' ;;.;'N 3 k 1 1 ') aSI'x '(a1:$5Il' .'1 6El)I>I F.

EI)5':( - L ) I 1

J R) NAAR E E O ( V RT E
5A YJEON 1R A1S

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866 DktEntry: 397 q-'L h 9'Z c . ) l' , . . u ' 3 - . . xsJo( > kt.-1t' .?. ' w tw x o'W b ' >yk a . %C . A' # / $

Page: 1 of 74

A ' NAI(A PA. SJ1 S R Ul I'1 PE 1 t4ReO - '1 O , 12 I S

t. - ; . * t A: x f x' y/. x'p t L Gc .t. ', r%' v1 . **,c%% .a k s t )x .

1 R WAR E B;IDIG ! L R N tI N A w 3(5cL l'E S-1 5 I. LS%R -R! 1 ) & 1 I ES NF A CS ( ( 912 A R N 1C) . 40 .2 A (1)8570 45 6-00

Au rmefs r s Cai r i pe ut f lsna f

CO llA NIlTR' RA D Uk- DINS Al N ' ' O C.R O TlES!R 5EC tt' :1 K F . t E. Ol' ! I P 1 II

ROLc.DWYR, KK MLt e k' E D EY Ev R ) GL

UsC UT F PEL ..O R O APAS

FR DERlKK. HL IH E C O RC

D C2221 E 21
FE ID L DCEE OKTD T AE IML NA I

Dee e 2 , 0 l cmbr 0 2 1

U.. o ro Ap elfrh Nit Ci ut S C ut f p as o te nh r i c 9 S vnhSre 5 e et t t e

SFns arco nai c

t - t/ q$ ot

Re 519 7 -PERRYv BROWN : 8 46 . E coe iacrf dcp o teo iino ticu'fe No e e 1, 0 1 n lsd s eti oy fh pno fhs o l i d vmbr 7 2 1 ie tl whc o iinin w f a. ih pno s o i l n
Veytuyy us r rl o r, F DE CK K.OHL CH RE RI RI Co rAd nsrtr n ut mii ao a d t Clr o teSpe Co r ek fh u rme ut By N. e aie : B nvdz

EcoueCp ooiin nlsr(oy fpno) AlC usln oiinecoe) l one(o pno nlsd
Re. c

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011 cD E CEK M LY .ID: 8011866 O L > R LR

R E c e kV K D USC UT F PEC ..Oq O APAS

DktEntry: 397

Page: 2 of 74

D 22221 2 21

SPE C R U R ME OU T

FI ED L

colv a

Ngy gj , , gj . y I THE S N UPREM E COURT OF CALI Fe eikK OhrhClr FORNG . lc ek rd r c i

D p: eu

Llr gsn s

,. .

KRITI M. ERRY ea. SN P t1 , Panif adRep n et, lit s n sodns f

519 7 846

G. BROWN,R.a Go e rec,t l 9hCi. .0 16 6 J ,s vmo,t.ea. t rNo 1-6 9 , Deedns fn at' , N. Ca. . D. lNo CI AND COUNTY OFS F NCICO, TY AN M S 30 -v-2 9 :9c 0 2 2VRW Itree adRep n et nevnr n so dn; ED
DENNI HOLLI WORTH e a. S NGS tl , ltreesadAp elns nevnr n p lat.

Ath rq et fh UntdSae Co ro Ap elfrteNit Cici te eu so te i tts ut f p aso h nh rut e , weare t d cd aq eto o Caiona1wta irlvn t teu dryn ged o eie usin f lfri a hts eeato h n elig

lwsiitimat nwpn igitafdrlp eltcut( r.vB o a utn hs tr o edn n hteeaapl e or.Per . rwn e a y (tCi No 1-69)seCa. ls f or rl858)As oe b te 9h r .0166;e lRueo C ut ue .4. p sd yh . , Nit Ci utteqet ntb dcddiSwqehr neatlI,et n8o nh r i h usi o e eie st hteudrrceIsci f c, o l i o
teCaionaCo si to , r tewieu drCaionalw,h ofca h l ri ntuin o oh r s n e l ri a te fiil f t f po nnso a iiaiemesr p sesete ap riuaie itrsi te rpoet f n nt t aue oss i r at lrzd neetn h iv h c iiaiesv l i o teatoi t asrteSaesitrsi teiiaies nt t ' ai t rh uh rt o seth tt' neetn h nt tv ' iv dy y i v l i , ihwo l eal te t dfn tecntuinlyo teiiaie ai t whc ud nbe hm o ee d h o si toai fh nt tv dy t t i

u o i aot noapaaug n ivlaigteiiaiewhnte u l pnt dpi rpel jdmetn ai t h ntt , e h p bi s o dn iv c

ofcascag dwi ta dt rfs t d s. fiil h re t ht uy eue o o o' h ' l adesn tiisewee h sz ateoteta ato g i ti n d rsig hssu , mp aie th ustht l u h n hs h cs teq et np sdb teNit Cicihp n t aiei liain aeh u si oe y h nh rut apeso rs n igto o t

S ECONCURRI OP NI E NG I ON

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 3 of 74

caln igte aii , n e teUntdSae C ntuin o teiiaie h l gn h vl t u drh i tts o si t , fh nt t e dy e to iv

mesr (rpsin8taaddascint teCai riCostt n auePooio )htde et oh lona ntui t o f i o poiigtaSonymar g bt e ama ada ma ivl o rvdn htll rae ewen n n wo ns ai r l i d rcgie iCai ri'( 1C nt at1j75,h sae1wisetahs eonzdn lona'Ca. o s,r., . te tt a su ht a f . )
b e sb te t ti cutsttl u rltdt tesbtni q eto o te en u mitd o hs o ri oal neae o h u sat u sin fh y ve cntuinl aii o Po oio 8 Isedteq eto b fr u iv le a o si t av l t f rp st n . nta,h u sin eoe sn ov s to dy i fmdmetl rcd rlsu ta ma aiewi rsetoayiiaiemesr, t a napoeua iseht y rs t ep ct n nt t aue h iv

wi oteadt i sbet tr T esme rcdrlsu rgriga t urgr ot ujcmat . h a poeuaiseeadn n h s e of ilntt epooet sadn t apaa apr iauiilrceig fcaiiai rpnn' tnigo pers at n jdcapoedn i iv s y t dfn tevl i o a oe-prvdiiaieo t apaaug n o eedh ait f vtrapoe ntt ro pel jdmet dy iv
ivaiaigiwh ntepbi ofcaswh odnrl po iesc adfneo n l tn t e h u l fiil o riai rvd u h ees r d c y flsc a ap a dciet d s,o l aiewi rgr t a iiai ie uh n p el el o o o cud rs t ead o n nt t n h i ve

mesrta,o ea l,1l tdcmpincnr uin tama b auehtfrxmpe()i e a ag otbt sht y e mi i o clce b eetdlgs t eo eeuieof il,r()mpsdtr l t ol td y lce eili rxct fcaso 2 i oe em i s e av v i mi freiaieadeeuieof e,r3poiidgvrmet fiilfo o lgs t n xct fcso () hhbt oen n of asrm lv v i e c
acpige ly n atrlaigofc wi cmpne o idvd asta hv cet mpo met fe evn fie t o ais rn iiul ht ae n h bn fe'rmteofcasdsrto aygv rmetl eiin whli ofc. eei dfo h fiil' iceinr o en nad cso s i n fie t e

(f eg, rp 7 (r r Ee.Jn 7 18:,naiae ipriKopv Cl ..Po.3 Pi y lc(ue ,98 ivl td n atn p . , ma d F iP lPate C m.19)1 Ca.t 67(a ag cnr uinl t) ar o. rci s o (9 5 1 1 h 0 cmpin oti t i s; c 4 b o mi Po .4 ( nEe.No.,90)uhliLgsauevE (9 1 5 rp 10 Ge. lc( v6 19),ped n eiltr . u 19) 4 Ca.d42(r l tqCi o SnaMoias alt aue rp L 1 9 t m i s; t f at nc'bl mesrPo . L 3 e mi y o ( noiae Ge. nEe.No.,00)uhliCto atMoiav Cosl td nMu.lc( v720),pedn i fsna nc . d y Se at20)16Ca. p4h4 (otoen n e ly n l tl T e tw r(05 2 l . 3 ps vrmetmpometi s. h Ap t g mi )
rslto o tipoeua q eto d e n tuno tesbtn eo te eouin fhs rcd rl u sin os o tr n h u sa c fh priua iiaiemesr a iseb tahro tep r s a ditgi o te at lrnt t aue tsu ,u rte n h upoe n nert fh c iv y iiitv poesisl. ntaie rcs tef
2

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 4 of 74

As dsusmoefl blw,ntep sof il rp n nso iiit e we ic s r ul eo i h at fi apo o et fntai y c v mesrsi Caionahv u ioml be pr te t priiaea prisaue n l ri ae nfr y en emi d o at pt s at f t c e ete a itreeso a raprisi itrs- i n meo slwsisi i r snevnr r sel at n neet n u ru a ut n h e Caionacutcaln igtev l i o teiiaiemesr tepoo et l ri o rs h l gn h ai t fh nt t aueh rp nns f e dy iv

sosrd S c priiainhsruieybe pr t d() totn pnoe. uh at pt a ot l en emie 1wi u ay c o n t h

iqiyit o so n tatepo o et' wnpo et,iet,rohr n ur no r h wig hth rp n ns o rpry l ry o te b pro alg l poetditrsswol b seil afce b ivaiaino esnleal rtce neet ud e p cal fetd y n l to f y y d

te auead() ehr r ote oen nof ilwh odnry h mesr,n 2 whte on th gvrmetfias o riai c l
dfn acaln e e at n weeas d fn igtemesr i tepoedn . eed h l gd ncmet r lo eedn h aue n h rceig e Thscuthwee, a nt rvo syh docso fl t epanteb ss i or, o v rh s o pe iul a cain ul o x li h ai y u o whc a ofca iiaiepo o etsait t priiaea apryi p n ih n fiilnt t rp nn' bly o at pt s at n iv i c sc liainrjs uh igto et. t Aswesalx li, ea s teiiaiepoesisei al itn e h lepan b cueh nt t rcs s p cfcl ned d iv y t ealtepo l t a n tesaeCo si to o t eattttswh n o nbeh epe o me d h tt ntuin ro n csaue e t

cret oen n'fiilhv dcie t aotadot hv pbil urn gvrmet f as ae el d o dp (n fn ae ul y oc n e c opsdtemesri qet ntevtrwh hv scesul aotda p oe)h auen uso,h oes p ae ucsfl dpe n i y
iiaiemesr ma rao al hro algt t cn entatep bi nttv aue y esnby ab r eii e o cr hth u lc i ma ofcas oodnrl d fn acaln e sae1w i cut yn ti tecs fiilwh riai eed h l gd tt a n o rma o,n h ae y e o a iiaiemesr,l y u dr k sc adfnewi vg r r t te f n ntt aueawas n et e uh ees t io M wi h iv a h h

ojcie aditrs o toe oes aa utnmid As cneune bet s n neet fh svtrprmoni n . a osqec, v s
Cai ricuthv ruieypr te teofcapo o eto a iiit e lona ors ae o t l emi d h fiil rp n ns fn nt i f n t av t itreeo ap a a raprisi itrst d fn acaln e v tr o nevn r p er s el at n neeto eed h l gd oee e apo e iiaiemesr i odrtog adtepo l'rg toe ecs p rvd nt tv auen re t u r h epes ih t xrie i t

iiaiepwe'( iigIdsrAs.. to a rl (964 Ca.d ntt o r Buln nut snvCi fc maio 18) 1 1 iv ' d y y l 3 8082( i igldsrAsn4o,nohr rst ealsc pooet 1,2 Buln nut s. ri tewod,o nbe uh rpnns d y 4
t asrte o e' adh netesae' itrsi d fn igtev l i o o seth pepl s n e c h tt s neetn ee dn h ai t f , , dy teiiaiemesr.Al wigofcapo o ett asrtesaesitrsi h nttv aue l n fiil rp nnso seth tt' neetn i o

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 5 of 74

tevl i o teiiaiemesr i sc liain(ln wi ayp bi h ai t fh ntt auen uhigt aog t n ul dy iv t o h c of ilwh ma as b dfnigtemesr) 1asrs oes o fcas o y l e eedn h aue()suev trwh o
sp otdtemesr adeatdiit 1w ta ayrsda h sit o u p re h aue n nce tno a ht n eiul otly r i i ifrn eo cret u lcofcast tesbtneo teiiaiemesr ndfeec f urn p bi fiil o h u sa c fh nt t aue iv wi nt rv n afladrb sdfneo temesr t b mo ne i cut n l o peet uln o ut ees fh ueo e u td n o ro l

te epes eafad()nue acutae wi tersosblyo h pol'bhl n 2 esrs orfcd t h epniit f , h i

rve n a drsligalg lhleg t a iiaiemesr ta iia r e iwig n eovn ea caln e t n nt t aueh tts wae ) iv o ada dessteflrn eo lgl ru nsta rao al ma b f n d rse h ulag fe aag met htesnby y e pofrdi temesr'd fne l timame,h ofcapo o et' rfee n h aues ees. n hs r rte fiil rp nns gn rlblyt ap a addfn tesaesitrsi tev l i o te eea ait o p er n eed h tt' neetn h ai t fh i dy

iiaiemesr adt apaalwecutug n ivl aigtemesr ntt aue n o p el o r orjdmetnai t h aue iv dn sre t ehnebtteareso teu iilrcsadteapaac o evso n ac oh h fi s fh jdcapoesn h perne f n
fins o tapoes ares fht rcs. Wehv cuindta i motntne ima wel ea aueo ae atoe htn sisacst y lb n b s f dsrto fracutofit pr th ofcapo o eto a iiaiet icein o o rt alo emite fiil rp nns f n nt t o iv

itreeiauiilrceigtpoeth pol'r ht eecs ter nevn n jdcapoedn o rtcte epesi to xri hi g e

iiit epo ree whno eo moeg ven n dfn at aedfn igte nt i we v n e n r r o rmet eedns r eedn h av

iiaies aii itepoedn .(e B i igIdsyA s.spa4 ntt 'vl t nh rceig Se ul n nut sn,ur, 1 i v dy d r Ca.dap 82)T u,na is ne letaietiditeqet n l t .2 . h si nnt c - i htdnie n h uso 3 a k f i
sb te b teNit Cici- i whc tep biofcashv ttl u mi d y h nh rut n ih h u l fiil ae oal t c y d cie t dfn teiiaiesvldt a alwecn ld ta,nl h o te el d o ee d h nt t ' aii t l, o cu eh ti i t fh n iv y g n tr a dp roeo teiiaiepoese o idi atl l,eto 8o te aue n up s fh nt t rcs mb de n ri e 1scin fh iv c

Cai riCosit n(eefeatll,etn8adteuiu rlo lona ntui hratrrceIsci )n h nqe oe f f to i o

iiai po o eti tecntuinlnttv poesa rcg ie b nt t rp nnsn h o si t a iiaie rcs s eo nzd y i ve to i n meo s rvso so teElin Co eiwo l cerycntuea aueo u ru po iin fh eto s d ,t ud lal o si t n b s f t

dsrt nfr cutodn teof il rp n ns f niiaiete icei o a ort ey h fi apo o eto a nt t h o c iv o p ruiyt priiaea fr l atsi tepoedn ,i e a itrees p otnt o at pt s oma pri n h rceig et r snevn r c e h
4

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 6 of 74

o a rap risi itrs,nodroasrtep o l'adhn etesaes r s el at n neeti ret seth epes n ec h tt' e

itrsitevl i otemesr adtapaaug n ivl aigte neetnh ai t fh aue n o pel jdmetnai t h dy dn

mesr.I ohr rsbcueiiesnlloteitgi o teiiaie aue n tewod,eas ts set t h nery fh ntt a t iv
poese o idi atl I,eto 8tateeb smen t asrtesaes rcs mb de n ri e Iscin h th r e o o e o seth tt' c itrsi a iiaiesv l i o bh lo tepo l wh ntep bi ofcas neetn n nt t ' ai t n e af fh epe e h u l fiil iv dy c wh n r l asrtaitrsdciet d s,n bcueteofca o omal sethtneet el o o o ad ea s h fiil y n

pooeto a iiaie( l ho ter nqerlt nhpt teiiaie rp nns fnntt i i t fhiu iu eai si oh ntt iv n g o iv mesrudrr.1j8adterlvnpo ios fh ElcCoe aeh aue n eat1, n h eeat rvs n o te e. d)rte i
mot b iu adlgcl ro st asrtesaesitrsi teiiaies so vo s n o iapesn o seth tt' neetn h nt t ' iv vaii o bh lo tevoeswh eatdtemesr, cn ld ta ldt n eaf fh tr o n ce h auewe o cu e ht y Caio a1w atoie teof il rp nnsu drsc cru tne,o lfmi a uh rzsh fi apo oet,n e uh icmsacst c ap a i tepoedn t asrtesaesitrsi teiiaiesvldt ad p ern h rceig o seth tt' neetn h nt tv ' aii n i y

t apaaug n ivlaigte aue Nehrh Goenrte o p el jdmetn ai t h mesr. i ete vro,h dn t

AtonyGeea,o ayohreeuieo lgsaieofcah steatoi tre n rln r n te x ct reilt fiil a h uh ry v v t t v t o iv l aea iiaiemesr tah sb e apoe b tev tr.l o eo rn ai t n nt t aueht a en p rvd y h oes t d iv wo l eatfr o e sbtnet itrrt lo a1w i aman rht ud ud xl om vr u sac o nepe Cai mi a n n e tawo l f pr ths p bi ofcast idrcl ahe esc arslb dn igte emitee u l fiil o n iety c iv u h eut y eyn h c ofca iiit epo o e tteatoi t se i t asrtesaesitrsi fiilnt i rp nnsh uh rt o tp n o seth tt' neetn av y

te adt o temesr ot apaalwecutug n ivl aigte h vl i fh aue ro p el o rorjdmetn ai t h iy dn

mesr wh ntoep bi ofcasdciet asrta itrso t ap a a aue e h s u l fiil el o seth tneet ro p eln c n

avreu g n. desjdmet
Acodn l, rso dt teq eto p sdb teNit Cic ii te crigy we ep n o h u sin oe y h nh rutn h afnnt e l ap seet ncaln et av trapo e iiaiemesr,h fi ai . n otlci h l g o oe-p rv d nt t auete v o e iv ofcapo oeto teiiaieaeatoie u drCaionalwt ap a fiil rp nns fh nt t r uh rzd n e l ri a o p er iv f

adasrtes t'itrsiteiiaies aii adtapaaug n n seth tesnetn h ntt 'vl t n o p el jdmet a i v dy

ivldt gtemesr whntep bi of ilwh odnrl d fn te n aiai h aue e h u l fi as o riai ee dh n c c y

mesr o apasc aug n dciet d s. aue rp eluh jdmet el o o o n

5

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 7 of 74

1Fat l n Prcd rl c ru . cua a d oe u a Bakgo nd Web gnwi abifsmmayo tefcul n poeuab cgo n e i t re u r fh ata ad rcdrl ak ru d h o tecret rce ig fh urn poedn .

I Ma 2 0, maoi o ticutocue tateC lo asa e n y 0 8a jry fhs orcnlddhth ai mi tmts t f

l t gtedsg aino mara et op st-e cu lsvoae terg t f i i h einto f rig o p oi sx ope iltd h ih o min e smesxcu lsot eul rtcino telwsa g aate b tetea -e o pe t he q apoeto fh a s urned y h hn

gvmigpoioso teCai riCostt n ( r MaraeC ss2 0) oe n rvs n fh lona ntui .1 e rig ae (0 8 i f io n 4 Ca.t77)T eefritegnrllcinhli C lonai 3 1 h 5 . hrat,nh eeaeet ed n ai ri n 4 e o f Noe e20, maoi ovtrapoe Pooio 8a iiaie vmbr 08a jry f oesprvd rpsin ,nntt t t iv
mesr ta a n e teCaio aCo si to b adn anwscinaueht med d h l mi ntuin y d ig e et f t o scin75- t at l lo teCaionaCo si to .Scin75o atl lo eto . o ri e fh lfri ntuin et . f ri e f c t o c teCaionaCo si to po ie i 11: l maig bt e ama ada h l ri ntt in rvd sn 1 y na e ewen n n f u on wo nivai o rcg ie i Caiona' ma s ld reo nzd n' lfri. ' Po oio 8wa sb te t teAt re Ge ea, i uae fr rp st n s u mi d o h t ny nrlcr ltd o i t o c sg auea dfr lyfldwi teSceayo Saefrsb sint te intr, n omal i t h ertr f tt o u miso oh e h vtrb fv Caionaeetr - DensHol gwot Gal . ih, ri oes y ie lfri lcos n i ln s rh, iJKng tMat i n F. terzHa-higWiim Ta adMakA.aso - wh aete Guire, ks n la m,n r Jnsn l orh

of ilrpnnsoteiiaiemesru dr ai rilw.(lcCoe fcapooet fh ntt aue ne C lonaa Ee. d, i iv f j 3290 . S ot atr o nigteiiaie eio poeste j 4 ,0 1) hry f cmmecn h ntt ptin rcs,h l e iv t pooetetbi e Poet rig. m - Ye o 8aPoet f lona rpnns salhd rtcMaraec s o s n , rjco Cai ri f Ree lhratr rtcMaig.o a aalt auecmmie'(e nwa(eef Poet naecm)s l mesr o t e se e bo t' Go. d, 817 t spri a1seto tecmpint qai te vCoej 4 0)o uevs 1apcs fh a ag o ulyh e f
mesr frh bl t n t se t oti i a o t na teesigeeto . aue o te al a d o ek o ban t d pi th nun lcin o s o On dyatrt No e e 2 0 eeto a whc Prpoio 8wa e a fe he v mbr 0 8 lcin t ih o st n s i

apoe b amaoi ovtr,p oeto temesrfe treptin prvd y jry f oesopnns fh auei dhe eios t l t
fr noiiawrt f n aei ticutc legn tevldt o o a rgn l io ma dt n hs or,haln ig h aii f y

P oio 8udrh C lo aCostt n th tre eios r mpsin n ete ai mi ntui .T ele ptin wee t f io t t

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 8 of 74

ut tl cnoiae addcddtgteiSrusvHotn(09 4 lmaey osl td n eie oehrn tas . ro 20) 6 i d Ca.t 34lt us.T e eios otn e pi rltaPooio 8 1 h 6 sr sj h ptin cnedd rmai ht rp sin 4 a l t y t
cnt e acntmt n leiin whc u drteCaionaCo siuincud o si d o si i arvso , ih n e h l ri nttt o l mt o f o nopo ryb aotdtru hteiiai po esrte ta acntuin l t rpel e d pe ho g h nt t rcs,ah rhn osi to a i ve t a n metwhc cudb aotdb iiaie o eptinas c ned dta med n, ih o l e d pe y nt t 'n eio lo o tn e ht i v, t Prpoio 8voae tesprto o p wesd crn e o idi te o st n iltd h eaain f o r otie mb de n h i CaionaCo si to . l ri ntuin f t Whltoep tin weep n ig adb fr ticut eie whte ieh s eios r edn ,n eoehs o rdcdd ehr t t acp tematr fr eiin teot il rp nnso Prp sto 8fld o ceth teso dcso ,h fcapo o et f o oi n i i i e moin t itre ei ec o tepo edn st d fn tevaii o to so nevn n ah fh rceig ,o eed h ldt f y Po oio 8 S ot teefe,hscut gedt h a addcd tepeio s rp st n . h rl hratrti orare o er n eieh tin i y t ad i tesmeodrgatdteofcapo o et' to st itreei te n ,n h a re, rne h f il rp nnsmoin o nevn n h po edn sl rceig. Afe bifn a doa ag metticuto Ma 2 , 0 9h n e tr reig n rlru n,hs o r,n y 6 2 0 , ad d

dwni dcs niSrusspa4 Ca.t34cnldn ()htudrh o t eii n tas,ur,6 l h 6.ocu ig 1ta,n ete s o 4 ,
CaionaCo si to , rpoio 8wa acntuin l med n,ahrta l ri ntuin Po st n s o si t a a n metrte h n f t i to acntuin leiin adtu cudb a otdtru hteiiaiepoes o si to arvso ,n h s o l e d pe ho g h nt t rcs, t iv

ad()hth mesr ddnt ilttesprt nop wes otn n 2 tate aue i ovoaeh eaai fo rdcr e o i
e o idi teCaionaCo siuin mb de n h l ri nt to . f t

OnMa 2,09jsafwdy bfrtedcso iSrusspa4 y 220,ut e as eoeh ei nn tas,ur,6 i

Ca.t 3 4 wa GldpanifKrsi M. ry S n r B. t rP u T. tmi 1 h 6 , s e, lit s i n Per, a da Si , a l Kaa , 4 f t e adJfryJZarl - t smesxcu ls o atrh ao to o n efe . rio wo a -e o pe wh ,fe te dpin f l

Th odri Srusspr, 6Ca.t 3 4 whlgat gtemoint e re n ta s,u a4 1 h 6 , i rni h to o 4 e n itre efldb teofcapo o eto Po oiin8smutn sydne a nevn i y h fiil rp nns f rp sto ,i l e ul eid e a moint itreeta hdb e fldb asprt poprp sto 8av cc to o nevn h t a en i y e aae r- o oi n d o ay e i og nzto Ca ag frCaipnaF mie,h t sn t nofcapo o et ra iain, mpin o l ri a l sta wa o a fiil rp n n f i o tecaln e iiaiemesr. fh h l g d nt t aue e iv

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 9 of 74

Prp st n8hdsu h b t a b e dne marael essi Almea o oio , a o g t u hd en eid rig i ne n a d i c Conya dLo An ee Co nyrsetvl - fldteu dryn at nite u t n s g ls u t ep ciey ie h n elig ci n h o

cret trnfdrlir tori SnFacso ( ryv urnmat i eeadsi cutn a rnic.Pcr . e tc Sh aznge ( D. INo30-v022W1 ) Paniscmpani qw reegrN. Ca. . :9c-29- W. litf'o litn 2 f
Per nme a dfn ati terofcacp cte teGo ro o Caiona ry a d s eed nsn h i fiil aai sh ven r f lfri, i teAtonyGeea o CaionateDietradteDeuyDietro te h tre nrl f lfri,h rco n h p t rco fh SaeDeat n o Pu l Hel sh Alme aCo nyClr- cre,n te tt prmet f bi at te a d u t ekReodra dh c h Lo An ee ConyReita- cre/ u t Clr.T ecmpan algd s g ls u t gsrrReodrco ny ek h o lit l e e taPrp st n8voae ted epo esadeu l rtcincasso te ht o oio iltsh u rcs n q apoeto lue fh i

fdrl ntuinadsu hijmcieaddcaaoyrl f eeaCostt n ogtnt t n elrtr ei . io v e3

OnMa 2 , 0 9tepo o et o Po oio 8ad y 82 0 ,h rp n ns f rp st n n i

Poet rig.o (eefr rpnnsfe amoint itreeite rtcMaraecm hrat Pooet)i d t onevn nh e l o
Pcr poedn , itiigtateeitn p risi teato wo l n t ry rceig manann hth xsig at n h cin ud o e aeutl rpeeth itrsso toewh wih dt dfn temesr. dq aey ersn teneet fh s o se o eed h aue 2 Th dcso rn ee b tefdrl itit o ratrrawa p bihd e eiin edrd y h eea dsrccutfe til s u l e s

aneyvShlreegrberfCe.00hi4Fson.Pe11dfr nt s eln ewi h ratrN. ra 21)0 p.upz 9ra ,o Pr .cw znge( D. I o n 7 n p s 2 n e a d c vnec, l eefe eerdt i t so ii a ry .Th Ni h o

Ciciodrsb tigteq eto o sadn t ticut sp bih da rut re u mit h u sin f tn ig o hs orwa u l e s n s

Pfre.cwhznyiratCr.11)e8eNit9,cdwideefeb ne eyvSh a eeg (h i 2 16 t .d1 1rni sehtat , r r e 9 r 0 t F3 1 a l r re e 2 ls r r rdt i tio l o sPe y1.Af rh nhCi uttl i odra w e r o n s pn n r

Goen ro Caionato ofc adtematr ssbeunl rtte Per v ro f l ri o k fie n h t wa u sq ety ei d ry f e l vBrwn tcretilo tepoedn i ticut . o ,h urn tt fh rceig n hs or. e Heefe,x et e s cfcl rfnn t ete tedsrccuts ratrecp wh n peiial ee ig o i rh itit o r' y h dcso o teNit Cici'odrtio iinwi rfrt tefdrla ut eiin rh nh ruts re,hs pno l ee o h eea lwsi l smpya tePer ato . i l sh ry cin 3 I teSru liainfldi ticutteptt n r caln e te n h ta n igt ie n hs o r,h eio es h l g d h t o i e v l i o Pooio 8o l o saecnt inl ru d,n ddntas te ai t f rp st n ny n tt o si o ago n sad i o rie h dy i mt q eto o tecntuin l aii o temesr u drtefdrl usin fh o si to av l t fh aue n e h eea t dy

Cosi in (e Srusspa4 Ca.t ap 421.1)Ou oiini nt o. Se t s,ur,6 1 h t . 1, 1. r pno n mt a 4

Srusddn tadestefdrlo si to a ise tas i o d rs h e ea cntuin lsu . t

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 10 of 74

OnJn 1, 0 9 a1 a ddfn atfldas r t tecmpan.I u e 22 0 ,1n me eednsie nweso h o lit n teras r,h nme d fn atohrhnteAton yGe earfsdt hi nweste a d eedns te ta h lre nrleue o tk ap sto o temeiso panif' o si in lh ln ea ddcie t ae oi n n h rt f lit scnt o ac al g n el d o i f mt e n d fn tevldt o Po oiin8 Th as rfldb teAtonyGeea eed h aii f rp st . e nwe i y h tre n rl y o e as dcie t d fn teiiitv ,u wetfrhradafr t eyto te lo el d o eed h ntaieb t n ute n fimai l ok h n v p st ntaPo oio 8iu cnt in l oii ht rp st n s no si o a. o i mt OnJl 2 2 0 ,h dsrccut edah aigo an mbro matr, uy , 09 te itit orhl ern n u e f tes icu igtemoint itreefe b Po nns Atht ern ,h dsrc n ldn h to o nevn i d y rpo et. tahaigte itit l cutbevdta n e Caionalw,s1u drtn i,rpo eto oro sre h t dr lfri a a n esad tpo nns f u iiaiemesrshv sadn t rpeet rp nnsadt d fn a nt tv aue ae tn ig o ersn po o et n o eed n i eat n ta ibo g tit lw b teiiaiepoes'n sg etdta n cmethts ru h no a y h nt t rcs'ad u gse ht iv sc itret nb teot aiiaiepo nns spriual apo rae uh nevni y h f lnt t rpo etwa at lry p rpit o ki i v c l eeteatoie,h d fn atwh odnrl wo l dfn te s r h uh rt ste eedns o riai ud ee d h wh i y po oio o tee at n ta ibigc aln e h r,r tkn tep sto rp st n rh ncmethts en hl gd ee aea ig h oi n i e i

ta,nfc,tscntuinl ifml. Netepanis o ayo tenme hti atii o stt al ni l' i r litfnrn fh a d io y r ' h f dfnatojce t Pooet' t nt itreeadtedsitor eedns betd o rpnnsmoi onevn n h ir cut o tc
ga tdtemoin. rne h t 4 o

