N. A.

To 1941 " "

. " " (.
, ' , 1989, . 121 160).
. ,
,
. ""
" ".
, ( ),
.
, , , ,
.
,
()
() , ,
.
, , (De
imbecillitate) ,
"" . n
; ,
. , ,

.
: ,
( )
.
.
, , . ,
.


'
. :
" "
.

. , ,
. , ' ,
( , , '
). , ' , ,
. ,
"", ,
,
. , " ",
" ". ,
( ) " , , '
".
" ".
. , .
"" , . ,
"" ' . .
, , . ,
, ,
, ,
, " ".
( ),
.
.
.
, "", ""
(, , ), (
, , .) (, ..).
,
.
"". " "
.

"
". " " .
( , ,
"" ..).

 "" , , "" (
) causeur ( ,
, , ).
.
(, ,
..).

. ' "
", " ", " ",
. ,
, , ,
().
.
, , , , , "",
.. "".
, .

, .
.
, .
. '
. , .
, , (
) . .
, , ""
"". "
( ), ".
. , ,
""
" ". ""
,
"", , , " "
. " " .
" " ""
, , "" .., " "
"" .
. " ,
,
,
". " "
" " " "
"". ,
. .
, , , ,
, . .

 . (
) :
, , , . "
".
, , "",
,
. , "",
. , ""
, .
,
. ,
.

B'
H

. , ,
. "" "quid facti". To
. ""
"quid juris".
" " (1941) De Imbecillitate
( ). .
, . , .
( Demolombe ),
" , , n ,
". . .
, Demolombe , . .
(), " ,

. ,
". , ,
,
.
(Gradbegriff), . .
"" ( ""), , , .

. ,
, . , . "
", .
" " .
"", . ,

 "",
" ". " ",
, " " (. ' ., . 34). ,
" " (.. ).
, .
.
, ( )
, ..
. , "" "".
, , . " (.
) (.
)". , " , ".
, ,
" " , , ,
. "", !
: "
, .

, , ". ,
(.. , , ..) '
.

. .
, .
.
) " , ,
, " ".
"", ,
" " .

. ' ,
, . , ,
, ""
. '
, (
).
, "", ""
(.. , , , ..), , ,
"",
. "
" "" . ,
.
"" " " ,

"". , , "".

 .
, ,
"", "" ( )
"".
( "
"). "" "" . ,
, " " (, ,
"" ..) " ".
) .
( ),
. " " (. ) '
, 1.
' ,
. (
), ' ""
"" . , ""
. ' ""
. , , . a priori " "
"" ( ), , "",
.
. ( ),
, , , .
) (Gradbegriff).
.
. "" ,
. , " " ( .)
, , ( .).
"" . ,
, ' "", , ..
, , , , "" ..
.
) ""
. , , " "
" , . ". ,
, . ,
. ,
.

...................
1. . " ", . 5 ( )

1

, ,
, " ".
, '
, .
. "".
(, ,
..). '
Scientific American (. 1979).
,
.
"" "", "" ( ),
"", " " ..
"" , ,
.
.

" ", " " (IQ),
. ("
") .
. "", "".
, implosion explosion.

. , "" "". ..
"" "",
"". ,
"" "".
, , ( . a priori).
"". "" (, ),
""
( . a posteriori). "" ,
. ,
"" "".
"". ,
, " " ,
.
" " (.. , ..), ,
, .

 , (),
.
"" ,
. , n
. "" (implosion).
, , ' ,
. , ,
(
). ' .
"" . .
.
, , , .

... !
.
, , ""
(explosion).
. ""
() (). ( )
" ", "" (Intelligence quotient, IQ).
) ( ),
. ,
. ""
"",
. ""
"". , .. "
", 14
( " NATO ")
""
. ' 14 ,
.
) , (), .
,
.
Nexus
' ( );
(nexus) ,
. ,
. , ""
. " ",
(. 259 ). , ,
. . , 2 , 3 (
), 4 ( ) 5 .

(. ) .

 ,
nexus . ,
(. "") nexus
. , (,
) , . ,
,
.
. ..
" ", " ", " ".
, , " ", " ", "
", " ". ,
, . . "
", " ". ""
( ) ""
. "" (Gradbegriff).

. .
. .
. ,
().

