Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jose Carlos Arias (PHD, Dba)
Jose Carlos Arias (PHD, Dba)
Abstract
This paper investigates three of the commonly- used analytical tools and concepts that are used to
help effectuate decisions in a business environment. The types of analytical models that are investigated
in this paper are probability theory and statistics, utility theory and game theory. Through investigating
these tools in this three-tired framework, the reader has a greater comprehension of how analytical tools
can be used to accomplish various reforms within a business or the business sector as a whole. Through
addressing the quantitative methods of business, those in management and cost- reassessment programs
can better understand the forces that are at work in their respective departments and within the business
environment as a whole.
Arias J.C. - Basic Analytical Tools Application in Business to Addressing Consumer Behaviors, Teambuilding, and Necessity
118 Business Intelligence Journal January
Arias J.C. - Basic Analytical Tools Application in Business to Addressing Consumer Behaviors, Teambuilding, and Necessity
120 Business Intelligence Journal January
where one article notes that: “Probability also takes into account variations based upon
theory and its offspring, inferential chance, where although the likelihood of a
statistics, constitute perhaps the most specific scenario can be compiled according
frustrating branch of human knowledge. to the existing factors at hand, it can also be
The abstractness of formal methods scares determined by those variables that do not
many people, and leads to frequent errors exist. This section shall demonstrate how
in the choice of procedures.” (Simon & both preset variables and chance figure into
Bruce: 1993) Indeed, the overwhelming the use of probability theory in an ordering
use of probability theory is a useful tool division of a glassware business.
only in scenarios where generalizations are Imagine that Randolph Glassworks has a
possible: No one would build a space shuttle very exclusive china pattern on hand as its
based upon the results of probability theory, upper- end model, and that the customers
but one could theoretically predict ordering a who order this pattern tend to do so most
preset number of products for a given month frequently in pieces rather than ordering the
based upon this method. One source writes set as a whole. Because of this, the company
that: “Probability theory freed researchers therefore needs to maintain full sets because
from the drudgery of repeated experiments. they need to keep track of the parts that are
With a few assumptions, researchers could most frequently ordered, and also to ensure
address a wide range of topics. While the that they have full sets on hand if a client
advances in statistics paved the way for wishes to order the entire set. The company
elegant analysis, the costs came high: therefore has decided to keep fifteen place
settings of its most expensive china on
• We could analyze only certain types of hand throughout the year in case it needs
statistics, such as the mean and standard to fill any type of order. Yet to maintain
deviation. these fifteen complete settings, the ordering
department also needs to be aware of which
• We had to make certain assumptions, pieces are the most likely to break and to
like the normality assumption, about the ensure that these pieces are constantly on
underlying distribution. hand in greater quantities. In this scenario,
the pieces that are most frequently ordered
• And researchers needed specialized are dinner plates and saucers for coffee
training to apply, understand, and cups: Using probability theory, the ordering
appreciate statistics.” (Lawrence & department therefore needs to order more of
Shafer: 1992) these items than any other item to ensure that
the company constantly has fifteen complete
Probability Theory in the Localized sets of china on hand.
Department
Probability Theory in the Business
Due to its limitations in a larger practice, Environment
probability theory is most applicable in
business within a smaller environment, such The least likely environment in business
as that created by the individual sections for a successful functionality of probability
of a business. What was made evident in theory is that of the business environment,
the earlier discussion on probability theory for the limitations that exist in probability
is that this method of analytical assessment theory makes this an unlikely tool for
determining business moves for a company. the Faculty of Theology at the University
As this paper shall describe in a later section, of Paris, had come out strongly against
other methods of analytical assessment are inoculation.
more effective in this type of environment. “Daniel Bernoulli [another
mathematician] applied his probability
Probability Theory in the Respective formulae for lotteries to the problem of
Industry smallpox. He calculated the number of
persons likely to be killed by smallpox
The best- known use of probability in a given time. Then, he calculated the
theory in business is within the industry as a gain in life expectancy from inoculation
whole: Specific industries such as insurance for any given age. His formulas were
and car manufacturers rely heavily on necessarily rather crude and the statistics
probability theory to help define the limits of mortality inadequate, but his results
for policies and the design specifications definitely favoured inoculation.”
for automobiles. Essentially, in the area
of probability theory and business, the This risk- versus- gain still exists in
use of this analytical method is done the modern business environment, where
according to the likelihood of damage or companies that do business that contains a
injury versus the constant state (life). This certain element of risk need to be aware of
area of business can trace its roots back the likelihood of injury to a customer, either
to the mid- eighteenth century, where one independently (insurance) or as a result of
source attributes probability theory in risk product use (car manufacturing). The end
assessment to the study of smallpox, where result of this assessment helps to create the
the mathematician D’Alembert attempted to parameters around which the business can
determine the risk assessment found within be conducted with the maximum amount of
inoculation to smallpox. This source notes: profit according to the minimum amount of
inherent risk.
