lnueg`vvzek_.s^ig`v4Fh^eQoqpl_egv`p
£ ¦{e x `p^|`8ik`v/©Sowp^p^`vs^ £x ek|lnegoqp^v x `v/|o{`¯|ek`pFluv j £ zo £ i°jmvzlnegFh^`v`p±oqvz|egikikjmlnegoqp
¬²oqu| £ `³ikjw_.egpjwegu`wª´µp± £ qek_.`³luh^u©th^ik`pl`l`p"vzluuh^|lnh^z`³§t}f`w¶·ik`-_.o x ]ik`8¸-¹»º
htlnegikegv £ s^ £ vu`pljwe¨l x `v x^£ §|ek`p^|`v x jwptvig`v4¼oqpt`v x `.u`|ekz|h^ikjmluekoqp½¶9|`Fh^e`ljwe¨l
h^p x owhtln`.vuhtig`v|Jjwsjm|e¨l £ v x h¾|o x `® ©^eg`p¿st £x ekz`ig`v x oq_jwegp^`v x¢ ekp^vljw©tekigegl £ v
j £ zo £ i°jwvlnegFh^`v x `vzluuh^|lnh^z`®+\jwhfl'`y{p^owi x vª
ÀZ`vDvzek_h^ikjmlnegoqp^voqpl £ l £ `¥S`|lnh £ `vDsLoqh^$Fhjwplueg§`D|`·_jwht¦mjwegv|oq_.sLoqzlu`_.`pl
`lrh^p³_.o x ]ig`4©^e¨ÁÂ|oqht|\^`cj £ l £ s^zoqsLoqv £ `lrln`vzl £ ªL´Qp- £ qek_.`4§t}f`ig`v £ |oqh^ig`_.`plnv
oq©tln`pFh^vvzoqplV`pt|oqh^ujwq`jwplnvª½~9oqhtzljmpFli ¢ jws^s^jwue¨lnegoqp x `s^\ £ p^oq_.]pt`vluoqh^u©tekigikowpfÁ
pjwegu`v'©jmvuvu`vZ¬² £ Fh^`pt|`vj+p £ |`vuvzegl £ i ¢ hflnegikegvnjmluekowp x `qzoqv5_jwekigikjwq`vr`l x `4lu`_.s^v
x `vzek_h^ikjmlnegoqp2luu]v4igoqp^qv¶`p2sjmzlneg|htikeg`4sSowh^ x `v £ lnh x `v`p2owvu|egigi°jmluekowp¬²oqz| £ `mª
~9oqh^Z|`v x `zp^eg]u`vVegi9vz`_©tik`cÃlnz`p £ |`vzvnjwegu` x `lnz]vZ©^ek`p x^£ |uegu`i°j x yfp^jw_.ekFh^`
lnoqh^z©^egikigoqp^pjmekz`V`lekiSp ¢ `vzl5s^jwvÄvuÅtÄFh^`!|`vÄ_.o x ]ik`v x `luh^u©^htik`p^|`!_.oÆyq`p^p £ sjw Á
¦feg`ptp^`pl®ig`!¬jwekz`wª
ÇDȲÉÊBȲË$̲ͽÎLÊÏVÈKÍÐqÑÓÒzÔ5Õ×ÖÙØkÚmÐÆÒÛÝÜÒÞ ßÖÙàmÒzÛKáãâJäDåKâàÓæÓÖçÕÓÞ ÖÙáÓÛKÖçÕÓÞ è¨Û
ȲÉÊBȲË
4 !
±
!
%,- '.
4, '#)*
5%9'#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
L .
