Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

_

1, SHCOUn r C t' r': ...rl l'. "/


" ',-,
. I' :" , f " ":': ,r:1 ,..
1, :.:..
; " 0
... ' ,i . '
, "
. ,
III
: 1 j
.".
IN'l'HE HIGH MADRAS .
.,
(O}u)J.NARY OlUGINALCI Vli.:
THURSDAY, 'J'HE: 29t.hDAY OF' MARCH 2012
1.' .1
BON' BLE 1'18 .lJUSTICE K. B. K. VASUKI
().A. No.230 of
2012
in
C.s. NO ,.208 of 2012
Mls.H ,. K. ProductioJ15Prl vnte LIm.' ted
r
16/5', RajcjmannClr St .h ,-, et.1'
T.Nagar, Chennaj,-'600 01'1. . . ..
.. .
1. Bna.f:qfh Sancha rN.i.gmn Limi.ted ,
$qn,Fhar Bhavanr
Ha,ttphCpandra Mathur Lane
r
, ' " .
Jappat.h:/ "Ne,,'" Delhi.-110 001.
.'
Mal1q'naqar .Telephon<:) N.i.gam :L.i.mi ted
r
:Hha'rti TOVler-- I r
124, ., COf):Iialtght. Circ u s y
New OO:L
. r'.1 r
, . . I, ; .. 1
3. '. Bhart.:L ,A'LFtel
, r- .. j .II "-t'
Bhart;. i
LNelsoqMafidela Road y
11,
.lir.:."'!V.l ,Dt!l hi. --11 0 0'7q.
4.
'j "'I f
fI,',
"
!!.:. ; \.; r:{',lli"l'r ... I .... I.";)
, ,.. \.'
I , - liI'"';f-! 91
.J ,JUI:- f"\ H" " }'I e " - ' ...."\ r :, ,
.
,t' ""i' I 1; . (. '::" \11 11' (11' ) ' ,! tV ... r Jr.;:, ' " .
, ',, : H , , J, ";' ..
'.!. 1 \ , :--""'\ ' ! \ .p ,,{ ' . l' '. -".
t" , =1
'ITI' ,
. . (\ .,10,:-: Hl nH r-r.! I ,!f :. . ..!t L fl.!' . . 1. H"'l : l', I
. j :' :. ':"',.... . . - ,1 .
' : .
/21 'r '
'H " IQ,ea ' Cellulnr Lim.ttedl' ,
Burna'll Tower, Plot ,No.1 B"
Se6torl1, Gandhinagar,
GUjarat-382 011.
9. , Reliance CQll'llnlii'liGat.l.ons Li.mi t ed, '
nhii"ubhai lXmbmli KilOkl.edgeCity',
Navi 709. '
10 'rata Lim.i.tedl'
"
lJeeyanBhat'ati 'I'cMer ,,1, '
JOth Flbor, 124, Connaught C.i rcus,
,Dt-'llbi"7l10001. . '
'11. Li.m.i,ted,
" 2A., 'b:ld Ishwar Nagar,
Main Miithu'ra Hoad,
New DGlhi.-tl0 065.
12. . Ne'twor)w Pr:i,vat.e JJimiteo,
, Gr6utid ''Fl:bor , C- 4S I'
. ' ', '
Grech. ' Park, New Delhi-1J.0 01 6.
13.. " Tikoi)a , blgital Networks Private Li.mit.ed,
3,rd 'Corpora r, L . B.S.Marg
r
Hurnbai.".. 400 ens:
, . ,
14.BG India Private Limited,
Plot ' j4o.b41' Marol Indu.'3trial r
Off Road.
Andheri (Eqst.) ,HumbCli--400 059.
'
J ,
t, !.'
1S. S'ify L:i.m.i.ted,
2nd 1' , I'I'TI'DEL , PN<K"' I' '
N() ,.,4, 'Cc::hlal Bank Hoa d
r
'
Chennai!.;.600 113.
I," I,
I ,. KlimaT,
- 'c :Pe rsoli I'
India .
' :',.' - r If. !" . ',.' ." , ..: . "' ," ... . ' . _',
,J : ;. I' ... ":"r ,JU:C: . I } . :
I " I '. ' , _ . " . ... : ! '. . _ f, I, -;1 . '
" ,,:,',l' ",'Aahek, M'umar
.. _' . . 11 '1
, " ", .. I,. A
C
Unlr..nt ':iWll""Pe,r-SOD' '1Ildia
' j I :.., i . _ -" " . 1:' t .i{fi f:: ""t ... i I .;,.h 1..,..,f.. J .t , ,'.. : -. .' ". . 1.
IpI L;nJI I:.. I:;:' i '-"':t! ,-of! -' ...10, ,:.: .. T' .f- i . , , J"" ':' .,
""... .' : '
I. " ",U-'Ul ' n" --:i,r" " ' , '.
I ' )i:-, ' .;'i, ... .. 1'+.....tf.. :H : , .. . ,
,' ,,; " J)igi a.,
. ;" r.F.. ;!.(.H/' ,\ jl: f.!..... 1 !" 11 : , .,
ItK.H f l C,CU;;'l'c;: )!"" IIJ'-;. ,'... Mr. i- ) .. " . ,;
J," ',e;' "",;- ""',-,( " " \' li t1\.' iJWFr i}" "t7'iif:J:i'-"': ," r" I'.
Y . . ,.. Jj-;I .. .. ... . I . :
Oil 1,. .
..'.:r, II.' .)1 :.(.;::.. .. r "';':II-J! ( \p :..J\ r;J'-U f. ;. ." ..... '!l " ., .' , 1 i/ . : .... ;' . ", " ..
.,-_., .. .... .... ....... - ... .... - ' '" . . ... Cr: i=fT{';" .
. .... ... 1 To', ' . ' . " "
-. : 1 ( ;:-4
t, : , . I; ' .'\' ,otHM ("'!r '\ J, fj ". I " . ,' .
