Moneycontrol

in.com

IBNLive

Firstpost

burrp!

Askme

Tech2

All Network

Tuesday, October 23rd 01:53 PM IST Facebook Twitter RSS Sign in Register

How Gadkari, Pawar, Kejriwal make corruption a non-issue

Why BJP wants Parliament in midst of Gujarat polls

Dengue wake-up call: The answer lies in your home and neighbourhood

For Yash-ji, romance was a much later discovery

More equal than us: Why netas face the rage of the aam aadmi Firstpost Participate

Questions arise over Wal-Mart investment in Bharti group 5 comments Vadra vs Kejriwal: This is also a war about class 106 comments
see more Front page India Politics World Business Economy

Investing Life Bollywood Sports Tech Blogs Real estate New Delhi Mumbai Photos eBooks Debates Firstpost Business

What public sector CEOs would like to tell the PM: Free us
by R Jagannathan 39 mins ago
Follow @firstpostin

#InMyOpinion #Manmohan Singh #PSUs #Public Sector Share200

Like 4

Email2 Comments Print

Indias Gandhi family
Read m ore from The Econom ist. Uncom prom ising global perspectiv e. www.econom ist.com

Cabot Position on Coltan

Cabot has not, and will not, m ine tantalum in the Dem . Rep. of Congo. www.cabotcorp.com /tantalum

Ads by Google

Also see Why govt wants to set up ETF for selling shares in PSUs Govt confident of raising Rs 25K-30K cr from disinvestment Govt aims to sell stake in Oil India, other PSUs by Nov
The prime minister is supposed to meet the chief executives of public sector undertakings (PSUs) later today. The reason, as a government press release says, is to allow the CEOs to convey their views to the Prime Minister on several key issues like autonomy and empowerment, including flexibility to their boards. Their investment plans will also be discussed. One wonders if Manmohan Singh does not know any of this. He, more than anyone else, should be aware that political interference has consistently degraded the capabilities of the public sector during UPA-1 and UPA-2 from the energy sector to aviation to telecoms. As for discussing their investment plans, one wonders how a PM is supposed to get into such minutiae; in any case, since autonomy is on the agenda, shouldnt their investment plans be left to their respective boards? This meet-the-PM initiative is supposed to have been the brainchild of Minister of Heavy Industry, Praful Patel, who as civil aviation minister presided over Air Indias decline into disaster. But we shall let that pass, and assume that the PM needs to know what the public sector chiefs have on their wishlist. Since it is unlikely that the CEOs, concerned for their jobs, will be too open about what they think is wrong with way the government is running PSUs, Firstpost will do the job for them. So here goes an open letter to the PM from public sector chief executives. Dear Shri Manmohan Singhji, We are extremely pleased to hear that Praful Patelji has organised a meeting with you to hear about the problems we face while running our businesses. We are collectively sending this letter to you in advance in strictest confidence, since we may not be able to speak openly on these subjects when we meet you, especially with the minister in attendance. We are sure you know the issues confronting us, but no government has ever bothered to reform the area of public sector governance because of political compulsions. We write this letter in the hope that your government will be able to transcend these political compulsions, since the public sector is financed from taxpayer funds. They should be valuable national assets, and not liabilities, which many of us have sadly become. Reviving the economy. Image courtesy PIB Our group of public sector CEOs includes very profitable companies like ONGC, Gail, Sail, NTPC and Coal India, and also many that lose heavily, including Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd and Air India. While our specific problems are different, our core concerns remain the same: political interference in our working, and the inability of our administrative ministries to treat us like professional organisations that have to deliver bang for the taxpayers buck. We also need to bring to your notice that the Honble Finance Minister, Shri P Chidambaram, has been saying that PSUs must use their cash or lose it (i.e. return the money to government as dividends or through buybacks). While his motives may be honourable, as operating companies these are our decisions. They finance

