(GL LDD,,,DHWDSDILQDO LXQLH &ODVDD,9D

 D 8WLOL]D L FLIUD  GH  RUL úL RSHUD LL DULWPHWLFH SHQWUX D RE LQH
&ODVDD,,,D UH]XOWDWXO
 D 'HOLD FDOFXOHD]  VXPD FLIUHORU SH FDUH OH DILúHD]  FHDVXO HL E$IOD LQXP UXOQDWXUDO[
GLJLWDO&DUHHVWHVXPDPD[LP SHFDUHRSRDWHRE LQH"    +    +    +    + 
=  −    +    
 E 3URGXVXO D  QXPHUH QDWXUDOH HVWH  úL VXPD ORU HVWH  [ +    +    +    +   
* VL LDFHVWHQXPHUH  D 6  VH DIOH SURGXVXO D WUHL QXPHUH QDWXUDOH úWLLQG F  SURGXVXO
 F/D%DOXO6SLULGXúLORUSDUWLFLS WR LVSLULGXúLLDOHF URUYkUVWHvQ SULPHORUQXPHUHHVWHSURGXVXOXOWLPHORUQXPHUHHVWH
DQLUHSUH]LQW QXPHUHGHFLIUHFXSURGXVXOFLIUHORUùWLLQGF  LDUVXPDGLQWUHSULPXOúLXOWLPXOHVWH
QXH[LVW GRLVSLULGXúLFDUHDXDFHHDúLYkUVW DIOD LFk LVSLULGXúL
DXSDUWLFLSDWOD%DOúLFHYkUVWHDX
 ÌQFXWLLVXQWELOHILHFDUHFXWLHDYkQGVDXELOH6HúWLH
F  QXP UXO FXWLLORU FX R ELO  QX H PDL PLF GHFkW  LDU QXP UXO
ELOHORUGLQFXWLLOHFXúLELOHvPSUHXQ HVWHPDLPDUHGHFkW
&DUHHVWHQXP UXOFXWLLORUFXELOH"$QDOL]D LWRDWHFD]XULOH
E&kWHFLIUHDUHSURGXVXO$⋅%GDF QXP UXOQDWXUDO$HVWHVFULVFX
GHFLIUHGHLDUQXP UXOQDWXUDO%HVWHVFULVFXGHFLIUHGH"
 6XQWXQWkQ UQ VFXWvQVHFROXO8OWLPHOHGRX FLIUHDOHDQXOXL
QDúWHULL IRUPHD]  XQ QXP U GH  RUL PDL PDUH GHFkW QXP UXO
OXQLLvQFDUHPDPQ VFXWùWLLQGF QXP UXOOXQLLvQFDUHPDP
Q VFXWHVWHGHRULPDLPDUHGHFkW]LXDPHDGHQDúWHUHV VHDIOH
SRVLELOH GDWDQDúWHULLPHOH
 /DXQRILFLXSRúWDOF VX HOHSRúWDOHVXQWDúH]DWHSHUkQGXULHJDOH  /D R FRIHW ULH VXQW DGXVH  FXWLL ILHFDUH FXWLH DYkQG 
QX PDL PXOW GH  UkQGXUL úL QXPHURWDWH FX QXPHUH QDWXUDOH
vQFHSkQG GH OD  & VX D SRúWDO  FX QXP UXO  HVWH VLWXDW  SH
UkQGXOGLQPLMORFLDUFHDFXQXP UXOHVWHVLWXDW vQGUHSWXOHL
GDUSHXOWLPXOUkQG&kWHF VX HSRúWDOHVXQW"
 ÌQWUXQ FOXE VSRUWLY VXQW PDL SX LQ GH  GH FRSLL 7R L SUDFWLF 
XQ VSRUW -XP WDWH GLQ QXP UXO IHWHORU HVWH HJDO FX R WUHLPH GLQ
QXP UXO E LH LORU 8QLL SUDFWLF  YROHLXO FHLODO L WHQLVXO 2 WUHLPH
FLRFRODWH  FXWLL DYkQG FLRFRODWH GH  JU LDU R FXWLH FRQ LQH
FLRFRODWHGHJU&XPVHSRDWHJ VLFXWLDFXFLRFRODWHGHJU
GLQWURVLQJXU FkQW ULUHDYkQGODGLVSR]L LHXQFkQWDUFXJUHXW L
SRWULYLWH
&ODVDD9D
GLQQXP UXOFRSLLORUFDUHSUDFWLF YROHLHVWHHJDOFXRS WULPHGLQ  D$IOD LUHVWXOvPS U LULLQXP UXOXL   OD
QXP UXO FHORU FDUH SUDFWLF  WHQLVXO ùWLLQG F   IHWH IDF WHQLV E$IOD LFkWXOúLUHVWXOvPS U LULLQXP UXOXL  ⋅   OD  ⋅   
DIOD LFk LE LH LSUDFWLF YROHL 'DPLDQ0DULQHVFX
  3HXQUDIWDOXQHLELEOLRWHFLVXQWDúH]DWHvQRUGLQHF U LDVWIHO
vQFkW QXP UXO GH IRL SHQWUX GRXD F U L ÄYHFLQH³ DO WXUDWH V 
GLIHUHFX3RWILSHUDIWF U LÄYHFLQH´DO WXUDWHFDUHV DLE 
vQWRWDOIRL"'DU"
'DQ1HGHLDQX
 6HG úLUXOGHQXPHUH
D&RPSOHWD LúLUXOFXXUP WRULLWUHLWHUPHQL
   
