Professional Documents
Culture Documents
विज्ञान आणि बुद्धिवाद Chapter 6A खरे विज्ञान खोटे विज्ञान
विज्ञान आणि बुद्धिवाद Chapter 6A खरे विज्ञान खोटे विज्ञान
Im
I'
4)(rl/rl..
'ffr JlIfff'
HIT6lI11fI
rlIfii:Jf7J ~
f.!t4fol
.".,m.ml. filjlf:1fWI
3~ 1~(ijll ~ ~ Cfi«fT ~.
f.!!Fl1T
"IIdtt 'fkiII:rrft,
~~
ft4t1ll1lq I~
f?iqi.."
I'd~
~
-qfu' ~ri!
1UriR1ilf.f'l1 gf406ffitt~
If1fe{1'l
m'lfllT QiUl4:a?
d('C4'11f~liiql}jj&q)q<+il~
How to defend society against science ? (~~l"1lql~'" 'Ei"''5Tf~q::;irlk&TOT Cf)(lq:CI 7) "lI1 qtiCill4I~1 ~
f4~r.4P:rI~
~
atT1'iff~
mPJUT Of){U4141
~.
~aCfll~
liTS. ~ ~ ~
3Rfr~
~ ~
~
T["{if
~ant;1li!fl
ctlllcfl,
~"tJ'Tlff
aI2~1(;I1"ft
Cl'f"Ctiif)i .. , ~
q;n:{~"WfI
affi
SlRNI<H ~
~
~, ~
t1ql~ltftcl
~QJ}fiJ
~"¥IT
~~
~
~~, ~
3-l'Q~
\ifT1TT Fa-~,o:rl~~
it t1'iI'51!~
~
am.
am-. ~m~"
~
~ ~:~~
:mfitT ~
ahl'-'l""Slq,~:q
~OificH ~
~-'i1q(~+t11
~~
rr~i;fI:g:q 1.311t ~~
~~I(~a h1~lI"RT~.
iN"Itfifi::r
~
I ~,
CfiGT~
aN ~ jrffi ~, ~
~:ql(cidi"'ll ~~HI~ ~ 'i414ffi<t ~~~~.
ftfim
Cf'l(UII=lI I, trcf
si~ ~ 11"i\::t~f::::q
f4*HIii41
am-.
I,
ii'lI(ucn;:ft ~;mft.
~I!:I~
ra~I"1r4f.tqfoT if;Hi"fItr~illf{Cf)
1M ~tt ~~I~Cf) '~'
!]ct14firtl~,
aW ?ti(J(l4Sil
qrscll~,
';it ~:qI(;id~
~~
§t'f:tlltl ~
~
~
~~~
<it
~ -cnfl3H'I~14 (fi ~
q16ij~fmil'~'
(f('ffrtt Ullqql('f~~,
~t ~~~~~
a-et1!4~. ~~
Fet;q!(i~ lR\if ~.
~.
f4i4I(i;;t) ~ tfUl '(rM~
am. :g~
m~,
~elft"
I~'
;it
t:lfda:srf;(l fefR~
iif'i:4l(i~"~6T~~
~ ~'ffi:
Ilas:rlcfl ~
}I (I
JI HI i:t
q.
Si~Iff' t'fl ~
t'I fCf011:tfl1:fl ~
.:r:~u~ll;OfiT ~"iII(I~1f4'iffMfn"l'!:l
tf4!m~
31T%, ~
w-ttl(l'tl ~
Q~!It1~.
~m ~
~ ~
'ffi: 4;q(l~:S';P:~;1Jf1lT~
~~
~,
% ftr.i ~
~
70fKftuT ~.
~ ~ ~i5Iff1C6 ~
3;:':15(01 ~
m~~~~.)~3WJT3if{ROilct
cnri~f~ ~
~ q~ ~.
~ ~~~
~~f(ci d ~
am. ~
({
m~
~
re"id ~
~ 41tiflt'll ~'ll~{ ~
m ;rrtt.
~u;qlitumJ f<iYh1tft
qtJJ ~
EfilQf.tCfiO(.1 ~
tdOi I ~
~ <Sif!1111:t[J&I~
~<Wt
[%OIf404k1
~ma
I~'~.
q~~
~l~t?1, ~
~~~m!
q'tlll!i'nH'I q~ftp;q
fth~:ih~11~~
G1Qiolt
~,
ChIt1ql61q~
~, a l1i~1I!fi;?'~'
qit;~ ~
~~.