money to government as dividends or through buybacks). While his motives may be honourable, as operating companies these are our decisions. They finance minister cannot decide this on our behalf. If an Infosys can decide what to do with its cash, we do not see why we need a finance minister to tell us what to do. The government, as owner, can, of course, ask us to pay huge dividends, but it cannot in the same breath also ask us to invest and focus on our corporate and social goals. That said, we would like to come to the nub of the issues bothering us. Shri Patel has informed the media yesterday that autonomy of PSUs and disinvestment will be discussed, but we need to discuss these issues beyond mere generalities. What, for example, do we mean by autonomy? For us, whether it is Air India or ONGC, it is about being left free to pursue the objectives set by the government as owner. We can illustrate this with an example. If the goal given to ONGC is that it must double indigenous oil production in three years, or five, this should be part of the longterm understanding the government should sign with the company. Once this is done, the minister should not be concerned with how we achieve this, as long as the means are legal. It also means that ONGCs cash cannot be considered public property, to be used by the finance minister as he pleases, unless that too is part of the agreement. We can always decide that 30-35 percent of pre-tax profits will be distributed as dividends. This cannot be decided arbitrarily based on the fiscal deficit of any particular year. In this context, it would be a good idea to insulate all PSUs through an investment board, headed by public-spirited persons with an impeccable track record, where all public sector stakes are housed. The purpose of this board (or boards) should be to monitor the delivery of what is agreed between the PSU and the government. And to maximise shareholder and social value for the government. The administrative ministry should be delinked from PSUs, and the only link between a PSU and the government should be the annual performance review, and the monitoring of the medium term objectives set by the government, with the investment board playing intermediary. Decisions on what to invest, where to invest, how to price our products, and who to recruit or sack should not the job of ministers and bureaucrats. The corporate board can do it. It is only when this job is done by ministries that we end up facing lawsuits from minority shareholders, as we did recently from The Childrens Investment Fund in the case of Coal India. If you can guarantee us this autonomy, we can guarantee results. We may occasionally fail, but this is something normal. Annually, and over the medium term, we could agree on specific financial or social objectives, profitability, and cost targets for us to achieve. Achieving these goals is our job and we should be held accountable for the same. Beyond that, it should be hands-off by the government. This brings us to disinvestment. We know the government needs money, and we are happy to allow it to disinvest any time it wants to. However, disinvestment does nothing for us the money we need to raise for our own investment is lost when the markets are swamped with disinvested shares. We need a judicious mix of disinvestment and further share offers, where the money raised from the latter can be used to grow the business and improve shareholder value, which includes the government. It is investment that raises share value, and not mindless disinvestment. We would thus like to make it clear that disinvestment is not always the best way to raise money or even improve shareholder value. A lot of public sector shares are undervalued because government meddling in our decision-making lowers our market value. This is why ONGC, despite being the countrys largest oil producer, get a price-earnings multiple of around eight, while Reliance gets 14. The difference is largely the result of the investor perception that government can meddle with the oil sector, but not with a private player like Reliance, which has its own power of agency to do what is right for its shareholders. We, thus, need a greater say in how disinvestment takes place. It should not be about selling the household silver. Investing in the public sector will, in fact, deliver better value that disinvesting over the long term. A third issue we want to raise is a level-playing field. I know this is a phrase your private sector chiefs like to use, but if anyone needs a level playing field, it is us. We would like to be frank here. Given our corrupt corporate culture, it is always possible for private sector competitors to bribe bureaucrats and ministers to delay our plans, or put our CEOs under vigilance probes, or force us to keep retendering for equipment that we badly need. A simple question in Parliament can delay our plans indefinitely. We cannot run our businesses like this. We can illustrate this issue with a few examples. Air India cannot decide what aircraft to buy without the minister intervening. You know what went wrong with the last Boeing purchase order, which ruined the airlines balance-sheet. It was one of the reasons why it needed a Rs 30,000 crore bailout. Our public sector telecom companiesBSNL and MTNLwere forced to buy costly 3G spectrum at the highest bid prices, which nearly ruined them. The government has since allowed them partial refunds, but shouldnt they have been allowed to decide what is best for them themselves? Our oil companies are forced to subsidise diesel, cooking gas and kerosene, and then wait endlessly for the subsidies to reach them. Even profit-making ONGC is forced to subsidise them. How can ONGC do its job of producing more oil and reducing the countrys import dependence if its profits are used to subsidise consumers of the oil marketing companies? Goldman Sachs has referred to this practice as a lack of corporate governance. The last issue we would like to raise is something we ourselves are ashamed of. Many of us are ex-bureaucrats, but we believe that public sector companies should be run by professional managers, including experienced ones from the private sector. If the private sector can use retired public sector executives, we dont see why the reverse cannot be done. We are not saying some IAS officers may not make very good CEOs, but companies need leaders, not just administrators. Bringing in fresh ideas and leaders from outside will make for a refreshing change. We can go on and on. But these three or four issues are enough for today. What we are saying is this: we (the public sector) can compete, and we will, if we are only allowed to. If you can, please remove our shackles.

Yours sincerely 25 PSU Chief Executives.

Work at home ? T ry SohoOS

Free Online Business Managem ent Tim e Tracker Free Inv oicing & m ore www.sohoos.com

North Africa Mining Expo

Free access to African m ining com panies, m inistries & equipm ent www.terrapinn.com /m iningm e
Ads by Google

Share200 See more

Like

Email2 Comments Print

#Manmohan Singh Sonia, PM, Advani to address rallies as Himachal hots up PM promises 600 million Aadhaar cards in next two years Aadhaar an important step in curbing dishonesty: PM 8% GDP growth not easy, but not impossible: PM Also see

Why govt wants to set up ETF for selling shares in PSUs

Sep 19, 2012 0 Comments The Department of Disinvestment (DoD) has invited bids from internationally-reputed advisors for setting up an Exchange Traded Fund (ETF) for selling shares of PSUs #Divestment #Hindustan Copper #MMTC #Nalco #NewsTracker #P. Chidambaram #PSU