.
, "".
, ,
. ,
' (
) " " (. . 8).
, ""
: ) , . , )
, . .
(, , , ..)
.

, , ,
. , ,
. ""
"". ' , ""
.
(, , ..). ' ""
. ' ,
(, )
(.
, , , , , , ..). '
(, , ,
, , , , ..),
1.

1. ""
( , .. ).
, ,
() ,
,
, . ,
, . .. ,
, , , ..,
.
***

( ). , ..
, , , "" , '
.
(, ).
,
, 1.
, , , ,
"" .
.
1. . . .

, ,
,
.
( )
( "").
(.. ,
, ..).
. , (.
""), ,
("").
, ,
,
. .. ( "")


. , , .. , ,
.., .
.

' ,
.
, .
"" (distincte)
Descartes
. ,
. '
. ( "" )
, .

.
(dnombrement)
.
, "" (discursive) (, , ,
)
) , ) . ,
, . '
(. . . 9),
:
"" , .
, , ,
.

( ). :
'
( ),

. , :
.
. .
, !
.

, ! ; , ,
, .
( ) .
, , , !
, , .


" "
. )
, ) .
;
, "" "" (
, , "" )1 ""
( , "" ).
"" (Implosion). ,
, "", "" "" . '
(omnis determinatio est negatio). , ,
"" ("" ) ""
("" )2.
, "" (. "")
(.. , ,
, ..). "" , , ,
(""). (
) .
() , a priori. .
"" ( a posteriori),
"", a priori.
3, :
" ". : ""
"" , , (.
).

..
1. . Kant, KRV 80 105 . , 23 ..
2. . 255 ..

' , ""
. , ,
. ,
. ,
. .
;
' (
""), (. a priori) ' : ,
(=, ), , ( ,
), , , , ( ,
). " , ",

 . a priori
: "" .
..
3. . " " (), . 150 ..

(.
), : (),
(),
( ). ,
() .
,
. ' .
, "" ;
.

, (
), ., ""
. ""
"", . " ". ""
"", "". "" ,
" " .
" ".
( ),
(" " ). "
" () .
,
" " (), . 141 272 La thorie
de l' espace, . 273 295.
""
,
,
. , , . ,
,
.
Levy Bruhl 4.
" ". ,
. LB
a priori.
. ,
. " ", 5,

 a priori. " ".

(. )
. ' , ,
. , .. , .
( ""),
.

4. La mentalit primitive (Paris, 1925).

5. "Fr uns Menschen wenigstens".

. "" , , "",
(Ides Distinctes). .
. .. " ",
LB,
. . ,
( ) .
' ( ""
""), , .
, , . ()
, . . .
"" "" . ,
. , ,
, 6.
,
( ) .
, ,
"" "" "" , , "".
.
"" .
.
6. , "
", "" "".
. . ! ' ""
. ""
.

(..
) , '
, , .
.
, ' ,
. , ,

 ;
, : .
, "
" (, 81).
'
. , ,
. ,
, , , ' ,
.
"" " ".

.
"". .
" " , , '
. , "
" "",
. , ""

. "",
, , "", . .
"" (
"")
(, ..)
"" . ( ,
, ..) .
" "
, "" "" , ,
7. .

, ( )
( ). '
.

..
7. "" . " ".

3

, .
, .
.
. , .

 . "
" (Nexus) .
.
:
; .
, '
. ;

, . . (
), ,
, .
"". (Connotatio) "
" " ".
.
" ". ,
' , . ,
.., "" "" : "
, ,
". " "
" ".
, , "
" (Quaternio Terminorum). ,
(.. "", "" ..)
, .
, 1990, : " .
.
"! ,
" , ".
,
(. , ' ., "
", ).
.


(Intention, Connotatio),
(Extension, Denotatio). , , .
, ,
: " " (
, . 2 " " 25.5.90).
, " " 45% ,
,
! . " " (In
Dictione) . , ,
Levy Bruhl , ,
! (
) .


, ,
" " ""
, " ", (A dicto simpliciter ad dictum
secundum quid). ..: " ,
, ".
.

..
. ( )

, "" .
"" ""
. ..
.

" ".

