Professional Documents
Culture Documents
विज्ञान आणि बुद्धिवाद Chapter 6A खरे विज्ञान खोटे विज्ञान
विज्ञान आणि बुद्धिवाद Chapter 6A खरे विज्ञान खोटे विज्ञान
विज्ञान आणि बुद्धिवाद Chapter 6A खरे विज्ञान खोटे विज्ञान
Im
I'
4)(rl/rl..
'ffr JlIfff'
HIT6lI11fI
rlIfii:Jf7J ~
f.!t4fol
.".,m.ml. filjlf:1fWI
3~ 1~(ijll ~ ~ Cfi«fT ~.
f.!!Fl1T
"IIdtt 'fkiII:rrft,
~~
ft4t1ll1lq I~
f?iqi.."
I'd~
~
-qfu' ~ri!
1UriR1ilf.f'l1 gf406ffitt~
If1fe{1'l
m'lfllT QiUl4:a?
d('C4'11f~liiql}jj&q)q<+il~
How to defend society against science ? (~~l"1lql~'" 'Ei"''5Tf~q::;irlk&TOT Cf)(lq:CI 7) "lI1 qtiCill4I~1 ~
f4~r.4P:rI~
~
atT1'iff~
mPJUT Of){U4141
~.
~aCfll~
liTS. ~ ~ ~
3Rfr~
~ ~
~
T["{if
~ant;1li!fl
ctlllcfl,
~"tJ'Tlff
aI2~1(;I1"ft
Cl'f"Ctiif)i .. , ~
q;n:{~"WfI
affi
SlRNI<H ~
~
~, ~
t1ql~ltftcl
~QJ}fiJ
~"¥IT
~~
~
~~, ~
3-l'Q~
\ifT1TT Fa-~,o:rl~~
it t1'iI'51!~
~
am.
am-. ~m~"
~
~ ~:~~
:mfitT ~
ahl'-'l""Slq,~:q
~OificH ~
~-'i1q(~+t11
~~
rr~i;fI:g:q 1.311t ~~
~~I(~a h1~lI"RT~.
iN"Itfifi::r
~
I ~,
CfiGT~
aN ~ jrffi ~, ~
~:ql(cidi"'ll ~~HI~ ~ 'i414ffi<t ~~~~.
ftfim
Cf'l(UII=lI I, trcf
si~ ~ 11"i\::t~f::::q
f4*HIii41
am-.
I,
ii'lI(ucn;:ft ~;mft.
~I!:I~
ra~I"1r4f.tqfoT if;Hi"fItr~illf{Cf)
1M ~tt ~~I~Cf) '~'
!]ct14firtl~,
aW ?ti(J(l4Sil
qrscll~,
';it ~:qI(;id~
~~
§t'f:tlltl ~
~
~
~~~
<it
~ -cnfl3H'I~14 (fi ~
q16ij~fmil'~'
(f('ffrtt Ullqql('f~~,
~t ~~~~~
a-et1!4~. ~~
Fet;q!(i~ lR\if ~.
~.
f4i4I(i;;t) ~ tfUl '(rM~
am. :g~
m~,
~elft"
I~'
;it
t:lfda:srf;(l fefR~
iif'i:4l(i~"~6T~~
~ ~'ffi:
Ilas:rlcfl ~
}I (I
JI HI i:t
q.
Si~Iff' t'fl ~
t'I fCf011:tfl1:fl ~
.:r:~u~ll;OfiT ~"iII(I~1f4'iffMfn"l'!:l
tf4!m~
31T%, ~
w-ttl(l'tl ~
Q~!It1~.
~m ~
~ ~
'ffi: 4;q(l~:S';P:~;1Jf1lT~
~~
~,
% ftr.i ~
~
70fKftuT ~.
~ ~ ~i5Iff1C6 ~
3;:':15(01 ~
m~~~~.)~3WJT3if{ROilct
cnri~f~ ~
~ q~ ~.
~ ~~~
~~f(ci d ~
am. ~
({
m~
~
re"id ~
~ 41tiflt'll ~'ll~{ ~
m ;rrtt.
~u;qlitumJ f<iYh1tft
qtJJ ~
EfilQf.tCfiO(.1 ~
tdOi I ~
~ <Sif!1111:t[J&I~
~<Wt
[%OIf404k1
~ma
I~'~.
q~~
~l~t?1, ~
~~~m!
q'tlll!i'nH'I q~ftp;q
fth~:ih~11~~
G1Qiolt
~,
ChIt1ql61q~
~, a l1i~1I!fi;?'~'
qit;~ ~
~~.
