Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Summer Project
Summer Project
Declaration
I, Mr. Abdul Kabir, student of Master of Business Administration(MBA) hereby, declare that this project report titled Financing under Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro & Small Enterprises (CGTMSE): Comparative Study of BOB, PNB & BOI. is the record of authentic work carried out by me during the academic year 2011 2012 and has not been submitted to any other University or Institute towards the award of any degree.
Abdul Kabir MBA (Finance) III Sem. Enrolment No. 301027 2010-12 Batch
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The satisfaction, which accompanies the successful completion of the project, is incomplete without the mention of a few names. I take this opportunity to acknowledge the efforts of many individuals who helped me make this project possible. I would like to express my heartfelt appreciation and gratitude to my project head Mr. Ashish Dutta Roy, Chief Manager, SME Loan Factory, Bank of Baroda, Varanasi .This project is a result of his teaching, encouragement and inputs. He made sure that my stay in the office was a learning experience. I would also like to thank Mr. S.K Srivastava, Officer Sales and Debabrata Sahoo, Officer Processing for their constant support, continued encouragement and guidance throughout my training period. Further I am indebted to Prof. H.C Chaudhary to act as my mentor for preparing this project more valuable & for his timely help and guidance. He had given me constant support, continued encouragement and guidance throughout my project preparation. Finally, I would like to thank my Institute, FMS BHU, for making this experience of summer training in an esteemed organization like Bank of Baroda possible. The learning from this experience has been immense and would be cherished throughout my life.
PREFACE
A project is a scientific and systematic study of real issues on a problem with the application of management concept and skills. The study can deal with small or big issues in any division of an organization. It can be case study where a problem has been dealt with, through the process of management. The essential equipment of a project is that, it should contain scientific collection of data, analysis and interpretation of data leading to a valid conclusion.
Summer Training is an essential part in the MBA curriculum. It enables the student to share the real experience in the corporate world. My summer training was placed in SME Loan Factory, Bank of Baroda, Varanasi.
Trust for Micro & Small Enterprises (CGTMSE): Comparative Study of BOB, PNB & BOI.
INDEX
Table of Content 1. Executive Summary 2. Banking Structure in INDIA 3. Classification of Banks 4. Introduction to Bank of Baroda 5. MSME 6. Bank of Barodas approach to SME sector 7. Business & Financial Performance 8. Financial Statement 9. SWOT Analysis 10. Research Methodology 11. Conceptual Framework of CGTMSE 12. Data Analysis & Interpretation 13. Comparison Table 14.Findings 15. Suggestions 16.Limitations 17.References 18.Annexure
Page Number 5 6 11 16 22 25 27 37 39 40 42 58 63 65 66 67 68 69
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Objective
The objective of this report was to study about the CGS of Credit Guarantee Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises (CGTMSE) and compare BOB, PNB & BOI for financing under the CGTMSE Scheme and thereby give certain suggestions to Bank of Baroda.
Approach
The study was conducted by analyzing the data collected through survey and also through the published data. Both primary and secondary data was collected in order to
Findings
During the study I found that it is necessary to create widespread awareness about the key features and benefits of the Credit Guarantee Scheme (CGS) of Credit Guarantee Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises (CGTMSE) to the customers. BOB is far behind its competitors in terms of achievement of target for opening of accounts under CGTMSE in Varanasi region for the financial year 2010-11. BOB was able to achieve only 43.2% of its target, whereas PNB and BOI were much ahead of its target. In spite of passing all the burden of upfront and annual service fees to the customer PNBs performance is best among the three banks.
Functions of RBI:
Currency issuing authority Banker to the government. Banker to other Bank. Framing of monetary policy. Exchange control. Custodian to foreign exchange and gold reserves. Development activities. Research and development in the banking sector.
