Professional Documents
Culture Documents
غاية البيان في تنزيه الله عن المكان - of the Four Madhhabs confirming that Allah Exists Without a Place
غاية البيان في تنزيه الله عن المكان - of the Four Madhhabs confirming that Allah Exists Without a Place
.
.
.
" : ."
.
" : " .
.
:
.
-
40( ) ( :)1( - -
. - - .
(" :)2 2-
. "
. ( ( :)3 " 3-
) : (
4-
. 94( ) ( :)4( "
. (( :)5 ) 5-
( )6 6-
148( ) " :)7(
.
. - "
150( ) 7-
" :)8(
. "
(" :)9 8-
. "
( " :)10 : - 9-
:-
. "
.
.
)12(
) ( .)36/
( :
)13(
( )14 ( )15
.
)4 /( : )(9
138/().
(10)
( .)25 /
). 54 /(
(11)
( )2 /
)54 /( (/
)75". :
( (12)
. " 427 /( : 9 )2 . 16 14 08
" : )(13
. ) 1 32/( : 9 )6 -5 1988
. 9 )(14
. 5 )(15
" :
" : "
"
.
.
" "
" :)1(
"
" (2):
. "
11-
) 204( " :)3(
. "
12-
) (241
)(1
). (198 /
. )(2
). ((3) 24 /2
" :)1(
. "
): ) 245( 13- 2(
"
"
( :)3 14-
. !
15-
( 256)
.
(449) " :)4(
). ((1) 144 /
) (2)- 388/9(
). ((3)- 6/
). (4) 416/13(
- -
. "
695( ) ":
"
"
) ( )3/
(
- -
"
). 1(
310( ) 16-
" :)2(
). (1) 419 -418 /13(
). (2) 25 /1(
.
.
,
.
( )1
( )3
(
{ }17
{18}
{ }19
{()}20)
"
.
. )(1
(2)
.
). (3) 26 /1(
. "
18-
:
(
) ( )3/ :)1(
) 16/
). :
.
.
19- 311(
) :)2( :
. "
324( ) 22-
(3): "
"
.
.
). ((1) 60 /
" : )(1
.
.
). (3) 150 /(
). (4) 45 /(
( ) )76/
(
. "
333( ) 24-
" :)1(
" .
.
. "
( 354) 27-
" :)2(
"
). ((1) 76 -75 /
). ((2) 1 /1
373( ) 30-
" :)4(
".
:)5( 31-
). ((1) 4 /8
). ((2) 136 /2
). ((3) 5 /
). ((4) 112 /9
). ((5) 5 /
:
. "
385( ) 32-
( )1(
. "
388( ) 33-
" :)2( ""
).
34- 403(
) " :)3( - -
: :
.
). ((1) 33/
( (2)
: :
( ) 147/2( )27/
).
). ((3) 184 /1
. "
)403( 35-
- - 1(): "
. "
( )3 37-
( :
). (1) 65/(
). ((2) 64 /
). : (3) 221 /(
: - - .
:
:
- -
: .
" :
"
. "
(38- 404
) " :
" : " --
"
). (1
406( ) 39-
(2): "
. "
). (1) 11/447(
). ((2) 57 /
42-
429( ) " :)3( - - -
. " -
. "
449( ) 44-
" :)5(
). ((1) 64 /
). ((2) 92 /1
). ((3) 333 /
). (4) 73 /(
). (5) 416 /13(
- -
. "
" : 45-
" .
)1(
.
456( )46- -
- " :)2(
)( )2/
( ( :
)( )59/
458( ) 47-
( )4 " (3):
). ((1) 433 /13
: (2) /(
! )65
). ((3) 400 /
" : (4)
. ,"
( .
" )
." "
). (1) 3 /3(
). : (2) 397 -396/(
:
( )1
_
."
465( ) 50-
" " :)2(
"
.
:
. "
471( ) 51-
: " (3):
. "
: )(1
. .
). ((2) 7 /
).. (3) 161 /(
52-
" :)1( 476()
. "
53-
) " :)2( (478
)3(. "
). ((1) 101 /1
). ((2) 53 /
)(3
.
). ((4) 58 /
). (5) 511 /(
. "
478( ) 56-
( :)1(
- -
. "
58-
552( ) :)3(
. "
59-
( 505) ( " :)4( - -
. "
). (1) 83/(
). ((2) 73 /
). ( : (3) 399 /
). : (4) 108 /1(
: )(5
1(/ 128).
.
. " :
:
:
. "
61-
" :)1( - - " )( 50
() 63-
512( ) ""
" :)3(
. "
64- 513(
) " :)4(
. "
65-
66-
520( ) -" : -
) .
