Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Social Media in Defence 2012
Social Media in Defence 2012
Social Media in Defence 2012
Content Page
ABOUT THE RESEARCH.. 3 WHAT IS SOCIAL MEDIA? WHAT DOES ONLINE PRESENCE MEAN?................. 5 THE IMPORTANCE OF BEING SOCIAL MEDIA SAAVY... 7 THE BENEFITS... 8 THE CHALLENGES.. 13 How not to become a nexus of hatred.. 15 Which other industries face similar challenges?.................... 16 WHICH PLATFORM IS MOST EFFECTIVE?.......................................................... 17 Dispelling myths about the word social... 19 Breaking news 22 DEFENCE CONTRACTORS RATED. 23 Listening: An alternative role for social media... 29 Counting the cost. 30 Getting it right. 31 TAKING ADVANTAGE OF OPPORTUNITIES... 33 APPENDIX A 35 APPENDIX B 36 APPENDIX C 37 APPENDIX D... 38 ABOUT DEFENCE IQ.. 39 DISCLAIMER... 40
Page 2
10%
22%
68%
Page 3
Looking at Figure 2 (the data for which can been seen in Appendix A, page 35), the United States had the highest representation in the survey (30%) followed closely by the UK (29%). Other European nations Germany (5%) and Sweden (4%) account for a significant portion of
respondents with the remaining 29% sourced from around the globe, including Canada, Israel, India, Australia, Singapore and South Africa.
Data: Appendix A
Page 4
Social media: Media for social interaction, using highly accessible and scalable communication techniques. Social media is the use of web-based and mobile technologies to turn communication into interactive dialogue. Wikipedia, The social encyclopaedia
Page 5
For the purposes of this report, social media platforms can include, but are not exclusive to, Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, Google+ and Pinterest. An online presence can be considered within a wider framework outside of and in addition to social media. Keeping a blog updated with timely and relevant content can help establish an effective online presence. So too can producing technical whitepapers, participating in topic-specific webinars and being open to interviews with relevant industry publications.
Page 6
Figure 3: Analysis of how important it is for defence contractors to improve their online and social media presence over the next 5 years
Essential Very important Somewhat important Not important
9% 21%
30%
40%
Page 7
The benefits
A key conclusion from the survey data suggests that social media should be used as a platform to increase brand awareness and for embracing outreach initiatives. It is more to do with nurturing a brand and less about generating new business. The top five responses in Figure 4 highlight this trend. All relate to brand awareness and thought leadership while the more hard sell factors, such as lead generation and competitive edge, come much further down the priority list. Thomas Guest, formerly of the UKTI Defence & Security Organisation, said social media is most important for improving PR and not as a means to drive new business, that will continue to be done in tradition manners. One of the challenges of using social media to any length is convincing the accountants that there is an ROI. This can be difficult. However, one area where this distinction becomes clearer is when social media platforms are used as recruitment tools. A number of firms including Boeing, Raytheon and Thales have active social media outreach programmes dedicated to recruitment. With 59% of respondents indicating that this is one of the key advantages of social media its likely that others will follow this example. But its not just the primes that can adopt online recruitment techniques. Any recruiter or headhunter will have a story where theyve been bested by a shrewd employee at an SME (Small and Medium Enterprise) that advertised and recruited someone independently through social media. Do not expect these stories to become less frequent in the future. Towards the bottom of the list of social media advantages is that it allows companies to keep tabs on the competition. However, as Figure 5 on page 14 shows, respondents felt that the risk of divulging too much information to competitors through social media channels was the key disadvantage to having an online presence. There is a paradox here. Contactors do not generally see social media as a useful means of gaining any form of competitive edge; it is not an effective corporate espionage tool. What we are seeing here is the unsupported and irrational fear of exposure being used as an excuse for online discretion to the detriment of the companys brand and, ultimately, bottom line performance. The climate of suspicion that surrounds social media in the defence industry does not reflect the reality. If managed properly social media platforms do not leave companies open to risks relating to IP and corporate strategy; they do, however, provide an excellent forum to enhance brand awareness, as underpinned by the survey data.