$%
«
`lulu` £ lnh x `!sjwzluek|eksL`®+i°j¦mjwige x jmlnegoqp x h|o x ` x½¢ egpln`ujw|luekowp .hte x `vlnuht|lnhtu`
Vdf
q¡dSªµ`/|o x `sS`u_.`l x `s^ £x ekz`ik`|oq_.sLoqzlu`_.`pl x¢ h^p^`vlnuht|lnhtu`vuowike x `
s^ikowp^ £ ` x jwp^v9h^p £ |oqh^ig`_.`pFl .^h^e x `wªq ¢ `}f`_.s^ig`5Fh^`ptoqh^vµjwigigoqp^vD|oqp^vze x^£ u``vlh^p
ljw©^igeg` x `sLoqpl_.egv`p_.oqht¦w`_.`pl'vuowh^vi ¢ jm|lnegoqp x h¦q`plJª{
3iS`×}tegvzlu`Zluuoqegv £ qeg_.`v
sSoqvzvueg©^ig`csSowh^ig`vZvueg_h^ikjmlnegoqp^vª Zp-§t}f`w¶½| ¢ `vzl® x egu`cFh^`cikjvlnzh^|luh^u`c`vzl!eg_._.omÁ
©^ekig`w¶Doqp u`jw x `jwigoquvcvzek_.s^ig`_.`pFli ¢¤£ |oqh^ig`_.`pFljwhflnoqh^ x h<s^uow§^i`lcik`vc¬²oqu|`v
`}f`z| £ `vcvuht4|`igh^e Á3|eª9$`.vz`|owp x `vl4ik` £ qek_.`.¬²oqu| £ oqvz|egikikjmlnegoqp`
l ãoqh¾lunjwptvuikjãÁ
lnegoqp ¶woqp+v ¢ jmlulnjw|\^`rjwigoquvQ®!|jwnjw|l £ uegvu`Qi ¢ egp^vljw©^egigegl £rx `Äln`igig`rowh.lu`igik`5¬² £ Fh^`pt|` x `
¬²oq jwq`wª@´µpt§^p ik`lnzoqegvueg]_.``vzlZh^p³ £ qeg_.`igek©^z`o ®.sjwzluek x `vZ|jwnjw|l £ uegvzlnegFh^`v
x y{pjw_.ekFh^`v x `-i°j¾vzlnzh^|luh^u` _jwvzvu`w¶«_.oq_.`pl x½¢ egp^`lneg`w¶·uegqe x egl £ ¶Qoqp i°jmekvzvu`³ig`
.h^e x `i°j._.`luluu``p_.oqht¦w`_.`plJª
3|eQoqp2htluekigegvu`uj-s^zekpt|egsjwig`_.`plcig`s^u`_eg` £ qek_.`mª9´µp`¥S`l x `st £ | £x `pln`v
£ lnh x `vµoqplµ_.oqplu £ Fh^`5i ¢ owp.jwuzeg¦mjwe¨lµjwvzvu`¼5©^ek`p®s^ £x egu`5ig` x oq_jwegp^` x¢ egp^vzlnjw©^egike¨l £
x¢ htp^`cvzluuh^|lnh^z`+_jwekv!Fh^`+s^jw|oqplnu`+ikj x `vu|uegstlnegoqp x `ci ¢¤£ |oqh^ig`_.`pFljwhflnoqh^ x `
|`lzln`vzluuh^|lnh^z` £ ljwe¨l's^igh^vr_jmht¦mjwekvz`wª
3|e½p^owh^vÄp ¢ jJ¦qoqp^v5hflnegikegv £ Fh ¢ h^ps^zow§iS`p 'avuhtÄik`Fh^`i©L`Jjmh^|oqhts x `V £ vuh^i¨ljãlnv
oqpl £ l £ s^h^©^ige £ vªDoq_._.` x jmp^vig`. £ qek_.` x `r`yfptoqi x vFh^eQp^oqh^v4egpFl £ z`vuvz`pl+`vzl
lnh^z©^h^ig`plJ¶mp^oqh^vDjƦwoqp^v9htlnegikegv £ ik`vD_.o x ]ig`v x `«lnh^z©^h^ig`p^|`Ä_.oÆyq`ptp £ `5s^ £ vz`plnv x jwp^v
ik` |o x `wª·À`v £ lnh x `vs^ £ | £x `pln`v |¬rjws^sLoqzl x `8'`|\t`u|\t`¾
Zr
3 Zo q
sjw'~µek`uz`Á ´µ_._jwpFh^`i oqhtup^`l«zjwp¦mqq oqplr_.oqpln £ Fh^`4ig`4_.o x ]ig` ÁÂ`s^vzekigoqp
+
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
"!