/3/
" 1
' ;
Original Applicat .iori praying that this Hon'ble Court be
. to grant. an order of' Jnterimr
.i nj llIlctJcm respOIiQE!nt.,3/ def endants and ()tl1or
llnkhovm pei.s611Db), t.hem::;elves
r
:their partners/propriEO)tOl',
"
bUf.liness, ass.i..qns, hei,rs,
II '
dlst.:r1.bubo);"s, agents or ill?Y . onE) c1:aini.inq throuqht.hem from
in any manner intrlnging ' t.he ai)pLtcant' ,CJ copyright in t.he
cin61nate)qraphic ' film/mot.i.on picture by copying,
'.
rec6tdi.ng
r
reproducing or allovlinq camcordinq ' or
.cOlTllTlunicat.inq or a.1J.ovIJ.nq others t.o communi.cate or making
avc'.lilab.le dist.ribut.inq or ' duplicat.inq or or
. or !3hOvl.i.ng or. uplogdin9 or downloading or
or playi.ng and/or in any commun.icat>ing
:the . Ys movi.e in any manner without a proper
I.from the app.1.i.cant. or in any other manrwr ' whi'eh
, ,
,,"()uld . viQlate/infringe the applicant's copyright in
, "
said . film 1'Y3I'Y throu9h 111ediumt;
. , .
including (;D, DVU, BJu-ray dJsc, \lCD, cab.le :--'1'\1, Direct. to
home r inte.nH':t mu.lt.i..media mes[;agJ.nq
\ I '
services;" pen dr.i..vesrhard dr.i..v8s, 1:. r ConditioIlal
[-)Ysterhs or.' ill any ot her l.ikE-) manner I,/ha
,'pei1din'g' di,c.l[){)sal of t.he slLi..t.
')"f,icL b priglt)alApplicati.on coininq on this day
'in the of Mr.A.A.Mohan
r
. , ' IT ' -r 'r ' .. , I ,.
and upon rt=H:'Idinq the
@fld . a.tf .-fl.- Bar rt.i.led
'! J 11 . '- . 'l In .r . ' I t.. ...... , .'",,} '.: t,... , ,
I 1'1 . ;_ ;..1:
." .. "" .
. :;- . (: ",-\!- " j l " : .. _ I '.' .,/., I'
IJ! . L ' , ' )lHi 1._ " J I.., t,;. -I fi . ' '.' . '.) .. \" I "(
' J. .. ... '" 1:1 .. H r.r .!'.l ''''1.'' -,'
, , _"tt
:'. .: .. . 'I ...... .: : . : ....... 1 , . 1" . ,. .:-",' , . -::f ,. ; . _L . ' 11 .. .>-' ( " , ,". r: ,, ' .I .
."::.:.,:" .. ::: ..;'; SaJ}(;har' Nlql'llri r' :Giihifdd, : Bhar.at [ii:n;l(,!h;j;r j,e " . >, " "
...... .. ,. ' ....I I-rl i.C' ..:dt.,!. ;I"I.Jr \l-"'n ' !.:":': . ':' ... . .... . : 1\'( 1 f.. .;,. . " to.'/ 'k ' " ', " 10, . ' " l-i. "
2 '.l'.eJ:6j;;ih6h(-) ,N:1g.HTi ;.; j )UnJied:/ ,' ,. ',: ,: ::': :'/
1- .. li= j ' )L'i' .)f .. !' .L'_1 ':f.. .. .. 1 : j ' ' , . F .I lo . ',I",,, , .n ' I .. , .. :, '.(" , l . .
1....-1 . ,' , ;.j ., " 11 , 'tft ;' 1: . . Hr .'j :,,! " .;'- " ! I . 1 , ::.11 .. , . 1 ;, f", I" ' :,' . ",', ,'" . : '}\
!o:' " ,"'" ,''; .. , r.:S1arE], .Aj'.'.r'te . . ', l..1:inaA.ed, I . BhaJ:1lt)J: H G>r:E3SeE-H1,t, ' ". ".' '. '" ,:, '. . ' , ' I ' " ."
;' : I: ;: ,; ': . ::::j'. : :,:; ;,::- .: .. ;:. ,:;. !: .. .. ;.. 1;:1\ :' '. '::. ::;::.::! \:',: ;; ,; J . ,: .. :.1; \ ::;:: . ::1 .:'.;t '; ': ,.: .. .,." :' : ":: : :. , :,: .. :
" " '''.r'' ,, 4'n :\!l!.:r,ce'x "" '''\;e'.L1ml!8r" ,' Ll.;lTl:l:1Ted .,. ,'S .' " JaJ:..>le ", " '& ".1 ,J)ataeelT\ """ , II, I :'" :.. 1"
1: \/ ,- .:'01 -.". 'II' '1 1,:-' ',: . .. . ... \".' '. rill'll ". ', I.., " . 1, . ! . " t q ",i ." , \ ' I ft .... " 1 '1 ' " " i- ' . ' .
. .. 1\ 1'11 .: "':'UHf ( , ; .!t:i W,; ..... I ;I..,;;,;.;j'l ;r,; . j .;:: . . \ .I.' l tI r ' i . 1; " _,i' 'f ' ':' 1 1"1 "' " ,(j ill' , . 'Iff ,' 1 ,( ' \ . > . . , " ' 1 I, ... :. .; ..
';; /::.:;: , . , "; ,," : ::;. ;';:
:< .. ': r' \ . , .r ' .' ! - .. . ... " J" : . I ' . 1' 1 '. < if . ' .-, ; ' .