“One urgent social issue which prompted To enumerate this concept further through
much argument about probability […] a quantitative method, the researcher uses
was inoculation against smallpox.. The the example of stocks of a company Genco.
procedure was not risk free. It involved Suppose a broker buy shares of Genco
impregnating the skin with live smallpox Corporation at a price of $100 per share and
pustules and could lead to death. At the intend to keep it on hold for one year for a
same time, however, over 10 percent dividend yield of 3%. Total rate of return of
of the populations of London and Paris the share can be estimated by the formula:
were being killed by the disease.
“For D’Alembert the choice was R=
Cash dividend Ending price of share − beginning price
+
Beginning price Beginning price
approximately as follows: a 1 in 7 longer-
term chance of dying of smallpox versus
a 1 in 200 short- term chance of dying Suppose the price of the stock changes
from the inoculation. Complicating the by 7% while its yield remains at 3% in one
issue was the generally small average week, then the total return is R= 3 + 7 %
life expectancy in Paris. In addition, = 10%. Genco’s stock price may yield 10%
conservative opinion in France, or it may yield differently but the yield will
including the Faculty of Medicine and be around 10% in the short run. The change
Arias J.C. - Basic Analytical Tools Application in Business to Addressing Consumer Behaviors, Teambuilding, and Necessity
122 Business Intelligence Journal January
in Genco’s stock’s price is basically based utility theory. This section shall define utility
on the volatility theory. For a short term the theory and how advances in technology
probability of the returns is easy to gauge have created an environment in which this
but in the long run, the volatility rate is method of assessment is most effective in
quite different. It is based on a range of predicting consumer responses.
deviation or probability distribution range.
For example if the possibility of not gaining Introduction to Utility Theory
return is zero then the probability ratio
of 10% return can be assigned as one. To The functionality of utility theory is best
determine the long term return, the broker found in measuring the preferences of an
will estimate probabilities of Genco’s stock individual or a target group of individuals and
in a weak, a strong and normal economy and measuring the impact of these preferences on
obtains the following figures: behaviors and beliefs. This practice should
sound familiar to any student in business,
State of Rate of Return –
Probability for the study of utility theory is the study of
Economy Genco
consumer buying behaviors. (Ford: 1987)
Strong 30% 0.20
In utility theory, the individual that is
Normal 10% 0.60
targeted for assessment is believed to be a
Weak -10% 0.20
rational individual who determines his or
her behaviors according to obvious needs
Using the above probability returns the or desires. The scale against which these
broker can further calculate the expected behaviors are measured is called a “utility”
returns: scale, and the ranking placed upon this scale
helps in the overall assessment of behaviors.
Expected Returns = Sum of (Probability The study of utility theory is by no means
of Return) x (Possible Return) a new area, but it has become a science over
the past five decades. The earliest methods
From the table ER = 0.20 X 30% + 0.6 x of utility theory in economic practice can be
10% +0.2 x -10% = 10% traced to a mathematician who suggested
that consumer behavior was essentially
Thus, the most likely return that a broker predefined according to set patterns of
will gain is 10% for Genco’s stock. The behavior, and that these behaviors could be
utility of probability theory can extended slightly altered or exploited: In his book
further if the broker decide to compare The Theory of Value, author Debreu (1959)
the price of Genco’s stock and that of its suggested that consumer behaviors could be
competitors. The outcome will give him an understood in the sense that these behaviors
idea as to which stock is a better investment created an “equilibrium” for consumers,
and which one poses a higher risk for returns. where if someone needed a product they
would seek out that product. Those seeking
Utility Theory to encourage consumers to change their
behaviors would not get them to alter their
Far more easy to understand than need but could instead alter their desires.
