Professional Documents
Culture Documents
02 Rokkan 02
02 Rokkan 02
o
(D
a
r-1 aa-f
in
(D
-.
.-l
CD a
i i; ie;iS
ig g1 gg s eg '
I S * F 3 s = 3 = 7 - .=: E 7 i s : q 9
A g: qyi q ei = i; ? :: a+-a ;Z X ; t \ = ; e : : i #l ;i E
= i ' g E r 4 ? "7= =1== 9=7a ;=?- i=! r ; ? t i = 2 i 1i = { 'ri' -i aq-= = i D =
; t t::i: ;. E ; : 5 e . T l i " = r r : - ; - ! . : : :. ,:
S P i ; 3 J r+ i ; t = ; i A ; ? A - { T ; * r
2 r xi d ia l i l ; = = *Qaz t* + F i i = i sit == lE
;i= = = E s Bdr^ qdl :+ = = = . 2 :, + ' : : 3 E $ :t$^ : = . : ;,
e ;3
S u i + ; r + t 1 is f ; a; : I
E r i + i i : E a + i: iti * i i i
i i s " T : ; l 3 ? E E I X :" = 5 F ? A : Z ;
In'cmal
FocusofAcuon
FrrcmJl
e.99-l
3!
Rv
L-bo
e' <::
- g s r
:
13;fl4
:h'=.7
*i-l
consumpr,on
tt'., : |
;
Mdrtc(
r "5'i,
l\
,/
,rri
i
l
9 = '6H t q 3 s
Ex * 6 ; 13;: ',=
q r = , 3 q O : : * i 3 X
, - t Ft
(D
l
a 2f
9Ni-9
oq
@
=i: ; i"
|'%" ,''""
\
!?
a: a:
! = a a 6 E . Xe 3
33 : s
P . - < :
-l
=
_!
L...f.
| /
+ = o *
!i i:< -
D '
a
i f-'t_
, 1 ./
\ \ lv ,r /
:.):' l ;
j
,/
E : Q; :- : l q ; H C
^ o :+ Y ! D r
o
-t
i
\
|
.'-. __ suppon
l : F 'o I i
i'>=
: r
<
" l \ >: - g: F
! z q
> < i i
r ? a
a " a 7 b
;iiuEs;aii ii
!
$ ss; i * 1i i
Etternul ln\trunentl
$ il[l i
A;F ?;i!a
fi
lse 1gtl1glgggla I
o z 2 q
:"
?.
6 -.i : i , :
:1 :
o: r l i = ; 2 0 - <! ; j
'': ?
Pcriohcla , 4 .'-1 1 ;
gif3
, u'ii
I
I
f,
!r
q
gF
6 ,ttototuun!rc.)
E1t i i li+iaisii
!
igiili+i+ i
(,
Ei* ri i
t + i ; ZZ ' s 9 + ;i a F
a!trffi
\ 9 t
'+eillgg
g[$Eg*g i1i;g
lggr
gg g ; g:?li
?t'ii ii:, ii ls 1 lgl; 1 iggg i i1ii* i :t=gii: ;i;$'F+s:, i'=211=I iii' ;iFF ilrugriii i i i a {ii,Ti
i+ ia!ai|, i izl?.;in i ?, s
*l+ i 11 ;
; 3
ggg1 + I *ialel:gl
T i z l a
1 ; ! : :
' *z I
'''''''.2\-''-.. , , , , // \ \ / \ / \
= ' 7 4 . -
a/
:
2 ; . -
"
t .