. (Connotatio)
(Denotatio) ,
(Secundum Quid).
.
.
" " " ".
, ,
( ) . ""
" ".
,
. "" ""
, .
, "
" ( !) " . .
"! ""
, . ,
! (.
"" " " . 1990 "
").

.
" ".

(.. , ,
, ..).


. .. . "
" : " ;" (Just
what do you mean? G.E. Moore ...
!").

.
".

.

4


, , .
: ()
, ()
. "" '
" " " ". " ".
, , .
" " (Extra Dictionem). ,
, . , ,
.

""
. ;, , , "
" (Intuition de tout la fois). ' ,
, , .
"" Descartes . 2. '
, , .
"" (Discursivit). (
)
, , .
, ,
.
"" , ""
, ,
, . , '
, , , ,
,
. . , , "" "", "
" "". "", ,

" ". .
.
" " (Ignoratio Elenchi)
.


. ..,

, " ". '
, ,
.
...
... , , .. . ,
, " ".
" " ( 1990)
, ,
, .
"" (. )
.
"" " ". ;
"" ""
"" ... "! ""
" ". .
"'
... "! ( ""
). , .
, , !
. " ".
, "
"". '
"" ... . ,
... .
. "
, ,
"! ( )
.

" ".
, , ""
"" , ""
! .
" " ... !
, ' '
.

Ad hominem ad rem
" " "Ad hominem".
:
) , (. ad rem) ,
.
" " !
) .
,
.
" " " ...".
)
, . : "
, , ".
.
. .
.
.
"" .
Ad hominem ( Ad homines) .
.
( )
" " " " (
).
Argumentum ad homines.
.
... " " "
"! Ad Hominem,
), ) ) .
.
( ) ""
Ad rem. ""
(" ") .

"" .
" " " ", "
" "" Argumentum ad hominem, .

, , .
. .

12 , ,
( )
.
(1561-1626).
, ,
. " " "
" (petitio principii).
, (. .).
, , , .
(begging the question). " " "
", (" ")
. , " " (
)! , "" " ".
.
. ""
, ' , ... ! ,
"" . ,
" ". "" ;

"" (induction).
; ""
"";
"" .
.
, " ".
,
, "" , .
. "".
.
. .
""
. ,
" ".
" " 1. "" .
, ' .
, .
. , "" .
"" . , ,
, " ". ,
, , .
, : "
" ( 81). " "

(uniformity of nature). ' , ,

. , ( )
, " " (non fit saltus). ,
"" (. ) "" (. ).
""
, ( ).

..
1. , , , ,
. : , .

, ,
,
.
, .
, .
, , . , ,
, . ,
. ,
, , .
. , , .

" ", " ". ,
,
. (
) . , , ,
, ,
. " ",
.

,
"" ( ... !).
.
, .
.
(.: "" , ,
). ,
. , ,
.
, ,
"". ""
" ".
, ,
, "" . ,

"" . .
. , . ..,
" ". ...
"". , .. "
" (. ). ,
.
"" , .
: " ", "
" () " ", "
", " ", " " ""
. ,
"
" ( !).

( ) . " ".
, . , ()
(). , , . , ()
()2 "" .
()
() (). " "
" " (. ).
"".
, . "
" " ",
,
( : " ") .

.
2. , Affirmo, , Nego

61

(. 2) "" :
"" "" ( ) "" "" ( ). (
La
thorie de l espace). ""
"". ,
. , ,
. ' ,
"" (Gemeinschaft). , ,
2.

..
1.
"" .
2. , , "" , Gestaltpsychologie.

, , , , "" (.
), (.
) "" .
" " ( )
(nexus). , ,
. ,
" " (a priori). ,
, , ,
" " (ex nihilo nihil fit), " ".
, , .
"" "". " a priori", . .
, , "" . a priori ,
3.
, , , " ". , ,
, . "" (a posteriori).
. "" (deduction), .
,
, . "", .
" ".
,
. , "" "",
"" "". "",
, . , ""
, "", ,
. , . , ,
"" ( ""), (
). .
("visibilia" "tangibilia") ,
' 4.
" ",
5.
.
, , : , .
"" ( ""), (
).
, "" " ". "" ""
. , , , . ,
, .
(
), .
"" .
"".

 ,
( . . ""
.

...........................................
3. ";".
4. ..
.
5. ""
( ),
. ,
.