Th rlvat otno tetasr to teJl 2 2 0 h aigras e ee n p ri fh rnci fh uy , 0 9 ern ed: o p

SWqhrsetotemointitreetabs aliuopsdadide i epct h t onevh,ht ai l s np oe n,t os l t o cy se tmesbtnil jsie itics,atualwhrteatoie, em o ,u sat l utidnhs aepri lr eeh uhris ay f c y t
ted fn atwh odnrl wo l dfn tepo oio o teeat n ta h eedns o riai ud eed h rp st n rh n cmetht y i ib igcaln e hr,r tkn tep st nta,nfc,tscnt in l s en h l gd ee aeaig h oio hti atii o si o al e i mt y

ifml.An s,temstmebtfrrciaraosadraos f ni ) d oise o ,oh opat lesn n esn o r c poedn itics ia odr adu iilaho taitretni rceignhs aen n rel n jdcafsin htnevni s y o aporae ()C r il,neCai milw,s udrtn ipooeto p rpit. ! etny udr lo aa a 1 nesadt rpnns f a f , iiit emesrshv tesadn t rpeet rp nnsadt d fn a ntai aue aeh tn ig o ersn po o et n o eed n v eat ntaibogtno1wb teiiaie rcs.(j..Ajeteeay ncmethts ruhit a yh ntt poes 1 .( r hr n iv r ojcin t gat gtemoint itree ( rsos.Her gnn,ht bet so rni h t onevn? No epne) ai oeta o n o n
moinwil egatd' to lb rne . '

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 11 of 74

ThrtrPrp nnsprii tda itre esi tedsrc cutra eefe, o o et at pae snevnr n h itit ortil c i Pel Ide, o o etweeteo l pryi tedsrccutopeet n ry. n edPrp nns r h ny at n h itit o rt rsn wi essadlgl ru n i d fneo tecaln e iiit emesr. t se n e aag metn ees fh h l g d nt i aues n e av Ath cnlso o tetiltedsrc cutsudaln tyo iin te o cuin fh ra,h itit o rise e gh pno , stigfr n meo sf dn so fc adcn lso so 1w addtr nn et ot u ru i ig fatn o cuin fa n eemiig n h n taPrp st n8voae b t ted epoesadeul rtcincasso te ht o oio ilts oh h u rcs n q apoeto lue fh i

fdrl osit (erfspa 74Fsp .d9 1 T edsitor eeaC ntui .P ry ur, 0 .upz 2 . h itccut to ) r ise a odr nonn dfn atiter fcacpctsadal esn sud n reejiig eednsnhiof ilaaie,n 1pros i i
5 T edsrc cutnPer as gatdamoinfldb teCi ad h itit ori ry lo rne to i y h t n e y

Conyo SnFacso(a Facso t itreeiteat no bhlo ut f a rnic Sn rni )onevn nh ci n eaf f c o

panif.Asa itree, a Frnic h sp riiae a apryitee litfs n nevnrSn acso a at p td s at n hs c poedn si tedsrc cuti teNit Cici adi ticutAl o g rceig n h itit o r,n h nh rut n n hs o r. t u h , h panis n SnFacsohv fldsp rt bif i ticuttelgl lit fad a rnic ae i eae resn hs o r h e a f e , ag metrie b teeprislreyo elpa dfrcn ein ewesal ru ns asd y h s at agl vra n o ovnec h l e rfrt teag metpeetdb ete o teep risa panif' ru ns ee o h ru ns rsne y i r fh s at s litfsag met. h e Ataltrsaeo tedsrc cut rceig,h Co nyo l eilte ae tg fh itit o rpoedn ste u t fmp ra,h l eil u t Bor o S priosa dtel eil u t DeuyCo ny mp ra Co ny ad f u evsr,n h mpraCony p t u t Clreeodrmo e t itre eiteato t dfn tev l i o ek cre vd o nevn n h cin o eed h ai t f dy Po oio 8 Th dsrccut i n tueo tel eil u t moint rp st n . e itit ordd o rl n h mpraCo ny to o i itreeu t a rtetil scmpee adtecut a hn e d wni nevn ni he h ra wa o ltd n h o rhd add o t l s rl go temei .Atht on,h dsrc cut eidteitret n ui n h rt tap itte itit ordne h nevni n s o moin ThratrI eil u t,tb ado sp riosadi dp t to . eefe,mp raCony i or fu evsr n t euy s s cu t cekrcre ap ae tedna o termoint itreet teNit ony lr/eodr p eld h eil fh i to o nevn o h nh Cic i OntesmedyteNit Cicifldi odrsb tigteq et n rut h a a h nh ruti t re u mi n h u si . e s t o o Po o et'tn igt ticutteNit Cic iise a o iinafmig f rp nns sadn o hs or,h nh rutsu d n pno fi n r tedsrccut dnao itreto b I eil u t,tb ado h itit o r' eil fnevnin y mpraCo ny i or f s s sp riosadisdp t cu t cekrcre.l afr n ted na o u evsr n t euy ony lr/eodr n fimig h eil f itreto ,h Nit Cicio iinrl di p ro tefcta itreto nevnin te nh rut pno ei n atn h athtnevnin e hdb e su h b tedpuycu t cekrcre rte ta tecu t a en o gt y h e t o ny lr/eodrahrh n h o ny cekrcre hrefteo iinlfo nteq eto whte ac ut lr/eodr esl;h pno etpe h usin ehr o ny cekrcre wo l hv sadn t itre e OnFeray2 , 01,h nwl lr/eodr ud ae tn ig o nevn . bur 52 1te e y eetdCo nyClrmeodro I ra Comt fldamoiniteNit lce u t ek cre fmpeil t y ie to n h nh Cicise igt itreei teato Tht t nicretyp n igi te rut ekn o nevn n h cin. amoi s urnl e dn n h o Nit Cici. nh rut

1 0

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 12 of 74

u drhisprio o cnrlfo apyn o efrigPooio 8 (0 neteruevs n r ot ,rm p lig r nocn rp sin .74 i o t F.upz ap 10. T e nhCrutusqet ise a odrtyn te sp .d t .03) h Nit i isbeunl sud n resaigh c y dsitor'jdmet edn apa,n a arslPooio 8rman i itccut u g npnig p elad s eut rp sin e isn r s t
efc atepeeti . fet th rsn tme Po o et,sitreesi tedsrc cutfldi teNit Cicia rp nnsa nevnr n h itit o r,i n h nh rut e

t lapao tedsitorjdmetnaiaigPooio 86Noeo i y p elfh itccutug nivl t rpstn . n f me r dn i te a ddfn atawhmtedsrtor'iucinwa drce h nme eednst o h itccut n nt s i td i sj o e apae f mtedsr torjdmethwee,n ,na er odr peldr h i i cutu g n,o vradi n al re o tc y
etbihn ash d l frcnieigteapa,h Nit Ciciseiial sal ig c eue o o sdrn h p elte nh rutp cfcl s y rq etdteprist bifh q eto whte Po o eth v sa dn t euse h at o re te usin ehr rp n ns a e tn ig o e ap atedsrccutsnl gi p elh itit o r' Ii . n
6 Iial,1f eo teidvd apo o eto Po oio 8mo e t nt l ali fh n iiu l rp nns f rp st n v d o iy v i itreei tePer liain l tecus o tedsrccutigto ,n nevn n h ry igto . n h ore fh itit o rliain o e t t

o teidvdapooet- Ha-hn WiimT m(a - moe t fh niiulrpnns ksig la a Tm) vdo l

wi da a adfn atnevn r Th dsrccuti n tueo Ta s t rw s eedn itree. e itit ordd o rl n m' h moint wi da u tlfe iise isdcso o temei,n atapon t o t rw niatrtsud t eiin n h rt ad tht it o h s tedsrc cut eidtemoint wihrw a mo t h itit o rdne h to o tda s o. Ta ddntoniteapafo tedsitorjdmetht s m i oji n h p elrm h itccutu g ntawa r flditeNit Cicib teohrfu idvd apo o etad i n h nh rut y h te o rn iiul rp nns n e Poet rig .o Fo cn ein efr rrfrne t t rp n ns'ee rtcMaraecm. r o vnec,ut eeecso o o et'rfr he p cl cieyt tefu idvd apo o etadPoet rig.o wh tld ol t l o h o rn iiu l rp nns n rtcMaraecm o ie ev teapa i teNit Cic iadhv priiae i tepeet rce igi h p eln h nh rut n ae at ptd n h rsn poedn n c ticut hs or. 7 Un e fdrla ap rywh h sb e p r t dt itreei alwe dr eea lw, at o a en emit o nevn n o r e

cutrceigietldt apaaug n iteasneote ato orpoedn snie o p el jdmetnh bec fh pr n t y

wh s sd itreto wa pr te o l u o aso n tateitree oe ie nevnin s emitd ny p n h wig hth nevn r idp n et flist cs o c nrves rq ie nso at l1Io te n eednl ufl he ae r o to ry eurmet f ri e 1 fh y l c

fdrl ntmin (e,..DimodvC als 18) 7 U..46. eeaCosi o. Seeg, a n . hr (96 46 S 5,8) t e Un e Caio alw,ycnrs, p rywh h sbe p r t dt itreei a dr l mi a b otata at o a en emit o nevn n f e lwecutrceigtdfn a atnma apafo a avreug n o rorpoedn o eed n ci y pelrm n desjdmet o dsi tefir o teoiiadfnatofea apa.(e,.. o ev ept h al e fh rgnl eednt i n pel Seeg, pl . e u l Pe PersriainDirc(9 1 12Ca.8,9-9 . riIrg t s it10) 3 l29202 1 o t )
1 1

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 13 of 74

l tebif fldi teNit Ci ut nta isepanif ag e ta n h res i n h nh r io htsu, litfs ru d ht e c Po o et lce sa dn t ap aadta,sacneu n eteap ai rp nnsak d tn ig o p eln h ta osq e c,h p eln Per so l b ds se.Po o etvgrul cnetdpanif' ry h ud e imisd rp nns ioo sy otse litfs cneto , onigo ththyh dbe pr t dt itreeadpriiae o tnin p it u tate a en emit o nevn n at pt n e c a pat si dfneo Pooio 8b t b ticutnSr usspr,6 s ri n ees f rp st n oh y hs o ri ta s,u a 4 e i Ca.t 3 4 a db tedsrccutnPer a dasrigta te p sesd 1 h 6 ,n y h itit o ri ry,n set h th y osse 4 n terq iiesa dn u drb t Caionaadfdrla 8 h eust tn ig n e oh l ri n eealw. f

Afr odcigoaagmettehe- de aeo te nhCrut t cnut rlru n,h trej g pnl fh Nit i i e n u c
asg e t tics ise a odro Jn ay4 2 1rq et gticuto sind o hs ae su d n re n aur , 01,eu si hs o rt n a s rh q eto o Caiona1w stot a o enmey whehe,n e nwe te u sin f l ri a efrh b v ; a l, t ru dr f Caionalw,h ofcapo o et o a i t t emesr tah sb e l ri a te fiil rp nns f n niai aueht a en f iv apo e b tev tr p ses i e $ p riuaie itrsi teiiitv ' p rv d y h oes osset r at lrzd neetn h ntaies h a c v l i 'o h atoi t asrteSaesitrsi teiiaiesvldt' ai t ' r e uh rt o seth tt' neetn h nt t ' aii ' dy t y iv y s a t afr tepo nnssa dn t dfn tecnttto ai o te o so fod h rpo et tn ig o eed h o si in ly fh u t

iiaieo t apaaug n ivlaigteiiaie e tepbi ntt ro p el jdmetnai t h ntt whn h ul iv dn iv c

oscas oodn rl wo l po iesc ad fneo fl sc a apa f ilwh riai ud rvd u h ees rie uh n p el y

dciet d s.( ryI spa68F3 ap 19. l i odrteNit el o o o Per L ur,2 .d t . 13) nt re,h nh n s
8 I adt nt dsgeiga t whte Po o ethv sadn t n d ii o ia ren so ehr rp nns ae tn ig o o ap a,nter resadoa ag met eoeteNit Cic ipanif ad p eli hibif n rl ru n bfr h nh rut litfs n Po o etdsgedo tecneune ta wo l fo fo adtr nto rp nns iare n h o sq ecsht ud lw rm eemiain b teNit CicitaPrp nnslc sa dn t ap a adteds sa o y h nh rutht o o et ak tn ig o p eln h imisl f terp el Plitfscne ddta ads sa o teap a wo l laete h iap a. anif o tn e ht imisl fh p el ud ev h o tenme saeofcr ado tet nme c ut cek .Po o et n h a d tt fies n n h wo a d o ny lrs rp nns cned d b cnrs,h tfh Nit Cicidtr n ste lc sadn t o tn e ,y o tatta ite nh rut eemie hy ak tn ig o ap a,ht o rwo l b rq ie n t nyt ds s teap ab tas t p eltac ut ud e eurd o o l o imish p el u lo o

dsitorjdmetnefcadtate itccutuigwolb bnig ir cutug n i fetn hth dsitorrl ud e idn tc r n

vcttedsitorjdmet (e P r I spa6 8F3 ap 19 & aaeh itccutug n. Se el L ur,2 .d t . 15 r y f. .Beas isb tdteqetno Pooet'tnigudrtt1w n2) cuetu mie h uso f rpnnssadn n es ea t i a t ticutteNit Ciciddn tn iaeis iw a t teefc o te o hj o r,h nh rut i o idct tve so h fet n h dsitorjdmetf dtr ntntaPooetlc sadn tapa. itccutug no a eemiai ht rpnnsak tnigo pel r o
1 2

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 14 of 74

Ciciidctdtatea s rotiq eto o Caio alw ma wel e rutn iae hth nwet hs u sin f l mi a y lb f

dtr nt eo teiseo sn igfrfdrla proe.(dap 19. eemiai fh su ft dn o eeal up ss 1.t .16) v a w

l epann i rao frsb tigtiq et nt ticutteNit n x liig t esn o u mit hs u si o hs o r,h nh s n o Cicisae i pr: tog teGo n rhscoe ntodfn rutttd n at h uh h v ro a h sn o t eed Al Po oio 8iteepoedn siin t la whte h ma cnitn wi rp st n n h s rceig,ts o cer eh r e y,o sset t i h teCaionaCo si to ,civ tru harfsloliaewh t ema n t h l ri ntuin aheeho g euat igt a h y o f t t d drcl:efcieyvt teiiaieb rfsn t dfn io apa a o iet fet l eo h nt t y euig o ee d t r p el y v iv

jdmetn aiaigi in oees icu igteiiaies rpnns ug nivl t t f o n le nldn h ntt 'pooetdn , iv
iq aiidt d s.Prp nnsag eta sc ahrhrsliaoddite s u l e o o o o o et ru htuh as euts v ie fh f b lneo p we po ie i teCaionaCo si inetbihsta aac f o r rvd dn h l ri nt o sa l e ht f mt s po o eto a iiaieaeatoie t d fn ta iiaiea aet o te rp nns f n nt t r uh rzd o eed htnt t ,s gns fh iv iv

P ol,nluo pbiofilwh rfs tb s.Smir ,n eC lona epei i f ul fias o eueo o o i l l udr ai ri e c c ay f

lw,h po o eto a iiaiema poss apriuaie itrsi a te rp nns f n nt t y ses at lrzd neetn iv c dfn igtecntuinlyo teriiit u o i e at n;h ee dn h o si to ai fh i nt i p n t ncmette t t ave s Co si insp roeirsrigteiiaiepo roteP o lwo l nt o ' up s n eevn h nt t we t h epe ud mt iv apa t b i-evdb alwigeetdofcast n li ete po o et' p ero e lsre y l n lce fiil o uly i r rp nns l o f h efrst rp s saue ada n mett teCo si t n o teP o l' fot o po oe ttts n me d nso h ntui ' rh epes to

rgtt aotreetsc pooio s Ca. nt at1, 8a. teta ih dp o rjc'uh rpsin. lCos,r.Ij () Rahrhn o t .
rl o oro u drtn igo tiblneo p we u drteCaio a ey n u wn n esadn fhs aa c f o r n e h l mi f

Cost o,o vrwe etyteqet ns tate( lonaSpe q ntminhwee, crf h uso ohth Cai ri urme i i i f
Co rma po iea atoit ea s ra t terg t,neet,n atoi ut y rvd n uh rt i nwe so h ihsitrssad uh rt av y u drCaionalw o teofcapo o eto a iiaiemesr t dfn n e l ri a fh fiil rp n ns f n nt t aueo eed f iv is aii u o i eat n i tecs o acaln et i cntuin ly, tv l t p n t n cmetn h ae f h l g ot o si t ai dy s e s to t

whr tesaeof ilcagdwi tadtrfs t eeuei'(el I eeh tt fcashre t htuy eueo xct t'P ry L i h . . spa6 8F3 ap 19. ur,2 .d t . 17)
OnF bur 1, 0 1weare t dcd teq eto o Caionalw eray 62 1, ged o eieh u sin f l ri a f a rqetdb teNit Cicia detbih da ep dtdbifn shd l s euse y h h rut n sa l e n x eie reig ce ue s
1 3

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 15 of 74

ta wo l p r thscutocn ut rlru n i timatra erya ht ud emiti o rt o d coa ag metn hs te s al s Spe e 2 1 A1prisa dn meo sa ccra tmeyfldbif i ti etmbr 01. 1 at n u ru mii uie i l ie resn hs e matra doa ag met sh l o Spe e 6 2 1. te,n rlru n wa ed n etmbr ,0 1 I.Reea c o SaeLa t Sa dn Un rFe ea La I lv n e f tt w o tn ig de d rl w Deiin o teUntdSae S pe Co retbihtate cso s fh i tts u rme utsal hth e s dtr nto whte a idvd a o ett seigt p riiaea ap r i a eemiain ehr n n iiu l r ni ekn o at pt s at n y c y

fdrlorpoedn ot apaf ma avreu g n etrdi sc a eeacutrceig ro p elr n desjdmetnee n uh o

poedn p sessterq iiesadn t st f teaeo cnrvry' rceig osse h eust tn ig o ai y h s r oto s' s c po iin o atl Ilo teUntdSae Co si t niutmaeyaq et n rvso s f ri e l fh i tts ntt i s li tl u si c e uo o

ofdrla uo whc tefdrlor hv tef asy (e,..P is feealw p n ihh eeacut aeh i la. Seeg, hl s n l Perlu C ..h t (954 2U..9,0.As cneunemay t em ovSut 18) 7 S77 84) a osqec, n o s
ra eso tio iinma rao a l b u cranwh teNit Cicihs edr fhs pno y esn by e neti y h nh rut a akdticutoavs iwhte iiitv poo etp sesatoi u dr se hs ort d ie t ehrnt ie rp nns oss uh rt n e a y

C lonalwtdfn tevli oa iiaie aueiacutrceig afri a o eedh ait fnntt mesr n orpoedn dy iv
i whc temesr icaln r ad is,h bsso sc atoi I l h n ih h aue s h l g d n ,fo te ai fu h uh rt n i t e y. g o tip tnil o fso , bleeta iiueu adapo raebif t fhs oetacnuin we eiv htts sfl n p rpit rel o y stot,th ote, u u drtn igo tefdrl eiin ta dsuste efrh ate ustor n esadn fh ea dcso sh t ics h rlta sae1wpasi dtr nn whte,n e fdrla a idvd a oehttt a ly n eemiig eh ru dre ealw,n n iiu l o ett p sesssa dn t pat iaea apryi afdrl rce ig We r ni osse tn ig o ri pt s at n e eapo edn . y c e h sz tao rdsuso o fdrl eiin intitn e t,n d e n t mp aie ht u ic sin feea dcso ss o ned d o ad os o p roto dcd ayiseo fdrla adwefl rc g ietateefc up rt, eie n su f eea lw,n ul eo nz hth fet y tatio iinscaict no teatoi ofcapo o etp ses n e hths pno ' lrf ai fh uhrt fiil rp nns oss u dr i o y Caionalw ma h v o teqeto o sadn u drfdrla iamatr lfri a y a e n h usin f tn ig n e eea 1w s t e tautmaeywi b dcddb tefdrl ors ht l tl l e eie y h eea cut. i l Asteq eto p sdb teNit Ci utn iae,ntepeetcs h u sin oe y h nh r iidctsi h rsn ae c

t ptnilae frtnigaei lae:() h of ilrpnns f wo oet bss o s dn r mpi td 1T e fcapooeto a a a c i

scesu iiaiemesr ma hv atoi t ap a i cutoasrte ucsflnt t aue y ae uh rt o p ern o rt seth iv y

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 16 of 74

qaesneetndfnigte aii o ad leatdsae1w,o()h tt'it si eedn h vl t f uy nce tt a 9 r2te r dy of ilrpnns yhk ter wnproa .atuai d'itrsite fcapooetma aehio esnlp r lrz ' eetn h i c e n
iiitv 'vl i .Webit dsust fdrl eiin ta aayete ntaies ai t dy rel ics he eea dcso sht n lz h y efc o saelw o ec o teep tnil ae frsadn i fdrl o r. fet ftt a n ah fh s oet b sso tn ig n eeacut a A. tn igt AsetteSaesltrsi a l iitv 'Vaiiy Sa dn o sr h tt' neetn n ntaies l t d Wi rsetoteqet no wh p sesssadn t asrtesaes t epc t h usi f o osse tn ig o seth tt' h o itrsi dfn igtevl i o asaecntuinl rvso o sa ewh n neetn eedn h ai t f tt o si to apo iin r tmt e dy t tesaemesr ic aln e i afdrl rceig webleeteUntd h tt aues h l gd n eeapoedn , eiv h i e e

Sae Spe C ut dcs iKace vMa (97 44U..2( rhr tts urme or' ei nn rhr . y 18) 8 S7 Kace) s i
srn l idctsta afdrl orwi lo t saelwt dtr n wh m te to gy n iae h t e ea cut l o k o tt a o eemie o h l saeh satoie t asrtesaesitrs itev l i o tec aln e tt a uh rzd o seth tt' neetn h ai t fh hl g d dy e
ne s e. n aur

I Kace, lwsiwa fldi fdrl itit o rcnedn ta a n rh raa ut sie n eea dsrccuto tn ig h t rcnl eatdNe Jre sauetarq ie pi r adscn ayp bi eety n ce w esy ttt hteurd rmay n eo dr u l c sh osi tasaet o sreamiueo sln eatesat f ahsh o dy co l n httt o bev nt f i c th tro ec co l a e wa u cntuin l savoaino teetbih n ca s o teFrt s n o si t a a ilto fh sa l met lue fh is to s Amed n o tefdrl nttt n Whnib cmeapaetth o te o n met fh eeaCo siui . e t ea p rn ate ust f o teliaintan i etecret w Jre AtonyGeean rayo te h igto ht et rh urn Ne esy tre nrl o n fh t h n me g vrmetdfn at- teNe Jre Deat n o Edct n te a d o en n ee dns h w esy p rmet f uai ,h o dp rmetscmmiso e,n t lcl orso euain- wo l d fn eat n' o sin rad wo o ab ad f d ct o ud eed tev l i o tecaln e sauetete S ekro teNe Jre Geea h ai t fh h l gd ttt,h hn pae fh w esy nrl dy e

Ase l ( rhradtete Peietfh Ne Jre Snt( eho smby Kace) n h hn rs n o te w esy eaeOrci) d

9 Deios fh U idSa s urmeCutlalet lhta Sa cin ote nt teSge orcer sbi ht tt s e t y as a e

hstn igtdfn tecntuinlyo i saue'( a n vC als a sadn o eedh ostt al ft ttt. Dimod . hre, io t s ' spa46U..46;e as Man vTyo (96 4 7U..3,3-3 (a ur,7 S5,2 se lo ie . alr 18) 7 S 111617 Saecer hsaeimaeitrsitecniudefreblyo i o tt lal a ljt t neetnh ot e nocait ft wn y i n i s saue'. tttsl ')

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 17 of 74

su h adweegatdtergtoitreea dfn att dfn te o gt n r rne h ih t nevn s eednso eed h c aln e sa o bh lo tesaelgsa e l tepoedn si dsrc h l gd tt n eaf fh tt eilmr. n h rceig n itit e me cuqtelgsauetru hi peiigof escridteeteb re o o r h e iltr,ho g t rsdn fi r, are h ni udn f s c r dfn igtesa e T edsrccut lmaeycn lddtatesamewa eedn h tmt. h itit o rut tl o cu e hth tt s i

u cntuinln etrdug n ivl aigtesa e nosi t aad neejdmetnai t h tmt. to dn

Kace adOrci, cigi terot a cp cte a S ek ro te rh r n eho at n h i fkilaai s s p ae fh n i Ne Jre Ge eaAse l adPrsdn o teNe Jre S nt,p eld w esy nrl smby n eiet fh w esy eaeap ae

tedsitorjdmetoteCoro Ap elfrh T i CiutT e h irccutug nt h utf paso te hr r i h t d c.

T idCi ut er teap a o temei adut tl afme tedsrc hr r ih ad h p el n h rt n lmaey fi d h itit c s i r cuteiiniv l aigtesaue ordcso n ai t h ttt. dn AfeteThr Cicihn e d wni dcso , rh radOrci ls trh i rut add o t eiinKace n eho ot d s terp ssa peiiglgsaieofcr adweerplcdb ohrlgsaos h i ot s rsdn e ilt fies n r e ae y te eiltr v i toelgsaiep ss Dept ti cag i sau, rhradOrci fld n h s eilt ot. si hs h n en ttsKace n eho ie v e a apa o teThr Cicid cso i teUntdSae Spe Co r.Th n p el fh i rut eiin n h i tts u rme ut e d e nw saelgsaiepeiigof eswh h drpae Kace a dOrci e tt eilt rsdn fi r o a elcd rh r n eho v c n tfe teUntdSae S pe Cq rtate weewi da n te oiid h i tts u rme uththy r t rwig h e h lgsauesap a, u atesmet ifr dtecutht rhrwatd e iltr' p elbt th a i nome h ortaKace ne me t cniu hsap ao teThr Cic idcso i teSpe Co r.Kac e o ot e i p el fh id rut eiin n h u rme ut rhr n cnime tap st n o fr d h t oio . i Th UntdSae S pe Co rp sp ndcnieaino te e i tts u rme ut oto e o sdrto fh e

jrdcinlsu pnigi haigo tecs,n,f rrlru n,h ui it aise edn t er fh aeadat oaagmette s o s n e
hg cutsu di dcso ,o cu igtabcueKace adOrci wee ih orise t eiin cnldn ht eas rhr n eho r s n ln e telgsaielaeso terset eh ue o teNe Jre o o grh e iltv edr fh epci o ss fh w esy v Leiltr,hylce sadn t ap a.Th cutx and rhrad gsauet ak d tn ig o p el e oreplie : ce n Ka Orci itre e i tilwsii terofca cp ct sapeiigofcr eho nevnd n hsa utn h i fiil aaie s rsdn fies i

o bhlote wJre L gsa e T e d ntp elh jdmetn n eaf fh Ne esy ei mr. hy o oapateu g ni l
toecp cte.Id e,hycudn tfrte n ln e h l toeofcs h s aai s n ed te o l o,o h y o o gr od h s fie. i

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 18 of 74

T eatoiyt p ru telwsio b hlo telgsa eb ln st toe h uh rt o use h a ut n e af fh eilmr eo g o h s

wh sceddKaceadOrcii ofe'( rhrspa 44U..t o ucee rhr n ehon fc. Kace,ur,8 S a i ' p 7. .7)
Kace adOrc i frhrag e ta i,stehg cuto cu e, rh r n eho ute ru dhtfa h ih o rcn ld d

terpel sob ds se fr n ojrsit ntecuthudas hiapawa t e i sd o wat fuidci ,h orsol lo mi o vctteu g nsotedsitoradteT i Ci utht a ivlae aaeh jdmet fh itccutn h hr r itahd nai td r d c d tes ttaiu.I rjcigticam,h Spe Corrldepiiyo h tue ts e n eet hs li te urme utei xl t n a s n e cl
tefcta Ne Jre 1wp r t dtecret rsdn lgsaieofcr, h atht w esy a emie h urn peiig eiltv fies t at go b hlo tesaelgsauet rpeeth saesitrs i ci n e af fh tt eiltr,o ersn te tt' neetn n dfn igacaln e saelw.Th cut bevd ll eNe Jre S pe ee dn h l g d tt a e o ro sre :- w esy u rme e -h Co rh sgatdapiain o teS ekro teGeeaAse l adte ut a rne p l t s fh p ae fh nrl smby n h co Peiet fh Snt t itreea prisrso dn o bh lo te rsdn o te eae o nevn s at -ep n et n e af fh e lgsauei dfneo algsaieeat n.I r Fos h , N..41 14 eiltr n ees f e ilt ncmet n e ryte91 J 1 , 4 , v

40A.d49 50(92.Snete wJre Lgsauehdatoi udr 5 2 9,0 18) ic h Ne esy eiltr a uhrt ne y
saelwt rprsn teSaesitrssi bt teDitit ut n teCo r tt a o e eeth tt' neet n 0h h src Cora d h ut

o p aswcne ntaaeteug nsblwfrlc o rp r fApel ed ovct hjdmet eo o akfapoe , dfnatp l n '( rhrspa44U..t .2ilsaddlo eedn- pel t Kace,ur,8 Sap 8,t i d e. a a ac l
Jre S pe Co rtawa ctda drle u o i Kace frh esy u rme utht s i n eid p n n rhr o te e po oio tau dr w Jre lw telgsa etru hteS ek r fh rp st n h t n e Ne esy a h eilmr,ho g h p ae o te i GeeaAse l a dtePeiet fh Snt, a atoi t rpeeth nrl smby n h rsdn o te e aehd uh ry o ersn te t

1 II r F ryh ( J18) 5 A.d4 9- tedcs no teNe 0 n n e osteN. 92 4 0 2 9 h eii fh w . o

st'ieetidfnnn tcaejdstfteStero tesySrrme tut ny rel eed dae atcpaiaea - ekNe Jr nul a se rs n x liig hlne o 1 h w ee pe e t sy l t w Co rvr bif epa e h p ril t no h p ae fh Geea

Ase l adtePeieto teS nt i ta liain,tt g:f eiia smby n h rsdn fh eaen htigt sai ' nt l t o n -h i av raypatsi tecs weeteptinr adteAton yGe ea.I d esr ri n h ae r h eio es n h tre nrl n e t a dt n teCorgatdteapiain o teS ekr fh Ge ea d io ,h ut rne h p l t s fh pa e o te n rl i co Ase l a dteGe eaAse l,n tePeiet fh Sn t adte smby n h nrl smby ad h rsdn o te eae n h S nt t itreea p risrso dn,lo wh m, t teAt re Geea, e ae o nevn s at -ep n etal f o wi h t n y nrl e h o

dfn tevli o teeat n. (5 A.dap 50) eedh ait fh ncmet' 40 2 t .0 . dy '

(ontcni eOFxpg) t toeotud nlfae b n d
1 7

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 19 of 74

Astefrg ige hszdp saedmo srtsi Kace te h oeon mp aie asg e ntae,n rhrh S pe Co rlo e t saelw t dtr n whte apop cieliat a u rme uto kd o tt a o eemie eh r rsetv ign h d t atoi t asrtesaesitrsi dfn igacaln e saemesr i uh rt o seth tt' neetn ee dn h l gd tt aue n y e fdrlo r.Up nrfeto tirslin tupiig iamuha lgc eeacut o elcin hs euts o srrsn ,n s c soi sg ettaasaeso l hv tep we t dtr n wh iatoie t u gssht tt h ud aeh o ro eemie o s uh rzd o asrtesae'o itrs i dfn igac aln e saelw. seth tt s wn neetn eedn hlegd tt a As litfacrtl p it u, rh rspr, 8 U..2 ddn t pani s cuaey on otKace,u a 4 4 S 7 , i o f iv leac aln et a iiaiemesr a dddn t d rs teq eto n ov hleg o n nt t aue n i o a desh u sin iv whte teofcapo o eto a iiaiecudpo el asrtesaes ehrh fiil rp n ns f n nt t o l rp ry seth tt' iv itrsi d fn igtev l i o sc a iiit e Plitfsas n t ta i neetn eedn h ai t fu h n nt i . anif lo oehtn dy av

i sbeun dcso iAroaso 04* g vAr oa(97 50U..3 t usqeteiin n i nnfr . En.. i n 19) 2 S4 s z / z ( i nnfrO il nlh, ihddiv leteqet no otil Ar oaso scaE gi )whc i nov h usi f f a z s o k iiaie rpnnssadn u dreea1wtapaaug n ivl aig ntt pooet'tnig nefdrla o pel jdmetnai t iv dn
a iiit emesr,h UntdSae Spe Co repesdtrv d u t' n nt i auete i tts u rme utx rse t a e obs' av e g

( .t .6whteteiiaiepooeti tacs p sesdterqii i ap6) e rh ntt rpnnsnhtae osse h eust d h iv e

sa dn addsig ih di erir eiini Kace.A coerve o te tn ig n it use t al dcso n rh r ls eiw fh n s e

rlvnp ro oteoiiniAr oaso O il gi ,o vr eeatotn fh pno n i nnfr ycaEnlhhwee, i z s

idctsta ted u tepesdb tehg cutnta cs aprnl aoe n iae h th o bs x rse y h ih o ri ht ae p aet rs y o t fh cut u cranycnenn teatoi o ofca iiaie u o te o r' n etit o crig h uh rt f fiilnt t s y iv po o ett dfn tevl i o acaln e iiaieu drArzn lw.' rp nnso eed h ai t f h l g d nt t n e io a a dy e iv Th rlvn p saed e n tu gsta iasaeslw d e atoiete e eeat asg os o sg ethtf tt' a os uh rz h

(ooeotud mp=iupg) f t tcni e#o r osae on n Th siFostetep riswh teUntdSae S pe Cori u,n ryh,h at o h ie tts u rme utn e Kace sbeunl cnlddh datoi u drsae1wt rpeeth rhr u sq ety o cu e a uh rt n e tt q o ersn te y saesitrsi dfn igacaln e sateweepr te t itreei a tt' neetn eedn hlegd ttt r emitd o nevn n z Ne Jre S pe Co rcs t dfn tev ldt o ac aln e saue w esy u rme utaeo ee d h aii f hlegd ttt y aogieteNe Jre AtonyGeeawh wa as d fn igtesaue ln sd h w esy tre nrl o s lo eedn h ttt.