CLASSIFICATION OF BANKS
On the basis of Ownership PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS Public sector banks are those banks that are owned by the government. The government owns these banks. In India 20 banks were nationalized in 1969 and 1980 respectively. Social welfare is there main objective. PRIVATE SECTOR BANKS These banks are those banks that are owned and run by private sector. An individual has control over these banks in proportion to the shares of the banks held by him. CO-OPERATIVE BANKS These are those banks that are jointly run by a group of individuals. Each individual has an equal share in these banks. Its shareholders manage the affairs of the bank. According to the Law SCHEDULED BANK Schedule banks are the banks, which are included in the second schedule of the banking regulation act 1965. According to this schedule bank: 1. Must have paid-up capital and reserve of not less than Rs500, 000. 2. Must also satisfy the RBI that its affairs are not conducted in a manner Determinate to the interest of its depositors. Schedule banks are sub-divided as:a) State co-operative banks b) Commercial banks NON-SCHEDULED BANKS Non -schedule banks are the banks, which are not included in the second schedule of the banking regulation act 1965. It means they do not satisfy the conditions lay down by that schedule. These are the banks having paid up capital, less than Rs.5Lakhs. They are further classified as follows:(A)Central Co-operative banks and Primary Credit Societies.(B)Commercial banks
Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises STRUCTURE OF BANKING SYSTEM
Different countries of the world have different types of banking systems. However, commercial banking had grown under all these banking systems. To understand the structure of banking system, let us take up various types Of banking systems one by one. These types are: (1) UNIT BANKING Unit Banking originated in the United State of America. It grew in the United States of America. As a counter part of independent or industrial units. An independent unit bank is a corporation that operates one office and that is not related to other banks through either ownership or control. Shaper, Solomon and White. Thus under unit banking, a single bank is a complete organization in itself having its own management. The scale of operation is small and the area is restricted to a locality only. Unit banking is localized banking and is much more responsive to the needs of the locality. It has better understanding of the local problems and conditions, which helps it to cater to the needs of the area in a better way. The staff of the unit bank is generally local and is in a better position to determine the standing or desirability of the customers. The failure of the unit bank will not endanger the banking system and economy. It is free from the difficulties and diseconomies of large scale operations. It will not drain out the financial resources of villages and small towns to big industrial centers and will ensure a balanced growth. (2) BRANCH BANKING: Economic and Managerial problems faced by the unit banks let to the emergence of banking system. Now, This the most popular and important banking system. In branch banking, a bank has a large network of branches scattered all over the country. Branch banking developed in England. Subsequently most of the countries of the world adopted the system. In terms of branches, the State Bank of India has emerged as one of the largest banks in the world. As under the system the resources of a number of branches get pooled under the same management, any individual branch is in a better position to face excessive withdrawals by the customers. It facilitates diversification of activities because the area covered by the branches is generally widespread.
History 1908-1959
1908: Maharaja Sayajirao Gaekwad III set up Bank of Baroda (BOB). 1910: BoB established its first branch in Ahmadabad. 1953: BoB established a branch in Mombasa and another in Kampala. 1954: BoB opened a branch in Nairobi. 1956: BoB opened a branch in Dar-es-Salaam. 1957: BoB established a branch in London. 1959: BoB acquired Hind Bank.
1960s
1961: BoB merged in New Citizen Bank of India. This merger helped it increase its branch network in Maharashtra.BOB also opened a branch in Fiji.1962: BoB opened a branch in Mauritius. 1963: BoB acquired Surat Banking Corporation in Surat, Gujarat. 1964: BoB acquired two banks, Umbergaon Peoples Bank in southern Gujarat and Tamil Nadu Central Bank in Tamil Nadu state. 1964: BoB lost its branch in Narayanjanj (East Pakistan) due to the Indo-Pakistan war. It is unclear when BOB had opened the branch. 1965: BoB opened a branch in Guyana. 1967: The Tanzanian government nationalized BoBs three branches there and transferred their operations to the Tanzanian government-owned National Banking Corporation. 1969: The government of India nationalized 14 top banks, including BoB. BoB incorporated its operations in Uganda as a 51% subsidiary, with the government owning the rest.
