Professional Documents
Culture Documents
June11 Beacon
June11 Beacon
Volume 6 #6
Wading River Baptist Church
P.O. Box 438, 1635 Wading River-Manor Road, Wading River, NY 11792
(631) 929-3512; 929-6022
www.wrbc.us office@wrbc.us
A Tragedy of Errors
Part 1: Hermeneutics
Well, May 21st came, and Jesus didn’t. By Unfortunately, however, he has not, The first problem with Camping’s
this time, most of America knows that and it turns out that we have not seen the thinking is his view of divine revelation.
Family Radio’s founder, owner, and chief end of Camping’s mischief. In fact, he God’s revelation, he says, consists of three
Bible teacher, Harold Camping, publicly found his answers rather quickly. On May parts. The first two are as expected, the
declared that, according to the Bible, Jesus 23, Camping resumed taping his “Open Old Testament (1447-391 B. C.), and the
Christ would return to earth on May 21, Forum” program, declaring that he was off New Testament (A. D. 33-95). But, Camp-
2011, and divine judgment would begin. by five months. The earth will now be ing asserts, “the New Testament, like the
He was adamant. “Beyond the shadow of a obliterated on October 21, 2011. In other Old Testament, was written by God in such
doubt, May 21 will be the date of the Rap- words, we have to go through all of this a way that many truths set forth in it re-
ture and the day of judgment,” he said to nonsense again. He did exactly what Wil- mained hidden from the true believers of
reporter Tom Breen of the Associated Press liam Miller did in 1844, when Christ didn’t the church age” (p. 2). These hidden truths
in a January 3 interview. At 6:00 PM on come as predicted. He declared that May concern the accurate understanding of the
that day, local time, each time zone would 21st was indeed a “spiritual” judgment day timing of God’s salvation program and the
be hit by rolling catastrophic earthquakes. (some of us called that one!). Even his final 23 years of the history of the world.
Just how certain was he? In the same in- employees at Family Radio were dismayed Thus the third part of revelation is new
terview, he concluded, “If May 21 passes that they saw no humility, but only arro- truth: “It is almost like God has given us
and I’m still here, that means I wasn’t gance. Camping’s public relations aide, an addition to the Old and New Testa-
saved.” Tom Evans, told the Los Angeles Times, ments” (p. 3). The New Covenant is the
When the Lord Jesus did not return on “We obviously went too far, and that’s whole Bible, and God is now finishing our
May 21, did Camping hold a press confer- something we need to learn from.” But will understanding of the Bible.
ence and announce that he had not been they? That’s highly doubtful. Thus, Camping holds to a view of
saved all along? Did he even humbly con- The tragedy is that we have been God’s Word that includes new revelation.
fess his heretical date-setting, declare him- through all of this before when Camping This is a very serious error, but one that
self to be—by biblical definition—a false predicted the end of the world and the has, almost without exception, distin-
prophet, and then beg the forgiveness of coming of Christ in 1994, which didn’t guished false religions and the cults. They
his many blindly naïve followers? Did he happen because he (trained as a civil engi- hold to the Bible plus—the teaching of the
promise never to engage in this sort of neer) made a mathematical error! One Roman magisterium, Science with Key to
speculation again? Not at all. On May 22, would have thought that he would have the Scriptures, the Book of Mormon, the
Camping described himself to the news checked his math this time. He has, how- writings of Ellen G. White or Herbert W.
media as “flabbergasted,” and unable to ever, decided that since judgment and sal- Armstrong, etc. Every false religion claim-
explain why events didn’t transpire as he vation were completed on May 21st, he will ing to be Christian insists upon additional
expected. He was looking for answers, he not warn people anymore. Family Radio revelation beyond the Bible. Camping fits
said. Equally perplexed were his many will just play Christian music and Bible well into this category of “cult.” That is
disciples, some of whom had liquidated teaching programs. The world will have to why he has fallen into the errors of declar-
their life savings to spread the word of the be surprised when it is obliterated in Octo- ing that the church age ended in 1988, that
impending rapture via RV caravans, some ber! Christ died twice, and annihilationism
5,000 billboards, and full-page magazine The question that we are addressing in (there is no hell and the unsaved simply
advertisements. Camping and his predic- this issue of The Beacon is why Camping cease to exist).