Ef'ItU'Q l"iilfl~
q Fct*141(ff~
$ilcl~~~!f11~4
"ift
~~,
511 J)~
m 3llfUy % ~
CR ~
§t'Pllltfi ~
Qlsuljli41 -~
~:ql(lifl
~ 14~ "flri;fi ~
~ Cfi~=rl
~ lilo5l
off l)ROllIlm ~
~ok1it ~i:gulHi1
~
'Hf4I:Jl
~~If?tdi"ii!fl
ijl '~'~
ih=zn.
m~.
3ilq~44idl~(ft
-ar.m~
~ Rtll
mOO(
~%~I~ij\'1
iR~
~fd(tli"1' 3leH~1
?~
't~~I1Sl~~,
~ let""1 4llH14${"IllSrt ~
m&fIJT il60I?fql~
~~,ItCf) §tq~lIttqFEi..4
~?
'!JUT
~
q;{lq<H~ ~,~
m!8UT
:~:t'U"ilI=it W!ffUl
#1(ItI;l?,
a:mT ~
~ ~iij
I RI9Ii.'1 f ~
tf'NI
tit?
fcQrR tt ~ ~~1(SIOIIt¥fi
am
'al t1'i\ild).
q, 0 1 ) dTtt
tfti411tl;:ft
W[ift ~~,
~ ~"Ilf.=lJ ~
~~tr~
~.
quJ ~
~:qRgollt?ft
~,
tt 14;q I'(5IUlltAl
Q1f
~
am Cfi11f?
(R
Rt;;qlttil
it arntft
~#fI~~~TliEiI
q.'lOHlig ~ ~~i<'tI:Jl ~ $141dtcl ~ g~tfqd
tl' ~
~
qtf ~
m:ram.
~ lfR ~
Cflf~tt~%t:fRRflJNf;'~ ~~~tnWi~~\ilIOlffi
~ >flIT01 'J:I'Rffi ~
tmf' ~Oljlifl ~ VlfM ~ ~. fl!n~~ ~. ~ ~1~i1 ftsItitOi W4ff4w qq 3ffi", Ci~iI1(1oll~i~1 ~'1ISl(n.sw~,~
3lUttlIN(c1inft,
~ q~ Cf
~~
~.
am. ~
iKrr. ~
~
~:nFlrcft ~
~
~
RI~1.. 1i4'64
am. Sf;l41lf&il1ijl<~
aJi;;jfi?l~.
Fft ~
~,
~ CR tf if?H,8~
~~fonfcff;4~,
"%~~q
q ~ifl
altl~~~
iIf~'1i(1
~
Q'~,,"
*r, ~
_ ~
~Holl:::<£ji~1 tcff5lQpi}~Iflftq;
~
'ij'OO ~;miffi
ntt
4"R1~6
~~I~q:;
ftCfi ~
~<Uql~ ~
0\<fI ~
eJ;(O~H"~,
I4~HI~Il%~
~Cf1f~11"R1T
'1tIOI(11, arnT ~
~
f4"qfuJ
~
'5fIfTUT ~
cr~
~
a.m. ~IPlCf)ii41 ~
~
~.
I c;{11l{f(1 amR
~;;mIT.
6FI1{Ollfllcfl ~
'Q'ttfF~
:-mn ~
'iR'ffi
*',
~
(1:;;q~II(,l'"1lql~"'I f)I(Cfl\9 ~ C
31m 31T!.m
am. S!i1:S(fQH'I, ~
~~~, ~
m~
ti41'ii11"q1~
~ ~~H~t!1t;ft~ ~
iQf1i:tft ~
-q1JJ
~t~~~.
~"4I(54U I ft
am.
q:;(I'q~~
qJf
fficR.,1 ~.
tt fiI#11"iffe),,4fl
;?fIerq"n !J05ld'it
i;fi(l'q4f 0lIT{
~
_
tt-
lidSiolltfl~;
fifm;I"WT~~~~.
%~q
3'1Qllk
ftmR ~
am.
~iOOIOII~
31'fftfi ~
~~
Slfttrq 1'=11 ~
ifi\Cf
nl ~
~;mft.
';f
'iQT ~
Gf.ffi. Rlitl(Slullcll
~ 41t9il
"~t1ijlft't
arna, ~~~~.
~7 ~
ffftn;r tt ~
fctiflUIUTIH1
~~-g
~~?