probability theory – and arguably the For example, if someone needs drain
method of quantitative assessment that is cleaner, this need cannot be changed but
most frequently used in business – is that of their decision of which drain cleaner to buy
Arias J.C. - Basic Analytical Tools Application in Business to Addressing Consumer Behaviors, Teambuilding, and Necessity
124 Business Intelligence Journal January
“In January of 1950, Melvin Dresher been replicated many times.) Dresher
and Merrill Flood conducted at the Rand and Flood interpreted this as evidence
Corporation an experiment which has against the general hypothesis that
had an enormous if indirect influence, players tend to choose Nash equilibrium
since it introduced the game that has strategies, and in favor of the hypothesis
subsequently come to be known as the that a cooperative “split the difference”
Prisoner’s Dilemma. The game they principle would be more powerful in
studied was the hundred- fold repetition organizing the data from games of this
of the matrix game given below, kind.”
between a fixed pair of subjects who Yet in a business setting, the welfare
communicated only their choices of row of a single company is weighed against
(1 or 2) or column (1 or 2). the potential benefits or losses that might
be incurred from interaction with another
(-1,2) (1/2, 1) company. (Webley et al: 1997) Game
(0, 1/2) (1, -1) theory is one way in which to best predict the
outcome of encounters between individuals
Payoffs were in pennies, with each and between organizations, as shall now be
player receiving the sum, over the clarified:
one hundred plays of the game, of his
payoffs in each play. The unique Nash Game Theory in the Localized
equilibrium prediction is that the players Environment
should choose (2,1) - the second row and
the first column - at each of the hundred Game theory in a localized environment
repetitions. Thus the predicted earnings is most often utilized as part of the team
of the players are 0 for the row player building process, where members of
(henceforth “Row”) and $0.50 for the a specific department are required to
column player (henceforth “Column”). participate in teaching tools that utilize game
Of course this is inefficient, since if the theory as a means of better understanding
players instead played (1,2) at every their role in business. For example, in the
period, for example, their earnings would aforementioned Randolph Glassworks there
be $0.50 for Row and $1.00 for Column seems to be a competition between two men
þ i.e. they would both earn more. in the design department for the attentions of
But this is not equilibrium behavior. their manager. The manager recognizes this
That equilibrium play is substantially competition as unhealthy only when one of
less profitable than cooperative play the men seeks to sabotage the other’s labor.
made Dresher and Flood anticipate Even after several meetings designed to solve
“correctly” that this game would present the problem, the manager is able to tell that
a demanding test of the equilibrium the problem persists and is afraid that it will
predictions. again erupt in a way that will harm the work
“The observed payoffs, for a pair of of one of the men. The manager determines
players […] were $0.40 for Row and that a day of team building is the best way
$0.65 for Column. This outcome is far to rectify this situation and he determines
from the equilibrium outcome, although that game theory is the best method of team
it also falls considerably short of perfect building to be used: Not only is the manager
cooperation. (This observation has since able to bring his department closer through
Arias J.C. - Basic Analytical Tools Application in Business to Addressing Consumer Behaviors, Teambuilding, and Necessity
126 Business Intelligence Journal January
Furnham, A. & Lewis, A. (1986) The Rudner, Lawrence M. & Shafer, Mary
Economic Mind: The Social Psychology Morello (1992). Resampling: a marriage
of Economic Behaviour. Brighton: of computers and statistics. Practical
Wheatsheaf. Assessment, Research & Evaluation,
3(5).
Johnson, I. (2000) And Still We Evolve:
A Handbook on the History of Modern Simon, J. L. & Bruce, P. (1993) “Probability
Science. British Columbia: Malapina and Statistics with Resampling Stats and
University. Mathematica.” Mathematica Journal.
Vol 3 (1) Winter.
Joyce, J. M (1999) The Foundations of
Causal Decision Theory. Cambridge Thrall, R.M., Coombs, C.H. & R.L. Davis
Studies in Probability, Induction, and (editors). (1954) Decision Processes.
Decision Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge New York: Wiley.
University Press.
Webb, P. (2002) “Laymans Guide to
Lawson, S. & Glowa, T. (2000) “Discrete Probabilty Theory.” Available online at:
Choice Experiments and Traditional http://www.peterwebb.co.uk/probability.
Conjoint Analysis.” Quirk’s Marketing htm
Research Review. May.
Webley, P, Burgoyne, C, Lea, S. & Young,
Lynch, J. G., Jr. (1998), “Presidential B. (1997) The Economic Psychology
Address: Reviewing”. Advances in of Everyday Life, Washington, D.C.:
Consumer Research, Vol. 25. International Series in Social Psychology.
Arias J.C. - Basic Analytical Tools Application in Business to Addressing Consumer Behaviors, Teambuilding, and Necessity