5\
\ , / \ , / \ , /
,/
q3 =
3
: il:iii r+ili H
l2vel oI ed(h thr.shoA trSili lncorpo radon Represr tltron Majonty power
R.sultitt pa
\s\
enl
Menium M
H M
H H
L L M
w M I
H H
reEnne., Verkmuns'of all plrlics: protessandgrievrreseilherchaDoelled rough Autocrari oligarchic or the field dmini$tionor throughenatepesenlatioo. clubs Bntinbforc 1832. H Embryonic inlernlparry system:cliques representatives, ofnri.rblcr. Exampls: of q ' d S $ e d e n n n 8 l h e u J r r e lb r t q e e n H d l s 3 n d c a p ' . ' generding associlion safeguards bl rudimentary oulsidesupponthtoughrcgist.alion H Inremlpny sy$ems ( o r M ) introduced the of predomimntin we$ern Europeduriog pe.iodbetween brcakdown [for] organisations: sff.age. and of monechic absolusm e introduclion p.limenley. Ie undermanhood lower<lass movemen$ fiee to delelop-but suffrage in ofextrnlpanysystem: l { lnitial phase development Example: Sweden before1909. nill Irmitedand/orunequal. rule: B elgiumbeforel 899i N oru lty, 188.11900. M Samebut with parlimcntry measres gtnsl minorily pnniesfrom lhe oatioolsyslem:resl.ictive Isolation lower{lassor religious of H rhe poliricalorganisaliors fll manhood suffrage. Examples: wilhelmine Rerchdurlg penodoflhe the but ofthe Third Republic. Empireanderlydecades Saznliste ^BeseE.,I 878 90;Frafte duringthe Second pany sy$emunderuniverlalandequalmanhood ruffragebr wirh bigh py oli\ for allirnces Competitive powe.s. would be lhe United The beslexample andwi a clersepntion legislative execrive of and Pany acliviliesandthe low dc /n.ro enfranchi!ment ifir on Srares wcrenot for the reslrictions Comrnnisr mry bc a bctcr ex:lmple. France underthe Fifih Republic ofNegrosin the South.
Francc underlaterdecdes oilhe Third Republ!c andmosloi rule. Examples: Samebut with prltumenlary the Foudh:GretBri(ainsince1918. representaron): needfor alliances achreve little lo rep PR M Samebur wrlh mediumlhreshold (proponional L L M tioughexplicitor implicit elcctoral rmnirnr ifltroduced against fragmeolalion resentadon safegudds but and sincel9i8 20. Betgium,the Nelhe'lnnds, Switzerland Examples:the Nordiccountries, centrifrsd pli Sarne with maximalPR andfewerresraintsagainnmajoritypower'e fragmented, but L L I L presidey ofe weirr Republic menlnde plebiscilian ' T h i s i s F a u l s l e m f o r t b e r n i r i a l p h a \ e i n t h e s r o * 1 h o f p a n i e s G e e F a u l6 4 ) . b S e e e s p O l s s o n1 9 6 3 ) . ( , 19 L L T I H
?lEl'gilgal?r
l,#aZ;flllaZr1#;
ii*rtru gg {
c
xgi
\
1
r-1
1l'
-!ri* llli 1 i:i ; gg$ iii3;ii i?g .iii it si ii,
I
(-
C) E r.-t CD
t'J
^t
CD ct)
i * a r1 ji3 * : i :E 3= !1is s1: r1+r? +[{z?;5 i = x8 e = E + qi* 1 t 3 l q l i l i i i gg i g E i i3 'T #ii s i iin *: 'i: g3 ? +c + 3ii * f es i=i * i is i i 3 i i; f i q i i i s + $ 3 3 = l i 1 2e ;* E i1 , t+ i + i 1 ; s1 ' * 1* a ' i : l ; !
'
' - : ' ,
. 5 -
? = E l
)' . 7 2 =
x l s r ? 1 $ iI ;i . E ! i i i , 1 : q ; F i i i * 3? i e ia s 9
9'9:"
? :?ryF:
: ! ; : 3
Xg='--; 3F3 3 - * z r g
E ' * i 3 ; E
5 e ? f
= = = P I = I :. : r ! i e
: v : :
> 2
rr!
2 ;73?E 1 6 e i ; ga =
" j3 E : 5
3 E
r
: = > -a
a !i
a 3
a t a
: - -
e - !
+ a = -
=o i - s d i .!) _ g r. T
= *
6 ;
^ j
- e - d z ? .tqsiqTFgEl
a - 2 ' = = =. ; ;* 3 3 q P ! T = < = : <
: i : !: 2:
* = t
sr q r . i r =l
3 o
: b
q ! ,
- 1 ,o -
b l
; 2
= !
a c z+ + i
q@ P = : l = - 6 =
- _ a
9 a l
t!