 E&DOFXOD LVXPDSULPLORUGHWHUPHQLDLúLUXOXL &ODVDD9,,D
0DULXV'DPLDQUHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
 6 VHJ VHDVF QXPHUHOHvQWUHJL[úL\FDUHVDWLVIDFHFXD LD
 3HQWUXQ ∈1Q ≥FRQVLGHU PPXO LPHD$  {«Q}
6SXQHPF PXO LPHD%XQGH % ⊆ $ DUHSURSULHWDWHDÄ0³GDF  \  =  [  +  [ +  
PHGLDDULWPHWLF DHOHPHQWHORUVDOHHVWHXQQXP UGLQPXO LPHD$  ,RQ%XUF UHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
D 6  VH DUDWH F  SHQWUX RULFH QXP U QDWXUDO N XQGH  ≤ N  Q  6  VH DUDWH F  GDF  S T U VXQW WUHL QXPHUH SULPH úL GDF 
H[LVW RPXO LPH % ⊆ $ FXNHOHPHQWHFDUHDUHSURSULHWDWHDÄ0³ S T U
+ + ∈1DWXQFLS T T
E 6  VH DIOH FkWH PXO LPL % % ⊆ $  GH GRX  HOHPHQWH DX T U S
SURSULHWDWHDÄ0³ & W OLQ LJ HUX
7UDLDQ3UHGD  )LH$%&'XQS WUDWúLSXQFWHOH0 ∈>%&@1 ∈>&'@3 ∈>$'@
DVWIHOvQFkW&0 %0úL$3 ≡%01RW P%1 ∩30  {4}úL
&ODVDD9,D $1∩30 {5}'HPRQVWUD LF 1HVWHPLMORFXOOXL>&'@GDF úL
 D$IOD LFHOPDLPLFQXP UQDWXUDOFDUHvPS U LWODG UHVWXO QXPDLGDF $4⊥%5
vPS U LWODG UHVWXOúLHVWHGLYL]LELOFX 7UDLDQ3UHGD
'RUHOD) LQLúLUHYLVWD$UKLPHGH  6HFRQVLGHU  ∆$%&DVFX LWXQJKLFúLSXQFWHOH0 ∈>%&@1 ∈>$&@
 úL 3 ∈ >$%@ DVWIHO vQFkW $∆$13 ≡ $∆&01 ≡ $∆0%3 ≡ $∆013  6  VH
E'DF  D − E + F =  DEF∈1V VHGHPRQVWUH]HF 
GLYLGHQXP UXOED±F GHPRQVWUH]HF 01úL3VXQWPLMORDFHOHODWXULORU∆$%&
'DQ1HGHLDQX  $PQRWDW $∆;<= DULDWULXQJKLXOXL;<=
 6 VHGHWHUPLQHVXEPXO LPHDFXQXP UPD[LPGHHOHPHQWHFDUH 7UDLDQ3UHGD
VH SRDWH DOHJH GLQ PXO LPHD $  {   « } DVWIHO FD
VXPDRULF URUGRX QXPHUHGLQVXEPXO LPHV VHGLYLG FX &ODVDD9,,,D
/LYLX2SULúHVFX
 )LH ∆$%& úL SXQFWHOH 2 úL , FHQWUHOH FHUFXULORU FLUFXPVFULVH  6 VHDUDWHF 
UHVSHFWLYvQVFULVHvQ ∆$%&6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF GDF P
$,%  DH[LVW [\]∈1DVWIHOvQFkW [  + \  + ]  =  
P
%,& P
&,$ VXQW GLUHFW SURSRU LRQDOH FX P
%$2  EH[LVW [\]∈1DVWIHOvQFkW [  + \  + ]  =   
P
&%2P
$&2DWXQFLWULXQJKLXO$%&HVWHHFKLODWHUDO  FSHQWUXRULFHQ∈1
H[LVW [\]∈1DVWIHOvQFkW [ + \ + ]  = Q 
7UDLDQ3UHGD
1LFXODH0DULQ*RúRQLXUHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
 6H FRQVLGHU  WULXQJKLXULOH DVFX LWXQJKLFH $%& úL $′%′&′ FX
 6HFRQVLGHU IXQF LDI1 →=I[ D[EDE ∈=
'DF P
vQ O LPLOH$0UHVSHFWLY$′0′úLFXPHGLDQHOH%1&3UHVSHFWLY
úLQVXQWQXPHUHQDWXUDOHGLVWLQFWHDVWIHOvQFkW
%′1′úL&′3′ 1RW P$0∩%1 {4}úL$′0′∩%′1′ {4′}6 
 I  + I   +  + I P = −Q  úL I  + I   +  + I Q = −P  V 
VHDUDWHF GDF $0≡$′0′úL%1≡%′1′DWXQFL
I  + I  +  + I P + Q
D
%40≡
%′4′0′ VHFDOFXOH]HUDSRUWXO 
 EGDF vQSOXV&3≡&′3′DWXQFL∆$%&≡∆$′%′&′ P+Q
7UDLDQ3UHGD 'DQ1HGHLDQX