tions have become the butt of irreverent makes these predictions. How do we ex- The second problem underlying
jokes throughout the media. Genuinely plain the obvious heretical nonsense of Camping’s theology is his faulty hermeneu-
evangelical believers, whose faith is tainted someone who says he believes that “the tics—his method of interpreting the Bible.
by the apocalyptic nonsense disseminated Bible is absolutely true and authoritative,” He insists that almost every church in the
by Family Radio, wish Camping would just and is God’s message of salvation (Camp- world cannot understand many truths of
go away. ing, We Are Almost There, p. 1)? the Bible, and that is because they don’t
obey the Bible’s instructions concerning
continued on page 2
1
continued from page 1
interpretation. Although he stresses the etc.” are used to represent the kingdom of caught (John 21), it is God’s purpose (#3)
importance of the original languages, he God. They are used spiritually of the to bring to heaven (#17) all those whom He
himself was never trained in the languages church which, during the church age (A. D. has saved.
and frequently betrays his ignorance. But 33-1988), externally represented the king- 5. Sometimes numbers prophesy a
the heart of his method of interpretation is dom of God (WAAT, pp. 9-11, 14). Like future event. Daniel 12:12 speaks of the
his “spiritualizing” hermeneutic. Camping most Reformed theologians, Camping re- blessing of those who come to the 1,335
reserves his most vitriolic scorn for the gards the 1,000 years of Revelation 20 as a days. This prophesies the coming of Jesus
“man-made” literal, historical-grammatical symbolic (“spiritual”) number representing whose ministry lasted from September 26,
method of biblical exegesis, the method the church age (“completeness”). The ac- A. D. 29 until May 22, A. D. 33, a total of
which interprets the biblical text according tual number was 1,955 years, but then ac- 1,335 days (!).
to the normal usage of language. Concrete tual numbers cannot be allowed to get in
6. The true understanding of any
language is understood concretely and the way! The insuperable difficulties
biblical truth comes only when the Holy
figurative language figuratively. It is no Camping faces in interpreting Revelation
Spirit decides that it is time for us to know
wonder that Camping is so hostile to this 20 this way are apparent when he says that
that truth.
hermeneutical method, because it is the in the church age, Satan was bound so as
only one that would ensure that he would not to deceive the nations, but even though 7. The ceremonial feast days are
not wander off into grievous interpretive he was bound, he still went about as a roar- shadows of things to come. Much of
error. This method, used consistently by ing lion (p. 15), leading to the failure of the Camping’s speculations about prophetic
conservative evangelical theologians, is to church. Bound or not bound, Mr. Camp- dates is grounded in the dating of the
be totally rejected, says Camping. ing? Which is it? ceremonial feasts.
The reason for this is that the Bible is a Camping justifies his approach to One can see the significant role that
“spiritual book.” His hermeneutical prin- prophecy with Daniel 12:9 (“these words numbers play in Camping’s hermeneutics.
ciple is based on Mark 4:33-34, which re- are concealed and sealed up until the end Even in the matter of biblical interpreta-
cords that Jesus “did not speak to them time”). The problem was that the “man- tion, however, it’s true that “there is noth-
[the crowds] without a parable.” However, made” hermeneutics of the churches “made ing new under the sun” (Eccl 1:9). Camp-
Camping conveniently leaves out the rest of a great amount of biblical information in- ing’s fascination with and manipulation of
verse 34: “but He was explaining every- accessible” (pp. 19-21). In his view, the numbers reflects the Jewish Kabbalah, a
thing privately to His own disciples.” Thus, entire Bible is a parable. There is hidden brand of esoteric mysticism with roots in
Camping assumes that every detail in spiritual meaning behind each historical the 1st century, but which fully emerged in
Scripture has some hidden, mystical mean- detail, and finding the truth “requires an the Middle Ages. Jewish exegesis was
ing; and when it comes to prophecy, the immense amount of Bible study” (p. 19). founded on four methods, only one of
keys to understanding have only been re- He, of course, was willing to do that im- which was the literal sense (Peshat); the
vealed since the end of the church age in mense amount of study, and thus, “almost other three involved mystical, hidden, and
1988. every day new truth is pouring from the allegorical interpretations. Kabbalah
Bible” (p. 21). Alluding to Amos 3:7 (that (“tradition”) claimed secret knowledge of
Camping’s background is in the Re-
God “does nothing unless He reveals His the unwritten Torah communicated by God
formed Church, and this denomination is
secret counsel to His servants the proph- to Adam and Moses, knowledge which pro-
committed to Covenant Theology with its
ets”), Camping assumes he is the one to vided a way of directly approaching God.
