Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FDI Moves Now Official, No Signs of Reforms Abating: Emu Business Took Flight On Interest-Free Govt Loans
FDI Moves Now Official, No Signs of Reforms Abating: Emu Business Took Flight On Interest-Free Govt Loans
FDI Moves Now Official, No Signs of Reforms Abating: Emu Business Took Flight On Interest-Free Govt Loans
82 pages in 3 sections
www.business-standard.com
COMPANIES P2
WORLD P12
PUBLISHED SIMULTANEOUSLY FROM AHMEDABAD, BANGALORE, BHUBANESWAR, CHANDIGARH, CHENNAI, HYDERABAD, KOCHI, KOLKATA, LUCKNOW, MUMBAI, NEW DELHI AND PUNE
> IN
BRIEF
SLOWDOWN BLUES
Part 4 of a five-part series on the slowdown that companies are facing
6>
ndeterred by protests from the Opposition and some of its allies, the UPA government today carried out its decision on FDI reforms and offered no signs of a rollback of the rise in diesel prices. The government is set to go ahead with its reform agenda be it restructuring of loans to state electricity boards or a hike in the cap on FDI (foreign direct investment) in the insurance sector though it postponed the Cabinet meeting scheduled for tomorrow. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, who initiated the first large-scale economic reforms in the country back in 1991 as the finance minister, has resolved to show the government's commitment to the recent reforms and is likely to convey the positive side of the measures in an address to the people tomorrow. Even a truce between the government and Vodafone appears in sight, which would end the prolonged battle between the two sides on the capital gains tax issue. Analysts say that would boost investor sentiment. The finance ministry is likely to put the Kelkar committee report on fiscal consolidation in the public domain soon, showing its commitment to correct the state of public finances. The government today issued all five notifications on FDI reforms cleared by the Cabinet last week. With that, up to 51 per cent FDI in multi-brand retail, relaxed conditions for 100 per cent FDI in singlebrand retail, clarity on foreign investment in power trading, 49 per cent FDI for foreign airlines in Indian carriers and a hike in the FDI limit in certain category of media, such as DTH, have been permitted. The notifications were issued a day before the Trinamool Congress ministers were likely to submit their resignation letters to the Prime Minister. Trinamool chief Mamata Banerjee termed the notifications shocking. News agency PTI said the Prime Minister was likely to explain to the nation the reasons behind the recent
GOVT SEES OUT THE STORM BJP supporters take out a rally during the Bharat Bandh to protest against government actions on FDI and diesel and LPG prices in Mumbai on Thursday PHOTO: KAMLESH PEDNEKAR
The parting of ways between the Trinamool Congress (TMC) and the United Progressive Alliance (UPA) is final, but the Congress is not short of friends and is open to making new ones. This was the political message on a day when a semi-successful Bharat Bandh saw some parts of the country, most notably West Bengal, down shutters in protest against the rise in diesel prices and opening of multi-brand retail to foreign investment. Congress ministers in the West Bengal government will be asked to resign tomorrow in tandem with TMC chief Mamata Banerjees letter to the President, saying her party is pulling out from the government. The UPA will scout, among others, for a new railway minister. Just to rile Banerjee, it could be a Congress candidate from West Bengal. The government exuded confidence today, buoyed by the BJPs reiteration that the party had no intention of asking the government to prove its parliamentary majority. We had enough friends yesterday, we have enough friends today. So, I dont think why you should doubt our stability, Finance Minister P Chidambaram told reporters here. Asked whether the government would look for new allies, he said, If we can acquire new friends, why would we not? Information and Broadcasting Minister Ambika Soni said the government was stable as it had the support of over 300 MPs in the 545-member Lok Sabha. We have support of over 300 members of Parliament who do realise that these are difficult times and know that hard decisions need to be taken, she said, rejecting the perception that the government had been reduced to a minority. Soni said a number of leaders had made it clear early elections were not in the national interest. The government got a further boost when Samajwadi Party chief Mulayam Singh Yadav said it was supporting the UPA and would decide when to pull out, later. The party was to have decided what its strategy was going to be today but put off the deliberations until bitter rival Mayawatis announcement of her position on October 9.