1970s
1972: BoB acquired The Bank of Indias operations in Uganda. 1974: BoB opened a branch each in Dubai and Abu Dhabi. 1975: BoB acquired the majority shareholding and management control of Bareilly Corporation Bank (est. 1928) and Nainital Bank (est. in 1954), both in Uttar Pradesh. Since then, Nainital Bank has expanded to Uttarakhand State. 1976: BoB opened a branch in Oman and another in Brussels. The Brussels branch was aimed at Indian firms from Mumbai (Bombay) engaged in diamond cutting and jewellery having business in Antwerp, a major center for diamond cutting. 1978: BoB opened a branch in New York and another in the Seychelles. 1979: BoB opened a branch in Nassau, the Bahamas.
1980s
BoB opened a branch in Bahrain and a representative office in Sydney, Australia. BoB, Union Bank of India and Indian Bank established IUB International Finance, a licensed deposit taker, in Hong Kong. Each of the three banks took an equal share. 1985: BoB (20%), Bank of India (20%), Central Bank of India (20%) and ZIMCO (Zambian government; 40%) established Indo-Zambia Bank (Lusaka). BoB also opened an Offshore Banking Unit (OBU) in Bahrain. 1988: BoB acquired Traders Bank, which had a branch network in Delhi.
1990s
1990: BoB opened an OBU in Mauritius, but closed its representative office in Sydney.
2000s
2000: BoB established Bank of Baroda (Botswana). 2002: BoB acquired Benares State Bank (BSB) at the Reserve Bank of Indias request. BSB was established in 1946 but traced its origins back to 1871 and its function as the treasury office of the Benares state. In 1964, BSB had acquired Bareilly Bank (est. 1934), with seven branches; it also had taken over Lucknow Bank in 1968. The acquisition of BSB brought BOB 105 new branches.
2010-11
2010: Malaysia awarded a commercial banking license to a locally incorporated bank to be jointly owned by Bank of Baroda, Indian Overseas Bank and Andhra Bank. The new bank, India BIA Bank (Malaysia), will reside in Kuala Lumpur, which has a large population of Indians. Andhra Bank will hold a 25% stake in the joint-venture, BoB will own 40% and IOB the remaining 35%. Online subscription of IPO/FPO (ASBA) was enabled. During financial year 2010-11, the total number of transactions in BCMS were 10,80,000 with total turnover of Rs 11,027 crore.
Banks Logo
Banks logo is a unique representation of a universal symbol. It comprises dual B letterforms that hold the rays of the rising sun. They call this the Baroda Sun. The sun is an excellent representation of what our bank stands for. It is the single most powerful source of light and energy its far reaching rays dispel darkness to illuminate everything they touch. At Bank of Baroda, it seek to be the source that will help all our stakeholders realize their goals. To our customers, we seek to be a one-stop, reliable partner who will help them address different financial needs. To our employees, we offer rewarding careers and to our investors and business partners, maximum return on their investment.
Particulars
Above Rs. 25/- lacs and Above Rs.10/- lacs and up to Rs.500/- lacs up to Rs.200/- lacs Above Rs.500/- lacs and up to Rs.1000/lacs Above Rs.200/- lacs and up to Rs.500/- lacs
Medium Enterprises
Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises Attractive features of the model are as under:
Team of officers having expertises in the area of credit with positive approach is selected. Instead of appointing DSAs(Direct Selling Agents), bank has appointed officers from existing dedicated team only.
The hubs main role is ensuring speedy appraisal & sanctioning of proposals pertaining to SME sector in a time bound program. The team members reach out to different market segments. Its important feature is working of the SME Loan Factory on assembly line principles with simplified processes. We have two nodes to take care of the marketing /sales(SALES HUB) and credit processing sanction(CREDIT HUB), under a single umbrella of the SME Loan Factory.
