zzD sa]zD

1972_ kBV . iJ]l[ The Impossible Question [D

g A>][ uz]l_ c^ gVkm mBVo[ >twVD m.
1970D g| g 8D >] W> mBV_. uV| V
V\ kEz [D \M>[ [xD t\Vk > zmD,
W \Vk>uV V]B^ zmD ]_ |^.
>ta_: V][

Ql[

B_D >[ |\V>D

zm u mBVVD. [D >V
kVD.
\M> \]KD >[ [skV J]KD
\VuD >k [> cD kl_, \m
QB zm gVFkm kEB\Vm.
Ql[ _ x\BV \VuD V]BD
>VV [> mV^ >^ gw\VD
_ k^m. M_ \m B_V|^
l[BV _m ys\VkV, \V
\V>V _m gw\V>V mD
Qlo> >V[[, k|[.
Ql_ _k V, ^ u
|^. kV D kV \B]_
x>[\ m. kVV z
|^ Ql[ c^> k Am
V^D, [ > m _k>uV
V]B>D cV\_, >B xBmkD
kVF> VB]_ ~|VKD m \KD zw
B WB\V >VuszD. >
>kV AmV^>_ kEBD. _
BM_ kVs[ \V \m c_ _m
_m D V[ >V s_
\|\ su]\V k> VD Km
km VVs|D. u QD, ]om
>VuD D m kBV B_V|
D >s BV> xD mB

\ >VuszD. z>\V kD
kV> sD m cz A>V?
^ >D [|> k|D
_m  k|D [ \z V\
V_oV^kmD
>\um.
M_
Wl_ k BV [D, m zm
B>D \uV^km\VB ^ [
. k u \>V_, m
D x\BV kM>uzB ka
k >V k|D. [ V m z>
VD mBV|kVD.
c_, \D, J c DB_ V>
ED, kuV| B QD VD
kV VV]uu kB|^m
[> V[ c[. > VVD V>
kVx x>B >xlVKD, M k
B >xlVKD >Vus|m.
_k V|^ QB
|mk> >sm, suz \|\
] xBmkD kwzk>V \m B_^
kV[D >s BV>kV D zw
>B sszD. J >V|, \>
D, kV> VV| _m cVBV
V[ B_Vuz \|\ x>[\
m WB\V xB >Vusm.
k m \KD zwB sszD.
> VD cV\V? >B_VD c

kl_ k s>\V |D.

Bu B_ c^>V? \KD |m Ww
B \uV BV| xV> x\
BV B_ V]BD>VV?
\m Ql_ E> V>V
km [> VD VVD. E>
[m >kuV_ >V[ s \|\
B_Vm, \m c^, E^, ]VD
z> D^, ^, Eu[^, mB
^ gB _V\ Q []_ zD.
g Ql[ kVV c^\ >[
|\V\V? _m >[ c^]om
\V \V kV[V?
kD, k^, B^, Eu[ V
^, u ]VA^, zu c^,
\KD \sV > V k^
V[kuV_ m Q Wm^m.
>B Qlom >V[ B >
BKD, \uB kBom
> s|sB BVVm. > ^
k\ g\V] kVD. m ^ E
kz kw|D VD V[ sB\_.
k V[ z|k> >BFm [V|
m V^^. >[ >D D [
V| cw k|D [>. cz^
D kM^. [ VD \ >Vm
_VD. >uV x[\Va> m .
V[ kVm k VV][ [s
kVk m Q >VuD u^m. >
VVD kz D >m^m
_m ]A V^m. _k Eu[
V^, B^, ]VA^, D^
gB _VD B Q [mk V[.
>B W>z Qlo
m >V[ >kV BKD >s B
V> >Vk zD. k
xD zw>\ >VuszD.
^ DRMv, Vov _m
>Vo c]_ >V_, c^ \D,
JBVm m V> J VV]V_
kB|m. > z J][
>D, \]A, VD V[k, c_ W
> cVzm. kVV W]
Qlom >V[ >kV B
K\ >s BV> >Vk
gm.
> ^sBD Vm kVD.
cz^ kM^. x>Vk>V >
V V_kk> ^. c^
^sD D V> >
s x[k kVD. kz \]BV

