Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Hamilton Judges
Hamilton Judges
Hamilton Judges
Fred Cartolano
Thomas Crush
Patrick Dinkelacker
Timothy Hogan
Robert Kraft
William Mathews
William Morrissey
Norbert Nadel
Arthur Ney, Jr.
Richard Niehaus
Thomas Nurre
John OConnor
Robert Ruehlman
J. Howard Sundermann, Jr.
Ann Marie Tracy
Ralph Winkler
Total
Judge
Penelope Cunningham
Patrick Dinkelacker
Deborah Gaines
Ronald Panioto
Total
Total Cases
3037
3372
1258
1954
3138
2264
3032
2959
3219
3353
3000
2969
3205
955
3141
3089
43945
Total Cases
2729
6001
8799
12970
30499
Appealed
Cases
137
119
44
60
127
91
121
131
125
137
121
129
145
60
127
88
1762
Probability
of Appeal
.04511
.03529
.03498
.03071
.04047
.04019
.03991
.04427
.03883
.04086
.04033
.04345
.04524
.06283
.04043
.02849
Probability of
Appeal as %
4.51%
3.53%
3.50%
3.07%
4.05%
4.02%
3.99%
4.43%
3.88%
4.09%
4.03%
4.35%
4.52%
6.28%
4.04%
2.85%
Appealed
Cases
Probability
of Appeal
.00257
.00317
.00546
.00247
Probability of
Appeal as %
.26%
.32%
.55%
.25%
7
19
48
32
106
Judge
Mike Allen
Nadine Allen
Timothy Black
David Davis
Leslie Isaiah Gaines
Karla Grady
Deidra Hair
Dennis Helmick
Timothy Hogan
James Patrick Kenney
Joseph Luebbers
William Mallory
Melba Marsh
Beth Mattingly
Albert Mestemaker
Mark Painter
Jack Rosen
Mark Schweikert
David Stockdale
John A. West
Total
Judge
Fred Cartolano
Thomas Crush
Patrick Dinkelacker
Timothy Hogan
Robert Kraft
William Mathews
William Morrissey
Norbert Nadel
Arthur Ney, Jr.
Richard Niehaus
Thomas Nurre
John OConnor
Robert Ruehlman
J. Howard Sundermann, Jr.
Ann Marie Tracy
Ralph Winkler
Total
Total Cases
6149
7812
7954
7736
5282
5253
2532
7900
2308
2798
4698
8277
8219
2971
4975
2239
7790
5403
5371
2797
108464
Total Cases
3037
3372
1258
1954
3138
2264
3032
2959
3219
3353
3000
2969
3205
955
3141
3089
43945
Appealed
Cases
43
34
41
43
35
6
5
29
13
6
25
38
34
13
28
7
41
33
22
4
500
Probability
of Appeal
.00699
.00435
.00515
.00556
.00663
.00114
.00197
.00367
.00563
.00214
.00532
.00459
.00414
.00438
.00563
.00313
.00526
.00611
.00410
.00143
Probability of
Appeal as %
.70%
.44%
.52%
.56%
.66%
.11%
.20%
.37%
.56%
.21%
.53%
.46%
.41%
.44%
.56%
.31%
.53%
.61%
.41%
.14%
Reversed
Cases
Probability
of Reversal
.04511
.03529
.03498
.03071
.04047
.04019
.03991
.04427
.03883
.04086
.04033
.04345
.04524
.06283
.04043
.02849
Probability of
Reversal as %
4.51%
3.53%
3.50%
3.07%
4.05%
4.02%
3.99%
4.43%
3.88%
4.09%
4.03%
4.35%
4.52%
6.28%
4.04%
2.85%
119
44
60
127
91
121
131
125
137
121
129
145
60
127
88
1762
Judge
Penelope Cunningham
Patrick Dinkelacker
Deborah Gaines
Ronald Panioto
Total
Judge
Mike Allen
Nadine Allen
Timothy Black
David Davis
Leslie Isaiah Gaines
Karla Grady
Deidra Hair
Dennis Helmick
Timothy Hogan
James Patrick Kenney
Joseph Luebbers
William Mallory
Melba Marsh
Beth Mattingly
Albert Mestemaker
Mark Painter
Jack Rosen
Mark Schweikert
David Stockdale
John A. West
Total
Total Cases
Appealed
Cases
2729
6001
8799
12970
30499
7
19
48
32
106
Total Cases
Appealed
Cases
43
34
41
43
35
6
5
29
13
6
25
38
34
13
28
7
41
33
22
4
500
6149
7812
7954
7736
5282
5253
2532
7900
2308
2798
4698
8277
8219
2971
4975
2239
7790
5403
5371
2797
108464
Probability
of Appeal
.00257
.00317
.00546
.00247
Probability of
Appeal as %
.26%
.32%
.55%
.25%
Probability
of Appeal
.00699
.00435
.00515
.00556
.00663
.00114
.00197
.00367
.00563
.00214
.00532
.00459
.00414
.00438
.00563
.00313
.00526
.00611
.00410
.00143
Probability of
Appeal as %
.70%
.44%
.52%
.56%
.66%
.11%
.20%
.37%
.56%
.21%
.53%
.46%
.41%
.44%
.56%
.31%
.53%
.61%
.41%
.14%