accompanying amillennialism. Reformed
whom God has revealed His secrets, thus Texts were interpreted according to the
theology has, for the most part, historically
tacitly ascribing to himself the status of a real and the symbolic. Kabbalism assigned
ignored the details of biblical prophecy; it
prophet (p. 22). meaning to letters of the Hebrew alphabet,
has dismissed the interpretation of pro-
and eventually involved magic formulas
phetic truth based on literal, historical- Here, then, are the basic principles of
and the symbolism of numbers (the meth-
grammatical exegesis. This interpretive interpretation embraced by Harold Camp-
od called “Gematria” which is similar to
mysticism, better described as “allegoriz- ing as he has given them (WAAT, pp. 24-
Camping’s speculations).
ing” than “spiritualizing” (there’s nothing 26).
spiritual about faulty interpretation), has In the Middle Ages, the influence of
1. The Bible is a very analytical
therefore distinguished Reformed escha- Kabbalism was passed down through
book, written like an engineering book,
tology, but not its approach to other divi- Jerome and Augustine to Roman Catholic
where truth is presented as absolute fact.
sions of theology. For example, Reformed Scholasticism in the quadriga (the fourfold
2. Each and every number recorded sense of Scripture: literal, allegorical, ana-
theology does not allegorize the cross (or
in the Bible is accurate, even if it is difficult gogical, and tropological). Thus the text
other doctrines concerning salvation).
to understand. usually did not mean what it seems to
When it comes to eschatology, however,
Reformed theology has chosen to employ 3. There is great precision in the mean, and Camping has eagerly embraced
so-called “special hermeneutics,” which occurrence of historical events (numbers of a similar approach to interpretation.
amounts to the application of allegorizing years, etc.). The important reality about these sys-
to biblical prophecy where it would reject 4. Frequently, God uses numbers to tems of interpretation is that they all led to
that approach to the rest of theology. What illustrate spiritual truth. Camping assigns serious theological error, and by adopting
Camping does, then, is to extend mystical specific meaning to specific numbers (2, 3, similar non-literal interpretive methods,
hermeneutics to details of prophecy which 4, 5, 7, 10, 11, 12, 13, 17, 23, 37, 40, 43). Camping has likewise perpetrated decep-
most Reformed, amillennial preachers and Number 17, for example, symbolizes tive beliefs. He has many devoted follow-
teachers have treated superficially, or not heaven, and number 43, God’s wrath or ers, and his refusal to acknowledge the
at all. judgment. Large numbers are then broken errors of his beliefs and his persistence in
Specifically, words like “Canaan, Is- down into smaller numbers. 153 is 3 x 3 x date-setting may lead to the development
rael, Judah, Jerusalem, Zion, the temple, 17. Thus as for the 153 fish the disciples of an identifiable new cult. Believers fully
continued on page 3
2
continued from page 2
committed to the truth of the inerrant and wasn’t saved.” Mr. Camping needs to give knowledge of our Lord and Savior Jesus
authoritative Word of God should be aware that statement serious consideration now Christ” (2 Pet 3:18), and living faithfully
of this danger and reject all past, present, that May 21st has come and gone. His fol- until He actually does return. Maranatha!
