Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Louis H. Kauffman - Linear Equations and Feedback
Louis H. Kauffman - Linear Equations and Feedback
H. ;(<<ct.U"C41-C,.
t-\.,.(e(,k
'-.
:r:: ..r"f,..JuC+iqlSc
O ..... e. a.. si ....... f>\e
a:.
.s,.s-\-ewt.
"fA..oJe\
C~\o(.
.for
CIt
0+
o-t-
-t-~i.s
be· +ke
CC)~.s;Je,.. +lte.
)
;
rl,.'$
10(.
d~rc_
j_ ""
r "C.+". is ~ ,. w kcue (H~+Pcct-.. is ~. Tke ,s;,,,,,cc.\ ~ ;s +tyct.~s£o"..~eJ. by +ke klcc.k L.fJx. A ~~J -tc:J-1cc.k +k'V'~"':Jk +'e 1,0x B +0 . be.. ..... e!'c:..o""~j~eJ
(.cJ ; -\-~
+O"f'IIC(.CC+io~ ..flo cu
+he
.S''ys+e~
-t--! dli"
w ~o~ e....
+\c..c: <w;'" i~
iCO'\ f c.rl-;
(e)
=-
o-t-
loj Ai--:
t- +ke
CYe.&ce..t+
The~
wee
«'''''-
c,4.",,~e"'f.s-\-c:t.\l'Vcl
,,4-
~,e
e, V'c~:+·.
-+;)' cdc""
i"
Fi.-.. lWe
+' ~ ~
01(.
+ke
",""'e
1M
be.k4.v;o
",lV"
oe£
55
~tC.+ +"-e...
,
-K\"vo... .jCc"
-\- ~
e .)
ke.
c.\.,..
"'p""f
\'
~es~(+.s
j~
+w",~eV'
-rk'$
o~
_H ..,
')C.+ SA?,
Ik.e
d-t-
\;... ke +'(OI(.~tcy" +"",d- ;0"-5 ,A c=t.."J 15 + «. v« !i..."l" . e :>0 -f-t..+ A Co( tf? .::A.o<. ~ A j9 e.-+c • T"-e."", e j e. + + It. e r=: e.....
<.U
$C>
C
c. "" J
e w:4
r "",4 s
l' t-BA~
1l + B
A"
T 3ABA?,
.I.~
t.lt
u.1
\e.-\-
+ +f) se-tfl e. , ~o $+<. LIe.. _..;....._;;.....;._-=-_ • .s:-+:-<.-+ e, A+ +ke S+<. ~le. s+<fe + ke ('t t ~+ J
4(.
ve.-('::Jlo~
+, Moe.
+ke" .sys-b~
~eMJ
.yo...t/ eN
0 V'
we... ex r e.c:...f
+ke.-+edhc:tc:..~. A~+B~)=~
cc. ~
"'"'fe..
....,
-rk(.$
~e~~~'
f5~
a.
vr,d
Of.t...+ p~+
is.
A(~~edLct.c;.k>
") •
Tk\(.->
.".
~ ~~AB
ji
C(..~J
+a"'~tlC.l~)
( ) Thf~~'Ye.sr.t.H~",-«.l.>'.s(.5 ~
+he
<J
.s
;f(&.+ io.........
J
kfs
. A &f\.d
cU
t,+-c..i""
c+
t;""e~v er",ce+;aw.
100 k
'>'
.so
~ e..ye...
s~.ste~
we.. c.ui+k
c.c,.)i+k H.Odes
c.)
+ttc:l+ ~~e.s.1ff- +It.e •••• 1.8> (e) 0++ke ecV'lt4~ KO+~;O~. Ii~c.k "'-~6 \$ 14t.~~leJ .by c. le1t(!'f «i . E«.c:..k c:::c...~c:..Ced,e) I~ Ic1..11J ~¥ 4> la*o.v: AJB"CpH ver "... ij + .... 'l"q,....!>-te... ~""'" -+;OIIU • Th. e " d...\ e r ,-1-i0 "L +
0
e ~?~e.$S eo'..s
~:,
'i~4
4. .$
.$'
c.c."",
~"''''-G-+:o",~ <"fled
J~.y'ee..-+eJ
r 0
+"
1'/s
w.ode
+ke
\41'
+ -t-t.....+
(:) ~
CV'~
+e.