(.
), " " (non causa pro
causa). . ,
"" .
. .
, , " ". ,
, " ".
, "" , " "
"" .
"". , a
priori, .
"",
. . Flix qui potuit rerum cognoscere
causas. ,
, n
.
"", . , ..
" ", .
"", .
" ",
"". .
Propter hoc
,
" ". " , " (post hoc,
ergo propter hoc). ( )
. , ..,
. " ".
"" , ,
. , , ,
... ! ,
"" ( ... !)6.
..................................

6. , " " '

. .., ,
. ' . ,
"".

, . ,
() ,
. , , " ".
, propter hoc
.
, .., 1989 ,
( ,
..),
. ... .
.
,
.
: 1990,
. . .
,
! post hoc ergo propter hoc (
) ,
" ", : (),
().
, , " ".
, "" "
". " ",
, "" . , , , '
, " ". , ,
" ", , a priori,
.
, , "", " ".
" "
. , , .
; , ,
.

 ,
, , .
.
"" "" .
"" . .
" " "".
, . ( )
, .
, , .
: ,
. ,
. , ..
, ,
.. :
1987.
"", , ,
( , , ..).
, ,
, ,
. , ,
, (, , ..)
. , ( )
, . '
" "
.
( ),
.
" "

" ".
. , ,
,
.
(
) . ""
. , , .
"" (Discursivit). "
". , ( "")
. "" "",
.
"" "" ("", , , ). , ,
"" ", ", "". '
:
"" . ,
, . .
"" , . . ,

 .
, , . , "
". "" . '
. "
' ", " " .. , ,
.
, .
, ' ,
, ' (.
" " Philosophical Works, ).

""
. ,
. , , .
: ,
, , " " . :
,
.
" ". ,
, "
". ( , , " , ,
... !).
, "" ""
. (.
) .
. "
" .
" " , " "
"" .
.
. : .

, . .
, "
, ", ().
, ,
, . , .
"" ,
, , ,
. , !
.
.
. ""

. , :
.

 .
, (..
).
, "",
. ,
. " NATO
" .
. '
" ", .
, ""
,
.
n n " ",
;
.

8
" "

( ) ""
. ,
, (. ), " "
. , ,
.
"" (Discursivit). , , ,
" ".
6 , .
.
.
.
.
, ,
.
. :
, . '
, .
. :
, , , , .
, "", . "
" .
, "", " ", " " ..

 "".
,
"" ! ""
. "" ,
. 20 , ,
"" "".
.
, .. (
""). .. " ".
' . '
. .. " "
.
, ...
,
, "" " NATO ".
. ..
. ,
, .
"", .
" ",
.
"" .
, " '
' ". , "", .
.
: ) (
, , ..), ) ""
, ) ,
" ". .

" " .
: ) , ' ,
, ) ,
(association) (). '
"" ,
. ,
.
, ( ) " "
,
.
" ". .
. , .
.
" " (
) .
, , , , , .

 , .
"" " ". '
. ;
" ",
. ""
. " " ' .
"" . ,
.
" "
. "" .
"" .
. ,
. "
". .
, "" , . " "1.
" ". , ,
. ""
"" .

n
.
,

.

. "" "",
" ". , "" ,
. , .
. ' ,
, "".
1989, 70 , ""
"".
, ,
( : )
" ".

.
1. . ,
"" . , , "
". . " " ().



, , .
, , ,
"" "" " ". .. " "
. "ad hominem"
" " .. , ,
.
"". 19 ,
" " (la chasse aux facteurs) , ,
"" ! , ..,
" " (. "
", . 44 66 ..).
"" "" (oversimplification).
"" (..
, , ..) ' ,
"".
"",
( ), ,
.
( ) " " "".
"" (,
..), "".
"" .
"" .
, , "" . ,

. "" .
. ,
: . "",
"" (: ""). '
" ".
,
" ",
"" , , . ,
( , ) .


" " (, "")
, , " ".
. (. .
. 2) () , () .
, :
" ". , , "
".' , , .
(. . 8).
. ,
.
"" "". ;
(
) .
...........................................
1. 1.8.1984 .
"" ( )
.
: " " ! (. "" 5.8.84).
.

""
. ,
"" "".
()
.
.
' ,
, ' , ..,
.
, '
! , ,
... ,

... ,

" ". , ,
.
() ""
.
"" " "" ;
, .
, , .