)." " (2
:)4( - - 68-
:
. "
" ()5
.
). (1) 2/108(
). : ((2) 2/149
). : ((3) 181 /3
). : ((4) 2/149
). (5) 124 /7(
69-
( 539) " :)1(
.
. "
70-
( ) 537 " " :)2(
"
. "
71-
" :)3(
"
.
). ((1) 63 -62 /
( )3( .)28/( ) )(2
/ 29). (
. 543( ) 72-
" " 1():
.
548( ) 77-
" 1( ):
" ( .)11/
"
. "
569( ) 78-
):2(
" "
. : ":
" ( )19
79-
571( ) ( )3
" : :
.
. :
). ((1) 103 /
( ( ) )( 2
7/ 19).
). (3) 150 /(
- -
:
. "
): 80- 1(
"
"
81-
578( ) " :)2(
.
. "
). (1) 2 /(
). ((2) 18 17/
). ((3) 18 /
. "
86-
) " : (589
"
" (4):
). ((1) 36 -35 /
). (2) 44 /(
). ((3) 43 /
). ((4)15 /
)
.911
" :)1(
. "
"
"
" "
".
): (2
( . )
). ((1) 113 /2
). (2) 15 /(
:)1(
"
" .
" "
.
" ): 1(
"
.
-" : :
: ! -
: -
). - : " 2(
" )(1
" )32 /(:
- (
1408)
.
" " )42 /( : - (2)
.1414
.
.
.
.
87-
. "
"
.
.
. "
91-
): 599() 4( ) (3
). ((1) 57 /
). ((2) 59 /
" : (3)
" .
"
).) 25 -23/7( .
" " )(4
). 10 /(
"
"
( ) 606 92- :)1(
"
".
6 0 6( ) " :)2( 93-
"
"()16
. "
( " :)3 " )4( " 94-
"
),"(1
). ( (1) 32 /4
( / (2) /30 -16
69).
). ( / (3) 144 /27 -4
.
- 95-
) " :)1( (620
. "
) 629( 96-
: : " " 2( ):
...
" (" )11
.
:
). ((1) 186 /8
)(2
45 /().
. "
":
" ( )16
": "
( )18 ":
)10(
":
/85(" ) ":
"( /84 )
: :
":
"( /10 )
) "(99/ ":
":
" (/206)
) ": "(69
":
"( /45 ) :
:
": )75("
": /39(" )
" : " ( )1
) ": "( /11
": "( )4
: : )(1
.
98-
) 636(
" :)1(
" .
99-
) 646(
:
" - - "
. " :)2(
" .
:
,
( )
-
- :
" :
: .
" : "
" :
" "
" (1)
.
: )( 321
" .
101-
) -" :)2( - (660
. "
669( ) 2 0 1- :)3(
(. ".
671( ) 103-
(1) 108 /(
).
). : (2) 219 /8(
). (3) 496 /(
). (4) 278 /3( 2 55 /
(")1 - - 105-
. " .
106-
" "
"( )158
" :)2(
. "
"(108- )22
( )4 ":
" :
.. "
109-
":
"( )16 :)5(
) (6
.
. " .
110-
672( )
): 1(
"
" .
111-
)2( , )(676
. ".
82( ) 112-
). ((2) 3/19
( " :)1(
" :
. " .
113-
) -" :)2( (684 -
. " .
115-
( 695) " :)4(
" "
":
"( )3 -
-
). (1) 24 /(
). ((2) 93 /
). (3) 31 /3(
. "
10 116-
( 699) " :)1(
( )
. "
117-
752( )
): (2
.
!118-
709( ) " :)3(
."
). / ( (1) 248/2
). - : ((2) 664 -663 /1
). (3) 1 .4 -103 /(
.
. "
123-
( 733)
:)1(
" - -
"
" (2):
. "
). (1) 35 /9(
). ((2) 36 /9
). ((3) 41 /9
. " .
125-
737( )
" :)1(
. - - " .
( 741) ( )3 127-
" :"
.
741( )4( ) 128-
.
). ((1) 146 /3
). ((2) 181 /3
). ((3) 238 /2
" : )(4
). " ( 147 /4
.
): 1(
"
.
. "
743( ) 129-
- - - -(2): "
. "
130-
(745
) ":
)19(" )1(
. "
( )
()
.
()
( )
()
. " ( )1
134-
756( )
.
"
) ( (\(1) 131-130
":)1( -
( - )
.
"
.
(
)
.
.
!!
" " ( \ 412 /
) -
). ( )(1) 105 /( :
.
,
":
"( )36
" :)1(
" . (" :)2
- -
" .
!! (" :)3
:
) .