~
31ffl it ;qa'::q
t
WOIlfqrl lRlf
~ fi!qlft
~
fcqn;{ "SIf2Ilfqa ~
~fi_ti2j ~.
~4ht
~iA"'l
f.%i4fuj ~
f.1l'1f~(i'"
t"IfNld ~
1 wr ~ QIF4+~' ~Cf
r:(IaOI1~~
~'C4I(!II011t.··n
~ffreareqo; ~
$lqlJlcl
nlfTfire
~
3lffUT ~~
cliZoll(1-m
aW Cf ~
q
~wttt
~ Qjt!~I~q;
~~iOll~QT
~
¥
lllf
q'
~J.r.6J
3MT~
lPfq ~m ~
~ ~
~
m~
1J\4ilCfh~e4lCf!(UI 'fflrI1: ~
:;tt{lEfl.g
fcftrR
q ~~I~
fcriWt
~, ~~
~ ~
a.nfUr m <tiiq"£i1 ~
U
+~
e't"iq:)(U1 wm:~.
flrI~
Q1t
~Q041~ qJ ~
4 41tilJ)
ftqrR
ifiRUf.
am\' ~
qftoll'l ~
<:fI('<HI"5I¥~, 3'i ql4ldl
er Q1f"lIT ~
311fitJ ~
~,
~:flI ..~tr€1llff{Cfi
am.
q ~P.#;C4I~t~ eLftCfi{O] ~
.l1Tt, ~
am. -
~Rt6ffijetl
if)l(uli~
qJi(j'i4
iSI§flGf1f;n
ftm\ tmfI.
a:illm
~.
~-gttf4f4()tftqsf4:qIt:I:tft~~"itJ{5I"OIld)
ifi{I'q~~
>it qftollit
~9fC1(
1IT81,
f1llfrr
~!
~
-at~~* ~
qrf ~
am, m¥l;;ql
~ Ri<i/R1Tl1Q7
~1!IIt<t~1 PlIEI/dlaw/
q 18$:IClICfI(U[[(1 ';fqf ~
rlf4M1 PIFf
w~ qj(?hi4i1 ~fcQn;J
(~Establishment
~*I"1I:;;q1 ~
lfir J1itrr. .
1P!"ff ~
(Pseudoscience) ~
ij('4
wttr :a:(l65@o4Id
*(011(1
~ ,
~!
l:q1 4Ia~(lqj
3<tf8dct'f
W~«H~ ri"
anfitT ~~rrali!fii'if(~Cflf~~~
(11~* ~~,
n ~~;ntt,
~aJffi ~
@laJI ~~l"Ill{tftf1~~~~~
~~
~~d;$it!
~mftcl~~
~ "fft1"iXfT~
(.lqillcH
3lTFfT
%~~~?
~
;rrqr~T ;roq-r ~if
t111Rft \1fTT1T ~~l'iI~1 'ilcU€irt11 ~qr;: IUlOI [fft~~ ~, 3fTfitT lIT 14 ill(5I0 IItficll
~
(Rationalism)
~
~r.:q=r
Wt fcfm :amt ~
ani {'=lI M
~.
~~.
q (I tt H (OJ ~1Ijj i
~f4:cW~ ~h f44Alld 1
~('f ~
l?lTllTM
qOIT"4iCfl{;r
~it q{lql"1l1~[ltjI
~~
fcAR ~,a£[
~,
~ ~. ~
l:a I ""11tt. ~
fqd~q~ ~
3lT%, ~ ~
~~,
GrcfT ilifitllfTflROO
, €fI~olltl ~ ~,
q f.:t:tJ&l f;rft&1Cf1[{I11 ~
q(I"Il"ttt:tIlij[I~~4
rqr ~*If:i?fl
'lfli*itl
~
-~"flIT
!~;:::II:st\"i
glf)(OIli1 ~~I(I~
~-=rrtI'-~
~ ;r&111 '!f ~
~~1(14
q(jq~r QlI~41-.:t1311t.
q(j"ll"'(Oi~H6I ! lmir;nit,
t~nf~Cfi ~oTl~oq
~~;ntt,
~
~ lmif
.qu)~
t~ am. ~4([qHfPfll~%~
~.
lfRiir
am)
m ana)tr ~
iQr.r ~
if ~
~
~ ~~,
~,amt ~
~ ~
m~
~q
0(Cfffi ~
Cl4(j"it'+EHH(:iI% ~~I(Wtft
!~[tJiCflIii'" ~
~:qI(SlOII~
mr-rm
~~
qUC1Ii1
~?tt ~
(f(
~a;
~i:lI(Slolifft ~ qlo~'PJf:4"~,
-Qcrr -Qum~t,
~.