Growth
Deposits
Growth
Advances
-Domestic -Overseas
Business Initiatives
To mobilize low cost deposits aggressively, a Savings Bank Deposit Campaign was launched on 21st June, 2010 for the period of three months. An amount of Rs 1,944 crore as fresh Savings Bank Deposit was mobilized during this campaign. A second Savings Bank Deposit Campaign was launched from 1st December, 2010 to 31st March, 2011, which generated a fresh Savings Bank Deposit to the tune of Rs 3,081 crore under 1,014,589 accounts. For augmenting Retail Loan Portfolio, a Retail Loan Festival Campaign was launched from 1st October, 2010 to 31st December, 2010. During the campaign, a total of Rs 1,218 crore was disbursed under both Home and Auto Loans. Another Retail Loan Campaign specially focused on Home Loans and Auto Loans was launched from 1st February, 2011 to 31st March, 2011. A fresh business of Rs 891.74 crore was generated during this campaign. To increase the attractiveness, maximum period of deposits under Recurring Deposit and Yatha Shakti Jama Yojna were increased to 120 months from the existing 36 months. Interest Rate Structure on Car Loans was revised from Quantum Based Interest Rates to Tenor Based Interest Rates with effect from 1st September, 2010. To facilitate the borrowers, an Online Auto Loan Application Module was made live with effect from 9th August, 2010.
MSME Business
The Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises (MSME) segment is a vital component of Indian economy. This sector accounts for around 40.0% of total industrial production, 34.0% of industrial exports and 95.0% of industrial units and 35.0% of total employment in manufacturing and service sectors of India. The contribution of services sector within the SME segment is quite significant, especially the IT enabled services, hospitality services, tourism, couriering, transportation, etc. To give a focused attention to emerging SMEs in India, the Bank has been considering other commercial units with a turnover up to Rs 150 crore at par with the SMEs. To promote the growth of SME sector, the Bank has launched a special and novel delivery model, viz. SME Loan Factory, which at present, is made operational in 36 centres of the Bank and well accepted in the market place. The SME Loan Factory is an innovative model for streamlining processes and for timely sanction of SME loan proposals. The model comprises of the Central Processing Cell for speedy appraisal and sanctioning of proposals within the stipulated deadline and a sales team to follow up on leads generated by the branches. Going by the past success, the Bank is planning to open more such loan factories in the ensuing year. The Bank has SME Loan Factories at all major
Growth of Business
The total outstanding in MSME Sector works out to Rs 27,365 crore as on 31st March 2011. The growth in lending to MSME Sector during the last three years is given in the table below.
The percentage growth of MSME credit during 2009-10 was relatively high as the advances up to Rs 20 lakh to Retail Trade were classified for the first time under the Micro & Small Enterprises Sector in 2009-10, in line with the RBIs revised guidelines issued during September, 2009. The growth rate was normalized during the year 2010-11.
Performance Highlights
Total Business (Deposit+Advances) increased to Rs 5,34,116 crore reflecting a growth of 28.30%. Gross Profit and Net Profit were Rs 6,981.61 crore and Rs 4,241.68 crore respectively. Net Profit registered a growth of 38.7% over previous year. Credit-Deposit Ratio stood at 86.77% as against 84.47% last year. Retail Credit posted a growth of 33.8% constituting 18.88% of the Banks Gross Domestic Credit in 2010-11. Net Interest Margin (NIM) as per cent of interest earning assets in global operations was at the level of 3.12% and in domestic operations at 3.72%. Net NPAs to Net Advances stood at 0.35% this year against 0.34% last year. Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR) as per Basel I stood at 13.02% and as per Basel II at 14.52%. Net Worth improved to Rs 19,750.63 crore registering a rise of 43.27%. Book Value improved from Rs 378.44 to Rs 504.43 on year. Business per Employee moved up from Rs 981 lakh to Rs 1,229 lakh on year.
Segment-Wise Performance
The Segment Results for the year 2010-11 reveal that the contribution of Treasury Operations was Rs 882.51 crore, which of Corporate/Wholesale Banking was Rs 1,525.49 crore, which of Retail Banking was Rs 1,517.89 crore, and of Other Banking Operations was Rs 2750.61 crore. The Bank earned a Profit after Tax (PAT) of Rs 4,241.68 crore after deducting Rs 1,026.18 crore of unallocated expenditure and Rs 1,408.64 crore towards provision for tax.