$#
4
½ #$%& 6 %
-¿'
roqh^vZs^ £ vu`pluoqp^vVeg|eik`vvzek_h^i°jãlnegoqp^v`¥½`|luh £ `v!vuh^ x `vZs^uow§^ikvr`p8'a/jJ¦w`|ig`
|o x `Vdf
+®i ¢ oq x u` qªt$jstu`vzvuegoqp vuh^ik`Vstuow§iL`vl5|ow_s^jw £ `jƦw`| x `v5 £ vuh^i¨ljãlnv
`}fs £ ueg_.`pljwh{} x h±5d{[ ªQB` r`yfptoqi x v x `i ¢ `}fs £ ueg`p^|`-`vzl x `i ¢ ow x z` x ` "!$#
sjwuowe ת
( "{% ,, ) "{w
$`v!_jwekigikjwq`v!igegvzl £ v®jwh^|\^`+owpFlVik`v!_Ã_.` x ek_.`ptvuegoqp^v +*-, w¶ , aZ`lig`vV¦{e Á
ln`vzvu`v x¢ `pln £ `vzoqpl§t} £ `vV®/.1032"46587:9
;<qªS`v_jwegikikjwq`vZoqpl £ l £ £ p £ £ vVjJ¦w`|ig`
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
+
!
'
S
$
$# +
+ #
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
"!
$#
i°j¬² £ {ht`p^|` x `vi w|\^` x `+lnowh^u©^egigikoqp x `i ¢ jwigi £ ` x `Qoqpjwu_jwp ikj ¬² £ Fh^`p^|`
x¢¤£ |\jwplnegigikoqptpjwq`-`vzlekptvuht¯vnjmpFlu` sLoqh^.`p±Ãlnz`-vzÅ^ UsLoqegpFluvsjms £ zeko x ` x `
i w|\t` x `vÄlnoqhtu©^egikigoqp^vª~oqh^Ä|`lzln`!_.Ã_.`!njmekvzoqpik`v £ |jwzlÁÂl3y{sL`v5`}fs £ zek_.`plnjwhf}
x `'s^u`vuvuegoqp/pt`rptoqh^vQvu`_©^ig`pl5sjmvQluu]v«§@jm©^ik`vªfdfh^Q|`zlnjwegp^v·|jwstlu`h^zv·oqpsL`htl«u`×Á
lnuowht¦q`µh^p^`Ävz`_.e¨ÁÂs £ uego x ek|egl £ `lµ_.Ã_.` x `vµsSoqegplnv§t}f`v«`p.jJ¦wjmi x `vµ|oqegp^vQjw_.oqplnvª
S
!
!
# # -
$
! #
µ~ \y{vuegFh^`_.`pl'egivu`_©^ig`Fh^`r|`v_.`vzh^u`v|owu`vzsSowp x `pl® x `vQlnoqh^z©^egikigoqp^v«Fh^e
vu`¬²oqz_.`pl x jwp^vi°j ¼oqp^`/|ekvujwekigig`_.`pl £ p £ £ `v.sjwik`vc|oqegp^v.jw_.oqpluvªµ$j³p^owpfÁ
s £ uego x eg|e¨l £ ¦{ek`pFl x `ikj-lnujã`|lnoqegu` x `|`vlnowh^u©^egigikoqptvcvuh^ik`s^uow§^i·Fh^e«`vlclnz]v
vu`ptvueg©^ik` ®-ik`h^csLoqvue¨lnegoqp egp^eglue°jmik` ekplu`njm|lnegoqp `pFluu`/ig`vlnoqh^z©^egikigoqp^v¶jJ¦q`|ik` .^owl
_oÆyw`p³`lZjƦw`|4i ¢ jwigi £ ` x ` Qoq p 4jmu_jwp x h-vzekigikjwq` ת
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
2
a #
!
#
!
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
Æ
"!
$#
:
roq_©^z` x `vuoq_._.`luv Æwqq
r oq_©^z` x `sSoqegplnv'vuhtrikj.vzlnzh^|luh^u` ã a
Zjã¯pt`_.`plZvuh^'ikj.s^jwuoqe
3vuowul uoqsL`
roq_©tu` x `|oqht|\^`vZvzlnzh^|luh^ £ `vZ®ikj+sjwzoqe
_.oÆyq`p x hs^u`_.ek`ZsLoqegpFl wq
KU , ( &
)u
"
[h^u©th^ik`p^|` p^oqp
r`y{p^oqi x v $! !