1 8

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 20 of 74

otcapo o et o a iiaiet asrtesaesitrsi teiiaie f il rp n ns f n nt t o seth tt' neetn h nt tv i iv i mesr'vldt whnp bi ofcash v d cie t dfn temesr,h aues aii e u lc fiil a e el d o eed h auete y n po o etwo l lc sadn t asrta itrsi afdrl rceig. rp nns ud ak tn ig o sethtneetn eeapoedn

ladesn tesadn iseiAroaso O il gi ,u a n drsigh tnigsu n i nnfr scaEnlhspr, z s

50U.. 3tehg cutttdi rlvn pr: eio esag epi rl 2 S 4 ,h ih o rsae n eeat at tinr ru rmai p t y ta,siiaiepo o et,h yh v aq ailgsaieitrsi dfn igte hta nt t rp nnste ae us-eilt neetn ee dn h iv v

cntuinlyo temesrte scesulsosrd (h iiaie osit ai fh auehy ucsfl pnoe.T entt to t y iv pooet)tesh fnsn efrte epne t aheeaot no ( e rpnnss ste ud ad fothy x edd o civ dpi ft r o h iiaie.We aercgie tasaelgs trhv s nigt cnet ntt ) hv eonzdhttt eilos aet dn o otsa iv a a
dcso h ligasaesameu c ntuin lfsaelw atoie lgsaos eiin odn tt tt no si to ai tt a uh rzseiltr t

trpeeth Saesneet.Se rhr . y 44U..2 8 (97. o ersnte tt'itrs e Kace vMa,8 S7,2 18) s (h iiaie rp nns,o vraentlce rpeett e,n wcae T entt pooet)hwee,r oeetdersnai sa d r iv v a ro oAi n lwap itgiiaiep nosa aeto hpolo waefn roaa poni ntt sosr s gnsfte epef z n iv Arzn t t-t iluf ul o/ ff te osttnlyo ntte io a o f/n n i op bi f3t- h cntui al fiiai s c f e c cz, i o ' iv t mae1wo h Sae NohshsC utvrdnie iiaiepooeta d a fte tt r a ti oree ietsdntt rpnns s . iv
Aril-l-u lfe dfn eso temesrste av ctd CfDo ' t ellq ai d eedr fh aue h y d oae . . nt c i

B nrp WahntnC mmie vC nietl1Na. n & Tut .f akut sigo o te . ot na11 tBak rsCoo t n . C iao40U..07(93 (u rlds sigfrako sadn apa hcg ,6 S 17 18)smmai i sn o lc ftnig p el y mi b a iiaiepooetrm a eio hligteiiaieu cntuinl. y nntt rpnnfo dcs n odn h ntt nosit al' iv i iv to ' (2 U..t .5ils de,n o t d) 50 Sap 6,ti addf.mie. ac t
Al o g frh frg igrao stecut xrse frv d u t' t u h o te oeon esn h orepesd < ae o bs' h g wh te teiiaieprp nnsi q eto h dsa dn u drat lIlo eh rh nt t o o et n usin a tn ig n e ri e 1t iv c

pru apltrve ( innfrO ilnlhspa50U..t .6, usepeleeiw Aroaso scaEgi ,ur,2 Sap6) a z s
t cut n o cn ld ta t n e ntdfntlrsleteise' fhe he o rwet n o cu e hts ed o eii y eov h su 'o t we e

iiaie rpnnssadn ( i bcueicnlddta,nayeeta ntt pooet'tnig id) eas tocue hti n vn, iv b
cag i tesau p tepanifnta cs rn ee teliainmota d hn en h tts fh litfi ht ae ed rd h igto o n t
1 9

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 21 of 74

jsi dvct gtelwefdrlorrl g tahdivl ae teiiaie ut e aai h o reeacutui sht a n ai tdh ntt i n n d iv mesr.(e i.tp6-0) aue Sedap .78. Ash e hse pro ote asg fo Aroaso O il te mpai d otn fh psaerm lnnfr sca z i k
En lhq oe ao eidctstehg cutsdu t a t teofcaiiitv gi u td b v n iae,h ih o r' o bs so h fiilntaie s po o et'tn igi tacs weeb sd alati sbtnil ato te rp nns sadn n ht ae r ae,tes n u satapr, n h fctatecut sn t waeo ay io alw ap itn iiaie athth o rwa o a r f n t zn a p onig nt t Ar iv so sr a a et o tep o l o Arzn t dfn . .h cntuinlyo p nos s gns fh epe f io a o ee d .te o si t ai f to t

iiaiemae1woteSae'(roaso O ilnlhspa50 ntt s d a fh tt. Ai nnfr scaEgi ,ur,2 iv ' z s U..t .5)I or iw,ohn itadcso idctshtf s t'1w Sap 6 . n u ve ntig nht ei n niae taiat esa i a
d e atoieteof il rp n nso a iiitv t asrtesaesitrs os uhrz h fi apo o et f n ntaie o seth tt' neet c i tev l i o acaln e saeiiit ewhntep bi otcaswh n h ai t f h l g d tt nt i e h u l fiil o dy e av c odnryasrta itrshv d cie t d s,h po o etwo l n t riai sethtneet ae el d o o o te rp n ns ud o l n h v sadn t asrt saesitrsi teiiaiesv l i i afdrl ae tn ig o sethe tt' neetn h nt t ' ai t n eea iv dy lwsii whc saeofcashv d cie t po iesc adfnel a utn ih tt fiil ae el d o rvd u h ees.l n

1 We oetaul eiKace,ur,8 U..2iAr o aso 1 nt htni n rhrspa44 S 7,n l nnfr k k Ofc / nlhte oen nofilnme a dfn atiteeea k s ia s d .# ; E gi h gvrmet fc s a d s eedn n h f rl lwsiddd fn tecnttt nl aii o tecaln e saepo iini a ut i eed h o si i a vldt fh h l g d tt rvso n uo y e tedsitorjoedns(roaso O#; Egihspa50U..t h itccutrceig.Ainnfr fcz nl ,ur,2 Sa r z ' s # p.15.An,giuleiKace,nAroaso O#f/nlhte p5-3) daan ni n rhri i nnfr .cJEgi h k z f s ofca iiaiepo o et ddn tse t itreei teliainu t atr fiilnt t rp nns i o ek o nevn n h igt ni fe iv t o l tedsitorarayhdise i jdmettkn dwntentt e h itccutl d a sudt ug n sr ig o h iiai r e s i iv mesro cntuinlru d.(2 U..t .6) aue n osit agons 50 Sap 5 . to Ash psaefo A i nnfr ycaEnlhqoe aoe(nea te asg rm rz aso O il gi utd bv at,t o s p 1)niae,h hg cutntacsas ctdDo 'B nrp Wahntn .9 idctste ih ori ht ae lo i nt akut sigo e C mmie vC nietl1Na. ak&Tut o o i g ,ur,6 U.. o te . ot na11 tB n rsC .fchc ospa4 0 S t n . a 17 , smmayodrtads se a ap a fo aNit Cicidcso fr 0 7 a u r re ht imisd n p elrm nh rut eiin o lc osadn. iAroaso O ilagaeiDo 'B nrpt ak ftnig Asn i nnfr scaL nug,n ntaku z Wahn tnCo tetenme gv rmet eednsd fn e te sigo mmie h a d o en n dfn at eed d h t cal gdiiaieo bhlo tesaeitelwe cut(e C nietl1 hln e ntt n eaf fh tt nh o r or se o t na1. e iv s n 1 Na.akecvSaefWah(tCi 18)9 F2 626772,n tee tB n,t..tto s.9h r 9366 .d 9,9-0)adhr . in idct ntateofca iiai po o et i ta matretbih d s o n iai hth fiilnt t rp n nsn ht t sal e o i ve e s ta,neteapialst1 (eete1 oteSaeoWahntn,n htudrh pl betea t r,h a fh tt f sigo)a c a wh w
(ontcniudn etae f toeot eonxpg) o n
2 0

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 22 of 74

Wen t i tirgr ta i i odrsb tigtepeet usint oen hs ead htn t re u mit h rsn q eto o s n ticuqteNit Cicisae epiiyta,ni ve iteofca hs o r h nh rutttd x l t hti t iw,fh fiil cl s poo eto a iiaieh v atoi u d r lo a1w t asrtesaes rp n ns f n nt t ae uhrt n e Cai mi a o seth tt' iv y f itrsi teiiit emesr'v l i i sc acs,h nu drfdrla neetn h ht i aues ai t n uh aete ,n e eea lw, av dy tepo o etwo l hv sadn i afdrl rceigt asrtesaes h rp nns ud ae tn ig n eeapoe. n o seth tt' d

itrsi dfnigtecalne iiaieadtapaaug n neetn eedn h hl gdntt n o pel jdmet e iv ivl aigteiiaie ( r f spa 68F3 ap 19.F r emoe nai t h ntt .Pel f ur, 2 .d t .16) ut r r, dn iv y h

ahuhh prebfru e htaldsge atw e eC lonaa log te ats eoe smpacl i re so ht r afri1 t i iy a h i w
atoie teof ilrpnns fniiaietasriesaesitrsite uhr sh fcapooeto a ntt o seth tt' neetn h z iv
v l i o av trapo diiaiemesr,ntebif fldb t iteNit ai t f oe-p rve nt tv auei h res i oh n h nh dy i e Ci utn i ticutlprisarewi teNit Cici'sae n tai r iad n hs o ral at ge t h nh ruts ttmethtf c e h teoscapoo et d hv atoi u drCaio a1wt asrtesaes h f il rp nns o ae uh rt n e l mi a o seth tt' y f itrsi sc acs,hnu drfdrla tepo o etwo l hv sa dn neetn uh aete n e eea lw h rp n ns ud ae tn ig

iafdrlrceigt dfn teiiaieadt apaaug n n eeapoedn o eedh ntt n o pel jdmet iv

ivldtn i. n aiaigt
B. tn igBae o riuaie l trs' Sa dn sd n i tc lrzd neet pa ' Un e tecnrln fdrluh rte,h rlta sae1w pasi drh otol g eea atoi ste oehttt a ly n i i dtr nn whte a ofcapoo eto ascesuiiaiemesr hsa eemiig ehr n fiil rpn n f ucsflnt t aue a iv sfiin p ro a latuaie itrs'i tev l i o temesr t uf et esn lt ri lrzd neet'n h ai t fh aueo c p c dy sp oth po nn'sadn u drfdrla ap ast b moecmpe up rte rpo ets tn ig n e e ea lw p er o e r o lx ta terlpae b saelw whnteofcapo o etsatoie b sae' hn h oe ly d y tt a e h fiil rp n n i uh rzd y tt . lwt asrtesaesitrsi tevldt o teiiaie a o seth tt' neetn h aiiy fh nt t . iv

(ontcniud mpeiupg) f toeot eko rv sae o n o iiitv mesr'ofcapo o eth v sadn t dfn temesr whn nt ie aues fiil rp nns a e tn ig o eed h aue e a ten me saed fn ati teliainh v u drae sc ad fne h a d tt eednsn h igto a e n etkn uh ees. t

21

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 23 of 74

Un e tepatuaie itrssa dr,e ead so setbihta a drh ri lrzd neettn ad fdrl eiin sa l h t c s fdrl o rcnieswhte apopetv pryia lt dmo srt n e eacuto sdr ehr rs cie at s be o e ntae a

ivso o algl poetditrswhc i()oceeadpriuaie,. nain f eal rtce neet ihsacnrt n at lr d .. y c z ad()ataoi nn,otojcua'o yohta.''(ua v n b ctlrmmietnt netrl r ptei l'' Ljn . z c ' h c' Deedro lle(9254U..5,6.lLjntehg cutute fnesfWi f 19)0 S5550) n ua,h ih orfr r d h epandtabyprclr e, mentateiuymutfeth xlie ht l atuai dwe a hth n r safcte l i z j pani iaproaadidvdawa. ( .t .6,n 1)Al og te litfn esnln niiul y' 1 ap 50f.. t u hh f 'd h
UntdSae S pe Corh src g ie taasaet a tep we t cet ie tts u rme ut a eo nzd ht tt sh o ro rae h nw itrssteiv so o whc ma cne sadn 'u drfdrla e neet,h n ain f ih y o frtn ig'n e eea 1w

( a n vChre,ur,7 U..46,n 1)ntvr itrstasae Dimod . alsspa4 6 S 5,5f.7,o eeyneethttt

1w rcg ie a cne n sadn o a idviu l retyt isi t o t a eo nzs s o fnig tn ig n n n i d a o ni o ntue ro t t d fn ap riua kn o lwsii saecut lb sfiin t etbihta eed at lr id fa utn tt o rwil e ufceto sa l ht c s teidvd ao etyhsapriuaie itrst bigo dfn a h n iiul r ni a at lrzd neeto rn r eed n t c

aaoosa utnfdrlor ( mpr C d Ci.rc, 56 (tt l nlgu lwsii eeacut Co ae oe vPo.j 2 asaea . w
rc g iigsadn o tx ae t caln eie aepn i r o p bi fmd eo nzn tn ig fapyro h l g l glx edt e f u lc t s e l u

i s tcutwi Damlr hylr r vC n (06 57U..3,4 -4 n te or t i ec rse Cop.. uo 20) 4 S 323236 a j h (aeapyrak sadn tcalnetecntuinlyo saetxcei s ttxaelcstnigo hl g h osit ai ftt a rdt t e to t i fdrlor.Unetegvrigfdrlae, ehr r h cetdb n eeacut) drh o enn eeacsswhteai t rae y l g
saelwi sfiin t sp oteea sadn u drh priuaie itrs tt a s ufceto u p rfdrltn ig n e te at lrzd neet c tsncsai dp n su o tenmr o tergtcnerdb tesaeadte et eesrl ee d p n h a e fh ih o fre y h tt n h y

ntro teijr tama b sfee b te udb liat ( . r v aue fh nuy ht y e ufrd y h wol-eign. CfWat . t h Sli(9 54 2U..9,0. edn 17) 2 S4 050)
l tepeet aetepat sdsge a t whte a ofcaiiit e n h rsn cs,h ri iare so eh r n fiilnt i e av po o et osse aseil rdsic itrsi tev l i o a iiit e rp nn p sess pcao it tneetn h ai t f n ntai n dy v

mesrte rpnnhjpnoe oc teiiaiehs enapoe b te aueh pooet a sosrd neh ntt abe prvd #h iv
v tr a da o tda saelw,n ,vnis, ehrtentr o taitrs oes n d pe s tt a ad e e fo whte h aue fhtneet

ado teijr tepooet udsfeiteiiaie aueiivl ae n fh nuyh rpnnwol ufrfh ntt mesr snai td iv d
2 2

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 24 of 74

aesf in t acr tepo o ettn igfrfdrla p roe u drte r usceto cod h rp n n sa dn o eea lw up ss n e h priuaie itrssadr. at lr dneettn ad c z Prp n nsmananta bcuete poss afn a na rg t n e o o et iti ht eas hy ses u dmetlih u dr teCaio aCo si to t po oesauoyo cntuinl hn e tru h h l mi ntuin o rp s tttr f o si t a c ag sho g f t to

teiiaiepoesseeg, otvSpeirCor(06 3 Ca.t96 h ntt rcs(e,..C sa .u ro ut20) 7 1 h 8, iv 4 10)te pses proa,atuaie itrsitevl i o a iiaie 07,hy ossa esnlprclrzd neetnh ai t fn ntt i dy iv
mesr ta te hv po oe a dtah s enapo e b tev tr,n aue hthy ae rp sd n ht a b e p rv d y h oesa itrsta wol g u dfn e ite aen t r te t po iesc a neetht ud o n eed d fhy r opemitd o rvd uh dfnewhntep bi ofcaswh odn rl d fn acaln e sae1w ees e h u l fiil o riai eed hl gd tt a c y e d ciet d s.Prp n nsag etater esnlfn a na rg t el o o o o o et ru hthip ro a,u dmetlih n g aate b teiiit epo iinwo l b n lfe iav trapo e u rned y h nt i rvso ud e ulid f oe-p rv d av i mesr te hv so srdii rprya dic ret ivldtdb cue auehy ae p noe smpo el n norcl n aiae eas y p bi ofcas oaeh si t temesr hv fi dt mo n adfneo t u l fiilwh r otl o h aue ae al o u t ee s ro c e e

apaao rorjdmettiigdwnteiiaie pel lwecutug n s kn o h ntt . r iv

Plitf, ycnrs,seth t l o g teofcapo o et.f n anisb o tatasrta at u h h fiil rp n nso a f h iiaiema p sesap ro a, atuaie itrsu drteCaiona nt t y oss esn lpri lrzd neet n e h l ri iv c f Co si to adteapial sauoypo iin i hviga iiaiemesr ntuin n h p l be tttr rvso sn a n n nt t aue t c iv te hv po oe sb te t tev tr, nea iiaiemesr h sbe hy ae rp sd u mi d o h oeso c n nt tv aue a en t i apo e b tev tr teofcapo o eth v n getrpro a lgl p rvd y h oesh fiil rp nns ae o rae esn leal y poetditrsi temesr'v l i ta ayohrme e o tep bi. rtce neetn h aues ai t hn n te mbr fh u l dy c Acodn l, litfag etao c a iiaiemesr hsb e eatdit crigy panis ru ht n e n nt t aue a en n ce no f iv lw,t ofcapo o et d n t oss adsic, at uaie itrsite a i fiil rp n ns o o p ses it tpri lrzd neetn h s n c iiaiesv l i . nt t ' ai t iv dy As epanwen e n t eiewh te teofcapo o et o a we x li, ed o dcd eh rh fiil rp nns f n iiaiemesr p sesapriuaie itrsi teiiaiesv l i o c nt t aue oss at lrzd neetn h nt t ' ai t n e iv c iv dy temesr hsbe apo e b tev tr.F rterao sdsusdblw, h aue a en p rv d y h oes o h esn ic se eo we cn ld ta whnp bioicasd ciet d fn av trapo e iiaieo o cu e ht e u l f il el o eed oe-p rv dnt t r c n iv
2 3

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 25 of 74

asrtesaesitrsi teiiaies aii ,n e Caionalw te seth tt' neetn h ntt 'v l t u dr l ri a h iv dy f ofcapo o et o a iiaiemesr aeatoie t asrtesaes fiilrp n ns f n nt t aue r uh rzd o seth tt' iv

itrsitevl i o teiiaieadt apaaug n ivlaigte neetn h ai t fh ntt n o p el jdmetnai t h dy iv dn

mesr.Bea s ta cnlso isfiin t sp otnasmaierso s aue cudht o cuin s ufceto u p ra fr t ep ne v t teq et np sdb teNit Cici, n e n t eiewhte, n e oh u si oe y h nh rutwe ed o dcd ehru dr o Caionalw,h ofcapo oet as p sesap riuaie ijrsi a l ri a te fiil rpn ns lo oss at lrzd neetn f c v trapo e iiaiesvldt. oe-p rvd nt t ' aii iv y 11 An lsso Iiitv Prp net'Sa igUn e Caio naLa 1. ayi f ntaie o o ns tndn d r l r i w f A.Baio l taiePrp n ns Sa dn ss fni tv o o e t' tn ig i Aril I,eto 1o teCaionaCo si to poli :t l oiia t e Iscin fh l ri ntt in rcams W1p l cl c f u t po riihrn i tep o l.Go en n i isi tdfrhipoeto , we sn eetn h epe vrmetsntue o ter rtcin t scrt,n b nftadte hv terg toatro rfr iwhntep bi eui a d eei,n h y aeh ih t l reom t e h u l y e c g o ma rq ie'Asticut oe i Srusspr, 6Ca.t 34 41o d y eur. hs o rn tdn ta s,u a 4 1 h 6 , 2 ' 4 41:-ipo iinoiiae i o eo teiiascin o teDelrt no 3 hs rvso rgntd n n fh nt let s fh caai f l i o o

Iihs otie i Cai ri'fsC ntuin( lC nto 14 ,r., 2, tgtcnandn lonasit osit Ca. os.f 89at1j ) f r to adrfcs bs peet fu gvrmetlytm:tatepolhv te n el ta ai rcp o or oen nasse hth epe aeh e c cntuinlih tatr reomte gvrmet (n o td) ostt ar to l o rfr hi oen n. F .mie. io g e r ' t Al og Caionas r ia 14 Cosit ndcae ta.lql t uh l ri'oinl89 ntui elrdhtl l h f g to a
p liap we iih rn i tepepl,iwa nt ni6 yasltr i oicl o rsn eetn h o e't s o u tl 0 er ae- n t ' 1 1 - ta teCaionaCosi t nwa a n e t afr tev tr o 9 1 hth l ri ntt i s medd o fodh oes f f uo Caio ateatoi t drclpo oeada ottt cntuinl l mi h uh rt o iet rp s n d p sae o si to a f y y t a n meta dsauoypo iin tru hteiiaiep we.l Aso itd med ns n tttr rvso sho g h nt t o r n scae iv

Ho Bulesec,n.. to iemoe(96 1 Ca.d525 1 me i r t.IcvCi fLvr r 17) 8 l 8,9 d y 3 ( sdae me ies, bit dsr e tehsoysgicnead Aso tdHo Bul r)we r l eci d h i r,inf ac,n d ey b t cnietu iilne eaino tecntuinl bsdiiaiepwei ostnjdcaitmrtt fh ostt al ae ntt o rn s o io y iv
Caiona 'ea n met fh Caio aCo si ini 1 1 t po iefr lfri: h med n o te l mi nt o n 9 1o rvd o f f mt teiiaieadrfrn u sg ie oeo teottn igahee nso te h nt t n eee d m inf s n fh usadn civ met fh iv i
2 4

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 26 of 74

po rsiemo e n o teer 10 '.Drfe i l h o teter ta al rgesv vmet fh al 9 0s atd n i t fh h oy ht l y g p we o g vrmet lmaeyrsdsi tepepetea n metsek o o r f o en n ut tl eie n h o l,h med n p a s f i teiiaieadrfrn u nta arg t rne tep o l,u a ap we h nt t n eee dm,o s ih gatd h epeb t s o r iv

rsre b te Delr gi edt o tecutijaos gadtir h eevd yhm. cai tt uy fh or oelul ur hsi t n h s y g
o tep o l' . ,h cuthv d srbdteiiaieadrfrn u a fh epe . . te ors ae ecie h nt t n eeed m s iv

atuaigSn o temot rco sihs f u dmort poes.. j rclt oe fh speiu r to or e cai rcs..' (/ i n g c f hsln be oruiil lytaplal eacntutnt tipo r a og en ujdcapoi o p y i rlosrci ohs we c b o whrvr1lcalne lodrtater h b n tm rpr a nld J eee '' h l gd' re hth l te olpoel nul f ts e n k ' y e d utcnraoalb rsle ifvro h ueo hs eevp we,ors o bs a esn b e eovdnao fte s ftirsre o rcut y wipeev i''(ais de,itn &fso t d) l rsret ' I l addct i s n.mie. l . tc ao t
Asanmbro or at eiin hv epand tepo rsie u e f u p sdcso s ae x lie ,h rgesv mo e n i Caionata itou e teiiaiep we it orsae v metn l ri htnrd cd h nt t o rno u tt f iv Co si t nge o t fdsaifcinwi tete -o enn p biof il ntui rw u o istsato t h hng vrig u l fi as to h c c adawiepedb l fhth p o lh dlscnrl fh p liapo es n d sra ei tate epe a oto to o te oiclrcs. e t

(e,..Idp netkryPrdcrAsnvMc hro (06 3 Ca.h Seeg,neednf cg oues s.. p esn 2 0) 8 lt 4 12,0 114 ;t usspa4 Ca.t 344 04 1 I tistn,le 0 0 14 -03Sr s,ur,6 l h 6,2-2. nhs etgtt a 4 ) i lh
iiit ewa ve da o emen o rsoigtep o l'rgtu cnrl vr ntai s iwe s n a s fetrn h epesihfl oto o e v ter o en n,yprvdn ameh dtawo l pr th pepet po oe h ig v rmetb o iig to ht ud emite o l o rp s

adaottt oypoios n cnt inlmed ns'(tas,ur, n dp s m r rvs n ad osmt aa n met. Srusspa a i io '

ap41 T e r rp/oe fh iiav w soafrte epeh t.2. h pi y u sotentte at f dh polte ) ma ii o

a it t pooeadt ao t osi to a a n met o sauoypo iin bly o rp s n o dp cntuin lme d ns r tttr rvso s i t ta tereetdp biofcash drfsdo dcie t ao t Th 1 1b l t h thi lce u l fiil a eue r el d o d p. e 91 al c n o p mp lt tu n i fv r fh mesr dsrbdteiiaiea h t a heagmetn a o o te aue ecie h nt t s a iv t sfg adwhc tep o lso l rti frte ev st sp e n tewok aeur ih h epe h ud ean o h msle,o uplmeth r o telgsaueb iiaigtoemesrswhc telgsaueete vcosy fh eiltr y nt t h s aue ih h eiltr i r iiul in h

o ngietfi o rue teat.. (etoSaePooe Amed.o r el nl al re sso nc..' Sc.f tt,rpsd nst g y s f '
2 5

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 27 of 74

Cos. tL gsResn, nElc( t1,9 1Resn wh SnCos. ntwi ei. aosGe. e.Oc.0 11) aos y e. nt h AmedNo2 solb aotdil sde. n. .2 hud e dpe,t i add) ac
T eCaionacntuin l rvso sstigfrhteiiaiep we h l ri o si t apo iin et ot h nt tv o r f to n i d n tx iiyrfroo fl pecieteatoi o'so sbliso te o o epl t ee t r ul rsr h uh rt rr p niit fh cl y b y e ie ofcapo oeto a iiitv mesr,zb th Leiltr,nao t g fiil rp nns f n nt ie auel u te gsauei dpi a n 1 Th cntuin l rvso srlt gt teiiaiep we aecret 2 e o si t a po iin eai o h nt t o r r urnl to n iv y stoti atl I,et n 8a d1,ril l scin1adat lXV11 e fr n ri e Isci s n 0 at e V,eto ,n ri e l, h c o c c scin 3ad4o teCaionaCo si t n. eto s n fh lfri ntt i uo ArilI,etn8poie irl at ata T eiiaieite t eIsci ,rvdsn ee npr:$) h ntt sh c o v ( iv p we o teeetr t po oesaue :da n mett teCo si t na d o r fh lcoso rp s ttts p med nso h ntt i n uo

t aot reethm. o dp o r cte j b Aniiaiemesr ma b pooe b peet gt teSceay ) ntt aue y e rp sd y rsni oh ertr ( iv n

o Saeap tinta stfrhtetx o tepo oe saueo a n meto f tt eio h tesot h et fh rp sd ttt r med n t t teCo si to adicrie t hv b e sg e b eetr eulnn mbrt h ntuin n s etid o ae en in d y lcos q ai u e o t f 5preti tecs o asauea d8pretntecs o a a n metote ecn n h ae f ttt,n ecn i h ae f n me d n t h Co siuin o tev tsfra1 addtsfrGo en ratelsg b raoil nt to , fh oe o 1cn iae o v ro th at u entra t eet n lci . o GcT eSceayo Saesalhnsb th mesr ate et eea ) h ertr f tt hlte umite aue th nxgnrl ( eet nh l alat1 1dy atriq aiiso aayseilttwieeet n lci ed tes 3 as fe t ul e r t n p ca sae d lci o f o

hlgirohteeae co. h Goenr yclasei st d ed r ttagnrll tn T e vroma a pc lte e o ei l a awi

eet nfrh mesr. lcl o te aue' o '