; \
-
= #
o =
:i q : < + ;
a 2 ed = " -
i q l ; 9 : 1 ij
: J
:.! Ci e:
d E : i i ?
b a ' 2 a .
L = a =
figr : 3 i I s+ + q+ * +
*i; 3 2 x q e
s = z
E r
l ; ;
''taF;^Eit
gAii i;
2 t . i ' ) : t c - - ? a : 6 -
e i -a <= + , , 8 . ; i; r -; :
! t
3 a n
Statc(s) allicd wrlh Roma. Catholic Chch Secularisi.S Rcvolution Stalc Roman Catholtc alliancc
o\
III Industrial
Mino. Major
spl'l
Major split
splil ll
Minor splrt l5
spl'r
l6
Twc
La,Ae Early
l0
t)
GA Irclandl
GB (incl. lreland)
Spin
Habsb Empirc ?
E
Rcich
-+
o o
z
Latc
FrcuRE 38. Iypology ofcleavage stmcturesand its fit with the empiricalcascsin western Europe
e;rri' ri; : Ti3qa ;'i$i;ii i *Ttzzl* i;1;11v'ltlii i tl?ziF1li iiii1? 21,1i ii +r?;irr 6i {g$1;i}| eiTztzrr* :
-l
/,
I I I
'..'-
I I I
l+ ,2 a : t t . : -.:: : '
a l
t t a
j-: ,- i: :.
'E a =.-
- l <-- I
7 =
,= . ' -
7* al t a= - -^_ ;.
i = - ) t
>
t . " a
a 4 - a - z
. r 1 =
. ^
i a
a, : t : .
.
a
:
:
:-=
/a
'
a <
?, ='r"|) - p
lFt3Tz==
1 = : i . . ; = . 1a: c- =
- *:
: j
. = ^ ; d . - . . ; - . : j . ) T - _ - e i =. (. '
j . a - 7 = = . t = ; - i - ) t - = = ; ,
-
; ; : : - _ = 7 - : = = t < - . _ 1 i 3 - i t - =t , - = : - = _ . : = i i - ; ' - . = : : . = - a = .
! 1 ' e ; : :
^,, ;
- 7
=1:
=+r;:a=;
- r . ^ , i = ; - ; . _
V /i :: _ : _ - = ? ) . _ a : -
= : / | ' I' -
iiili;tllai+iiii;gii ztzllllirtiii'
1:',2 g = :
] ; T
a\
!
\ r : s
: ?i1 i
l u i *
a
3
L
gi ti iilg i i{tfii iii lairi Ii: IiiiIlil gI +fei+i;rIzEr?{i i r I iIi* i iI i I ii'l5 ;iiiii;giiiil i f iii
:
CRITICALJUNCTURESAND CLEAVAGES
irst dichoton\: REFOR. MATION Scco^l dichobm\': DEMOCMTIC REVOLUTION Thitd dichotomt: INDUSTRIAL REVOLUTION
PARTYSYSEMS
Cl.'se st Enpiri. al Er.ttrles N ptltt\ 'P padies
(-]
Oflion Condition C I Option P-D U I C
II
P D L
v Scandi- CONS. s.
'LEFI'r
SLrte natronal
lcunlsrreNs
IRADICALS III C R nrons minonty R strons minorily IP, S U P r r . r : s r a C O N S v s / ?: R Re'ch P, -O-L II-R L P,-U I-rR P R-L
It y
IBAVARIANS l LIB I ZENTRUM Calvinists: CHU. AR { crholicsr t KVP lclalan /-UGA {Celisls CONS.-CATH.-CHF
IV
U L U
s
Stte allied o r
Cdlhol(
Sulansing .evolul'on
VI
VII VIII
R R
P S U Austria
P L
Eelgium CHR-/LIB.vs.