~Djwv x `!ln`_.s^v fª
ÀZ`i¨lj x `i°j.ikowe x `sjwzoqe Á
[`_.s^v'lnomljwi x `4ikj+vueg_h^ikjmluekoqp mqtª
&L¿ " ( "{w
3
ip ¢ yj.sjwvrs^ikjmln`jwh x `4s^z`vuvzekowp `p³jƦmjwi x `vZ©Loq x v x½¢ jmlzljwFh^`4`lZegip ¢ yj.sjwv x `
6
®ikj§p ¦woqegfª ÆtªÙ ¶Q_jwigq £ vu`v x^£ ¬jmh^igluv¶·| ¢ `vzl/`igik` Fh^e x oqp^pt`³ig`v/_.`egigik`h^uv
£ vzh^i¨ljmluv`p³oqvu|ekigi°jãlnegoqp³¬²oqz| £ `mª½$j x y{pjw_.ekFh^`cluoqh^z©^ekigigoqp^pjwegu`4p ¢ `vl!sjwv x^£ |ue¨ln`
!
KU , ( &
) (
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
#
# ! #
&L¿ " ( "{w
D~ jwv x `Vlu`_.s^v'`l x `i¨ljco _jmekv5ikj x^£ stu`vzvuegoqp jmhf}|oqekptv'jw_.oqplnv5`vl5lnzoqs qnjwp x `
6
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
Ó
"!
$#
S # #
+
'
! #
+
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
Æ
+ +#
!+
#
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
Ja
"!
$#
@ #
+!
!
#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
2 #
# ! #
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
Æ
"!
$#
Æ
# #
+
'
! #
+
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
+
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
Æ
"!
$#
roq_©^z` x `vuoq_._.`luv
2+ maqa
r oq_©^z` x `sSoqegplnv'vuhtrikj.vzlnzh^|luh^u` mq
Zjã¯pt`_.`plZvuh^'ikj.s^jwuoqe
3vuowluuoqsL`
roq_©tu` x `|oqht|\^`vZvzlnzh^|luh^ £ `vZ®ikj+sjwzoqe
_.oÆyq`p x hs^u`_.ek`ZsLoqegpFl ( w
`vzlrlnzoqs\jwhtl s^© x h³_.o x ]ig` ת@
3i$yj.h^p^`¬²oqln` x^£ s^z`vzvuegoqp `p³jw_.oqpl x `v©Loq x v
x `+¬²h^eglu` jw||uo{|\jwq` x `v4luoqh^z©^ekigigoqp^v׶$_jmekv4i°j x egvuvy{_ £ lnzek`/`vzl_.oqekptv_jwz{h £ `
{ht`-sLoqh^.ikj¾vzek_h^i°jãlnegoqp±vuhtig`-_jwegigi°jww`³ Á Ó fª
3|e'`p^|oqz`w¶«ik`v¦mjwze°jãlnegoqp^v x `
s^u`vuvuegoqp-vuoqplrvuh^ £ ¦mjwigh £ `vª
' (
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
2
Æ
#
# ! #
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
w
"!
$#
Æ
# #
+
'
! #
+
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
#
Ja
#
!
#
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
q
"!
$#
roq_©^z` x `vuoq_._.`luv maFma
r oq_©^z` x `sSoqegplnv'vuhtrikj.vzlnzh^|luh^u` mq
Zjã¯pt`_.`plZvuh^'ikj.s^jwuoqe
3vuowluuoqsL`
roq_©tu` x `|oqht|\^`vZvzlnzh^|luh^ £ `vZ®ikj+sjwzoqe
_.oÆyq`p x hs^u`_.ek`ZsLoqegpFl wq
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
w
#
# ! #
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
ma
"!
$#
Æ
# #
+
'
! #
+
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
w
"!
$#
$
KU , ( &
) ( )
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
+
J
#
# ! #
ikoqegp x½¢ Ãlnu`-p £ wikegq`Jjm©^ik`-s^h^egvuFh^` Fh ¢ oqp u`luuoqhf¦q` ikjp^owpfÁ3s £ zeko x eg|e¨l £x h^` ®Ui ¢ jw Á
njw|\^`_.`pl x `vlnoqhtu©^egikigoqp^vcjw||uo{|\ £ v+jmh¿s^uom§i·`lcikj³i £ q]u` x ekvzvzy{_ £ lnzek` Fh^e«`p
x^£ |oqh^ig`wªS`lzln`vueg_h^ikjmluekoqp-u`s^uo x h^e¨l'|`ikig` x h-_jwegikikjwq` Á w ¦qoqegZfª¤tª ª
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
w
"!
$#
2 # #
+
'
! #
+
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
(2
½w #
!
#
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
q
"!
$#
S #
# ! #
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
$
Sq # #
+
'
! #
+
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
"!
