CIVIL PROCEDURE SY 2011-2012 II Manresa Case Outline Rule 6-22 Atty. Melissa Romana P.

Suarez

Rule 6
Topic Sec. 3 Case Title Zaida Alberto v. CA-d Flour Daniel v. EB Villarosa-g Citation GARCIA TUMAND A GR 119088 159648 Date Jun 30, 2000 Jul 27, 2007

Sec. 5

Tropical Homes v. CA-f Lucia Miranda v. Esperanza Besa-N

DOMING O DE PERALTA

111858 146513

May 14, 2007 Jul 30, 2004

Sec. 6

Mel Velarde v. Lopez-N UST v. CA-Q

RIZADA QUIBOD

153886 124250

Jan 14, 2004 Oct 18, 2004

Sec. 7

Spouses Meliton v. CA-T Felipe Yulienco v. CAFinancial Building v. Forbes ParkEvangeline Alday v. FGU InsuranceTan v. Kaakbay Finance Korea Exchange Bank v. Judge Gonzales

CABADING ONTAL ILUSTRISIM O FERNANDO NARTATEZ DE CASTRO

101883 131692 133119 138822 146595 142286

Dec 11, 1992 Jun 10, 1999 Aug 17, 2000 Jan 23, 2001 Jun 20, 2003 Apr 15, 2005

Sec. 8

Florencio Ruiz v. CA Ligon v. CA-D

GARCIA DOMING O

101566 127683

Aug 17, 1992 Aug 7. 1998

Sec. 11

Samala v. Victo-F Allied Bank v. CA Erasmo Tayao v. Rosa Mendoza ACDC v. CA CDCP v. Cuenca Sarmiento v. CA

RIZADA TUMANDA CABADING ONTAL QUIBOD NARTATEZ ILUSTRISIM O FERNAND O DE PERALTA

L-53969 123871 162733 160242 163981 152627

Feb 21, 1989 Aug 31, 1998 Apr 12, 2005 May 17, 2005 Aug 12, 2005 Sep 16, 2005

Sec. 12,14

Lafarge v. CCC

155173

Nov 23, 2004

Rule 7
Topic Sec. 2 Case Title PCIC v. PNCC Citation DE CASTRO GR 185066 Date Oct 2, 2009

Sec. 3

Buklaran v. CA Dadizon v. Bernadas Jocson v. CA SOPA v. Santos

NUNEZA GALAGA R TUMAND A ECHAVE Z

158158 172367 162836 152579

Jan 17, 2005 Jun 5, 2009 Jul 30, 2009 Aug 4, 2009

Sec. 4

Robern v. Judge Jesus Quitain

FERNANDO

135042

Sep 23, 1999

Verification

Torres v. Specialized Christine Chua v. Jorge Torres Rolando Clavecilla v. Spouses Quitain Fernando Go v. CA Marohomsalic v. Cole Negros Planters v. Presiding Judge Vallacar Transit v. Catubig Pagadora v. Ilao

CHAN NARTATEZ ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO

149634 151900 147989 163745 169918 179878 175512 165769

Jul 6, 2004 Aug 30, 2005 Feb 20, 2006 Aug 24, 2007 Feb 27, 2008 Dec 24, 2008 May 30, 2011 Dec 12, 2011

Sec. 5 None

Arquiza v. CA Eastland v. Mortel

GALAGA R GARCIA

160479 165648

Jun 8, 2005 Mar 23, 2006

Sec. 5 Defective

BA Saving Bank v. Roger Sia BPI Leasing Corp. v. CA Torres v. Specialized Expert Travel v. CA and KAL Spouses Estares v. CA Levi Strauss v. Vogue Traders Daniel Aninao v. Asturias Chemicals Concepcion Ancheta v. Metrobank PAL v. FASAP Wilson and Peter Go v. Rico RBA v. Salvaa Panfilo Abaigar v. Jesus Abaigar Teresa Gabriel v. CA Chinese YMCA v. Remington Steel Altres v. Empleo Vda. De Formoso v. PNB RP v. Coalbrine Mediserve v. CA Mandaue Galleon v. Isidto Atty. Bautista v. Judge Causapin