Ef'ItU'Q l"iilfl~
q Fct*141(ff~
$ilcl~~~!f11~4
"ift
~~,
511 J)~
m 3llfUy % ~
CR ~
§t'Pllltfi ~
Qlsuljli41 -~
~:ql(lifl
~ 14~ "flri;fi ~
~ Cfi~=rl
~ lilo5l
off l)ROllIlm ~
~ok1it ~i:gulHi1
~
'Hf4I:Jl
~~If?tdi"ii!fl
ijl '~'~
ih=zn.
m~.
3ilq~44idl~(ft
-ar.m~
~ Rtll
mOO(
~%~I~ij\'1
iR~
~fd(tli"1' 3leH~1
?~
't~~I1Sl~~,
~ let""1 4llH14${"IllSrt ~
m&fIJT il60I?fql~
~~,ItCf) §tq~lIttqFEi..4
~?
'!JUT
~
q;{lq<H~ ~,~
m!8UT
:~:t'U"ilI=it W!ffUl
#1(ItI;l?,
a:mT ~
~ ~iij
I RI9Ii.'1 f ~
tf'NI
tit?
fcQrR tt ~ ~~1(SIOIIt¥fi
am
'al t1'i\ild).
q, 0 1 ) dTtt
tfti411tl;:ft
W[ift ~~,
~ ~"Ilf.=lJ ~
~~tr~
~.
quJ ~
~:qRgollt?ft
~,
tt 14;q I'(5IUlltAl
Q1f
~
am Cfi11f?
(R
Rt;;qlttil
it arntft
~#fI~~~TliEiI
q.'lOHlig ~ ~~i<'tI:Jl ~ $141dtcl ~ g~tfqd
tl' ~
~
qtf ~
m:ram.
~ lfR ~
Cflf~tt~%t:fRRflJNf;'~ ~~~tnWi~~\ilIOlffi
~ >flIT01 'J:I'Rffi ~
tmf' ~Oljlifl ~ VlfM ~ ~. fl!n~~ ~. ~ ~1~i1 ftsItitOi W4ff4w qq 3ffi", Ci~iI1(1oll~i~1 ~'1ISl(n.sw~,~
3lUttlIN(c1inft,
~ q~ Cf
~~
~.
am. ~
iKrr. ~
~
~:nFlrcft ~
~
~
RI~1.. 1i4'64
am. Sf;l41lf&il1ijl<~
aJi;;jfi?l~.
Fft ~
~,
~ CR tf if?H,8~
~~fonfcff;4~,
"%~~q
q ~ifl
altl~~~
iIf~'1i(1
~
Q'~,,"
*r, ~
_ ~
~Holl:::<£ji~1 tcff5lQpi}~Iflftq;
~
'ij'OO ~;miffi
ntt
4"R1~6
~~I~q:;
ftCfi ~
~<Uql~ ~
0\<fI ~
eJ;(O~H"~,
I4~HI~Il%~
~Cf1f~11"R1T
'1tIOI(11, arnT ~
~
f4"qfuJ
~
'5fIfTUT ~
cr~
~
a.m. ~IPlCf)ii41 ~
~
~.
I c;{11l{f(1 amR
~;;mIT.
6FI1{Ollfllcfl ~
'Q'ttfF~
:-mn ~
'iR'ffi
*',
~
(1:;;q~II(,l'"1lql~"'I f)I(Cfl\9 ~ C
31m 31T!.m
am. S!i1:S(fQH'I, ~
~~~, ~
m~
ti41'ii11"q1~
~ ~~H~t!1t;ft~ ~
iQf1i:tft ~
-q1JJ
~t~~~.
~"4I(54U I ft
am.
q:;(I'q~~
qJf
fficR.,1 ~.
tt fiI#11"iffe),,4fl
;?fIerq"n !J05ld'it
i;fi(l'q4f 0lIT{
~
_
tt-
lidSiolltfl~;
fifm;I"WT~~~~.
%~q
3'1Qllk
ftmR ~
am.
~iOOIOII~
31'fftfi ~
~~
Slfttrq 1'=11 ~
ifi\Cf
nl ~
~;mft.
';f
'iQT ~
Gf.ffi. Rlitl(Slullcll
~ 41t9il
"~t1ijlft't
arna, ~~~~.
~7 ~
ffftn;r tt ~
fctiflUIUTIH1
~~-g
~~?