$#
½w #
!
#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
q
Sãa #
# ! #
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
wa
"!
$#
S # #
+
'
! #
+
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
4
½w #
!
#
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
q
"!
$#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
4+
S(+ #
# ! #
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
q
"!
$#
Sw # #
+
'
! #
+
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
2
½(2 #
!
#
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
a
"!
$#
$
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
a
Lw #
# ! #
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
aF
"!
$#
L$ # #
+
'
! #
+
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
a
S #
!
#
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
aqa
"!
$#
Sq #
!
#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
a
&
$
Zoq_©^u` x `vuow__.`lnv Æma #
Zoq_©^u` x `sLoqekpluvrvzh^'i°j.vzluuh^|lnh^z` Ó #
rjm¯p^`_.`pFlZvuhtrikj+sjwzoqe
3vzowlnzoqSs `
|oqh^|\t`vrvzlnzh^|luh^ £ `v®.ikj.sjwuowe +
_oÆyw`p x h-s^z`_.eg`rsSoqegpl
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
a
"!
$#
Lma #
# ! #
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
a
&+
L4 # #
+
'
! #
+
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
a
"!
$#
Sq #
!
#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
a
42
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
w
"!
$#
L+ #
# ! #
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
#
Lq # #
+
'
! #
+
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
q
"!
$#
S2 #
!
#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
w
roq_©tu` x `vuoq_._.`luv Æ Jwa
$
Z oq_©^u` x `sSowekplnv'vzh^'i°j+vzluuh^|lnh^z` 4 m
rjm¯p^`_.`pFlZvuhtrikj.sjwuowe hf}|oqegp^vZjw_.oqplnv
Zoq_©^u` x `|owh^|\^`vrvzluuh^|lnh^ £ `vV®+i°j.sjwzoqe +
_.oÆyq`p x hs^z`_.ek`'sSoqegpl
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
ma
"!
$#
@aq #
# ! #
KU , ( & " ÓN) K " ( &S * ,, ( & &' *q "
4
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
@a
# #
+
'
! #
+
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
w
"!
$#
LaF #
!
#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
+
La #
!
#
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
w
"!
$#
@awa #
# ! #
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
(2
@a& # #
+
'
! #
+
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
q
"!
$#
a
# ' #
! #
#
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
$
_.`egikig`h^zvZ £ vzh^iglnjmlnvª
¡Degpjwig`_.`plQig`Ä_jwekigikjwq` J$LNMO
NO NO$LsjwujweglDÃluu`Äig`5_.`egikig`h^µ|oq_.s^uow_egv
s^h^egvuFh^`/Fh ¢ h^p¿_jwegigi°jww`s^igh^vsL`lueglp^`sS`u_.`lsjwv x `vz` x^£ ©jwuujwvuvz` x `v
jw||uo{|\jwq`v x `!lnoqh^z©^egikigoqp^v ¦woqegrstikh^vr©jwv ª
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
"!
$#
O
Ä #
#
B`vZs^z`_.eg]u`vVvueg_hti°jmluekowp^vVjJ¦q`| x `v_jwegikikjwq`vZptoqp³ujm¯p £ vZ®ikjs^jwuoqeB`l x `v
_o x ]ik`v qÁÂ`vustekigoqp/jJ¦w`|roqhvujwp^vQigoqe x `'sjwzoqe^oqpl«_.oqpln £ Fh ¢ `p`¥S`l«i ¢ £ |oqh^ig`_.`pl
£ ljmegl_jmi x^£ |ue¨lJª½~µikh^vekp^Fh^e £ lnjwplJ¶`ikig`v!owpFl_.oqpln £ {ht` x `csL`lne¨lnv|\jwp^q`_.`plnv
sSoqhf¦wjmek`pFlQegp x htekz` x `5wuoqvzvu`vµ¦mjwze°jmluekowp^v x jwp^vµvuj¬²oqz_.` ¦qowekQig`v x e¨¥ £ u`pt|`v«`pluu`
ik`vV_jwekigikjwq`vjwvzy{_ £ luuegFh^`v`lVvzy{_ £ lnzekFh^`v ¦qowekVfªÙfª c`lfª fª ¶Loqh8jJ¦w`|c_.oqegp^v
x `!¦fegvu|oqvue¨l £ lnhtu©^h^ig`plu` ¦qoqegZfª {ªç ת
3 !