... .. .... ..v ....... ............."""''''''''
11 : 1}l ", f:' ...... 'I' .... to. . '01
,t'". ;: ' I (; . r IF!
' ; ... ' .. " , I
'. / 4. /
. , J
."
.ilia.ia Limited, 8. Idea . :L.ij"ni t Bd, 9
R(:!1.ianc.8
. Lim.i..t.ed,
1. o. 'l'at.a 'l'ele,gervices 1111'11. t. ed.,
. : " . ' .'
jeevan Bhart.i 11.'l'afa 12. o
Zone PrivIJt(-';l J,j.lYd.t.ed, LLTilwlllJ D.Lq:ital
. .. .1
PrJ.VEltE} Limit.ed, 14 .BCi P.Ll.vato I.,i mited, lS.
. .
L.i.n'l.i.L \:; d
16 : .. Ashok Kumar, :17.
..... ' .... .'
K\.J}TIi3,L,( <:L8.A$hok Kumar, 19. r 2 O. Kumar
t.he . . he reiq, . . iOlnd other unkno",rn
. ! I , _ . . .
pi2,rs'(,)Qs ' ):)y' .. Ule-mselves"t.heJ.r pat'tner.c.;/prop.rietor r heiTs,
succes::lOI'S in
bU::l.l.n(-':lSS, a
dlstr.iblito.t'E.l, t-3gelits or anyone claiming throuqh t.hem be .
and re:3tra.Lned by a n order 01 intf3d.m .injunct.ton .
until turtJler orders ot this Court. trom in any manner
infrJng.iV9 ,the appl,tcant r s . copyright in tlw cinematographic
filrn/m.ot.:lon picture ... 3'" by copy ing, ' .r8cordi.nq r reprodu(';ing
or . camcording or communicating or allmJinq (jthers
. . ,
.lob c:ommtl nic!ate o .r making available or di.stribut .i.ng or
d{ipllcaU.l'lq or disp'Jayinq or relE;asing or show.i.nq or
llploadiri<Jor. dovmloading or exhibiting or play.in9 and/or in
any mannercommunicatinq the a ppl.icant Y s movie ":)" in any
manner ' vlithout a prop(-)r license trom tlle appLLcant or in
any other 'dould v rinqe the
appLi..cantf in the said cinematographic f:LLm IY 3"
thrOl19h. different medilJm:"; J.nc.luding CD, DVD
r
B.l.u-ray dine,
VCD, ' cable '1'V, Direct. to horne int.El.l."nfd:.
mUlt.lll'le<Ua P('3)) drives, hard drives,
" T ' , .