Arcel,etn1 poie irlvnpr:aAniiaies tt.. tl 1sci 0 rvdsn eeat at ) ntt tue . i o ( iv a apoe b amaoi o vtshro tksefctedyat teeet n p rvd y jry f oe teen ae feth a frh lci t e o ulstemesrpoie ohr s.(q .() nesh aue rvds tewie ! . .! I . c T e gs tr . . ya n o rpaa iiaiesateb $) h Leilue .ma med reeln ntt ttt y ( a iv l
aoh rttt ta bcmeefcieo l wh napo e b teeetr u ls nte saueht eo ft ny e p rv d y h lcos nes v teiiaiesauepr ta nd n o rpel to th iapo a. h nt t ttt emis me met re awi u ter p rvl iv h
sal esb te t teAt re Geea wh sal rpr atl adsmmay h lb u mi d o h t ny n rl o hlpe ae ie n u r t o t o temesr a po ie b lw. fh aue s rvd d y a e T eL gsauesalrvd temahrnwhc ptin sale ) h ei tr hlpoieh n ei ih eio shlb ( l t cruae,rsne,n criid admesrssb te t teeetr. icltd peetd a d et e,n aue u mi d o h lcos' f t ' Aril I scin1po ie i 11 -elgsaiep we o ti Saei t e V,eto rvdsn 1 h eilt o r fhs tt s c :l v v se i teCaio aLeiltr whc cnito teS nt adAse l, etd n h l mi gsaue ih o sss fh e ae n smby f b th p o lrsret te ev sh po r o iiit ea drfrn u ' u te epe eev o hmsle te wes fnt i n eeed m. av ' Aril XVIIscin3po ie i 11:l eeetrma a ndte t e I,eto rvdsn 1 - lcos y me h c -h Co sti nb iiaie' ntui y nt t . i o iv ' Iontcniudonxpg) otoeot e netae n 2 6

d Pirocruaino a iiaie..eio frintrsacp 1 ) r t i lt fnntt .ptin o sgaue, oy ( o c o iv t

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 28 of 74

saue t fr l ea dfclaeteiiaiepo esh seatdan mb ro tttso omai n aitt h nt tv rcs, a n ce u e f z i i po iin taeplil ietywh teofcapo o eto a iiaie rvso sht x i t dni o h fiil rp n ns f n nt t cy f iv mesr aeadd srb teratoi addte. aue r n ecieh i uh rt n uis y Elcin Co escin3 2d f e tepo o eto a iiaiemesr eto s d et 4 ei sh rp nn fn nt t ape o n iv a h eetro eetr wh sb th tx o apo oe iiaieo s e lco r lcos o u miteet f rp sd nt t r t iv rfrn u t teAt re Geeawi arq etht eo sepeaea eeed m o h t ny nrl t eustah r h rpr o h cruaigtt a dsmmyo tecif up s adponso tepo oe iclt ie n u r fh he p roe n it fh rp sd n l

mesr ..'Smir , lcin C d scin90 sae tatt e lcos aue .. i l l Eet s oe et 0 1ttshtl eetr ' ay o o rh peet gterqettteAt re Geeaqhlb k o a te rsni h eus( h t ny prlsale nwn sh n o o
rp n ns 'adrq ie tapirotecruaino a iiaiep tinfr po o et''n eursht ro t h iclto f n nt t eio o iv t sg auetetx o tepo oe mesr mut esb te t teAt re intr h et fh rp sd aue sb umitd o h t ny o Geeawi arq ethtcruaigtt a dsmmayo tecif up s nrl t eu sta f iclt il n u r fh hep roe h a n e adp ito tepo sdmesr b peae .l Elcin Co escin 9 0 , n ons fh rpoe aue e rprd'3 eto s d eto s 6 7 ' 9 0 ,n 9 0 paea o l ainu o teofcapo o eto a iiit e 6 8ad 6 9 lc n bi t p n h fiil rp nns f n nt i go av mesr t ma aea dsp rietepoesb whc sg aue frh iiaie aue o ng n u evs h rcs y ih intrs o tent t iv p tinaeotie ,n Elcin Co escin9 3 seiishtatr eio r ban d a d et s d eto 0 2 p cfe ta,fe t o

s ntrs aebe clce,leiht feteptin( ttedsgae i aue hv en ol tdSt r to i h eio wi h eintd g e lh g l t h eet not iljh lb rsre t ipooet adayscinteef lci fcassal e eevd ot rp nns n n et hro o i s , o
peetdfrfl gb ayp ro o pro sohrta tepo o et o a rsne o ii y n esn r esn te hn h rp nns f n (ontcniud mpeiupg) otoeot eko rv sae n o Aril XVIIscin4po ie i rlvn patt pooe a nd n t e I,et rvdsn eeat r:W rp sd me met c o teentk sefctedyatrteeeto u ls temesr po ie hro ae feth a fe h lcin nesh aue rvds oh r s. tewie' ' 1 Elcin Co escin9 0 as rq i stepo o et o a iiaie 3 et s d eto 0 1 lo eur h rp nns f n nt tv o e i mesr,nsb tn terrq etfratl adsmmay t pyafewhihi auei u mit g hi eu s o ie n u r,o a e c s i t t b rfn e t tepo o etitemesr q aie frh b l t ti t o e eudd o h rp nnsfh aue u lis o te al wi n wo f o h yasfo tedt tesmmayifrihdt tepo o et. er rm h aeh u r s unse o h rp n ns
...

sal esb t dt teeetradiapoe b amaoi o vts hlb umie oh lcosn fp rvd y jry f oe t t

2 7

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 29 of 74

mesr o b p ro sd l atoie i wrtn b o eo moeo tepo nns aue r y esn uy uh rzd n i g y n r r fh rpoet i

saledseaddb teeetn of il'(ais de. hlb i gre y h lci s fca. l l add) r o i ' tc
On ea iiitv mesr h sq aiidfrh b l tsvrl rvso so c n nt ie aue a u lfe o te al ,e eapo iin f a o teElcin Coev spo o etwi tep we t cnrlh ag meti h eto s d et rp n ns t h o ro o tote ru nsn h fv ro a iiaiemesr.Al og ayvoe cnfewi teS ceayo ao f n nt t aue t u h n tr a i t h ertr f iv h l h

Saea agmeto o aanth iiaie( e. d, 96)abl t tt n ru n fr rgistentt E1cCoej 04, al iv o

ag methln t eacpe u ls ih sbe uh rzdb tepo o et ru n sal o b cetd nest a en t toie y h rp n n' a '

(1cCoej96,u d().lmoeta oeagmetsfe, lcin Ee. d, 05sb .d) f r hn n ru n i i dEet s l o

Co escin9 6 po ie ta i peaigteb l t a he rfrnea d d et 0 7 rvdshtn rp rn h al p mp lt eee c n o o p pirt'sal egvnt teb l tru n sb te b teofcapo nns roi 'h lb ie o h al ag metu mitd y h fiil rpo et y o o t iiit emesr.Po o etsmirycnrlh rb ta ag meti fhent i aue rp nns i l l o to te eutlru nsn av a

fvr fniiaie (e ElcC d, 96.Moevrpoo etrtite ao o a ntt . Se e. oej 09) roe,rpnnsean h iv

p we t wi da ab l t ru n a ayt b fr teda l frfl g o ro t rw al ag mett n i eoeh edi o ii h o me ne n

agmet.(e ElcCoej90 . ru ns Se e. d, 6 1) Uneteeadrltdsttr poiin (e,..Ee. d,j90 , drhs n eae t uoy rvsosseeg, lcCoej 02 a 90 ,64,h ofilrpnns fniiaiemesr aercgie a 0490)te fcapooeto a ntt aue r eonzd s i iv
h vn adsicrl- iv ligb t atoi adrso sblista dfe a ig itntoe n ovn oh uh rt n ep niite ht ifr y i fo ohrsp otr o temesr - wihrgr t teiiaiemesr te 'm te u p res fh aue t ead o h nt t aueh r iv po o eth v so srd rp nns a e p noe. Nete tesaecnt inl rvso srlt gt teiiit ep we, i rh tt o si o apo iin eai o h nt i o r h mt n av n rh sauoypo iin rltn t teofcapo o et o a iiaie o te tttr rvso s eaig o h fiil rp nns f n nt t iv mesr,x rsl adesteq et nwhte,riwht icmsacste aueepesy d rs h u si ehro n acru tne,h o ofcapo o etaeatoie t apa i cutodfn tev ldt o a fiilrp nns r uh rzd o p ern o rt eed h aii f n y iiit emesr tepo o eth v so srd No ehls,ic teaoto ntai aueh rp nns ae p noe . nteessn eh d pin v o teiiaiep we acnuyao dcso so b t ticutn teCo rso fh nt t o r etr g , eiin f oh hs o ra d h ut f iv Ap el aerpael adu iomlpemitdteofcapo o eto p ahv e etdy n nfr y r te h fiil rp nns f iiaiemesrst p riiaea pris- ete a itre eso a ra nt t aue o at pt s at iv c e i r snevnr r s el h
2 8

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 30 of 74

prisi itrs i b t pelcina dp seeto liaincaln igte at n neet n oh reeto n otlcin igto h l gn h e t e iiaiemesr te hv so srd.Futemoetepriiainb ofca nt l aueh y ae p noe rhr r,h at pto y fiil iv c iiaiepo nnsa fr l at si sc liainh sruieybe nt t rpo et s omapri n u h igto a o tnl en iv e t p r te whte o n th At re Geea o ohrp biofcasweeas emitd ehr r o te t ny n rl r te u l fiil r lo o c

dfnigtecaln e iiaiemesr iteuiilrceigiqet n eedn h hl gdntt auenh jdcapoedn n usi . e iv o T edcsosnwhc of ilntt e rpnnso ognzt n ta h eiin i ih fcaiiai pooet(r raiai sht i iv o hv be drcl iv le idatgadsosr gteiiaiemesr) ae ae en i t n ovdn rfn n pnoi h ntt auehv ey i n iv
benpr te t p riiaea prisi Caio zapoedn siv lig e emi d o at pt s ate n l ni rceig n ovn t c f

calnet a iiaie aueaelgo.(e,..Srusspa4 hl gso n ntt mesr r ein Seeg,t s,ur,6 e iv a Ca.h3439(otlcincaln e;ne net nr.P oues snv lt 6 ,9 p seet hl gqIdpednf cgz rdcrAs.. 4 o e ) Mchro,ur, 8Ca.h12 (ne net cpz rdcr)pelcin p esnspa3 1t 0 0Idpednfnr P oues (reet 4 o calne; otvSpeirC utspa3 Ca.h96 10 ( sa hl g)C sa .u ro or,ur, 7 1t 8,0 1Cot) e 4 (reet ncalne;eaefteSaeo a..oe (9 9 2 Ca.t pelci hl gjSnto h tt fc lvJns 19) 1 l h o e 4 14, 16(reet ncalne; tl poes&Retuat pl es 12 14 pelci hl g)HoeEm lye s rnEm o e o e a y ltra. no vDai(99 2 Ca.t 5550( tl m oesU in nentU in . vs 19) 1 1 h 8, 9 HoeE pl e no) 4 y (otlcincaln e; sSrlsC .. l n(95 1 Ca.t 14, p s et hl g)Amwetu.n. ov Wio 19) 1 1 h 23 e o e s 4 15 (mwetEotlcincaln e; 0hC nuyIsC .. aa ni 20A s)pseet hl g)2 t etr n. ovG rmed o e (94 8C 1t 262 12 tC nuylsC .(otlcincaln e; 19) a.h 1,4 (0h etr n. o)pseet hl g) 4 o e Leiltr vEuspr,4Ca.d42 50(otlcincalne; afr Is gsaue . ,u a 5 l 9,0 pseet hl g)C l m n. 3 o e a C .. umein(9 9 4 Ca.d8582(otlcincaln e; epec ovDek ja 18) 8 1 0, 1 p s et hl g)P ol x 3 e o e rlDek ja vC uto noio(943 C1d4640&f. e. umein . on fMedcn 18)6 a. 7,8 n1 y 3 (otlcincalne; eiltr vDek ja (93 3 Ca.d6863 pseet hl gjLgsaue . umein 18) 4 1 5,6 o e 3 (reet ncaln e; onhnvEu(92 3 C 1d13(reet n pelci hl gjBrsaa . 18) 1 a. , pelci o e 3 o calne; to a tMo i vSe r,u a 16Ca.p .t4,3 hl gqCi fs na nc .twatspr,2 1 p4h 35 e y a A (otlcincaln e; i eso Jb dteE oo yvC u to rne pseet hl gjCt nfr os rh cnm . ony foag o e i (02 9 C 1 p4h11,36& f. (otlcincalne; to 20) 4 a. .t 3 111 n 2p s et hl gjCi f Ap e o e y Wet ntr . onyo ag (98 24Ca.p .d6366(otlcin smise vC ut forne 18) 0 l p3 2,2 ps et A e o
2 9

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 31 of 74

caln e; o ntHel AsnvB ado uevos(93 16 hl gqC mmui at s.. or fsp ri r 18) 4 e y h s C 1 p .d9092(otlcincalne; i c sg lcvAlit(9 9 a. p3 9 ,9 pseet hl gjSma Dein n.. cai17) A o e 9 Ca. p3 16 13lotlcincalne;e asAse lvDek ja 2 1 .d 4,5 s et hl g)se lo smb . umein Ap e o e y (92 3 Ca.d686465( frnu pooet emie tprcpta 18) 0 1 3,4-4 r eedm rpnnpr t do atiae s 3 e t i rapr iitrsipelcincaln eoa rp sdrfrnu .4 elat n neetn reet hl g t pooe eeedmjl y o e l
1 P sdcso shv feunl da .adsicin fr up sso 4 at eiin a e rq et rwn itnto ,o p roe f y itreto , ewen o teo eh n ,h ofcapo o eto a iiaie nevnin bt e, n h n adte fiil rp n ns f n nt t iv mesr o ognzto staweedrcl iv le i dat gadso srn aue r ra iain ht r iet n ovd n rfi n p noig y n temesr,n , nteohrhn ,te av cc gop taielgcl h auead o h te ad ohr d oay ru shtdoo ial y sp oth mesr. u p rte aue As oe aoe(neap 7f.)ite tas liainor or ntd bv at,t .,n 1,nh Srusigt u cut t o gatdtemointldb teofcapo nnso Po st n8t itreea rne h to ip y h fiil rpo et f rpoio o nevn s i fr l at si dfn igteiiaiemewr,u atesmetmedne a omapri n ee dn h nt t a eb tth a i id e iv moint itreeta hdbe fldb a ohr r-rp sto 8av cc to onevn h t a en i y n te popo oi n d o ay e i

gop (e.s C n elvSaePronl .2 0) 7Ca.t 16, 18 ru . Sea o onr .tt esneBd(06 3 l h 19 17l y 4 17 (ot sn tesau o a a cscra avcc gopwi tao 19 cnr t gh tts fn mi uie doay ru t ht f ai u h

ofcapo o eto ab l t auei cn ldn tatea cscra cud f il rp nns f al mesr n o cu ig hth miu uie o l o n t rpel b h l lbefratre fe a re u drCoeCi Prc, o po ry e ed i l o tony es wadd n e d v. o . a j12 .4ih o tidsicinplitfs rlac u o teCoro Ap el 0 15. t fhs itnto , anif'ein e p n h ut f p a ) . ll ng dcso i Ci a dCoffo a Fac c vSaefcafri (05 18 eiin n t n z . fs n rni o .tto lona 20) 2 y np s Ca. p4h13 lcsmei.I tacs,h Coro Ap elfime atil 1 .t 0 0 ak rt n htaete ut f p a afr d ra Ap cutre dn igamoinfldb a av cc ognzt n- tePo oiin o rodr eyn t ie y n d o ay raiai h rp st o o o 2 Lea Dees a dEd cto F n - seigt itreei a ato 2 gl fne n u ain u d ekn o nevn n n cin caln igtev l i o Po oiin2 I u h ligtetil o rodr h l gn h ai t f rp st 2. n p odn h racutre e dy o dn igitret n h wee,h Coro Ap elx lct sae ta h eyn nevni , o vrte ut f pa epiiy ttd htt e o l t F n ief ly dn rli so srn Po oio 2 bcueteognzto u d t lpae o oe n p noig rp st n 2 eas h raiain s i

wantvncetdut oeyaJ r oes asdteiiaie'18 s oee rae ni n er/cvtrpse h ntt '(2 l iv Ca.p .hap 13)adepandtaths aede nt rsnte l p4 t .08,n xlie httics os opeeth A t qet no whtea ofilrpnn o a iiaie(1cCoej32 hs usi f ehr n fiapooet fn ntt Ee. d, 4 ) a a o c iv sfiinl drc adi daeitrst pr titret i liain ufcety ietn mmeit neeto emi nevnin n igt t o caln igte aii o telweatd'18C 1 p .t ap 13) T u, hl gn h vl t fh a nce'(2 a. p4h t .08. h s e dy A

cnrr t panif'cnet n tadcso in tno sset t te o tay o litfs o tni ,ht eiin s o icnitn wi h o h n meo sd cso sb t o ticutn teCorso Ap atah v u ru eiin oh fhs o rad h ut f pelht ae p r t dteofcapo o eto a iiaiemesr t itreei ato s emit h fiil rp nns fn nt tv aue o nevn n cin e i c aln igtev ldt o teiiaiemesr.Fo tesmerao ,hscuts h l gn h aii fh nt t aue rh a esn ti o r' e y iv sbeun dtr n to iI r Mara eCae,u a 4 Ca.t 7 7 7 9 u sq et eemiain n n e rig ssspr, 3 l h 5 , 8 4 Iontcniudonxpg) otoeot e netae n
3 0

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 32 of 74

Moevrtecsshv nt nyp r te ofca iiaiepo o ett ro e,h ae ae o o l emitd fiilnt t rp n nso iv ap a a fr l at sb t aeas p r te tepo o ett apa fo a p er somapri u hv lo emi d h rp nnso p elrm n e t

avreug n.(e,.. s,ur, 1C lt ap 15 ;0hC nuy desjdmet Seeg, tspa 1 a.h t .2 02t etr Amwe 4 IsC .spa 8C 1t ap29P ole rlDek ja vC uto n. o,ur, a.h t .6; epe x e. umein . ony f 4
Med cn ,ur, 6Ca.dap. 0 Sma Deinspr, 2Ca. p3 a n oiosp a 3 1 t 48 ; i c sg ,u a 9 1 .d t 3 Ap

p 13) .5.
Al o g i mot fteecssteotca iiaiepo o ets t u h n so h s ae h fiilnt t rp n n' h iv priiaina afr l at- ete a a itree o a arapryi at pto s omap r i r s n nevnr r s el at n c y h itrs- wa n th ln e qd a acneu neticut pir eiin neet s o cal gd n, s o sq e c,hs o r' ro d cso s e s

( t teecpino te uli IdsrA s.eiindsusdblw) ae wi h xet fh B i n n ut sndcs icse eo hv h o dg y o .

n t a ocso t aay eteqeto o teofcapo o etsatoi t s o h d cain o nlz h usin fh fiil rp nn' uh rt o o y p riiaetepeaec adu iomiyo ticutspatc o pr tn at pt,h rvln e n nfr t fhs or' rcie f emit g c i ofcapo o ett ap a a fr l at st d fn teiiaiemesr fiil rp nnso p er somap ri o eed h nt tv aue e i te hv so srdn nteesisg icn.AsChe JsieMasal hy ae p noe o ehls s inf at i ifut rhl c epan di a eryd cso o teUntdSae S pe Co r,h eitneo x lie n n al eiin fh i tts u rme utte xsec f e

n meos eiin tahv pr t dauiilrcdrwi otxliy u ru dcsosht ae emie jdcapoeue t uepit t h cl

dsusn tepoeuesvl i aepo el ve dt aemu hweg ta icsig h rcdr' ai t r rpry iwe o v c ih,s dy h

te so ta( easr dfwitepoeuenieocre t tebr r hy hw htt set l nh rcdrj et r curdoh ao h e a h tebnh'(ako h U idSae vDeeu (89 9U..5Cac) 1 h ec. B n fte nt tt . vax 10) S ( rnh 6, ' e s 8;e as Bo nSo C .. ntdsae (92 30U..9,0. 8se lo rw h e ovU i tt 16) 7 S24 37) e s
(ontcni e#o peiupg) f toeotud m rv sae o n o 7 1tatesmeav cc gop- tePo oio 2 Lea Dees ad 9 ,hth a d o ay ru h rp st n 2 g l fne n i Ed cto Fu d- lce sadn t mananalwsit o ti adcaaoy u ain n akd tn ig o iti a uto ban elrtr

jdmetpilignauaaisfrptiot2iysstuprpaofisl ul nudodh te edtoPofsin2 den esdothii i j h n h vl d o e otu o o osp y lnf' iy tf camsrgr n te tr n cp o h a hrt posse b te fca l ea g e
po o eto a iiaiemesr. rp nns f n nt tv aue i

31

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 33 of 74

Panifak o eg ta Cal mitiln ap lt cuthv lit s cn wld eh t lo ar ad p el e ors a e f f a a rp ae l adcnitnl pr te teofcapo o e to a iiaiet eetdy n o sset emi d h fiil rp n ns f n nt tv o y t i ap a a fr l rist dfn t iiaiemesr te hveso srd p er s omapat o eedhent t aue hy a p noe . e iv Plitfmanan h wee,htnal fh pircssteofcapo o et anis iti, o v rtai 1o te ro ae h fiil rp n ns f weepr te t itre eo t ap a a rap risi itrso l b vru o r emi d o nevn ro p er s el at n neet ny y ite f t e

al eaeecs ojdcadsrt nadte oltrpeeth pooet' i rlxrie fu iilicei n hn ny o ersn te rpnns b o

o pro a itrsrte ta t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o te wn esn lneetahrh n o seth tt' neetn h ai t fh dy
me sle al . r

Panif'hrceiaino tepeeet, o v rin t ae o te litfsc aatrzto fh rcdnsh weess o bsd n h tx o toedcso s Asarayn td i al u o eo ticutspir et fh s eiin. led oe ,n lb t n fhs or' ro dcso s hv n t encl du o t adesteb sso oru iom eiin we ae o b e al p n o d rs h ai f u nfr e pat eo p r tn oi ilnt t epo o ett itreeo t ap a a ra rci f emiig fca iiai rp nnso nevn ro p er s el c t iv pat si itrsi sc liain ad i p riua,oepan' ehrt ri n neetn uh igt ,n ,n at lrt x li wh te he e t o c po o et' atiainwa t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o te rp nnsp ri pto s o seth tt' neetn h ai t fh c dy mesr o t dfn tepo o et' wnpriuaie p ro aitrsi te aue ro ee d h rp nns o at lrzd esn lneetn h c

vl i otemesr (r ehp i bt cpcts. T e ait fh aueo prasn oh aaiels h dy i l

1 Nete tesauoypo iinrltn t itreto n rtepo iin 5 i rh tttr rvso eaig o nevnin o h rvso h prann t tesau o arap ryi itrsadessteq et nwhte a etiig o h tts f el at n neetd rse h u si ehr o wo l-ep rys rp sdpriiainit asri o itrso t asrte udb at'po oe at pto so sett wn neet ro seth c s saesitrs. tt' neet Co eo CiiPoeuescin3 7- teitreto saue- po ie d f vl rcd r eto 8 h nevnin ttt rvds tematrnliain o i tesceso ete o tepriso a itrs h tei igto , rn h u cs f i r fh at , r n neet t h e

po iino lw cnesa u cn io arg toitreeo itepesn rvso fa o fr n no dt n lih t nevn rfh ro i seigitreto camsa itrsrltn t tepo et o tascin ekn nevnin li n neeteaig o h rpry rrnato

irlvnpr:a Upnt lapiain aypro, ohs nitrsi n eeat at 1) o i y p l t ,n esnwh a a neetn ( me c o aant oh ma itreeiteat nopoedn .. ()()fn gisbt, ynevn nh ci r rceig ..! b Iay o

o teato ma a apatcl te i aro i eetap ro sait t fh cin y s rcia matrmp i rmp d ht esn' bly o i poethtitrs, nestapro 'itrsia eutl rpeetdb rtcta neetu ls ht esnsneets dq aey rsne y eit gpristecuthl,p ntmeyapiain pr tht esnt xsi at ,h orsalu o i l p l to , emitap ro o n e c itree' nevn. ' (ontcniudonxpg) f toeot e netae o n
3 2

whc itesbet fh at nadtapro is stae tatedsoio ihsh ujco te ci n htesn s o i td hth i st n o u p i

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 34 of 74

peet rceigafrsu teop ru i t adestip it6 rsn po edn fod sh p otnt o d rs hs on. y l I aay igtelg l aiu o whc a ot a iiaiepo o ets n nlzn h e ab ss p n ih n f lnt t rp n n' ki i v atoiyt p riiaei sc liainrssweb lv iiueut da a uh r o at p t n uh igt et, ei e ts sflo rw t c t o e dsicinbt e lglh l n e t a iiaiemesr tapeeete itnt ewen e acal g so n nt t aueht rcd h o e iv v tr'p rvlo a iiaiemesr adlglh ln e t a iiaie oes apo a f n nt t aue n ea cal g so n nt t iv e iv mesr ta aebo gt fe teiiaiehsbe apo e b tevtr ad aueht r ru h atrh nt t a en p rv d y h oes n iv

aotdit lw.(o cneinewerfrotefr r aeoya dpe noa Fr ovnec, eet h omectgr s ireet n css n teltr aeoya totlcin'ae. celci ' ae adh at ctgr st s et 'css p o e p e o )
Piroa eeto,igto iv liga iiit emesr ma aie ro t n lcin liain n ovn n nt i aue y rs t av

wi rgr t a d vrt o iusicuigfrxmpe() ehrh t ead o wie aiy f s e,nldn ,o ea l,1whtete h e s

po oe mesr ma n t esb te t tevtr tru hteiiaiepo es rp sd aue y o b u mitd o h oesho g h nt tv rcs i Iooeotud mpeiupg) ottcni eko rv sae n n o Co eo CiiPoeuescin3 7- terap ryi itrssaued f vl rcdr eto 6 h el at n neetttt po ie smpy: v r ato mut epoeue i ten meo terapat rvds i l s ey cin sb rsctd n h a fh el ry E i itrs,x etsohr s po ie b saue' n neetecp a tewie rvd d y ttt. ' 1 Al o g psC/ionadcsoshv gnrl n t a ocso t 6 t u h at l ri eiin a e e eal o h d cain o h f y epl iyadestertoaeo b ssu dr igteatoi o ofca x i t drs h ainl r ai n el n h uh rt f fiil cl y y iiaiepo o ett priiaea itreeso rap risi itrs,h nt t rp nnso at pt snevn r rel at n neette iv c e Nit Cici'q et nt ticute ntae tateu dryn b ssfr nh ruts u si o hs o rdmo srtshth n elig ai o o po o et' atiainu drCaiona1w ip tnil dtr ntv o te rp n nsp ri pto n e l ri a s oetal eemiaie fh c f y q eto whte tepo o ethv sadn u drfdrla t ap a alwe u sin ehrh rp nns ae tn ig n e eea lw o p el o r p biofcaswh odnrlwo l p ru sc a ap ahv dcie t d u l fiil o riai ud use uh n p el ae el d o o c y n s.Beas,swehv se,tiwel salse ta Caionacuth v a o cue a ae en i s letbihd ht lfri ors a e n o l aint l eal cntu tepo iin o teCaionaCo siuin bi t o i rl osreh rvso s fh lfri nttt go b y o rlt gt teiiaiep we t asr tateiiaiepo esin t iet o eai o h nt t o ro suehth nt t rcs s o drcl r n iv iv y

fdrlorjdmetnaiaigaCai rivtrapoe iiaiewhnte eeacutug n ivl t d n lona oe-p rvdntt e h f iv

adb cueteCaionaiiaiepoesma b u dr n diaCaio a n eas h l ri nt t rcs y e n emie f lfmi f iv iiaieg e u dfn e i afdrl rceigbcuefdrl orslc a nt t os n eedd n e eapoedn eas e eacut ak iv po ru drtn igo tebsso teatoi p sesdb a iiaie rpe n esa dn fh ai fh uh rt osse y n nt t y iv mesr'ofcapo nnsu drCaionalw,tsetrl aporaeta aues flil rpoet n e l ri a ii ni y p rpit ht f e wersleteistp sdb teNit Cici. eov h st oe y h nh rut e

idrcl anld(e Ascae Ho Bulessp a 1 C 1dap 5 1, ni t nul se soitd me i rqur, 8 a. t .9) ey e d 3

3 3

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 35 of 74

i lh o i jbet trseneednf cr Prdcr,ur, 8Ca.t ni t ft ujcmat (e Idp net nr ouessp a3 1 h g s e 4 12) r eas ie ois rta oesbetse eaeo h Saeo 00 o bcuetmbde moehn n ujc(e Snt fte tt f C lkJnsspal C 1t 14)() ehrhrhv be peu iil a..oe,ur, 1 a.h 12,2 whtetee ae en rjdca 4
poeua ieuaiisi tepo eso sb tigtematrt teAt re rcdrlr g lr e n h rcs fu mit h te o h t ny r t n o

Geeao gteigsgaue o teiiaieptin(e C saspa3 nrlr ahr intrs n h ntt eio se ot,ur,7 n iv t Ca.h96,r3 whteasfiinnmbr f ai s ntrs a be 1t 8)o () ehr uf et u eo vl i aue hs en 4 c dg otie t qai tematro tebltse rsaa vEuspa3 Ca.d band o uly h t frh al (e Bonhn . ,ur, 1 l f e o 3
I tepelcinstn , e apo sdiiaiemesr h snt e be n h reeto et g whn rpoe nt t aue a o y t en i iv a otda saelw,h ofcapo nnso a iiit emesr wh itre e d pe s tt a te fiil rpo et f n nt i aue o nevn av o ap a a raprisi itrsaepo el ve da asrigtero r p er s el at n neet r rp r iwe s set hi wn e y n p ro arg t n itrs- u drat l l,eto 8o teCai ri esn lih a d neet n e rie lscin fh lona c f Co si o adteCaionasaue rlt gt iiaiepo o et- t ntmin n h l ri ttts eai o nt t rp nns o t f n iv po oea iiaiemesr adhv temesr sb te t tevoesfr rp s n nt t aue n ae h aue u mitd o h tr o iv

apoao rjcin Ipelcincssteof ilntt e rpnns prvlreet . n reet ae,h fcaiiai pooet o o i iv P ses dsicitrsi dfnigtepooe iiaiebcuehyae ossa i nineetn eedn h rp sdntt easte r t iv
atn t vn iaeter wnrgt n e terlvn Caionacntuin ln cig o idct hio ih u drh eeat lfri o si to a ad t sauoypoiin t hv terpo oe mesr - amesr te hv tttr rvso so aeh i rp sd aue aue hy ae sb t dt teAto ayGeea, aecruae frsg aueadhv te u mie o h lne nrlhv icltd o intr,n aeh t e cuiergtosb toteS ceayo Saea rsg aue hv b e x lsv ih t u mit h ertr f tt Ae intrs ae en c l ce = p toav to tep o l.Beas i tepelcincneth ol td u t oe fh epe cuen h reeto otx te e iiaiemesr h sn t enapo e adeatdit lw,h saesitrs nt t aue a o be p rv d n n ce no a te tt' neet iv i dfn igtev l i o a eatdsae1w d e ntcmeit pa.7 n eedn h ai t f n n ce tt a os o o no ly1 dy
1 Thsd e n t a ta saeofcascn o priiaei sc liain 7 i o s o men h ttt fiil an t at pt n uh ig t c t o

adtk a oio o whtetepelcincaln e a mei (e,.. n ae p sin n ehrh reet hl g hs r. See , t o e t g Sh tvY ugr 17) 1 l d9,3)Beas temesrhs oyt cmi . one (98 2 Ca. 0 9. cueh aue a nt e z 3
b e aotd h wee, u l ofcaswo l n t erpeet gtesaes en dpe , o vrp bi fiil ud ob ersni h tt' c n itrsi dfn igad l e atdlw. neetn ee dn uy nce a