and future influence from Camping. lowers need to do the same, and then move
Perhaps the most sobering issue of all forward by rejecting his teachings, joining ⎯ Pastor Ron Glass
is Camping’s words quoted above, “If May solid Bible-preaching churches, commit-
21 passes and I’m still here, that means I ting themselves to “grow in the grace and
A Month in Review
April 29, 2011 will be a date remembered Mother, very representative of how WRBC recipients of a special 1st prize award.
by the history books; the date when Prince honors our mothers. May God continue to May 14, 2011 – For the seniors that are in
William of Wales married Kate Middleton. bless and honor moms, especially those senior denial and missing the Senior Saints
The attention given to this royal wedding who honor His Word. Luncheons, you have missed another out-
captured the hearts and souls of people standing luncheon honoring our vets and
worldwide as everyone lived in the fantasy coming together as God’s Army for a meat-
of the event. The pomp and circumstance loaf and mashed potato
given to such an occasion in the grandeur luncheon. It was a record
of Westminster Abbey was beyond all ex- turnout to hear Bill
pectations of one’s imagination. Mallman not only lead
But for those that love the Lord and are the devotions but to hear
constantly waiting for Christ’s return, April him make a “joyful noise”
29, 2011 will not hold a candle to what is on his harmonica and
awaiting God’s children. May this royal May 13, 2011 – Not enough is ever said banjo. Diane Pandolfini showed up in full
wedding be a reminder to be ready for our about WRBC’s AWANA program under the army gear supplied by her son serving in
royal ascension in the pomp and circum- leadership of Chris and Jackie Hallstrom. the army; this was Diane’s tribute to our
stance of God’s love? They run a full schedule of Friday nights fighting men. Closing the activities for the
May 1, 2011 – The Bible study resumed at beginning in September through the end of afternoon was a very loving and surprising
the Hallstrom’s home after a month of can- May, with sometimes as many as 16 young- acknowledgement to the Senior Saints
celed meetings due to excessive holiday sters attending. One of the favorite events leader (that would be me, Joan Tyska) on
scheduling. Only, this particular Bible remains the Grand her birthday. Even a writer can be lost for
study started an hour Prix when each words at moments like this; so humbly I
earlier to accommodate AWANA participant say⎯thank you!
a surprise 60th birthday purchases a small pine block of wood and
buffet to honor Doug plastic wheels from which they construct
Heuzey. Bonnie Heuzey, their cars, hopefully getting one or both of
with Jackie Hallstrom their parents involved
assisting, put together a with the project. The
wonderful buffet, birthday cake and all, to cars race on a wooden
celebrate Doug’s milestone birthday of 60 two-lane track, this year
years. run by Kendal Conway, May 21, 2011 – Congratulations are in
May 5, 2011 – Regular Wednesday night one of the AWANA assis- order for Mike Pandolfini on his retirement
prayer was moved to Thursday night to tants. Awards are given for the best design after 23 years with the Long Island Rail-
accommodate National Day of Prayer. It and the fastest car. The following Friday, road.
was a time when churches all across Amer- May 20, 2011 was the final night of
ica observed this annual event with unified AWANA for the 2010-2011 season where
prayers for our nation. Let not the prayers awards were given out and the AWANA
stop as we continue to pray for our nation kids were able to spend their AWANA dol-
and our leaders at such a critical time. May lars in the AWANA store set up for this
we continue to pray daily for a revival purpose. Throughout the year, the kids
among evangelical churches in America were able to earn “dollars” through club
May 21, 2011 – Spring work day turned
and a great awakening of lost sinners? attendance, wearing their
out to be the perfect day weather wise to
May 8, 2011 – Pastor Glass never forgets uniform, bringing their
tidy up around WRBC. Flower beds were
to honor the mothers on Mother’s Day handbooks, bringing a
weeded and cultivated, curbing repaired,
visitor, and completing
⎯especially his own Mother⎯as he fea- bushes trimmed, the kitchen cleaned, and
handbook sections. Jacob
tured his Mom in the May issue of The the biggest project of all⎯the garage was
Chapman was one of the
Beacon. It was a wonderful tribute to his cleaned out. Clutter had been collecting in
continued on page 6
5
continued from page 5
the garage for many years, and for Cheryl and historic definition of marriage in the July 25-29 seems a good distance away, but
Sunderland and Maureen Glass, this was face of a powerful effort on the part of Gov- plans are already in the working for
not only a big task at hand but a most cou- ernor Cuomo and some in the state assem- WRBC’s Vacation Bible School. Please
rageous move on their part. bly to pass legislation permitting same-sex pray that it will all come together in a
May 22, 2011 was designated as “Mayday marriage in New York. The bill has been timely fashion.