C" t eln -c.: .. " .
Cc;i1cU.t t on<1 1 _,'. ,> _ ,JY..) .. . s or in any
. .. . I
d I 1 ".r:',.

. , ....:. .. Jp , ,, : . i
r- . ; .C TH: ..
.J . I. , . .\: i ... :A)", I t ...
, ,,, :' . ' Hf . f.Q.J:' ;: on 18 .04 .201.2. ,::;.
: ..1. :" ,. , .... ; . '.- .f.-, .. . .. f-: . u :.' ,. : . ::, .. _1-:1,_ I' . ..: 1:iC1 I (;l ,t [-'T'. ,- II) .r
..'I"r ....\ ... I,,: !,: ! .. Jl .. II . . : . . ' . , . ..; ' ... .-: '-H ,-:T ' , .. I
"'-tt ,r ' : '-I'.+..l l('d;"'! . ,;..0 '":"
",,>n:m''''E"1
I ..""....""....,,!?'. u "\
... I, ....' '''I''-:' . ....f'IJ"J1""'! ! . .. .. ,
I . . ..,
\ h' . . ' j '1"",1 : ;: ,1 i " , , '. . t,ro 1!.A, I-f.GH 1M" (
- H ..... !
: .'.
,"
':\ ' .
1'1
/s I
B\-lilie of .this order.
,
J'
I',
I .
4. That th:L,g O.A. No.230 of 2012 be pOt,ted on .