   
 D'DF DE∈5 DVWIHOvQFkWDE∈4úL &ODVDD;D
    
D + E D + E + D E ∈4V VHDUDWHF DE∈4  )LHNS∈1 $WXQFLDYHP
NS
'DQ1HGHLDQX  + ] S + ]  S +  + ] NS ≥  − ] ∀]∈&
 E)LH[\] ∈5DVWIHOvQFkW[ ∈\ ∈] ∈
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX0LKDL3LWLFDUL
'HPRQVWUD LLQHJDOLWDWHD [ + \] > [] + [\ 
 )LH QXPHUHOH D E !  D E ≠  D ≠ % úL   PD[{D E} 6  VH
/LYLX6PDUDQGDFKHUHYLVWD$UKLPHGH
DUDWHF  OJ D ⋅ OJE + F = OJ E ⋅ OJD + F GDF úLQXPDLGDF F 
 D 7HWUDHGUXO 6$%& DUH PXFKLD 6$ SHUSHQGLFXODU  SH SODQXO
$%&3XQFWHOH'34VXQWSURLHF LLOHSXQFWXOXL$SHGUHSWHOH 9LUJLO1LFXOD
[ [ [ [ [ [
%&6%UHVSHFWLY6&LDUSXQFWHOH0úL1VXQWSURLHF LLOHOXL'SH 6 VHUH]ROYHLQHFXD LD  +  +  +  <  +  +  [ +  [ 
6%UHVSHFWLY6&6 VHDUDWHF GUHSWHOH01úL34VXQWSDUDOHOH $XUHO'RERúDQ/XJRM
ùWHIDQ6PDUDQGDFKH  $U WD LF GDF WULXQJKLXULOHRUWLFúLELVHFWRUIRUPDWGHSLFLRDUHOH
E $IOD L SULPHOH  GH ]HFLPDOH GXS  YLUJXO  DOH QXP UXOXL ELVHFWRDUHORU DOH XQXL WULXQJKL DX DFHODúL FHQWUX GH JUHXWDWH
 DWXQFLDFHVWDHVWHHFKLODWHUDO
D= (  − )  *K6WRLFD3HWURúDQL
$GLúRU1LVWRU
&ODVDD;,D
&ODVDD,;D
DUFWJQ
 6 VHGHWHUPLQHWRDWHIXQF LLOHI5→5FXSURSULHWDWHD  6HFRQVLGHU úLUXO DQ = Q ≥  
DUFWJ Q + 
I D[ + E\  ≤ DI  [ + EI  \  ∀[\∈5∀DE∈>@
D6 VHDUDWHF úLUXODQQ≥HVWHVWULFWFUHVF WRU
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX&RVWHO&KLWHú
 )LHDEF!6 VHDUDWHF  E6 VHFDOFXOH]H OLP DQ DQ +DQ  
Q →∞
D E  (D + E ) E  F  (E + F ) D F  (D + F ) ,90DIWHL3HWUXú$OH[DQGUHVFX
D + E + F ≥ + +   6 VHFDOFXOH]H
D  + E E + F D + F
 