NARTATEZ ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMANDA NUNEZA CHAN CABADING FERNANDO ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO GALAGAR GARCIA NARTATEZ ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMANDA

131214 127624 149634 152392 144755 132993 160420 163410 143088 140862 175020 167003 149909 159422 180986 154704 161838 161368 181051 07-2044

Jul 27, 2000 Nov 18, 2003 Jul 6, 2004 May 26, 2005 Jun 8, 2005 Jun 29, 2005 Jul 28, 2005 Sep 16, 2005 Jan 26, 2006 Apr 25, 2006 Oct 4, 2007 Oct 23, 2006 Oct 11, 2007 Mar 28, 2008 Dec 10, 2008 Jun 1, 2011 Apr 7, 2010 Apr 5, 2010 Jul 5, 2010 Jun 22, 2011

Sec. 5 False

Cladius Barroso v. Judge Ampig Espinosa v. CA RMC v. Siesenando Singson

NUNEZA CHAN CABADIN G

138218 128686 150798

Mar 17, 2000 May 28, 2004 Mar 31, 2005

Sec. 5 Forum Shopping

Tirona v. Judge Alejo Land Car v. Bachelor Express Evelyn Paradero v. Judge Abragan Nordic Asia v. CA Reyes de Leon v. Del Rosario HSBC v. Cecilia Diez Catalan Guaranteed Hotels,v. Josefina Baltao Korean Exchange Bank v. Gonzales Levi Strauss v. Vogue Traders Spouses de la Cruz v. Pedro Joaquin Manuel Laxina v. Ombudsman Amando San Juan v. Miguel Arambulo Angel and Maritoni Sadang v. CA Spouses Cruz v. Spouses Caraos Wacnang v. Comelec SOPA v. Santos

FERNANDO ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO GALAGAR GARCIA NARTATEZ ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMANDA NUNEZA CHAN CABADING

129313 154377 158917 111159 152862 159590 164338 142286 132993 162788 153155 143217 140138 138208 178024 152579

Oct 10, 2001 Dec 8, 2003 Mar 1, 2004 Jul 13, 2004 Jul 26, 2004 Oct 18, 2004 Jan 17, 2005 Apr 15, 2005 Jun 29, 2005 Jul 28, 2005 Sep 30, 2005 Dec 14, 2005 Oct 11, 2006 Apr 23, 2007 Oct 17, 2008 Aug 4, 2009

Rule 8

Topic Sec. 2 Rule 8 Topic Sec. 1

Case Title PCIC v. PNCC

Citation FERNAND O Citation ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO GALAGAR GARCIA NARTATEZ

GR 185066

Date Oct 2, 2009

Case Title Marie Jao v. China Banking Lucas v. Lucas Soriente v. Estate of Concepcion Associated Bank v. Montano Luistro v. CA Tiu v. PB Com Eastern Shipping v. Prudential Filtex & Villanueva v. CA Permanent Savings v. Velarde

GR 149468 190710 160239 166383 158819 151932 174116 119800 140608

Date Oct 23, 2006 Jun 6, 2011 Nov 25, 2009 Oct 16, 2009 Apr 16, 2009 Aug 19, 2009 Sep 11, 2009 Nov 12, 2003 Sep 23, 2004