WITNE:SS '. TIll!: HON' E1.l: THIRUM.YOSUF 'l'HECHIEf'
aUSTICE, ' HIGBCOUR:f' AT MADRAs A:FORES.AID
r
THIS THE.: 29t.h DAY
OF ' MAHCH 2012 .
l' <t .
sdl-
ASSISTANT (0. S. I I)
/ /C.E:R'l'I FI ED '.1'0 BE A 'l'HUE COpy / /
pi h te, ') () 'I ') . ' .
DA'l'ED'l'HIS J9; DAY OF'
. . l1<- 1--/
,' .
COURT OF'FICr:H.
F.r.om 25th 2000 Registry is is,su.i.n9 c ert.i f ied
copies qf J,hEl Orders/ audqments/Deci-E!e in this f o rmat.
.' ""
' . t
If,,' :
: 11 1. 1
II h '.
. J . __ n..
' .1\"
.: '''):
J .j':lr .
.....: . 1L-iE: ... -r- J .... r ,;:! ....
)';, ;" ,' , \', ,.'I";l'" ,:,,!=- ) ,:r.:lI..:\ft ' .", ".. . ,1 ' .. ,.. : ,II.'.'.:.. , i." '1; ; ,\ ';
. /1 r HIGH COUffT JI 'D1C....T: /--:t. ! . , '1 . ' i t)' .Ill!:>', ..... , ." f :..
jl ' !, 1'-: "'1"\ . ... l-fi:::;H {) !."J'j l(l OF r ' . JI1':; l-I" ... f '.;' . . ,:-)..,,:, I' : r' .,!
. '.... "TI !;:.f' ....hlH"II<;. :"' !rjH .::r.'l)fl1 or' ..i :..t!:'{c ;" .n .; ", .' ! 11 , ;;1 , 1 . 1' ) :' ... .1':. 'I' "J .... . . <
.! f['. , .-,., .. -:; ' .. .. . .. -.;: : rp\,
lIJ''c .1.;1 3 .I . Rt.::; l uGl tc:o u:nC' FJUOJ(.I!I-I.J" d . . ' -j "'
1" :"-I ,,: ::r.\3,11(,1 .. , !, ; " '. 1 . I , . ",.: n\"rl_: ,;:::I"
t ,',H
J,c" H :.-.... ' -'T

t . '

t r flHC';:\ jiT ._
Hl ., t. ' T I .. j '
HI. :'t (:r;., T C; .h.t[",
(; WI : ,-
r '" II ;:'1 , )" J, . t ;1,.
tw.;; ... . .. . ,O:::'.t I'
1'11" ,:_;.',, ", .... - 1" ,.' '., "
... .,
I
1-,,;,,11.
. c ,
r ..
' I'
. '!, ; 1 .,1fT' M.t.
(.'L' r c''; 1.} -,":;-4-,rl-> ' ..'t .:.'
. :,,-10
. .' - '
: ,I I . ' :r .J '!..".;:' . .1AI
' :, :- , _r<:"" '" IT .! . .
r ' .I -it.: . 1L.t
. , ' . C J.;. v
,. ,'- IV'!l 1
. I ,; i t. . i .. 0; .f Jt ' r,':':,1 .,iJ ' E"
' . \; ".';; .'1 1'1' 7 __ I
f,:;,'"'I-I':'; ur C" \ . ;-< 0!
.:)' \ ' .0; ... ......
It: I iHt= ....".ntt.: -;: 'II: r- L'C1..
'
F(l nr IdLH\ I ,A:' .
.. ..!.'Ii\.:-;' C \(JI-: ....'Foe \,,'"
,... ... I .TfV, .. ' rr,... . ...--',
I I
. ,
, I
II. ,' , I h_ ;; ...
f , ..
J. t I' . . 'f " '. r: .!-: . a ."- .H.
I .. Jf . . 1 . ..:
:.... . '-
, .}. ... F:1 t'.};:: .J . ii.t. : ;:'i l j n- i : :.:1;,. 1- 1['ll ' .tJI' .... '
' ,-'lI' .. .. . ';i" l; ..... .. .. ' ., , ;. . 1 a
"., - -- ' -ro ' - JlWGf'I.etXrR ' "'!. :O,"?l."?:'".... ,' -. - ..:""
. I : f',:" ' j r'
. ), .. , .: .. :.
/ 6/
.1
',.
..
.
9 20].2
. j.
,n f; 9'- ': ' 0" 3 . . 2"'01:'2"
..; .,.'" . : , .-o J