[ V_km _m >k [ ^
gDVD. gV_ V> c^ \]_
^s^ D mkV_, ^ s
VFs_ [ >\VzD, g \m
mBV_ xu us|D, VD m
V^s_ [VzD. VD gVF sBD
t EVm, O\Vm. x>o_ ^
> m k|D.
Q [m [k[ VD B
xB_VD. ]_ c^^ _k s
B > ckV^kV _m m
c^]om s| kV[V? c^
]om s|>V_, >B >]
Wl_ W>|D BVm, #|>o[
>|k>VzD. kV_BM_ c^
\ m B_D y\VMm
[VzD. m >. VD m zm \KD u
xB_kVD.
[ V kMzD kl_, >,
WV, ]V D[ sk V[
[> c[. _k V
D, \m Ql[ xmAD V[
[mk. kVV c^]om guD
BVm, >s BV> u>V \|
t[, s>\V >] WD u>Vk
zD.
g, QBVm >VVk c^D
m\u WB B x\V? kVV
Q >V [>D, Wl_
xuKD kV B_ W\V [>D
D\V_ B |\V? , m
^ AmV^D kl_ c^>V?
Ql_ ^ m\ gw\u
B zB V[m. ]K^ E
>k D >> Am. > E
>k V_km, V[ k[ [.
m >m _B D xB_m.
D B zlB kD kD
E >k>V[ m. > B z,
s> c^xt[ x\BV >[
k\BV V^ x\V?
m B E z [m, V[ kVm
k VVD. > EB >k, V[
[D VV> ]m VV kB
k|D mm. gV_ kBVKD
m >kBVk zD. kV[_
BVuVKD, \uV B zB
>V[ m ckVzD. >BFm > gw\V
c^.
> VB]_ ~|VKD, _m ~|
|\V W]VKD, > BxD

km Ql[ c^]VB
kB|^m [> \D Wl_
c|D. kVV cD kl_, m
|m [ FB|D? kB|^
QB m >V_ _|\V? m
x>_ sBD.
Vkm sBD, > E zD,
]K^ E >kD m skBVD.
glD m ckV V^ >kD,
z _z>Vk zD.
> E >k D kVuD,
kD BVD. > D,
kxD m, skk>uV kBD >u
z >VD. D > kl[ \B]_
VmD c^m E >k>V[. M >
zz z|k> \Vm.
g Ql[ TB\Vm, VmD \B
]V_ z s|m. c_ \BD z
\VV_ m > >>VlD, Ql[
_m >[ _ [m VmD
zB>V s|m. > zz ]BV]_
JVD. _k kak [uVD.
gVKD m VmD zVk W]
zD. gk m > ckV V^D
>kD zB>V, gw\u>Vk
zD. m Vkm sBD.
J[Vkm sBD, \B\u Wl_ c^
_Bu k [m [? > VD
uVD.
^sBV : Q >m kB
x\V?

iJ] : m k g, V
V[ku V|^ zz, x gu
K[ B_|, >V ckV V
Ql[ kB m_ |\V?
ks>\V V_k>[V_, >V[ [ >
zz, ]BVD,  ||m>_,
 m Vz>_, _m VV]>_
V[ ms>\V VBKD ~||
m. kVV >Vm BVu >[
BD >[B m _B Wz
V|Vz\V?
g, Ql[ c^\VB >V[, >V
km > zz >m V xm \u
V^D xBuE, zl[ kBom
> s|sz\V? m ^s >m V>
kB[ _ zz xuKD \
]BV kM |\V? Wl_ ku
m_K>_ [mD V]BD>VV?
^sBV: \B]_ xD zz W
u^m. k kuk [> _. g

>]xD V]Bt_BV?