3 4

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 36 of 74

On ea iiaiemesr hsbe apo e b terq ii v t o c n nt tv aue a en prv d y h eust oe f i e eetri a eeto , o vrtemesr bcme ad l eatd lcosn n lcin h wee,h aue eo s uy n ce cntmin lmed n o saue Atht on,ntea sn eo aso n o si o a a n met rttt. tap iti h bec f h wig t tatep riua iiaiei q eto wi dfeetal afcteofca h th at lrnt tv n u sin l ifrnil feth fiil c i l y po o et' wnpo et,iet o ohridvd al posse lg lih o rp nns o rp ry l ry r te n iiu l sesd e argt r b y lg l poetditrs,tiag al ls certa teofcapo o et eal rtce neeti s ruby es la hth fiilrp nns y p sesapro a lgl poetdsaei teiiaiesv l i tadfes oss esn le al rtce tk n h nt tv ' ai t ht ifr y i dy fo ta o ec idvdawh v tdfrtemesr o,n ed fo ta o te rm ht f ah n iiul o oe o h aue rid e,rm ht fh

polo tes ta awhl.Al og temat isbetoraoal epe fh t e s oe t uhh trsujct esnbe a h e

dbt, n ma q eto whte teocapo o et o ascesu iiitv eae o e y usin ehrh f il rp nns f u csflntaie mesr,n moeta lgsaoswh hv ito ue a dscesul auea y r hn eiltr o ae nrd cd n u csfl y sehre abltru htelgsaiepoescnpo el cam aydsic hp edd i ho g h e ilt rcs,a rpry li n it t l v n o p ro a lg l poetdsaei temesr o c iieatdit lw. r esn leal rtce tk n h aue n ets n ce no a y No ehls, swehvese ,h d cso so ticutn teCo rso n teesa a en te eiin fhs orad h ut f Ap elnpotlcincaln e t v trapo e iiaiemesrshv p ai seeto hlegs o oe-p rv d t t aue a e iv u ioml pr te teofcapo nnso a iiaiemesr t itree nfr y emitd h fiil rpo et f n nt t aue o nevn , iv o t ap a a raprisi itrs,odfn tevldt o tecaln e ro p er s el at n neett ee dh aiiy fh h l g d e e iiaiemesr.I tep seeto stn ,h ait o ofca iiaie nt t aue n h otlcin et g te bly f fiilnt t iv i i iv po o ett itreeo t apera araprisi itrshsnvrbe rp nnso nevn ro p a s el at n neet a e e en e cnign u o te rp nns dmo s aintater wnpro apo et, ot et p n h po o et' e nt t hth io esn l rp r n ro y l et,euain o oh ridvd al p sesd lg l petditrss i ry rp tto ,r te n iiu l osse,e al rtce neet b y y

wolb avreyo dfeetl afce b au iil eio ivlaigte ud e desl r i rnil fetd y jdcadcs nn ai t h f ay i dn iiaiemesr.(e,.. eiltrvEuspa 3 Ca.d1( iaie ntt aue Seeg, gsaue . ,ur, 1 l itt iv L 3 ni v mesr i oiglgsaieeml tadl t glgsaiebdelCi o auemp s eil v tr i s n i i eilt ugt; t f n t mi min v y SnaMo iavSe atspa 16C 1 p .t4 ( iaiemesrl t g at nc .tw r,ur,2 a. p4h 3 it t auei i A ni v min e ly n b pbioG ilat laigpbisrie.Panis aent mpomety u l fcas frevn ul evcq litfhv o c e c ) f
ctd a do rrsac h s o dslsd aydcso i whc teofca ie,n u eerh a n t icoe,n eiin n ih h fiil
3 5

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 37 of 74

po o eto a iiaiemesr weepelddfo itreigo apaig rp nns f n nt t aue r rcu e 'm nevnn r p ern iv r a raprisi itrsi ap seeto cs caln igtemesr'v ldt, s el at n neetn otlcin ae h l gn h aues aii e e y e e whnte ddn t a etetp o dsicp roa,eal poetditrs vn e hy i o h v h y e f it t esnllgl rtce neet n y

itesbet tr fh iiaiemesrtawolodnryspot nh ujcmat o tentt aueht ud rii upr e iv l

itreto o rap ryi itrssau o apriuaie itrsbss nevnin rel at n neettts n at lrzd neet ai. c lsedte hv be p r t dt p riiaea prisi sc liainsmpy nta,hy ae en emie o at pt s at n uh igto i l t c e t b vru o tersau a ofcapo o eto tecaln mesr. y ite fh i tts s fiil rp nns fh h l g d aue e Asarayn td ato g mot f u pircsshv n t a ocso t led oe ,l u h so o r ro ae ae o hd cain o h dsuso aay etesuc o teatoi posse b teofcapo o et ics r n lz h o re fh uhrt sesd y h fiilrp nns y o a iiaiet itreei apotlcincaln et dfn teiiaie f n nt t o nevn n seeto h leg o eed h nt t iv iv mesr tepo nnshv so srd o ecs - BuligIdsr Asn, aueh rpo et ae p noe, n ae i n n ut s. d y jpr, Ca.d81 - d e iu nt ticut u iom patc o p r tn ' a 41 1 0 osl miaehs o r' nfr rcie f emiig u 3 l s t ofca iiaiepo nnst priiaea p risi sc p seet ncss fiilnt t rpo et o at p t s at n uh otlci ae. iv c e o Ii i igId sr Asn,u a 41Ca.d81,h iseb fr tecut lBul n n ut s .spr, 1 0 te su eoeh or d y 3 cnendtevl i a dpo e itrrtt no ate rcnl e atd o cre h ai t n rprnepeai f hn eety nce dy o sauoypo iin- EvdneCo escin6 95- ta,mo gohrtig, tttr rvso iec d eto 6 . hta n te hn s pae teb re o po fo ayct,o ny o ct a dcu t ta ao tda lcd h udn f ro n n i cu t, r i n ony ht dpe n y y odn nel t gftr rsdnil e eo metoso i aypo edn riac i i uue eiet dvlp n t h w,n n rce ig min a caln igtev l i o teodnn etateodnn esncsayfrh h l gn h ai t fh riac,hth riac eesr o te e dy i

poet note( ncplyspbihah sft,r l r'(vdCoe rtci fh muiiai ') ul el ,aey owef e'E i. d, o t c t a j695sb .b) T eseicqetnbfr tecut s ehrh nw 6.,ud(). h pcf uso eoeh orwa whtete e i i
po iin- sit gt temu iiai teb re o po f ntiiservso hfi o h ncply h udn f ro o hssu n t apidt ago hcnrl riac tah dbe ao tdtru hteiiaie p l o rwt oto odnn eht a en dpe ho g h nt tv e i poeso whte tenwpo iinapido lt odnn e eatdb te rcs r ehrh e rvso p l ny o riacs n ce y h e lcleilt eb d oa lgsai oy. v

Ite ore ftoiinte oriB ii Idsy sn,ur,1 nh cuso i pno,h cutn uln nut As. pa4 s g r s
Ca.d8 0a desdalglru n av n e b a a cscra t sp ot l 1, drse ea ag met d a cd y n miu uieo u p r 3 3 6

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 38 of 74

tep st ntatesauecudn t rpryb itrrtdt apl t a h oio hth ttt o l o po el enepee o p y o n i odnneao tdtru hteiiaiepoes Th cutttd:t cs riac dpe ho g h nt t rcs. e o rsae s u iv Ami

(uie ..rushtet n695sbtnil i arteait otepol cr q .agetasci 6. u sat l mpi h bly fh epe a o ay s i
t e cs iiaiep web cuetepo o eto teiiaiewo l nthv o xrient tv o r eas h rp n ns fh nttv ud o ae i i a efciewa t dfn i Dept tefcta tect o cu t wo l h v a n fet y o eed t si h athth i r o ny ud ae v . e y dt t d fn teodnne act o cu t mih n t os wi vg riih s uy o eed h riac, i r o ny gt o d o t io ft a y h u dryn op st nt teodn ne Futemoetepo o et o te n elig p oio o h riac. rhr r,h rp n ns fh i iiaiehv n g aateo bigpemie t itreei teato, matr nt t ae o u rne f en r t d o nevn n h cin a te iv t whc idsrt n r wi tetilor (e Coe i.rc j 8. T i ih s icei ay t h racut Se d CvPo. 3 7 hs o h . . , ) agmet udhv meiiitret nwa u a albe Bu whnact o ru n wo l ae rtfnevni s nvi l. t e i r o a y cu t irq ie t dfn a iiaieodnn ea db cueo Evdn eCo e. o ny seurd o ee d n nt t riac n , eas f iec d iv scin6 95 muth udrh b re o po igrao alrlto si t eto 6 ., sso le te udn f rvn esnbe eainhp o p bih at,aeyo wefr, b lv tetilo ri motntne so l u l el sft r laewe ei e h racutn sisacs h ud c h e alw itret nb po o eto teiiaie Tofit d s ma wel ea lo nevni y rp nns fh nt tv. alo o o y lb n o i aueo dsrto .Pemit gitreto b teiiaiepo o etu dr b s f icein r ti nevnin y h nt t rp n ns n e n iv teecru tne wo l sret g adtepepesrg toeecs iiitv h s icmsa cs ud ev o ur h o l' ih t xrientaie

p we, r htamut eeluldfne b tecut. (1 1da o rai tht sb jaos eedd y h or ' 4 Ca. t g y s 3 p 82) .2 .
Al o g tipsaeiBuligIdsr Asn,u a 41Ca.d8 0 t u h hs asg n i n n ut s.spr, 1 1, h d y 3 wa drce atesei cnetaisei ta cs - iv ligteb re s ietd th p csc o tx tsu n ht ae n ovn h ud n sit gpo iino Evdn eCo escin6 95- i orve tep saei hfi rvso f iec d et 6 . n u iw h asg s n o po el u drto a moebo dyisrciei an mb ro rset. rp ry n eso d s r ral ntutv n u e fep cs Fittep saercg ie ta ato g p biofcasodnrl hv r ,h asg eo nzsht l u h u l fiil riai ae s h c y terso sblyo dfn igacaln e lw,nisacsi whc te h ep niii f eedn h l g d a i ntn e n ih h t e c aln e 1w hsb e ao tdtru hteiiaiepo esteeiarait hlegd a a en dpe ho g h nt t rcs hr s el i iv sc rs ta tepu l ofcasma n t eedteapo e iiaiemesr S t ik h th bi fiil y o d fn h p rvd nt tv aue h c i wi

vgr'( i igIdslAsn,ur, 1Ca.dap 82)T iehne rk io. Bul n nut s.spa4 1 t .2 . hs nacd i ' d y 3 s
3 7

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 39 of 74

iatiualt teu iu nmr adp poeo teiiaiep we, ihgv s s t b tbeo h nq e a e n u s fh nt t o rwhc ie r iv tep o lterg toao tno1w mesrstatereetdofcashv n t h epeh ih t dp it a aue hthi lce fiil ae o aotdad>a o no p s. d pe n y Ae p oe S cn ,h psa eepan tab cueo trrs ta p bi ofcas eo d te asg x lisht ea s fh ik h t u l fiil c ma n t eeda iiaiesv l i wi vg racuth udodnrl pr t y o dfn n nt t ' ai t t io, o rso l riai emi iv dy h y teofcapo o eto a iiaiemesr t itreei a ato h fiil rp n ns f n nt t aueo nevn n n cin iv caln igtev l i o temesr i odr g adtepepl'rg to hl gn h ai t fh aue n re o ur h o es ih t e dy t

eecsiiaie o r'( i igIdsyAs.spa4 Ca.dap 82) xrient t pwe. Bul n n ut sn,ur, 1 l t .2 . iv ' d r 3
Beas ofcaiiai -rp n nsaep r t dt itreei odrt c 'ue fiilnt t po o et r emit o nevn n re o i ve e sp e n teefrso p bi ofcaswh ma n t eedtemesr wi uplmeth fot f u l fiil o y o dfn h aue t c h vg riiapo raet ve tepo nnsa at gi a a ao o sad io,ts p rpit o iw h rpo et s ci n n nlg u n n cmpe naycpct t toep bioscasnmeya asrigtep o l' o lmetr aai o h s u l f il, a l s set h epes y c n

itrs(riohr rstes t'itrs itevl i o adl eatd neeto,n tewod,h t esneet nh ait f uy nce a ) dy lw. dbcueh psaecer sae taipemiigitret nb te a An easte asg lal ttsht lr tn nevni y h y l t o iiaie rp nns.. udsreogadte epes lht eecs ntt pooet .wol ev t ur h p ol'r to xri iv k e iiai p we'( i.ils de)iiaprntateof ilrp nnso nt te o r i d,t i add,tsp aethth fcapooet f iv ' b ac i
teiiaieaep rii t go bh lo tepo l'itrs,n n toeyo h nt t r at pai n eaf fh epesneetad o sll n iv c n bh lo tepo o et' wnp ro aitrs. eaf fh rp nso esnlneet Thr, otayt panif' o tnintat n meo sdcso s id cnrr o litfscneto hthe u ru eiin pr tigiiaiepo nnst itreeo t ap a a rapat si itrs emit nt t rpo et o nevn ro p er sel ri n neet n iv e ipotlcinliaincaln iga iiit emesr smpyrfet n seeto igto h l gn n nt i aue i l elc t e av

u ftrddsrt nrjdmetifvr fh pooet'atiainte nete icei ay ug nsn ao ote rpnnspript ,h e o c o

pasg i BuligId sr Asn,u a 4 Ca.d8 0 sae t t knwh n sae n i n n ut s.spr, 1 1 1,ttshae e e d y 3 p biofcasaedfn igac aln e iiaieipedn lt ain h til u l fiil r eedn h l gd nt t n n ig ii to ,se ra c e iv g t cutnmotisa csso l alw itret nb po o et o teiiit e' ori s ntne h ud l nevni y rp n ns fh nt i ' o o av

lLap82,n tat fit d s ma wel ea aueo dsrt n' i t .2 )adhtfj alo o o y lb n b s f icei . 6 lo o' ( i BeasBuligIdsrA s.niaetai motntne iwol I d) cue i n nut snidctshtn sisacst ud b d y
3 8

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 40 of 74

b a aueo dsrto fracutopeld itreto b teofca e n b s f icein o o rt rcu enevnin y h fiil iiaiepo o et ee i isacsi whc tenme g vrmet eedns nt t rp nns v n n ntn e n ih h a d o en n dfn at iv aedfn igtemesr,no r iwteecnb n q et nb thtiwo l r eedn h auei u ve hr a e o u si u ta t ud o b a aueo dsrto fracutopeld teofcapo o etfo e n b s f icein o o rt rcu eh fiil rp nnsrm itre igt d fn acaln e iiitv mesr wh ntenme gv mmet nevnn o ee d hl g d ntaie aue e h a d o e n e dfn athv dcie t dfn teiiaiemesr.l telt rstigte eedns ae el d o ee dh nt tv aue n h at et ,h n i e n ofcapo o et'blyt itreeidsual incsayog adte fiil rp nns ait o nevn n ip tby s eesr l ur h i t

pol'r ht eecs iiaiepwe. (bd) epesi to xri ntt o r'Ii. g e iv '

Panif ag etatep saei BuligId sr Asn,u a 41 lit s ru h th asg n i n n uty s.spr, f d Ca.d80 wehv b e aay igso l po el b cniee dcu ad l 1, ae en nlzn h ud rpry e o sdrd itm n 3 so l nt efl we .Panif ap rnl rl o tefcteein idcto h ud o b ol d litfs p aet ey n h athr s o n iain o y iteBuligId sr Asn dcso tateofcapo o etwh h d n h i n n uty s. eiin h th fiil rp nns o a d so srdteiiaieodnn eaisei ta cs hdsu h adb e dne p noe h nt t riac tsu n ht ae a o g t n en e id iv terg toitreei teu dryn at ncaln igteodnne h ih t nevn n h n elig ci h l gn h riac. o e Po o ettk isewi plitfsc aatrzto o tip saea dcu rp nnsae su t anif' hrceiain fhs asg s itm, h p it gothth p saeepliysae ta teag met d acdb te oni u tate asg x i t ttshth ru n av ne y h n cl a cscra - ta i,ht vdneCo escin6 95cudnt miu uie h tsta E iec d eto 6 . o l o cnttt nl b itprtdt apyt odn ne e atdtru hteiiaie o si i al e ne ee o p l o ria cs nce ho g h nt t uo y iv poesb cuesc apiainwo l sbtnil i arh iiaiepoes rcs eas u h p l to ud u satal mpitent t rcs c y iv
-

olhv meiiitretnwa uaalbe'(1Ca.dap 82) l ud ae r fnevni s nvi l. 4 1 t .2 . w t o a ' 3

Po o etmanantatisae n dmo srtsta tedsuso o te rp nns iti hths ttmet e ntae hth icsin fh aii o ofcaiiit epo nnst itre ei sc ato swa esnilo bly f fiilnt i rpoet o nevn n uh cin s setat t av tecutscnlso ta tesauecudc ntuin l b apidt h o r' ocuin hth ttt o l o si to al e p l o t y e odnn e eatdtru hteiiaiepo es riacs nce ho g h ntt rcs. iv I o r iw,h r in n e t dcd whte tep saeiBulig n u ve tees o ed o eie eh rh asg n i n d Id sr Asn ipo el cniee ah ligo dcu bcuei aye et n ut s.s rp ry osdrd odn r itm, eas n n vn we y b lv tatep sa eacrtl dsrbsa lato efn a nab sso ti ei e hth asg cuaey ecie tes n udmetl ai fhs e
3 9

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 41 of 74

cutsu iom patc o pr tigteofcapoo eto a iiaiet or' nfr rcie f emit h fiil rpn ns f n nt t o n iv itre eo t apa a raprisi itrsi csscaln igtev l iyo nevn ro p er sel at n neetn ae h l gn h ai t f e e d av trqpo diiaiemesr.Th sae n iBuligId sr Asnta oe-p rve nt t aue e ttmetn i n n ut s .ht iv d y p r tn itret nb sc po o etsre t gadtrpepl'rg to emit g nevni y uh rp n ns evso ur h o es ih t i o eecs teiiit ep we fn ssp otnn meo scssi whc ofca x rieh t i o rid u p ri u ru ae n ih fiil av iiitv po o et av ne mayo temotsbtnileatere ta ntaie rp nns d a cd n fh s u satalg lh oisht weerie i sp ot fh caln e mesr adweedsusdi ti r asd n u p ro te h l gd aue n r icse n hs e

cut o iin (e,..Srusspa4 C 1t 344 549Hoe or' pno. See ,tas,ur,6 a.h 6,6-6; tl s g 4
Emply e Upo ,u a 21Ca.t 55 6 561; s,u a 1 Ca.t oes in spr, l h 8 , 0- 2 Amwetspr, 1 l h 4 4

14,2 616; afr lsC .. umeinspa4 Ca.d85898 1 23 15-25 C l m n. ovDek ja ,ur,8 l 0 ,1-2 , a 3 . seas Cteso Jb tteE oo yvCon o ag,ur,4 e lo iznfr osth cnm . ut fornespa 9 i y C l p .t 11,3612 ; mmui Hel As.. or o uevsr, a. p4h 3 111-33Co nt at snvB ad fsp ri s A y h o spa 16C 1 p3 909 193)T eedcsos ihih tedfeet ur,4 a. .d 9,9-9. hs eiin hgl th i rn Ap g f
p rp cie rgrigtev l i o po e itrrtt no av trapo e eset s eadn h ai t r rp rnepeai f oe-p rv d v dy o iiaiemesr otnh l b teof ilrp n nso teiiaiemesr nt t aue fe ed y h fi apo o et fh nt tv aue iv c i adb tev trwh eatdtemesl it lw,scnrse wi toehl n y h oes o n ce h ate no a a otatd t h s ed r h b teeetdofcaswh odn rl dfn caln e saelwsa d y h lce fiil o riai eed h l gd tt a ,n y e dmo srt ta terlpa e b tepo o eti sc liainicmpaal e ntaeh th oe lyd y h rp nnsn u h igto s o rbe t t terl odnrl pae b teAton yGe eao ohr u i ofcasi o h oe riai lyd y h tre nrlr tep bl fiil n y c vg rul d fn igad l eatdsae1w a driigalru belg l ioo sy eedn uy n ce tt a n asn lag al ea tere u nwhc acaln e po iinma b ssand h ois po ih h l g d rvso y e utie . e Th eprec o Caionacuti rve n caln e t v tr e x eine f l ri o rsn e iwig hl g so oef e apo e iiaiemesrso e mayy ash sece tap r tigte prv d nt tv aue vr n ertu tah sht emi n h i t ofcapo o eto a iiaiet priiaea p risi p seet ncss fiil rp nns f n nt t o at pt s at n otlci ae, iv c e o ee whnp bi ofcasaeas dfn igteiiaiemesr, f ni vn e u lc fiil r lo eedn h nt t aue ot s iv e esniloesr tateitrssadprp cieo tev tr wh apo e set t nuehth neet n esetv fh oes o p rv d a temesr aen t o siul o u cnco sysb riae t ohr u l h aue r o cnco sy r n o siul u odntd o tep bi c
4 0

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 42 of 74

itrsstama b c a il db eetdofcasadta a1 ibelg l neet ht y e hmpoi y lce fiil,n ht lva l ea e ag meti fv ro teiiaiesv l i aebo gtotecutsatnin ru nsn ao fh nt t ' ai t r ru h t h o r' teto . iv dy Al o g telglru nsav ne b teofcapo o eto a iiaie t u h h ea ag met d a cd y h fiilrp nns f n nt t h iv aen t l y tesrn et rmot esaieag metrgrigtev l i o r o awash to gso sp ru sv ru ns eadn h ai t r dy po e itrrtt no teiiaiemesr ta aebo gtoacut rprnepeai fh nt t aueh tr ru h t o r' o iv s atnin p sdcso dmo srt tei otn eo afrigsc po o et t to , at eiins e ntaeh mp rac f fodn uh rp nns e teop ru i t priiaeao gwi eetdofcasi asrigtesaes h p otnt o at p t,ln t lce fiil,n set h tt' y c h n itrsi tev l i o acaln e iiaiemesr.S c priiainb neetn h ai t f h l g d nttv aue uh at p t y dy e i c o teofca iiaiepo nnsehn e bt tesbtniefi esad h fiilnt t rpo et n acs oh h u sat ar s n iv v n

cmpeees fh jdcaeaut no teiiaies aii adte o ltnso teu iilvlai fh ntt 'vl t n h o i v dy apaac opoeuafi eshts set lf cuteiinajdct g p erne frcdrlar staiesni ia ordcso duiai n a n
tevldt o avtrapo e iiaiemesr it b p rev da lgt t h aii f oe-p rv d nt t aueso e ecie se imae y iv i b teiiit essp otr. y h ntai ' up res v Moevrato g o rp sdcso s a ent a ocso t dsuso ro e,l u h u at eiin h v o h d cain o ic s r h ietf teseiisuc o teatoi p sesdb teotcapo o eto dniy h pcfc o re fh uh ry osse y h f il rp nns f t i a iiaiemesr t asrtesaesitrsi teiiaiesvldt, n nt t aueo seth tt' neetn h nt t ' aii we iv iv y cn ld t ttlatntoecru tn e i whc tegv rmet f il o cu ehaa esi h s icmsacsn ih h o en n ofcas wh odnrl dfn ac aln e saueo cnttto aa n met ae o riai eed hl gd ttt r o si in lme d n hv y e u d cie t po iesc adfneo t ap a alwe cut eiinsrkn el d o rvd u h ees ro p el o r ordcso tiig n d wntemesr,h atoi o teofcapo o eto teiiaiet asr o h auete uh rt fh fiil rp nns fh nt t o set y iv tesaesitrsi tev ldt o teiiitv ipoel u drto a aiig h tt' neetn h aii fh ntaies rp ry n eso d s rsn y oto at l1,eto 8o teCaionaCo si to a dtepo iin o te u f ri e 1scin fh l ri ntuin n h rvso s fh c f t Elcin Co erlt gt terl o iiaiepo o et.Th iiaiep we eto s d eai o h oe fnt t rp nns e nt tv o r n iv i wo l b sg icnl i ie iteeween o et asrtesaesitrsi ud e inf at mpard fh r r o n o seth tt' neetn i y tev l i o temesr whneetdofcasdciet d fn ii cut ro h ai t fh aue e lce fiil el o ee dtn oro t dy n

4 1

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 43 of 74

apaaug n ivl aigtemesr. Une atlI,et n8adte pel jdmetnai t h auel drrcelsci n h dn 8 i o
Elcin Co et otcapo o eto a iiaiemesr h v au iu eto s d ,he fiil rp nns f n nt tv aue a e nq e i rlt nhpt tev trapo e mesr ta mae te ep cal l eyt b eai si o h oe-p rv d aueh t kshm seil i l o e o yk rlbeadvg ru av ctsfrtemesr adt b s ve db toe ei l n ioo s d oae o h aue n o e o iwe y h s a wh s v tsscrdteiiaieseat n it lw.As hv se,h oe oe eue h nt t ' ncmetno a iv we ae en te Leiltr h srcg ie tel q erlpae b ofcapo o eti t gsaue a eo nzd h miu oe ly d y fiil rp nnsn he iiaiepoese o idi atl1,eto 8 b eat gn meo s nt t rcs mb de n ri e Iscin ,y nci u ru iv c n po iin paigu o tepoo ettedrcrso sblyt maaead rvso s lcn p n h rp nnsh ietep n iit o n g n i cnrlh b l tq ai igadp tinfigpoesa wel satoiig oto te al -u lyn n eio -in rcs,s la uh rzn o f t l

fooettcnrlh agmetif o otenttehtpernte rpnnso ot te ru nsna r fh iiav taapai h o v ii

of iloe ifr tng iepbi e b teSceayo Sae (e,.. fcavtrnomai ud ulhd y h ertr f tt. Seeg, i o s Ee. d,j90 ,6890,02 96 ,05sb .d,0990.T u, lcCoej 6790 ,6993,0496,u d()96,6 1) h s
rgrls o teiiit esefco terpro a adp riuaie lg l e ades fh nt i ' fet n h i esn ln at lrzd eal av c y poetditrssteofcapo o et aetemotlgcln apo rae rtce neet,h fiil rp nns r h s o iaad p rpit

1 Plitfsp itothth ivldto o Prp sto 8iteu dryig 8 anif on u ta ten aiain f o oi n n h n el n i fdrligto ddn teutrm ayat no iato b teGo ro o eea liain i o rslfo n ci rn cin y h ven r r t o At re Ge eab tfo adcso b tefdrl itito ratr cnetd t n y nrl u rm eiin y h eea dsrc cutfe a o tse o til Oriai ,o vrp bi ofcas aedfn igasae1w aant ra. dnrl hwee, u l fiilwh r ee dn tt a g isa y c t a ap l t cut Id e,rm teote o tefdrl itit or o n p el e or. n ed fo h ust fh eea dsrc cut a poedn si teu dryn cs,h dsrc cuttefe h szdi rceig n h n elig aete itit o ri l mp aie t s s epcainta i dcso wo l cntueo l tefrttg o poedn s x etto h tt eiin ud osi t ny h issae f rceig s t tawo l la t a ap l t cut eemiaino tesg icn cntt o a ht ud ed o n p el e o rdtr nto fh inf at o si nl a i mi q eto a isei tepoedn .Th iait o teofcapo o eto a usin tsu n h rceig enbly fh fiil rp n ns f n i

cnt inlhlnecnb epce tapaa avretacutu g n osmt acal g a e x etdo p eln des rlorjdmet io e i

iiaiemesr t apaar lorjdmetn aiaigtemesr, e ntt aueo pel ti cutug nivl t h auewhn iv a dn
tep bi ofcaswh odnrl wo l flsc a ap adciet d s, h u lc fiil o riai ud i uh n p el el o o o y e n wol sg icnl u emiet iiaiep we. ud int at ndr n hent t o r s y iv

4 2

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 44 of 74

coc t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o teiiaiemesr of h ie o seth tt' neetn h ai t ' h nt t aue r dy f iv bh lo teeetrwh v tdi fv ro temesr.g eaf fh lcos o oe n ao fh auel Acodn l, cn ld tawh ntep bi ofcaswh odn rl crigy we o cu eht e h u lc fiil o riai y d fn acaln e mesr dciet d s,rill,eto 8o teCaio a eed h l g d aue el o o o at e Iscin fh l mi e n c f Co si to adteapia lpo iin o teElcin Co eatoiete ntuin n h p l be rvso s fh eto s d uh rz h t c ofcapo o eto a iiaiemesr t itreeo t priiaea ra fiilrp nns f n nt t aue o nevn ro at pt s el iv c

prisnitrsi auiilrceigt asrtett'itrsite at i neetn jdcapoedn o seth saesneetn h e iiaies aii adtapaau g nivl aigtemesr. ntt 'vl t n o pel jdmetnai t h aue i v dy dn B.PanisObet n t OfcaIiaieP oo et' toi t litf' jci so f ilnt t rp nnsAuh rt o f o i iv y
Panisavneanmbr f bet n t adtr nt ntate litf dac u eo ojci so eemiai hth f o o

AsetteStt'Itrsi teVaiiyo aVoe-pp o e l taie sr h aes neetn h l t f tra rv d niit d v

ofcapo o eto a iiaieaeatoie t asrtesaesitrsi te fiilrp n ns f n nt t r uh rzd o seth tt' neetn h iv v l i o av trapoe iiaiewhntep biofcas oodnrl ai t f oe-p rv d nt t e h u l fiilwh riai dy iv c y d fn acaln e sae1w dciet d s.Fo terao sdsusdblw, eed hl gd tt a el o o o rh esn icse eo e n

wecnld tann oteojcin hs r. ocueht oe fh bet s a mei o t

1 . Plitfsiial rl u o tepo iin o teCaionaCo si to anif nt l ey p n h rvso s fh lfri ntuin iy t stigfrhteatoi a do l aino teGoen radteAt re Geea et ot h uh rt n bi t fh vro n h t ny nrl n y go o