~
31ffl it ;qa'::q
t
WOIlfqrl lRlf
~ fi!qlft
~
fcqn;{ "SIf2Ilfqa ~
~fi_ti2j ~.
~4ht
~iA"'l
f.%i4fuj ~
f.1l'1f~(i'"
t"IfNld ~
1 wr ~ QIF4+~' ~Cf
r:(IaOI1~~
~'C4I(!II011t.··n
~ffreareqo; ~
$lqlJlcl
nlfTfire
~
3lffUT ~~
cliZoll(1-m
aW Cf ~
q
~wttt
~ Qjt!~I~q;
~~iOll~QT
~
¥
lllf
q'
~J.r.6J
3MT~
lPfq ~m ~
~ ~
~
m~
1J\4ilCfh~e4lCf!(UI 'fflrI1: ~
:;tt{lEfl.g
fcftrR
q ~~I~
fcriWt
~, ~~
~ ~
a.nfUr m <tiiq"£i1 ~
U
+~
e't"iq:)(U1 wm:~.
flrI~
Q1t
~Q041~ qJ ~
4 41tilJ)
ftqrR
ifiRUf.
am\' ~
qftoll'l ~
<:fI('<HI"5I¥~, 3'i ql4ldl
er Q1f"lIT ~
311fitJ ~
~,
~:flI ..~tr€1llff{Cfi
am.
q ~P.#;C4I~t~ eLftCfi{O] ~
.l1Tt, ~
am. -
~Rt6ffijetl
if)l(uli~
qJi(j'i4
iSI§flGf1f;n
ftm\ tmfI.
a:illm
~.
~-gttf4f4()tftqsf4:qIt:I:tft~~"itJ{5I"OIld)
ifi{I'q~~
>it qftollit
~9fC1(
1IT81,
f1llfrr
~!
~
-at~~* ~
qrf ~
am, m¥l;;ql
~ Ri<i/R1Tl1Q7
~1!IIt<t~1 PlIEI/dlaw/
q 18$:IClICfI(U[[(1 ';fqf ~
rlf4M1 PIFf
w~ qj(?hi4i1 ~fcQn;J
(~Establishment
~*I"1I:;;q1 ~
lfir J1itrr. .
1P!"ff ~
(Pseudoscience) ~
ij('4
wttr :a:(l65@o4Id
*(011(1
~ ,
~!
l:q1 4Ia~(lqj
3<tf8dct'f
W~«H~ ri"
anfitT ~~rrali!fii'if(~Cflf~~~
(11~* ~~,
n ~~;ntt,
~aJffi ~
@laJI ~~l"Ill{tftf1~~~~~
~~
~~d;$it!
~mftcl~~
~ "fft1"iXfT~
(.lqillcH
3lTFfT
%~~~?
~
;rrqr~T ;roq-r ~if
t111Rft \1fTT1T ~~l'iI~1 'ilcU€irt11 ~qr;: IUlOI [fft~~ ~, 3fTfitT lIT 14 ill(5I0 IItficll
~
(Rationalism)
~
~r.:q=r
Wt fcfm :amt ~
ani {'=lI M
~.
~~.
q (I tt H (OJ ~1Ijj i
~f4:cW~ ~h f44Alld 1
~('f ~
l?lTllTM
qOIT"4iCfl{;r
~it q{lql"1l1~[ltjI
~~
fcAR ~,a£[
~,
~ ~. ~
l:a I ""11tt. ~
fqd~q~ ~
3lT%, ~ ~
~~,
GrcfT ilifitllfTflROO
, €fI~olltl ~ ~,
q f.:t:tJ&l f;rft&1Cf1[{I11 ~
q(I"Il"ttt:tIlij[I~~4
rqr ~*If:i?fl
'lfli*itl
~
-~"flIT
!~;:::II:st\"i
glf)(OIli1 ~~I(I~
~-=rrtI'-~
~ ;r&111 '!f ~
~~1(14
q(jq~r QlI~41-.:t1311t.
q(j"ll"'(Oi~H6I ! lmir;nit,
t~nf~Cfi ~oTl~oq
~~;ntt,
~
~ lmif
.qu)~
t~ am. ~4([qHfPfll~%~
~.
lfRiir
am)
m ana)tr ~
iQr.r ~
if ~
~
~ ~~,
~,amt ~
~ ~
m~
~q
0(Cfffi ~
Cl4(j"it'+EHH(:iI% ~~I(Wtft
!~[tJiCflIii'" ~
~:qI(SlOII~
mr-rm
~~
qUC1Ii1
~?tt ~
(f(
~a;
~i:lI(Slolifft ~ qlo~'PJf:4"~,
-Qcrr -Qum~t,
~.