for Marriage” Sunday by the New Yorker’s put under the disguise of Governor ⎯ Joan Tyska
Family Research Foundation as New York Cuomo’s Program Bill, so stay alert to its
churches focused on preserving the biblical progress.
A Tragedy of Errors
Part 2: Eschatology
In his cover article, Pastor Glass addressed May 21, 2011. Camping factors 722,500 into October 2, 7 B.C. – Birth of Jesus.
both the incorrect view of divine revelation (5 × 10 × 17) × (5 × 10 × 17), and comments: Camping maintains that Jesus was born on a
and the faulty, allegorizing hermeneutic of “We have learned the spiritual meaning of year of jubilee (WAAT, p. 27; cf. Lev 25:8-13).
Harold Camping, the president and principal these numbers. The work of the atonement April 1, A.D. 33 – The Crucifixion.
Bible teacher of Family Radio. This article (5) is completed (10) when all of the elect are
will build upon the foundation laid by Pastor May 22, A.D. 33 – The Beginning of the
safely in heaven (17). This wonderful fact is
Glass and will summarize Mr. Camping’s Church Age. “The church age officially be-
doubled by the repetition of the three num-
overall chronology (his timeline which begins gan on the following Pentecost” (WAAT, p.
bers, 10 × 5 × 17. This emphasis is, according
with creation and concludes with the end of 50), which is affirmed by Scripture (Acts 2).
to Genesis 41:32, ‘because the thing is estab-
the world) as well as his eschatology (doctrine lished by God, and God will shortly bring it May 21, 1988 – End of the Church Age.
of the last things). to pass’” (WAAT, p. 61). “For 1,955 years, the churches all over the
The information communicated in this article world were symbolic of the kingdom of
Let’s examine twelve important dates in
is from the revised edition (August 2010) of a God…Truly, God was forever finished using
Camping’s chronology, starting with Creation.
document authored by Camping entitled, We the churches to represent the kingdom of
11013 B.C. – Creation. Camping places the God” (WAAT, p. 41). Camping’s eschatology
Are Almost There! (WAAT). To download
year of God’s creation of the heavens and the contains a 23-year (8,400 days = 7 × 12 × 100
this book, go to:
earth seven millennia earlier than did James days) “great tribulation” period that follows
http://www.familyradio.com/graphical/litera Ussher (A.D. 1581-1656), the biblical scholar immediately after the church age and which
ture/waat/waat.pdf and Archbishop of Armagh in the Church of he divides into two unequal parts.
Camping’s chronology is based upon his con- Ireland. Ussher, in his monumental work The
September 7, 1994 – Completion of the
viction that numbers recorded in the Bible Annals of the World, deduced that the first
first part of the great tribulation. The
frequently have a “spiritual meaning” in addi- day of creation commenced at nightfall pre-
2,300-day period between May 21, 1988, and
tion to an “earthly, literal meaning” (WAAT, ceding Sunday, October 23, 4004 B.C. An-
September 7, 1994, “was a time when all over
p. 51). To the fourteen integers listed below, swers in Genesis has made Ussher’s respected
the world, and within all of the churches,
Camping has assigned the following spiritual chronology available in a graphical format:
virtually no one was being saved” (WAAT, p.
meanings: http://www.answersingenesis.org/creation/v
27/i4/TimelineOfTheBible.pdf 43). Camping also notes that 3 × 1,290 years
2 – those who have been commissioned to (10 × 3 × 3 × 43) had elapsed since Jacob de-
bring the Gospel. 4990 B.C. – The Flood. This cataclysmic
parted Canaan for Egypt, once again invoking
3 – God’s purpose. event occurred 6023 = 6000 + 23 years after
Daniel 12:11 (p. 40).