ii;F
@ f
t-. H
(/)
v) CD
-1
iIU ligil+ 3
CD
ggllcll1 ii'i*g
o
c/)
Il.rp ssi on on N.t \' \ ) st el re To{alcore Corrpetiliye rcrro n p o l i \ . I a t e rd e p c n d c n l o n I a r g c ru n i r llghly depnden( Dominant wilhin old Empre, depcnden{afier .ise of Prus s i a nR e i c h( d e f r i n 1 8 6 6 ) English/Sconishsctrlclenl I'an Gcftnanss (lrrholics \
Teriloiially
J . , . J r ' o a o f s i x N o r l h e r nc o u n r r c sp a r t yd i v N r o n : ove. rcceptancc/rejccrnof \ece\slon: Iine Grel p i o C o l l l m o n * c ] l hs o l u i i o n . r a n n a i r l p r o r o r l F F \eparti0n fronr nr(rop1.'lis /.,re..rjlon of Swedi\h arer (trobleln of no l s h n d \ ) , s e p a r rS s c d i s ht a f l y , e l r l y F i n n i s hp a r ( ) e J i ! N ' u nu \ c r c \ t . r n . r l , r i r r e g C u n ' r r r u t r o n J l r ' r , ) ( Y o u n gF r n n s )r s C o m p l i r n l s{ O l d I i n n s ) l - . l l R i g h ro p p o s r l r o o ! e r c u l r u r e l n g u g e , n . orieinal divi\ion o\rr \tcfd oi lrbc.rlon sLrcn ovcr c o m c ;f u n c l i o n ap l l r t ) y s l c l l l r e r g e d a f i e r I 9 2 5 j l e I N o d i r e c le x p r c \ \ i o no f r c f r i t o r n l c l e l a g e n p a n y i \ y s l c m h e f o r r l 9 2 t ) \ F _ l e n n s h p a r a r i s l s1 ) r r r r r r s se t, N o d r r e c r r p r e \ s i o n f t e r n t o r i c l c a v g c! n t a . r y e o l t s y s t e m( e x c e p J u r aa r c ao f U c r e i n 1 9 5 0 s t 9 6 0 s l
-D
.a'
l a l c r( l t s r u p l d
Slo!!dr\ruption
NO IC
D a n i s hc h u r r l i n f l u encern ca\t and cirics Diffusr Danish impcr on breucrrcy, prricirtc Frcnch speakingelire. Flemr-\hspcaking subjcct populrtion Major lanruage etoup\:
Cultural/ethnic
I ) r v r d r dd e p c n d c n c c :
llll
Srnre
I ) i v r d e dd c p e n d: t w o m a l o rc e n t l e s u t s i d e o
+ Merropoliran ofl.rr8er oie(hnic/cukural parr are ntenlny. Ftotlnt, 4J. I hc politicxl consequenccs liberation/secession of struggles: climcnsicrns territonal conflict oi in sevensnrallerEuropcannations
I leg*ggsg ig l u lggsg i gi
ttltlzlli
t+t;i5
2 <
^ -.=^
^ ^
c i..'
I
fl
+;;o =z
rt o =-: c ; a G 7 : )
e 7 ; 7
2 7
7 i
E*i q F
qg : . i i I e
*3 5
3q>
_^
? i
77 \ ii \
:-t'
n : " ?r Q :
: -: = c-
p - ! :
i.>
+f r = /_lr.i
;.2 :r
:31? +
z 3 c
io
I 3 i + E ! 3 - a Y S s g.r; s = : : u 9 I o a : Z ?: ! z Ei = ;
:
^ i = = - F
1 7
_!2 ()4 E
a 4
i-l !i.
:1_x:pa i +( n : --> * s q
9
a , i - i ; =1 ; s+ ; - " { i ! * ._ 5 ::
F +
! 9 f'
? : i 3 3 Ft i
o
g
* .
-: T - ; : :a :l Z re
i ?
1 :
= !