Cfllol("'qlifl
3Nffi
Sl0tlt"ftt'H
fc4f1r:tl=4 ~t{
PItlioa ~
3rttl'i4l ~
~~.l:J11Jlff ~.
ftMrqf1
iffuR
am?
~:tIlAati ~&f)tIi~ I ~~, ~~:n If.ti+i q4Jfl'ill rarnur ftriR ~<4ICn iff cl1Cfii=4 ~ l~
am, a.m
am.
~F.lc.,tl i~~
f4iil41 fA51U{r~~
~.
$1t1~
'~nmfWii;ft~
J'lQ(";q14 (~
Q14\jJUqlfi q ~
~ ~
Q'Nl"
QUlII'6ll1 q ~~"oll<5llffl
q3ffifql;::q~vm~~,
(§(
,m~. ~mtm:H~~ij'4atijlna 'lSI (1 Qt:IUI'i,CI owft ~ f*ctT 8((11 d, ~ T.rt am: ~? ~ qficPtll(illri1H Cf q 1'1t1~ 1I(iIIfa'1i:1 -qc;;n ~ I Pcncmt t{q r~ E! m- ~, ~
~. amur ~ i~ IdlerlfG-fT
'" ~
ff'~I1~
WRft ~li."ft ~.
) m mtl~i"i 1 ~
d~l1&cFriitRf
~14(1'if1~
m~H"@IQ( I~ AA'5tO~ItA
~Cfl~lI(;ffclT:q~
(R ~
oFlfR4'ti1 ~ q Jff"tI~lI&I ~
CiTTfitffitt~
~
M ~.
~. qv(lfri:i~ ~ ~~IPrchlfflI~,
~14'lOfR~,
orrtto 31it
('1Q\ild
gi$OO(4011
ftifi'tt'lM~. M1Qta')~
% 311~f{"
"8('qP~~.
(4iiifl-q,it
'itfT
~fd
wnft
m :t Ietit"ft,
~
3~lt(QI ~~.
~ am~~.
QU'4It1 ~ ~'i4I\fA1
Cf)Qffl"'4l1{(f
VfCfin ~ 'ALi\{Pj
""~tH ~
~""i(1l=an
~
iJlii4i:11d~~ If.l0fl1"lE4 ~
anIiJt ach~1I(i'lI~
~.)
~IGt,qc:fl(1
31Tt. ~ ~
~"fftt
qft~
~amx.3l1fUf
~ ~, ~
m-a- "1f1P.u;l:R12
! (TTfiJRr
m f4~Hlift
~ ~
3OIei?lll~
f4iitS"'fl
~
eglo'u4 ti"~
q1Jl
~, ~ lit
~CR1IT~CfTlR~it@N"~=QIt1~.
~1~q41
f.RH~qr
~
"3"Rl
c610ltttt ~.
~",idl~t4 ~
~1!ifRf
iRt. ~~~
f4tnft ;ntt ~ ~alTff ~ ~. it llfUrn ~ CM{lq~ <HfStq4f~ 3lT%. {fqTeq TJfORf~cUq(IZI=atrfCf~~ ~~, -ij1ffUrn (en C1ct:tIi~) cuq~-t CWt flLf\jf 011 <? ~~ tt'i~c:1 a~~.g CfilJ aUC;,u II( ?'"
foncn it 1lf1)ro~.
am QfiTlI41
d~II'Wq(TTfURr Citlq(I~~
311 a:n:rffi,
ott tfr ~
"~
*ft
~f&i;ft~r -rnn.
~O('1f'l1lij{cl ~
~Iffit~
~~
~("0:4
Ji ["101 [(I
n.~CC 1d
fq~'::ut1~.~"4T
% fcNR >rftf~ ~.
~(HI4l3i\1(P=L1I~'~
lrffif ~Q
~.