Sec. 4 Sec. 5

Sec. 7

Sec. 8

Sec. 10

Teraa v. De Sagun PBCOM v. Spouses Go RP v. SB

ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMANDA

152131 175514 166859

Apr 29, 2009 Feb 14, 2011 Apr 12, 2011

Rule 9
Topic Sec. 1 Case Title Villanueva v. CA Katon v. Palanca Aquino v. Aure Anunciacion v. Bocanegra Toshiba v. CIR Sec. 2 Diaz v. Diaz Financial v. Forbes Park Reyes-De Leon v. Del Rosario Loadmasters v. Glodel Sec. 3 Viron v. Pantranco Cerezo v. Tuazon Acance v. CA Sablas v. Sablas United Overseas Bank v. Rosemoor Monzon v. Relova David v. Judge Fruelda BDO v. Tansipek Heirs of Medrano v. De Vera City of Manila v. Te Citation NUNEZA CHAN CABADIN G FERNAN DO ONTAL DOMING O ILUSTRIS IMO QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO GALAGAR GARCIA NARTATE Z ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMAND A NUNEZA CHAN CABADIN G GR 143286 151149 153567 152496 157594 135885 133119 152862 179446 117020 141538 159699 144568 172651 171827 170427 181235 165770 169263 Date Apr 14, 2004 Sep 7, 2004 Feb 18, 2008 Jul 30, 2009 Mar 5, 2010 Apr 28, 2000 Aug 17, 2000 Jul 26, 2004 Jan 10, 2011 Apr 4, 2003 Mar 23, 2004 Mar 16, 2005 Jul 3, 2007 Oct 2, 2007 Sep 17, 2008 Jan 30, 2009 Jul 22, 2009 Aug 9, 2010 Sep 21, 2011

Rule 10
Topic Sec. 2 & 3 Case Title Spouses Tirona v. Judge Alejo Leonardo Andres v. Serafin Cuevas Armand Nocum v. Lucio Tan Rafael Bautista v. Maya-maya Cottages Citation FERNANDO ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM GR 129313 150869 145022 148361 Date Oct 10, 2001 Jun 29, 2005 Sep 23, 2005 Nov 29, 2005

PPA v. WG&A Biglang-Awa v. PTC Limbauan v. Acosta Tiu v. PB Com

O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO GALAGAR

158401 158998 148606 151932

Jan 28, 2008 Mar 28, 2008 Jun 30, 2008 Aug 19, 2009

Sec. 4

Zosimo Godinez v. CA

GARCI A

154330

Feb 15 2007

Sec. 5

Spouses Mercader v. DBP Lolita Ayson v. Marina Enriquez Azolla Farms v. CA and Savings Bank Royal Cargo v. DFS Sports Wenceslao v. Freyssinet Panganiban v. Spouses Roldan New Sun Valley v. Sangguniang

NARTATE Z ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMAND A NUNEZA CHAN CABADIN G

130699 152438 138085 158621 166857 163053 156686

May 12, 2000 Jun 17, 2004 Nov 11, 2004 Dec 10, 2008 Sep 11, 2009 Nov 25, 2009 Jul 27, 2011

Sec. 6, 7

APT v. CA Oaminal v. Castillo Planters Development v. LZK Holdings Lambino v. Presiding Judge Chan v. Chan

FERNANDO ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD

81024 152776 153777 169551 150746

Feb 3, 2000 Oct 8, 2003 Apr 15, 2005 Jan 24, 2007 Oct 15, 2008

Sec. 8

PEF v. PII Cagungun v. PDB

DE PERALT A DE CASTRO

120384 158674

Jan 13, 2004 Oct 17, 2005

Rule 11
Topic Sec. 7 Case Title Chan v. Chan Citation GALAGA R GR 150746 Date Oct 15, 2008

Topic Sec. 11

Case Title Crisologo-Jose v. Land Bank

Citation GARCIA

GR 167339

Date Jun 22, 2006

Rule 13
Topic Sec. 2 Case Title Rene Ramos v. Antonio Lim Jimmy Go v. Judge Abrogar Citation NARTATE Z ECHAVEZ GR 133496 145213 Date May 9, 2005 Mar 28, 2006