Page 8
Figure 4: Overview of the advantages for defence contractors using social media
Increased brand awareness Recruitment purposes Chance to become a recognised thought leader in the market Easier and freer relationship building with journalists and the media Its the cheapest form of marketing Lead generation Keeping tabs on the competition For collecting customer feedback To stay ahead of the competition Other There are NO advantages
11% 5%
Page 9
Data: Appendix B
While only 5% of respondents noted that there are no real-world advantages to using social media, its still 5%. Even those that have least bought into social media would be expected to have had some appreciation for what benefits an online presence can offer, however minor. For a respondent to underline that there are none is revealing. At the Farnborough International Airshow in July, the Defence IQ team undertook a straw poll to get some indicative insight on social media practice. One participant made an interesting comparison; he explained that social media today is much like Territorial Army (TA) service in the 1980s.
Up to that point, most of the people making the decisions at the corporate level had gone through the National Service programme whereby all healthy males between the ages of 17 to 21 years were signed up to the armed forces for four years. When a TA asked for leave from work to participate in exercises, the answer, since most managers and directors were proud ex-military personnel, the answer was often a resounding yes. With a hearty pat on the back too. However, following the demise of National Service in 1960 in the UK, by the time the 80s came around many of these leaders with military breeding had passed the torch on to a new generation of company management. The new generation didnt understand the need for TAs to have quite so much paid time off. So the yes count dried up. The point is that there was a generation gap; a fundamental change had occurred from one generation to the next. A whole mindset had shifted.
Social media is most important for improving PR and not as a means to drive new business, that will be done in tradition manners. Thomas Guest, Formerly of UKTI Defence & Security Organisation
Page 10
Likewise, when this generation of internet savvy children become the decision-makers of the future, not having a robust online presence with an engaging and spirited social media policy would be, at the very least, ignorant. Like it or not, in one form or another, social media is here to stay. The platforms we use will evolve Facebook and Twitter may or may not be the tools of choice ten years from now but the concept of connecting with more people, customers, brands and businesses online is unavoidable. As Douglas Burdett, a social media expert in the defence industry and author of the Fire Support blog, says: Inertia is a powerful force in the defence industry. Some defence
contractors are having difficulty transforming their cultures the need to be more open and communicative is not currently familiar territory for the defence industry, but it will be. As Figure 4 highlights, there are significant benefits to using social media, regardless of industry.* However, there are of course challenges too and the full benefit of these social platforms cannot be realised until these hurdles are addressed, mitigated and eradicated.
* A comparison of how other industries face similar challenges to defence is presented on page 16
Page 11
The climate of suspicion that surrounds social media in the defence industry does not reflect the reality. If managed properly social media platforms do not leave companies open to risks relating to IP and corporate strategy; they do, however, provide an excellent forum to enhance brand awareness.
Page 12
The challenges
Figure 5 highlights that the discreet nature of the defence industry is a critical barrier for companies to utilise social media. One third of respondents stated that a lack of an active and relevant online community to engage with was one of the pitfalls for defence companies using social media. But to reframe that, 70% of respondents inferred that there was an active and relevant community. Most of the top 20 defence contractors have active Twitter, Facebook and LinkedIn accounts, so its clear that there is a readymade audience. However, the extent to which these are being successfully utilised is explored in greater detail later in this report.
Companies from all industries face the challenge of not divulging proprietary ideas, direction or corporate strategy, so defence is not unique. Steven Mains, PhD COO, TechMIS, LLC
Page 13
Figure 5: Overview of the disadvantages for defence contractors using social media
58% Risk of divulging too much information (to competitors, enemy states etc.) The discreet nature of the business 53% Limited internal understanding and lack of correct skill base 47% 30% Inactive/irrelevant online community 30% Easy for detractors to air grievances Other 14% There are NO significant challenges compared with other industries 10%
Data: Appendix C
Page 14
It doesnt matter that the social media team responded with humour; the key point is that O2 responded. It could have been with grovelling apologies or with parent-like disdain; the way in which O2 responded is less important that the simple fact that it actually responded. In doing so it exposed the members of that community that were uninterested in participating in a sensible interactive dialogue and, in turn, won the company a legion of new fans. Developing a detailed social media strategy is compulsory as it will be an effective tool when faced with online detractors.
Page 15
Page 16
Figure 6: Analysis of most effective platform for brand awareness and thought leadership
Innefective 0% Whitepapers Linked In Twitter Hosted article Company newsletter Blogging Webinar Hosted videos YouTube Facebook Other social media (Pinterest) Banner ads Somewhat effective 10% 20% 30% 40% Very effective 50% 60% Critical 70% 80% 90% 100%
Page 17
However, this belies what the defence media think. Figure 7 shows that LinkedIn is the most critical platform, while Twitter is the most effective. Although this report seeks to distinguish social media from other forms of online presence, the disparity between the data in Figures 6 and 7 demonstrates that the two are inextricably linked. Both work hand-inhand to present an overall picture of a company.