 " ". , ,
.
"".
, '
.
. esprit de
corps, () .
"" ""
"" . " "
.
, , "",
, , , , "",
, . . ,
( 1990) ""
(" ") ....
!
"" "".
.

. " ".
,

.
. "" (. . . ).
"" " "
.
.
. ,
. "",
" " (wishful thinking)
(" ").
" ".
,
, "
". .

.
" ".
.
. "
" "" (education)
"". , () , ,
() , , ..
"" ,

 (, ..) "
" . ' "
, ", ' . " ".
, ,
.

. .
" " ' ,
.
, . , ,
. ""
(.. , ).
" ". ,
, " ", " ", "
", " "! jtou
" ", .

, ,
. , ,
.

.

"" ""
"". , .
, , .
" ". " "
. , , n
. , .
.
.
" ".
, . , ,
.
, ,
. "" .
,
.
. ' .

 10

, , , n
, .
, ,
. , ,
, , .
.
"
", .
,
:
) , (,
)
(). "", ""
"", ' (, , , ,
..), .
) ,
( , , ,
).
) , ,
, " ".
, ,
" ' ".
, (
"" ) : ,
, ;
( " ")
, , ,
.


. .
: , )
(. ) )
, . ,
" " (adequatio rei et intellectus), " ""
.

 , , , "
". , ' , .
, .
, ""
. , , n ,
"" () "" ().

, . " ".

"" ' .
... " "! '
"" ( .. ) "" '
"" "" .
, "" (.
) , ,
. , , ,
, :
"" !
.
! , ,
. , :
. . "
", , , .
" "
" "
. , (... ) :
,
"" ,
. , ..,
! , n , ' , .
, , ' ,
. " ".
" ",
, . , .
" ", "".
,
. n "", ,
. " "1. .
.

, .
, .

""
, , " ",
.
, '
, , , . ,
, . ,
.
"",
, .

,
,
.

.

1) "verit effettuale". . " ".

, , ,
... "". . ,
.
.
. , ,
.
. " " ( ,
, ), .
,
. , ,
, , , ( )
.
, .
, "

 ". , , "
".
.

. , .
,
, " ".

. ,
:
.
( )
, (conceptus). ,
:
) ( "")
) ( "")
) ( "")
, "" .
, "" .
, . , .
, , , ,
, (.. , , ..).
,
. , ( ""
"") .

, ,
"",
. " "
"" 1990.
, .

1
(. " ", 13 19 1990)

" ", , :
)
(attitude) . ) .
, " ", .
NATO.
***
27.11.1975 : " NATO
" (!). 1979,
: "
, ".
1988 STERN: " ,
NATO". 1.12.1983 : "
, ,
". 18.10.1982

Washington Post: " NATO,

".
' , .. 30.8.1988 "
" "
".
, 1989 : "
. "!
"
".

.
, . :
1987 : " ,
. , " !
"" :
, .
( "
").
1.8.1984
"" (
) ,
, .. : "
"! (. "" 5.8.84).
"" (10.8.86) , ""
" (1986) (1987),
".
""!
(1985), : " .. :
, "! , Davos,
: " , ,
, .
".
, 1983
"": "
. "! 25.7.84 :
" ,
, ' " (. "" 26.7.84).

12.4.1985: " . :
, ".
(17.10.1985),
: " . : 4
; ! ,
. .

".
, 1.
1. ,
"" " ",
State
Department (. . 3).

2
(. " " 2531 1990).

"" . (.
6.2.1986). (11.1.1986),
1986.
. , : "
, ' ,
.
, ... 4 ...
, ...

,
".
' 1986 ( !)
. , " ": "
. .
, "!! : "
, ,
. , "! : "
: ,
, , ,
(!)
"!
. 1986, .
... . : "
.
(!).
.
(! ! !). , ,

".

 1986, 5 , "
" " "!
; 1986 " ",
. , ,
!
" ", . . "

. ".
... " ", ...
, . ,
""!

, .
.
NATO " ". , 1988,
" ", .