Dividend
The Banks Directors have proposed a dividend of Rs 16.50 per share (on the face value of Rs 10/-per share) for the year ended March 31st, 2011. The total outgo in the form of dividend, including taxes, will be Rs 753.35 crore.
Key Financial Ratios Particulars Return on Average Assets (ROAA) (%) Average Interest Bearing Liabilities (Rs crore) Average Cost of Funds (%) Average Interest Earning Assets (Rs crore) Average Yield (%) Net Interest Margin (%) Cost-Income Ratio (%) Book Value per Share (Rs) EPS (Rs) International Business
The improvement in global economic scenario, strong economic revival especially in the advanced countries and a substantial growth in the International Trade flows supported growth of business and profitability of International Operations. The Bank leveraged on its long experience of international banking, strong and loyal customer base, time-tested business model, technological initiatives to live up to its position as the Indias International Bank. During 2010-11, there was a better than expected growth in the business and profits of the Banks International Operations. The asset growth was further assisted by Foreign Currency requirements of Indian Corporates for their overseas expansion, and, also, to take advantage of the difference in cost of resources. To meet the requirements of borrowers, the Bank raised Foreign Currency resources in timely fashion at overseas centres at the finest terms supported by the Banks strong credit story.
2010-11 1.33
2009-10 1.21
2,80,098.94 2,15,886.21 4.67 4.98 2,82,109.79 2,16,735.54 7.76 3.12 39.87 504.43 116.37 7.70 2.74 43.57 378.44 83.96
Total Assets
Total Assets of the Banks International Operations increased from Rs 68,375 crore to Rs 91,273 crore registering a growth of 33.49% during the year.
Net Profit
The Gross Profit for the year 2010-11 registered a healthy growth of 23.94% over the level of previous year. The Net Profit, however, declined by 7.32% due to an unfavourable statistical base effect. During the year 2009-10, the Net Profit had increased sharply because of the reversal of provisions made under Mark to Market of Investments. The contribution of international operations to the Banks Total Net Profit stood at 19.15% during 2010-11.
Asset Quality
Consistent with its past practices, the Bank took all the necessary safeguards at the time of asset creation and ensured monitoring of assets on an ongoing basis to be in readiness for any eventualities in the economic scenario around the world.
International Presence
With the commencement of operations in New Zealand, the Bank extended its overseas presence to 26 countries with 85 branches/offices as under.
Banks Overseas Branches Banks Representative Offices Branches of Banks Overseas Subsidiaries Total
54 3 28 85
Capital Reserves and Surplus Deposits Borrowings Other Liabilities and Provisions TOTAL
ASSETS
Cash and Balances with Reserve Bank of India Balances with Banks and Money at Call and Short Notice Investments Advances Fixed Assets Other Assets TOTAL Contingent Liabilities Bills for Collection
INCOME
Transfer to : a) Statutory Reserve b) Capital Reserve c) Revenue and Other Reserves I) Investment Fluctuation Reserve II) General Reserve III) Special Reserve IV) Statutory Reserve (Foreign) d)Proposed Dividend (including Dividend Tax) e) Investment Reserve Account TOTAL Basic & Diluted Earnings/ Share
38 Banaras Hindu University
SWOT ANALYSIS
- It is 3rd largest bank in India
- It has maximum number of international branches. - It has good image among the customers
-Lesser branches across the country when compared with SBI and PNB -Insufficient Workforce
- Bank Of Baroda has huge opportunity to increase its customer base overseas. - Expansion in the rural areas
-New licenses for commercial banks is going to make competition more intense.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
RESEARCH OBJECTIVES: To understand Credit Guarantee Scheme (CGS) of CGTMSE. To make a Comparative study of Bank of Baroda, Punjab National Bank and Bank of India for providing loan under CGS of CGTMSE.