Sec. 4

Atty. Julius Nery v. Judge de la Pea

RIZAD A

05-1896

Apr 29, 2005

Sec. 6

Spouses Tagle v. CA

TUMAND A

162738

Jul 8, 2009

Sec. 7

Spouses Belen v. Chavez

NUNEZ A

175334

Mar 26, 2008

Sec. 8

Cheng v. Javier

CHAN

182485

Jul 3, 2009

Sec. 10

Land Bank v. Heirs of Alsua Tomawis v. Tabao-Caudang PAL v. Heirs of Zamora

CABADIN G FERNAND O ONTAL

167361 166547 164267

Apr 2, 2007 Sep 12, 2007 Mar 31, 2009

Sec. 11

Maceda v. De Guzman Teresa Gabriel v. CA Tible & Tible v. Royal Savings Reyes v. NLRC Quileste v. People

DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO

164947 149909 155806 180551 180334

Jan 31, 2006 Oct 11, 2007 Apr 8, 2008 Feb 10, 2009 Feb 18, 2009

Sec. 13

Government v. Aballe

GALAGA R

147212

Mar 24, 2006

Sec. 14

Heirs Lopez v. Judge Enriquez David Lu v. Paterno Lu Ym Delfin Tan v. Benolirao

GARCIA NARTATE Z ECHAVEZ

146262 153690 158380

Jan 21, 2005 Aug 4, 2009 Oct 16, 2009

Rule 14
Topic Sec. 6, 7 Case Title Lazaro v. Rural Bank of Balagtas Oaminal v. Castillo Spouses Jose v. Spouses Boyon Domagas v. Jensen Manotoc v. CA Alegar Corporation Regner v. Logarta Potenciano v. Barnes Sansio v. Mogol Spouses Galura v. Math-Agro Wong v. Koyama Sagana v. Francisco Garcia v. SB Pascual v. Pascual Citation RIZADA TUMANDA NUNEZA CHAN CABADING FERNANDO ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO GALAGAR GARCIA GR 139895 152776 147369 158407 130974 172555 168747 159421 177077 167230 183802 161952 170122 171916 Date Aug 15, 2003 Oct 8, 2003 Oct 23, 2003 Jan 17, 2005 Aug 16, 2006 Jul 10, 2007 Oct 19, 2007 Aug 20, 2008 Jul 14, 2009 Aug 14, 2009 Sep 17, 2009 Oct 2, 2009 Oct 12, 2009 Dec 4, 2009

Sec. 11

Aboitiz v. CA Weena Express v. Rapacon Paramount Insurance v. Ordonez BD Long Span v. Ampeloquio

NARTATE Z ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMAND A

142272 149625 175109 169919

May 2, 2006 Sep 28, 2007 Aug 6, 2008 Sep 11, 2009

Sec. 12

HSBC v. Cecilia Diez Catalan Pioneer v. Guadiz

NUNEZA CHAN

159590 156848

Oct 18, 2004 Oct 11, 2007

Sec. 14

Santos v. PNOC

CABADIN G

170943

Sep 23, 2008

Sec. 15

Romualdez v. Licaros Rosalino Acance v. CA

FERNANDO ONTAL

150656 159699

Apr 29, 2003 Mar 16, 2005

Velayo-Fong v. Spouses Velayo Perkin Elmer v. Dakila Trading Regner v. Logarta

DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD

155488 172242 168747

Dec 6, 2006 Aug 14, 2007 Oct 19, 2007

Sec. 19

Gonzales v. CA

DE PERALT A

150908

Jan 21, 2005

Sec. 20

Gonzales v. Balikatan Anunciacion v. Bocanegra Wong v. Koyama Garcia v. SB Rapid City v. Villa Palma v. Judge Galvez NM Rothschild v. Lepanto

DE CASTRO GALAGA R GARCIA NARTATE Z ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMAND A

150859 152496 183802 170122 184197 165273 175799

Mar 28, 2005 Jul 30, 2009 Sep 17, 2009 Oct 12, 2009 Feb 11, 2010 Mar 10, 2010 Nov 28, 2011