iJ]: VmD \B]o> B

VuS^ [> Vk kMyV?
\BD [m D, VD, EBD V[
kBV VD. ^ VmD >B
\B]o> BVuS^, _BV?
V[ c[ E[, V[ c[ k
[, V[ D ]Vx^kV sDA
[ kVV \m B_^ mD
\B]o> >VuD [. > \B
\Vm J]uV _m E>V>]uV
>[ m V^VD. glD
WlKD B_|km \B\. m V
mkV, mk A]B \B\Vm. VmD
Wm V >B B_V
\|\ ^ TV? _m kVs[ E
_, \B][ B_V[ >D W
>V? WB\V kV Wm. ]|\
\BD mt[ ^ kMS^, kV
S^, cS^. m xuKD \V
>V \VD. [ E> V_m, [
uA>\V W m [. VmD m
>V k|\ V[ sDA[. [
>B s\ \B\Vm. E z
x[ W> [[ W, E>l[ V
\BD m.
\BD [> uKD VmD k
> ckV V^k> VD cV\V?
> >M\|] V^_, >|A ^,
>>_^ V[ku V^.
\BD [ [ c^ kl_, zBk
[>D mkVk ckVs|D.
kB skV VD sDAkVD. M_
kVV kVs[ kEB> VD sw
VD. gVKD >B > \V[\
lKD, VmD \BD [m c^m. k
k m s]>VKD k
_z>Vm. WB
cz^V kMm V^. V[
V_k> B uV^Vy^. c
z^ kMzD kl_, kuB_VD
^ V>V\Vk BVD. \KD c
_ WD VV^ [mD, \B
z B>V[. kV \BxD s
kB, ko>, g]D K> sDA[
zz[ gD!
g, V[ > u sDA[. \D V_
m, > V[ >kV V[.
kVV \D um. > \BD kV
>V[m? JD, VVD gBku[
[skV > \BD >VuD u^>V
_m m >FT\V>V? >FTD [

V_ B[|]B>uz [ \[M^.
mD J]VKD VV]VKD
\V|>|^m. NmD BVD
> g\V [D \z^ zD
\[\BV [VD k[. mD
VmD _k >V_ [ >^
| s|m. gk ^ > s|s k
|D. >[ J\V \FBVm c\BV
zz kkkm V]B\VzD.
k kVD VV]o> \BD c
kVm [m >. km kB
V> k^, W^, x\ BV>
Wl[ V\V ckV^ ^,
^ gBkuV_ \BD >VuD m.
g J]V_ \B\Vm >VuD km
\|\_V\_, mk x[VD sm
_m. >VVk kzm^ _ >
\BD m _ |\V? B\Vk \]
|] V|, ||] V|, ]BV
]_ gm, >Vk [u, \B\Vm
cm E>s|>_ V]B\V? WB\V x
BVm. x[\V]B [u, >uz
]kV B_|k][ J\V, m \KD
D k BKD. glD |>_ >]D
m s>V u FmV^D
|D. zz VmD BV> cB>\V \
WB WB\V xuKD >> QVD u
W. g, zz kV >m B_ x
z V|kD? WB\V [ [u
k>VV m  ]k>VV
_. kB_VD z[ >].
k >]_ ~||, >[ >V
\Vu V^D WB zz >V?
V[ J \Vu]uz c>[, >[ >>
cBmk]_ V^[, J],
\[\BV kVxV cw[ [
_VD zz |D. kB_VD >
z >V FmV^D >]V c
z >V[s_BV? ]_ V_K^. m
>kV ABBm. >]u
t_. cz c]BVs_ M_ >B
Fm m zm VD \KD VD,
mBVVD.
^sBV: J]uz cw>_, J k F>_
V[ VB k V Fkm V
^ E k_ V_S^. gV_ V[
J]om kk_. k J]uV
>V| Fk> Vk Fkm Vk c
[. |\ [>V[. V[ k|]
Vs_.

iJ]: c[ V> sB]_ V[

>l|k>V  kVD. ^

D k|] Vs_BM_ V[
m, \BD >]_ [xD E^
>V, _BV?
^sBV: m Vm.