)13( "
"
)12("
). ((1) 7 /
). ((2) 14 /
). ((3) 28 /
.
.
135- )1(
761()
" " " (2):
"..
768( ) 136-
" :)3(
:
. "
( : )(1
) ) . (36 /10
: )(2
(8/ 185).
). ((3) 498 /
137-
771( )
" :)1(
" .
.
: ( )2 138-
"
"
): (139- 3
"
"
790( ) 140-
"(4):
782( )5( )
" " " :
). (94 -93/
. (5)
" :
)17(
":
. :
"
.
786( ) 141-
. " :" "
"
1().
791( ) 142-
" :)2(
.
." .
) 817( 143-
:)1(
.".
144-
826( ) " :)2( " -
" " "
" . .
.
145-
(829)
852( ) 146-
(3):"
".
.
. " .
" ::
855( ) 150-
":)5( ":
) " (7
- -
. " .
). (1) 30 /3(
)(2
. :
). (3) 124 /7
). (4) 505 /11(
). ( (5) 111 /25 /12
). ( (6)117 /25 /12
864( ) 152-
-" : -
155-
895( ) " :)4(
( (1) /2( )
405).
). ((2) 18 /3
). ((3) 248 /20
( ) )(4
(4 /).
"
..
156-
" (1):
. " .
157- 901(
)
( " :)2( :
.) " .
). (1) 88 /(
). ((2) 72 /
). ( (3) 342 / 886
911( ) ( :
) " :)1( :
.
. : ".
160-
933() ":)2(
. " .
)22("161-
"
":)3(
()22 ""
"( )22 "
"()23 ..
.
926( ) 162-
" " " :)4(
. ) .
165-
() 933 ( )2
(":)3
. "
). : ((1) 595 /
(2)
( ".
: ( )174 / ()196 /8
.
). ((3) 175 /
). ((4) 175 /
.
.
167-
( 953) " :)1( :
. ) .
973( ) . 68 1-
): (2
!
".
169-
) (974
" :)3(
) ( 72 /2 (1) 758
). ((2) 275 /
). ((3) 144 /
.".
170- 977(
)")1( - -
. " .
- -171-
(" :)2 -
:-
" .
.
":
"( )18
. " .
174-
)1041( " "
):. 2(
"
)
175-
):) (10413(
. )
". 176-
. :)4(
177-
: " : (1)
)."(64/
( ( ) (2) /43
13).
((3) 48/
).
). ((4) 49 /
1057( ) ":)1(
. " .
178-
(1078) " :)2(
. " .
1098( ) 179-
( : " 3():
) ( "
) "
..
).. ( (1)327/7 /4
). ( )3( .)137 / ((2) 197 /
). ((4) 201 /
1122( ) 181-
" :)1( :
. ".
182-
) " :)2( (1132
. .
183-
) ( (1138
: " ):) 3(
.
. : ".
184-
) :)4( (1143
. ".
). ((1) 36 /2
). (2) 12 /(
). (3) 1/576(
)5( ). ((4) 49 -48/
.
. ".
186-
):) (12011(
"
"
187-
1205(.) " :)2( " .
189-
(" :)4 - . -
. ".
). ( ( ) (1) 25 /31
). (2) 24 /2(
). ((3) 25 /2
). ((4) 25 /2
( )1 " : 190-
. " .
191- 1206(
:
) ( :)2( :
" " : :
. : " .
1230( ) 192-
( :
) :
-
. ( )3
193-
) ( :)4( (1242
. ! .
). ((1) 103 /2
(2) 73 -1 72 /1(
1).
). " " ((3) 130 /
). (4) 312 /1(
195-
): (1252) 2(
) . ." "
.
196-
1260(:)
""
" 3( ):
"( /11 " :
)
.. "
1268( ) 197-
: 4( ): "
.
). ((1) 312 /1
). ((2) 422 /1
(3) )4( .
). (16/
. " .
198-
1276( ) " :)1(
. " .
( " :)2 - - 199-
. ".
( )3 " : 200-
. " .
201 -
( " :)4
)5("
":
1209
). ((1) 40/
)3( ). ((2) 49 -44 /
). ((4) 106 /
.
.
): 1277( ) 202- 1(
- . "-
. " .
":)2( 203-
. ".
( 1281) 204-
3( ):
"
"
:
.
205-
287( )
(" :)1
. "
293( ) 206-
): 2(
207- 298(
(3): " )
. - -
. "
). ((1) 420/
). ((2) 276/
). ((3) 69/
( 208-
) " :)1( : 299
. "
209-
1305( ) ( :)2(
".
:
. : -
.