4 – The farthest extent in time or in distance creation; the mystical meaning that Camping
that God spiritually has in view. ascribes to the number 23 is God’s wrath or May 21, 2011 – Conclusion of the sec-
5 – The atonement, which emphasizes both judgment. Archbishop Ussher dated the ond part of the tribulation, and the
judgment and salvation. global flood of Noah’s day at 2349 B.C. Rapture of the church. According to
7 – The perfect fulfillment of God’s purpose. Camping, the last 17 years have actually been
1877 B.C. – Jacob to Egypt. “When Jacob
10 – The completeness of whatever is in view. “the 6,100-day final period of salvation”
and his family were commanded to leave the
11 – The first coming of Christ, 11,000 years (WAAT, p. 54). “The Holy Spirit was poured
land of Canaan, it was like being commanded out so that outside of the churches, that is,
after creation. to leave the kingdom of God” (WAAT, p. 41).
12 – The fullness of whatever is in view. completely independent of any church any-
13 – The end of the world, the details of 1447 B.C. – The Exodus. Camping accu- where in the world, a great multitude, which
which began exactly 13,000 years after crea- rately states that “Israel was in Egypt for 430 no man could number, would become saved.”
tion. years to the very day (Exodus 12:40-41)” (p. Although believers were not removed from
17 – Heaven. 29). However, it is vital to note at this point the earth on May 21, Camping insisted that a
23 – God’s wrath or judgment. that Camping fails to consistently distinguish “spiritual” judgment had still occurred.
37 – God’s wrath or judgment. between Israel, God’s earthly, covenant na-
October 21, 2011 – End of the world.
40 – Testing. tion, and the Church, the heavenly body and
Not surprisingly, Camping assigns spiritual
43 – God’s wrath or judgment. bride of Christ. “The Bible frequently uses
meaning to the 153 days following May 21.
words such as Israel, Judah, the temple, etc.,
Camping frequently represents the large “The number 153 spiritually breaks down to 3
in speaking about the churches of the church
numbers in his chronology as the product of × 3 × 17, just as it does when we examined the
age” (WAAT, p. 9).
multiple smaller numbers included in the 153 fish” (WAAT, p. 62). Camping strains to
above list. For example, according to his Bib- 587 B.C. – Babylonian destruction of further justify this date by representing the
lical timeline, there are 722,500 days (inclu- Jerusalem and the Temple. Camping 1,978 years between the Cross and the Apoca-
sively) between the Crucifixion of the Lord cites Daniel 12:11 in an attempt to explain the lypse as 2 × 23 × 43, and by claiming that
Jesus Christ on April 1, A.D. 33, and the 1,290-year interval between Jacob and his 7,000 years have elapsed since Noah’s flood.
(falsely predicted) Rapture of the church on family leaving Canaan and the destruction of
Jerusalem at the hand of the Babylonians. ⎯ Peter Albrecht
6
June Bible Quiz Questions May Bible Quiz Answers
1) Name the daughter of Ishmael who became a wife of Esau. 1) Egypt (Isaiah 30:7; Psalms 87:4).
2) What was the name of the city that Lot escaped to when 2) True (1 Peter 2:5, 9; Revelation 5:10; 20:6).
Sodom and Gomorrah were destroyed?
3) Forty days and forty nights (Genesis 7:11-12).
3) Who built the first temple in Jerusalem?
4) A rainbow (Genesis 9:8-17).
4) Which two books of the Bible are named after priests?
5) Antioch in Pisidia (Acts 13:14). Note: Antioch was a
5) By whom was the Apostle Paul baptized? city of southern Asia Minor in Phrygia, situated just
Bonus: What is the branch of systematic theology dealing north of the territory of Pisidia.
with the doctrine of salvation called? Bonus: Castor and Pollux, twin sons of Zeus, the chief
― Felix Acerra Greek god.
7
PO Box 438
Wading River, NY 11792
Our Purpose
Wading River Baptist Church 1. To glorify God through sharing
the good news of salvation by God’s
sovereign grace through faith in His
Son, the Lord Jesus Christ.