Y'
1.£,
~~4'E=::::::--?---;---.
~Il. ..
~~,
NDd",,1 E f~a.-t-ro"\. .
r~..: ::; ai-,;' t;t~1 + ."· + 1t~"~j/(
J
5()\"\~
+-~;.s
.>y..s:-b ~
<;.
t.£
tte ~
/ 11
~..:s
..
11~
r4.e sy.s:fc~
+ke t "tf""+ \S 1C 0 «'c.(.J +c.. e.. oc,.e..+f~ is ?t3. -rke",,4t. c:tt.""e fced-\:.«c:.ks £""0""'" ~-a.. c:t"C,d ~'3 bc~k +0 1£ ( • ~~ ~
Koclc.\ e("",+iollt..s
q.Ve.:
~, :: a.1to
+ C¥~
-+e~3
Sit4ce
') W~
tye ...~"V';+e
-c:t¥o
0
0
- -1ll
-+6~~
d.1G~
1'1 l'e
ct..$.
t Iiof&<,+)
-~$
-a.~o
0
-t
b
0
-I
e t
-I
ne. )
+()
1'3
\$) o-Pc:oc.(.,'V£e)
i.... ec:1'
cJJebV"c.. rY'~~teWo1...
~IJ?C"".J~:J
~3)
si",c(!!
$olve,-ft,"t
."C,+c:'l" ........ 0+ .s
"'tr..j4.",.J.
~o.
(Pttt.T+i'c",(fIC,.".&
~"'+po(,+J
;tt;,+c:.
w.le
;-1- ~.s
+0-1'
1-kis. s),s+€ ~ •
+~e. +o-r~
o~
+~~~~-t""r)Ct
;'Vt = +1 -c
o-
... +1 b
e -5+l
<r u.c.{S
T~ e
\1.0 l'
£4.c:k d i<.&,o~,\ea.(..-t-v-y
+,.
""~$'
~;L{,
+0 +~e +1
co\
i "'- f.(..4 s • t
~d.e.s
+~
C:.1''lfe.s
f ol(..d
Cl-Ye_)
rhrt4S
f<,~.t,:: JA., l~ _
= \ ~\'e\
cliV'ee.teJ
0""
c=t..
'S\(..e.-
-S1'OM4
~i +0
c..c,;
C-k~:t~) AI(J «a
+0'
S O{"e
+~c:
s:f£+e~ ') w e,
"l'¢tcc.i'l'¢s
C«""l..
Se,..,
C"'c;~e""$
'Y'«;(e-.
T~,s
eo .....
r.ct- i'::1
-J
+ IS +~c) ,..b
0
I I ~f-l. +,
+\
0
e -b
tI
0 ...
c$ <t> ~
-!-
Ih.,u,s d'·"ec.+eJ c:.i4V'c,,;{s i~ +k.e. J.".~&t (l) ( i.E' • +ee:.d - h a. c k. 10 ofs) t:t. f>f' eer.4' j ~ f-ft e. J e:f.t! .,..w& i e)C r~c.(.siot.(,. ,N'cr+e.. ~cc:.~ c \V'c.C(.'-\--
(f)
~+
*c.c.""
+-
~<ts
"'0 "'''''''4+...J
4ffec-0.
0~
ve"'+iceS
(+l....u
is
<t
n.o+
\ "\
~ cae c. ~
+t... ts t
J ts. e
T l..e'Yc.
C(".$S
'e...
does
e.,.......(
.yes...l+
Ee+o1"e
i"'j
c
(ert-$
CO$C4.t<.te
~3~
+It.e. -k
,.-;c
e-
~r't,. +-«.-+1:0"'l ~
0 0
+ Cte
j eC4e v-st l
...y"C!!'
so-e (-l-
a 1'0
I ,Nt \
r.
~3
-=-
a.,to [ b
elJ
\ - cl-£ - \0 c - e '-od
l-
+0
c::t.bJ
is
ch.-ec:.+eJ t'.d-Gu
-t-'Yo......
~g.
"A,
c.
\.
I4lz
1)l_3
-c l
-e
r
i.s
-b
0
~£J
-J
+e..
4IIIt.
Me,.,)
_.<i." .
T1t ;:£
,
iIJ
0W
c.u e
Co
.ss 0 e ict.