The conclusion is that a balance between producing informed, constructive content and effective social media engagement is fundamental to building and maintaining a strong brand, which is backed up by a robust online presence. Another critical point to understand here is that while no one thinks Twitter and for the purposes of this analysis we can extract that out to mean social media platforms in general is a critical tool (Figure 7), it is the most effective for online engagement, as the majority (53%) indicated.
Figure 7: Analysis of key platforms the media use for engaging with and learning more about defence contractors
Innefective 0% Linked In Hosted videos Facebook Hosted article Banner ads Blogging YouTube Whitepapers Other social media (Pinterest) Twitter Webinar Company newsletter Somewhat effective 10% 20% 30% Very effective 40% 50% 60% Critical 70% 80% 90% 100%
Page 18
Page 19
The urban myth of the social media world is when the CEOs daughter comes back home and asks him why his company isnt on Facebook. Next morning the CEO tells his marketing team to create a Facebook page but with no understanding of what the point of having one is A lot of companies set-up a Facebook page and just become a nexus of hatredwithout clear social media objectives all youre doing is creating a public forum for people who hate your brand. Theres a real negative ROI with outreach which I think defence contractors have to be careful of. Patrick Herridge, Co-Founder, Social360 Ltd.
Page 20
Douglas Burdett recommends that those companies considering using social media as a marketing tool ask themselves one question: Which groups would you most like to have a relationship with and what content can you offer that would be of interest to them? This will be the cornerstone of any successful social media strategy.
We still have telephones the same as we did in 1972, but in 2012 they now come equipped with music players, navigation systems and cameras too. Social media is to marketing what the iPhone was to the rotary dial.
Figure 8: Analysis of which tools the defence media use to learn more about industy news and issues
Innefective 0% Linked In Twitter Facebook Whitepapers Hosted videos Blogging Hosted article Webinar Company newsletter YouTube Banner ads Other social media (Pinterest) Somewhat effective 10% 20% 30% 40% Very effective 50% 60% Critical 70% 80% 90% 100%
Page 21
Breaking news
According to respondents, Figure 8 again shows that Twitter is most effective in helping users learn about and understand issues in the defence industry. The reason for this is that social media offers instant, up-to-date and, if youre following the right people, reliable information. While blogging is also highly rated by defence media professionals, Twitter is the preferred option because its immediate. It also allows users to easily read a wide range of opinions and quickly appreciate many different angles on the same story.
Page 22
Special recognition
EADS provoked a decent response from the survey participants (with 22%), but this does not fairly represent the quality of the European defence companys social media outreach. This was demonstrable during the Farnborough Airshow where the EADS social media team, using the event-specific @EASlive Twitter account, gave a master class in how to provide informative on-site
updates. The EADS team shared exclusive pictures, insight from visiting delegations, chances to win (relevant) prizes in on-going competitions, as well as general event updates. The coverage was not aimed at being corporate propaganda and nor was it idle nonsense it was balanced, helpful, and interesting.
Page 23
Data: Appendix D
Page 24
We still have telephones the same as we did in 1972, but in 2012 they now come equipped with music players, navigation systems and cameras too. Social media is to marketing what the iPhone was to the rotary dial.
Page 25
Together with the survey data it is worth considering these responses in the context of what the specified companies social media presence actually looks like. Figure 10 shows the number of followers each company has on their main Twitter account, the number of likes they have on Facebook, as well as giving an indication of how frequently their Twitter accounts are updated (based on an average taken from three random samples).
Essentially, the higher the purple areas and the lower the blue bar, the better a companys social media presence is. The companies identified by survey respondents are generally those that have active and established social media activities, although its clear that Booz Allen Hamilton should have been considered within the top group that included BAE, Boeing and EADS.
Page 26
I think the large defence companies are failing miserably in this area. If you go to a webpage, Facebook page, etc. for one of these companies, you can hardly tell which one you're visiting. There is no individuality or personality. The large companies seem to benefit from being perceived as a commodity - a concept that is inconsistent with having an effective social media presence; an effective social media presence benefits from personality. Gregg R. Sypeck, Senior Vice President, Mav6, LLC
Page 27
For further context, in his blog Douglas Burdett recently published a list of the top 100 defence contractors rated by the quality of their website.