The agenda before the Cabinet tomorrow is bristling with economic decisions. After tomorrow, a Cabinet reshuffle will become inevitable and consultations have already begun on who will be drafted and who will be asked to move to the party. The bandh today was moderately successful, but no clashes or violence were reported. In most states, shops opened late and stayed open. In UP, SP workers locked the entrance of Bharti-Walmarts store on Sultanpur Road. The womens wing of the party was also seen asking traders to down shutters in some local markets. According to the UP home department, train movement was disrupted at 19 places by bandh supporters, while the AgraGwalior highway was also blocked by protesters. However, no untoward incident was reported from anywhere till the time of filing of this report. While there was no order for closure of schools and colleges in the state, some educational institutions voluntarily declared a holiday as a preemptive step. In Delhi, though some markets were shut, especially in the inner city and traffic was thin, offices were open. Road and train services were also hit in several parts of Bihar. A group of BJP workers blocked rail traffic at Patna junction and stopped movement of a number of long-distance express and passenger trains. Life in Kolkata and elsewhere in West Bengal was disrupted due to the 12-hour bandh called by Left parties. This could be bad news for the beleaguered TMC government, which had resolved not to allow disruption of services because of the bandh. The final word came from the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), a UPA ally. A senior NCP leader said they were wholeheartedly with the UPA on FDI in retail. As for the dissenting noises against the diesel price hike and the demands for a rollback from the NCP unit in Maharashtra, he said, These are necessary political rituals to keep the party afloat in the state. This is akin to what Mulayam Singh Yadav is doing or the DMK is doing right now. ECONOMY, P6 Discom restructuring next on govt agenda ECONOMY, P7 Govt must dump its panel report to please Nitish TSI, 1 Brokerages hopeful on progress despite TMC jolt
ECONOMY, P7
INSIDE
BRAND WORLD Quanto: M&Ms new price warrior TAKE TWO The changing face of Philips
13 > 9>
The Union government was giving interest-free loans to entrepreneurs setting up emu farms, which have now turned into a multi-crore scam in Tamil Nadu. These loans were granted under the central governments Poultry Venture Capital Fund and were routed through the National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (Nabard) and commercial banks. Though the scheme was for all poultry, emus find a mention in the scheme documents and several emu farms in southern states, including Tamil Nadu, have availed themselves of loans under these schemes, say officials. A senior Nabard official looking after the investment credit department said, Nabard was just acting as an intermediating agency to pass on the subsidy. The loans were given not only by public sector banks, but by all commercial banks, Nabard was only refinancing them and passing on the subsidy. The scheme was originally floated as a pilot titled Venture Capital Scheme for Dairy and Poultry by the Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairying and Fisheries of the central government in 200506. In 2009-10, a separate scheme called Poultry Venture Capital Fund was carved out of this to focus more on the poultry sector. That scheme
| Emu farms funded under poultry venture capital fund subsidy scheme | Over ~10 crore disbursed as subsidy under the scheme since 2011 | Nabard projection based on 1997 paper by a French firm executive | Ground reality far removed from Nabard estimates was further modified into Poultry Venture Capital Fund (Subsidy) Scheme with effect from April 2011. Under the new scheme, Breeding farms for low input technology birds like turkey, duck, Japanese quail, emu, etc were eligible for backended capital subsidy of 25 per cent of the total outlay. According to Nabard officials, over ~10 crore has been released as government subsidy under the latest scheme since April 2011. According to the website, a pair of ostriches (including emus) can
earn up to $30,000 (over ~16 lakh) in a period of 12 months. The projection is based on a paper presented by an executive of a French company at a 1997 Indo-French food seminar in Bangalore. According to the projection, a pair of emus is capable of producing 30 offspring in a year. These 30 birds can produce meat of 60 pounds each. At the rate of $10 a pound, the meat alone would fetch $18,000 (~9.72 lakh) every year. In addition to that, emus were said to produce hides worth $10,500 (~5.5 lakh) every year, not to mention the plumage value of $1,500 (~81,000). These unverified estimates put out on the Nabard website were the basis on which the farms were designed. Many websites peddling emus also quote the same or similar figures. It gave newcomers an assurance that since state-owned institutions were involved, there was a legitimate business. Even now, farmers are hoping a Nabard-funded project to produce emu oil will bail them out, said Anand, a farm owner in Bangalore. While poultry experts say there is no business case as emu meat is not a widely consumed delicacy, a Nabard official expressed hope that emu oil-producing units, when set up, would create a steady demand for these birds. But, he was not sure if even that would suffice, given the disproportionate breeding that had taken place already.