Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Differences Between Spoken and Written Discourse (Answer)
Differences Between Spoken and Written Discourse (Answer)
Spoken discourse has its own complexity and has the feature of grammatical intricacy. - Halliday points out that clauses in spoken discourse can be much more spread out than written. General view: Content words tend to spread out in over a number of clauses - General view: low level of nominalization and shorter noun groups in spoken discourse - Rebuttal view: Both can be explicit depending on what they want listener or reader to understand, and how direct they wish to be. -General view: Speech depends on a shared situation and background for interpretation. - Rebuttal view: Spoken genres (e.g. academic lectures) do not generally show a high dependence on shared context Spontaneity -General view: Speaking is disorganized and ungrammatical - topics can change and speaker can interrupt and overlap with each other as they speak. - speakers can ask for clarification and they can correct what they have said. -Rebuttal view: Speaking Written discourse General view: Writing is more structurally complex and elaborate than speech
Lexical density (i.e. ratio of content words to grammatical/function words) Nominalization (i.e. actions/events are presented as nouns rather than verbs) Explicitness
-General view: Content words being tightly packed into individual clauses - More content words than function words - General view: Include longer noun groups than spoken texts - Information in written text is more tightly packed - General view: writing is more explicit than speech
Contextualization
- General view: writing is more decontextualized than writing. -Rebuttal view: certain text (e.g. fiction and nonfiction) depends on background information supplied by reader to allow reader to enter into the world of text. - General view: Writing is more organized and grammatical. - only see the finished product - written discourse is more constrained in that ways of conveying meaning are more limited
Continuum view
is organized but organized differently from writing -spoken is produced spontaneously and we are able to see the process of its production as someone speaks (how it is organized). - General view: Speaking uses much more repetition, hesitation and redundancy than written discourse. - produced in real time, with speakers working out what they want to say at the same time as they are saying it. -uses more pauses and fillers like hhh, er and you know to give time to think what they are going to say. McCarthy (2001) -the differences are seen as being scale, or continuum (e.g. from texts which are more involved interpersonally to texts which are more detached) -avoid over-simplified distinctions between speech and writing -speaking and writing draw on the same underlying grammatical system but encode meaning in different ways Biber (1988) - there is no absolute differences between speech and writing in English - dimension of variation where linguistic features tend to cluster (structure), all of which varies for different kinds of texts/genres - variation occurs within particular genres -speaking and writing have a number of features in common such as linguistic features may cluster in text that share similar in conversation - a number of characteristics show differences such as style and type of genres. - spoken and written styles may intermingle with each other where spoken language may also occur in written language such as email messages, informal letter.