1fik"q
fu",i(1
m ffCfiRfl(l
118?lf ~
Ri;s:i(1h?l1
3~llot
iif)14ct;I(UfI~
CfI(UII<I 31t1(¥'l1I91~
~fdq;~r[ijf[{"i ~
ttifztr
31f$::Rrf;rqr
Cfi{On~ lIT ~
31+C4'fiJ ~
(=lIlltrat!jlJ
4 i'!i?t(P"'q! "lfIljg}dff<fli.'11
'ltft3fR q(isTtffi'
lfikLj~l'.ljllq;
~ IJtli.11ifll
lfrIIj
(1Qmo41f1la1
m~
~
~.
q~ Cf ~ ~
4$1110:51
QI(;Ul1lf1li!t 1J.Cfi ~
wrr~.
lf1Wf
m~
~'l~ In'i?ft'!ffm~
~Ht&lfI1l ~l(§i:I ~
1JT Qil5l.jlllil<1 ~
lfI ~11~:tII~ ~~
~",it1 ~
t~
~gld1irq
3m1 ~
lIT $141411~~
q;nu( ~
q~e~f
~
f.:rqfIJr ~
re;c:i(tI~I(
~.
1lI4id1tlct
srCflI~lIq&1T ~
li1ftJ'joeft ~ClIUI~G4lijlita m) ~
~. ~
at 1f;;z1f.1i41 mardtCfTe:1'6l1t
~R1q;Pci~ql(1 51q;I}(~en ~
(Insight) a' ~~
WI ~ ifiTli ~
VP-fi(f~.
'
-m tl1:ISIt:i»1
4JUldH'Iq
.
~:m
\;ft ~
3flTl
fPI~qtiltft a:Rft~
q~
(Creative Intelligence)
atl!~
q)ffI
(3iIf'Rlto:r~(1cfi)'i!4 ~
~tAf'ill) ~RiCfl:tIl(il~I~
'ift \1t:fct;f4~, mQt 3jilfQ,"Il ~, 3mT ~lVf iFoe& ~ lfr R:t 3Ie~{"ln it ~1f;R14"i .. il,,( Gfi1lJ
qjJit.'11
am.
~o
'3r.ffi ~
~~I01I~ft
!~j'((1~
~1~6fi
Sl'ltftiilfl ~
cri"$r own ~!
~
3q~
11fURI! ~
3ia:~
ijtj\iijUlIlH
If{UI '~
itfflw ~ .
,
am ~
~q•
ocfi q 1ffUra ~
3ilctlsOIl"41
~~ 1"1lift
(~
~ ~I;:ql)
woo 3-RttftlJtt
~*1'1ld ~W'Rft~,
f.tFm~,
~11~~ll&ifq~O!fl ~
CI[(O(1~ICC( facts) ~ (
~~(Theory-Building)
3iqftev.f~~(Logical
Necessity)
~(dld
~a.rn:r ~
~ ~
~.
€I 6011(1 ~
4;SdHI
(flfiq-r~
-l'Ilfctifilt)\JI(11
31itilo:fteldl
ql~liillli4¥i~
ftlm' ~('C4I'i41fe4ffi~.
~
~
~ :il1l(iif~I<?IllR~~
mrR!~~~ ~"ii1llT
1fcd;n
~q
onm
~~ ~
J~
~I~~o:r
(flJT
a1 TffUrn
%41c(~~~.
% lrflJ !!'&{)MI
ttfQ~
~ ~
ft'hill«Ol ~04Itn;J)
~II(ii1~i:o:J1 J4lf'l,n
q6ijill:~lfI1:f.l~.
~8;l~:rrtt,
~13W ~
~$-mFR
llfillt1I,tti Olfl~l ~
Cfi!tIlRA~
(3UfttT~~
~;ma.
"Q!fi ~
~ m ontt. amur ~
n
itli1ct1 ~
~
i1)~ffi,it lSR
(Mathematics may be defined as the subject in which we never know what we are talking about. nor whether what we are saying is true.) ~)(TffitRr (~d43:tII$) tt~ ~ii11 aqilu41f1ld"nr~m: ChBt'ft
lfr6'tfflffif ~. 1fTitff~
Qjflld~
am.~
:q~Cfi~d ~ ~,
U
"As far as the Jaws of mathematics refer to reality they are not certain; and as far as they are certain they do not refer to reality,", (llfOlt·[J~ ~ f\itft~ Sf41ull\1 tlt"lIl~ft ~ 3(e~
I~
.Jff~"f2;141~:q
~,
3i8ff1
ct
~.
Oiti did.) ~
11MrtJ
it'!
4 IfUH11'i4 I
Ftlf1I mwr.rlt
(en
d q)frsql )
F4 ~(14U1 ~;ntt
~\110lJ IQ Itt
owltam
q dOfifq( ~
aQull4l1
!
TtfUrn
q i$li1