,90DIWHL0DULXV5 GXOHVFX  

 6 VHGHWHUPLQHWRDWHIXQF LLOHI>±@ →>±@FDUHYHULILF   [   [    [Q  Q
  
OLP  +  +  +  +  +  +  − Q   [!
Q→∞  Q  Q 
FRQGL LD  I D I  [  ⋅  I D I D I  [  =  I  [  I D I  [  −  [I  [     Q 

∀[∈>±@
'DQLHO3HWULFHDQX
 )LH0⊂0Q5Q≥FXSURSULHWDWHDF ;⋅<∈0∀;<∈0
 6HFRQVLGHU IXQF LLOHIJ5→5GHILQLWHSULQ úLH[LVW ( ∈0DVWIHOvQFkW;  (∀; ∈06 VHDUDWHF 
GDF  H[LVW  $ ∈ 0 DVWIHO vQFkW GHW $ ≠  DWXQFL ; ⋅ <  < ⋅ ;
I  [ = VLQ [ VLQ  [ + FRV [ FRV  [ úL J  [ = VLQ [ VLQ  [ − FRV [ FRV  [ 
∀;<∈0 
 6 VHGHWHUPLQHFHDPDLPDUHúLFHDPDLPLF YDORDUHDIXQF LLORU
'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
IúLJ
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX&ULVWLDQ$OH[DQGUHVFX

   
     
 
 )LH Q ≥  XQ QXP U QDWXUDO úL $ =  [ [  [Q   R PDWULFH
 \ \  \ 
   Q
UHDO FXWUHLOLQLLúLQFRORDQHFXXUP WRDUHDSURSULHWDWH
3 3HQWUX RULFH GRX  FRORDQH DOH PDWULFHL $ H[LVW  R D WUHLD
FRORDQ  FX SURSULHWDWHD F  PDWULFHD FX WUHL OLQLL úL WUHL FRORDQH
RE LQXW DUHGHWHUPLQDQWXOQXO6 VHGHPRQVWUH]HF 
 D'DF WRDWHFRORDQHOHPDWULFHL$VXQWGLVWLQFWHUH]XOW F UDQJXO
PDWULFHL$HVWHFHOPXOWGRL
E'DF Q H[LVW RPDWULFH$FXSURSULHWDWHD3úLFXUDQJ$ 
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX,RQ6DYX

&ODVDD;,,D
π
DUFFRV [
 6 VHFDOFXOH]H ∫ π G[ 
− FRV  [

'0% WLQH X*LXUJLX
 )LHLQHOXO$⋅úL[∈$FXSURSULHWDWHDF H[LVW S∈1 DVWIHO
vQFkW [ S + = [ S 6 VHDUDWHF   − [ + [  HVWHLQYHUVDELO
1LFRODH3DSDFXUHY$UKLPHGH
 )LHI5→5RIXQF LHFRQWLQX FXSURSULHWDWHDII[ [∀
[∈5$WXQFL
DI I úLIHVWHVWULFWFUHVF WRDUHSH5
 
E ∫ I   [ G[ ≥ 
 
6RULQ5 GXOHVFX0LKDL3LWLFDUL
 )LH* ⋅XQJUXSFDUHHVWHUHXQLXQHDDSDWUXVXEJUXSXULSURSULL
DOHVDOHGLQWUHFDUHWUHLDXFkWHGRX HOHPHQWHúLRULFDUHGRX GLQ
FHOH SDWUX VXEJUXSXUL DX FRPXQ GRDU HOHPHQWXO QHXWUX DO
JUXSXOXL6 VHDUDWHF *DUHúDVHHOHPHQWHQXHVWHFRPXWDWLYúL
HVWHL]RPRUIFXJUXSXOSHUPXW ULORUXQHLPXO LPLFXHOHPHQWH
1LFRODH3DSDFX6ORER]LD