Rule 15
Sec. 2 Gonzales v. Balikatan NUNEZ A 150859 Mar 28, 2005

Sec. 4

Patricio v. Judge Leviste Winnie Bajet v. Judge Baclig Atty. Fabella v. Judge Lee Gutierrez v. Cabrera Atty. Neri v. Judge Dela Pena Alfero Bagano v. Judge Hontanosas Primetown Property v. Juntilla Jehan Shipping v. NFA Fajardo v. Comandante

CHAN CABADING FERNANDO ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO

51832 00-1598 04-1518 154064 05-1896 15-1915 157801 159750 185396

Apr 26, 1989 Jul 30, 2002 Jan 15, 2004 Feb 28, 2005 Apr 29, 2005 May 6, 2005 Jun 8, 2005 Dec 14, 2005 Nov 24, 2009

Sec. 8

Anunciacion v. Bocanegra

GALAGA R

152496

Jul 30, 2009

Rule 16
Sec. 1 Allied Bank v. CA PNB v. CA R & M General v. CA and La Perla Tirona v. Judge Alejo Malayang Samahan v. Pinakamasarap Clark v. Mondragon Silangan Textile v. Baricuatro v. Caballero Fil-Estate Golf v. Navarro Forbes Park v. Pagrel City of Makati v. Taguig Spouses Santos v. Heirs of Lustre Villarica Pawnshop v. Gernale Heirs of Maramag v. De Guzman Vitangcol v. New Vista GARCIA NARTATEZ ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMANDA NUNEZA CHAN CABADING FERNANDO ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO 95223 121251 144189 129313 139068 150986 166719 1586433 152575 153821 163175 151016 163344 181132 176014 Jul 26, 1996 Jun 26, 1998 Oct 5, 2001 Oct 10, 2001 Jan 16, 2004 Mar 2, 2007 Mar 12, 2007 Jun 19, 2007 Jun 29, 2007 Feb 13, 2008 Jun 27, 2008 Aug 6, 2008 Mar 20, 2009 Jun 5, 2009 Sep 17, 2009

Subic Telecom v. SBMA Dotmatrix v. Legaspi

GALAGAR GARCIA

185159 155622

Oct 12, 2009 Oct 26, 2009

Sec. 5, 6

Misamis v. David Navarro v. Metrobank Associated Bank v.Montano

NARTATE Z ECHAVEZ RIZADA

129928 165697 166383

Aug 25, 2005 Aug 4, 2009 Oct 16, 2009

Rule 17
Sec. 1 DBP v. Pingol Land Transport OB Jovenir v. Macamir Realty TUMAND A NUNEZA 145908 135803 Jan 22, 2004 Mar 28, 2006

Sec. 2

Landcenter v. Ponce, Inc.

CHAN

160409

Oct 2, 2009

Sec. 3

Sto. Domingo-David v. Judge Guerrero Josefina Cruz v. CA Edgardo Pinga v. Heirs of Santiago Regner v. Logarta Gomez v. Alcantara Polanco v. Cruz Atty. Pontejos v. Desierto Spouses Corpus v. Citibank Espiritu v. Lazaro

CABADING FERNANDO ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO GALAGAR GARCIA

120965 164797 170354 168747 179556 182426 148600 175677 181020

Sep 25, 1998 Feb 13, 2006 Jun 30, 2006 Oct 19, 2007 Feb 13, 2009 Feb 13, 2009 Jul 7, 2009 Jul 31, 2009 Nov 25, 2009

Rule 18
Topic Sec. 1 Case Title Espiritu v. Lazaro Citation NARTATE Z GR 181020 Date Nov 25, 2009

Sec. 3

Mariano de Guia v. Ciracio de Guia

ECHAVE Z

135384

Apr 4, 2001

Sec. 4, 5,6

Victory Line v. CA Johanne Pea v. CA Rodolfo Paredes Anson Trade v. Pacific Bank BPI v. Dando Vda. De Agatep v. Rodriguez