RESEARCH DESIGN:The project was a research project. Both primary and secondary data was used. The research design was a exploratory research design.
SAMPLE DESIGN:Population Size Sampling Size (No. of Respondents) Data Collection Tool Data Analysis Tool Sampling Technique Location Duration Data collection design Credit Managers of BOB, PNB & BOI 20 Questionnaire Charts and graphs Convenience sampling Varanasi May and June Primary & secondary
CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK
CREDIT GUARANTEE TRUST FOR MICRO AND SMALL ENTERPRISES (CGTMSE)
The Board of Trustees of Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Small Industries, having decided to frame a Scheme for the purpose of providing guarantees to a substantial extent in respect of credit facilities to borrowers in Micro and Small Enterprises, hereby make the following Scheme: 1. Title and date of commencement (i) The Scheme shall be known as the Credit Guarantee Fund Scheme for Small Industries (CGFSI) (ii) It shall come into force from August 1, 2000. (iii) It shall cover eligible credit facility extended by the lending institutions to eligible borrowers effective June 1, 2000. Subsequent to the enactment of MSMED Act-2006 the Trust was renamed as Credit Guarantee Fund Trust for Micro and Small Enterprises and scheme as Credit Guarantee Scheme for Micro and Small Enterprises. 2. Definitions For the purposes of this Scheme (i) "Amount in Default" means the principal and interest amount outstanding in the account(s) of the borrower in respect of term loan and amount of outstanding working capital facilities (including interest), subject to a maximum of fund based & non-fund based working capital limits sanctioned and guaranteed as on the date of the account becoming NPA, or such of the date as may be specified by CGTMSE, for preferring any claim against the guarantee cover. (ii) "Collateral security" means the security provided in addition to the primary security, in connection with the credit facility extended by a lending institution to a borrower. (iii) "Credit facility" means any financial assistance by way of term loan and / or fund based and non-fund based working capital (e.g. Bank Guarantee, Letter of credit etc) facilities extended by the lending institution to the eligible borrower. For the purpose of calculation of guarantee fee, the "credit facility extended" shall
GUARANTEE FEE
8. Guarantee Fee and Annual Service Fee
(i) A one time guarantee fee at specified rate (a)currently 1.00% in the case of credit facility upto Rs. 5 Lakh and 1.5% in the case of credit facility above Rs. 5 Lakh (b) 0.75%, in case of credit facilities upto Rs.50 lakh sanctioned to units in North Eastern Region including State of Sikkim) of the credit facility sanctioned (comprising term loan and / or working capital facility) shall be paid upfront to the Trust by the institution availing of the guarantee within 30 days from the date of first disbursement of credit facility or 30 days from the date of Demand Advice (CGDAN) of guarantee fee whichever is later. (ii) The annual service fee at specified rate (currently 0.50% in the case of credit facility upto Rs. 5 Lakh and 0.75% in the case of credit facility above Rs. 5 Lakh) of the credit facility sanctioned (comprising term loan and / or working capital facility) shall be paid by the lending institution within 60 days ie. on or before May
GUARANTEES
9. Extent of the guarantee
CATEGORY
Micro Enterprises
Women entrepreneurs/ Units located in Rs.40 lakh plus 50% North East 80% of the amount in of amount in default Region (incl. default subject to a above Rs.50 lakh subject Sikkim) other than maximum of Rs.40 lakh to overall ceiling of Rs.65 credit facility upto lakh Rs.5 lakh to micro Enterprises
Rs.37.50 lakh plus 50% of amount in default above Rs.50 lakh subject to overall ceiling of Rs.62.50 lakh
All proposals for sanction of guarantee approvals for credit facilities above Rs. 50 lakh and upto Rs.100 lakh will have to be rated internally by the MLI and should be of investment grade. Proposals approved by the MLIs on or after December 8, 2008 will be eligible for the coverage upto Rs.100 lakh. The guarantee cover will commence from the date of payment of guarantee fee and shall run through the agreed tenure of the term credit in respect of term credit / composite credit. Where working capital alone is extended to the eligible borrower, the guarantee cover shall be for a period of 5 years or a block of 5 years, or for such period as may be specified by the trust in this behalf.