Govt confident of raising Rs 25K-30K cr from disinvestment

Sep 28, 2012 0 Comments The official said government would take steps to curb wasteful expenditures and plug leakages in implementation of schemes. #Arvind Mayaram #Disinvestment #NewsTracker

Govt aims to sell stake in Oil India, other PSUs by Nov

Oct 12, 2012 1 Comment

India aims to divest stakes in state-owned companies Oil India Ltd, Hindustan Copper and National Aluminium Co by November, the official in charge of the governments divestment programme said on Friday. #Hindustan Copper Ltd #Nalco #NewsTracker #Oil India #stake sale CLOSE X Firstpost encourages open discussion and debate, but please adhere to the rules below, before posting. Comments that are found to be in violation of any one or more of the guidelines will be automatically deleted: Personal attacks/name calling will not be tolerated. This applies to comments directed at the author, other commenters and other politicians/public figures Please do not post comments that target a specific community, caste, nationality or religion. While you do not have to use your real name, any commenters using any Firstpost writer's name will be deleted, and the commenter banned from participating in any future discussions. Comments will be moderated for abusive and offensive language. Please read our comments and moderation policy before posting

3 comments

0 Stars

Discussion

Com m unity

My Disqus 7

Ba b u b h a i Va g h e l a 0 9 4 2 7 6 0 8 6 3 2
0

in a few seconds

CEOs of PSUs may also like to tell Dr Manmohan Singh, please do not use us as dogs.
Edit

Reply

Share

s anjay
2

28 minutes ago Share

What Manmohan would like to tell Sonia: Free Me!

Reply

Chan
0

37 minutes ago Share

Else, get lost

Reply

ALSO ON FIRSTPOST

What's this?

Gujarat Gas deal: Modi has his way. What about shareholders?
98 comments 19 days ago

Sunil Gangopadhyay in translation: What his death robbed literature off

4 comments 2 hours ago

rian1989 Points to be noted >>> "The global energy major fell out of favour with the state government after

joghonno to understand what is the loss, you have to develop a love for literature. smartarse.

Big dud: How hype killed substance Kejriwals expose Gadkari

344 comments 6 days ago

Why India never figured in Obama-Romney debate

33 comments 3 hours ago

satyamsh Arvind Kejriwal, Anjali Damania and Prashant Bhushan essentially made allegations of improper (note,

technofrEEk Manmohan & Co. have destroyed the image of our motherland in not only our own eyes; but everywhere i

Search Firstpost..

Submit

The 10 biggest stories, hand-picked for your inbox.

Email Address

More from business 1

How Bransons Virgin has triggered a price war in Indian skies

2What public sector CEOs would like to tell the PM: Free us 3What Mallya could learn from Zees Subhash Chandra 4With Rutgers deal will Rain Commodities become the next Suzlon? 5Biyani, Mallya, Suzlon, DLF: Easy money screwed up India Inc 6Is Vijay Mallya Indias worst businessman? 7Wal-Mart hit with minimum wage lawsuit as walkout threat looms in US 8Kingfishers villains: DGCA, bankers, and Ajit Singh 92G auction: Is Videocon proxy for Reliance Industries? 10Yes Bank Q2 net up 30%, bad loans fall View More

eBOOK OF THE WEEK

Can this man stop Robert Vadra?

1516 dow nloads

More eBooks

Saina Nehwal has eclipsed Prakash Padukone

I AGREE I DISAGREE

Share Recent Popular

Tw eet

What's hot. People

34 Comments

Most Discussed
Gadkaris Purti group gets murkier: driver is director of six companies 49 comments 1 minute ago Vastanvi calls Modi tyrant, irked BJP demands ban 53 comments 58 minutes ago Why India never figured in Obama-Romney debate 33 comments 22 minutes ago Arvind Kejriwal: Retrograde socialist or India 3.0 leader? 127 comments 10 minutes ago British thaw with Modi shows which way the wind is blowing 29 comments 21 minutes ago

Recent Activity
Ravi Srivastava recommended DGCA suspends Kingfisher licence until it submits revival plan. on
S aturday

Vivekanand Tripathi recommended How the politician-builder nexus really works. last
Thursday

Stephen Dmello recommended How mango people can use RTI for their money matters.
about a w eek ago

More equal than us: Why netas face the rage of the aam aadmi 52 people recommended this.

F acebook social plugin

Submit
About Firstpost Newsletter RSS Twitter Facebook

Verticals: Plus: Tools:

Front page New Delhi Sitemap

India Mumbai RSS Feed

Politics Photos

World

Business

Economy Cartoons

Investing Video room

Life

Bollywood Election

Sports

Tech

Blogs

FP Exclusives

eBooks

Latest Movie Songs

Latest Videos

Play Online Games

Jhalak Dikhhla Jaa

Business Technology News & Videos

Sur Kshetra

Bigg Boss Season 6

[+] Hot Topics: Copyright 2012 Firstpost All rights reserved Terms of use Privacy Advertise moneycontrol.com ibnlive.com in.com tech2.com cricketnext.com