Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Weed More Carcinogenic
Weed More Carcinogenic
The ndings and methodology of this relatively small study have since been seriously questioned on more than one occasion, but the BLF chooses not to mention this at all. The second study gets only a small mention, possibly because it found only a 2.4-fold increase in the risk of lung cancer. The third study gets no mention in the text at all even though it looked at more peoples cannabis use over a longer time than any of the other studies and so could be argued to be the most valid. One suspects the BLF largely ignored it because it found zero correlation between cannabis smoking and lung cancer. There is a fourth study the BLF could have included, but were not surprised it didnt. Donald Tashkin of the University of California has studied the effects of cannabis on the lungs for three decades and found that even smoking as many as 20,000 cannabis joints does not increase the risk of lung cancer. To what must be the BLFs horror, he goes on to speculate that cannabis could even have a positive effect on the health of a smokers lungs. The active ingredient tetrahydrocannabinol or THC may have an anti-tumoural effect in which cells die before they age enough to develop mutations that might lead to lung cancer. Whether Tashkins ndings will stand the test of time remains to be seen, but it seems we can say truthfully that the
evidence connecting cannabis smoke and lung cancer is far from conclusive and that there is no scientic basis for the BLFs claim. To the BLFs credit, it did acknowledge there was a need for more research to verify these ndings. However, Mythbusters thinks theyre guilty of mishandling the evidence in the meantime. And while we cannot doubt the BLF had the best of intentions to inform and protect, attentiongrabbing reports such as these could have the opposite effect. What we do know is that inhaling any smoke is bad for you. Smoke is a bunch of particulates and gases released during combustion, and both tobacco and cannabis smoke will contain harmful substances such as sulphur dioxide and carbon monoxide. Putting these things into your body is not likely to be good for your health long term. The BLF acknowledged more research on the subject needs to be done before any claims can be made then made a claim anyway for which there was little evidence. Mythbusters thinks thats disappointingly poor form.
REFERENCES