ȲÉÊBȲË
- # +#
q
lnu]vs^z]v x `³ikjsjmuoqe'`l x oqp^| x `v_jwekigig`vluu]v £ luek £ `v ®¾_owekp^v x `³_jwegigi°jww`v
©S`jwh^|owh^slnzoqs/qzoqvת V·ik`v_ £ lu\^o x `v5pFh^_ £ zekFh^`v x `!Vd{
£ jwqegvuvu`pl5_jwi½®|`
q`p^z` x `· £ ow_ £ lnzek`mªw´µpcsjmzlneg|htikeg`ig`|jwig|h^i x `v9|Jjwujw|l £ zekvlneg{ht`vµp^`·|oqp¦q`uq`sjwv
s^u]v x `vsjwzoqegvVFhjwp x ik`v!_jwekigig`vvuoqpl!luuoqs8sL`lueglu`vª rp¾jwhtlnz`cs^zoq©^ig]_.`.`vzlikj
ljwegikig` x `vÄ_jwegikikjwq`vÄ`lÄik`vÄsS`lne¨lnvÄs^jwv x `Zln`_.s^v{hte½|owp x h^egvu`pFlr® x `vÄvzek_h^ikjmlnegoqp^v
qoqh^z_jmp x `v`plu`_.s^v x `Z|Jjwig|h^iª`|eptoqh^vÄj|oqp x h^egl5®`vzvnjJyq` x `V_.ekptek_.egvu`5ikj
ljwegikig` x h _jwekigikjwq`sSowh^5ik`|jwik|h^i$`p £ qek_.`!¬²oqz| £ ª
`lulu` x `up^eg]z`Ävueg_h^ikjmluekoqpp ¢ jrsjwv x oqp^p £ ig`vD £ vzh^iglnjmlnv9Fh^`p^owh^vD`vus £ uegoqp^vªw´µp
`¥S`lZp^oqh^vjmlulu`p x egoqp^vZh^p^`jw_ £ igekownjmluekoqp x `ikj.s^ £x ek|lnegoqp x h³|o{`¯|eg`pl x½¢ jw_.oq Á
lnegvuvu`_.`pl x jwp^v!ig`v©jwvzvu`v¬² £ Fh^`p^|`v x `c¬²oq jwq`cs^htekvz{ht`| ¢ `vzl x jwptv!|`lzln`+¼oqp^`
{ht`ikj+{h^jwike¨l £4x `ikj x `vu|uegstlnegoqp x `4ikj x y{pjw_.ekFh^` x `vrluoqh^u©tekigikowp^v x `¦mjwe¨lZÃlnz`4ikj
s^ikhtvµvu`ptvueg©^ik`mª !µ|`lzln`5vueg_hti°jmluekowpj x owp^p £5x `v«|of`¯|eg`plnv«i°jmuq`_`plQvuh^s £ zek`h^uv
®.|`hf} jmlulu`p x htv ¦qoqegrfª ÆtªÙ ªdfeoqp `}tjw_.egp^``p x^£ lnjwegiik` x^£ uoqhtik`_`pl x `4ikj+vue Á
_h^ikjmlnegoqp<oqp |oqp^vzlnjmln`Fh^` x `v.jwznjw|\^`_.`plnv©jwvzvu`v+¬² £ Fh^`pt|`v x `/luoqh^z©^ekigigoqp^v
!
Ê-á!#"%$'&'(
Unité de recherche INRIA Sophia Antipolis
2004, route des Lucioles - BP 93 - 06902 Sophia Antipolis Cedex (France)
Unité de recherche INRIA Futurs : Parc Club Orsay Université - ZAC des Vignes
4, rue Jacques Monod - 91893 ORSAY Cedex (France)
Unité de recherche INRIA Lorraine : LORIA, Technopôle de Nancy-Brabois - Campus scientifique
615, rue du Jardin Botanique - BP 101 - 54602 Villers-lès-Nancy Cedex (France)
Unité de recherche INRIA Rennes : IRISA, Campus universitaire de Beaulieu - 35042 Rennes Cedex (France)
Unité de recherche INRIA Rhône-Alpes : 655, avenue de l’Europe - 38334 Montbonnot Saint-Ismier (France)
Unité de recherche INRIA Rocquencourt : Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt - BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)
Éditeur
INRIA - Domaine de Voluceau - Rocquencourt, BP 105 - 78153 Le Chesnay Cedex (France)
ISSN 0249-0803