: :
. "
). (1) 7/(
). ((2) 2/
). ((3) 5/
1316( ) 212-
" :)2(
. "
( :)3( 213-
. ".
( 214-
) ( :)4( 1317
. "
). ((1) 7/
). ((2) 5 /
). ((3) 37/
). ((4) 94 /1
215-
( 1323) " :)1(
"
.
): (&##1610;3 217 -
"
. "
218-
" :)4( -
. "
). ((1) 13 /
). ((2) 2 /
). ((3) 119 /
). ((4) 119 /
( )
)1(
:
"
" :)2(
"
.
). 97 /3 /29 ( (1)
: 4 26 1399 (2) 23
. 1 979
(3)
.
). ((4) 18 /
221-
) " :)2( " (1328
" :
. "
1335( ) 223-
"
(:)4
. "
1335( ) 224-
" ): 5(
((1) /
4).
( )4 / )(2
1308
.
). ((3) 5 /
). ((4) 385 /6
( (5) /( )
74).
".
( :)3( 227-
. ".
1350( ) 228-
()4
( 1351) 229-
(":)5
. ".
). - ((1) 60 /
). ((2) 29 /
( )4( .)16 / )(3
:
(3 /).
). ((5) 118/
231-
) " :)2( (1352
. .
. " .
1352( ) 233-
" :)4(
). ((1) 122/
). ((2) 24 /
). (3) 57 /(
). ((4) 5 /
. ".
1353 ( ) 234-
" )1( "
" :
... .....
. ".
( 1355 236-
- ): "- 4(
. " .
: )(1
(/ 277).
)(2
.
"
(
.
). ((3) 85 /
). (4) 13 -12 /(
( ")1 : 238-
. ".
238-
( " :)2
. ".
" 239-
( :)3
. " .
1362( ) 240-
":
55( "
) /
" :)4(
- -
. " .
1365( ) 241-
/1( ) 1(
) " ":
. ".
" : 242-
. )2("
( )3
" "
1367( ) 243-
:)4(
"
. " .
( ) )(1
). - 16/( 1357
). ((2) 17 /
). (3) 211--201194 -/183(
( )186/2 (4) :
( "
.
.
- - 244-
( )1 "
. ".
.
245-
1371( ) " :)2(
. )3( " .
" (247- 11
/ " :)5(
)
. " .
). ((1) 190 /2
). : ((2) 452 /
": : (3) :
)..
(). : 262 / -
). (4) 88/(
). ((5) 102 /
" "
1372( ) 248-
(" :)1
- - - -
.. "
1376( ) 249-
(" :)2 -
. - ".
250-
) " :)3( : (1380
" )4( " -
:-
). (1) 73 /(
). ( (2) 93/( )
( ) ((3) /
62 -61).
). (4) 35 -34 /5(
: ,
" .
.
251-
1395( ) " :)1(
".
1393( ) ( )2 252-
)
(:)3 (
" .
). (1) 79 /1(
(2)
). (174 /6
). ((3) 33 /29
1393( ) 253-
" :)1(
. " .
254-
(" :)2 - -
.
"..
255-
) " :)3( (1413
.
" .
). ((1) 57 55 /
). ((2) 57 55/
). : (3) 11 /( :
1411( ) 257-
(" :)2
. ".
258-
":)3( :
. " .
)4( 259-
-": -
). (1) 29 /(
). ((2) 9 -8 /
). ((3) 27 -26 /2
)(4
. 1384(2/ 35)1964 -
. "
263-
" : )4(
- -
). ((1) 39 /
). : ((2) 167 /1
). : (3) 151 /1( :
). : 65 /( 306 -305 14151994- )(4
".
. ":
264-
"" ""
)" " (1
". "
" : "
. ".
.
.
= ( : /2 282 /4 (1)
)( /2 63/ /9 1350)( . 1350 /9
). 1357 ) 16 / /
265-
" .)1( :
.
":
/5(" )
:
:
:
":
/5(" )
": :
"(/5 )
"( /16
"
)
.
( )1
.
.".
( :)2( : 266-
(1)
.
). ((2) 128 -127/
( )1
.
: :
. :
. " .
: : (1)
: :
: :
)449 / (2/ 291 /2(
143 -142).
). ((2) 144 /
) " 1(
..
" : 268-
" "
" .: " .
.. "
). ((1) 76 /
). ((2) 73 -72 -71/
" "
.
"(/3
. "
)
-
.
.
:
" ( /11
"
" : )
"
" :
"
( )1 )2(
( )3
( .)4
:
:
.
(" : )1
/139( " )
"
:
( )4 "
/19( "
) ":
)
":
"
.
). ((1) 151 /
.
.
.