Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 36 views

    Bid Evaluation - BP10-0036

    Uploaded by

    Allan Badillo
    The document summarizes bids for the construction of an SPG Extension Office, with the lowest bid from D.J. Roque at 6.89 million pesos, 8.71% lower than the company estimate. It notes that Romari did not provide proposal details and confirmation is needed that Archen and SD Platon included air conditioning and all network equipment. D.J. Roque's bid was found to be fully responsive to the job specification requirements. The reviewer recommends confirming scope of work with Romari and equipment inclusions with Archen and SD Platon during negotiations.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as XLS, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content

    You might also like

    Bid Evaluation - BP10-0036

    Uploaded by

    Allan Badillo
    36 views1 page
    The document summarizes bids for the construction of an SPG Extension Office, with the lowest bid from D.J. Roque at 6.89 million pesos, 8.71% lower than the company estimate. It notes that Romari did not provide proposal details and confirmation is needed that Archen and SD Platon included air conditioning and all network equipment. D.J. Roque's bid was found to be fully responsive to the job specification requirements. The reviewer recommends confirming scope of work with Romari and equipment inclusions with Archen and SD Platon during negotiations.

    Original Description:

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    XLS, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    The document summarizes bids for the construction of an SPG Extension Office, with the lowest bid from D.J. Roque at 6.89 million pesos, 8.71% lower than the company estimate. It notes that Romari did not provide proposal details and confirmation is needed that Archen and SD Platon included air conditioning and all network equipment. D.J. Roque's bid was found to be fully responsive to the job specification requirements. The reviewer recommends confirming scope of work with Romari and equipment inclusions with Archen and SD Platon during negotiations.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as XLS, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as xls, pdf, or txt
    36 views1 page

    Bid Evaluation - BP10-0036

    Uploaded by

    Allan Badillo
    The document summarizes bids for the construction of an SPG Extension Office, with the lowest bid from D.J. Roque at 6.89 million pesos, 8.71% lower than the company estimate. It notes that Romari did not provide proposal details and confirmation is needed that Archen and SD Platon included air conditioning and all network equipment. D.J. Roque's bid was found to be fully responsive to the job specification requirements. The reviewer recommends confirming scope of work with Romari and equipment inclusions with Archen and SD Platon during negotiations.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as XLS, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    Download as xls, pdf, or txt
    of 1

    Attachment-1

    Evaluation Sheet BP10-0036: SPG Extension Office


    Item 1 2 3 4 Criteria Cost: 6,337,738.92 Duration: 30 CD Percent Lower(-)/Higher(+) than Company Estimate Scope of Work 3.1 Clearing and grubbing 3.2 Earthworks (excavation, backfill and compaction, disposal) 3.3 Supply of Container Van Type 1 (fully furnished incl. AC) 3.4 Supply of Container Van Type 2 (fully furnished incl. AC) 3.5 Covered walkway (2m x 100mm thick) 3.6 Concrete stairway with railing 3.7 Cyclone wire fence 3.8 Gate 3.9 Electrical (direct cable burial, lighting, switches, breakers, conduits) 3.10 Network connection (LAN system including all equipment) a. CISCO Catalyst 2960 (24 Port PoE) 1 pc. b. Linksys EG008W 1 pc. c. CISCO IP Phone 7940 15 pcs. d. SP3508A VDSL Switch 2 pcs. e. SP3501AS VDSL CPE Modem 2 pcs. f. CAT 6 Ethernet Cable (RJ-45) g. Telephone line (RJ-11) 3.11 As-built drawings Romari 9,839,053.00 30 CD 55.25% For confirmation For confirmation For confirmation For confirmation For confirmation For confirmation For confirmation For confirmation For confirmation D.J. Roque 6,890,000.00 30 CD 8.71% Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Archen 7,039,200.00 30 CD 11.07% Complying Complying For confirmation if bid includes AC For confirmation if bid includes AC Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying SD Platon 12,300,000.00 30 CD 94.08% Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying Complying

    For confirmation

    Complying

    For confirmation if all network equipment are included in proposal

    For confirmation if all network equipment are included in proposal

    For confirmation

    Complying

    Complying

    Complying Confirm with SD Platon if all network equipment are included in the proposal during negotiation. The bill of quantities enumerated in the proposal is for Contractors reference only. The materials shall not be used as the only basis of the award of contract. Since the project is lump-sum, all materials required to complete the project shall be supplied by the Contractor.

    OVERALL REMARKS

    Romari did not submit proposal details. Confirm scope of work during negotiation.

    Confirm with Archen if AC and all network equipment are included in the proposal during negotiation. The bill of quantities enumerated in the proposal is for Contractors reference only. D.J. Roque's proposal is The materials shall not be used as the only basis responsive to the requirements of of the award of contract. Since the project is the Job Specification. lump-sum, all materials required to complete the project shall be supplied by the Contractor.

    Prepared by: A.V. Badillo

    Reviewed by: P.E. De Guia

    Approved by: F.H. Enriquez

    You might also like