1 Bes teNit Cicihsak du t dtr n ol wh te te 9 cue h nh rut a se so eemie ny eh rh ofcapoo et o a iiaiemesr hv atoi 'n e Caiona1wt fiil rp n ns f n nt t aue ae uh rt u dr l ri a o iv y f asrtesaesitrsi tevl i o a iiit ewhntep biofcas seth tt' neetn h ai t f n nt i e h u l fiil dy av c wh odnrl d fn temesr dciet d s, h v n o cso t o riai eed h aue el o o o we a e o cain o y n a desteh p t t a q eto wh te i acs i whc p bi ofcashv d rs h y ohei l usin ehrn aen ih u lc fiil ae c d cie t d fn temesr adteofca iiaiepo o et aen t el d o eed h aue n h fiilnt tv rp n ns r o n i a albeo d n tekt asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o temesr, v i l r o o se o seth tt' neetn h ai t fh aue a dy oh ridviu lo etiswo l b etldt itreeitepoedn t te n i d as r nie ud e nie o nevn n h rce ig o t t asrtesaesitrsi tevldt o teiiitv .Weepesn o iino seth tt' neetn h aii fh ntaie y x rs o pno n ta q eto . ht usin

4 3

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 45 of 74

wi rgr tteefre n otelw(a. nt atV, j1 1)0n t ead oh nocmet fh a C 1Cos. r. j ,3, ad h , 2

u o teCaionasauoypo iin d sg aigteAt re Ge ea'rl i p n h lfri tttr rvso s ein t h t ny nrls oen n o

cptcin aanth sae ( vCoej 15 1152 C d CvPo. orat s giste tt.Go. d,j 2 1,2 1; o e i.rc, o j921)1Pa tfmanantateecntuinln s mtr poios 0 .. liis iti hths ostt aad t oy rvs n 2 nf i o a i
mentateAt r yGeea iteo l pro wh cnasrtesaes a h th t ne nrlsh ny esn o a seth tt' o itrsi dfn igacaln e 1w a dpeld iiaiepo o et'o neetn eedn h l g d a n rcu ent t rp nnsf m e iv r asrigt saesitrsi tevldt o acaln e lw.Plitfiss set he tt' neetn h aii f hlegd a ani snit n y f tawhnteAt re Geea dcie t po iesc adfnetesl h t e h t ny n rl el so rvd u h ees,h oe o n

rmeyo toe oojct teAt re Geea'at nitth blt o . e d fhswh betoh tny nrls ci s te al bx' o o a o '
Th cntuin ln sauoypo iin t whc panifp it e o si to a ad tttr rvso so ih litfs on t

etbi taiauiilrceigiwhc tevli o asaelwi salhhtn jdcapoedn n ihh ait f tt a s s dy

caln e,h saesitrsi tetev l i o telw iodnrl asre h l gd te tt' neetn h h ai t fh a s riai setd e dy y b tesaeAtonyGeea.Ths cnttto a adsauoypo iin, y h tt tre nrl ee o si inl n tttr rvsos u h we e, aenv r enitrrtdt mentateAtonyGeea ite o vrhv ee b e nepee o a hth tre n rlsh

2 AfceV,et n1o teCai riCo si t npo ie i 11 l' 0 tl sci fh lona ntui rvdsn 1 h i o f to :- e f spe e euiepo ro tiSaeiv se i t Go en r T eGo en r u rme xct we fhs tt s etd n he v ro. h vro v sale tate1w ifi ul eeue . h lsehth a sat l xctd' hf y ' ArilV,eto 1 o teCaionaCo si o po ie i rlvn t e scin 3 fh lfri ntt n rvd sn eeat c mi pr:tujctte o raddts fh GoenrteAt re Geea at betoh pwesn ui o te vro,h l ny nrl s e o sal etec ifa ofcro teSae lsal etedt o teAtony h lb h he 1w fie fh tt. th lb h uy fh tre Geeat setatelwso teSaeaeuioml adaeutl efre. n rlo e hth a fh tt r nfr y n d q aey nocd' ' 2 Go en n Co escin151 po ie i rlvn pr:SneAtony 1 vrmet d eto 2 1 rvdsn eeat at h tre l Geeah scag ,satre, fa1ea matri whc t Saeiitrse n rl a hrea t n y o llgl t sn ih he tt sneetd o e 5 : Go ea n Co e scin15 2poie;t'eAton yGeeasal vnmet d ,eto 2 1 rvds lh tre nrlh l f atn teS pe Co radpoeueo d fn a1a sst whc teSaeo t d h u rme utn rsct r eed 1cue o ih h tt,r e aySaeofcriapryi hso hrofca cp ct ' n tt fie s at n i r e fiila ai ' y. Co eo CiiPoeue scin9 21atoie teAtonyGeeat d f vl rcd r,eto 0 . uh rzsh tre nrlo itreeadpriiaei ayap ai aypoedn i whc asaesaue nevn n at pt n n p eln n rceig n ih tt ttt c o rg lt nh sbe dcae u cnttt n l yacut reuai a en elrd n o siui a b o r. o o
4 4

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 46 of 74

o lp ro o etytama asrtesaesitrsi tevldt o asae ny esn r ni ht y seth tt' neetn h aii f tt t y 1w i apoedn i whc telw'v l i ia ise a n rceig n ih h a s ai t s tsu . dy Th Saeo Caiona o cus,scmp sdo trebace o e tt f l ri, f o rei o oe fhe rnh s f f g vrmetaget u e o eetdadap itdp bi ofcasadmyid o en n, ran mb r f lce n p one u lc fiil,n ra saeadlcl gnisb ad,n p bi etis I mayisa cste tt n oa ae ce, orsad u l nie. n n ntne h c t isrs o t o mod u l of ilo etis ycnl tn gv r et neet fwo r r p bi fcas r nie ma o tc ad ie i o s c i t i s dfeigofcave a t tev l i o po e itprtto o acaln e ifrn fiil iws so h ai t r rprne eain f hlegd dy saelw.I sc isacsiin t n o nfrdfeet fcaso etis tt a n uh ntn e,ts o u cmmo o ifrn ot il r nie i t

t apai auiilrceiga dsnt atsn t b rpeetdb o pern jdcapoedn s iicpre ado eersne y t i
sprt u slec ofca o etypeetn i o prpcieo te eaae o ne,ah fiil r ni rsnig t wn eset fh t s v saesitrswi rgr t tecntuinlh l n eo po oe tt' neet t e ad o h o si toa cal g r rp sd h t e itrrtto a isei tecs. nepeain tsu n h ae Th cs o Amwetspr,1 Ca.t 14 ,rvdsa atiutain.I e ae f s,u a 1 l h 2 3 po ie n p l srto n 4 l Amwetsot atrh v tr apo e Prp st n13- abodisrne s,h rl fe te oes p rv d o oio 0 y i ra nua c rfr iiaiemesr ta,mo goh rhn srq ie arl ako eom httv auehta n te tig,eurd ol c f i b isrn erts- tepanifisrrfe aptt nfrwrt fmadt i nuac ae h litf nue i d eio o io n aen l i sp ro cutalgn taapiaino tertrl akpo iin o u eir or,l ig ht p l to fh ae ol c rvsos f e c b Po oio 13t srt isrrwo l voaetecntuin lihso sc rp st n 0 o uey nues ud ilt h o si t arg t fu h i to isrr.T ep tinnme teGo earteAt re Ge ea,h SaeBor nues h eio a d h vno,h t ny nrlte tt ad t o o Eqaiain adtelsrn eCo sinra d fn at.Whlte f ul to ,n h nuac mmiso e s eedns i h z e poedn wa p n igi sp ro cutteLeiltr eatdasauerceig s e dn n u eir or,h gsaue n ce ttt IsrneCo escin16115- tap rotdt ee tueyisrr fo nuac d eto 8 .3 ht up re o xmp srt nues rm tert rl akpoiin o Pooio 13 T evldt o t n wsaue h ae ol c rvso s f rp st n 0 . h aii fhe e ttt b i y wa cle it q et niteAmwet rceig bcus teewa adsue s ald no u si n h o spoedn , ea ehr s ip t whte tesauewa acntuin l i emisbeatmp t rvs ehrh ttt s o si t al mpr sil te to e ie to y

Pooio 13wi otumiigtervs nt a oeote epeseCa. rp sin 0 t u sb tn h eii o vt fh pol(e l t h t o Cos.atl, 1,ud()o isedwhtetesauefr ee te ups nt r.lj 0sb .c) rnta ehrh ttt ut rdh proe , h
4 5

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 47 of 74

o Po oio 13adtu wa p r silu drh epiitr o f rp sin 0 n h s s emi be n e te x l tems f t s c

Pooio 13ief (e A etsp aap 14 . rpstn 0 t l.Se mw s,ur,t .27) i s

Al o g Amwetso eo temayCaionacssctdao e i t u h si n fh n l ri ae,i b v ,n h f e whc a iiaiepo o et s emie i itre ea afr l at adt ih n nt t rp nn wa pr t d o nevn s omap r n o iv t y

apaa avre eiin(e a t,tp 2-1, sias acs iwhc peln d es dcso se neap .93)Amwets lo aen ih
ten me gv rmet eednste ev sto cnlcigp sto srg rig h a d o en n dfn at h msle o k ofitn oiin eadn tevldt o tenw saue l tacs,h Go enrteAt re Geea, h aii fh e ttt. n ht aete vro,h t ny n rl y o adteSaeBor o Eq aiain- alersne b teAt re Geea n h tt ad f u l t z o 1rpeetd y h t ny n rl o manandtatenw sauewa cnt inl v l .Bycnrs,h itie hth e ttt s o si o al ai mt y d o tatte Isrn eCo sinr rpeetdb spaaecu sl to tepoiin nuac mmisoe - ersne y e rt one- o k h sto ta tenw sa eddn tute tep roeo Po oio 13adwa iv ld h th e tmt i o frhrh up s f rp st n 0 n sn ai. i

(e A s,u a 1 Ca.t ap 15,n 8)Alog smeo te Se mwetspr, 1 1 h t .2 1f.. t uh o fh 4 h gvmmet eednsnA etteGoen rteAt re Geeaadte oe n dfnati mw s( vro,h tny nrln h h o SaeBor o E ulain weedfnigtevl i o tenwsauoy tt ad f qai t ) r eedn h ait fh e tttr zo dy
mesr a otdb teL gs mr wh ra iermann g vrmet eedn aue d pe y h eil e eesh e iig o en n dfn at a

( eIsrneCo sinrwadfnigteitgi o te oe-prvd t nuac mmisoe) s eedn h nery fh vtrapoe h t

iiaiemesr,ahg vrmet eedn cudacrtl b d sr e a nt t aueec o en n d fn at o l cuaey e eci d s iv b asrigtesaesitrsi tev l i adpo rapiaina d set h tt' neetn h ai t n rpe p l to n n dy c itrrtto o ad l eatdsaelw.I t t rceig teAt re nepeain f uy n ce tt a n hapo edn ,h t ny o Ge eawa n th sl o ecuierpeettv o tesaesitrsi te nrl s o te oe r xlsv ersnaie fh tt' neetn h v l i adpo ritmrtt no ad l eatdsaesaue ai t n rpe ne eai f uy n ce tt ttt. dy o As siutae,ts adyu cmmo fr u l ofcaso etis Amwetl srtsiih rl n o n o p bi fiil r nie l c t t tk dfeeteap st n wi rgr t tev l i o po ritrrtto o a e ifrn lg l oio s t ead o h ai t r rpe nepeain i h dy

o acalne s tl (e,..I r MaraeC sssp a4 Ca.h7 7 f hl gd tea Seeg,n e ri ae,ur, 3 lt 5 e a w. g 4 (rp21 LgsauevE ,ur,4Ca.d4 250(rp 10; dr Po .2; eiltr . usp a5 1 9 ,0 lo.4 1Amao 3 i VlyJ it no ff/ShDi..tt#to qai tn(982 C 1 d al on U in f o c. s vSae : fE ulai 17) 2 a. e y t 1 zo 3 28(rp 12 0 Po.3. )
4 6

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 48 of 74

Moevre e wh nteein i e acnlco itrsn radfeec ro e,vn e h r s et r o fit fneet o ifrn e h o o iina n teg vrmet fiilo etis a di teliain i f pno mog h o en n ofcas r nie n me n h igto ,n t t toeisacsi whc teAt re Geeao aohrp bi of il el e t h s ntn e n ih h t ny nrl r n te u lc fi ad ci so o c n d fn asaesaueo cntuin l rvso i acut rceigbcueo eed tt ttt r o si to apo iin n o rpoedn eas f t ta ofca've tatecaln e po iiniu chtuin lohr u lc ht fiils iw hth h l g d rvso s n o si to a,tep bi e t ofcaso etisrpeetdb sprt cu slhv b e p r t dt asr fiil r nie,ersne y eaae o ne,ae en emit o set t e

tes t'itrsi dfnigtecalne lw.(e,..C nelvSae h tesneetn eedn h hl gda Seeg, onr .tt a e y PesneB .spa 3 Ca.h16 , 14)Pr tn ohr fcasopeet ronl d,ur,7 1t 19 17. emiig te oG ilt rsn 4 t
lglru nsi d fneo acaln e sae1wwh nteAton yGeea ea ag met n ee s f h l gd tt a e h tre n rl e h sdcie t d s d e n t a tateAtonyGeeahsvoae hso a el d o o o o s o men hth tre n rl a iltd i r n h rdt o atdi rp ryi dciigt d fn telw.Evnwh nte e uy r ce mpo el n el n o eed h a e e h n At re Geeah jdsrt nt d ciet d fn acaln e lw o t apa t ny nrl a icei o el o eed h l g d a ro p el o o n e alwe cut l givldt gtelw,h AtonyGe ea'dcso t o r ornln n aiai h a te tre nrls eiin o i n eecs dsrto i ta fsind e n t rcu eoh rofcaso etisfo x rie icein n htaho os o peld te fiil r nie rm t

dfn igtecalne lwo apaiga avreug n.Alog te eedn h hl gd a r pel n desjdmet t uh h e n h At re Geea'lglug nma apor tlgieht fca'o tny nrl eajdmet y p rpiey ud taof il wn o s a i s
dsrtoayato stevl i o po e itrrtto o acaln e sae iceinr cin,h ai t r rp rnepeain f h l gd tt dy e cntuinl rvso o sauei, f o reut tl amatrt b o si to apo iin r ttt so cus,lmaey te o e t i

dtr ndb tecut nth At re Geea.( .eg, oke vCi ad eemie yh or,ote t ny nrl Cf ..L cyr . t n s o , y Cof/ o a Frni o2 0) 3Ca4h15. We r a r on cs ta z . fs n ac c (04 3 lt 05) ae wae f o aeht ny s .
h s edo sg etdta teAton yGe eama peld oh r fo a h l ru g se h th tre nrl y rcu e tes rm

dfnigacalne st1wofo apaigaug nivlaigte eedn hl gdtea rrm pel jdmetnai t h e a n dn

lw whnteAt re Geea hsdcie t po iesc ad fneo tk a a e h t ny nrl a el d o rvd uh ees ra n o n 2PC 2 P Y'2 2 2 Plitfs rlac o teCo ro Ap a'rln i Beke v anif'ein e n h ut f pels uig n cly . (ontcniudOnxpg) t toeot e n etae b n

Sh reegrSp.,00NoC052)smmai dniga eio fr cwaznge (et12 1, . 690,u rl eyn ptin o y t

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 49 of 74

Th stecntuinl n sauoypo iin rlt gt teAtony u,h o si to a ad tttr rvso seai oh tre t n Geea'atoi adrso sblis on t rcu eohr fo asrigte n rls uh rt n ep niit d o peld tesrm set h y i n saesitrsi tev l i o acaln e lw. tt' neetn h ai t f h l g d a dy e
Plitfs et ru taap aigi cutoasrtesaesitrsi anifn x ag e ht p ern n o rt seth tt' neetn

te aii o acalne lwo tapaau g nivl aigtelwi h vl t f hl gd a ro pel jdmetnai t h a s dy e dn

ecuieya eeuiebac fnto .Bea s teatoi t po oea d x lsv l n x ct rn h ucin cueh uh rt o rp s n v y a otsaecntuinaa n meto saue e o idi teiiit e d p tt o si t l med ns r ttts mb de n h ntai to v

polin o teCai riCosi iniesnil algsaieatoi (e, rvsos fh lona nt o s set l eilt uhry se f mt ay v t eg, rfsinl n ier iCafriGoen nvKe po (07 4 ..PoesoaE gnesn lona vrmet. m tn 2 0) 0 Ca.h1 1,08A LCOvE (94 3 C 1 d677 5,litf lt 06 13; F -I . u 18) 6 a. 8, 1)panis 4 3 f
mananta iwo l voaetesprt no p wesd crn t pr th iti htt ud ilt h eaai f o r otieo emite o ofcapo o et o a iiaiet asrtesaesitrsi d fn iga fiil rp nns f n nt t o seth tt' neetn ee dn iv caln e mesr. h l gd aue e P satoi , o v rd e n tu p rpanif'li ta ap aiga atuhrt h wee, os o. p ot litfscam htp ern s y s ap ryi cutoasrtesaesitrsi tevaii o acaln e lw i at n o rt seth tt' neetn h ldt f hl gd a s y e

ecuieya eeuiefnt n I1 vC ah (93 42U.. 1 xlsvl n xct uci .nNS . hda 18) 6 S99 v o (hda,o ea l,h UntdSae Spe Corsae e ht al: C ah)fr xmpete i tts urme utttd mp ai l e cy
C hv ln hl taCo gesitepo e p ryt dfn tev l i o a C ae o g ed ht n rs sh rp r at o eed h ai t f We dy (ontcni eho peisae f toeotud' rvupg) o n m o wrt fmadt ta su h t cmp lh Go en radteAt re Geeat io n aeht o g to o ete vro n h t ny n rlo o fl n t e o ap a fo tefdrl itit o r'dcso iPer i ie oi s f p elrm h eeadsrccuts eiin n ry s c mipae.T eq eto whte teGo en ro teAtonyGeea hs slcd h usin ehrh vro rh tre n rl a dsrto t d ciet dfn acaln e lw o t ap aalwe cutuig icein o el o ee d hl gd a ro p el o r o rrl n e n ivl aigtelw ittl dsicfo teisewhte smeohrofca o n ai tn h a soal it trm h su ehr o te fiil r d y n idvd a hssa dn t d s,n tu teodri Beke hsn b aigo n iiu l a tn ig o o o ad h sh re n cly a o ern n tedtr n t nwhte teofcapo o et o a iiaiehv sadn t h eemiai ehrh f ilrp n ns f n nt tv ae tn ig o o i flsc a ap a. i uh n p el e

4 8

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 50 of 74

sa ewhna aec o gv rmeta ad fn athre wi e frigte tmt e n gny f o en n, s eedn cagd t nocn h h sa eare wi paniftatesa eiiapia lo u cntuin lo tmt,ges t litfshth tmt snp lcbe r n o si to a. 3 h t '

( ah,t .4.An,s i usderirntioiinteU idSae Chdaap90) da ds se al i hs pno,h nt tts c e e

S pe Co rhl iKace,u a 4 4U. 7 ,htwhna toie b sae u rme ut ed n rhrspr, 2 S.2 ta, e uh rzd y tt lw,edr o asaeslgsaiebac aepr te t ap a a prist a laes f tt' eilt rnh r emitd o p er s at o v e asrtesaesitrsitev l iyo acaln e sauewhntesaes seth tt' neetn h ait f h l g d ttt e h tt' d e e euieofcasdciet d s. xctv fiil el o o 02 n 4 Al o g weaen t waeo ayCaionacs i whc teLeiltr t u h r o a r f n l ri aen ih h gsaue h f hsapae a afr l at t d fn acaln e sae1wwhnteAt re a p erd s omapry o eed hlegd tt a e h t ny o

2 l Ch d a afdrltttr po iintaa toie ete h ueo 3 n a h , eea sauoy rvso ht uh rzd i r o s f h

C n s,yrsltnotahue ln,onadta eio b te ogesb eo i fhtosa etivlae dcin yh uo o i s

l gainadNa aiainSriel )oalwaprclr eot l mmlrt n mrl t evc ( t l atuadp rbe o zo NS o i a

aint rmaniteUntdSae wa caln e a avoaino tesprto le o e i n h i tts s h l gd s ilto fh eaain e e o p wesd crn .l tapoedn ,h I - rpeetdb teUntd f o r otie n ht rceigte NS ersne y h i e Sae At re Geea- are wi teptt nrain'cam tateo e tts t ny nrl ged t h eio e l s li hth n o h i e h us vt po iinwa u cnt in la dCo ges spr te t o e eo rvso s no si o a,n n rswa emitd o mt itre ei teCoro Ap elt dfn tecaln e sa e Wh ntecs nevn n h ut f paso eed h h leg d tmt. e h ae rah dteSpe Co r,h hg cutx iiyhl ta n rs ibt a ec e h u rme utte ih o repl t ed htt gess oh cl co

poepr tdfn teosmtnlyo (ehlne stt)n a rpr ryrat o eedh cnt i ai ft caegd tuead poe y io t h l a
ptinr ne 2 U.. j15() ( ah,ur, 6 U..t .3. eloeu dr 8 SC. 241. Chdaspa42 Sap 99) t 5
2 T eporeyo cn rsinl rlgsaiepriiaini c ut 4 h rpit f o geso ao eilt at pto n o r v c poedn si dfneo acaln e saueias ilsrtdb te rceig n ees f h l gd ttt s lo l tae y h e u cru tn e sro n igteUntdSae Aton yGeea'rcn dcso t icmsacsuru dn h i tts tre n rls ee t eiin o e

cae eedn h vli oa rvs noteeeaD fne f rae t esdf i e ady f poio fh fdrl ees oMarg Ac n jt it i i
AtonyGeea an u cdtah Ao l n ln e dfn tesauei tre nrln o ne ht e ud o o gr eed h ttt n q et nb cueh adtePrsdn o teUntdSae h dc nlddta te u si ea s e n h eiet fh i tts a o cu e h th o e mesr wa u cntuin lte tre Ge ea s td t hv ifr d aue s n o stt a,h At ny nrlt e: $ aenome i o o a I Me eso Co geso tid cso ,oMe eswh wiht d fn tesaue mbr f n rs fhs eiin s mbr o s o eed h ttt ma p ru ta ot n.Th Deat n wi as wokcoeywi tecutt y useht pi e prmet l lo r lsl t h o rso o l h

( U.. j7 lcutcin calnigtasaue Ath smet te 1 SC. )n orat s hl gn htttt. te a i h o e me

liain'(ttmet fh At . no Ligt nlv ligteDees o igt . Sae n ote t Ge.n t al n ovn h fne f t o' y i o MaraeAc(e.32 1) hp/ .sc.o/p r o l bur/1 rig tFb2,0 1<l :- j t egvoip/ lTerayl/ ui z a-2 .t >(soNo.72 11 g22hm1 a f v 1,0 1. )
4 9

esrtaC nrshs fladfiopr nltprc aen edn nueht oges ayu n a pot i o ati tipni l r u t ip g

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 51 of 74

Geeao ohr u l ofcashv d cie t d s, litfshv ctdn nrlr tep bi fiil ae el d o o o panif ae i o c n e cs ta sp ottecam taiwo l voaetespaaino p wesd crn aehtu p rsh li htt ud ilt h e rto f o r otie e o idi teCaionaCo si to frteLe iltr t po iesc a mb de n h lfri ntuin o h gsaue o rvd uh t d fnewhnohrp biof ildciet d s.I an mb ro Caiona ees e te u l fi as el o o o n u e f l ri c c n f cssteLe iltr o o eo i cntun hue h sap ae a ap ryi ae,h gsaue r n ft o si et o ss a p erd s at n s t liainc aln igtev l i o apo oe o a otdiiaieo igt h l gn h ai t f rp sd r dpe nt tv r t o e dy i

rfrnu mesr(e,..Snto h Saeo a..oe,ur, 1 eeedm aueseeg,eaefte tt fc lvJnsspa2

Ca.t 14 , 16 f. ; gsauevEuspr 5 Ca.t 4 2; giltr v l h 12 15 ,n 9 Leiltr . ,u a,4 1 h 9 Le saue . 4 4

Dek ja ,ur,4Ca.d6 8AsmbyvDek j' ,ur,0C l d umeinspa 3 l 5; se l . umelnspa3 a. 3 a 3 6 8- ot i is ne iwhc te tre Geeao ohrxct e 3) fn nnt csn ih h At ny nrlr teeeui e a o v
ofcaso kap sto c nrr t teLeiltr'rgrigtev l i o te f ilto oi n o tay o h gsauese adn h ai t fh i dy

mesr (e,.. gsauevEuspr,4Ca.t42Lgsauev aueseeg, iltr . ,u a5 1 h 9; ei tr . Le 4 l Dek ja,ur,4Ca.d68Ase lvDek ja,ur,0Ca.d umeinspa 3 l 5 ; smb . umeinsp a3 l 3 y 3 68.Tts css eiaysg et ntasc at nb teLeilmr iay 3) l e ae bl n ugso htuh ci yh gs en n e e i o a
wa uup do itree wi t e euieofcasp roma c o ter y sre rnefrd t he x ct fiil' efr ne fhi h v

eeuiefnt n (e as C lonaso a O e Pr r vMc esn xct uci . Se lo afrinfr n p n i y . phro v o ma (06 3 Ca.t 75Eeiauerpeetdb sprtcu slapae a 2 0) 8 1 h 3 L gs tr,ersne y eaae one,p erd s 4 l
rap r i itrst dfn v l i o vtrapo e cntuinl el at n neeto eed ai t f oe-p rv d osi t a y dy to

a nmetsb t dt eetrtb Leiaue; p vFar o. ate med ns umie o lcoae y gs trjKop . iP lPrci s t lc Co ,ur,1 Ca.t 6764(eiauepr tdt itreeodfn te m.spa 1 1 h 0 , 1 L gs tr emie onevn t eedh 4 l t
vldt o tedfn atcmmiso sato swhntec mmiso iefo ka aii fh eedn o sin' cin e h o sin t lto y s

nurloio wi rsetotecalnet i at nq et p sin t epct h hl g ot ci s. a t h e s o )

Acodn l, fn n meii panif' li ta ap aigi cuto crigy we id o rtn litfs cam h tp ern n o rt asrtesaesitrsi tevldt o acaln e 1w ie cuieya seth tt' neetn h aiiy f h l gd a s x lsv l n e eeuiefnto o taiwo l voaetesprt no p wesd crn t x tv u cin rhtt ud ilt h eaai f o r otie o o p r th ofca'rp nnso a iiaiet asrtesaesitrsi te emite fiil o o et f n nt t o seth tt' neetn h p iv

vl i oteiiaiei au iilrceigiwhc te aii o te ait fh ntt n jdcapoedn n ih h vl t fh dy iv dy

5 0

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 52 of 74

mesr icaln e .F rhr r,eas t r in rao t du thth aue s h l g d utemoeb cuehee s o esn o ob tate e CaionaLeilmr,ieteUntdSae Co vesi Chd aspr, 6 U.. l ri gsa e l h ie tts n s n a h ,u a4 2 S f k 91,rh Ne Jre Le iltr iKace,u a48 U.. 2wo l hv 9 o te w esy gsauen rhrspr, 4 S 7 , ud a e atoi t se i t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o asaueeatd uh ry o tp n o seth tt' neetn h ai t f ttt nce t dy b teLeiltr itesaeseeuieofcashv dcie t dfn te y h gsaue fh tt' xct fiil ae el d o eedh v n sauesv l i i acutrceig wecn ld ta tep o eaen ls ttt' ai t n orpoedn , o cu eh th epl r o es dy etldt hv tesaesitrsitev l i o av trapo e iiaie nie o aeh tt' neetn h ai t f oe-p rv d nt t t dy iv asre o terbhlwh np biofcasdciet dfn temest. setd n h i e af e u l fiil el o eed h aue c n 3 . Plitfsas riea ohrsme arltd sprto o p wescam, anif lo as n te,o whteae,e aain f o r li cnedn tapr tiga iiaiepo o etoasrtesaesitrsi otn ig ht emit n ntt rp n n t seth tt' neetn n iv

te aii o acaln e iiaiemesrwi itreewi te tre h vl t f ht gdntt aue l nefr t h At ny dy e iv l h o

Geea'eecs o tep weso hso h r fc i rpeet gtesaes nrls x rie fh o r f i r e of en ersni h tt' n itrs.Ou rcg io ta oGcaiiitv po o et aeatoie t asr neet reont n h t f ilntaie rp n ns r uh rzd o set i tesaesitrsi a iiaiesvl iywhe p bi ofcashv dci dt h tt' neetn n nt t ' ai t n u lc fiil a e el o iv d ne dfn temesr, o v rde ntmen a panif sgett th eed h aueh wee, os o a,s litfs u gs,hate po nnsaeatoie t vrie'h AtonyGeea'o ohrp bi rpoet r uh rzd o erd'te tre nrls r te u l o c ofcas atoi t maetero dcso srgrigtedfneo te fiil'uh rt o k h i wn eiin eadn h ees fh y mesr.Aswehv dsusd i maypscssiiaiepo o ethv aue ae icse,n n at ae nt tv rpn ns ae i b e p r t dt priiaea fr l atsdfn iga iiaiemesr en emie o at p t s omap ri ee dn n nt t aue t c e iv ao gwi tep bi ofcasnme a dfn at,n i toeisacsec ln t h u lc fiil a d s eed nsad n h s ntn e ah h pryhsb e pr te t pofri o ag metadcnrlto ato s at a en emitd o rfe t wn ru ns n o to i wn cin s s i dfneo teiiaie n ees fh nt tv . i Smi ry teait o of ilntai poo ett d fn acaln e i l l,h bly f fi aiiit rp nnso eed h l gd a i c ve e iiaiemesr o b hlo tesaein tn o sset t tedsrto te nt t aue n eaf fh tt s o icnitn wi h icein h iv h At re Ge eama p sest d ciet d fn acaln e mesr o t t ny nrl y oss o el o eed hl gd aue ro o n e

dcieoapaf m a avreug n whnte tre Geeaio te el t p elr n desjdmet e h At ny nrls fh n o o