(Nf,..-.:,.
-f -r i"-
1-c
• __
cI t~e~+ccI ~Jt,
II,
...
-,
...
()
Co "'" ,~
• ...,
l.M. (t') 1
f:
IMer)\ ::::..a..
+0 ,
e..\e~~+,s
~e
.$~
oio~
f'Y'od ....c.+s
#- (1')
0
".£-
c:.o1'..e.$fo~!'''1
-!-
l .) J 3 'to
+\~es
~..,_ ~
~•
•
Tke",- , f- fG 'oS
..
II
..
•
""""-t...(.....". i J(
1
f
...)
+k~
I~\ ~ ~
~
• ••
Ji~~
+/_~
wlt~e
i s ~,. (J""lI9t.tIf.,-F ..
tff'.f-
~I
~, :i
-4,,a1
-4t"
.&..
I~I
. ".. ,
d..
WA
/' !'?'/'
,
/",,(.;,/
:: t-t (r)
)(~ =-1
(J A. •. - -
",
""',"
\ ~.l
a·· ~
/ f{{P)! ==
.
;<....r:.
f"rod.",,+
A re.'VW\.'-\..+~+(·.~ ,£
cycles . 1~C'Se. e, • .ot''Vu /ooF ; +"ke J "'rh !
wf.
<IIf.,..
p o~
+0 +ke..J
'f J ~~)
o~
e)<......... ple:
I~3'" ;:: ::
vu -= S"')
cr'
= (0:,0-:. JO;J
'::; ') (
J
u-:.)o:;:.)
~-:l.a
\
eC~
i..)-
IJ
,Nt. C7\ ;{
'"
r:. f{., ~
f! <cr1}(., €(~ ~
)
/
It
(aJ'~-
al:t)
"'3
f~)
~
tl.3J
"
€~)
::::-J
_ex.c,,\:!1,'(e. • ~
n =b
0- =
<..~) ~
J
0-; .>
a-;.)
0 ..~:.. .)
0--:)
u
:::. ( ~
3~
v-.>1.)
, .) s-)
",fe +k,d- +k e
(1-9- {e~+k, ~
ts
exp' .....':O io ... ) we
C~ )
co;lf
«.+1
Ji:
i.l """ o~
C~
e~ e. ~V
-t'Y""'1.. e~"-
+~
e1 Co
r e.
e.v~+t.C.4l
i ..... 't/;J.~( J
+e""'&4(,5..
,e.+
i 4oc.
+'-e...
K.
f:::cll
T~"-5
.ye~e
e (~
e (0--»
,.c(,Vi • ~ •
E::O'fH
(-11 =
E:L) c.-o e. +(
~'ot
(+\) ~~~)
'f)..
-t;
(a (.,_ Cl
~
3-)
d:5 f
Cly.,)
•
( tt J-'
(j,s: )
_________.,
~
L~
~
KI ::. ~
L, .::\.,
=-
-~
;&jo,,,,,+- ct
{4-~\s
0""-
v-c.~-b
+e.x.
cl
f~.cl""t;.-+s.4-
o~ .~ ...,(e..J
~$;oi"'"
" ......
0"'"
r-~~·-------·-
-- ...~-.~----.
-.---~- ..----~--
... ----
----------~-----
----
Yow Ie.+5
~~ +l,e"l" • ~
COllf.-/- i
1'f,V{.
-i-k« ~1I1.~.Jy s i s:
e x.
¢
c::t..
10;
ke: +he..
+-
"""P (e :
¥I
~ 2.
;.
= c. ~,
~"'O + h"" ~
+
a:'"
.3
~S
= K.~1f-e
0
r
~l ~
l.
~1&o o
I-~
00 0
o
o
-b
0
~J
-(YO
1-%0 0 -€ '0
0 -K
1'--:1
~<f
<..._.__-----...r
-r:.>
.Me(1)
~~~i/U~;)
1t.s -=
j
-h 0 0 -c I -~ 0
I 0
a..l}to
0
-'0
0
-d I
0
o -e
-sI
O
0 0
1)1 (f1))
o -K.
IS
a..~o
-G
0
-6
0
-d
0
~~ \
-8
0,
-T
l
-K
CfU)Co) tK)
C~
,~
d_'e\ -
I~ Ib ~e
(P 1_0b-
i l)
-@<.JCo)EK')(-cde
::: ')Co (
=.