iJ]: Vm [>_. [
VD kV >]uz [s|kVD.
VD, Vm, kBm, kV>m
V[k mD V>k. xl_
[ W? VD JxD [ [> u
V [AD \B\Vm, >Vkm V[ [
> zz [xD c_ BVu>V,
_BV?
z[ BD c^ kl_ m >V
k s, zwD, u V> Vo
D V[kuu ka kzzD. [D
\BV V_k>[V_, > \BD [m
BD. B\ VmD BVum. V[
>FT>[\ VD, JM_
V| V JD VKD,
]_ m \BD B_|m M_, m >
\um.
|> ^s, kV > \BD \
\B|D? B s]VV? \ c
]BVV? xm \uV^|D luE
VV? _k k J>VV,
>_VV? _m >D [_ >[
nB|] V^k>VV? k mD
z[ . k Q [m z
[ _z>. ]_ c^ kuxD,
z[ D D k. k >] W
[> _.
g \D V_km V[ > >kV
V[. V> >kV c W
BVk V[ z|[. > o
z^> Vm V. > V[ k
s_. > k\ V[. [
[ Wm?
V>uzD, >D >uzD x\BV
kD >k, _BV? ^ [ V_
S^ [> AmV^ k|\M_,
V[ ]_ m x k>D K> k
|D. kVV g> kD KmD kl_,
zz B_|>V? >BFm ^.
^ V_k> sDA[. ^
xBmk\V _m xB\u >V [
S^. ^ V_km [ [>
>mV^ k|\VV_, V[ m x
k>D ]_ K> k|D. >[
V^ m \D, >BD, c_, s DA^
gB mD m kD Km>_
k|D. \D [m coom k

kl_, >uz ]A >V[k]_. VD

V\ w]_. kVV zD
Wl_, zV| B \BD BVu>V?
^. m ]KV V]
kVD. |^.
> V[ cB xkm[
^ SV? >[ V^ k V_
k>uz V sD, g\V]>_ _m
WV>_, A Vz>_, _m c[
\]uz ukV >|] V^>_
V[ > BoK\ ~| Vm
[>VzD. kVV >D W>V_, ^
xkxD K>s_ [ VVzD.
x\BV kD Km>_ [][ >D,
\D D mt[ x \][ m
[>BVzD. kV ^ FSV?
>uVm kVV x\BV kD K],
V[ cB SV?
BVV_ Wl_ \BD [m c^>V?
^sBV: V^ \]BV kMVD.

iJ]: ^ \]BV SV,

ys\V BzSV []_ z
l_. V[ m x\BV kD Km
SV [. m [m x\BV k
> Kmkm. kVV kD Km
>o_ zz Bz>V? gD, _
s kVD. ^. m zm u
V^^. zz s> >]KD
~|V> kD Km>o[ >D [?
>_. >BD [mD \]om \V>_.
k m\ m B_|km
>V[ kD Km>_ [>VzD. mk
x\BV kD Km>_. zz B_|D
Vm, \D >B x\BV k>
Km>V?
x\BV kD KmD kl_,
z[ B_V VD ks_. >
_m >k \]| FBs_.
z[ >]^ ]KD, k\ kD
KmVD. >B kM>o_ z>VF
_. m c\BVk xBmkD kVF
>m. gk cm x guD ]_ ~||
m^. , \uV z]B gF FD
kl_, z BVum. g, \D \u
B kl_ x\BV kD K], z
[ m BD kM>V?
kVV x kxD K>|DVm [
Wm?
^ > FSV? kVV kM
zD W [k[ cz >\V? >
\wl[ x\BV zD

^sBV: m u WBV?

iJ]: z >BVm. u
W, \D k\BV W [_VD
ku kV>VVy^. ^, u
V^^. >[ V^, >Vm >
kD Km>_. E ^ \|\ kD
K], [ Wlom s s|k>_.
x\BV kD K> B \][
>> |^.
^sBV: \D _B[ ^ V_KD
]B \D [m c^m.