Based on Defence News annual list, here are the top 20 defence contractors from 2011 together with their website grade:
1.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20.
68% Boeing 72% BAE Systems 45% General Dynamics 46% Raytheon 69% Northrop Grumman 78% EADS 58% Finmeccanica 27% L-3 Communications 50% United Technologies 57% Thales 68% SIAC 73% Huntington Ingalls 61% Honeywell 55% Booz Allen Hamilton 84% Rolls-Royce 55% CSC 72% Oshkosh 54% Textron 53% GE 67%
Lockheed Martin
Page 28
Page 29
Figure 11: Overview of what percentage of marketing budget defence contractors should spend on social media (company perspective)
0% 2% - 5% 10% - 20% <2% 5% - 10% 20% - 30%
10% 15%
10% 20%
12% 7% 26%
Figure 12: Overview of what percentage of marketing budget defence contractors should spend on social media (media perspective)
<2% 5% - 10% 20% - 30% 5% 5% 2% - 5% 10% - 20% 30%+ 11% 21%
47%
11%
Page 30
Getting it right
When a social media campaign goes right it can have a real impact. Perhaps one of the more obvious examples is Raytheons Hashtags for Heroes (#HT4H). This is how the company described it in a press release: This innovative campaign takes advantage of what is, in effect, surplus tweet capacity. Of the total 140 characters that Twitter users are allotted for every tweet, many characters often go unused (according to one estimate, the most common tweet length is about 28 characters). The campaign enables users to download a special Twitter platform application to tweet from their computers or mobile devices and easily "donate" their unused Twitter characters in support of WWP [Wounded Warrior Project]. The Twitter application powered by Raytheon led to the donation of 335,013 characters to the WWP. This resulted in a huge surge in traffic for the WWP website together with an influx of (monetary) donations. Details of the successful campaign can be found overleaf.
Page 31
Page 2 Page 32
Figure 13: To what extent do you think you will be increasing your social media and online presence over the next 5 years?
It will probably increase organically, but we wont be putting much resource into it
0%
5%
Page 33
When this generation of internet savvy children become the decisionmakers of the future, not having a robust online presence with an engaging and spirited social media policy would be, at the very least, ignorant. Like it or not, in one form or another, social media is here to stay.
Page 34
Appendix A
US UK Germany Sweden Australia Canada Italy Israel Netherlands Norway Spain Ethiopia India Lebanon Malaysia New Zealand Pakistan Romania Saudi Arabia Singapore South Africa Switzerland 0% 5% 10% 15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
Page 35
Appendix B
Page 36
Appendix C
Risk of divulging too much information The discreet nature of the business Limited internal understanding and lack of skill base Lack of active online community to engage with Too easy for detractors to air complaints publically Other There are NO significant challenges 0% 10% 20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Page 37
Appendix D
Page 38
About Defence IQ
Defence IQ is an authoritative news source for high quality and exclusive commentary and analysis on global defence and military-related topics. Sourcing interviews and insights directly from senior military and industry professionals on air defence, cyber warfare, armoured vehicles, naval defence, land defence and many more topics, Defence IQ is a unique multimedia platform to discuss and learn about the latest developments within the defence sector. So join over 60,000 defence professionals to access all the exclusive video interviews, podcasts, articles and whitepapers that are available and updated on a daily basis. Join today for free by signing up on our website: www.DefenceIQ.com Connect with us through social media too, just follow the links below:
Google+
Page 39
Disclaimer
This report is provided for information purposes only. This report may not be reproduced, published or distributed by an recipient for any purpose. The company accepts no responsibility whatsoever for any direct or indirect losses arising from the use of this report or its contents. Images courtesy of U.S. DoD, w3origin.blogspot.co.uk, slashgear.com and Raytheon.
About the author Andrew Elwell is the Editor-in-Chief of Defence IQ. He has previously worked as a survivability specialist for a provider of ballistic and blast armour systems. Andrew holds a BA in History and American Studies from the University of Nottingham. He can be reached on andrew.elwell@iqpc.co.uk. In the spirit of social media outreach: Connect with Andrew on LinkedIn Follow him on Twitter: DefenceIQ and @AJElwell
Page 40