Cfllol("'qlifl
3Nffi
Sl0tlt"ftt'H
fc4f1r:tl=4 ~t{
PItlioa ~
3rttl'i4l ~
~~.l:J11Jlff ~.
ftMrqf1
iffuR
am?
~:tIlAati ~&f)tIi~ I ~~, ~~:n If.ti+i q4Jfl'ill rarnur ftriR ~<4ICn iff cl1Cfii=4 ~ l~
am, a.m
am.
~F.lc.,tl i~~
f4iil41 fA51U{r~~
~.
$1t1~
'~nmfWii;ft~
J'lQ(";q14 (~
Q14\jJUqlfi q ~
~ ~
Q'Nl"
QUlII'6ll1 q ~~"oll<5llffl
q3ffifql;::q~vm~~,
(§(
,m~. ~mtm:H~~ij'4atijlna 'lSI (1 Qt:IUI'i,CI owft ~ f*ctT 8((11 d, ~ T.rt am: ~? ~ qficPtll(illri1H Cf q 1'1t1~ 1I(iIIfa'1i:1 -qc;;n ~ I Pcncmt t{q r~ E! m- ~, ~
~. amur ~ i~ IdlerlfG-fT
'" ~
ff'~I1~
WRft ~li."ft ~.
) m mtl~i"i 1 ~
d~l1&cFriitRf
~14(1'if1~
m~H"@IQ( I~ AA'5tO~ItA
~Cfl~lI(;ffclT:q~
(R ~
oFlfR4'ti1 ~ q Jff"tI~lI&I ~
CiTTfitffitt~
~
M ~.
~. qv(lfri:i~ ~ ~~IPrchlfflI~,
~14'lOfR~,
orrtto 31it
('1Q\ild
gi$OO(4011
ftifi'tt'lM~. M1Qta')~
% 311~f{"
"8('qP~~.
(4iiifl-q,it
'itfT
~fd
wnft
m :t Ietit"ft,
~
3~lt(QI ~~.
~ am~~.
QU'4It1 ~ ~'i4I\fA1
Cf)Qffl"'4l1{(f
VfCfin ~ 'ALi\{Pj
""~tH ~
~""i(1l=an
~
iJlii4i:11d~~ If.l0fl1"lE4 ~
anIiJt ach~1I(i'lI~
~.)
~IGt,qc:fl(1
31Tt. ~ ~
~"fftt
qft~
~amx.3l1fUf
~ ~, ~
m-a- "1f1P.u;l:R12
! (TTfiJRr
m f4~Hlift
~ ~
3OIei?lll~
f4iitS"'fl
~
eglo'u4 ti"~
q1Jl
~, ~ lit
~CR1IT~CfTlR~it@N"~=QIt1~.
~1~q41
f.RH~qr
~
"3"Rl
c610ltttt ~.
~",idl~t4 ~
~1!ifRf
iRt. ~~~
f4tnft ;ntt ~ ~alTff ~ ~. it llfUrn ~ CM{lq~ <HfStq4f~ 3lT%. {fqTeq TJfORf~cUq(IZI=atrfCf~~ ~~, -ij1ffUrn (en C1ct:tIi~) cuq~-t CWt flLf\jf 011 <? ~~ tt'i~c:1 a~~.g CfilJ aUC;,u II( ?'"
foncn it 1lf1)ro~.
am QfiTlI41
d~II'Wq(TTfURr Citlq(I~~
311 a:n:rffi,
ott tfr ~
"~
*ft
~f&i;ft~r -rnn.
~O('1f'l1lij{cl ~
~Iffit~
~~
~("0:4
Ji ["101 [(I
n.~CC 1d
fq~'::ut1~.~"4T
% fcNR >rftf~ ~.
~(HI4l3i\1(P=L1I~'~
lrffif ~Q
~.