iJ]: kV_. \D _ [
> V[ kV>V_ z |m V_
KDVm, Wl[ W>V[ z|
m. gV_ V[ m x\BV kD
KmD kl_ \BD [m c^>V?
WB\V m \BV sBD.
] kBV WEB
c\BVk V DVm, ^ BV
\B m c kVFs| E km.
Wl_ \BD [m c^>V? cz
gkJ| [ WVm, m zm

^ s> WV|D |Vm kMzD

kl_, >B kM>o_ zz, >Vkm
\BD [m c^>V?
\BD _BM_ |m DAD ^s,
>B W >Vm Bz\V?
|\V? D \|\ Wm [ W
lom ks s|k>_. BuBV, >V,
xBuEl[ >Vm W z\V?
xm WB B xBuEm [][
c^>D zz >VuD >_. >_VD
cz sz>V?
x kV V> VB_ zz ~|
klzD. zz VuD V
BxD kD Km>o_ m >V[B>V?
_m kD Km>o[ zz >[M
BV Bz>V? Kk]uz _kmD,
z BVu>KD tz> km[ B_
B B\V? _m > zz x\
BV >[k\V V|^>V? V[
s \VkV k|D, V[ ]
\V D DV] k|D, V[ \V
cw k|D, V[ Vl| x[
k|D, V[ cB >sB B k|D,
_m m V[ k >BVkm zz
|D. >uz^ Ow^ nBV. ]_ m
cm kVs_ m Vm? c[
VB^ ] ]\BV, clmA^
g> kD Km>o[ B\V? _m
zz x\BV > >[ ]_ |m
V|^>V? c[ V> VkD
>uz ]^. VB x\BV
>[k\V V|^ zz, k
>D y ss>V_, >[ [s^
[? \KD zz^ VmD >V
FB|D! [ y s> BVx
t[ Vs |\V? V_K^. ku[
w _VD ^ ck>l_.
u BVV k c\B_V> [
[MD V. zz c Bo_
V_ sDBm, VFB[ [. m
gw> km[ zz BVuV> Wl_
W> B\V? kVVV_, c\B_V>
> u s> V]D u|]
Vm. zz B_|\VV_ WB\V >D
V]A WD. g, V[ m >B
kD >Vm |\V? M_
kV bkmD z[ B. gV_
xD >B kD K> |\VV_,
\xD >V| m BzD.
>uz ^ ]> g k|D. m
c\BVk t xBmkD kVF> ^s.
VD m^m z[ BD \|\. >

D E k_ \|\ zz E>D
>Vu\V> g> k> D\V_ K>
xm. [ zz Wm, WB V[
VmD >km V^ k|D [.
[ m Vz [ ]BV]_ ~||
m. _m ]BVsuz [, BVV
km Vl[ \m. _m m V[
k >D Fm.
VD VD, gm kD Km
B\Vm VD m^ QBV| xu
KD >Vu>V [. WB\V >V[.
m BD >l[ >Vm
Bz>_ V[, gm kD Km
BxD m Bz\V? \KD zz
B_ mkzDVm, WB >
z cm g> k]uz R
WwV] F\V?
u BVV k [ k\]> Vm,
sa]> zz c ]>m. >[B
cB Wl[ V\VD, z[
>]V_ u|D E_ ]
B B xk>VKD, kD Km>_
>l[ Wm. kV V[ >
Fkm [>_ sBD. \KD, >
>Vm FB k|D [ ^
czD ]B, m z[ BVm.
m xB\V [. g zz BVuD
kl_, > > z cmV^
m. >B O\V saA c^ W
l_ cBV > \]|>D Fm.
^sBV: kVV BD Bt[, R
mt[ Wk>V_, guKD T Vk]_.

iJ]: g> kD Km>_

[> guo[ cW, _BV? ]_ x
]D c^m. , s [ ^
mD _. VF u B_|D
]B, z[ k mksm
[Vm. \KD zz, mD u V^
m [>V_ O\V ]D saAk
D m. gu_ TVk>D cm
V^k>V_, BuBVk \] m.
M zz, g> kD [ \ _.
uzD l_ sD BVm.
s c^Vm, kMk cB>VD u
\V g\V [_VD kw|m.
zz^ |m^ >]^ _VD
c >\. gV_ kM>_ [>
x\BV>V BD. mk xuV B_.
k xuV B_, kM>_ [
Wz ]V>_. m]ik\V zu
V> kVD c^>V_, kVm
mD sam V^m.