T \
; Q : : i . : . - : ' i = ;
= . i r :
F
^ 1
z !
i 1*7i{ I1 iI * + i i I i4i; +l;xi i+i+$ i +i'1r' *Es+ i }ii+ iiE 1 ?18' [' lcc ifit***e{l a;111 i;
+Tii iil++ i, g
s, *+:iiE 4; - if 1i+ii sFil aiiiiiasiil lil z;iaiFi; s$i1sii f, ii +iai Ei+ iii,i i a ,i*iii+ii i ; ; +i = i ; -i + E=;i:ii
.o
*ii **irati' iiii taT: -' iiiEi 1i+ iil= =s{ A+ai+ ls.' T!;3I1 ;
! -7 : ? ;i iial'?\ =7r1 =? 4 2 3 + 3 z - : = ! . r . = = v . :
1 : = , j
z
-
?,; ='..' _ 9 :
< 9
=a r ,''
; + d .
-!
.:
:r
? a !.. :: :"r - -? i - .'! i i r - ' : = : 3 = > - : o
q
a I 7 * n
*; g * i i i = 2 ; h :q
i!;==Ti=-?ii S
af : .
r. -\
ar
q 2 t i ; + - ?
= = 9 : . =
z ; = |- -- a= -| t ? ! ; i - i
: .
; f -
=. A '- 5
/ .
! = ' I = r =
E 5; r = = ? ' i
-:
-:1
u)
; A4 + 3 i d i e :5 B? r s+q=; z a a o; I : : 3+ i 3E r = ;a i : =a *
! l = C
iq = =P' = Ss g\ l * 1 Y
i{ c d I
2= i o < o
S=
: i; r !
=
;j -
4 Q
** + t1:i a :1 iIiitsTiiiiF a i i - ii i l i a :e :
atl
v1
< J2 O
Z a \ . 2
E: i , g , =- ! j : ! s ; a t d ! 3 : :
q:E
T < :
F i . ; T 5 e + : Pz : ' 3 " .= ; { p s 6 U ;
'Jtv
a = . = ar i\ ; 3 - ^ .
= q
H 3 6 s P o -
= 6
3
$
i
4 c
) o a q_ l 5 a; s1*
rl rr r
g
9
'
3-rD Pa4 -
l i111
1#1111E11*g g g a g g:iIigiiFg *I ii
1glgl* ll1ag11*+ ss
i'iiHai:lg: ;r slsaaala ri
?;iiE3a;2 ?.i
*t24;;;+-1 ?*
i * = : - ; ' iV ; E A 2
4 = , ' = . 4 " t ' - 2 . ; 4 '
? , E ia. F ?l i+ i + a = 4 a :
i4?i'q*-.sq=
-r
i f: r 2
n' '-
7 +
3s
!r r^
= ? = ^i ; s i ; '
;1
+ti
- - T !,! ^=2a7\ A .
sr;
T
a*-i
1i-i
=,
l^
I =;Z3l ls= ,3 1 ; i+ I :z !f i = | l 3
1;
-
d z
- a\-
5E-.
^ f -
? F a j T 3 j - 'E i i
i,iieriq
v _ . 4 ' J = _ : 1 a ; ' .
i
i . < :
1
r t
CLi ;
a,-
-i
ir: 5
za,??:1 Aj
tee-,.1"ii
'2e
i : = E i ;Z L i+ii?ii i:
3-"
s !
: i 3:',.
t 1 i .
@ - ! a
; i r i ii|1Ei? ;i 3{i ci i :; !
a c
2
i 9 z Q
; o
f.
3di < 99 ? :
=-== i . i i a .
,:; ) !
)
q 4 e ? - t - , - 7 *+ : i1 i 12 3.:rdd;;:ir i 1 i 3 3 = ? F t; e 7 ? ^ E i : a : i i a :t . t
i:r*giisxnij-E
i : 4: *EzZ:7: 7';=_
't6;3l
. a: = = :1 * o f. ) , - = h . x : - a ;
(t r
=,
3 E 1 { : i C p : = " } ?
z
CD a
t : : i a i i ; ;!: +
; + e ii * +; 7 i- ! E1 7 i : 9 #
- = r" = " a - = 1; 93. 7sL 3 = 2 " i 9 9 l 5 ii:
; J q
L 4 3.
=.