51

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 53 of 74

ve taacalne iiaiemesriucnt inl( .tto iw ht hl gdntt aues nosi oa. CfSaef e iv mt C lonavSpeir ut18)14Ca.p .d34)As l aydsusd afri .u ro Cor(96 8 1 p3 9. ar d icse, A e
ee whnteAtonyGeeah sdsrto t dciet dfn asae v n e h tre nrl a icein o el o eed tt n cntuinl rvso o samei acutrceigcaln igtemesr, o si t a po iin rtt n orpoedn h l gn h ape to e teAtonyGeea d e nt aeatoi t peet tesfo moniga h tre n rl o s o hv uh rt o rvn ohr rm u t y n d fneo bh lo tesaesitrsi tev l i o temesr.F r ees n eaf fh tt' neetn h ai t fh aue o dy e a l,nteu dryn poedn si tePer liain hdayo teohe xmpei h n elig rceig n h ry igto ,a n fh t r t p biofcaswh weenme a dfn at coe t peetasbtnie u l fiil o r a d s eedns h sn o rsn u satv c

dfneo tecaln e mesr o t apateavreug nete b ees fh hl gd aue ro p elh desjdmetne d y e r

teta cutteAtonyGeeacul n t aepe etdtap biofca h r lo r,h tre nrl o d o hv rvne ht u l fiil i c fo peet gadfneo fl ga ap a adcudn t esaieymanan rm rsni ees rin n p eln o l o prusv l iti n i tatepeett no sc adfneo tefigo sc a ap a b aohr hth rsnai fuh ees rh in f uh n p el y n te o l dfn at udcnttt a i rpe itreec wi teAtonyGeea' eedn wo l o siue n mpo rnefrne t h tre nrls h eecs o hso hrofca atoi .Bytesmetkn teatoi o x rie f i r e fiiluh rt y h a oe ,h uh rt f y ofca iiaiepo o ettp riiaea afr l at t d fn acaln e fiilnt t rp nnso at p t s omapry o eed hl gd iv c e

iiaieadt apaaug n ivl aigtemesr,os o i rpr ntt ,n o p el jdmetn ai t h auede ntmpoel iv dn y

itreewi teAt re Geea'atoi add e n t ilttesprt n nefr t h t ny nrls uh rt n os o voae h eaai h o y o o p wesd crn . f o r otie 4 . Panif as cnedtab cueteofcapo nnso a iiaie litfs lo otn h t ea s h fiil rpoet f n nt tv i mesr aepiaeidkdas oh v n t eneetdt p bi ot etk n aue r r t n iiulwh a e o be lce o u l fc,ae o v c i ot t u h l teCaionaCo si ino lwscr t ercl do ah o p od h lfri nt o ra ,amo b eal r mt e

i ece,n aentujcttecnl t fneetue o ohrtia mpahdad r osbetoh otco itrsrls r teehcl i

sadrstaapyt p biofcaste cn o po el asrtesaes tn ad ht p l o u l fiil,hy an t rp ry seth tt' c itrsi tev l i o acaln e iiaiemesr. neetn h ai t f h l gd nt t aue dy e iv Ou dtr nto tateofcapo o eto a iiaieaeat rzd r eemiain hth fiil rp nns f n nt t r uhoie iv t asrtesaesitrsi tevaiiyo teiiaiemesr whnp bi o seth tt' neetn h ldt fh nt t aue e u lc iv

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 54 of 74

ofcashv dcie t dfn temesr, o vrd e n t a tate fiil ae el d o eed h aueh wee, o s o men hth n po o etbcmed fcop bi ofcaso p sesayofcaatoi t rp nns eo e at u lc fiil r oss n fiiluh rt o y e ata o rg lto so ee t drcl efreteiiai mesr i nc lws reuain r v n o iety noc h nt t aue n i ve q et n Rahrteatoi tepo o etp sesi ticnetismpyte usi . te,h uh rt h rp n ns oss n hs otx s i l h o y atoi t p rii t a apryi acutcinadt asrlglru nsi uh rt o at pae s at n orat n o setea ag met n y c o d fneo tesaesitrsi tev l iyo teiiaiemesr whnte ees fh tt' neetn h ai t fh nt tv aue e h d i p bi ofcas oodnrl wo l asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o u l fiilwh riai ud seth tt' neetn h ai t f c y dy temesr hv n tdn s.Thsatoi iete l nro adl tdad h aue a e o o e o i uh rt s xrmey arw n i e n y mi d e n tmpyayatoi t at nbh lo tesaei oh rep cs os o i l n uh rt o c o eaf fh tt n te rset. y Bea s o tel tdntr o tepo o et'uh rt,h yaepo el cue fh i e aue fh rp n ns atoi te r rpry mi y

sbetotesmeehclosrittaapyt a1tepre ialgl ujct h a tiacntanshtp l o lohr atsn ea i

poedn . rceig Asdsusdao ewerc g ie i BuligId sr Asn,u a 41 icse b v , eo nzd n i n n ut s.spr, d y Ca.dap g 82 tab cueo tefn a nap moea du iu ntr o l t a e 2 ,h t eas fh udmetl u s n nq e aue f 3 teiiai poes- apoesdsg e t gv tep o eo Caionate h nt t rcs i ve rcs ein d o ieh epl f l ri h f atoi t drcl a o to si t nl med nso saue tatereetd uh rt o iet d p cntui a a n met rtttsh th i lce y y to of ilhv rfsdo dcie t a ot n ma otnop s - teeia fi as ae eue r el d o d p ad y fe p oe h r s n c n icesdrs,v nwhnp biof ilaed fn igacaln e iiaie nrae ik ee e u l fi as r eedn hlegd nt t c c iv mesr,hth p bi ofcasma fit dfn temesr wi vg r Asa auetate u l fiil y alo eed h aue t io. c h cneu neweidctdi BuligIdsr Asn ta ee i sc o sq ec, n iae n i n n ut s.ht vn n uh d y cru tne acut eeal so l pr th of il rp n nso a icmsacs o rg nrl h ud emite fi apo o et f n y c iiaiet itreei tepo edn tog adtep o l'eecs o nt t o nevn n h rceig u r h epes x rie f iv t

iiaie o r'(bd)Whnp biofilttl dcieodfn a ntt pwe. Ii. e u l fcasoal el t eed iv ' c i y n
c aln e iiaiemesr,h saesitrsi teiiitv 'vl i wo l hl gd nt t auete tt' neetn h ntaies ai t ud e iv dy g cmpeeyu dfn e ,n tev trwh eatdteiiaiemesr it o o ltl n ee dd ad h oes o n ce h nt tv aueno i lw wo l b etrl dpie o hvn tesaesitrsi teiiaies a ud e niey erv d f aig h tt' neetn h nt t ' iv v l i asre o terbh l u ls smepiaeidvd a o etyi ai t setd n h i e af nes o r t n iiu l r ni s dy , v t
5 3

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 55 of 74

p r te t asrta itrso tev tr'tait sy tep o l',e af emitd o seth tneet n h oes,htso a ,h epesbhl. Beas o terseileainhpt teiiaiemesr,h pfca cue fh i p ca rltosi o h nt tv auete fiil i po o eto temesr aetemot b iusadlgcl rvt idvd ast rp nns fh aue r h so vo n oiapiaen iiu l o al advg rul d fn tevldt o tec aln e mesr o b hlo te by n ioo sy eed h aii fh hlegd aue n eaf fh y itrsso tev tr wh aotdteiiai it lw,n tu t asrte neet fh oes o d pe h nt t no a a d h so seth i ve saesitrsi teiiaiesv l i whnp biofcashv dcie t d tt' neetn h nt t ' ai t e u l fiil ae el d o o iv dy c n
S O.

Moevree otieteiiaiecnettsni e u peeetdn r ro e,v n usd h nttv otx ii et r n rcdne o i h priual u uu l n e Caiona1w frpro sohrta p bi of ilt at lry n sa u dr lfri a o esn te hn u lc fi aso c c b p r t dt pat iaea fr l atsi acutcint asrtep bi' e emie o ri p t s omapri n o rato o seth u lcs t c e o tesaesitrsi u h ligo efrigad l e atdlw.F rea l, rh tt' neetn p odn r nocn uy n ce a o xmpe u drh s-aldu l itrs'e cpini madt ato spiaectzn n e te ocl t bi neet xeto n n ae cin,rv t i es e p c ' i hv ln be atoie t bigama dt ato t e freap bi dt aeo g en uh rzd o rn n ae cin o noc u l uy c iv ligtepoeto o ap birg tnodroesr ta n g vmmet n ovn h rtcin f ulc ih i re t nue ht o o e n

bd i aro dfash proeo lgsainetbihn sc ar h.(e, oy mpi r eette up s fei t sal ig uh i t Se s lo s g eg, envObeo(9 12 C 1d16 1415 C mmo C uevB ado ..Gre . ld 18) 9 a. 2 ,4 -4 ; o n as . or f 3 Sp ri r(99 4 Ca.d4249segnrl 8Wi i, a.rcdr uevs s 18) 9 l 3,3;e eeal t n C lPqeue o 3 y k (t e.0 8E tariayWrsj8,p 9093)Smir ,netewel 5h d20) xrodnr i, 4p .7-7 . i l l udrh l t ay etbihdpiaeatre gn rl otiepiaeidvd asaep n itdt sal e rvt ton y eead cr , rvt n iiul r e hte o s n a i sp ot ftep biitrsb bign lwsi t e fresae d n up ro h u l neet y rn ig a ut o noc tt c s cntuinl rsauoypo iin i cru tne i whc efre n b o si toa o tttr rvso sn icmsacsn ih nocmet y t

pbiof ilma ntesfcet (e,..SraovP-s(9 72 ul fcas y ob uf in.Seeg,ern .jet17) 0 c i i i Ca.d2,24 ; oln l R s etAsn,n.. tC ucl17) 3 l 44-7 WodadHis ei ns s.IcvCi oni(99 2 3 l d y Ca.d97939 192)5Ide,h atoi o teof ilrpnns fn l 1,3 ,4 -4 . nedte uhry fh fiapooeto a 3 2 t c
2 Wen t ta i b t tep biitrsadpiaeatre gn rl 5 oeh tn oh h u lcneetn rvt tony eea c net,h atoi o piaeidvd ast at nbh lo tep bi itrs o txste uh rt f rvt n iiu l o c o e af fh u l neet y c Io oeotudonxpg) ot tcni e n etae n n
5 4

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 56 of 74

iiaiet asrtesaesitrsi tepeetcnetiamoemo et nt t o seth tt' neetn h rsn otx s r d s iv atoi ta teatoi e ecsdb piaeidvd asu drete te uh rt hn h uh rt xrie y fvt n iiu l n e i rh y y h p bi-neet n aeecpino tepiaeatre gnrl otiebcue u l itrsmadt xet rh rvt t ny eead crn ,ea s c o o u drh s d crn spiaeidvd asaeatoie t at fimaieyo n etoe otie rvt n iiul r uh rzd o caf tvl n r b hlo tep bia disi poedn st efreap birgtwhra te e af fh u l n ntme rceig o noc u lc ih, eesh c t atoiyp sesdb teofca iiaiepo o eti tepeetcnets uh r osse y h fiilnt t rp nnsn h rsn o tx i t iv smpyap sie dfnieatoi t se i t asrtesaesitrsi te i l asv , eesv uhrt o tp n o seth tt' neetn h y v l i o ac aln e mesr whnteiiaieh sbe caln e b ohr ai t f hlegd aue e h nt t a en h l g d y tes dy iv e

i auiilrceig adpbiof ilhv dcie t dfn temesr. n jdcapoedn sn ul fcas ae el d o eedh aue c i n
l sm,vnto g teofcapo o eto a iiaiepesr aen t n u e e h u h h fiil rp nns f n ntt aue r o iv p biofcasterlte pa i asrigtesaesitrsi tevldt o u lc f il h oehy ly n set h tt' neetn h aii f n y

a iiaiemesr itijdcastn de nthetntedmort n ntt auen hsu iilet g os otrae h e cai iv i c

poeso tepo e g vmac o tesaebto tecnrr,evst rcs rh rp r o e ne fh tt,u,n h o tay sre o sfg adteu iu ee nsa ditgi o teiiaiepoes aeur h nq e lmet n nert fh nt tv rcs. y i 5 . Fn l , litfssg etht dtr nt ntateofcapo o et ial panif u g sta a eemiai hth fiil rp nns y o o a iiaieaeatoie t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o a f n nt t r uh rzd o seth tt' neetn h ai t f iv dy caln e iiaiei acutrceigwi rsli u twadcneun e i h legd nt t n o rpoedn l eutn no r o sq e csn iv l ohrcnet. te otxs Fo ea epanifcnedta iofca iiaiepo o etae r x mpl, litfs o tn htf fiilnt t rp nns r iv pr te t asrtesaesitrsi a iiaiesv l i a dt ap aa emitd o seth tt' neetn n nt t ' ai t n o p el n iv dy

Iontcni eko peiupg) otoeotud m rv sae n o

u dr ai milwwa iialrcgie b jdcadcso nt ts nig ne C lo aa sntl eonzd yu iilei n owi t dn f iy i ha tea sneo ayseiccntmt nlo sauoypo iineprslgat g h bec f n p cf o si i a rtttr rvso x esy rni i o n sc atoi .(e,..G envObeospa2 C-1dap .4 -4 ,n uh uhry Seeg, re . ld ,ur,9 a. t p 1415ad t 3 cssctd Sra ovPretspr, 0Ca.dap 4. 4 . ae i ;ern . is,u a 2 1 t p.5 7) e 3
5 5

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 57 of 74

avreug n whnteAt re Geeaadohr ul of ilhv desjdmet e h t ny nrln tepbi fias ae o c c dcie t d s,h po oet'cini figa apama sbeth s t el d o o ote rp nnsat n in n pel y ujctet e n o l a
t sbtnil ntr l blyfratre fe so l tepo o et' foti o u sat mo eay i it o tony es h ud h rp n ns efrsn a a i sp ot fh caln e mesr po eu scesu.Th q eto o wh u p ro te hl g d aue rv nu csfl e u sin f o e so l ba rso sblyfrayatre fea r i sc cru tn e, h ud er ep niit o n ton y e wad n uh i msacs i c h we e,seteydsicfo teq eto whte teofcapo o et o o vri ni l it trm h u sin ehrh fiil rp nns f r n a iiaieaeatoie t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o a n nt t r uh rzd o seth tt' neetn h ai t f iv dy caln e iiit emesr a din t eoeu i tipoedn .Ou h l g d nt i aue n s o b fr sn hs rce ig r e av cn lso taofca iiaiepo nnsaeatoie t asrtesaes o cuin ht fiilnt tv rpo et r uh rzd o seth tt' i itrsi tevl i o acaln e iiaiemesr whnp bi ofcas neetn h ai t f hl g d nt t aue e u lc fiil dy e iv dciet d s d e n t a ta aymo eaylblyicre a arslo el o o o os o men ht n ntr i it nurd s eut f n ai tepo o et'cin so l o mut eb reb tesae Th atre fe h rp n ns at s h ud r sb on y h tt. e tony e o

isecnpoelb adesdiadwhnteqet naie i tef ue ( . su a rpr e drse fn e h uso r sn h m r. Cf y i s

Co nr vSaePesn e#J, u a 3 Ca.t ap 17 - 19 n el . tt ro nl spr, 7 1 h t p. 1817 y 4

(itg i igsts fnevnrntt epooetfo tao a cs uie dsi us n tu o itreeiiai rpnnsrm ht fmiu cra n h a iv
i cnldn taa c scra cudn t rp r b h l l befrpiae n o cu ig ht miu uie o l o po el e ed i l o rv ty a

atre-eeaatre fea rj t nygnrlt ny e wad. o o )

Smial, hv n ocso i tics t adejohrlg l u sin i lry we ae o cain n hs ae o d rs te e a q eto s ta ma aiei ftr cssiteeiacnlcbt e tep sto sae b h t y rs n uue ae fh r s o fit ewen h oi n tkn y i iiitv po nnsa db ohrdfn atwh aeap aigo bh lo te nt ie rpoet n y te eedns o r p ern n eaf fh a sae Th iseb fr u il tdt t q eto whte ofcaiiaie tt. e su eoe ssi e ohe usin ehr fiilnt t mi iv po o et aeatoie t apa a prist asrtesaesitrsi te rp n ns r uh rzd o p er s at o seth tt' neetn h e v l i o a iiaiemesr whntep biofcaswh odnrl po ie ai t f n nt t aue e h u l fiil o riai rvd dy iv c y sc ad fnehv dcie t d s.Th n meo scssdsusdao ei uh ees ae el d o o o e u ru ae icse bv n n whc iiit epo o et, n rs, rtt lgsaielaeshaebe ih nt i rp nnsCo geso sae eilt edr v en av v pr te t itreet peetlglru nsrgrigtev l i a dpo r emitd o nevn o rsn ea ag met eadn h ai t n rpe dy itrrtt no acaln e lw rft tecam ta pr tiga iiai ' nepeai f h l g d a eue h li ht emit n ntt s o e n i ve
5 6

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 58 of 74

of ilrp nnst priiaeo tibssiu wok beo wi ieiby fi apo oe t o at pt n hs ai s n ra l r l nvt l c c l a rsli dti nacneun e. eutn ermetl o sq ecs C.Ou-fsaeDeiin to-tt cso s Astefrg igdsuso idctsi rahn tecn lso tate h oeon ic sin n iae,n ecig h o cuin hth ofcapo o eto a iiaieaeatoie u drCaiona1w t fn a fiilrp nns f n nt t r uh rzd n e lfri a odeed iv

calne iiaie aueadtapafo aug nivlaigte hl gdntt mesr n o p elrm jdmetnai t h e iv dn

mesr whnp biofcasd ciet dfn teiiaiewehv rldu o aue e u l fiil el o eed h nt t , a e ei p n c n iv e tehsoyadp roeo teiiaiepo iin o teCaionaCo si to h itr n up s fh ntt rvso s fh lfri ntuin iv t adu o ten meo sCaio ad cso stahaeu ioml pr te te n p n h u ru lfmi eiin h t v nfr y emitd h ofcapoo et o iiaiemesrst ap a a p risaddfn te f il rp nns fnt t aue o p er s at n eed h iv e v l i o temesrste h v so srd ai t fh aue hy ae p noe. dy l a dto , nt tai rcn yasec o tet ohrsaespe n d i n we oe htn eet er ah fh wo te tt u rme i cuttahsadesdteq eto whte teofcapoo eto a orsht a d rse h u sin eh rh fiil rp nns f n ' iiaiemesr hv sadn u drsaelw t itreei a ato ' nt t aue ae tn ig n e tt a o nevn n n cin iv * caln igtev l i o teiiaiemesr h scn lddta,n e ec h l gn h .ai t fh nt t aue a o cu e htu dr ah e dy iv saesrset elw,ntaiepoo et gnrl aea toie t itree tt' ep ci a ii t rp nns e eal r uh rzd o nevn v iv y

a o ihi sc a at nisaecut sfr tn uh n ci n tt or. g o IAlsaso aC mmo L nug vKrt( ak 20) P3 9 6 n aknfr o n agae . i Alsa 0 03 .d 0 z ( aknfraCo nL nug)teiu osadn aoeia atn Alsaso mmo agae,h s e ftnig rs n n ci s o
caln igtevldt o av trapo e iiaiemesr ta- l ete h l gn h aii f oe-p rv d nt t aueht i h e y iv k

Ar oaiiaieivle iAr oaso O il gihspr,2 U..3 i n ntt novdn i nnfr scaEnl ,u a50 S4 z iv z s (e at,tp 1-0 - po ie taE gi sal eue b alul se neap .82) rvddht n lh hlb sd y 1pbi s c
aece i al o en n fntosadato sadi tepe aaino a1 gn isn 1g vrmetu cin n cin n n h rprto f l ofdap bid cmet adrcrs Twoog nzto s- tefs,h ofca fiil u l ou ns n eod. c raiain h i tte fiil r po o et o teiiaiemesr i Alsa adtescn , nto a rp nns fh nt t auen ak ,n h eo d a ain l iv

ognzt n( SE gih taspotdteAlsamesr- suht raiai U..n l )htupr h ak aue ogto o s e

5 7

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 59 of 74

itre ea fr l at si tetil o rpoedn sb th tilo rdne nevn s oma pri n h racutrce ig, u tera cut e id e b t rq eto tevo n tateitrsso tewol-eitrees r oh eu ss n h u d hth neet fh udb nevnrwee a eu tl rpeetdb teg vrmetdfn atwh weed fn igte dq aey ersne y h o en n ee dns o r eedn h iiit emesr i tepoedn .Bohognzto sap ae tetil o r' nt i auen h rceig t ra iain p eld h ra cut av s nl gdn igitret n Onap a,h AlsaS pe Corrvre te zn eyn nevni . p elte ak u rme ute esd h i o tilo r'rl gisfra idne itreto b teotcapo o eto ra cuts ui noa st eid nevnin y h fiilrp nns f n temesr b tafr dtelwe cutuigisfra idne itreto b h aue u fime h o r o rrl noa st eid nevnin y n

ieohr raiain h te ognzt . o

l a ayigteq eto o teofcapo o et'ih t itreete n nlzn h u sin fh fiil ip nnsrg to nevn ,h AlsaS pe Co rn tdtapirt tev t o teiiaiemesr a ak u rme ut oe ht ro o h oe n h nt t aue t iv isei ta cs,h At re Geea' Of ehdrie p tnil u sin su n ht aete t ny n rls fc a asd oet q eto s o a rgrigtecnt in lyo temesr adteGoen r a pro al eadn h o si o ai fh aue n h vro h d esnly mt t

opsdtemesr dr gteeet ncmpin ( aknfr C mmo p oe h aue ui h lci a ag.Alsaso a o n n o L nug,ur, P3 ap .0-1.Noehls,bevn tacut agaespa3 .d tp9990) nteesosright or s
gnrl eo nz apeu to o aeut rpeetto whngv rmet eeal s c gie rsmpin f dq ae ersnain e o en n yr etisaep rist alwsib cuetoeetisaecag db 1wwi nie r at o a ut ea s h s nie r hre y a t t e t h

rpeet gteitrss fh pol'( .t . 1)teAlsaSpe Cor ersni h neeto te epe'/ ap 93,h ak urme ut n # s tdtabae o te rsmpino aeut gvrmetersnainwe t e htl lsd nh peu t f dqae oen nrpeett , a g o o
peu teAton yGeea'Ofiewo l n talod fn te rsmeh tre n rls fc ud o fit eed h cntuinlyo teiiaieeegtcl adcpby Bae o ta sme o si to ai fh nt t nreial n aal. sd n ht a t t iv y

peu t nweas peu tategvmo wolntnefr. (da rsmpi , l rsmehth o e r ud oitree' 1.t o o ' p 94) . 1. T ecutnAlsaso aC mmo L nug ,ur, P3 96wetn h ori aknfr o n aga espa 3 .d 0 , n o
t epan h wee,htdsi tec uts rsmpintategv rmet o x li, o vrta ept h o r'peu to hth o en n e dfn atwo l eegt al adcpbyd fn tecaln e mesr, eedns ud nrei l n aal eed h hl g d aue cy e iamuha teiiaiepo o ethdsdtepoeso drc lgsaint n s c sh nt t rp nns a e h rcs f iete ilto o iv u

eat 1wtateeeuiebac qet ndadopsdy(hycnob ncaa hth xct rnh usi e n p oel t e ant e v o )l
5 8

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 60 of 74

futdfrwat gt g aatetateiiaieidfn e zao syo fr al o ni o u rne h th nt t s eed d elul ro e n iv tyn t esr tateceiii o isi o aag meti fv ro te rig o nuehth rdbly fntminl ru nsn a o fh t t iiaiein t i nse b tepeiu cmmetfo teeeuiebac. nt t s o dmiih d y h rvo s o ns'm h x ct rnh iv r v Tote adt tep bi i smptywi teiiaieteg v ro' hm,n oh u l n y ah t h nt t ,h o en rs c h iv op sto adteAt re Geea Ofiesq eto s. . uigtecmp in p oi n n h t ny n rl fc' u sin .d rn h a ag , i o cudceta apaa c o avri .Evr srtgcdcso ma eb te o l rae n p ern e f d est ey taei eiin d y h y Aton yGeea' Ofiei d fn igtelgsainmih b p bil tre nrl fc n ee dn h eilt gt e u l y s o c q eto e adscn -u se b teiiit 'smpties Thths u sin d n eo dg esd y h ntai s y ahzr. ati ve

ssiinma b ufuddde nt k ilsieibe'( P3 ap 94) upco y e none os omaetesnvt l. 3 .d t . 1. a '

T eAlsaSpe Corwet nt cn ld:seeb cueo te h ak u rme ut n o o o cu e -r, ea s fh l l n tr o drc lgsaintru hteiiaiepoesteposbeap aac aue f i teilto ho g h nt tv rcs,h sil p ern e e i o av ri o itrsisfiin t o ecmetepeu to o a eut f d est fneets ufceto v ro h rsmpin f dq ae y

rpeett n Ide wcblv taa ( iaie sosrs i citrsi ersnai . ne4 ei ehtn i tt l p no 'dr tneetn o e ni v e
lgsaineatdtruhteilale o esa dtecno .a t edt e ilt n ce hog h n.it prcs n h o cml n ne o o t. v t
'

tttteap aac o destwiodnrlpeld cutko dnig z?fh p ernefa vri l riai rcue or m eyn vf y l y s itretnao ihtasosrggop'( aknfraCmmo nevni sfrgto pnoi rui Alsaso o n o n ' L nug,ur, P3 ap 94ils de.6Acodnl,h cuted ag aespa 3 .d t .1,ti add) crigy te orhl ac 2
tatetilo rerdi dn igitret nb teofcapo o eto te hth racutre n eyn nevni y h fiil rp n ns fh o iiaiemesr adrvre tap rino tetil o r'rl g. nt t aue n e esd ht ot fh racuts ui iv o n

2 Th cutd e anro q aiiaint isbodh ligta iiaie 6 e o radd arw ul cto o t ra odn htnt tv f i po o et aeetldt itre ei sc liaina amatro rg t rp n ns r nie o nevn n uh igto s te fih, t t epann ta C ak cutso l rti dsrto t dn itreto i x liig hts sa o rs h ud ean icein o ey nevnin n Al

ecpinlae,eas (erlvnAlsasauerlt gt iiaie xet acssbcuet eeat ak ttt eai ontt o h n iv sosr) lcs ol t ntenmbr fntt esosr adteeoe pnospaen i o h u eo iiai pnos n hrfr mi iv

p tnil o esh d o t a u i tdn mbro moin fritret n.As oetal pn te oro n nl e u e f to s o nevni y mi o a atmaiet l tn itret nitoecsscutma isedco s t n l tv o i ig nevni n h s ae,o rs y nta h oe o e mi o rd c dpiainb rq iigtoeso sr wi sbtnil smiritrss eue u lct y eurn h s p nos t u satal i l neet o h y a

tcnoia te Viigado atiaehog la cusl'Alkn o osl t hi en n tprc ttruhed one. ( a as de r f ip ' s fraCo nLnug,ur, P3 ap94) o mmo agaespa3 .d t.1.
5 9

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 61 of 74

Th AlsaS pe Co rrahdacnrr cnlso , o v rwi e ak u rme utece o tay o cuin h wee, t h rsetoteohrognzto ta hdsu h itreto i tetilo r. ep ct h te ra iain h t a og tnevnin n h ra cut

P it gothttqercr fi t so adU.. gi hs oasrd oni utatt eod al o hw,n SEnlh antset , n lh s s e

taisdrcosofcr,ricroaosweeso sr o teiiaiei htt ietr, fieso n op rtr r p nos fh nt tv n i

Alsaowee mbroteiiaiecmmie'(lsasoaCo n ak r rme esfh ntt o te'Aaknfr mmo iv t L nug,ur, P3 ap 96,h cuton taI SE gi hs o ag aespa3 .d t . 1)te orfu dhtC . nlh ant U. s
etbihdta i itrsiaygetrta agn rl e itrso ap lia sal e htt neets n rae h n eeai d neet f oicl s s z t

ntr'ii. Ihltateognzt nddntulyfrnevnina a aue'bd) t ed hth raiai i o qai o itret s ( . o f o

matro rgtadtatetil orddn t b s isdsrto i dn ig te fih n hth ra cut i o auet icein n eyn

pr sieitret n ( i. emis nevni .I d) v o b

2 .

ISotmefr-4 vFenhJdC utMot20) 0P.d40 n p r no 113 . et u. or( n.02 4 3 0 s (p rs no 113,h Motn Spe Corsmir adesdte Sot fr-44te naa urme uti l l drse h me ay
gnrlsu S eh rh pi r po o et fab l tnttv h salgl eeaiset te te rmay rp nn o al iiaie a eal wh o i y poetbeitrssfiin t alw it itreei acs caln igte rtcal neetuf eto l to nevn n ae h l gn h c o e

rsln sttL (dap42)AsiAlsaso aC mmo L nug,u a eut g tue' 1.t .0. . n aknfr o n ag aespr, i a ' 3P3 96iS rs n o 113tetacuta dne amoint itree .d 0,n pot fr-4 h r lorhd eid t onevn me i o
b teso sr o tecaln e iiaiemesr o tego n tate y h p nos fh h l gd nt tv aue n h ru d hth e i gvrmetdfn at a di tepoedn - teeteMo tn Deat n o en n ee dn nme n h rce ig hr,h naa prme t o Fih Wi leadP rs- cudaeu tl dfn temesr.Al o g i f s, l i ,n ak o l d qaey eed h aue t u h n df h taisac teewa lterao t ssethth n me gvrmet htntn ehr sil esn o up ctate a d o en n t dfn at udn t ioo sydfn teiiitv mesr adtersln eedn wo l o vg rul eedh nt ie aue n h eut g a i lgsainteiiaieh degn ee ,h Motn S pe Corn ntees eilto h nt tv a n edrd te na a u rme ut oeh ls i o sre tateiiaiepo o ett oat eydatdadsp otd113 bevd hth nt tv rp n ns ci l rfe n u p re -4 i wh v ma b i tebsp st nt dfn teritrrtto o tersln y en h et oio o eed hi nepeain fh eut g i i

lgs tn'4 P3 ap43 adhlta,s gnrl triiaie eili '(0 .d t .0)n edhta a eeamat,nt t ao e iv
6 0

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 62 of 74

pooetEretldt itreea amatro ih'ia at ncal gn rpnnste nie onevn s t fr t n n ci hln ig a t e g' o e te aii otemesr te hv sosrd (bd,tls de.7 h vl t fh auehy ae pnoe.li.i i add) dy ac 2
l Co cuin V. n lso I rso s t teq eto sb te b teNit Ci utwecn ld,o n ep ne o h usin u mitd y h nh r i, o cu e fr c terao sdsusdao etawhntep bi ofcas oodnrl dfn a h esn icse b v,ht e h u l fiilwh riai eed c y

calne sae1 o apaaug n ivl aigtelwdciet d s, hl gd tt a rpel jdmetnai t h a el o o o e w dn n

u dratl I,eto 8o teCaionaCo si o a dterlvat rvso s n e ri e 1scin fh l ri ntmin n h ee n po iin c f t o t Eldin Co eteofcapo o eto av trapoe iiit e fhe e o s d,h fiil rp nns f oe-p rvd nt i av mesr aeatoie t asrtesaesitrsi teiiaiesvl i , aue r uh rzd o seth tt' neetn h nt t ' ai t iv dy e al gtepo nnst dfn tecntuinlt o teiiaieadt nbi h rpo et o ee d h o si to ai fh nt t n o n t y iv

apaau g n ivl aigteiiaie p el jdmetnai t h ntt . dn iv

CANTI S L-AKAUYE, J C..

WECONCUR: KENNARD,. J BAXTER,. J WERDEGAR,. J CHI J N,. CORRI J GAN,. LI J U,.

2 WenttabtAlsaso aCo nL nug,ur, P3 96 7 oehtoh aknfr mmo agaespa3 .d 0, adSot no 113spa4 P3 40weedcddat teUntdSae n prs fr-4,ur,0 .d 0, r eie frh i tts me e e Spe Cor'dcsniAroaso O il gihspa50U..3 urme ut eii n i nnfr scaEnl ,ur,2 S4. s o z s T oedcsos ofmtatefdrlihcut dcs niArznnfr hs eiin cni hth eeahg or' eio n ioaso r s i O/ f/ nlhi oen i ei ntastcut dtr ntnta, fzlEgi mpss ompdmeto teor' eemiai ht c s a s o
u drsaelw,niiaiepo o et a teatoi t itre ea o rg tn n e tt a a nt tv rp nn hsh uh rt o nevn s fih i i y a ato i saecuth ln igtevl i o a iiaiemesr. n cin n tt o rcal gn h ai t f n nt t aue e dy iv
61

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 63 of 74

C O PY PERRYv BROWN .