CLAIMS
10. Invocation of guarantee
(i)The lending institution may invoke the guarantee in respect of eligible credit facility if the following conditions are satisfied: (a) The guarantee in respect of that credit facility is in force; (b) The lock-in period of 18 months from either the date of last disbursement of the loan to the borrower or the date of payment of the guarantee fee in respect of credit facility to the borrower, whichever is later, has elapsed; (c) The amount due and payable to the lending institution in respect of the credit facility has not been paid and the dues have been classified by the lending institution as Non Performing Assets. Provided that the lending institution shall not make or be entitled to make any claim on the Trust in respect of the said credit facility if the loss in respect of the said credit facility had occurred owing to actions
MISCELLANEOUS
12. Appropriation of amount received from the lending institutions The amount received from the lending institutions shall be appropriated in the order in which the service fee, penal interest and other charges have fallen due. If the service fee and the penal interest have fallen due on the same date, then the appropriation shall be made first towards service fee and then towards the penal
II.
15. Returns and Inspections I. The lending institution shall submit such statements and furnish such information as the Trust may require in connection with any credit facility under this Scheme. The lending institution shall also furnish to the Trust all such documents, receipts, certificates and other writings as the latter may require and shall be deemed to have affirmed that the contents of such documents, receipts, certificates and other writings are true, provided that no claim shall be rejected and no liability shall attach to the lending institution or any officer thereof for anything done in good faith. The Trust shall, insofar as it may be necessary for the purposes of the Scheme, have the right to inspect or call for copies of the books of account and other records (including any book of instructions or manual or circulars covering general instructions regarding conduct of advances) of the lending institution, and of any borrower from the lending institution. Such inspection may be carried out either through the officers of the Trust or of SIDBI (except in case of Institutions other than SIDBI) or any other person appointed by the Trust for the purpose of inspection. Every officer or other employee of the lending institution or the borrower, who is in a position to do so, shall make available to the officers of the Trust or SIDBI or the person appointed for the inspection as the case may be, the books of account and other records and information which are in his possession.
II.
III.
16. Conditions imposed under the Scheme to be binding on the lending institution
II.
17. Modifications and exemptions I. The Trust reserves to itself the right to modify, cancel or replace the scheme so, however, that the rights or obligations arising out of, or accruing under a guarantee issued under the Scheme up to the date on which such modification, cancellation or replacement comes into effect, shall not be affected. Notwithstanding anything herein contained, the Trust shall have a right to alter the terms and conditions of the Scheme in regard to an account in respect of which guarantee has not been invoked as on the date of such alteration.
II.
III.
In the event of the Scheme being cancelled, no claim shall lie against the Trust in respect of facilities covered by the Scheme, unless the provisions contained in Clause (i) and (ii) of Section 10 of the Scheme are complied with by the lending institution prior to the date on which the cancellation comes into force.
18. Interpretation If any question arises in regard to the interpretation of any of the provisions of the Scheme or of any directions or instructions or clarifications given in connection therewith, the decision of the Trust shall be final. 19. Supplementary and general provisions
FY 2000-01 FY 2001-02 FY 2002-03 FY 2003-04 FY 2004-05 FY 2005-06 FY 2006-07 FY 2007-08 FY 2008-09 FY 2009-10*
9 16 22 29 32 36 40 47 57 82
(*) Data of FY 2009-10 is till January 31, 2010. Over 6 lakhs guarantees for an amount of Rs. 26,900 crore has been approved by the trust as on June 30, 2011.
