Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Square of Opposition
Square of Opposition
Superaltern
Contraries
Superaltern
Contradictories
I
Subaltern
Subcontraries
O
Subaltern
Subcontrariety A relation which exist between particular proposition that differ in quality only. Subalternation A relation which exist between two proposition having the same quality but differing in quantity. It is the only relation where it matters which of the pair of propositions one begins with:
The universal proposition is the superaltern The particular proposition is the subaltern
Laws of contrariety
Contrary opposition is one which
exist between two universal proposition that differ only in quality. A and E are propositions are contraries.
If one is true, the other is false. If one is false, the other is doubtful
(either true or false) Examples: A. A - All diamonds are gems True E -No diamonds are gems False
More examples..
B.
E- No apples are mangoes True A - All apples are mangoes False
Laws of contradiction
Contradiction opposition is one
which exist between two propositions that differ both in quality and quantity. A and O, E and I are contradictories.
If one is true, the other is false. If one is false, the other is true.
More examples..
B. E - No women are married. False I - Some women are married. True C. I - Some apples are oranges. False E - No apples are oranges. True
Some apples are oranges, must be denied of the whole All apples are oranges. The negation of the latter which is No apples are oranges is therefore true. Example: O Some prisoners are not guilty. True A All prisoners are guilty. False
Thank you!