-6
+ a.bK
+crbd)
-
yo
T+«, ~
~,+
+
11\0(.(.)
.et..C.de.K'
a.
<rbA",
J
•
~cJe K + ~ b-k:
(.s .::t.,
C1~ ~ d J)
~e. JY-~f'l.v . F ~ fierI-'!.? -f-o +Cr..rs
Jo4L
if {
~c
s e e;
~+-
\ fl : Z p~ ~
c::t.bK
de L<' ~
F "C.-t"se:co"t.-cl
-t¥O\NV
Fc:c.+~
~Tk~~~~;;64~
~+
dces
ner~ ls +!te
11.0
do
~~+--I-ou..c-~ Pr ,.
locp
,.J
+kq / ~
[ Thois
is The
5 e .... .,"'.,j
\0 e._
c::c_
f"'-- tl-e-'>"vu
s t..(_
"'1A.._..)
!1
0~
/0 c.<..+ P":+'
~'fwO
<T; AK
c..V r- ((
V1.!;("""t~'Y'c{'+Oy
d.e+e~wt.j~...,,+- -fe-f
cc» h-e...-ye....:J
+ke........
1<'
is
;r...
+he.+..y~~~ fry j
0 Wi...
fro
'1.
~~
COVVl.-p
e:Y'
-+ "V'\.-C..+
J~v+
ia'-'\.
01+0
d e,
+0".')
e d Je
0 (..(...+ p "(..
+0 '(' ~
(~~e[s
J. i .ye.c.+c:.-cl
l-t~"t.c..e._
f G(..-t4.__
-t..-
+~
J
+k'E!..---
o (..(..+p ~+-
\-t-
~
U,.)
~e
k.~V-E!..-
c.
C(_.VL.o
S::~.Y
""-c! e.... 0
i ~.j
t)(-
e~ey-aJ
q,,"1.,....
e.,
.s 0 t.V'V"
~
C. e,
V\.O cJ e..
(7L/~ -
:f T; ~i4
-t-o r
+~e..~
d._
+~C(.....+-
----~-----------o---------------It..t,v~
--r;; J;
e
I-t
i.s k
o c..(...y'
e x. e:t
.b
(AA,.,f> (~ K
(\ -(c~-~32> -C9~~h)
c "d c. c.(.,
Co
-(e-£)+ .
cc.h)(e~))
e)(.~ {tc:.'{..[Y
o~
+Ct...e..
( 0(.
~f>
","Y
..;--tz,~::>
fcj
i .s 0 v.....
+e d -+ ~e.
c.u (c:-(._.
vt..
r""'t.-'<...
+~
e..~+- fc:e..je..
c..c..)e...
k~ve__.
~
«C-
1;At (/1) l
A~.5 a
+c)
+-
0'")1"
'Y
-t--
",,'
.s
..y't..(.. (
e,..
_---------
---
-----~---_-_--_--
---
6 ==
\ fit Cr)\:::
\ -h
-c., \
0
0
0
0
0 0
o-b
o
d.
0 0
-~
-e
0
\ --!l
-K.-
-~
00
+h,
-c
-b
0
-do
0 0
\ -~
-e
0
-~ +h
l0
-to<
\ -€,
0
-s\
0 -0
o
0
'::: \ I _- ~
-e
o
0\ 0
+(JJ
-_d
o
C
..:..~0 \
-K \
-k
l
+a 'b
-
-k 1 e \ \ --t 0
-e.,. I
0
0 -K \
-f
I0
j_
-I
+~I-: ~1-8"dl~~~
~ (f d Jc.
c, ~
-K
+ h -C[I +s-I-o€ ~+
-== \ - e £-
t ~£--r-:~I
I-
hR
-
ef ~ + a-I-t -%- ( - b)
c~
==- \ oo.~
e~ - ~
3-' b ~ 5- +
e£-
= \-
rh is
~e
s(J"'ed
C" ec..{oCr.
loof -
c...v
o.-e-
sc;(.WL)",
/r
~\\~~~~.~.~~
~~~.~~~
~~
~/~~~.
~~~.~~~
~~~.
)1.ASOtV>S
,~CoR!1-LtLA
tr/~
=::-
~TKAy.6