O.A. . of 2012
'l l
in
No.26Bof 2012
ORDER
DATED: 29.03.2012
.1
l! -'
'l'HE BON r BLE MS. JUSTICE
K. B.K.VASUKI I .
: .. .
fOR APPHOVAL: 29.3.2012
APPROVED ON : 29.3.2012
."
'. 1
. . :.1 '
I ; . 1
U., .1)", .':: 11' : '1 . t'Ut-:. 1- .. 1. :10. : ..'{' '"
',i; .' . ',, :' .. H,J.f,.,lr..l l . :.j: ' iJ
"
;' 1.<: f 'rn . ,'.
J ,.II . ; :, I i , .. ;/ lj., " I , t
.! ) .:: ", " I ..: :)ur. 1 u 1... L.lI ,Jo V ,',;, .
U P .!. r ,. if: ....r':' '' . '', ' , .;;r ,:.; .
. ' , JI , " ..... " L i:. {.'I,'i.o r. ..:.::,. kl :"':! . G..:..H..: tn ,J1. th >:. ,.... II '
ir.L O f- ' L"{JI ' ;l,1l . f .l
... ....1.ol.!.lF;,.;\" .; : 11...;:t . :":O u FH ( 1. I " " P t .. . ;
Il If",r:,. : H! n H :;:.Jw n--:- 0 ,1'" ./1; [* nJI , " .. ,, ' '" , .. . . :.;,r'
Hil .:Lj COUr:r I '\1. ' f ; " I. f4. ..:,. . l ' : 1 . _'I t 1/,.i'\1
.'.;\}FL H; ":,: ' C O oJf!!" G F .1;"1 !IC:\ "I .... .' . . ' '" : . , 1ft": ... t ' !,
.Ie 'n:. ' :/:':Lr .... s HlCiH ':OU-{, ( .... i- ,l !..Jt)r,. '-;-O:.' ?-o: " ;: ."t.- . I . .f "; '-'_,J7.;.1f I." . [ , J ... .:: ,-
IU:;;t. .:....J :.i: {L :"! f(,'''': 'i t-':' OL1Fr- OF J I)L,j.:'A }'a . . ! .... I ." ' - (" 1.1 '::-: :tH.. 'ArUPr ..':.,.;!. , :"' :;-: r ;- '.'f , J C' JC : ; "; ' t -:..("/
Wr: t ; ,'.1 .JilL i t,:'L[l r-!':\ ... LC)l,. P.'r'.(' !- ..' t...HICf':-:- 1;" L , .;.:..,., ., ' .. t.J.: . r' t 1 ..- '. : J\" '. ' . ;: :- " 1,- . :A!,.:
' :.ID IC'" t .1 URf:: h i C! : (I f:".lU " )(' -1. ! Jf'F .. ; ; " j ' 1
I fR.:" '. ..... (,-, ; ' . :A "lI; . . .::..rvPF .-r,'.
",,,-uR ,,, 111.L, t l r"": ).4J ., 0:"'.1 t ' (': , If".! _" ". ',

"
' . l.' .'
. . '. ., .
.' : ,

. -'. "<- " -'
. =--

..
HIGH COURT.
,
VR1GINAL SIDE
C.A. .. ..,.1.Lt.V d '4----
.... pplled . . ...
Stamp called to _ _. __ _
Stamps put 10_. ___ j'" ... __
___
(f
{iL.-- C.. (.5.)

You might also like