. . ,
"" 25.3.1990.
, "" 1986, .
: " 15
"!
' 1975, .
, "" " "! ,
" 15", 1990!
: " ,
.
(!)
... ,

".
, ...
" ", "" . ,
25 ( ) 1990!
. .
( ... !): " ,
( ... )
. (!)
, .
. , ,
(!).
. (!).
n
(!)

 , , .

.
... , ...
".
1990 ,
" " (, ,
"", ). 6.2.1986
: "
"! , , " "
" NATO ". ,

! ,
. , ,
.
***

( "" ""),
. ""
" " , .

3 .

( "" 10.11.90.
).
.
: ) ,
) * " ".
, , ,
, , . '
, ""
" " "" (
)
.
' ,
,
. "" .

: . ,
, :
" , "

 " ".
( ) .
, ,
.
' "" ,
. "
" , .
(, , , , ..).
,
CIA
, 1983: " "!

, , . ;
,
. , . ,
, . , ", ,
" . . , ,
.
. , ( )
, , (
) .
,
. ' , ,
. , ,
.
, , . '
. , ,
. :
, , . ,
. , .

. ,
, .
. . ,
,
. (
) ,
" ". ,
,
.
" ". n
.
[ , . )
, ) .

"" .

 ,
. " NATO "
. , 1974,
" "
. , ( )
, .
:
Kunpou. H , ,
( ) .
.
.

.
"
".
. .
NATO.
"" ;
,
, "" , .
'
. , .]1
NATO
.
"" ""
.
. , 2
. , , , ,
.
, . NATO

.
, , ,
, ( ;)
" ".
1. ,
.
2. "" "" . Kissinger,

"" Watergate.

:
.
. . ,
, , , . . (

 ) (
). .
, , ,
( "")
.
[,
. ,
, .
,
, , ,
"" .
,
, ,
"".

.]
""
"" 1988. 30.8.88,
.. , "
" " ".
,
"" ( ). "" :
..
, : "
;". . ,
. .
" "
, .
, ,
1989 : .
, .
. , 1989, ,
, , : "
.
"!
.
' , , "
".
, , "" (.
)
.
, (petites perceptions) ,
.

!
" ", '

 . ,
( ) "", ""
( ).
( .. )
"" "" .
" " "" ,
.. ", " ""
... " "
! (. . 2). " "
, .. " " "
" .. .
. ,
' , " ",
, .
,
1.
; , , .
( ), ""
,
, .

..
1. . " ", . () . 157 - 164.

. , (. . ,)
"". ,
, , ""
.
, ,
, .
:
.
(, , , , , ,
, ).
""
"" ' , ""
" ".

 ( )

( )
" ".

" ". .
" ,
". .
()
" . . .
, ". .
()

1
" " "
". .
" " ". .
" , ".

" ,
, ".
(. 162)
" "
". ( )
" ".
.
( )
" , ...
" (!).

()

" , .
, , , , .
". .
()
" " "
".

" . .
". .
()

,
" ". " ".

(12.5.1984)
.
" .
. , , , ".
(21.3.88)

,
", , , .
, , ". .
()
"J'ai abord avec grand plaisir votre prsentation de notre histoire (Chap. II), laquelle me
semble tre aussi courte que prcise et des plus intressante". H.V. Willi, Service juridique.
Chancellerie Fdrale, BERNE

PHILOSOPHICAL WORKS ECRITS PHILOSOPHIQUES

(: . Eu. , )
"Je vous flicite de maintenir ouverte et vivante votre activit philosophique dans votre intrt
et dans le ntre. Je garde votre livre porte de la main et ne manquerai pas de le reprendre chaque
fois que ma soif philosophique m'en donnerai' envie". (29.6.1989). Ren Schaerer,

(. , . )

" , 5 ,
,
".
(26.6.1991)
:
La thorie de Lespace chez Kant et Platon, Genve ( .
), . 300.
Le principe de la distinction chez Descartes, Revue de mtaphysique et de morale, Paris.
DIOTIMA ( ).
:
( ,
, 4 18 ..).

...............................................................................5
, ' . ......................7
' ...................................12
1. ..............................19
2. .....................27
3. ........................38
4. ..................44
5. ...............................50
6. .......................................................56
7. ...................................63
8.0 " " ......................69

9. .....................................76
10. ...........................................................83
.....................................89
,
..........................91
1 ...........91
2 .......................94
3
. ...............................98
.............................................................................105