Vm \BD [m _V> Wl_,

kM>_ [m x\BV c>
Wl_, c^m [k[ z
>sV? DtBD gu TVVm,
cB> saAk m^ \D [
kVm, Wl_ Wkm [? V_K^.
xxD V E V[.
^sBV: Jz x \] |D. >V[
[> u W...

iJ]: zz >]^ kVD.

J, , c_ V[kuuz \|\_,
x kzD [ Wm [> V[
m. ^ us_. > V *|D
z kVsV_, k m sV_ [
FT^? kV u V^T^? >D
BVlD [ l_TV? xBVm
nBV. k V> u V^^.
cB> saA WB > \D [
kVm? ]_ x\BV gu_ c^m.
>B cB> >]_ c^ OB
\z [ Wm?
^sBV: m \B Vm.

iJ]: _. ^ > B
s_. >BFm u FB kVD.
^sBV: m xuV \] W.
iJ]: J B_|m. VB\Vu
m. mk zD ckV^m. tz>
saA V>V m B BV>V?
cz >Bs_ [V_ >BFm u
BV >D kVD. \KD gu_
tz>, cm >xD c^m. ku gu_,
TVV>, V> ]D u
Wl_, x\BV clm V
|^ > kz, \M>z [ Wm?
>>V[ V[ [.
^sBV: m saAu, [ cl u, u
V^m.

iJ]: _. x>Vk>V cl
>V_>V[ u BKD. _BM_ uk
xBVm. c]_ g>kV, V[ Vm^
VB DA[, ku E
[, > W>^ uA>\Vk [_
VD Wl_, ^ [xD sa
s_. gV_ ku zm ^s^
AD ]B, ^ u mkzS^.
cl>[\^ saAk S^.
m ^s mk_. > Jz, cKz
[kVm?
^sBV: x\BV >VA W ckVm.
s []_. gBV_ x saA
Wm.

iJ]: >\u _ >

TVVm V_K^. > J [ B
]]uz [kVm? J [m kD
B]D V[ BzD V>D>V[.
^sBV: m clmA V>Vm.

iJ]:
>BFm
cB
kM^. c^ >BD, c_, \D, c_
c^ mD m, kV
][, kV bs[ ]BD ], >
D [_ x\BV k> Km^.
[ [ WD?
^sBV: ]_ V[ [> Vm.

iJ]: gD. gV_ cz [

kVm [>_ ^s. > Jz [
kVlu? \BD Vm [> V[ A
V^[. gV_ c_ c^m. J c^m.
>uz [kVlu?
^sBV: m {F m. Aml m.

iJ]: Jl[ [?
^sBV: z.

iJ]: >BFm V[ V[>B

]DD |m kVD. J [m
[? m _V| V V\ kE
m^ V>D. m W m
km^ z. D BVu gu_
t V^. m AmV^m, VmV
m, >|m, E]m, _m E]V\_
m, D V^m, VmV V|
m. D nBxD V^m. ]_ _
k W^ ]kV^. uB QV
^ \|t[, uV| V ]^,
c z> ]^, VDB ]^, z|D
W^ gB mD ]_ c^
^. >B Jz VD \uz
V>V\V>V Wl_ [ Wm?
^sBV: m A]>Vm...

iJ]: V[ |\BV sD
s_. c[ J A]>V B_|>V
[? _m ^ V_km ku kV>
V? B]D Vk B V
> Jz [kVzD [> >Bm
V_K^. m M B]\B\V BVm
[ ]_ s kVD. J [m
kD B]\. >[ kB w_
^, ^, Eu[ V^ V[kuu
u m B_|m. ] E>D TVV>
Wl_, > B] Jz [ Wm?
^sBV: m A ][ D Wz...

iJ]: VD > V k s|
kVD.