1fik"q
fu",i(1
m ffCfiRfl(l
118?lf ~
Ri;s:i(1h?l1
3~llot
iif)14ct;I(UfI~
CfI(UII<I 31t1(¥'l1I91~
~fdq;~r[ijf[{"i ~
ttifztr
31f$::Rrf;rqr
Cfi{On~ lIT ~
31+C4'fiJ ~
(=lIlltrat!jlJ
4 i'!i?t(P"'q! "lfIljg}dff<fli.'11
'ltft3fR q(isTtffi'
lfikLj~l'.ljllq;
~ IJtli.11ifll
lfrIIj
(1Qmo41f1la1
m~
~
~.
q~ Cf ~ ~
4$1110:51
QI(;Ul1lf1li!t 1J.Cfi ~
wrr~.
lf1Wf
m~
~'l~ In'i?ft'!ffm~
~Ht&lfI1l ~l(§i:I ~
1JT Qil5l.jlllil<1 ~
lfI ~11~:tII~ ~~
~",it1 ~
t~
~gld1irq
3m1 ~
lIT $141411~~
q;nu( ~
q~e~f
~
f.:rqfIJr ~
re;c:i(tI~I(
~.
1lI4id1tlct
srCflI~lIq&1T ~
li1ftJ'joeft ~ClIUI~G4lijlita m) ~
~. ~
at 1f;;z1f.1i41 mardtCfTe:1'6l1t
~R1q;Pci~ql(1 51q;I}(~en ~
(Insight) a' ~~
WI ~ ifiTli ~
VP-fi(f~.
'
-m tl1:ISIt:i»1
4JUldH'Iq
.
~:m
\;ft ~
3flTl
fPI~qtiltft a:Rft~
q~
(Creative Intelligence)
atl!~
q)ffI
(3iIf'Rlto:r~(1cfi)'i!4 ~
~tAf'ill) ~RiCfl:tIl(il~I~
'ift \1t:fct;f4~, mQt 3jilfQ,"Il ~, 3mT ~lVf iFoe& ~ lfr R:t 3Ie~{"ln it ~1f;R14"i .. il,,( Gfi1lJ
qjJit.'11
am.
~o
'3r.ffi ~
~~I01I~ft
!~j'((1~
~1~6fi
Sl'ltftiilfl ~
cri"$r own ~!
~
3q~
11fURI! ~
3ia:~
ijtj\iijUlIlH
If{UI '~
itfflw ~ .
,
am ~
~q•
ocfi q 1ffUra ~
3ilctlsOIl"41
~~ 1"1lift
(~
~ ~I;:ql)
woo 3-RttftlJtt
~*1'1ld ~W'Rft~,
f.tFm~,
~11~~ll&ifq~O!fl ~
CI[(O(1~ICC( facts) ~ (
~~(Theory-Building)
3iqftev.f~~(Logical
Necessity)
~(dld
~a.rn:r ~
~ ~
~.
€I 6011(1 ~
4;SdHI
(flfiq-r~
-l'Ilfctifilt)\JI(11
31itilo:fteldl
ql~liillli4¥i~
ftlm' ~('C4I'i41fe4ffi~.
~
~
~ :il1l(iif~I<?IllR~~
mrR!~~~ ~"ii1llT
1fcd;n
~q
onm
~~ ~
J~
~I~~o:r
(flJT
a1 TffUrn
%41c(~~~.
% lrflJ !!'&{)MI
ttfQ~
~ ~
ft'hill«Ol ~04Itn;J)
~II(ii1~i:o:J1 J4lf'l,n
q6ijill:~lfI1:f.l~.
~8;l~:rrtt,
~13W ~
~$-mFR
llfillt1I,tti Olfl~l ~
Cfi!tIlRA~
(3UfttT~~
~;ma.
"Q!fi ~
~ m ontt. amur ~
n
itli1ct1 ~
~
i1)~ffi,it lSR
(Mathematics may be defined as the subject in which we never know what we are talking about. nor whether what we are saying is true.) ~)(TffitRr (~d43:tII$) tt~ ~ii11 aqilu41f1ld"nr~m: ChBt'ft
lfr6'tfflffif ~. 1fTitff~
Qjflld~
am.~
:q~Cfi~d ~ ~,
U
"As far as the Jaws of mathematics refer to reality they are not certain; and as far as they are certain they do not refer to reality,", (llfOlt·[J~ ~ f\itft~ Sf41ull\1 tlt"lIl~ft ~ 3(e~
I~
.Jff~"f2;141~:q
~,
3i8ff1
ct
~.
Oiti did.) ~
11MrtJ
it'!
4 IfUH11'i4 I
Ftlf1I mwr.rlt
(en
d q)frsql )
F4 ~(14U1 ~;ntt
~\110lJ IQ Itt
owltam
q dOfifq( ~
aQull4l1
!
TtfUrn
q i$li1