RIZADA TUMAND A NUNEZA CHAN CABADIN G FERNAND O

125034 126275 164375 179999 177456 170540

Jul 30, 1998 Nov 11, 2004 Oct 12, 2006 Mar 17, 2009 Sep 4, 2009 Oct 28, 2009

Sec. 7

PCIB v. CA Heirs of Conahap v. Heirs of Regea

ONTAL DOMING O

34959 152021

Mar 18, 1988 May 17, 2005

Barangay Conciliation LGC RA 7160

Topic Sec. 408-409 Case Title Vercide v. Judge Hernandez Berba v. Heirs of Palanca Pascual v. Pascual Citation ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA GR 00-1265 160032 157830 Date Apr 6, 2000 Nov 11, 2005 Nov 17, 2005

Sec. 412

Atty. Magno v. Atty. Jacoba Aquino v. Aure Wee v. De Castro

DE CASTRO GALAGA R GARCIA

05-6296 163567 176405

Nov 22, 2005 Feb 18, 2008 Aug 20, 2008

Rule 19
Topic Sec. 1 Case Title Viginia Clareza v. Benjamin Rosales Nordic Asia v. Ca Foster-Gallego v. Spouses Galang Elmar Perez v. CA Joshua Alfelor v. Josefina Halasan Executive Secretary v. Northeast Lopez v. CA Rural Bank of Sta. Barbara v. Manila Mission NARTATE Z ECHAVEZ RIZADA TUMAND A NUNEZA CHAN CABADIN G FERNAND O GR 15364 111159 130228 162580 165987 179516 164108 130223 Date May 31, 1961 Jul 13, 2004 Jul 27, 2004 Jan 27, 2006 Mar 31, 2006 Mar 17, 2009 May 8, 2009 Aug 19, 2009

Sec. 2

Spouses Magat v. Spouses Delizo International Pipes v. FF Cruz Demosthenes Agan v. PIATCO Diana Jean Lopez v. Spouses Pozon Concepcion Ancheta v. Metrobank Salandanan v. Mendez Associated Bank v. Ponstroller

ONTAL DOMINGO ILUSTRISIM O QUIBOD DE PERALTA DE CASTRO GALAGAR

135199 127543 155001 152745 163410 160280 148444

Jul 5, 2001 Aug 16, 2001 Jan 21, 2004 Mar 17, 2004 Sep 16, 2005 Mar 13, 2009 Sep 3, 2009

Rule 21
Topic Sec. 2 Case Title Lorena-Collado v. Teresita Bravo Armando Canillas v. Corazon Pelayo Citation GARCIA NARTATE Z GR 99-1307 02-1575 Date Apr 10, 2001 Aug 1, 2002

Sec. 3

HC Liebenow v. PVOC Gil Georga v. Judge Pedro Quitain Universal Rubber v. CA Lorena Collado v. Teresita Bravo

ECHAVE Z RIZADA TUMAND A NUNEZA

13463 981 30266 99-1307

Nov 9, 1918 Jul 29, 1977 Jun 29, 1984 Apr 10, 2001

Sec. 6

Macaspac v. Flores

CHAN

05-2072

Ag 13, 2008

Rule 22
Topic Sec. 1 Case Title Vilma Labad v. USP Emmanuel Herbosa v. CA Jaime Luz v. National Amnesty Commission Domingo Neypes v. CA Aguilar v. CA CABADIN G FERNAND O ONTAL DOMINGO GR 139665 119086 159708 141524 172986 Date Aug 9, 2001 Jan 25, 2002 Sep 24, 2004 Sep 14, 2005 Oct 2, 2009

Sec. 2

Rural Bank of Caloocan v. CA

ILUSTRISIM

32116

Apr 21, 1981

Donato Sumaway v. Urban Bank

O QUIBOD

142534

Jun 27, 2006