519 7 846 CONCUM NG OPI ONBYKENNARD, . NI J

Whljiigfl itecut uai u oiinatoe b teC if i onn ul nh ors nnmos pno uhrd y h he e y '
JsieIwrt sp rtl t hg l h tehsoiaa dlglv nstahv 1d utc, i eaaey o ihi th itrcl n ea eet ht a ee e g t tdy'dcso a dt epanwh 1 o cri tadcso o o a s eiin n o x li y cnu n ht eiin. I Thscs mak tefutt i rcn y astaticut a adesd i ae rsh orh i n eet er hths o rh s d rse me ise rltdt teog igp lia adlg lt geaot ehrsmesx sus eae o h n on oicln e asmg l b u whte a -e t ma igsso l b rcg ie a v l i Caiona l 2 0 ,hscut edta nae h ud e eo nzd s ai n l ri. n 0 4ti orh l ht d f SnFa csop bi ot asecee teratoi wh nte ise marae a ric u lc f l x edd h i uh rt e hy sud rig ki y

lessosmesxculswi ot piruiil eemiainote i ne t a -e ope t ua rojdcadtr nt fh c h o

cnt in lyo aCaiopasa ersrcigmaraet htrsx a o si o ai f lfri tmt etit rig o eeoeu l mt t n

culs (oke vCi adC ?fo a Frni o(04 3 Ca.h15 ope.L cyr . t n /npfsn acs 20) 3 lt 05 y z. c 4 lo#el Ageigwi temaoi ta, ti orttgvrmet L c r. ren t h jryhtwi n u sae oen n, l h t h
dtr nn tecntuin l aiiyo saesaue iats rsre t te eemiig h o si to av l t ftt tttss ak eevd oh t d

jdcabac,jie itadcs n ecp isfr st elrdv isme uiilrnhIondn ht eio,xetnoaa idcae od o i

40 0smesxma ig sprome i rln eo lcne ise i Sn ,0 a -e n ae efr d n ei c n ie sssu d n a a

Facso (dap 12 (oc&dsono Kenr,.)Mysprt rnic.1.t . 15 cn. i.p .f n adJ. eaae )

o no i Lok repan dtabcuetep ro s oemara e weea piin n cye x lie ht eas h esn wh s rigs r t

ise r nt eoehscutadbcueu iilrceig t dtr n te su wee o bfrti or n easjdcapoednso eemieh ,

cnt inlyo Cai rilws aigsmesxmar g weete pnig osi oai f lonaa bnn a -e ri e r hn edn mt t f a
1

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 64 of 74

i ohr lonacut, wo l hv rfan dfo dtr nn tev l i o n te Cai ri o r 1 ud a e erie rm eemiig h ai t f f s dy

toe nae.(bd) h smaigs 1i.

Thra ri Ma 2 0 ,hscutedta Caio assauoy1w eeAe,n y 0 8ti orhl ht l mi' tttr a f dn igsmesxcu lsterg toma'voae tepiay d epoesad eyn a -e ope h ih t ny iltd h rvc , u rcs,n

eulrtcinpoiin o orttCosi ina ite ra .(nr qapoet rvsos f u s e nt o sthn ed 1 e o a mt MaraeC ss(08 4 Ca.t 77( rig C ss.l adt ntsgig rig ae 20) 3 1 h 5 Marae aej n d io o inn 4 ) i temaoi oiinteel oesprtlt epa imyo wod wh l h jry pno hr, wrt eaaey o xli n wn rs y t n r etdteagmetht ehra -e culssolb alwe tmar e ce h ru n tawhtesmesx ope hud e l d o ry j o peetdesnil f scaopliaiu iaportfruiil rsne set l oilroicls enprpieojdca ay a t s a cnieain'( ap 89(ocono Kenr,.)I oetaors os rt . 1 t .5 cn.p .f n adJ) wrt hts ut d o 'd . c
ao emut eiewhte ecu igidvd asfo maig b cueo sx a ln sd cd eh r x ldn n iiul rm n ae ea s feu l oinaincnb rcn idwi o rsaeCo si inseu l rtcin rett a e eo cl t u tt ntmt ' q apoeto o e h o

gaate'(6ap 80) urne. 1 t .6. 'L

Sxmotsltri No e e 2 0 , lonasv tr apo e i nh ae,n vmbr 0 8 Cai ri' oes p rvd f Prp sto 8a iiaietaa n e CaionasCo siuinb adn a ooi n ,n nt tv htmedd l ri' nt to y d ig i i f t

nwpoiinepesyl t gmaig t htrsxaculs ( 1C nt e rvso xrsl i i naeo eeoeulope. Ca. os. min , at1j75)I Ma 2 0,hscuteetdsaecnt inlhlne t r., .. n y 09ti orrjce tt osi oacal gso mt e
Po oio 8dtr nn %htt a b e v l l eatdb tepo eue rp st n , eemiigta ihd en ai y n ce y h rcd rs i d pecie frcnt in lme d nsrte ta temoerg ru rsrbd o o si o a a n met,ahrhn h' r ioo s mt poeue pecie frcntuin leiin,n dtr nn as ta rcd rs rsrb d o osi to arvso sa d eemiig lo ht t

Pooio 8ddnt ilttesprtnop wes otie (tasvHotn rpst n i ovoaeh eaai f o rdcr .Srus . ro i o n (09 4 Ca.t 34lt us.T icutntacs as dcddta 2 0) 6 1 h 6 sr sl hs ori htae lo eie ht 4 a l
Po oiin8ddn tn aiaeaymaig sprome b fr isefciedt. rp st i o iv l t n n ae efr d eoe t fet ae o d v

(t usap44)li dteut oiinadwrtacnu igoiini Sr s,t .7. sre h or' pno n oe ocnn pno n a s
whc Iepandta ato g itrrtn e it gsaecnttto apo iin ih x lie ht l u h nepeig xsi tt o siuin l rvso s h n

iauiilepniit,h vtrrti lgsaieatoi t atrh s jdcarsosblyte oeseanei t uhryo l te i lv t e

Caio aCo si to 'ln u g adteeyt dnag o rd c tep ro a lfmi ntuinsag ae n h rb o lre r eu eh esn l t e
2

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 65 of 74

rg ttatesaeCo si t na s a n e wi teefe g aatead ihshth tt ntui s o medd l hratr urne n to l

poet'( .t .7 (ocono Kenr,.) rtc. 1 ap 46 cn.p .f nadJ. 'd ) I Ma 20,h rybfr ticutsudi oiinrjcigtesae n y 09sot eoehs orise t pno eet h ttl s h lwcalne tPooio 8(t usspa4 Ca.t 34,orniiul a hl gso rp sin Sr s,ur,6 l h 6)fu idvdas e t a 4
bo g t nato i fdrl itit orcaln igPo oio 8o fdrl ru h a cin n eeadsrc cuthlegn rp st n n eea i cntuinl ru d.Na da d fn atweeteGo en rCaionas o si to ago n s me s eedns r h vro, l ri' t f AtonyGeea,n CaionasDietro P biHe1 No eo toesae tre nrla d l ri' rco f u l at n fh s tt f c h. p biofcash we e,igtdi dfneo Po oiin8 Th Go en rad u l fiil, o vrliae n ees f rp sto . e vro n c t teDietro P biHel d cie t tk ayp sto o temeiswhl te h rco f u l at el d o ae n oi n n h rt, i h c h n i e Aton yGeeato tep sto ta Pooio 8voae teUntdSae tre nrlo k h oi n ht rp st n iltsh i tts i i e Co si to .Th fdrl itit orpr te Po oio 8sofca ntuin e e eadsrc cut emi d rp st n ' fiil t t i

Pooettitreeadiwa te,n te aoewl dfne te rpnnsonevn,n t shyadhy ln, k eeddh o mesr dr gteesignnuytil (e ma.p .at,tp71. aue ui h nun ojr ra. Se jon,neap.-0) n
Afe tetiltefdrl itit orise a o iincn ldn ta trh ra,h eeadsrc cutsu d n pno o cu ig ht Prp sto 8voae b t ted epoesadteeu l rtcincasso te o oi n ilts oh h u rcs n h q a poet lue fh i o fdrl ntuin.Onyteiiaiepo o etap ae ,oteUntdSae eea Co si to l h nt t rp nns p eld t h i tts t iv e Co ro Ap elfrh Nit Cici, ihise a odrakn ticuto ut f pas o te nh rutwhc su d n re sig hs o rt dcd ,samatr fsaelw, eh r rp nnso a iiaietatev tr eiea t o tt a wh te po o et f n nt t h th oes e iv apo e hv ete aatuaie itrs'i teiiaiesv l i o te p rv d ae i r ri lrzd neet n h nt t ' ai t rh h p c ' iv dy

atoi t tseth saesneetidfnigteiiaie (e ma.p . uhry ot srte tt'itrs'n eedn h ntt . Se jon, t a ' iv a t,tp 1-3)Wi oteiigwhte iiaie rpnns aea neap .01. t u dcdn ehrntt pooethv h iv
S riulrzditrs'iteiiaiesv l iyticutsu ai u o iin ' t aie neet'n h nt t ' ai t,hs o r' n nmo s pno pa c iv d h lstau drCaionalwteosca po o et o av trapo e od ht n e l ri a h f il rp nns f oe-p rv d f iiit ehv atoi t seth saesitrs'i tevaii o ta nt i ae uh rt o srte tt' neet n h ldt fht av y a ' y

iiaieadtapaaug n ivl aigteiiaiewhnstof il ntt ,n o p el jdmetnai t h ntt , e t e fcas iv dn iv a hv dcie t d s.( jon,neap ., 1 ae el do o o Ma.p .at,t p56. n )

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 66 of 74

1 1 larewi tdy'h ligadwi terao igo tecuts ge t o a s odn n t h esnn fh o r' h h u a i u o iin Ibif epanwh . nnmo s pno . rel x li y y

Ash maoi oiiniSrus one otticut dcsosnte te jry pno n t spitd u,hsor' eiin i h t a s
treerirsmesxma ig cssiutaetepo e rlso,n te he al a -e n ae ae l srt h rp roe fad h e l l tt n i oe u n ec bac o Caionasg vrmet te i ai smp sd po, ah rnh f l ri' o en n h mi o f

eeuietelgs t eadteuiil udr u saeC ntuin xct ,h eili ,n h jdca- h eprtt o stt . v av io (tas,ur, 6Ca.t 3435)L cyrhwshth rlo Cai ri' Srussp a4 1 h 6, 8. oke so tateoe f lonas 4 f
eeuiebac ofcasit e fresauoylwswhc te mutr a x ct rn h f il so noc tttr a , ih hy stet s v

vl ,eadesoter esnliwsuls adut teu iir hs ai rgrls fhiproave ,nesn ni h jdcay a d l dtr ndohr s.(oke,ur,3Ca.t 15,08)MaraeC ss eemie tewie L cyrspa3 1 h 05 16 . rig ae 4
so taterlo Caio aslgsaieba c it eattmtstaae h wshth oe f lfmi' eilt rnh so nc sa e htr v cnitn wi Caio asCo si t n whc a n ohrtig g rneste o ssef t l mi' ntui , ih mo g te hn s uaate h h f to

r hsopiay depoesadeulrtcino tel .( rig C ss i tt r c,u rcs,n qapoet fh a Marae ae, g v o ws spa4 C lt 777975 8586)Srusso tateoeo ur,3 a.h 5,7-8,5-5: t s hwshth rl f 4 a Caio asu iilrnhit itrrtxsigsaesauoyadcntuinl l mi'jdcabac sonepeei n tt tttr n osit a f t to poiin, p we adrsosblytaisbetotel tt ntate rvs sa o rn epniit htsujct h i ai hth o i mi o
eetrt,ho g tep we o teiiaiecna n tesaeCo si int lcoaetru h h o r fh nt t ,a me d h tt nt o o iv mt

oeiefo tat fr r,h cut rl g (tas,ur,tp 35 vnd,rm hti owadte or' ui .Srusspa ap .8, me s n 3 132) 9-9.
Thscs rie a iseo smi ri otn et apo e u drtn igo i ae ass n su f i l mp ra c o rpr n esadn f a o rsaeg vrmetltutr u drCaionasCo si t n Whnte u tt o en nasrcue n e l ri' ntui : e h f to v tr,ho g teeecs o tercntuin l g aate iiit ep we, oestru h h x rie fhi osi to al urnednt i o r t y av hv eatdanw saueo hv a n e tesaeCo si t n adtevldt ae nce e ttt r ae med d h tt ntui ,n h aii to y

o taiiaieicaln e i auiilrceigwh ma apaicuto fhtntt shl gdn jdcapoedn, o y p ern ort iv e

dfn teiiaie eed h nt t ? iv
4

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 67 of 74

Caionassaetil n ap lt cuthv ruieyp r t d l ri' tt raa d p el e o rs ae otnl emie f a t iiitv poo ett dfn a iiit esv l iy adt ap a fo a ntaie rp n nso eed n nt i ' ai t,n o p elrm av d

jdmetodn a iiaieivl,atualwhnsaeotilhv ug nhlig nntt nai pri l y e tt fcas ae iv d c r s dcie t d s.(e ma.p .at,t p2-1)T et manraoso el do o o Se jon,neap .83. h wo i esn fr n
tisadr patc aeesl sae . hs tn ad rcie r ai ttd y

Frtte aii o adleatdsaeiiaiemesr (atual oe i ,h vl t f uy nce tt ntt auepri lr n s dy iv c y taa nsh s tCosit na Pooio 8de)samatr f ra htmed te te ntui ,s rp sin osi t o get a lo t e p bii otnehta b dtr ndoltruhjdcapoedns S c u l mprac tacn e eemie nyhog uiilrceig. uh c
poedn saemotl eyt po uearsltawi b rl be adtate rceig r s i l o rd c eutht l e ei l,n hth k l a p bi wi f dacpa l,fh ise aetoo g l advgrul liae . u l l i cetbeitesu s r h ru hy n ioo sy igtd c ln t

Astecut oiinnts( jon,neap .04)iiaiepooet h or' pno oe ma.p.at,t p4-3,ntt rpnns s iv

gnrl h v temoiainadtersucst liaetoo g l ad eeal a eh t to n h eo re o igt h ru hy n y v t

vgruli dfneo iiaiemesrshyhv sosrd(atual ioos n ees fntt aue te aepnoe prclr y iv i y whnst of ilhv dcie td s)adteeyt asth cutia e t e fias ae el d o o o,n hrb o si te or n a c n s s
wa ta ivtloteitgi o teetepo es y h ts i t h nert fh ni rcs. a y r Scn ,h iiaiep we wa ad dt tesaeCo siuini 11 eo dtent t o r s d e o h tt nttto n 9 1 iv

( 1C nt at1,j8 1) eas o teve wieyhla n C lonas Ca. os. r.1j ,0bcue fh iw, dl ed mog ai ri' , f
v tr,hth Leiltr adsaeofcash db cmes dpn et nseil oesta te gsaue n tt fiil a eo o eedn o p ca itrsstate weeu a eo uwiigt tk ato sta tep biitrs neet hthy r nbl r n ln o ae cin hth u l neet l c rq ie.Togv toesmesaeofcassl atoi t d cd whte o n t eurd ie h s a tt f il oe uh rt o eie ehr r o y ad l e atdiiai wi b dfn e i cut udb icnitn wi te uy nce nt t l e eedd n o rwo l en o sset t h i ve l h p r s adrto aeo teiiaiep we, ea s iwo l alw p bi upoe n ainl fh nt t o rbcuet ud lo u l iv c

ofcastruhiatn efcieytanlntt e tate dsiel(e f il,log nci ,fet l o nu iiai shthy i k. Se i z o v iv l B i igIdsrAsnvCto maio(96 4 Ca.d8082) uln nut s.. i fca rl 18) 1 l 1,2 . d y y l 3
1 Aths on an t o cuinii odr Whnten me dfn atna tip it oe f at sn re. e h a d ee dn i o lwsibo g tnaCaio asaecut el e t peet d fne adn a ut ru h i l mi tt o rdci so rsn a ees,n o f n (ontcnieon pg) f toeotudn atae o n
5

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 68 of 74

ltiepaainsf etoa s rh q eto tateNit Cic i shs x lnto ut n t nwe te u sin hth nh rut ki p sdt ticutwhc iwhte po o et o a iiit etatev tr oe o hs o r, ih s ehr rp n ns f n nt i hth oes av apo e hv ete atatuaie itrs'i teiiitv 'v l i o te p rv d ae i r t ri lrzd neet n h ntaies ai t rh h p c ' dy atoi t fseth saesitrs'i dfn igteiiit e Moe uh rt o srte tt' neet n eedn h nt i ? r y a ' av sei al,o siso a ticut o iinh lsta iiit epo o et p cscl d e th w, shs or' pno od,htntai rp n ns y s v h v atoiyt tseth saesitrs'i teiiaies aii ?Th a e uh rt o t srte tt' neet n h nt t 'v ldt e a ' iv y as ri s' nwe s . Ye ' Th wodSuh rt'i ista iiai po o ethaearg to e r toi 'mpl h tnt t rp nns v ih t a y e i ve dfn a iiit ei cutAl o g Caionassaecutg nrl hv eed n ntai n or. t u h l ri' tt o rs eeal ae v h f y dsrto t gato dn itreto ,t udb a aueo dsrto fra icein o rn r ey nevnin iwo l e n b s f icein o cutodn a iiit epo o etsmoint itreewhntev l i o te o rt ey n nt i rp n n' to o nevn e h ai t fh av dy iiit emesr ibigcaln e adCaionasaeofcasaen t ciey ntai aue s en hleg d n l ri tt fiil r o atvl v f

dfnigi (ema.p.at,t.9)Itasmainalatiiacrt eedn t Se jon,neap3. nhti t tes,tscue . o

t saeta iiaiepo o ethv atoi t itre es tateitgi o o tt htnt t rp n ns ae uh rt o nevn o h th nert f iv y y teiiaiepoesma b peevda dtev l i o teiiaiemesr h nt t rcs y e rsre n h ai t fh nt t aue iv dy iv

Io oeotud' peiupgl ot tcnieho rv sae n n m o ' p ryitree t asradfnet tepanifscam,wodfeetn at nevn so set ee s o h litf li t ifrn ad

ojseeutae os l dphig nte atuaccms ne. h poi rsl rpsie eedn o h prcl iu t cs Te t s b, i rr a ?a tf ywib dfutrsln iet oa ealug no sple lli ma n y eal eut gn nr f dfu jdmetrtua d nf , i y t i t Jdmetrnijh rqet rlf(e,., oe i.rc j 55esq, ug ngat teeusd ee See .C d CvPo. j 8 te. n e i g ,
646)B th tacut ydcd isedtawi ot gn iedsue 6 .. u ter lorma eienta ht t u a eun i t l h p bt e tepre,uiilciniuncsayadiaport,eutgia ewenh atsjdcaat s neesr n nprpiersln n i o a i ds saoteat nwi otnr o ayug n.(e i.j16; o n i slfh ci t u ety fn jdmet Seds 0 1C mmo mi o h C uevBor o uev os(99 4 C 1d4249P c Lg l as . ad fsp ri r 18) 9 a. 3,3; asc ea s 3 FonainvC lonaC atl o (92 3 Ca.d18 1011)Beas udt . afri osa C m.18) 3 1 5, 7-7. cue o 3
tepeet te cn en o l ten ro yfa dq eto p sdb teNit h rsn matr o crs ny h arwl rme u sin oe y h nh Cici whc o teet apoc e so l apyi ayp riua cs ia rut ih fhs wo p rahs h ud p l n n at lr aes n , c isen t eoetic ut ee su o bfr hs o rhr.
6

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 69 of 74

ma b rlbydtr n dtru hvg ru liainab t tetiln y e ei l eemie ho g ioo sigto t oh h ra ad a t

apltl es f ai ri'jdcasse p elee lo C lonasuiilytm. a v f

Il I T eatoi p sesdb teofcapoo et o a iiaiemesr h uh rt osse y h fiil rp nns f n nt t aue y iv

t asrtes t'itrsitaiiaies aii cmpe nsh jdcays o seth t esneetnhtntt 'vl t o lmetteuiir' a i v dy
atoi t ma etefnl eiino whte teiiaieiv l .Aslhv uh rt o k h ia dcso n eh rh nt t s ai y iv d ae srse i mysp rt o iin i teerirsmesxma ig scss tesd n eaae pno sn h al a -e n ae ae, e itmrtn saesaue adsaecntuin lrvso sa ddtr nn ter ne eig tt ttts n tt osi to apo iin,n eemiig h i t

vli,rtersos itotegvrmet jdcabac.(tas, ait aeh epnily fh oen n' uiilrnh Srus dy bi s spa4 C 1t 3446(ocono Kenr,. MaraeC ssspa4 ur,6 a.h 6,7 cn.p.f n adJ) rig ae,ur,3 4 ; Ca.t77 80(ocon oKenr,.L cyrspa 3 Ca.h15, l h 5,6 cn.p .f n adJ) oke,ur,3 lt 0 5 4 ; 4 12 (oc&dsono KemadJ. 15 cn. i.p .f r r,.) ) T euiilytmids ndt oeaetruhp bipoedn sn h jdcass s ei e o prt hog u l rceig i e g c
whc avraisliaefculn lglsustoo g l advg rul. ih d esre igt ataad ea ise h ru hy n ioo sy t Wh ha iiaiemesr icalne i cutteitgi a defcie es e n nt tv aue s hl gd n o r,h nert n fet ns i e y v

o teuiilrcsrqi taacmptn adsitddfneb peetd fh jdcapoeseur ht o eetn pre ees e rsne. e i

lp bi of ilrfs t po ietadfneteait o teiiaie f u l fi aseueo rvd ht ees,h bly fh nt t c c i iv po o ett itreei tep n igliain adt ap aa avre rp nnso nevn n h edn igt ,n o p eln d es t o

jdmetiihrni,n esniloteefcieeecs o,h ug n,sn eetnad set t h fet xrie fte a v

cntuin lntaiep we.Toh l ohr s n to l wo l u dr n ta o si to a ii t o r od tewie o ny ud n emieh t t iv cntuin l o rias wo l alw saeeeuiebac ofcast o si to ap we,t lo ud l tt x ct rn h f il o t o v efcieyan l oe-p rv diiaie smpl b d ciigt d fn te fet l n u v trapo e nt t s i y y el n o eed hm, v iv n teeypr tigtoeofcasoece terpo e rl i o rsae hrb emi n h s fiilt x ed h i rpr oen u tt t g vrmetscntuinltutr. o en n' o si toa srcue t

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 70 of 74

F rteeraosI ge ta, e saeofcasrfs t dfn av tr o hs esn, arehtwhn tt fiil eue o ee d oe-

apoe iiaiemesr icuqo t apaau g n ivl aigta p rvdntt auen or ro p el jdmetnai t ht iv dn

iiit ei oscapo o ethv at rt,samatro saelw,oasr ntai ,t f il rp nns a e uhoi a te ftt a t set v s y tesaesitrsi teiiaiesv l i . h tt' neetn h nt t ' ai t iv dy
KE NNARD,. J

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 71 of 74

Seataeoadessntlhnnmbrfronewmage iSpee or el pgfrdrseadepoeu esocusl/ rudn urm Cut s e .

Na o Opno Pryea.. o me f iin er t1vBrwn Un u lhdOpno p bi e iin s Orgn l pa iiaAp el Orgn l rceigX'x-o rqetusatorl858C l ue o Cor iiaPoedn X n eusprunt ue .4, a. l f ut R s ReiwGrne ve a td Reern Grne haig a td Opno No5 846 iin . 197 Dae ld Noe e l,0 1 tFi : vmbr 72 l e Co r: ut Co ny u t: Jd e u g:
1

C usl o ne: LwOf soAnrwP PgoAnrwP Pgi; lneDees Fn , inW.Ram,a sA. a t f de .un, de . ur Alac fne u dBr ke o i a u Jme Ca bl C o eadKi , als . o e,DaiH.hmpo, wadC. io,r NioeJ mpel oprn r ChreJCopr vd T o snHo r Nel nJ. cl . , ' k s , Mosn Ptr Ptro frnevnradApelns sad eeA. at sn o Itreesn pl t. e a E wiMes 1;onC. at nadKae JL g fr etroCosttnlui ndneaAmi s d n ee1 Jh E s n rn . uo o Cne f ntui aJrp zec s c 1 ma io s u C r e nbhlo Itreesn Apel t. ui o eaffnevnrad plns a a Sao L. o eHaodE.ono adDa e M.Shffr aic eaFudtn Wad r r hrn Brwn, rl Jh sn n min i f f o r Co , Gln Cute,Ro Un adT e wadJriTxacs o Pc ia Amiinrio bhlomel yn s d n z n h Ho r avs apyrAsoiinL glo uae , ea f y r e scao s cC i n f t a ltreesn Apelns nevnrad pl t. a Pcf Jsielsi eKeiT Sie, te B.McenlsadKelA. yfr .oh a aic ut nt , vn .ndrMat w R yod n l Wa o DrJsu i c mt h y Beke aAmiu C r eo bhlo ItreesadApel t. cly s cs ui n eaf fnevnr n plns a a JmeJsp L nhJ.fr riRel a Amiu C ra o bhlo ltreesn Apelns a soeh yc,r o Mage iy s cs uie n eaffnevnrad pl t. , l a Jl B. erdfruiil thlc,s csC reo bhlo Itrees n Ap elns ui Axl o JdcaWac,n.aAmiu ui n eaf fnevnrad pl t. e o a a Bos, cir FenrDaiBoe,JrmyM. lma, hooe Un ; bo,D l &Crt e, ieShl & lxe, vd is ee Go nT edrH. o Gisn e d T edr B. sn Mate D. Gi, rC.T yaiT edr JBotosJ.C rumhr . c r hooe Olo, t w Mc l Ami arn, hooe . uru,r hio eDu h h l , sp t Dusatn Eniu A. ngso PanisadR sodns selad rqe Moaafr litf n epnet. f KedlBi &KlgrL uaW. rlNihls .Dam, ibdSDaisnadAsleR.L n fr nal rl i e, ar Bi, coaF u Cllr . vdo n he l e l f JnB. snegadPoesr ar L.Lvno aAmi Cui o bhlo Pa tfad yn o o Ei br n rfso Lui eesn s c r e n ea f lnf n e e i a f iis Rsodns epnet.

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 72 of 74

Pae2-5846-o necniud g. 197 cu slotn e Co ne: u sl

CrzCto Oaln, i o ClvraeConyo SnMae, i o SnaCu adConyo Snma u, i f kad Ct f oedl; ut f a toCt f at rz n ut f oo y y y a Amii ra o bhlo Panisn R sodns s cCuie n eaf f litfad epnet. f Dens. reaCi Atre, eeeM.twatCheDeuyCi Atre.Da yChuC if f niJHerr, t t nyThrs Se r if pt t t ny mz o, heo y o , y o Co l adSeil igto, neC hbi, leM. eadCusieVa AknDeuyCt mpe n pcaLt ainVic har Mol Le n lit n e, pt i x i a i n y At resfrnevnrn Repnet t ny,o Itreead sodn. o Cad lLsi& PotrDaiC. oelAlet agAlsar col Sao PMitradJn lwel el rco, vd C dl brGin, atiAgai;hrn . ne;n o , e , i W. vdo fr qai C loz, tnl etroLeba RihsadLmb a eaDees ad Daisn o E uly aini Nai aCnefr sin gt n a d L gl fne n t f a o E uainFn,n.a Amii uieo bhlo ItreeadRepnet dct udIc,s cC ra n eaffnevnr n sodn. o Grie, rnSen&RihadRoiMedwadC nha T bs nfr egeoCai ri ensMat,ti cln, bn ao n ytiE. oi o Lau f lona i ma f Wo nVoes f ai lia Amiu C ra o bhlo ItreeadRepnet me tro C lo a s cs uie n eaffnevnr n sodn. fm EiAl Iaco' ua Ka WevrSae M. pa;n Re.ioNadn fr lonaFi fr r a sasnS sn y ae;tcy Kalnad v Sl roio Cai ri at o c n , v f h E ulyC lo aConioChrhsGeeaSn do te idChrho ChitUnvra qai , ai mi ucl f uce, nrl yo fh Unt uc f r , iesl t f e s Flwsio Merp la Co nt C uce, h E i oaBihp o C lonaadL s gls el hp f t oin mmui hrhsT e ps pl sos f ai ri n o Anee, o o t y c f PorsieJwi Alac, aicAsoiino ReomRabsUntra Unvrai Asoiinad rgesv e s lnePcf scao f fr b i, i in ieslt scao n h i i t a s t UntrnU ieslt eiaieMiir C lonaaAmii uieo bhlo Itreead i i nvrai Lgs t nsy ai ri s cC r n eaf fnevnr n aa s lv t f a Repnet sodn. Ka lD. ri At re Geea, neM. di sSaeSlir nrlDai C ae, if maa Har, t ny nrlMaul Meer , tt oit Geea, vd hnyChe s o o co AssnAtnyGnrlD ul JWod, tgAst t tre Geea Mi al rno st t tre eea, oga . osAcn ssnAtny nrl c eTocs, ia o s i ia o , h Sno Cone, ntneL Ll us n T maPctrDeuyAtresGeea,s cCuie eir uslCos c . ea iad a r ahe, pt t ny nrlaAmii ra. a o o

MieMuzCutCuslSna la,oi.egAsttony o eJ pr. g l r e,ony one(atCa)LrEPg,sia CutCt lt eL u q r sn ms,mi Do sAcigLa DeuyComtCone,en SYei,mpcLtainFl w; cio, wn, t ed pt l y u slJny . l I at igt el Athsn n n i o o BroeCnot&Koaei ,o G.ain,iAtnytatCulJh A.us,i ain,odt vcvc Jl BroeCt tre sna rz;on RsoCt s i h m s y o y Atnyt kad,abrJPre,heAsttiAtnyJl CBisCutCusl tre oal lBraa.akrCi ssnCt tre;o .er on one o n f ia y o m e, y trne,lnM.eyDeuy on CuslEiDnyDaa ReCt y o e(at oaglGe Lv, ptCut one r al; nMca,o Ct lSna n y ;c mt ms Culad rcD.odtiCutCuslSnma,oCutoSna laCutoSna rz;n Bue Gls n ony one(oo )fronyfatCa,ony fat e r

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 73 of 74

C usl h age iSpe C utntneddfr ulainwtoiin: onew o rudn u rme or(oitne o pbi t i pno) co h
Chr s. opr al JC oe e Coprn Ki oead r k 12 Ne Ha si AvneN. 53 w mphr eu, W. e WahntnD. 2 06 sigo, C. 03

(0)2-60 222090

T edrB. sn hooe Olo GisnDum&Cnthr bo, l z e c 15 C netu Avn eN. 00 onci t eu, W. c Wahntn D. 2 06 sigo, C. 03

(0)5-50 229580

- +-- 1--

feeefee - x t lcvor r

w- - - - - - e- c ws - i

Case: 10-16696

12/22/2011

ID: 8011866

DktEntry: 397

Page: 74 of 74