1500 1000 1400 500 0 BANK OF BARODA TARGET PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK 750
Interpretation: The target of Bank of Baroda in Varanasi region was 750accounts and for PNB in Varanasi circle was 1400. Bank of India dont receive any target from head office or the zonal office. NOTE: No. of Cities in BOB Varanasi Region= 21 No. of Cities in PNB Varanasi Circle= 12
Common Cities=9 (Azamgarh, Balia, Chandauli, Ghazipur, Jaunpur, Mirzapur, Pratapgarh, Sonbhadra, Sant Ravidas Nagar)
ACHIEVED
Interpretation: Punjab National Bank has achieved 165 percent of its target whereas Bank of Baroda opened only 324 accounts against the target of 750 in Varanasi region.
No. of Accounts
2000 1500 1000 500 0 BANK OF BARODA 750 324 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK 1400 2310
TARGET ACHIEVED
Interpretation: In this graph it can be seen that PNB is the leading bank in achievement of its target.
Interpretation:
Here it can be seen that Bank of Baroda has maximum no. of NPA among the three banks. Out of total 17 NPA of the three given banks 12 belongs to the BOB in Varanasi region.PNB has the least no. of NPA with 2 accounts.
Comparison Table
PARTICULARS BANK OF BARODA PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK
Above 12 40% -60%
BANK OF INDIA
Above 12 40% -60%
Number of Schemes Above 12 for MSME Percentage of total Loan Amount shared by MSME Awareness level regarding CGTMSE among customers Methods adopted to aware the customer about CGTMSE 40% -60%
Low
High
Low
Customers are mostly aware, those who are not are made aware through interaction at branch level.
When customers are unable to provide collateral security then they are told about the CGTMSE.
Establishment of Target
Head office gives target to zonal offices, zonal offices then gives target to regional offices and regional offices finally gives target to branches.
There is no target for branch. Head Office gives target only to the Circle Office.
Incidence of Fees
Number of NonPerforming Assets (2010-11) Rehabilitation Assistance covered under CGTMSE. Processing Time (Maximum)
Yes
Yes
Yes
14 days
5-10 days
10-14 days
FINDINGS
Majority of people are unaware about the CGS of CGTMSE. There is no proper advertising for the promotion of the scheme by all the three banks. 40-60% of total loan amount is shared by the MSME in all the three banks. Bank of Baroda is far behind in achieving the target in the year 2010-11. Many of the branches of BOB were even unable to open a single account under CGTMSE in the financial year 2010-11. Bank of Baroda shares the fees in 50:50 ratio up to the amount of 50 lakhs, above 50 lakhs all fees is borne by the borrower, Punjab National Bank passes all the incidence of fees to the borrowers, In Bank of India for loan up to 5 lakhs full upfront guarantee fee is borne by the bank and for loan of above 5 lakhs bank shares the upfront fee with the borrower in 50:50 ratio. Annual service charge is entirely borne by the borrower. Performance of Punjab National Bank is best among the three banks. Bank of Baroda has maximum number of NPA as compared to PNB & BOI. Processing time of loan application is maximum in Bank of Baroda. Bank of Baroda branches receives target from the regional office , In PNB there is no target for the branches, Head Office gives target only to the Circle Offices, whereas in Bank of India there is no target for zonal offices or branches from the head office.
SUGGESTIONS
Effective communication regarding CGS of CGTMSE should be provided to the customer at the branch level. Branch should not only adhere to the target given by the regional office rather they should try to open more and more accounts under CGTMSE. The processing time of loan application should be reduced from 14 days. There should be proper supervision of customers after giving the loans to reduce the defaults. Bank should share the upfront guarantee fee and annual service fee paid to the trust in 50:50 ratio with the borrower for the loan amount of above 50 lakhs and for below 50 lakhs it should entirely be paid by the borrower. Advertisement should be done on frequent basis through print media.
LIMITATIONS
Limited span of time. Uncooperative attitude on a few occasions. Difficulty in surveying the PNBs & BOIs credit managers. Difference in the organizational structure of PNB made the comparison little difficult. Mistakes made being a student.
REFERENCES
1. www.bankofbaroda.com 2. www.pnbindia.in 3. www.bankofinida.com 4. www.cgtmse.com 5. www.rbi.org.in